GreNME
Philosopher
- Joined
- Sep 16, 2007
- Messages
- 8,276
In a way, it did. I realised that what I bought for dinner was not jusitifable, as the tofu is right there next tot eh chicken. So to speak. I had no excuses not to.
Every time I shop, I have a choice. So do you. On what basis do you pick the meat?
Now you're being intentionally obtuse. No one's decision on what they eat comes from a blank slate. Not yours, not mine, not anyone's. I don't just mean what you or I may have had for dinner yesterday, I mean in general. If you're not jumping to conclusions with stuff like this then you're really reaching the level of bad faith on the discussion quickly.
I'm not really interested in going tit-for-tat in a constant circle with you, volatile. You're still not actually making an argument, you're making loose insinuations and when objections come up you revert to these cheap hypothetical nonsense ploys. You keep insisting that I (or someone else) defend eating meat, when you've not come even close to presenting something to defend against. You're demanding that we use values dictated by you and within the context of your foregone conclusion, but it just doesn't work like that. So I'll see if I can explain this one more time, in a different context (and with pictures):
One of the most basic areas of differing (though not always necessarily competing) opinions on social issues is where the basis of the argument comes. This can usually be broken down to a sliding scale with 'Liberty/Freedom' on one end and 'Equality/Equity' on the other.
Most people you're going to come across will fall somewhere in the middle area of this sliding scale.
There are people who hold extreme views, and they can typically be represented as...
OR
Those extremes signify a greater-than-average assignment of value to one ideal or the other, often at the expense of the other. PETA, for example, would qualify as the former (though it could arguably go even further to the edge), while in a rough sense a typical anarchist ethos would fall pretty much around the latter.
Your arguments, volatile, seem to be close to the edge of the average area for people, leaning heavily toward the Equality/Equity spectrum,
While many of the arguments you're using are arguing against the opposite end of that average area,
And in the meantime all of my own posts and arguably the majority of RandFan's posts (among others), have actually fallen even further in the middle of that average area,
To at least some degree, considering the general view of distaste or disapproval for cruelty to animals, the line arguably falls closer to the Equality/Equity side than the true mid-level (as shown above), but ultimately still falls closer to the Liberty/Freedom side of the spectrum than, based only on your posts so far (since you haven't really been completely agreeable to stating your own case from the start), your own position and perspective on this issue. Every objection, every disagreement, and every rejection to the points you attempt to make-- which consist primarily of asking a pointed question and attempting to point out contradiction-- has come from that perspective that is differently situated than your own.
However, for you to not know this would require a level of wanton disregard or ignorance that I wouldn't attribute to you. However, you persist in arguing without the acknowledgment of that difference in value on the scale of Equality/Equity versus Liberty/Freedom. You keep asserting that the different perspective is wrong and unjustified, but every attempt to get you to flesh out your position results in you going right back to the attempts to take a response to your assertions and try to turn that into the contradiction that proves your point.
But that's the problem: it doesn't prove your point. Even in cases where you might see something contradictory, that doesn't automagically affirm your case by default (as I pointed out, the issue is not binary), and even if it did there is no way for those of us trying to reason with you to judge for ourselves, because there is no post where your position has taken anything but a challenging assertive tone instead of presenting an argument, plain and simply. You're so wrapped up in this game of "Gotcha!" with your hypothetical constructs and rhetorical acrobatics that after nearly three dozen pages there is still little else going on but tit-for-tat sniping. I'm aware that I've taken part in some of it as well, which is why I've instead written this post asking you to try a different presentation and approach it in a way that doesn't involve relying on the "Gotcha!" nonsense and the tit-for-tat that's gone on throughout the thread.
And honestly, to give credit where credit is due, Cain is currently approaching this with more intellectual honesty and reason right now.