Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

That's not a connection, that's religious dogma. Just like how Scientologists try to make every subject about how Scientology makes it better, PETA twists any issue-of-the-week into somehow supposedly having to do with PETA's anti-fur and anti-meat AR campaigns.

Strawman. The concept that life has inherent value is independent of religion. Your inclusion of scientology has absolutely nothing to do with what I stated. A group of people in the US consider aborting a fetus to be equivilent to murder. They believe that fetus is living creature with an inherant right to its life. In the same way a group of people believe that animals are living creatures with an inherant right to life.

False dichotomy and moral absolutism right there. That you need to resort to such basic 'true believer' rhetoric shows your bad faith on the subject. You're not debating, you're preaching.

Strawman again. I'm not preaching anything. I'm outlining the connection that other posters in this thread said they couldn't understand. You know nothing about me, for instance the fact that I eat meat all the time. The concept of rights of animals, and the difference between humans and animals when it comes to rights is a well known philosophical topic that is frequently debated. For instance it was the subject of my social ethics class. So yes sir, it is debate. And if you'd like to actually address the issue rather than attack me or decide my motives that would be wonderful.


It's negative because it's opportunistic and taking advantage of tragedy to get attention. It's the ethical equivalent to tabloid paparazzi who troll police bands and dig through people's trash to chase a paycheck.

Regardless of the recent tragedy this is a very real issue of contention for many people, just as the abortion issue is.

MikeSun5 said:
How many hedgehogs and cute little mice are senselessly slaughtered when a wheat field is plowed? Oh, the humanity!

All living things need to eat. So regardless there will be deaths. However we produce, cage, and kill millions upon millions of animals needlessly. This isn't done for food. This is done for taste. The amount of plant matter such as grain we have to grow to feed the animals we eat far outpaces what we would need to eat if we simply grew and ate plants. As such eating meat means we kill more hedgehogs and cute little mice than we would if we didn't eat meat because we have to plow far more fields.

I am genuinly interested in a polite discussion on this topic. Let me start off by asking, what exactly makes it okay to kill a cow, but not a fetus or child?
 
Last edited:
Strawman. The concept that life has inherent value is independent of religion. Your inclusion of scientology has absolutely nothing to do with what I stated. A group of people in the US consider aborting a fetus to be equivilent to murder. They believe that fetus is living creature with an inherant right to its life. In the same way a group of people believe that animals are living creatures with an inherant right to life.

Ok but then another group of people think that both are silly.



Strawman again. I'm not preaching anything. I'm outlining the connection that other posters in this thread said they couldn't understand. You know nothing about me, for instance the fact that I eat meat all the time. The concept of rights of animals, and the difference between humans and animals when it comes to rights is a well known philosophical topic that is frequently debated. For instance it was the subject of my social ethics class. So yes sir, it is debate. And if you'd like to actually address the issue rather than attack me or decide my motives that would be wonderful.

Coolness.




Regardless of the recent tragedy this is a very real issue of contention for many people, just as the abortion issue is.

Ok.



All living things need to eat. So regardless there will be deaths. However we produce, cage, and kill millions upon millions of animals needlessly. This isn't done for food. This is done for taste.

How so?

The amount of plant matter such as grain we have to grow to feed the animals we eat far outpaces what we would need to eat if we simply grew and ate plants. As such eating meat means we kill more hedgehogs and cute little mice than we would if we didn't eat meat because we have to plow far more fields.

It's not just grain and it's not just plowing. Here we are surrounded by Walnut, almond, and a small orange grove. When they are ripped, mowed, harvested, or watered the small land mammals that aren't killed by the tending, remind the cats that they are cats

I am genuinly interested in a polite discussion on this topic. Let me start off by asking, what exactly makes it okay to kill a cow, but not a fetus or child?

A cow isn't a human.
 
Strawman. The concept that life has inherent value is independent of religion. Your inclusion of scientology has absolutely nothing to do with what I stated. A group of people in the US consider aborting a fetus to be equivilent to murder. They believe that fetus is living creature with an inherant right to its life. In the same way a group of people believe that animals are living creatures with an inherant right to life.

And neither groups are related. Fabricating a connection where there is none does not a valid defense make. Claim strawman all you like, but your attempts to relate unrelated things holds no water.

Strawman again. I'm not preaching anything. I'm outlining the connection that other posters in this thread said they couldn't understand. You know nothing about me, for instance the fact that I eat meat all the time. The concept of rights of animals, and the difference between humans and animals when it comes to rights is a well known philosophical topic that is frequently debated. For instance it was the subject of my social ethics class. So yes sir, it is debate. And if you'd like to actually address the issue rather than attack me or decide my motives that would be wonderful.

I couldn't care one bit about you personally. Your argument was flawed, and I explained why. Trying to personalize it doesn't somehow give your assertion any more validity.

Regardless of the recent tragedy this is a very real issue of contention for many people, just as the abortion issue is.

You're playing a weasel's game now. The fact that the billboards were placed when they were makes it obvious that they were taking advantage of unrelated tragedy to further their cause. There's loads of examples of PETA doing this over and over with tragedies, so your attempt to try and weasel out of the obvious fact that PETA is taking direct advantage of it is another display of bad faith on your part.

All living things need to eat. So regardless there will be deaths. However we produce, cage, and kill millions upon millions of animals needlessly. This isn't done for food. This is done for taste. The amount of plant matter such as grain we have to grow to feed the animals we eat far outpaces what we would need to eat if we simply grew and ate plants. As such eating meat means we kill more hedgehogs and cute little mice than we would if we didn't eat meat because we have to plow far more fields.

I am genuinly interested in a polite discussion on this topic. Let me start off by asking, what exactly makes it okay to kill a cow, but not a fetus or child?

And now, much like PETA does with tragedies, you're attempting to hijack this thread into another subject. Bravo.
 
I am genuinly interested in a polite discussion on this topic. Let me start off by asking, what exactly makes it okay to kill a cow, but not a fetus or child?

Cows are tasty.

Oh, and they are another species.

It is how it works in nature. You see, we are "omnivores". This means that we eat meat and vegetable matter.

There are a number of other omnivore species on the planet - including several of our ape relatives.

Also, there is too much work and effort in raising a fetus to harvestable size, or putting up with a child for years until it is ripe and ready for the pot.

It is just easier to eat cows.

Or deer, or goats, or sheep, or horses, or fish, or yams, or whatever.
 
My interpretation is that K is either a Peta fan/supporter OR comparing responding to Peta publicity by eating meat to hangin someone in response to civil rights publicity OR
not thinking before he hits the Post Quick Reply button. I hope it is the 1st or third of those but I have a nasty feeling respect for him has dropped some large number of notches (YMMV)

I find the statement I made in jest very, very slightly more morally repugnant than the statement made by TriskettheKid.

(No I'm not a PETA supporter, except to the extent that I'm an animal rights supporter).
 
Cows are tasty.

Oh, and they are another species.

It is how it works in nature. You see, we are "omnivores". This means that we eat meat and vegetable matter.

There are a number of other omnivore species on the planet - including several of our ape relatives.

What you are articulating here is called the naturalistic fallacy. It is the error of inferring from the fact that something occurs in nature the conclusion that it is morally good.

e.g. "Chimpanzees rape. Therefore we should rape too. It is how it works in nature".
 
What you are articulating here is called the naturalistic fallacy. It is the error of inferring from the fact that something occurs in nature the conclusion that it is morally good.

e.g. "Chimpanzees rape. Therefore we should rape too. It is how it works in nature".

IF rape had an evolutionary advantage (it doesn't), then you might be right.

However, we are "designed" to eat meat and vegetables. It isn't a choice - it is the way we are.
 
IF rape had an evolutionary advantage (it doesn't), then you might be right.

http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2001-06/NS-Raes-1906101.php

Still. Just because something is "natural" or !"an evolutionary advantage" dfoes not mean its just how things should be. Rape is repugnant no matter what evolutionary advantage it may give. Eating meat (and I really like putting my teeth and thick slab of rare beef) may be what we've "evolved" to do being omnivores, that does not mean its just how things must, or should be.

Something about an "is" should not be an "ought" I think.
 
I find the statement I made in jest very, very slightly more morally repugnant than the statement made by TriskettheKid.

(No I'm not a PETA supporter, except to the extent that I'm an animal rights supporter).

And you have nothing to say about my "Bucket o Hostages" gag?

I'm hurt. :(

You're right that your joke was morally repugnant. Trisket wasn't making fun of actual people.
 
Last edited:
What you are articulating here is called the naturalistic fallacy. It is the error of inferring from the fact that something occurs in nature the conclusion that it is morally good.

A "naturalistic fallacy" only exists if something exists that is above nature, a higher power that establishes objective standards of right and wrong.
 
wrong as in I'm a vegetarian. And PETA are *still* nucking futz

Vegetarian =/= self-righteous petty fascist.

None of the vegetarians I've known have ever had a problem with others eating meat. It's their own choice they make for themselves.

Q: How do you rationalize performing at "The Great American Rib Cook Off" when you are a vegetarian?

A: "The same way I can rationalize playing at a college even though I’m not a student anymore."

- Weird Al Yankovic
 
A cow isn't a human.

And?

Cows are tasty.

Oh, and they are another species.

It is how it works in nature. You see, we are "omnivores". This means that we eat meat and vegetable matter.

There are a number of other omnivore species on the planet - including several of our ape relatives.

Also, there is too much work and effort in raising a fetus to harvestable size, or putting up with a child for years until it is ripe and ready for the pot.

It is just easier to eat cows.

Or deer, or goats, or sheep, or horses, or fish, or yams, or whatever.

Animals eat other animals. They also don't have a choice in the matter. We do, and we have the means to stop eating meat, or at the very least eat far less of it so we don't have to factory farm millions of animals. Again it is not a matter of survival, it is a matter of taste. Just because we can do something doesn't mean we should. Further other animals don't cage and breed millions of other animals in captivity for it's own purpose. We don't treat them like life, we treat them like resources, like oil or coal. No other animal does this, so it is not just the natural way of things. Nothing about factory farming is natural. The argument that it is natural falls flat.

As to your other argument I never said anything about eating the fetus or children. I simply said killing them. You could say the difference then is that we eat the cows but not a child we murdered. I could then say what if we ate the child, does it then become okay to kill children just like cows? You say we don't do it because its easier to use cows but that is not how our society works. Most people hold the notion that killing children is wrong, but killing a cow isn't.

What makes killing children wrong, but killing cows okay?
 
I find the statement I made in jest very, very slightly more morally repugnant than the statement made by TriskettheKid.

(No I'm not a PETA supporter, except to the extent that I'm an animal rights supporter).

Except that your statement lacked the clear sense of hyperbole that mine had.

So, not only did you use the civil rights movement as a comparison for PETA, you also made a very, VERY bad joke.

PETJ is NOT happy about that.
 
What makes killing children wrong, but killing cows okay?

I don't know.

I suppose part of the reason is empathy. I've been a child, I have children, and I empathize with my own species. Cattle, not so much. I find more value in a person than in a cow.

Should I? I don't know.

I do know that beef is mighty tasty, and I don't plan to stop eating it. Ever.
I also know that this value I perceive was formed in childhood, and is part of my society. The vast majority of those around me also find beef mighty tasty.

I hope we have tacos for dinner tonight. :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom