Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

It is not up to us to make a case for eating meat but YOURS to make one for NOT doing so, because it is YOUR claim.

Seconded.

But the way to do that seems to be to convince you that logically it is not a good thing to do. Or else you are wrong.

I am wrong. On many levels. Now what?
 
It is not up to us to make a case for eating meat but YOURS to make one for NOT doing so, because it is YOUR claim.

Yes, Belz. And it is one I have made, repeatedly. At least one poster has read it, understood it, and re-stated it in his own terms, and it is disingenuous to pretend otherwise.

In case you're not following:

1) Meat eating causes demonstrable harms
2) The benefits are not sufficient to mitigate these harms.

The lack of a positive case in the face of demonstrable harms is rather key to my point. Either argue the harms - to do so, you'd need to take on the scientific muscle of the UN - or make a positive case that the benefits outweigh the negatives.

You can all wriggle all you like, but the fact that you all baulk at ever justifying your demonstrably-harmful and demonstrably-unnecessary actions speaks volumes about just how rational your positions are.

Can you, or can you not, rationally defend your dietary choices? When you go shopping for food, you can choose a harmful diet, or a less harmful one. On what grounds can you justify picking the harmful one?

They're the same only in the same way that sending troops to Afganistan to get rid of the Taliban is the same as going there yourself and raping their little children. You're equivocating two different things, and if you can't distinguish them I can't help you much more.
What?

You think that killing for food - for taste, as meat-eating is not necessary - is OK, but killing for sexual pleasure is wrong. On what grounds do you distinguish between the validity of gastronomic pleasure and the invalidity of sexual pleasure in this equation.

Now you're being deliberatly obtuse, because I explained it when I said it. I don't like vegetables. Forcing myself to eat only vegetables is an awful prospect to me. Hence the harm.

What are you? Five years old or something? In any case - are you purely carnivorous? Or do you supplement your diet with grains, cereals, beans and, yes, vegetables on occasion?

But let's probe this line of reasoning. I wonder how you'd feel about the same argument offered in favour of a similarly harmful behaviour: "I hate taking my trash with me to the nearest trashcan. I don't like having trash in my bag. Forcing me to carry trash around rather than dropping it on the ground is an awful prospect."

Is this an argument you'd accept in defence of littering?
 
Last edited:
On littering:

Perhaps we can recast this argument as one for or against littering. The litter-bug, it seems to me, would express many of the opinions expressedin favour of meat-eating.

The Tidy Advocate - I think you should take your trash home with you

The Litter-Bug - But it's convenient, and easy, and enjoyable to throw it in the street. What have you got against it?

TA - Well, it harms the environment, for starters. It also happens that dropping litter might be considered anti-social; there's a moral dimension too. Furthermore, there's no reason to drop litter - disposing of it in a trashcan is a trivial inconvenience.

LB - So? Why should I stop? You haven't told me why it's WRONG!

TA - There are demonstrable harms, and there's no good reason to do it.

LB - Why is it WRONG, though? I HATE carrying trash around - it's dirty. I'd much rather throw it in the street.

TA - But littering is harmful in a variety of ways. And your laziness isn't really doing much to make a case that it's a worthwhile activity.

LB - So? Why is it wrong?
 
In case you're not following:

1) Meat eating causes demonstrable harms
2) The benefits are not sufficient to mitigate these harms.

The lack of a positive case in the face of demonstrable harms is rather key to my point. Either argue the harms - to do so, you'd need to take on the scientific muscle of the UN - or make a positive case that the benefits outweigh the negatives.

In case you're not following:

1) No, eating meat causes harms, but the natural harms of nature, and often times less than that. The other harms you attribute to the eating of meat are incidental to the production of meat, not to the eating of it.
2) Many of the benefits are subjective, and will differ based on who you ask. It is essentially personal. In your opinion the benefits don't outweigh the harms. This is not an objective fact.

And did you just use the term, 'the scientific muscle of the UN' and assume we wouldn't see that as an appeal to authority?
 
You believe that humans are much more responsible for their actions than animals,

Yes, I do.

A dog can hump another dog without consent, and in the street. A cat can piss on my neighbours lawn. If I did either of those things, I'd be held accountable in a court of law.

Humans are more responsible for their actions than animals. Evolution gave us brains powerful enough to rationalise the consequences of our actions. The same is not true of wolves, or even the higher primates in any full sense. As rational creatures, we can and should act rationally. That's what this forum is about, right? Rationality?

Where we have an active choice to make, we should aim make the least harmful one, especially when the choice is trivially easy to make.
 
Yes, I do.

A dog can hump another dog without consent, and in the street. A cat can piss on my neighbours lawn. If I did either of those things, I'd be held accountable in a court of law.

Humans are more responsible for their actions than animals. Evolution gave us brains powerful enough to rationalise the consequences of our actions. The same is not true of wolves, or even the higher primates in any full sense. As rational creatures, we can and should act rationally. That's what this forum is about, right? Rationality?

Where we have an active choice to make, we should aim make the least harmful one, especially when the choice is trivially easy to make.

Again with faulty premises! The choice is not trivially easy in the least. There are instincts, thousands of years of tradition, socio-cultural influences, and the sheer difficulty of doing a vegan or vegetarian diet right.

Rationally, a chicken is dumb. Absolutely dumb. In exchange for protection and a longer life than it would have in the wild, I get to eat it and gain it's protein and other nutrients. Rationally, eating the eggs is also a good idea (I support stem cell research too, so don't think I'm applying a different standard to humans).

I'll be the first one to get in line when they start selling shmeat. But don't give this issue the insult of calling the choice trivially simple.
 
In case you're not following:

1) No, eating meat causes harms, but the natural harms of nature, and often times less than that. The other harms you attribute to the eating of meat are incidental to the production of meat, not to the eating of it.

How do you draw the line between production and eating in your every day life? You can mitigate the harms from production by not eating it. Yours is not a valid objection to being vegan, nor a case in favour of eating meat.

2) Many of the benefits are subjective, and will differ based on who you ask. It is essentially personal. In your opinion the benefits don't outweigh the harms. This is not an objective fact.
This is true, and something Cain has already addressed.

Do you believe in complete moral relativism? That there is no right and wrong? That's the consequence of this line of thinking.

I wonder if you'd take those subjective benefits - and here again we're talking about taste - as defence for other harmful actions? See my littering example - is the litterbug's pleasure in littering sufficent for us to shrug our shoulders and say "Hey, well. Each to their own! If you enjoy dropping trash, go ahead. After all, your benefit is subjective - thus I can't argue with it, even if it causes demonstrable harm."

And did you just use the term, 'the scientific muscle of the UN' and assume we wouldn't see that as an appeal to authority?
An appeal to authority is not falacious if the authority knows what they're talking about. Citing Stephen Hawking on black holes would not be "an appeal to authority". Similarly, citing a body which has condcuted extensive scientific research - for which no counter-evidence exists, as far as I am aware - is not "an appeal to authority".

What did Kevin say earlier about irrational people sticking around here long enough to learn how rational people talk?
 
Last edited:
Again with faulty premises! The choice is not trivially easy in the least. There are instincts, thousands of years of tradition, socio-cultural influences,

We were talking about fallacies in that last post. You just made three - the naturalistic fallacy, the argument from tradition and the argumentum ad populum. Unlike your mistaken accusation of argument to authority, these are cast iron fallacies.

"We evolved to do x" is not an argument in favour of "x". It could be used to support rape or eugenics. "My society has always done x" is not an argument in favour of "x". If could be used to support slavery, genital mutilation, whale-hunting and a whole host of things. "Everyone else does it" is not an argument in favour of "x". Your mum probably pointed that out to you when she said "If everyone else put their head in an oven, would you?".

The only arguments put forward in favour of meat-eating are of this order of rationality. That is to say - they're broadly fallacious.

and the sheer difficulty of doing a vegan or vegetarian diet right.
What on earth do you mean? Read about 2 sides of A4 and you'll have enough information to eat a healthy, nutritionally-complete vegan diet.

I'll be the first one to get in line when they start selling shmeat. But don't give this issue the insult of calling the choice trivially simple.
At the supermarket, the tofu and the chicken are on adjacent aisles. The soy milk and the real milk are next to each other on the shelf. You buy vegetables, beans and grains ANYWAY - just buy more of them to offset the calories lost from removing meat. How could the choice be any more trivial than that?
 
Last edited:
Cavemonster:
I've asked several times why you draw the line exactly there for those two distinctions, but I haven't gotten an answer yet. I can tell you exactly where I draw the line for my legal/moral imperfections, and exactly why.

You asked me several times? As far as I know you've asked me once why I draw the line for convenience/enjoyment where I do, and that I answered. I've explained (many times) where and why I draw the line for moral reasons, not that your argument had any relevance. Dropping your vegetarianism-for-taste bit -- which is inaccurate, and most certainly implies hypocrisy -- is better reconstructed as "informed animal harm reduction," which counter-intuitively suggests consuming animals in order to reduce suffering -- a convenient truth. If this is essentially what you're arguing, and it's something that crops up on almost every thread on this topic, then I accept the basic reasoning and see it as no challenge to the moral arguments put forth as it does not alter the status of animals, but merely offers a modest proposal for suffering reduction.
---------------------------------
Tyr_13 writes (to Volatile):

The other harms you attribute to the eating of meat are incidental to the production of meat, not to the eating of it.

I'm not sure exactly what you mean by "incidental," but it seems a similar argument can be made for the consumption of conflict diamonds. It's true that mining diamonds need not involve slaughtering people with machetes, but that's what happens, and when you buy diamonds you're supporting that activity (even if you preferred it did not happen). Assuming wearing diamonds causes no harm (bracket out conspicuous consumption, signaling), then you have an apt comparison, and maybe you can see why your objection misses the point.
 
At the supermarket, the tofu and the chicken are on adjacent aisles. The soy milk and the real milk are next to each other on the shelf. You buy vegetables, beans and grains ANYWAY - just buy more of them to offset the calories lost from removing meat. How could the choice be any more trivial than that?

Volatile,
If altering our diet were trivial, why is there a $40 billion diet industry instead of people making the trivial decision to consume less calories? Because our food drives, what we like to eat, what we want to eat are more than trivial. They are deeply rooted, intermeshed with our culture our history, our brain and body chemistry and much more.

Think of a food you don't like very much, liver I might guess? Suppose that tomorrow, A scientist created a new food that has all the nutrients a person needs, and is grown in a lab in a way that harms absolutely no animals, with a far, far smaller footprint than the industrial farm produce that you currently eat. Every supermarket stocks it abundantly right next to your vegetables, and it's so cheap to make that it's 10¢ a pound.

By your standards, it eliminates more animal suffering/death and environmental impact than switching from meat to veganism would. The only drawback is that you would be eating only something that tastes like liver for the rest of your life. Is the taste trivial? Would you make the switch?
 
Hey, I'll take the bait.

I eat meat because it is higher in energy (in the form of protein and fats) and building materials (complete amino acids) per volume than other foods.

I'm kind of a skinny guy with a not exceptionally efficient metabolism. I require more fuel than the average person, even just running at idle. For me to get the energy I require out of less energy rich food would require a lot more eating on my end. This is a problem because I don't generally enjoy the act of eating, and in fact often forget to do so until I start to notice the physical effects of hunger ("the shakes" and such).

Case in point--right now. Excuse me while I eat half a chicken sandwich.

I was convinced once to go vegitarian for one day a week. By the end of that day, I always felt like I was dying. I simply couldn't get enough to eat. When I found myself standing in the pantry eating tuna out of the can with my fingers, I realized that this wasn't going to work.

Eating is something I do to stay alive. I have absolutely no interest in utilizing a less effecient approximation of the diet I evolved to do so on some abstract moral grounds. When they can grow a steak in a vat, that's one thing, but having to eat twice as much tofu and mushrooms for the sake of an animal that does even know what life is, much less value it? No, thanks.

BTW, my cat would disagree with you on the morality of eliminating livestock farming. It has already been established that cats need animal matter to survive. If we don't farm livestock, then where is that meat going to come from? Or should we just get rid of the cats too?
 
By your standards, it eliminates more animal suffering/death and environmental impact than switching from meat to veganism would. The only drawback is that you would be eating only something that tastes like liver for the rest of your life. Is the taste trivial? Would you make the switch?

That's really not complicated. Of course I would.

Wouldn't you?
 
How do you draw the line between production and eating in your every day life? You can mitigate the harms from production by not eating it. Yours is not a valid objection to being vegan, nor a case in favour of eating meat.

I could make money by killing someone and taking their money. I could make money by working a full day. The 'making money' part isn't what is moral or immoral in the equation. I could eat meat by destroying the environment. I could eat meat and not destroy the environment (and any other combination). The eating meat part is irrelevant.

This is true, and something Cain has already addressed.

Not very well.

Do you believe in complete moral relativism? That there is no right and wrong? That's the consequence of this line of thinking.

This is a faulty conclusion. Just because I believe some things are neither moral, nor immoral, doesn't mean that I think every action is moral or immoral. Cutting down rainforest for cows is, in my view, immoral. Cutting down rainforests for soybeans is likewise immoral in my view. African coming of age rituals involving the removal of the clitoris is immoral in my view. African coming of age rituals are not all immoral in my view.

I wonder if you'd take those subjective benefits - and here again we're talking about taste - as defence for other harmful actions? See my littering example - is the litterbug's pleasure in littering sufficent for us to shrug our shoulders and say "Hey, well. Each to their own! If you enjoy dropping trash, go ahead. After all, your benefit is subjective - thus I can't argue with it, even if it causes demonstrable harm."

No because it isn't the litterbug's land to do it on. Your strawmaning is painful.

An appeal to authority is not falacious if the authority knows what they're talking about. Citing Stephen Hawking on black holes would not be "an appeal to authority". Similarly, citing a body which has condcuted extensive scientific research - for which no counter-evidence exists, as far as I am aware - is not "an appeal to authority".

The UN is not a scientific body. You didn't say 'reports from scientific panels funded the UN', but the UN's scientific muscle. This is an appeal to a false authority.

What did Kevin say earlier about irrational people sticking around here long enough to learn how rational people talk?

Ad hom. Sweet. I was wondering when you'd get to those.
 
That's really not complicated. Of course I would.

Wouldn't you?

Then why don't you eat purely beans and rice and (vegan) vitamin supplements?

Even organic, pesticide free beans and rice is far less expensive than a diet that contained, say tinned pineapples.

There is a diet available to you that is nutritionally complete, easy to procure and has a much lower environmental footrpint and animal loss of life than you currently use.

Compared to wheat or corn, rice uses much smaller amounts of land, and land that generally did not need to be cleared. Beans can easily be produced domestically in almost any climate. They are available at the grocery store down the street.

Yet you still engage in extravagences that result in the death of more animals, like eating imported fruit. If foregoing the taste of imported fruit is trivial, why don't you do it?
 
1) Meat eating causes demonstrable harms

That has not been shown. Aside from environmental concerns, we simply do not agree on this. Ergo, your case has not been made.

2) The benefits are not sufficient to mitigate these harms.

Personal opinion.

You can all wriggle all you like, but the fact that you all baulk at ever justifying your demonstrably-harmful and demonstrably-unnecessary actions speaks volumes about just how rational your positions are.

Don't get excited.

I'd like to point out that eating plants is harmful because it kills the plants and uses valuable land that otherwise would be available to wild animals. Therefore we should commit species suicide and stop using up the damn ecosystem to our advantage.


....or... we could instead eat what we like to eat and accept a certain level of consequences to our actions like we do when we build hydroelectric dams, coal power plants and nuclear reactors.

Can you, or can you not, rationally defend your dietary choices?

I don't need to. Remember the part in red ?

When you go shopping for food, you can choose a harmful diet, or a less harmful one. On what grounds can you justify picking the harmful one?

On the grounds that I don't see it as harmful.


You heard me.

You think that killing for food - for taste, as meat-eating is not necessary - is OK, but killing for sexual pleasure is wrong. On what grounds do you distinguish between the validity of gastronomic pleasure and the invalidity of sexual pleasure in this equation.

Bolding mine. Vegetable-eating is not necessary, and causes demonstratable harm.

What are you? Five years old or something?

If you want to trade insults I will be more than happy to go to Flame Wars with you and duke it out. Otherwise please refrain from this childish name calling.

In any case - are you purely carnivorous?

Almost.

But let's probe this line of reasoning. I wonder how you'd feel about the same argument offered in favour of a similarly harmful behaviour: "I hate taking my trash with me to the nearest trashcan. I don't like having trash in my bag. Forcing me to carry trash around rather than dropping it on the ground is an awful prospect."

... which is why I can pay somebody else to do it for me.

I'm not sure we're using the same definition of "similar".
 
Yes, I do.

A dog can hump another dog without consent, and in the street. A cat can piss on my neighbours lawn. If I did either of those things, I'd be held accountable in a court of law.

Humans are more responsible for their actions than animals. Evolution gave us brains powerful enough to rationalise the consequences of our actions. The same is not true of wolves, or even the higher primates in any full sense. As rational creatures, we can and should act rationally. That's what this forum is about, right? Rationality?

Where we have an active choice to make, we should aim make the least harmful one, especially when the choice is trivially easy to make.

Actually, you're making a mistake by assuming that more harm is necessarily worse. You have to consider the benefits, as well.

Whatever you answer, I'll say this in advance: for some reason plants are not included in your moral considerations.
 
We were talking about fallacies in that last post. You just made three - the naturalistic fallacy, the argument from tradition and the argumentum ad populum. Unlike your mistaken accusation of argument to authority, these are cast iron fallacies.

"We evolved to do x" is not an argument in favour of "x". It could be used to support rape or eugenics. "My society has always done x" is not an argument in favour of "x". If could be used to support slavery, genital mutilation, whale-hunting and a whole host of things. "Everyone else does it" is not an argument in favour of "x". Your mum probably pointed that out to you when she said "If everyone else put their head in an oven, would you?".

You really don't see the issue with treating animals like humans? No, "we evolved to do x" is not an argument in favor of "x", but as you can see from my post, it most certainly is an argument about the ease of doing so.

Arguing the popularity of an action which is neither moral or immoral seems very salient to continuing the act. It isn't a logical fallacy to say that we shouldn't stop doing something the overwhelming majority favors that harms no people. I guess you want people to stop watching WWE too?



The only arguments put forward in favour of meat-eating are of this order of rationality. That is to say - they're broadly fallacious.

No, sorry, show how, don't tell.

What on earth do you mean? Read about 2 sides of A4 and you'll have enough information to eat a healthy, nutritionally-complete vegan diet.

Which isn't to say that eating that diet is trivially easy. It isn't easy. Don't feed me ******** and act like it's organic soybean paste. How much time and effort to do something that you don't like which isn't moral or immoral?

At the supermarket, the tofu and the chicken are on adjacent aisles. The soy milk and the real milk are next to each other on the shelf. You buy vegetables, beans and grains ANYWAY - just buy more of them to offset the calories lost from removing meat. How could the choice be any more trivial than that?

And you'd need to balance the right veggies to get other nutrients besides calories. Vegans often have very low energy, almost non-existent sex drive, and brittle bones. We don't all live in cities. Tofu is not next to the chicken where I shop most of the time. It certainly isn't the same damn price. I happen to like tofu, but eat more fish and chicken. I also grow a substantial portion of what I eat. It takes a lot of work to eat right with any food source, so you still are building an argument on a faulty premise.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom