Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

I love this thread -- from the title through scattered posts I read. It's sort of like every other animal rights thread.

I especially enjoyed that whole "digression" on animal rights versus animal welfare.

Animus, I know this was touched on earlier, but if killing cows (animals) for food is wrong, how do you justify killing plants? Plants are a life form. Plants are possibly more widespread and diverse than people. It is life. Why is it OK to kill that life. If we are no better than a cow, why are we better that a tree?

Question: Do you think it's OK to harm cows for fun?
Follow-up question: Do you think it's OK to harm plants for fun?
 
There are many species of animals that display the characteristic of sentience.

Do they build spaceships and hospitals, write poetry and practice medicine?

If not, then let's knock off the semantic hair-splitting.

Many animals are able to recognize themselves in a mirror which suggests that they are capable of differentiating between themselves and others.

Recognizing yourself in a mirror isn't sentience. Manufacturing a mirror is.

We are the one sentient species known to exist. We are the standard. Our activities represent the baseline for comparisons.

In addition there have been numerous human societies that have existed that did not factory farm and would never have dreamed of doing so as it would have gone against their beliefs and philosophy towards life. The only reason factory farming is the norm now is because those cultures that had less respect and reverence for other life weren't as well armed or as imperialistic.

I didn't say anything about societies. I said species. Even then, of the developing societies on earth, they all want to reach our level and when they do, they too will factory farm.

After all.... it's human nature.


Which is a combination of might makes right, and whatever is popular is right.

I believe in God. I believe he placed us in a position of stewardship over his creation, allowed to use it as we see fit but with the responsibility to ensure that it's there for future generations.

But God can't be proven and that argument doesn't play well on a Skeptics discussion board. So what else are we left with but "the law of the jungle"? Without a higher power, how do you decide what "moral" is? In my worldview, all you can eat rib night at Montanas™ is morally acceptable. I don't see any reason why I should think otherwise when it's not people that are getting hurt.

Not a couple hundred years ago the more numerous and better armed saw blacks and women as inferior and unequal, but over time rights grew and now it's the other way round.

The US constitution originally made african-americans 3/5ths of a white man. No cow, chicken, pig or lab rat has ever had that level of recognition.

Slave Driver ants do exactly as their name suggests, BTW. Technically making slavery "natural".

Even animals rights have grown, albeit much more slowly. Were you able to see society a couple hundred years from now you might very well find the same reversal with regard to animal rights.

I'll worry when cows become 1/5th of a human under the US constitution.

Mind you, they'll become extinct the day before that. Every rancher in the country will see the change coming and kill and sell their entire herds before the deadline. Giving them rights would precipitate a cowpocalypse.
 
I've really come to resent Us vs Them politics. I find it silly and beside the point. It seems that everyone has a punching bag for which to unleash their pent up frustrations and anger.

I think we are better than that.

!!! Hypochrite alert !!!

God I hate PETA.

:rolleyes: At least I'm honest about it.

I really do hate them though. I find them (on the whole) arrogant and politically tone deaf. The ends don't simply justify the means. IMO, to them, the means ARE the ends. Smug, self assured and self rightreous.

I'm in the UCLA options program and for the last two months I have eaten very little meat and my family have followed my diet pretty closely.

It's ribeyes tonight. :)
 
I've always wondered which is worse:

-a pack of wolves taking down a deer, eating the meat they need, and leaving the leftovers for the scavengers

-a hunter taking down a deer, cutting the meat he needs, and leaving the leftovers for scavengers

-cutting down a tree to build a house

-ripping a head of lettuce out of the ground so as to eat it
 
I have to wonder, Animus, if we stop eating cows, what should we do with them?


Professional Tipping Leagues!!!!
woop.gif
 
I have to wonder, Animus, if we stop eating cows, what should we do with them?

We'd have to kill them.

As I pointed out above, not only would there be a mass slaughter the day before the new laws go into effect, but they are completely domesticated animals. Have been for thousands of years. Their wild antecedents are long gone and there is no ecological niches for them in the wild anywhere.

Releasing them into the wild would be unnatural.
 
A "naturalistic fallacy" only exists if something exists that is above nature, a higher power that establishes objective standards of right and wrong.

No.

It would also be a fallacy if there were no meaningful moral claims at all, or if there were meaningful moral claims not based on objective standards established by "a higher power".

IF rape had an evolutionary advantage (it doesn't), then you might be right.

So if I did some research and some planning and figured out that I could increase my chances of reproductive success by raping, I should (morally speaking) do it, and that would be okay with you? Assuming that I'm the kind of person who wants to rape - I'm not, but our prisons have enough rapists in them that such people are definitely out there.

I find that idea morally repugnant.

However, we are "designed" to eat meat and vegetables. It isn't a choice - it is the way we are.

We are designed so we can digest meat and vegetables, and we have no choice about that. However we are not designed so that we cannot live without meat, the way cats are designed to be obligate carnivores. We can live on non-animal foods just fine if we have to.

It's not a case of them dying or us dying. It's a case of them dying or us eating mushrooms instead for dinner tonight.
 
No.

It would also be a fallacy if there were no meaningful moral claims at all, or if there were meaningful moral claims not based on objective standards established by "a higher power".

Your morality and my morality are diametrically opposed on this issue.

What is your evidence that your morality is moral and mine is not?

I find that idea morally repugnant.

Morally repugnant like making jokes about hanging black people, or some other kind of repugnant?

We can live on non-animal foods just fine if we have to.

I live in a country where I have the freedom to live the way I want. And I don't want to live that way.
 
Last edited:
We are designed so we can digest meat and vegetables, and we have no choice about that. However we are not designed so that we cannot live without meat, the way cats are designed to be obligate carnivores. We can live on non-animal foods just fine if we have to.

It's not a case of them dying or us dying. It's a case of them dying or us eating mushrooms instead for dinner tonight.

I really get annoyed at the self-righteous crackpottery that continues this ridiculous, scientifically false idea. The fact is and remains that mankind evolved specifically because we began eating more meat (suggested reading). That isn't to say that the meat made us evolve or that it gave us the chromosomal building blocks on which to evolve-- the reality is simultaneously more complex and more simple than that-- but to ignore that fact is to ignore evolutionary reality. Yes, it is possible for mankind to eliminate meat from our diets (in the first-world countries, at least), but that's not a sufficient argument that we should and all of the ethical arguments in favor of doing so are built from the conclusion.

From a position based on health and development, conservation, and ethical sustainability, there are indeed arguments that support greatly reducing our meat intake, but not cutting it out completely. The biological advantages of eating meat are still evident today in much the same way they were 5,000 or 50,000 or 500,000 years ago, but there is a precedent that too much of a thing can be detrimental, even (or especially) with rich food sources. As much as I dislike things I perceive as trendy phases, there is quite a bit of merit in the suggestions to shop for 'organic' or local meat rather than mass-produced products, both for health and for sustainability reasons, among others (including reducing one's carbon footprint).

And that's why this argument comparing cows to fetuses is so damned stupid: it ignores the realities of biology, particularly the evolutionary biology, and instead makes a complicated emotional appeal where it really doesn't apply, not from a scientific or economic perspective. These emotional appeals are the intellectual equivalent of Ray Comfort's attempts to 'prove' the existence of his god using a freaking banana.
 
And?



Animals eat other animals. They also don't have a choice in the matter. We do, and we have the means to stop eating meat, or at the very least eat far less of it so we don't have to factory farm millions of animals. Again it is not a matter of survival, it is a matter of taste. Just because we can do something doesn't mean we should. Further other animals don't cage and breed millions of other animals in captivity for it's own purpose. We don't treat them like life, we treat them like resources, like oil or coal. No other animal does this, so it is not just the natural way of things. Nothing about factory farming is natural. The argument that it is natural falls flat.

As to your other argument I never said anything about eating the fetus or children. I simply said killing them. You could say the difference then is that we eat the cows but not a child we murdered. I could then say what if we ate the child, does it then become okay to kill children just like cows? You say we don't do it because its easier to use cows but that is not how our society works. Most people hold the notion that killing children is wrong, but killing a cow isn't.

What makes killing children wrong, but killing cows okay?


Like I said above - killing cows is more efficient than killing children.

Also, not too many species eat their young exclusively...

Also - I don't recall saying that farming was natural - merely suggested that eating cows was a more efficient way to get meat into us.

So if I did some research and some planning and figured out that I could increase my chances of reproductive success by raping, I should (morally speaking) do it, and that would be okay with you? Assuming that I'm the kind of person who wants to rape - I'm not, but our prisons have enough rapists in them that such people are definitely out there.

I find that idea morally repugnant.


While it might increase your short term reproductive success, it isn't much of a long term strategy. Reproduction and fitness to breed isn't simply about "can I pop out a baby" - it is "can I pop out enough babies to make sure that my genes last into the distant future."

Ending up in prison, where the sex is almost certain NOT to result in further breeding opportunities (unless you want to breed countersunk brown mullets...) isn't a good reproductive strategy.


We are designed so we can digest meat and vegetables, and we have no choice about that. However we are not designed so that we cannot live without meat, the way cats are designed to be obligate carnivores. We can live on non-animal foods just fine if we have to.

It's not a case of them dying or us dying. It's a case of them dying or us eating mushrooms instead for dinner tonight.

Whatever floats your boat.

Just don't presume to tell me what I have the right to eat.
 
Just don't presume to tell me what I have the right to eat.

[fundie]

Don't listen to him Kevin. Forcing him to live according to your morality would be just a tiny little legal precedent. There's no way it would ever come back to bite you in the ass.

You have my word as a christian!

[/fundie]
 
No, we could go back and hunt our food. But raising livestock is better.

Says you.

The Animus said:
Yes. Perhaps I explained that poorly. Let's say you have 1000 people who need to eat. If they eat only plants they will actually have to grow less plants than if they eat meat. The animals needed to feed those same 1000 people would eat more plants in raising them than would be eaten if those 1000 people only ate plants.

An oft repeated canard from the animal rights wonkos that have obviously never spent time farming or raising animals for food. Not all land is appropriate for raising human grade crops. Replacing the fields used for animal grade feed with human grade food is not a 1:1 trade off.
 
Last edited:
So if I did some research and some planning and figured out that I could increase my chances of reproductive success by raping, I should (morally speaking) do it, and that would be okay with you? Assuming that I'm the kind of person who wants to rape - I'm not, but our prisons have enough rapists in them that such people are definitely out there.

I find that idea morally repugnant.
(emphasis mine)

I do too. However, I'm curious, do I find it repugnant because:
  1. I reason it so?
  2. I share societal norms that view rape as repugnant?
  3. The suffering of others disturbes me and my evolved natural inclination to procreate and pass on my genes pales compared to my evolved natural inclination to feel empathy during times of plenty and social cohesion?
  4. All of the above?
IMHO, it's a bit simplistic to focus, in a vacuum, on a single variable (a single evolved natural desire). Our sense of right and wrong is a very complex dynamic of a number of variables including natural compulsions and drives. It's important to note that many of these are often in some degree of conflict.

For example:
  1. I want to live.
  2. I want my associates to live.
  3. I don't want to be hungry.
  4. I don't want my associates to be hungry.
During times of plenty and even during times of some famine all of these will guide my behavior. If resources are reduced sufficently and social cohesion breaks down #4 might become rather trite and #2 might become a liability.

In fact, if history is a guide, given desperate times, most of us would kill others to live.

We have the luxury to set aside many of our natural desires in our attempts to fashion a moral guide and we even reason fallacious any appeal to our nature in framing our morality. However we lie to ourselves if we honestly think that we truly can divorse our natural desires and inclinations from our sense of morality.

"Evolution is cleverer than you are." Orgel's Second Rule
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom