Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

Rape is wrong because of the suffering that it causes.
It may also be wrong for other reasons as well, but certainly that is one of them.
So what? I don't mean to be sticky on this point but it's important. Suffering is a feeling. It's natural.

Don't get me wrong, I agree that suffering is a valid premise. I would add that our ability to feel empathy is ultimatly critical to our sense of morality but we need to first decide whether or not natural feelings should be considered as it relates to morality. Kevin Lowe and others have said no.
 
If you'd care to look it up (or ask any nutritionist) - there is no nutritional difference between a balanced vegan diet and balanced omnivorous one. Therefore "omnivorous is better" is false, and thus irrelevant in making a rational case for meat-eating. Any nutrients you can get from meat can also be found from plant-based sources.

Try again.


Youa re missing the point entirely. It is NOT whether you can do a vegetarian diet as equilibrated as an omnivore one. It is about rationality thus what is most OPTIMAL. You cannot biologically say that vegetarian diet is optimal on that side, all you can say is that with MORE knowledge and MORE planning you can have a vegetarian diet instead of an omnivore one. But under that light you cannot say it is more optimal than an omnivore one.

Do you eat only until your RDA in each category has been sated, and then no more? Is "sufficiency" your motivator behind what you put in your mouth?



Yes, and I seem to recall you losing that particular line of argument.

It is more difficult to equilibrate a vegetarian diet than an omnivore one.
 
Last edited:
See my reply to your repletion of this point, I guess - but if anyone here rationally bases their diet solely on the sufficiency of the nutrients it provides, then I'll eat my hat.

Even so - it's irrelevant. It is entirely possible for most of us to easily and simply get all of our nutritional needs from plant based sources. Meat-based diets often have demonstrable harms to health and nearly always cause greater environmental damage than a plant-based alternative. Meat-based diets are logically inconsistent with the stance most people hold on animal welfare. As such, on what grounds can meat-eating be justified for those where a nutritionally-equivalent plant-based diet can be easily obtained?

I've asked that a number of times on this forum. And still we get back to "Meat tastes good". That's irrational.

And we come back to the pleading to supposed rationality. You know, rational people also wouldn't smoke, wouldn't drink alcohol, and probably wouldn't engage in sex or risky relationships with people (especially marriage) for much of their lives. Yet we do those things anyway, often in spades and sometimes to excess.

So, unless you're suggesting we do this supposedly more rational thing simply so that we can claim... what? 'Rational superiority'?... then I'm not following your logic to conclusion. Yes, most of us get our diets from our childhoods, our culture, and in some ways our larger societies. You've not elaborated on what's so horrible about this yet.

Come on, I know I'm prodding somewhat subtly, but it's not that subtle. Just go ahead and say it already, get it out of the way so that I'm not the one who says it first.
 
It's still a valid contribution to a discussion to point out that stated arguments are fallacious or lead to dead ends for other reasons. I don't need to know all the answers to know that fallacious answers are wrong, and challenging me to provide a better answer won't turn a fallacious argument into a good one.
Then, following your logic, there is no right answer.

The problem is that you have simply glomed onto the idea that anything to do with "natural" is simply fallacious and that is itself a spurious concept.

I'm also not interested in enabling a derail by articulating my own position before we've even reached agreement that all arguments of the form "X is natural, therefore X is moral" are fallacious.
This isn't even the argument you recently dismissed.

Seeing others in pain causes me pain ISN'T of that form.

Once we get consensus on that point it will become worthwhile to explore alternatives. Until then, at least according to my past experience, presenting alternative position is just opening the door to a barrage of (flawed) tu quoque arguments.
Nonsense. A.) Right or wrong you will not get your consensus. B.) A good argument for morality would be instructive in ways that arguing over fallacy isn't.
 
Are you able to take a bite out of a live cow? Kill a sheep using only your teeth? Hunt down a pig and kill it with a nibble on its jugular vein? You have teeth like our omnivorous cousins, the bears? Seriously?
Why is taking a bite out of a live cow important? I agree that we are omnivorous like our cousins the bears and more to the point Chimps (they eat monkeys) but I don't get the live cow bit. Explain?
 
So if I did some research and some planning and figured out that I could increase my chances of reproductive success by raping, I should (morally speaking) do it, and that would be okay with you? Assuming that I'm the kind of person who wants to rape - I'm not, but our prisons have enough rapists in them that such people are definitely out there.

I find that idea morally repugnant.

(emphasis mine)


I do too. However, I'm curious, do I find it repugnant because:
  1. I reason it so?
  2. I share societal norms that view rape as repugnant?
  3. The suffering of others disturbes me and my evolved natural inclination to procreate and pass on my genes pales compared to my evolved natural inclination to feel empathy during times of plenty and social cohesion?
  4. All of the above?
IMHO, it's a bit simplistic to focus, in a vacuum, on a single variable (a single evolved natural desire). Our sense of right and wrong is a very complex dynamic of a number of variables including natural compulsions and drives. It's important to note that many of these are often in some degree of conflict.


For example:
  1. I want to live.
  2. I want my associates to live.
  3. I don't want to be hungry.
  4. I don't want my associates to be hungry.
During times of plenty and even during times of some famine all of these will guide my behavior. If resources are reduced sufficently and social cohesion breaks down #4 might become rather trite and #2 might become a liability.

In fact, if history is a guide, given desperate times, most of us would kill others to live.

We have the luxury to set aside many of our natural desires in our attempts to fashion a moral guide and we even reason fallacious any appeal to our nature in framing our morality. However we lie to ourselves if we honestly think that we truly can divorse our natural desires and inclinations from our sense of morality.

"Evolution is cleverer than you are." Orgel's Second Rule
Reposted for reference.
 
Why is taking a bite out of a live cow important? I agree that we are omnivorous like our cousins the bears and more to the point Chimps (they eat monkeys) but I don't get the live cow bit. Explain?

[Going home now so will deal with the rest later]

We don't have teeth like bears - look at their canines compared to ours! It really bugs me when people bring up the "look at our teeth" 'justification' for eating meat - aside from being irrelevant, it also misses the point that our teeth, alone, are insufficient to allow us to survive on meat in the wild. We need to use tools to eat anything larger than a chicken... you cannot kill a wild animal with your teeth, like all other truly omnivorous wild animals can.

But, yeah, it's irrelevant.
 
I don't need to eat meat to survive. Do you?

Does an is imply an ought? Does can imply should? Does able to imply must? I am sure you do not use evolutionary advantage to justify your moral philosophy in may areas other than this one.

Whether or not we are evolved to behave in a certain way or not (and I have some issue with comparing human dental structures with other omnivores - it is quite clear we cannot eat much of the meat we do without preparing it first), that point is irrelevant - it's a textbook example of the naturalistic fallacy.

When you must rely on fallacious arguments, your argument is not rational. There are a number of people who argue quite compellingly and scientifically that we're "evolved" to be religious, or "evolved" to be unfaithful to our partners. Should such arguments be taken into account when deciding whether to believe in God, or to sleep with other people? Or should decisions of a moral and ethical nature be taken with different considerations in mind?
Then perhaps you will answer my question.

Why is rape wrong?

Isn't our sense of right and wrong, to a degree, natural?

X is natural therefore X is moral is a fallacy.

The problem is that given sufficent premises a valid moral argument can be made taking into account our nature.

We can't completly divorce ourselves from nature. We are in fact the result of hundreds of thousands of years of evolution (see above).
 
[Going home now so will deal with the rest later]

We don't have teeth like bears - look at their canines compared to ours! It really bugs me when people bring up the "look at our teeth" 'justification' for eating meat - aside from being irrelevant, it also misses the point that our teeth, alone, are insufficient to allow us to survive on meat in the wild. We need to use tools to eat anything larger than a chicken... you cannot kill a wild animal with your teeth, like all other truly omnivorous wild animals can.

But, yeah, it's irrelevant.

Of course it is! Bears will probably use their claws, letting the animal die from blood loss. But most likely not it's mouth.

A human will use a tool to kill the animal. But most likely not use it's mouth.

In the end, each animal used what was available to it to kill the cow.
 
We don't have teeth like bears - look at their canines compared to ours! It really bugs me when people bring up the "look at our teeth" 'justification' for eating meat - aside from being irrelevant, it also misses the point that our teeth, alone, are insufficient to allow us to survive on meat in the wild. We need to use tools to eat anything larger than a chicken... you cannot kill a wild animal with your teeth, like all other truly omnivorous wild animals can.

But, yeah, it's irrelevant.
You DIDN'T answer my question.

Perhaps it is irrelevant but why can't you answer me? I'm getting a bit frustrated. Those who I think are ethical vegans seem to be saying that eating meat is immoral just because it is and we don't have to answer your questions.
 
Of course it is! Bears will probably use their claws, letting the animal die from blood loss. But most likely not it's mouth.

A human will use a tool to kill the animal. But most likely not use it's mouth.

In the end, each animal used what was available to it to kill the cow.
Add to the tool box humans had at their disposal cooking.
 
Last edited:
Ad to the tool box humans had at their disposal cooking.

Beat me to it. Mankind had at its disposal cooking for nearly a million years. Considering the brief amount of that time having been recorded history, the sheer span of archaeological history suggests that our diets played more of a role in our more recent development into civilization than we often give credit.

That does not, by the way, make an argument for (or against) eating meat. At best, the book is basically a good source of information for why we cook our food, and how it helps to 'unlock' the benefits of the food we eat. For example: eating raw meat would not provide the same benefits as does cooked meat, because in the process of cooking we soften parts of the meat that would go undigested were it eaten raw. The same applies to many plant food sources as well (most notably grains and corn/maize).
 
[Going home now so will deal with the rest later]

We don't have teeth like bears - look at their canines compared to ours! It really bugs me when people bring up the "look at our teeth" 'justification' for eating meat - aside from being irrelevant, it also misses the point that our teeth, alone, are insufficient to allow us to survive on meat in the wild. We need to use tools to eat anything larger than a chicken... you cannot kill a wild animal with your teeth, like all other truly omnivorous wild animals can.
"Truly omnivorous"...

Shirley you jest (I just noticed this)

Volatile, in all due respect, and I say that with the deepest sincerity, there is no such thing as "Truly omnivorous". You are bastardizing the term.

Scientifically, omnivores include raccoons (no large canines), pigs (no large canines) insects like wasps, ants, flies (no teeth whatsoever) spiders (no canines), birds like hawks, eagles, chickens (no teeth whatsoever).

The notion that there is such a thing as a "true omnivore" and that it is distinguished by large canines is downright silly and not to mention without foundation.

An omnivore is simply a species that has evolved to survive by having the capacity to eat both plants and animals. They are typically opportunistic with general (as opposed to special) diets. Sound like humans? It should. It's because it's true.

Irrelevant or not.
 
Last edited:
I warned PETA.

KFC will be delivering another 'Bucket o Hostages' to my house tonight. :p

Actually, KFC isn't even real chicken

At least according to what I've been told



And now if you'll excuse me, I'm gonna go buy myself some real chicken and roast it in my oven
 
It seems to me that you are in the same boat. At the very least you have to admit that it's an amazing coincidence that the legal environment for animals right now in the USA and Canada in 2009 just happens to be an acceptable system.

Do you think you would feel the same way if this were 1990? 1980? 1970?

Not being an expert in animal law, I don't think there has been any significant change since 1970.

For specificitys sake, I would be in favor of loosening up restrictions on animal use in medical research if it would accelerate the process of getting new medical technologies to the public. Saving human lives should always come before animal welfare.

Once again you are hiding behind the straw man that someone is attacking your precious freedom.

Have you heard about this group that calls itself PETA?
 
Not being an expert in animal law, I don't think there has been any significant change since 1970.

For specificitys sake, I would be in favor of loosening up restrictions on animal use in medical research if it would accelerate the process of getting new medical technologies to the public. Saving human lives should always come before animal welfare.

Most of the legislation that would fall under 'animal law' in this nation since 1970 has focused more on pets, most notably under the various 'dangerous dog' laws that have been and continue to increasingly make it less and less legal to own certain types of dogs. You have your animal rights groups to thank for that, as well as the constant increase in mandatory spay/neuter laws out there, also designed to lower the number of available pets (though the AR groups have been less successful on the federal level, which are where the problem 'puppy/kitty/animal mills' actually exist, protected by the FDA). If anyone (I'm looking at you, mumblethrax) is looking for examples of where the AR movement went off in their own direction during or after the 1970's, the increase in dangerous dog and mandatory spay/neuter laws that have gone up dramatically since the early 1980's is your proof.
 
Ok, carnivores, you've let the omnivores bully you long enough. I'm here to tell you that you're giving them too much leeway. By trying to defend your eating of meat, you're letting them have power over the debate. Instead, why not have THEM convince us that eating meat is wrong. After all, the burden is upon them to do so. The social norm is that eating meat is ok. They have to show that it's wrong in order to change society. So, ominvores, show me why it's wrong to eat me and stop trying to get me to defend it.

And yes, social norm is an appeal to popularity, but not really a fallacy in this case. The reason is because we're talking about subjective morality and not trying to determine a fact. The social norm used to be that slavery was ok. The minority of freethinkers had to convince the rest of the public that it was wrong using reasoned debate. So, being that you're in the minority, you have to convince the public that eating meat is wrong.

So far, you're not doing all that well.

Also, is having a pet immoral?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom