Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

RandFan said:
I've really come to resent Us vs Them politics.

I agree and I'm sorry if any of my posts come across that way. I have nothing against the people who have been debating the opposite viewpoint I have. I wanted to discuss this issue and I appreciate the people who have done so politely.

Question: Do you think it's OK to harm cows for fun?
Follow-up question: Do you think it's OK to harm plants for fun?

No on both counts. Or rather I don't think people should do it, but it happens. Generally if I see people needlessly breaking tree branches in a public park it makes me a little disappointed or sad and I might ask them to stop, but if they don't I don't make a big deal out of it. You could point out that any time people play soccer or go hiking for fun they are harming plants by stepping on them, and that is true but also largely unavoidable unless you propose people never go outside. Some amount of plant, bacterial, animal harm and death is unavoidable. I guess part of it is about the intent behind the action.

Do they build spaceships and hospitals, write poetry and practice medicine?

If not, then let's knock off the semantic hair-splitting.

Recognizing yourself in a mirror isn't sentience.

Based on the definition of sentience I disagree and hold to my statement that some animals are sentient. I think you are meaning a different word.

I didn't say anything about societies. I said species. Even then, of the developing societies on earth, they all want to reach our level and when they do, they too will factory farm.

After all.... it's human nature.

I know you said species. The problem is you attribute a specific set of beliefs to our entire species instead of recognizing that numerous societies and cultures have existed and that many of them have had differing beliefs. You can't just cherry pick one of them and then apply it to the entire species and declare it as human nature. Many native american tribes held a great reverence towards nature and the creatures in it. They didn't aspire to be like the white man, they wanted to be left the hell alone. For many cultures it was only after we had taken them over and supplanted our culture in place of theirs that they eventually became like us. It is what the Chinese are doing to Tibet right now. Even after a military takeover they are still having problems getting them to convert to chinese ways so the chinese now import settlers into their area to ultimately muffle and destroy their culture.

Animus, I know this was touched on earlier, but if killing cows (animals) for food is wrong, how do you justify killing plants? Plants are a life form. Plants are possibly more widespread and diverse than people. It is life. Why is it OK to kill that life. If we are no better than a cow, why are we better that a tree?

I'm not really sure we are. Better is all in who does the judging and what is being judged. I would, however, say we are different. Many of the plants we eat, apples, corn, strawberries, etc, are parts of the plant that the plant itself produces for the express purpose that it be eaten by another creature. It doesn't kill the plant, and while it could be argued differently I would say it doesn't harm it either since the plant itself does this intentionally.

With people and many of the animals we eat and keep as pets this is not the case.

As I mentioned previously, some species of animal have some sense of sentience, or consciousness, as they have the ability to differentiate themselves as an individual entity separate from that around it. A dog can look in a mirror and understand that what it sees is not another dog but itself. Some animals also share other characteristics with people. If you burn yourself or are attacked by someone else you will generally recoil, run away, or fight back. Some animals do this as well. My mom's dog loves interaction and attention, loves to play fetch and tug of war with a stuffed toy, and understands the difference between various words/phrases such as his name, get the toy, gotta go outside/go potty, who's here, food, and more. It's funny because if I ask him who's here he will run to the various windows and stairs trying to see where they are and who has arrived.

In a similar fashion it can be seen that some animals don't like being caged up or mistreated. I remember reading something about tigers in zoos, though I can't think of what it is called. A formerly wild tiger is put into a zoo, and for a time it continues to act like a wild tiger, it skulks around its cage, learning where it is and if there is a way out. Eventually however, after a period of time it becomes resigned to its circumstances, it's cage, and loses all zest for life becoming a lazy, depressed, uninterested tiger knowing that it is stuck in its little cell.

In certain animals I can see qualities that are all too similar to people, an awareness of themselves, of others, of the good and bad happenings to them, and their circumstances in life. And in seeing this consciousness of theirs I can't help but be reminded of people, if less complex/intelligent people.

I've never thought of this before, but at what point in our evolution from apes to as we are today did we suddenly gain the right to life and liberty? Would it have been okay to cage and kill Homo Habilis? Homo Erectus? Homo Ergaster? Homo Neanderthalensis?

I agree with Animus. It's a matter of taste. Meat tastes great!

It most certainly does. That is why I eat it. Not because I need to, not because I think there is nothing wrong with it. But because it tastes so damn good. I've tried to go vegetarian before and ultimately failed due to a lack of willpower. Unfortunately I often fall short of my own expectations. Though this thread is making me consider giving it another go.

I hope that this discussion has shown this is a real issue for many people and that there are good arguments on both sides regardless of which side you ultimately lean towards.

I also hope that I've shown that there are a good deal of people who believe that animals should have the same rights to life and liberty that people enjoy, and it is for this reason that they consider eating meat to be murder just as a good deal of people believe abortion is murder. Comparing the two is not bloody dam stupid as the OP proposes, but rather a different ethical perspective in relation to life, consciousness, and it's inherent value.
 
Last edited:
I agree and I'm sorry if any of my posts come across that way. I have nothing against the people who have been debating the opposite viewpoint I have. I wanted to discuss this issue and I appreciate the people who have done so politely.
That's cool but we shouldn't gloss over my own rank hypocrisy if for no other reason than it brings attention to me. ;)

BTW: I've a great deal of respect for Mumblethrax and Kevin. I find that they are both quite capable of being both fair minded and constructive.

I've learned much from both of them and I think others would do well to carefully consider their points of view.

JMO.
 
Your morality and my morality are diametrically opposed on this issue.

What is your evidence that your morality is moral and mine is not?

Since you haven't explained in enough detail what your morality is, I have no idea. I suspect if you explained your morality I'd say that your "morality" doesn't actually count as morality because it lacks one or more qualities I think are necessary to a moral theory, but until you elaborate a bit more that can only be a suspicion.

I live in a country where I have the freedom to live the way I want. And I don't want to live that way.

Just because you are free to do something doesn't mean it's good for you to do it, and don't pretend that somebody is trying to take away your "right" to eat meat.

We're talking about whether it's right or wrong. If it turns out it's wrong, then maybe we can talk about regulating it. Maybe. Not all things that are wrong are a good idea to regulate.

To GreNME
I really get annoyed at the self-righteous crackpottery that continues this ridiculous, scientifically false idea. The fact is and remains that mankind evolved specifically because we began eating more meat (suggested reading). That isn't to say that the meat made us evolve or that it gave us the chromosomal building blocks on which to evolve-- the reality is simultaneously more complex and more simple than that-- but to ignore that fact is to ignore evolutionary reality. Yes, it is possible for mankind to eliminate meat from our diets (in the first-world countries, at least), but that's not a sufficient argument that we should and all of the ethical arguments in favor of doing so are built from the conclusion.

This is just a second helping of the naturalistic fallacy, along with a straw man. If we somehow proved tomorrow that a major breakthrough in the evolution of intelligence was rape (maybe it turned out that intelligent primates are better at raping, or are better at choosing fertile targets or something) that wouldn't make any difference to whether rape was right or wrong.

The straw man, for those keeping score, is pretending that the vegetarian argument is "there is no evolutionary advantage in eating meat, so we should not eat meat". Nobody ever said that, although to be sure we could probably keep some more humans alive if we all went vegetarian and used the resources thus freed up for humanitarian goals.
 
Based on the definition of sentience I disagree and hold to my statement that some animals are sentient. I think you are meaning a different word.

Whatever the word, the fact remains that 100% of the species that have evolved and advanced to our level have factory farmed. It's therefore natural.



I know you said species. The problem is you attribute a specific set of beliefs to our entire species instead of recognizing that numerous societies and cultures have existed and that many of them have had differing beliefs. You can't just cherry pick one of them and then apply it to the entire species and declare it as human nature. Many native american tribes held a great reverence towards nature and the creatures in it. They didn't aspire to be like the white man, they wanted to be left the hell alone. For many cultures it was only after we had taken them over and supplanted our culture in place of theirs that they eventually became like us. It is what the Chinese are doing to Tibet right now. Even after a military takeover they are still having problems getting them to convert to chinese ways so the chinese now import settlers into their area to ultimately muffle and destroy their culture.

You've got a thing for mythological creatures, don't you? First aliens, then vampires and now aboriginal peoples that live in harmony with nature.

It may surprise you to know that the very first factory farm was established around 4000 BC by Canadas inventive, cunning and industrious first nations peoples (canadian terminolgy for "native american")at a place called Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump.

It didn't get that name because a chief saw a buffalo fall off a clif. Nooooo... it got that name because the Chief and his men would slap on warpaint, glue feathers to their heads, sneak up on grazing buffalo, jump up screaming their heads off, scaring the living $#!+ outta the buffalo and chase the herd down a funnel shaped fence and run the whole damn herd over the edge of a cliff.

They got more efficient at it after they got horses from the white man.

Two weeks ago, I was at the 30th annual conference of the Canadian Nuclear Society in Calgary Alberta where I watched an aboriginal nuclear fuel technician present a bold and ambitious plan to install small nuclear frakkin reactors in all of Canadas isolated northern inuit communities. The plan he proposed would hopefully energize these communities, provide nearly unlimited power and heat and allow then to have even more of the luxuries of modern life at much cheaper prices without the exorbitant cost of regular shipments of heating and power generation fuel. And it's an aboriginal who is pushing this idea.

Oh... aboriginals HATE animal rights kooks. Three weeks ago, an inuit community in Canadas arctic honored our Governor General by cutting a live seal open in front of her and feeding her its (almost) still beating heart! Predictably, animal rights kooks soiled their collective panties over it, totally mocking Canadas native traditions.
 
Last edited:
This is just a second helping of the naturalistic fallacy, along with a straw man. If we somehow proved tomorrow that a major breakthrough in the evolution of intelligence was rape (maybe it turned out that intelligent primates are better at raping, or are better at choosing fertile targets or something) that wouldn't make any difference to whether rape was right or wrong.
But what does make rape wrong? Doesn't our natural ability to feel empathy figure into it?

If you took away the human ability to feel empathy and the evidence showed that rape was good for the human species then I can see how social norms could evolve for a society to see rape as moral.

You have a problem. By what measure are you declaring rape immoral in the first place? Morality is not a priori. So there must be some means to reason the morality or immorality of rape. I would posit that the means includes an appeal to our innate feelings of not wanting to see distress in others (see mirror neurons) and to reason that the best way to ensure that I'm not harmed is to not harm others (I "naturally" do not like to be harmed).
 
Last edited:
No.
We are designed so we can digest meat and vegetables, and we have no choice about that. However we are not designed so that we cannot live without meat, the way cats are designed to be obligate carnivores. We can live on non-animal foods just fine if we have to.

It's not a case of them dying or us dying. It's a case of them dying or us eating mushrooms instead for dinner tonight.

But it is not suggested, there is nutrients that you get from meats that you cannot get from plants.
 
But it is not suggested, there is nutrients that you get from meats that you cannot get from plants.
Most people are capable of getting sufficient nutrients from plants. There are exceptions like Laura Dern.

In any event, we could most certainly eliminate beef from our diet. Beef is a nutrient dense food but it is not necassary for the human diet as many people throughout the world have lived for many centuries without it.
 
The idea that killing cows, or other animals for food is absurd. I don't understand why anyone would argue it is. I've heard the sentient argument, but I don't care. I only care about sapient beings. Yes, I'm a sapientist, I only really care about the thoughts and feelings of species that can actually articulate their thoughts and feelings, species that think.

Also, if we stopped eating cows, we'd still have to kill them. Except instead of killing them to a useful need, we'd be killing them to make them extinct.

Without meat, we'd have to eat much more of the other foods. Meats doesn't mean just beef, but also pork and chicken and fish. And if PETA is really upset about eating animals, this would also include insects. No, PETA is not basing their abjection to meat based on any rational thought, but based on their anthropomorphizing of animals. Mammals are cute, avians are cute, fish are pretty...insect, eww gross, who cares?

These people are insane. They don't want to just stop animals from being eaten and killed. They want to stop the "slavery" of animals, they find the keeping of pets wrong. To use a horse to pull a sled is wrong. To keep animals in zoos is wrong. To restrict animals from doing what they want is wrong. Sorry, but they're just absurd notions that PETA believes in. They're morons.
 
Last edited:
But what does make rape wrong? Doesn't our natural ability to feel empathy figure into it?

If you took away the human ability to feel empathy and the evidence showed that rape was good for the human species then I can see how social norms could evolve for a society to see rape as moral.

You have a problem. By what measure are you declaring rape immoral in the first place? Morality is not a priori. So there must be some means to reason the morality or immorality of rape. I would posit that the means includes an appeal to our innate feelings of not wanting to see distress in others (see mirror neurons) and to reason that the best way to ensure that I'm not harmed is to not harm others (I "naturally" do not like to be harmed).

It can't be that "what makes rape wrong" is that we "naturally" feel an aversion to it. That would just be the naturalistic fallacy yet again.

To Steelmage
But it is not suggested, there is nutrients that you get from meats that you cannot get from plants.

Name them.
 
It can't be that "what makes rape wrong" is that we "naturally" feel an aversion to it. That would just be the naturalistic fallacy yet again.
Ok, let's accept, for the moment, that it is simply a naturalistic fallacy. Answer the question, what make rape wrong? Do you believe that rape is a priori wrong?

Look, I realize that you have in your head this idea that anything natural that would or could lead anyone to a moral conclusion is, on its face, fallacy. Ok, but if that's the case then you need to give us an answer. Why is rape wrong?

Take away empathy and make a case.

Repeating ad nauseam "natural fallacy" isn't resolving the issue.
 
You've got a thing for mythological creatures, don't you? First aliens, then vampires and now aboriginal peoples that live in harmony with nature.

I made no claim that ALL Native American tribes felt this way. I said that there have been many cultures whos beliefs systems included a respect and reverence for other living creatures. You ignored this and proceeded to continue cherry picking and then applying those lovely cherries to all of humanity. Do you honestly believe that no human culture has ever existed which held the belief that animals should be treated with respect?

I don't even understand why you continue to argue that factory farming is a natural event to all of humanity when even were it natural, it still has no bearing on whether it is morally right. As others have mentioned, rape is natural, does that make it right?
 
As others have mentioned, rape is natural, does that make it right?
I can't get an answer but I'll keep asking. :)

What does make rape wrong?

BTW: To avoid natual fallacy you must forgo any mention of feelings.

Do you believe that rape is a priori wrong? If not then what argument can you formulate to justify a stance that morality is wrong.
 
Last edited:
Answer the question, what make rape wrong?

It violates the principle of treat others as you would like to be treated. Or the alternate but similar principal, treat others as they would like to be treated.

It intentionally causes harm to another living conscious being who has the ability to decide for itself what it wants.

It restricts the ability of a living conscious being from choosing its own actions or what it wants/doesn't want to do. Another way of phrasing that might be that it oppresses, or takes control of someones life away from them.
 
It violates the principle of treat others as you would like to be treated. Or the alternate but similar principal, treat others as they would like to be treated.
So what? Isn't wanting to be treated in any way the result of evolved and natural desires?

It intentionally causes harm to another living conscious being who has the ability to decide for itself what it wants.
Why should I care? Isn't empathy the result of evolved and natural impulses (sense).

It restricts the ability of a living conscious being from choosing its own actions or what it wants/doesn't want to do. Another way of phrasing that might be that it oppresses, or takes control of someones life away from them.
Aren't the wants and deisres of another the result of evolved natural impulses? So what if it oppresses? So what if it controls someone?

Why should I care?

If we divorce all feelings and natural tendancies and desires from our forumlation then I don't see how we can formulate morality. Do you?

FWIW: I've personally made thousands of posts on this very subject and I've yet to see anyone formulate an argument sans any natural feelings or desires.

You said: "As others have mentioned, rape is natural, does that make it right?" Ok, the way I want to be treated is natural. It's the result of evolution. Does that make it right?

ETA: Thanks for answering. :) I should note that I actually do accept the naturualistic fallacy. I just don't think it is as simplistic as many here do.

Given sufficent premises, natural traits can and in fact are the basis for morality.
 
Last edited:
Do you honestly believe that no human culture has ever existed which held the belief that animals should be treated with respect?

Our society holds that belief, actually.

We have placed numerous laws and regulations upon the ranching, pet breeding, entertainment and medical research industries along with various other areas of interaction between humans and animals for the purpose of minimizing need less pain and suffering by animals.
 
Ok, let's accept, for the moment, that it is simply a naturalistic fallacy. Answer the question, what make rape wrong? Do you believe that rape is a priori wrong?

Look, I realize that you have in your head this idea that anything natural that would or could lead anyone to a moral conclusion is, on its face, fallacy. Ok, but if that's the case then you need to give us an answer. Why is rape wrong?

Take away empathy and make a case.

Repeating ad nauseam "natural fallacy" isn't resolving the issue.

It's still a valid contribution to a discussion to point out that stated arguments are fallacious or lead to dead ends for other reasons. I don't need to know all the answers to know that fallacious answers are wrong, and challenging me to provide a better answer won't turn a fallacious argument into a good one.

I'm also not interested in enabling a derail by articulating my own position before we've even reached agreement that all arguments of the form "X is natural, therefore X is moral" are fallacious.

Once we get consensus on that point it will become worthwhile to explore alternatives. Until then, at least according to my past experience, presenting alternative position is just opening the door to a barrage of (flawed) tu quoque arguments.
 
I don't know.

I suppose part of the reason is empathy. I've been a child, I have children, and I empathize with my own species. Cattle, not so much. I find more value in a person than in a cow.
Fair enough, but personally I've never been a chinese child, but I empathise with them. Hell, I've never been this particular child, nor that one. What is it about them that I see as being the same as me?

Personally, I would say how their minds work, how they experience the world, etc.
And, while there is more difference between my mind and that of a cow than there is between my mind and that of a human child, there are also many similarities as well.

I have less empathy for cows than humans, but certainly that difference is one of degree, rather than a kind.
 
There is no viable plant-based analogue for pork spare-ribs.

That's all the reasoning I need.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom