Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

In a way, it did. I realised that what I bought for dinner was not jusitifable, as the tofu is right there next tot eh chicken. So to speak. I had no excuses not to.

Every time I shop, I have a choice. So do you. On what basis do you pick the meat?

Now you're being intentionally obtuse. No one's decision on what they eat comes from a blank slate. Not yours, not mine, not anyone's. I don't just mean what you or I may have had for dinner yesterday, I mean in general. If you're not jumping to conclusions with stuff like this then you're really reaching the level of bad faith on the discussion quickly.

I'm not really interested in going tit-for-tat in a constant circle with you, volatile. You're still not actually making an argument, you're making loose insinuations and when objections come up you revert to these cheap hypothetical nonsense ploys. You keep insisting that I (or someone else) defend eating meat, when you've not come even close to presenting something to defend against. You're demanding that we use values dictated by you and within the context of your foregone conclusion, but it just doesn't work like that. So I'll see if I can explain this one more time, in a different context (and with pictures):

One of the most basic areas of differing (though not always necessarily competing) opinions on social issues is where the basis of the argument comes. This can usually be broken down to a sliding scale with 'Liberty/Freedom' on one end and 'Equality/Equity' on the other.

socialbar1.png


Most people you're going to come across will fall somewhere in the middle area of this sliding scale.

socialbar2.png


There are people who hold extreme views, and they can typically be represented as...
socialbar3a.png

OR
socialbar3b.png


Those extremes signify a greater-than-average assignment of value to one ideal or the other, often at the expense of the other. PETA, for example, would qualify as the former (though it could arguably go even further to the edge), while in a rough sense a typical anarchist ethos would fall pretty much around the latter.

Your arguments, volatile, seem to be close to the edge of the average area for people, leaning heavily toward the Equality/Equity spectrum,
socialbar3c.png


While many of the arguments you're using are arguing against the opposite end of that average area,
socialbar3d.png


And in the meantime all of my own posts and arguably the majority of RandFan's posts (among others), have actually fallen even further in the middle of that average area,
socialbar3e.png


To at least some degree, considering the general view of distaste or disapproval for cruelty to animals, the line arguably falls closer to the Equality/Equity side than the true mid-level (as shown above), but ultimately still falls closer to the Liberty/Freedom side of the spectrum than, based only on your posts so far (since you haven't really been completely agreeable to stating your own case from the start), your own position and perspective on this issue. Every objection, every disagreement, and every rejection to the points you attempt to make-- which consist primarily of asking a pointed question and attempting to point out contradiction-- has come from that perspective that is differently situated than your own.

However, for you to not know this would require a level of wanton disregard or ignorance that I wouldn't attribute to you. However, you persist in arguing without the acknowledgment of that difference in value on the scale of Equality/Equity versus Liberty/Freedom. You keep asserting that the different perspective is wrong and unjustified, but every attempt to get you to flesh out your position results in you going right back to the attempts to take a response to your assertions and try to turn that into the contradiction that proves your point.

But that's the problem: it doesn't prove your point. Even in cases where you might see something contradictory, that doesn't automagically affirm your case by default (as I pointed out, the issue is not binary), and even if it did there is no way for those of us trying to reason with you to judge for ourselves, because there is no post where your position has taken anything but a challenging assertive tone instead of presenting an argument, plain and simply. You're so wrapped up in this game of "Gotcha!" with your hypothetical constructs and rhetorical acrobatics that after nearly three dozen pages there is still little else going on but tit-for-tat sniping. I'm aware that I've taken part in some of it as well, which is why I've instead written this post asking you to try a different presentation and approach it in a way that doesn't involve relying on the "Gotcha!" nonsense and the tit-for-tat that's gone on throughout the thread.

And honestly, to give credit where credit is due, Cain is currently approaching this with more intellectual honesty and reason right now.
 
Again with the meta-arguments? And with pictures?! Are you serious?

Rather than spend a few seconds actually answering the questions, you draw a diagram to show just how reasonable you think you're being? Seriously?

I've asked some pertinent questions to try and get a handle on exactly what you believe, and why you believe it, and in return you draw me a diagram? Do you think that's to your intellectual credit?

Let's ask directly: What's wrong with bestiality, Gren? Is sex with animals a moral issue?

ETA: I think that's a fair question, by the way. It's not a gotcha. I'm interested in pinning down exactly what your criteria are for determining which animal/human interactions are worthy of moral consideration, and on what grounds you make the distinction. A clear response to that question might help us get back to some productive discussion.
 
Last edited:
Well, let's at least try to be accurate. I called it a terrible argument, and then explained why it's a terrible argument. Observing that it's difficult to legally sort these issues out says nothing at all; first comes the moral argument -- that is, whether or not these issues are worth pursuing. I went on to point out (unnecessarily) that your argument fails on it's own terms as it's probably easier for a legal system to deal with animal rights.

I know what you argued, but I disagree that it explained why what I originally said was a terrible argument. I've already stated that saying the moral argument comes first assumes the conclusion before it's reached. I can keep saying this using different sentence structure each time I point it out, but the fact of the matter is that beginning with the conclusion isn't useful in this context. We know what the basic conclusion is: that eating meat is wrong. You now have to lead an argument to that conclusion instead of starting from it.

This seems like another uniquely bad argument, and I think Volatile's observations indicate you believe otherwise (or ought to for the sake of consistency):
Welfare, conservationism, euthanasia and extinction are all moral issues. You have no grounds to exclude meat-eating, and meat-eating alone, from moral consideration.

Your response went something like, "that's what YOU say" and then demanded he demonstrate meat-eating is a moral issue, even though it obviously involves competing interests, even though philosophers who (attempt to) justify meat-consumption agree it's a moral issue. It's possible for a person to insist he does not view an issue as a moral matter, but sincerity is not enough. An artist may murder people in order to create a crime scene of "transcendent beauty," but there's still an undeniable moral dimension. Reasons for eating meat tend to be more hum drum, given little or no thought, but your behavior still impacts creatures with interests who, it just so happens, are given consideration in other contexts.

No, because I don't consider every part of animal welfare or conservationism a moral issue. The argument volatile makes is inaccurate because it assumes far too much and then argues against those assumptions. I and others have continually attempted to point this out, and yet the assertions keep coming back to these types of false assumptions.

I should think the examples, "hypothetical games" or whatever you want to call them, unmistakably refer to accepted moral principles that have been repeated countless times. I do not think there has been a failure to understand the arguments; on the contrary, I think people see the implications all too clearly, which is why participation in this thread so often feels like yanking teeth.

This is not intended as a "formal" argument as it summarizes/highlights the basic tactic seen throughout this thread.

Let's go through them, then, because I'm of the opinion that again many assumptions are being made that are not reflective of what people are really saying.

-It's wrong to cause harm to a morally significant being for a relatively trivial reason (think about -- oh, say -- stealing money to pay for an IPOD).

This is a subjective statement, through and through. Different factors and different opinions on what constitutes harm, what constitutes morally significant, and what constitutes trivial reasons.

-Animals are morally significant beings, meaning their interests are worthy of our consideration. (We've attempted to get explicit consent on this many times, though the example involving a sadist works well. If you think it's OK for a sadist to dispose of an animal however he pleases, then you probably do not believe animals are morally significant beings, which would then move discussion to sub-arguments such as what constitutes a morally significant being, how do animals differ from humans who have moral standing, and so on. Why is torturing animals wrong? I suspect most people think it's wrong because it involves causing great harm for a trivial end; or consideration of interests -- the animal's versus the torturer's -- favors the animal.

This is an assertion without substance and is again based on subjective assignment. On top of the subjectivity of morally significant, both the interests of the animals (which I assume at this point you're referring to domestic livestock) and worthiness of consideration are subjective and are not a 'total yes' or 'total no' binary scenario.

-Typical meat consumption involves harming animals for a trivial reason (taste). Here you get into other sub-arguments: "eating is not trivial; we must eat in order to live." That's mistaken for reasons identified earlier, more than once (i.e., you are not required to eat MEAT in order to live). Others want to argue death is not harm (even if this was true, animals raised in factory farms suffer quite a bit). There are exceptional cases where the consumption of meat does not violate the harm principle as we understand it: passive death/killing (e.g., eating an animal that has died from natural causes, or a freak accident (roadkill)). Active killing for food purposes can also be justified: "if I do not eat this animal, then I will die." In such a case any pleasant taste is an unintended byproduct of a far more compelling interest: living. In any case, it might be useful to compare typical factory farm meat to purchasing conflict-diamonds.

Again, this gets into the subjective assumptions of what constitutes trivial reasons.

Put another way, an animal's interest in its one and only life, in not suffering, outweighs a human interest in the taste of meat, which has plenty of substitutes in the industrialized western world.

I would say that this is a better way for you to put it than the way it was put above, as it avoids most of the subjective assertions. However, the value of human taste for meat compared to the individual lives of each animal, regardless of whether this is to be constituted as suffering-- none of which has been conclusively argued-- has not been established as a completely moral issue. In bringing up the alternatives, it definitely can be made into a strong practicality issue, but the constant assertion of a moral issue is still not established.

As an alternative argument, I would say that there are significant changes to both the meat and the crop farming industries (they are typically tied to each other in many ways) that could be made that not only improve the time alive for the animals used for feedstock, but improve the quality of the land on which these food sources come, provide a smaller destructive footprint on the local and regional ecology, are more beneficial to the environment in general, and could result in reduced consumption of several foods that tend to be over-consumed-- not just meat, but corn and soy by-products in particular. Oh, and such changes would have the added benefit of our crops being able to be used as resources in competitive products in a market that requires greater transparency for what we eat, which (over time) allows for healthier foods to compete in a market currently dominated by high-fructose corn syrup products.

Sure, there's a bit of moral wrangling in that ideological argument, but even what's in there isn't a primary driver.
 
Again with the meta-arguments? And with pictures?! Are you serious?

Rather than spend a few seconds actually answering the questions, you draw a diagram to show just how reasonable you think you're being? Seriously?

I've asked some pertinent questions to try and get a handle on exactly what you believe, and why you believe it, and in return you draw me a diagram? Do you think that's to your intellectual credit?

Let's ask directly: What's wrong with bestiality, Gren? Is sex with animals a moral issue?

ETA: I think that's a fair question, by the way. It's not a gotcha. I'm interested in pinning down exactly what your criteria are for determining which animal/human interactions are worthy of moral consideration, and on what grounds you make the distinction. A clear response to that question might help us get back to some productive discussion.

My only guesses are that you are really working hard to not get the fact that I've been making this argument for dozens of pages, or maybe you are under the impression that somehow trying to focus on trying to get me to work through hypothetical conundrums is going to prove a point, or maybe some other as-yet-unclear motivation, but you thinking that trying to make a moral argument at me while ignoring the larger picture is going to fly, then you've crossed pretty clearly into the batcrap insane line of arguments.
 
One thing stands out in that post: Why would you want to "improve" livestock animals' time alive if they are not worthy of moral consideration? Wanting to make their lives better is a moral judgement, Gren.
 
My only guesses are that you are really working hard to not get the fact that I've been making this argument for dozens of pages, or maybe you are under the impression that somehow trying to focus on trying to get me to work through hypothetical conundrums is going to prove a point, or maybe some other as-yet-unclear motivation, but you thinking that trying to make a moral argument at me while ignoring the larger picture is going to fly, then you've crossed pretty clearly into the batcrap insane line of arguments.

Gren, seriously. I'm trying to understand what you do, and do not consider a moral issue, and I'm not sure what your answer to that question would be. So humour me: In your moral framework (or a-moral framework, as it might be), how do you deal with bestiality? Is it wrong, and if so, why?

[By the way, of course I think "somehow trying to focus on trying to get [you] to work through hypothetical conundrums is going to prove a point". I think you think it's going to prove a point to, which is why you're quite comically evading it.]
 
Last edited:
One thing stands out in that post: Why would you want to "improve" livestock animals' time alive if they are not worthy of moral consideration? Wanting to make their lives better is a moral judgement, Gren.

But it's not the primary driver in what I said! Why can you not understand this and accept that different priorities do not always have to mean that there's some kind of contradiction? I also happen to be of the opinion (based on experience) that cows, pigs, and chicken that have not been subjected to the harsher environments in the industrialized production facilities actually tend to taste better-- is the fact that I include that as part of the motivation still making it a clearly contradictory moral judgment on my part?

Jeez, man. Instead of jumping to conclusions and playing this corny game of "Gotcha!" why not actually try to consider the whole of what's being said for once.
 
But it's not the primary driver in what I said! Why can you not understand this and accept that different priorities do not always have to mean that there's some kind of contradiction? I also happen to be of the opinion (based on experience) that cows, pigs, and chicken that have not been subjected to the harsher environments in the industrialized production facilities actually tend to taste better-- is the fact that I include that as part of the motivation still making it a clearly contradictory moral judgment on my part?

Jeez, man. Instead of jumping to conclusions and playing this corny game of "Gotcha!" why not actually try to consider the whole of what's being said for once.

It's not GOTCHA at all. You can pretend details don't matter, but they do. Your entire argument rests, and has rested, on your continued assertion that livestock are not worthy of moral consideration, but then, there you are, making a reasonable argument which requires moral consideration of livestock. I'm sorry you feel "caught out", but these issues are the conclusions of your own lines of argument. If you think that they sound like "gotchas", maybe that says more about the strength of your arguments than you'd like it to.

On any other topic, you'd be on anyone engaging in such duplicity like a tonne of bricks. And you know it.

If you now wish to claim that your concern for animal welfare is that such animals taste better, then you'll need to empirically prove that you or people in general can tell the difference between the two, in the first instance. You may also wish to reconsider all those arguments you made in response to our criticisms of the taste imperative.
 
Last edited:
Nope. Oh, they may say as much on their website (somewhere, probably in smaller print, away from the front page), but I can attest to knowing that they still go to municipal and other shelters asking to "help" find the animals new homes and take some off the hands of the shelters. They have about five facilities like this that I know of personally.

So we can now say that PETA are a bunch of Hypocrites as well as being Batcrap Crazy?
 
It's not GOTCHA at all. You can pretend details don't matter, but they do. Your entire argument rests, and has rested, on your continued assertion that livestock are not worthy of moral consideration, but then, there you are, making a reasonable argument which requires moral consideration of livestock. I'm sorry you feel "caught out", but these issues are the conclusions of your own lines of argument. If you think that they sound like "gotchas", maybe that says more about the strength of your arguments than you'd like it to.

On any other topic, you'd be on anyone engaging in such duplicity like a tonne of bricks. And you know it.

If you now wish to claim that your concern for animal welfare is that such animals taste better, then you'll need to empirically prove that you or people in general can tell the difference between the two, in the first instance. You may also wish to reconsider all those arguments you made in response to our criticisms of the taste imperative.

Maybe if you got off your moral high horse it would help your argument.
 
My only guesses are that you are really working hard to not get the fact that I've been making this argument for dozens of pages, or maybe you are under the impression that somehow trying to focus on trying to get me to work through hypothetical conundrums is going to prove a point, or maybe some other as-yet-unclear motivation, but you thinking that trying to make a moral argument at me while ignoring the larger picture is going to fly, then you've crossed pretty clearly into the batcrap insane line of arguments.

Now you're not even pretending to make sense.
 
It's not GOTCHA at all. You can pretend details don't matter, but they do. Your entire argument rests, and has rested, on your continued assertion that livestock are not worthy of moral consideration, but then, there you are, making a reasonable argument which requires moral consideration of livestock. I'm sorry you feel "caught out", but these issues are the conclusions of your own lines of argument. If you think that they sound like "gotchas", maybe that says more about the strength of your arguments than you'd like it to.

On any other topic, you'd be on anyone engaging in such duplicity like a tonne of bricks. And you know it.

If you now wish to claim that your concern for animal welfare is that such animals taste better, then you'll need to empirically prove that you or people in general can tell the difference between the two, in the first instance. You may also wish to reconsider all those arguments you made in response to our criticisms of the taste imperative.

Yup, now you're definitely jumping into extremism-land. I did not "claim that [my] concern for animal welfare is that such animals taste better," I pointed out that your assumptions and jumping to conclusions are falling short of the reality.

Volatile, trying to discuss this with you is quickly becoming similar to trying to discuss the merits of more than one candidate in an election with someone who is essentially a one-issue voter. Do you really not see how narrow a scope you're demanding I (and everyone else) work from?

Really, things would go much better if you rebooted your argument (for why you believe eating meat is immoral) and posted it in a thread specifically dedicated to that subject. I'd ask Kevin but he's too busy ignoring anything honestly critical and Cain (who would probably provide a better argument at this point) is responding to multiple people at once in each post.
 
I agree that if "necro-bestiality" has "public health issues," then it may warrant outside intervention. For the purposes of these discussions it's usually best to assume the behavior is self-contained. Your point on a cases of incest that are not consensual is another exception for a similar reason: it involves coercion. It should go without saying that some types of harm do not raise moral concern, perhaps when two (or more) people engage in consensual rough sex.



I think you're expressing a commonly accepted view, but later on you write:



Well, this goes back to a consideration of interests, the interest in the animal not suffering versus the pleasure a human derives from the act.

I agree with all of this, although we likely disagree on some specific instances of what constitutes "suffering", and I probably put more weight on the human pleasure side of the scale.
 
Gren, I explained my position as a numbered series of bullet points on the previous page! Demonstrable harm, lack of necessity and lack of a sufficient positive case to mitigate the harms. That's my case, always has been my case, and at least one poster in this thread without a horse in the race has read, understood and clearly restated it in his own terms.

How on earth can you claim I "haven't made an argument" at the same time as you yourself AGAIN refuse to answer questions, dismiss questions out of hand without justification, make contradictory statements, evade any lines of questioning which may require you actually say something and claim, outright, that you don't *need* to make an argument.

It's astonishing.

Tell me what you think about the moral status of bestiality, Gren. Why won't you?
 
Today, 12:43 AM "I did not "claim that [my] concern for animal welfare is that such animals taste better,"

Yesterday, 11:45 PM "I also happen to be of the opinion (based on experience) that cows, pigs, and chicken that have not been subjected to the harsher environments in the industrialized production facilities actually tend to taste better... I include that as part of the motivation"

One hour, Gren. And you dare accuse me of "intellectual dishonesty"
 
Today, 12:43 AM "I did not "claim that [my] concern for animal welfare is that such animals taste better,"

Yesterday, 11:45 PM "I also happen to be of the opinion (based on experience) that cows, pigs, and chicken that have not been subjected to the harsher environments in the industrialized production facilities actually tend to taste better... I include that as part of the motivation"

One hour, Gren. And you dare accuse me of "intellectual dishonesty"

You're being ridiculous now. I pointed out that it was not the only reason. My reasoning includes both, but is driven by neither. Stop trying to attribute an argument I've not made to me.

Really. That you have to reach so very far at trying to make what doesn't fit for you into something that does fit for you shows how little of an actual argument you have.
 
At this point I doubt he can help it, or even realizes it. Again, it's the Dunning-Kruger effect in all its splendor.

Back when that paper was originally published (yes, not all of us learned about it from Youtube) a number of people pointed out that it was only a matter of time before some incompetent people started using it to insulate themselves from criticism.

As the research shows, if you're bad at philosophy you may not know you're bad at philosophy. You may even think you're in the top 25% of the population in terms of reasoning skills, when in fact you are solidly down in the bottom 25%.

However not knowing you're bad at philosophy you could end up making a fool of yourself by waving that paper at people who are actually on the far end of the bell curve from your incompetent self.

Consider: You are avoiding clearly stated arguments and retreating into incoherent rants about other people being "bat-crap insane". You're starting into RandFan's game of saying "Yes I say all sorts of things, but my beliefs aren't driven by any of them, so you can't ask me to keep my claims consistent. Consistency is for people whose beliefs are driven by their stated bases for belief". You're trying to wiggle out of consistency by calling consistency a "gotcha" or a "hypothetical conundrum" when in fact it's a prerequisite for calling yourself a rational human being. You're outright denying Volatile has even made an argument when it's stared you in the face in black and white bullet points.

Are you absolutely sure that your impressions about your own philosophical competence are justified? One of the important lessons of the Dunning-Kruger paper is not to get too sure of yourself when you're in unfamiliar territory, because you might just be making a total fool of yourself and not know it.
 
Last edited:
Are you absolutely sure that your impressions about your own philosophical competence are justified? One of the important lessons of the Dunning-Kruger paper is not to get too sure of yourself when you're in unfamiliar territory, because you might just be making a total fool of yourself and not know it.

Irony aside, what you're asking is better applied to your arguments, not mine. You see, you're the one arguing that one diet is morally superior than others. I've already pointed out that, yes, there are merits and strengths to a number of reasons to switch to a vegetarian or vegan diet. You're the one getting stuck on the issue that because there are valid criticisms for how meat is currently produced that consumption of meat is immoral.

But go ahead, Kevin: assume it's everyone else who has the problem here.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom