Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

I'd just like to point out that I'm not a vegetarian so the inconsistency that I'm seeing here is in my own attitudes and behaviour.

Which is why I went vegan.

It's also what Cain and Kevin and I have been arguing in favour of all thread. Consistency with other behaviours.

I appreciate that someone, finally, has understood what we've been saying. :)
 
GreNME:

Thanks. With this clarification I can say a few things, but one very important thing: this is a terrible argument. It also seems to rely heavily upon a dark, stilted understanding of "across the board." Should I have said the law ought to strive for inconsistency? Most importantly, just because it's difficult to legislate and enforce competing claims does not mean animals lack moral standing. Perhaps more devastating to your (no pun intended) densely written objection is that the law is arguably simpler with regard to animals, whose interests are the same regardless of where we find them versus the competing moral claims of people rooted in a tribal or religious culture (read as "thick" identities).

Calling it a terrible argument and not at all actually addressing what was said does not lead me to take your accusation very seriously. That you speak to the "interests" of animals being simpler to the more complex variations for humans as if that's somehow damning of what I said, humans are the only ones who are required to follow the laws, so you're not making much of a point here. Whether you value the different versions of human systems one way or another compared to animals is ultimately subjective to the fact that it is what it is, and there is no universality within it.

The problem with this construction is that you have it perfectly backwards. First we dispute relative merits of value systems -- are animals worthy of moral considerations -- then we can argue over circumstances (e.g., animals as livestock, which is an important and practical concern), and later we can argue over the "human application of death" on a species by species or case by case basis, but this is something any criminal justice system will "muddle" through anyway.

Nope, it's only backwards because you wish to work backwards from the conclusion. You are trying to drive the conversation from the preconceived notion that it's a moral issue to begin with. You need to define the values you're using first, then present the moral argument, and follow through with why your moral argument is applicable to something most currently consider morally neutral in the general sense. The biggest failure in your arguments, Cain, is that you continually refuse to acknowledge that any value system but the one you are applying is valid, yet you have never once quantified it. You construct hypothetical intellectual games and you make rhetorical statements and assertions, but while you may be aware of your foundational value set you're beginning from the argument that the inherent symbiotic relationship between humans and animals is wrong, and you've placed death (and "harm") as the basis for it. So, beginning from that basis, then explaining the value as a (negative) moral construct instead of a symbiotic one, and then offering the conclusion as morally superior, is what would make an argument. You have yet to do that, and you're damning everyone else for not accepting what you've been proposing already that has contained an as-yet-unmade argument with what appears to be an assumed conclusion. None of those who disagree with you share your foregone conclusion, yet you keep coming at anything said as if they should. It would do your posts well to explain why.
 
Gren - they could be kept in the exact same way they are now and be killed for kicks instead of food. We could convert the entire meat-production apparatus into a bestial-sex-toy-production apparatus, and retain all the "benefits" you and RandFan and Belz have cited, except for taste. It'd just need different packaging. But I think you'd find that problematic. Wouldn't you? Many happy meat-eaters would.

My happiness is not connected to my eating of meat, so your punctuation of an assertion with an obvious emotional accusation just shows the weak ground your argument is standing on. I've explicitly argued that, in as much as I feel anything about the current state of the food market, there is much that can be changed for the better and should be changed for the better, on many levels. Your (and others') constant disregard of this has been a blind spot in the criticisms against what I've said.

If we're interested in biodiversity, then let's do something about that. Let's not engage in practices which go against the very heart of conservationist ethics by using animals as commodities. There are innumerable ways "to support biodiversity and maintain ecological habitats" other than mass-producing food animals - and in fact, an elimination of livestock farming would probably help this goal in a number of ways.

It would also be throwing out the baby with the bathwater, as far as my opinion is concerned. That there's a symbiotic relationship between humans and domestic animals is historically demonstrable. That doesn't mean I advocate the over-exploitation of this, but my objections in the welfare and conservation terms are not based on the assumption of intrinsic wrong of eating meat, any more than my objections to the production and consumption of fossil fuels is based on the assumption of intrinsic wrong of using fossil fuels. My objection is that both can be done in a manner that is less wasteful, less destructive, and more in line with our civil and social level of development.

On PETA - I don't agree with them, nor was that the point of my post. What I objected to was (as usual) one poster's inconsistent application of a standard. He was outraged enough at the euthanasia programme to call it "genocide", but still eagerly supported the killing of a different species for a much more amorphous reason.

The problem is that PETA's ultimate solution of liberation leads precisely to a condition of genocide. Just because it's done through ignorant misunderstanding of consequences makes it no less objectionable.
 
Gren - how can you deny that you consider the treatment of animals a moral issue, but then advocate animal-environmentalism, a moral position?

It's not fair to Cain to berate him for "trying to drive the conversation from the preconceived notion that it's a moral issue to begin with" because this is an issue you yourself accept as a moral one. This is what we mean about inconsistency. You might claim that meat-eating, of all our interactions with animals, is not a moral issue, but then you make arguments against euthanasia or for animal welfare laws, say, in explicitly moral terms. If animals are worthy of moral consideration - a point I think you agree with - on what basis can you exclude food animals from your moral framework?

In fact, I don't even think you do that - after all, you have accepted that you are in favour of anti-cruelty legistaltion and for better standards of care. These are examples of taking food animals as a moral issue. Cain's argument is built on that very point of agreement.
 
I'd just like to point out that I'm not a vegetarian so the inconsistency that I'm seeing here is in my own attitudes and behaviour. My point is that finding the killing for kicks of animals wrong but seeing killing for food as being ok seems to be rating my pleasure from eating meat as being more morally justifiable than the animal killers pleasure from just killing.

I disagree with your point completely. Cultivating an animal for food is simply not equitable to killing an animal for fun or for sex. Considering them the same is part of the equivocation fallacy that's been mentioned before-- unless one can present an argument of why they are the same, the assertion is insufficient.
 
Gren - how can you deny that you consider the treatment of animals a moral issue, but then advocate animal-environmentalism, a moral position?

It's not fair to Cain to berate him for "trying to drive the conversation from the preconceived notion that it's a moral issue to begin with" because this is an issue you yourself accept as a moral one. This is what we mean about inconsistency. You might claim that meat-eating, of all our interactions with animals, is not a moral issue, but then you make arguments against euthanasia or for animal welfare laws, say, in explicitly moral terms. If animals are worthy of moral consideration - a point I think you agree with - on what basis can you exclude food animals from your moral framework?

In fact, I don't even think you do that - after all, you have accepted that you are in favour of anti-cruelty legistaltion and for better standards of care. These are examples of taking food animals as a moral issue. Cain's argument is built on that very point of agreement.

You're viewing it in black and white. I don't view what I eat as a moral issue. I view being less wasteful, proactive about the environment, and having a healthier diet and relationship to our resources a moral issue. They are not the same thing, I see no reason to make them the same thing, and no argument has been sufficiently made to change that.
 
My happiness is not connected to my eating of meat, so your punctuation of an assertion with an obvious emotional accusation just shows the weak ground your argument is standing on.

You don't think that the "Mmmmm,.... steak" posts on page one, or RandFan's admission that a vegan diet would be intolerable, taste wise, is reason for me to doubt you? Are you now saying that you do not consider the taste-factor to be an issue, and that you have other compelling reasons behind your dietary choices? If you wish to disregard the pleasure principle entirely, you are thus required, that you make a positive argument that meat-eating is better than the alternative in terms of environmentalism, your principal aim. I do not believe that you could support such an argument.

In any case, mine is most resolutely not an emotional argument, but a technical one. I contend that sexual pleasure and gastronomic pleasure are not dissimilar, and as such to disagree with one would also be to disgaree with the other.

What's your take on the industrialised production of bestial sex-toys? It's a legitimate question, and an important one.


I've explicitly argued that, in as much as I feel anything about the current state of the food market, there is much that can be changed for the better and should be changed for the better, on many levels. Your (and others') constant disregard of this has been a blind spot in the criticisms against what I've said.
Not at all. On this, we agree. This shows that you see the welfare of animals as a moral issue, and that it should be discussed in moral terms. To turn away from this statement to claim that meat-eating is not a question worthy of moral consideration shows up the inconsistencies we've been talking about.

On what grounds - for what reasons - do you think animals should be treated better?

Where do you stand on testing cosmetics on animals?

I'd like to understand your rationalisations.


It would also be throwing out the baby with the bathwater, as far as my opinion is concerned. That there's a symbiotic relationship between humans and domestic animals is historically demonstrable. That doesn't mean I advocate the over-exploitation of this, but my objections in the welfare and conservation terms are not based on the assumption of intrinsic wrong of eating meat, any more than my objections to the production and consumption of fossil fuels is based on the assumption of intrinsic wrong of using fossil fuels. My objection is that both can be done in a manner that is less wasteful, less destructive, and more in line with our civil and social level of development.
No-one's argued that there is an "intrinsic" wrong with eating meat. In fact, I have directly expressed the contrary view on more than one occasion. But the point is, if bio-diversity is your goal, let's work on bio-diversity. It's quite clear that in a number of cases, farming reduces and inhibits the diversity you say you support. The two things, in other words, are separate issues, and citing "bio-diversity" in support for meat-eating makes no sense, as your desired goals can be achieved (and, perhaps, better achieved) in ways entirely divorced from the production of livestock.
 
Last edited:
You're viewing it in black and white. I don't view what I eat as a moral issue.

Yes, you've said.

But that's inconsistent with all your other positions on animals. From your posts, it's clear you view animal issues from within an explicitly moral framework. "Better", in your last post, is but the most recent example.Welfare, conservationism, euthanasia and extinction are all moral issues. You have no grounds to exclude meat-eating, and meat-eating alone, from moral consideration.

And that's the problem. You still haven't made a credible case why diet should be excluded from your moral system.

I view being less wasteful, proactive about the environment, and having a healthier diet and relationship to our resources a moral issue. They are not the same thing, I see no reason to make them the same thing, and no argument has been sufficiently made to change that.
You're making a meta-argument here. All these positions are one step removed from a central point - which is regarding animals themselves as worthy of moral consideration. Why worry about euthanasia, for example, the if animal death doesn't bother you? Why worry about improving the welfare conditions of livestock if you do not consider animals themselves worthy of moral consideration?
 
Last edited:
I disagree with your point completely. Cultivating an animal for food is simply not equitable to killing an animal for fun or for sex. Considering them the same is part of the equivocation fallacy that's been mentioned before-- unless one can present an argument of why they are the same, the assertion is insufficient.

True in that they're obviously not identical actions, one is done for food and pleasure (the taste) the other done sorely for pleasures sake. Still given that there are alternatives to eating meat I can see the logic in Volatile's argument in that choosing to eat meat seems to boil down to the personal prefernce for the pleasure it gives me compared to other sources of food.
 
Why not? You do not need to eat meat.

You do not need to eat vegetables.

But you do, because it tastes good.

And also because it's the easiest way to get the proteins I need. You seem to conveniently ignore that point every time it's brought up.

You're engaging in an activity which requires in the death of animals solely (principally, perhaps) for the pleasure it brings you. How is that not sadistic?

Do you kill bugs in your home ? If you do, you're doing so in order to maintain a certain amount of comfort, which is a pleasure don't actually need. In other words, you are engaging in an activity which requires the death of animals solely for the pleasure it brings you. How is that not sadistic ?

Perhaps now you see why your question isn't relevant.

I mean, the duck-shagger would have all the defences you have for your meat-eating - it's convenient, pleasurable and, in RandFan's altruism argument, he's giving them life before he kills them for the thrill. And yet you find his actions "sadisitc" or psychologically-troubled. Why?

Apples and oranges, Volatile. If you can't see that, I can't really help you.

Which is why we're having this discussion. You claim "it's not immoral", and then express moral concern about similar behaviours.

That's the point.

No, it's not. You are the one who is incapable of distinguishing between two very different things. Those behaviours aren't even remotely similar.

You eat vegetables, nuts and seeds in addition to your steak already, right? So who's forcing anyone to do anything?

My point is that you're claiming that we shouldn't eat meat. That it's not really a question of choice unless you're evil. So presumably you'd like to force me to NOT eat meat or at least convince me to do so. My argument is that this would result in harm towards me.

You think dead-duck sex is indicative of psychological problems, but then state that "the taste of meat isn't "so awesome" as to supersede any of my moral values". Those two statements are contradictory. Explain to me how you reconcile them.

I don't see how they are contradictory. In fact, they have nothing to do with one another, whatsoever.
 
You don't think that the "Mmmmm,.... steak" posts on page one, or RandFan's admission that a vegan diet would be intolerable, taste wise, is reason for me to doubt you? Are you now saying that you do not consider the taste-factor to be an issue, and that you have other compelling reasons behind your dietary choices?

Wait, so I make a personal statement about myself, and you try to catch me in some supposed contradiction by using other people's statements?

You're doing a helluva job there, Volatile.

In any case, that is most resolutely not an emotional argument, but a technical one. I contend that sexual pleasure and gastronomic pleasure are not dissimilar, and as such to disagree with one would also be to disgaree with the other.

Which is more equivocation on your part. Well, either that or you lack experience of sexual pleasure to know the difference on a personal level (though scientifically speaking that should be a limiting factor). No, eating even the most tasty of meals, regardless of whether meat is present or not, is nothing at all like sexual pleasure, not in the mechanics or the motivation.

What's your take on the industrialised production of bestial sex-toys? It's a legitimate question, and an important one.

How is this legitimate as a question? This reeks of spaghetti-on-the-wall technique. No context, no details, no circumstance, just a demand for a black-or-white answer. Again, you can do better than this.

GreNME said:
I've explicitly argued that, in as much as I feel anything about the current state of the food market, there is much that can be changed for the better and should be changed for the better, on many levels. Your (and others') constant disregard of this has been a blind spot in the criticisms against what I've said.
Not at all. On this, we agree. This shows that you see the welfare of animals as a moral issue, and that it should be discussed in moral terms. To turn away from this statement to claim that meat-eating is not a question worthy of moral consideration shows up the inconsistencies we've been talking about.

You keep saying that, but have yet to back it up. At this point I'm tired of trying to provide you an explanation that I think is actually addressing the argument you're claiming to make (but not explicitly making) with your attempts to highlight (what you call) inconsistencies.

On what grounds - for what reasons - do you think animals should be treated better?

Which animals? The answer depends on which animals you're asking about. Do you really not see the ways you're slithering around actually making an argument?

Where do you stand on testing cosmetics on animals?

I'd like to understand your rationalisations.

Sorry, but I don't believe you would like that. I believe you would like me to continue supplying defensive arguments so that you can continue to try to pick them apart and consider that your full argument. So no, you make your case, then I'll make my case, and we can go from there. Let's be intellectually honest with each other for once in this thread.

For the record, I see no reason or need for cosmetic testing. That's pretty much it. Other than that I'm agnostic on it.

No-one's argued that there is an "intrinsic" wrong with eating meat. In fact, I have directly expressed the contrary view on more than one occasion. But the point is, if bio-diversity is your goal, let's work on bio-diversity. It's quite clear that in a number of cases, farming reduces and inhibits the diversity you say you support. The two things, in other words, are separate issues, and citing "bio-diversity" in support for meat-eating makes no sense, as your desired goals can be achieved (and, perhaps, better achieved) in ways entirely divorced from the production of livestock.

I'm not making an argument supporting eating meat. I'm not defending anything. That you're continually demanding that I defend it without putting forth an argument against it first is ridiculous and long past tiresome. All I've said is that I don't see the value of a moral argument that the symbiotic relationship between humans and domesticated animals is inherently wrong, in moral terms or otherwise. I think that there are a number of things that are curently operationally wrong, in that the wrong-ness of the means has become wasteful, damaging, and unhealthy. I've already said a number of times that those "number of cases" you object to on moral grounds against eating meat I object to (though apparently to a lesser degree) for reasons not having to do with eating meat, yet you insist that I should be viewing it from your perspective. Well, give me your perspective first so that I can evaluate!
 
I disagree with your point completely. Cultivating an animal for food is simply not equitable to killing an animal for fun or for sex. Considering them the same is part of the equivocation fallacy that's been mentioned before-- unless one can present an argument of why they are the same, the assertion is insufficient.

They are the same because they are both killing an animal for the pleasure it brings. If other food sources are available, the choice to eat meat becomes solely one of preference. This is belied by any number of "Mmmm... steak" posts in this thread and elsewhere. The taste of meat is by far the over-riding concern when justifying meat-eating and, in any case, we could achieve any and all other supposed benefits of industrial meat production cited thus far in the thread (altruism, conservation, protection from extinction) other than taste by turning the whole apparatus over to making bestial sex toys.

With this in mind, in what way are taste and sexual pleasure from bestiality different, and why is one OK but the other frowned upon? Why is the sensation of taste enough to dispel the obvious problem you have with a hypothetically-identical system of production geared towards necro-bestiality?

I don't see a difference. Could you please explain why you do?
 
Yes, you've said.

But that's inconsistent with all your other positions on animals. From your posts, it's clear you view animal issues from within an explicitly moral framework. "Better", in your last post, is but the most recent example.Welfare, conservationism, euthanasia and extinction are all moral issues. You have no grounds to exclude meat-eating, and meat-eating alone, from moral consideration.

So you say, but you never explain why I have no such grounds (even though that's not an accurate summation of what I'm doing).

And that's the problem. You still haven't made a credible case why diet should be excluded from your moral system.

That's a little better than the above, and closer to addressing what I actually said. My reply is: you have never, not in this thread or the last, provided any kind of argument explaining why I should include diet as a moral issue.

You're making a meta-argument here. All these positions are one step removed from a central point - which is regarding animals themselves as worthy of moral consideration. Why worry about euthanasia, for example, the if animal death doesn't bother you? Why worry about improving the welfare conditions of livestock if you do not consider animals themselves worthy of moral consideration?

I have never stated that animals are not worthy of moral consideration. However, that does not equate to my believing that all animals are worthy of equal consideration under any terms and without context. That's your own faulty construct right there, and until you actually provide a real argument that lays out where your attribution of values actually lies, I'm not inclined to keep trying to guess. So instead you get to keep making these strawman arguments that would make your position easier to hold in moral absolutist terms.
 
Why is the sensation of taste enough to dispel the obvious problem you have with a hypothetically-identical system of production geared towards necro-bestiality?

Wow, just wow. Really, Volatile, until you make an actual argument that isn't built on strawmen responses to answers I give, I'm really not inclined to continue down this path with you.
 
This is my suggestion, Volatile: start a new thread, sans the baggage in this one. Fill out your argument, from bases to the conclusion (or the closest approximation), within the first post. If you really want to do this, then let's to it in an intellectually honest manner.
 
They are the same because they are both killing an animal for the pleasure it brings. If other food sources are available, the choice to eat meat becomes solely one of preference. This is belied by any number of "Mmmm... steak" posts in this thread and elsewhere. The taste of meat is by far the over-riding concern when justifying meat-eating and, in any case, we could achieve any and all other supposed benefits of industrial meat production cited thus far in the thread (altruism, conservation, protection from extinction) other than taste by turning the whole apparatus over to making bestial sex toys.

With this in mind, in what way are taste and sexual pleasure from bestiality different, and why is one OK but the other frowned upon? Why is the sensation of taste enough to dispel the obvious problem you have with a hypothetically-identical system of production geared towards necro-bestiality?

I don't see a difference. Could you please explain why you do?


Do you believe that stealing to feed yourself is just as bad as stealing to buy a new Ipod? Do you believe that killing someone to defend yourself is different from killing to watch a man die? They are both stealing, they are both killing.

The urge to eat, and eat meat, is fundamentally different from the urge for sex, or to watch something die. Your equivocation is weak on this level. They are not at all the same except for the death of the animal.

I haven't even seen any evidence that it would even be possible for a large percentage of the populace to get nutrition from a vegetarian diet, let alone a vegan one. I share many of the concerns of wasteful and destructive production (especially with cattle and hogs right now), but that doesn't mean that eating meat is wrong.

If eating meat is morally wrong because of harm it causes animals, and animals have the right not to be harmed, then they have the responsibility not to harm in turn. Are you then for the jailing of wolves? Of mountain lions? This isn't a strawman or me mocking you. If you are consistent in your argument, this is a logical conclusion. Please tell us why or why not.

EDIT: Damnit GreNME, you can't go posting so many good posts while I'm trying to struggle through what I'm trying to say! Unfair. :p
 
Last edited:
Wait, so I make a personal statement about myself, and you try to catch me in some supposed contradiction by using other people's statements?

I'm interested if you'd disagree with them. Taste is not a consideration in your diet?


Which is more equivocation on your part. Well, either that or you lack experience of sexual pleasure to know the difference on a personal level (though scientifically speaking that should be a limiting factor).

I'm not a necro-besaphile, but I can imagine that there are people who are. On what grounds do you belittle their pleasure?

No, eating even the most tasty of meals, regardless of whether meat is present or not, is nothing at all like sexual pleasure, not in the mechanics or the motivation.

Why? They are both activities orientated towards the fulfilment of pleasure. One might even argue that sexual pleasure is MORE powerful than even the juciest lamb chop.

You're the one who claims not to see diet as a moral issue - so explain to me why a system of aninmal cultivation geared towards the production of tasty meat is OK and hypothetically-identical one geared towards the production of bestial sex-aids is not? Why is the use of animals to fulfil a sexual desire a moral issue, and the use of them to fulfil a gastronomic one isn't?

I don't understand your point.

How is this legitimate as a question?

Because I'm interested i9n why you exclude diet and diet alone from your consideration of animals. If you're bothered about necro-bestiality - and, it seems you are - I'd like to know why. Clearly.

You keep saying that, but have yet to back it up. At this point I'm tired of trying to provide you an explanation that I think is actually addressing the argument you're claiming to make (but not explicitly making) with your attempts to highlight (what you call) inconsistencies.

Gren, I've backed it up over and over again. All you've done in return is stonewall. "It's not a moral issue" you cry, over and over again, all the while failing to explain why this might be the case, given your other views.

At least one poster has understood and acknowledged that I have made a logical and sound case. As such, your pretence that I haven't done so rings all the more hollow.


Which animals? The answer depends on which animals you're asking about. Do you really not see the ways you're slithering around actually making an argument?

Evasiveness and inability to answer noted, Gren. You know very well that we're talking, in this context, about animals in food production. In fact, if you're following the argument, it's quite clear that I was referring you your repeated claims that conditions for livestock should be improved. If you think that animals should be treated better, then you see animals themselves as worthy of moral consideration. We've been over this.

Sorry, but I don't believe you would like that. I believe you would like me to continue supplying defensive arguments so that you can continue to try to pick them apart and consider that your full argument. So no, you make your case, then I'll make my case, and we can go from there. Let's be intellectually honest with each other for once in this thread.

So rather than making a positve case, you'll pretend I was lying?

This is where Cain starts getting snarky, and where I start getting disappointed. You'll note that you've not made any attempt either to answer the questions or justify your psotions, but instead baldly calim that the questions are pointless, or that 'm "dishonest" when asking you to make a case.

You cannot seriously, with a straight face, still claim that I haven't made a case when other posters have acknowledged that I have, and when your entitre rebuttal is basically "But... no". I've explained, in some detail, how I believe your exclusion of diet from your broader stance on animals is inconsistent, and you have made no positive case to the contrary other than gainsaying. This post alone is clear enough evidence of that.

If you have a case to make, make it.

For the record, I see no reason or need for cosmetic testing. That's pretty much it. Other than that I'm agnostic on it.

No reason or need. I agree.

What reason or need do you have to eat meat?

I'm not making an argument supporting eating meat.

Well, hurry up and do so. Without a considered argument in its favour, its as unsupportable as a behaviour as any other.

All I've said is that I don't see the value of a moral argument that the symbiotic relationship between humans and domesticated animals is inherently wrong, in moral terms or otherwise.

And yet at the same time, you have moral qualms about all sorts of human-animal interactions (welfare, euthanasia and, it seems, bestiality). So you're being either dishonest (with yourself, perhaps) or you're being stupid.

I know you're not stupid.
 
Do you believe that stealing to feed yourself is just as bad as stealing to buy a new Ipod? Do you believe that killing someone to defend yourself is different from killing to watch a man die? They are both stealing, they are both killing.

No and no. But these two are not relevant examples. I suggest you read my posts earlier in the thread; I thought I'd made it abundantly clear earlier. Another poster got it and even restated the entire argument correctly and concisely in his own terms, so it can't have been that obscure.

The urge to eat, and eat meat, is fundamentally different from the urge for sex, or to watch something die. Your equivocation is weak on this level. They are not at all the same except for the death of the animal.

The point, Tyr, is not about the "urge" to eat. Of course we must eat. But I guarantee that most posters on this forum can buy a nutritionally-complete vegan diet from the same stores they buy their meat from. So the analogy is not about the "urge" but about the end result - the pleasure that results.

The taste of meat is cited (and you can see this in this thread) as the primary or even the only reason for eating it. As such, if you want to support meat-production but oppose killing for necro-bestial purpouses, you must explain why the satiation of taste is sufficient to overcome the moral bjections to the satation of sexual desire when an animal death is involved.

I'm running for my train, but the rest of your objections have been covered in this thread already.
 
GreNME said:
I'm not making an argument supporting eating meat.
Well, hurry up and do so. Without a considered argument in its favour, its as unsupportable as a behaviour as any other.

Nope, not good enough. We (humans) do not operate from a tabula rasa, so if you're demanding that a proper counter argument be made against the supposed immorality of eating meat, then make the argument against eating meat in the first place.

And yet at the same time, you have moral qualms about all sorts of human-animal interactions (welfare, euthanasia and, it seems, bestiality). So you're being either dishonest (with yourself, perhaps) or you're being stupid.

I know you're not stupid.

I also know that you are likely not fond of false dichotomies, yet there one is in your post.
 
No and no. But these two are not relevant examples. I suggest you read my posts earlier in the thread; I thought I'd made it abundantly clear earlier. Another poster got it and even restated the entire argument correctly and concisely in his own terms, so it can't have been that obscure.

Don't assume that anything couldn't be obscured in 20+ pages on a forum.

The point, Tyr, is not about the "urge" to eat. Of course we must eat. But I guarantee that most posters on this forum can buy a nutritionally-complete vegan diet from the same stores they buy their meat from. So the analogy is not about the "urge" but about the end result - the pleasure that results.

The taste of meat is cited (and you can see this in this thread) as the primary or even the only reason for eating it. As such, if you want to support meat-production but oppose killing for necro-bestial purpouses, you must explain why the satiation of taste is sufficient to overcome the moral bjections to the satation of sexual desire when an animal death is involved.

I'm running for my train, but the rest of your objections have been covered in this thread already.

This is faulty reasoning. Just because someone cites taste as their primary reasoning does not mean that it is the primary reason overall. It would be like saying that evolution is wrong because someone who believes in evolution cites some faulty evidence.

The rest of my objections it appears, though I may have missed it, have been said over and over to be covered, but asserting doesn't make it so.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom