Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

Poor comparisons. We are not straight carnivores. Our cousins, the bears, have fairly sharp claws.

The argument is fairly simple:

The teeth we have are the result of quite a bit of evolution. As such, I intend to use mine.

I would just like to know, have you gotten yours removed? If not, why not?

I don't need to eat meat to survive. Do you?

Does an is imply an ought? Does can imply should? Does able to imply must? I am sure you do not use evolutionary advantage to justify your moral philosophy in may areas other than this one.

Whether or not we are evolved to behave in a certain way or not (and I have some issue with comparing human dental structures with other omnivores - it is quite clear we cannot eat much of the meat we do without preparing it first), that point is irrelevant - it's a textbook example of the naturalistic fallacy.

When you must rely on fallacious arguments, your argument is not rational. There are a number of people who argue quite compellingly and scientifically that we're "evolved" to be religious, or "evolved" to be unfaithful to our partners. Should such arguments be taken into account when deciding whether to believe in God, or to sleep with other people? Or should decisions of a moral and ethical nature be taken with different considerations in mind?
 
Last edited:
Why is it ok for the grizzly to eat meat?

The grizzly can't go down the shops and buy a nutritionally complete meal without meat. Neither has it the rational capacity to consider the costs and benefits of its actions, nor develop an ethcial code at all. Bears are not moral agents.

You might as well have asked me why is it OK for the dog to hump any bitch that walks past, without seeking her consent first as a defence for rape, or why the beaver can cut down trees as a defence for permitless logging!

Yours are not rational arguments.
 
Last edited:
The grizzly can't go down the shops and buy a nutritionally complete meal without meat. Neither has it the rational capacity to consider the costs and benefits of its actions, nor develop an ethcial code at all. Bears are not moral agents.

Yours are not rational arguments.

But a bear can eat a nutritionally complete meal without meat. They are omnivores.

Just like us.

Furthermore, I noticed earlier that you used our preparation of meat as an argument against humans eating it. Yes, we prepare meat to eat. But then again, we prepare all of our food. I highly doubt that you eat a tomato right off the vine, or dig up a carrot to eat where you found it.
 
Why do you offer "social norms" a free ride from rational consideration? That almost sounds like an argumentum ad populum...


I'm sure comparing rape to eating a hamburger has some fancy schmancy latin term for it too. :p
 
I've said it before and I've said it again - if a nutritionally-balanced plant-based diet is readily available (which it is for pretty much everyone who posts on this forum), then there is no rational reason for continuing to eat meat.


An equilibrated optimal diet for an omnivore contain of all sort of food stuff both vegetal and animal. You OTOH want to force a pure vegetarian diet onto an omnivore animal. That is sub optimal. Therefore a rational decision is to stay with an omnivore equilibrated and limited in energy diet (aka : no abuse).

PS: you were the one wanting to speak of rationality ? It is NOT rational from the biological POV (aka suboptimal) to deviate greatly from the diet our teeth, stomach, and other part of the body have been made for. That we CAN do it, don't make VEGE(tarian/alism) optimal. It only make it optimal if you consider OTHER externalities, like politic.
 
Last edited:
But a bear can eat a nutritionally complete meal without meat. They are omnivores.

Just like us.

It can. Sure. But is it able to make the "choice" as a rational actor? No.

Unless I over-estimated your brain-power, however, (and that is becoming more and more of a possibility the longer this silly conversation goes on), you are. I really hope you don't decide what's for dinner in the same way a bear does!

Furthermore, I noticed earlier that you used our preparation of meat as an argument against humans eating it. Yes, we prepare meat to eat. But then again, we prepare all of our food. I highly doubt that you eat a tomato right off the vine, or dig up a carrot to eat where you found it.

No, that's not an argument against us eating it. It's just a really obvious rebuttal to the silly argument you were making, which was "I have sharp teeth, therefore I have to eat meat". Your teeth are not what makes it possible for you to eat meat.

What does make it possible is your brain - the same brain that has given you the rational capacity to make informed and considered choices about what you eat.

As for "not eating tomatoes right off the vine", have you ever heard of salad? :rolleyes: I can eat a carrot out of the ground. You cannot kill a cow with your mouth. All this is irrelevant, however, because - as I already explained - can does not equal should.

So, you can eat meat. Fine, I don't dispute that. Why should you, rationally?
 
An equilibrated optimal diet for an omnivore contain of all sort of food stuff both vegetal and animal. You OTOH want to force a pure vegetarian diet onto an omnivore animal. That is sub optimal. Therefore a rational decision is to stay with an omnivore equilibrated and limited in energy diet (aka : no abuse).

If you'd care to look it up (or ask any nutritionist) - there is no nutritional difference between a balanced vegan diet and balanced omnivorous one. Therefore "omnivorous is better" is false, and thus irrelevant in making a rational case for meat-eating. Any nutrients you can get from meat can also be found from plant-based sources.

Try again.
 
To GreNME


This is just a second helping of the naturalistic fallacy, along with a straw man. If we somehow proved tomorrow that a major breakthrough in the evolution of intelligence was rape (maybe it turned out that intelligent primates are better at raping, or are better at choosing fertile targets or something) that wouldn't make any difference to whether rape was right or wrong.

Except you're wrong here on both counts. I'm not arguing that it's morally or ethically better to eat meat-- you are, and that's where the naturalistic fallacy would come into play. I'm pointing out that the argument which states there is no need to eat meat is based on a biological falsehood. In the same post I also point out that reducing meat consumption is a valid argument, though due to the long list of debatable reasons and the fact that PETA has jack and squat to do with most of them I don't feel an overwhelming urge to get into all of the details.

As for this bringing up of rape BS, all I can say is that you're making the same type of mistake Cain did the last time we went around in circles on this topic: using faulty extremes to provoke a reaction is intellectually childish and using unrealistic hypotheticals is avoiding the reality of right now. I understand why you'd go this route-- it's far easier to argue this case in hypotheticals and 'what ifs' while keeping only the emotional arguments anchored in reality-- but just because you're demanding that I follow you on this route isn't sufficient reason for me to follow you on it.

Sorry, man, but trying to play both the strictly-logic and the jarring-emotional argument game isn't going to fly with me. The world is an unfair, uneven, and sometimes arbitrary place. Some, some, some I, some I murder; some I, some I let go.

The straw man, for those keeping score, is pretending that the vegetarian argument is "there is no evolutionary advantage in eating meat, so we should not eat meat". Nobody ever said that, although to be sure we could probably keep some more humans alive if we all went vegetarian and used the resources thus freed up for humanitarian goals.

While I'm sure you would love it if I were arguing against that strawman, unfortunately for you that supposed scarecrow is strictly of your own making. Instead, what I'm saying is precisely what I said, that the arguments that since one theoretically can eliminate meat form their diet is not sufficient reason to establish that we should. That, by the way, is no strawman, as Volatile proves in a later post:

I've said it before and I've said it again - if a nutritionally-balanced plant-based diet is readily available (which it is for pretty much everyone who posts on this forum), then there is no rational reason for continuing to eat meat.

This is demonstrably false. The rational reason to eat meat is that there is no other source of food, pound-for-pound, that contains the potency for energy, nutrients, and hunger satiation that is within meat. This is a double-edged sword, however, because in much of the first-world the consumption of meat is far above the level of meeting that need, but again that argues for a decrease in consumption and not complete cessation. Yes, with appropriate effort enough mixture of non-meat foor can give the same results, but on the whole that requires more effort. If someone finds personal pride or meaning in taking those measures, then more power to them for finding something that works for them. However, that does not make doing so any more an objective 'truth' than does the Catholic who prays to their rosary or the Muslim who follows their daily prayer times.

Kevin_Lowe, I don't think you're stupid or wrong for advocating eating a vegetarian diet. Really, I don't. I do, however, think you're being a self-righteous boor by making petty arguments that have little (if any) basis in fact and serve instead to demonize those who disagree instead of convince someone that your point of view has any merit. If you expect me to take anything you're arguing seriously then the first thing you need to do is drop the self-righteous BS and approach the subject with a more level head. Yeah, I know that the snide comments from people saying that they're going to eat extra meat or kill a bunny every time PETA says something stupid (the world would have no more bunnies in a week if they actually did) was rude and mean, but trying to cover your tracks by trying to appeal to logic after shooting off with an even more offensive line of crap isn't convincing, at least not to me.
 
If you'd care to look it up (or ask any nutritionist) - there is no nutritional difference between a balanced vegan diet and balanced omnivorous one. Therefore "omnivorous is better" is false, and thus irrelevant in making a rational case for meat-eating. Any nutrients you can get from meat can also be found from plant-based sources.

Try again.

No need to try again. Getting the same nutrients from plant-based (and, actually, it would also require fungus-based) sources would require more separate sources than just eating meat. Pretty plain and simple, if you ask me.

Would you like to get into the economic models of production? Really, haven't we been down this road before?
 
I made no claim that ALL Native American tribes felt this way. I said that there have been many cultures whos beliefs systems included a respect and reverence for other living creatures.
How many of the cultures were voluntarily vegetarian?
 
Painter: Your "response"... is not a response at all. OK?

Cain wrote:
Question: Do you think it's OK to harm cows for fun?
Follow-up question: Do you think it's OK to harm plants for fun?

Animus:
No on both counts. Or rather I don't think people should do it, but it happens. Generally if I see people needlessly breaking tree branches in a public park it makes me a little disappointed or sad and I might ask them to stop, but if they don't I don't make a big deal out of it.

A tree in a public park muddies the issue.

You could point out that any time people play soccer or go hiking for fun they are harming plants by stepping on them, and that is true but also largely unavoidable unless you propose people never go outside. Some amount of plant, bacterial, animal harm and death is unavoidable. I guess part of it is about the intent behind the action.

Again, you're needlessly complicating the issue. Most people, vegetarian or not, make an intuitive moral distinction between plants and animals. It's not surprising most people support legislation on the treatment of animals.

-------------------
Volatile:
PETA are idiots, but on the quality of the responses posted here, it seems a large number of people on this forum are too.

Check out my sig. :)
 
I'm sure comparing rape to eating a hamburger has some fancy schmancy latin term for it too. :p

I wasn't "comparing rape" to "eating a hamburger". I was illustrating that most people don't seem to think "we evolved to do x" means "I am morally obliged to do x" in most of their moral philosophy.

Why make an exception here? Any rational reasons?

Why does steak make even the most eloquent of posters start posting the kind of irrational, childish drivel we saw up-thread? What is it about meat that renders it totally impervious to rational consideration?

Face it - the diet we eat is more or less that diet given to us by our parents. That's why Koreans eat dog, but Americans find it repulsive, why the French love horsemeat but the British don't, why some countries' citizens consider monkey brains tasty treats.

Our diet is, for most of us, pre-rational. As pre-rational as religion often is. It certainly was for me. We simply never stop to question why we eat what we eat, or what the ethical consequences of our diets are. For all the time you guys spend criticising the religious, perhaps some of it would better be directed inwards, at your own indoctrinated, unconsidered behaviours and beliefs?
 
Our diet is, for most of us, pre-rational. As pre-rational as religion often is. It certainly was for me. We simply never stop to question why we eat what we eat, or what the ethical consequences of our diets are. For all the time you guys spend criticising the religious, perhaps some of it would better be directed inwards, at your own indoctrinated, unconsidered behaviours and beliefs?

I totally agree with the above quoted statement.
 
No need to try again. Getting the same nutrients from plant-based (and, actually, it would also require fungus-based) sources would require more separate sources than just eating meat. Pretty plain and simple, if you ask me.

Do you eat only until your RDA in each category has been sated, and then no more? Is "sufficiency" your motivator behind what you put in your mouth?

Would you like to get into the economic models of production? Really, haven't we been down this road before?

Yes, and I seem to recall you losing that particular line of argument.
 
This is demonstrably false. The rational reason to eat meat is that there is no other source of food, pound-for-pound, that contains the potency for energy, nutrients, and hunger satiation that is within meat.

See my reply to your repletion of this point, I guess - but if anyone here rationally bases their diet solely on the sufficiency of the nutrients it provides, then I'll eat my hat.

Even so - it's irrelevant. It is entirely possible for most of us to easily and simply get all of our nutritional needs from plant based sources. Meat-based diets often have demonstrable harms to health and nearly always cause greater environmental damage than a plant-based alternative. Meat-based diets are logically inconsistent with the stance most people hold on animal welfare. As such, on what grounds can meat-eating be justified for those where a nutritionally-equivalent plant-based diet can be easily obtained?

I've asked that a number of times on this forum. And still we get back to "Meat tastes good". That's irrational.
 
If you'd care to look it up (or ask any nutritionist) - there is no nutritional difference between a balanced vegan diet and balanced omnivorous one. Therefore "omnivorous is better" is false, and thus irrelevant in making a rational case for meat-eating. Any nutrients you can get from meat can also be found from plant-based sources.

Try again.

Except that you are overseeing that all those nutriment are brought by one single source (meat) instead of multiple one. And there is from where the optimal is coming, you keep ignoring it, and I can see why. Admiting that point would destroy your rationality argument.
 
Do you eat only until your RDA in each category has been sated, and then no more? Is "sufficiency" your motivator behind what you put in your mouth?

Really? Using recommended allowances? "Sufficiently" is the motivator behind what almost everyone puts in their mouths (no jokes, fellas). Listen, you have a choice: getting something from one source, or getting the same something from six (number chosen somewhat randomly) choices-- why is one inherently better than the other?

Yes, and I seem to recall you losing that particular line of argument.

:rolleyes: If you say so. I think maybe you're being selective in your assessment, but I'm willing to be proven wrong: are you actually suggesting that the economic model of mass-production for a vegetarian-based diet wouldn't eventually suffer similar environmentally detrimental problems that mass-production for the meat-based diet does? If yes, on what do you base this suggestion? Considering how mankind seems to consistently over-do pretty much everything we set our minds to, what (pray tell) makes you so confident that this would be any different?

In case you forgot (and it seems you did), I had no problem with the suggestion that the mass-production meat market be either severely limited or done away with. I recognize and acknowledge the problems with it. That doesn't make the case for me switching to veggie-burgers, though.
 
Except that you are overseeing that all those nutriment are brought by one single source (meat) instead of multiple one. And there is from where the optimal is coming, you keep ignoring it, and I can see why. Admiting that point would destroy your rationality argument.

Sorry, I don't follow.

I can eat just as healthily (perhaps more healthily, even) with a plant-based diet, with fewer negative consequences and no disconnect with my broader ethical opinions. How does "steak is nutritionally complete" even function as an argument against that?

You're actively engaging in a destructive, unnecessary behaviour (which, I presume, also contradicts some of your ethical precepts like "harming animals for no reason is wrong"), simply because you've done it all your life. That's irrational.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom