It is not up to us to make a case for eating meat but YOURS to make one for NOT doing so, because it is YOUR claim.
Yes, Belz. And it is one I have made, repeatedly. At least one poster has read it, understood it, and re-stated it in his own terms, and it is disingenuous to pretend otherwise.
In case you're not following:
1) Meat eating causes demonstrable harms
2) The benefits are not sufficient to mitigate these harms.
The lack of a positive case in the face of demonstrable harms is rather key to my point. Either argue the harms - to do so, you'd need to take on the scientific muscle of the UN -
or make a positive case that the benefits outweigh the negatives.
You can all wriggle all you like, but the fact that you all baulk at ever justifying your demonstrably-harmful and demonstrably-unnecessary actions speaks volumes about just how rational your positions are.
Can you, or can you not, rationally defend your dietary choices? When you go shopping for food, you can choose a harmful diet, or a less harmful one. On what grounds can you justify picking the harmful one?
They're the same only in the same way that sending troops to Afganistan to get rid of the Taliban is the same as going there yourself and raping their little children. You're equivocating two different things, and if you can't distinguish them I can't help you much more.
What?
You think that killing for food - for taste, as meat-eating is not necessary - is OK, but killing for sexual pleasure is wrong. On what grounds do you distinguish between the validity of gastronomic pleasure and the invalidity of sexual pleasure in this equation.
Now you're being deliberatly obtuse, because I explained it when I said it. I don't like vegetables. Forcing myself to eat only vegetables is an awful prospect to me. Hence the harm.
What are you? Five years old or something? In any case - are you purely carnivorous? Or do you supplement your diet with grains, cereals, beans and, yes, vegetables on occasion?
But let's probe this line of reasoning. I wonder how you'd feel about the same argument offered in favour of a similarly harmful behaviour: "I hate taking my trash with me to the nearest trashcan. I don't like having trash in my bag. Forcing me to carry trash around rather than dropping it on the ground is an awful prospect."
Is this an argument you'd accept in defence of littering?