Wait, so I make a personal statement about myself, and you try to catch me in some supposed contradiction by using other people's statements?
I'm interested if you'd disagree with them. Taste is not a consideration in your diet?
Which is more equivocation on your part. Well, either that or you lack experience of sexual pleasure to know the difference on a personal level (though scientifically speaking that should be a limiting factor).
I'm not a necro-besaphile, but I can imagine that there are people who are. On what grounds do you belittle their pleasure?
No, eating even the most tasty of meals, regardless of whether meat is present or not, is nothing at all like sexual pleasure, not in the mechanics or the motivation.
Why? They are both activities orientated towards the fulfilment of pleasure. One might even argue that sexual pleasure is MORE powerful than even the juciest lamb chop.
You're the one who claims not to see diet as a moral issue - so explain to me why a system of aninmal cultivation geared towards the production of tasty meat is OK and hypothetically-identical one geared towards the production of bestial sex-aids is not? Why is the use of animals to fulfil a sexual desire a moral issue, and the use of them to fulfil a gastronomic one isn't?
I don't understand your point.
How is this legitimate as a question?
Because I'm interested i9n why you exclude diet and diet alone from your consideration of animals. If you're bothered about necro-bestiality - and, it seems you are - I'd like to know why. Clearly.
You keep saying that, but have yet to back it up. At this point I'm tired of trying to provide you an explanation that I think is actually addressing the argument you're claiming to make (but not explicitly making) with your attempts to highlight (what you call) inconsistencies.
Gren, I've backed it up over and over again. All you've done in return is stonewall. "It's not a moral issue" you cry, over and over again, all the while failing to explain why this might be the case, given your other views.
At least one poster has understood and acknowledged that I have made a logical and sound case. As such, your pretence that I haven't done so rings all the more hollow.
Which animals? The answer depends on which animals you're asking about. Do you really not see the ways you're slithering around actually making an argument?
Evasiveness and inability to answer noted, Gren. You know very well that we're talking, in this context, about animals in food production. In fact, if you're following the argument, it's quite clear that I was referring you your repeated claims that conditions for livestock should be improved. If you think that animals should be treated better, then you see animals themselves as worthy of moral consideration. We've been over this.
Sorry, but I don't believe you would like that. I believe you would like me to continue supplying defensive arguments so that you can continue to try to pick them apart and consider that your full argument. So no, you make your case, then I'll make my case, and we can go from there. Let's be intellectually honest with each other for once in this thread.
So rather than making a positve case, you'll pretend I was lying?
This is where Cain starts getting snarky, and where I start getting disappointed. You'll note that you've not made any attempt either to answer the questions or justify your psotions, but instead baldly calim that the questions are pointless, or that 'm "dishonest" when asking you to make a case.
You cannot seriously, with a straight face, still claim that I haven't made a case when other posters have acknowledged that I have, and when your entitre rebuttal is basically "But... no". I've explained, in some detail, how I believe your exclusion of diet from your broader stance on animals is inconsistent, and you have made no positive case to the contrary other than gainsaying. This post alone is clear enough evidence of that.
If you have a case to make, make it.
For the record, I see no reason or need for cosmetic testing. That's pretty much it. Other than that I'm agnostic on it.
No reason or need. I agree.
What reason or need do you have to eat meat?
I'm not making an argument supporting eating meat.
Well, hurry up and do so. Without a considered argument in its favour, its as unsupportable as a behaviour as any other.
All I've said is that I don't see the value of a moral argument that the symbiotic relationship between humans and domesticated animals is inherently wrong, in moral terms or otherwise.
And yet at the same time, you have moral qualms about all sorts of human-animal interactions (welfare, euthanasia and, it seems, bestiality). So you're being either dishonest (with yourself, perhaps) or you're being stupid.
I know you're not stupid.