Drudgewire
Critical Doofus
- Joined
- Feb 27, 2006
- Messages
- 9,421
And what?
Really if "one is a human being and one is a
ing cow" isn't a clear enough answer, I'm pretty sure nothing ever will be.And what?
ing cow" isn't a clear enough answer, I'm pretty sure nothing ever will be.What makes killing children wrong, but killing cows okay?
What the hell? That ain't correct for PETA. PETA's answer to protesting: GET NAKED. Running of the Bulls: GET NAKED. Vegetarianism: Have sex in public. Circus animals: GET NAKED. How is that not eroti.... I mean insane?Most of the Animal Rights groups like PETA run their game like Scientologists. You don't get to see the distilled nuttiness until you get into the upper echelons, even though you still get to see the occasional nutbag activity from some of their middle levels.
And what?
I asked, why is it not okay to kill people, but okay to kill cows.
What is the difference between cows and people that makes this answer relevant?
And you didn't answer the question.
I asked, why is it not okay to kill people, but okay to kill cows.
You say because cows aren't people. That doesn't answer anything. What is the difference between cows and people that makes this answer relevant?
And?
Animals eat other animals. They also don't have a choice in the matter. We do, and we have the means to stop eating meat, or at the very least eat far less of it so we don't have to factory farm millions of animals. Again it is not a matter of survival, it is a matter of taste. Just because we can do something doesn't mean we should. Further other animals don't cage and breed millions of other animals in captivity for it's own purpose. We don't treat them like life, we treat them like resources, like oil or coal. No other animal does this, so it is not just the natural way of things. Nothing about factory farming is natural. The argument that it is natural falls flat.
Death penalty, abortion, war? Seems not only okay to kill people but legal as well.
Tell you what, the day a cow successfully makes this argument I'll swear off red meat forever.
Well first off, just because you don't want to accept an answer doesn't mean one wasn't given.
Second. The difference is people are human. Do you think that a cow's life is equal to a human's and if so, why?
No but animals live on other animals slowly making their life a hell or even killing them going to another host, that is another animal using another animal as a resource. They are called parasites.
So you are saying that our superior mental faculty is what distinguishes us from animals and therefor gives us the right to do whatever we want with them?
All living things need to eat. So regardless there will be deaths. However we produce, cage, and kill millions upon millions of animals needlessly. This isn't done for food. This is done for taste. The amount of plant matter such as grain we have to grow to feed the animals we eat far outpaces what we would need to eat if we simply grew and ate plants. As such eating meat means we kill more hedgehogs and cute little mice than we would if we didn't eat meat because we have to plow far more fields.
...You know nothing about me, for instance the fact that I eat meat all the time...
I am genuinly interested in a polite discussion on this topic. Let me start off by asking, what exactly makes it okay to kill a cow, but not a fetus or child?
Again, that wasn't an answer. Saying people are people is not only irrelevant to the question I asked, it is redundant. Obviously people are human. I asked you why you think a cow's life is not equal to a human's (though phrased differently) and twice now you've said because humans are humans.
Wow, and here I was thinking you were just playing devil's advocate! You mean to tell me that meat eaters cause animals to die?? Whaaaat???
Which side I believe is rather irrelevant in a debate. The only thing that should matter are the arguments.Okay, so you are playing devil's advocate. Or you're not.
We have thumbs. Since you don't accept the mentally superior argument, we'll go genetic. If you don't accept that, then how about morally superior? We're at the top of the food chain and PETA thinks we are obligated to protect the rest of the food chain because of that. If you were running around the Serengeti, would a lion value your life enough to eat plants and/or protect you? Do lions strive for equality?
Here's a question for you: What makes an animal's life equal to a human's?
(but if you argue sanctity of life, we'd better not see you swatting at any mosquitos!)
Again, just because you don't want to accept the answer doesn't mean the answer wasn't given.
Fine, you want it spelled out. Like it or not, we as humans run this planet. We are, in fact, the tippy top of the food chain. Be this by design of some old guy on a cloud, natural selection, pure dumb luck, or the force... Here we be.
As a result of this, we can grow food for us, for the animals, raise said animals and eat them. Mainly the reason that we raise said animals for food is because it's easier than hunting them for food just as it would be easier for the cows to plant, grow, and store their own food. Alas they can't. They can't farm, they can't tend crops, they can't build a silo, and (Key point here!) they can't learn how to. So that is (granted, put very briefly) why a cow's life is not equal to a human's.
What relevance does having thumbs have for a moral question?
That was my point, yes. As for the last question, yes to the first part, no to the second. We don't have the right, but what right does a brown bear have to kill a fish when berries would suffice?Morally superior. Now there is another interesting argument. First a lion can't eat plants and survive, at least not to my knowledge. Second a lion is incapable of making the choice to value another living beings life. But perhaps that is your point? Are you saying that our ability to make moral judgments makes us superior, and therefor because of this moral superiority/ judgment ability we have the right to do with other life as we please?
With our amazing ability to consider moral ramifications and make judgments we as a species have done more damage to the planet, other life, and ourselves than any other species that has ever existed.
I don't know that I would consider this to make us morally superior Even if you wanted to say our ability to judge and form concepts of right and wrong does make us morally superior, why would we use that moral superiority to justify the large scale cruelty and killing of other animals? That just seems paradoxical.
Thank you. That was what I was asking for
It would be easier for humanity to cut meat out. To grow only crops requires less work than raising animals to eat.
As for the top of the food chain, that sounds like might equals right, which generally from a moral standpoint raises all sorts of problems. Men are stronger than women, that is just the way it is, therefor should they be able to rape women because they can?
In stories and folklore Vampires are considered to be even higher on the food chain, yet they are generally considered to be the evil ones. The wicked creatures which should be destroyed.
If an alien race that was far more advanced than we are came to earth and fed on people, would you then consider it morally okay for them to treat people like cattle? To cage, raise, kill, and eat us by the millions, especially if they didn't need to in order to survive?
Which side I believe is rather irrelevant in a debate. The only thing that should matter are the arguments.
Vampires
![]()
alien race
![]()
Animals eat other animals. They also don't have a choice in the matter. We do, and we have the means to stop eating meat, or at the very least eat far less of it so we don't have to factory farm millions of animals. Again it is not a matter of survival, it is a matter of taste. Just because we can do something doesn't mean we should. Further other animals don't cage and breed millions of other animals in captivity for it's own purpose. We don't treat them like life, we treat them like resources, like oil or coal. No other animal does this, so it is not just the natural way of things. Nothing about factory farming is natural. The argument that it is natural falls flat.
This position has already been addressed. The parasites need to do this to survive. We do not need to factory farm millions of cows to survive. We have other means, the parasites do not.
How so? I mean how well do you understand what goes into doing either one?
Well yes, I was just trying to point out that when we do this to animals it's no big deal, but when done to us it suddenly becomes this great evil. And this sort of thing is portrayed repeatedly in various books, stories, movies, etc.Yeah, but those are stories.
I suppose I can't say for sure unless it happens. I probably wouldn't stop for the rabbit or cat as it would be almost certain they would be dead. I can honestly say I'd probably cry at having killed them, especially for the cat. I love cats. I would stop for the child, partly because the child has a greater chance of being alive and being able to be saved, and partly because I grew up in this culture and so like everyone else I've been cultivated to see human life as more important. However the problem with this question is two fold. One, if I don't stop for the child and notify the police I'm creating further legal problems for myself because of the difference our societies laws place on the value of animals and people. And two, my own personal inclinations have no relevance as to what is morally right or wrong. If human life is worth more than animals there should be a reason, not simply because I feel more for the human.Now then, if you were driving to a very important engagement and a rabbit or a cat ran in front of your car and you hit it, would you stop? What if it was a human child?
Not at all. Might equals right implies oppression. Forcing women to stay at home and raise the kids, cook, clean, etc... keeps her from being a Dr, scientist, bike builder, or whatever. Forcing Blacks to pick cotton, and tend crops... does the same. At this time in the world's evolution cows simply are either an animal foraging for food or it is food. Aside from a few that become pets that's it.
Hell no, but then that's one of the distinctions. I know the difference and I've seen no indication that a cow does.
You have no grounds to make that statement. 100% of the species that have evolved sentience have factory farmed. Like it or not, we are the baseline and factory farming is natural.
Unti.l... that is, you discover sentient species that do not factory farm in sufficient numbers to make us the odd one out.
This is the kind of thing that people can debate back and forth till they are blue in the face. But ultimately, the only real argument that can be made here is this: Those of us who like meat are more numerous and better armed than those who want us to stop.