Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

So, PETA euthanising animals who cannot be re-homed (and this is not uncommon for rescue shelters) is "genocide". Maybe it is.

Why isn't killing cows for food "genocide"? What's the difference?

As has already been pointed out, PETA isn't killing animals that cannot be rehomed. I'm not necessarily against that. What PETA is doing--the actual PETA, not the media attention whore--is in a small, stupid way, attempting to exterminate species of animals. They go and they lie to people to get them turn over animals with the promise of a new home--I mean, this is PETA, right, they are against fishing, they'll work tirelessly for my dog, right--then they take the animal into the van, kill it before they leave the driveway, and dump it into a trash bin in a plastic bag.

What's more, PETA infiltrates "no kill" shelters and attempts to change that policy. They lobby for laws to make pet ownership more difficult. The stupid antics you see are just the marketing face, the real push of PETA is the end of pet ownership.

As for the killing of cows, no, that not genocide. Genocide is the attempted destruction a bloodline. Cattle farmers don't do that. In fact, it is in their express interest to keep the bloodlines going.

The analogy is the Matrix. Would Neo still be the hero (such as he was) is he tried to destroy everyone still in the Matrix on the probably very true grounds that most of them couldn't survive outside it?
 
Put it this way, volatile: I think we can both agree that unreasonable search and seizure is wrong. However, I'm not against search and seizure. Personally, I don't support a theocracy in the United States, but as far as my thoughts about Iran are concerned I am not advocating for their theocracy to be taken down, neither overnight nor over a period of years. While I believe that the absurdity of George W. Bush's religious views skewed a lot of his decisions while he was in office, I don't have any such view that Barack Obama is working from such skewed views despite his religious views.

None of that is inconsistent, internally or externally. Saying it is so details more about what is being brought to the discussion than what is inherent to those statements. The reason for this-- which pertains to each-- is that the position on the subjects is not going to be a binary "for" or "against" approximation in a real sense, unless one can only see in those terms. In my approximation, the issue of eating meat is similar to, though not the same as, each of those statements, in that the advocating of one does not necessarily preclude the outright wrong-ness of the other. And in the context of this (and the previous) thread, no such argument has been outlined to explain why I should change that approximation.
 
OK, fine.

Why not? And where do you stand on the necro-bestiality issue?

Because testing to see if such products are harmful on animals first makes it safer to test on humans.

If you want to have sex with dead animals, that's fine with me. I think it's gross, as the site of any corpse never aroused me sexually.
 
I often use my computer for pleasure, like interacting in this forum. There are, however, some people that use their computers for please to watch child pornography. Volatile, does this mean that using computers for "kicks" is immoral? Why or why not?
 
I often use my computer for pleasure, like interacting in this forum. There are, however, some people that use their computers for please to watch child pornography. Volatile, does this mean that using computers for "kicks" is immoral? Why or why not?

Because I can make a coherent case that child pornography is immoral without invalidating or contradicting any of my other moral positions.

Can you do the same for duck-******* in a way that does not contradict a premise of your meat eating? What's so wrong about duck-******, or more precisely, farming ducks explicitly for the purpose of having sex with their dead corpses?

Explain it to me, in the framework of your broader ethics.
 
Put it this way, volatile: I think we can both agree that unreasonable search and seizure is wrong. However, I'm not against search and seizure.

Sure. The key word is "unreasonable" - the search must be justified IN THE POSITIVE. With good reasons to mitigate the negatives (and, in this case especially, the inconsistencies with a broader position that values right to privacy). In fact, this in an excellent example of precisely why a positive case does need to be made; somewhat of an own goal on your part.

Personally, I don't support a theocracy in the United States, but as far as my thoughts about Iran are concerned I am not advocating for their theocracy to be taken down, neither overnight nor over a period of years.
Sure, but that's for a bunch of very sensible reasons - if asked, I'm sure you (or I) could justify this at length, rationally and consistently.


While I believe that the absurdity of George W. Bush's religious views skewed a lot of his decisions while he was in office, I don't have any such view that Barack Obama is working from such skewed views despite his religious views.
And that's because... it is possible to make a positive case that he is not doing so.

None of that is inconsistent, internally or externally. Saying it is so details more about what is being brought to the discussion than what is inherent to those statements. The reason for this-- which pertains to each-- is that the position on the subjects is not going to be a binary "for" or "against" approximation in a real sense, unless one can only see in those terms. In my approximation, the issue of eating meat is similar to, though not the same as, each of those statements, in that the advocating of one does not necessarily preclude the outright wrong-ness of the other. And in the context of this (and the previous) thread, no such argument has been outlined to explain why I should change that approximation.
Because, even in the examples you give above, each action or belief can be justified in the affirmitve, logically and sensibly, and without contradiction. Even in shades of grey.

I've never held a dogmatic position - there are plenty of circumstances in which eating meat is perfectly justifiable. But the key word is "justifiable". I think it's possible to make a case that eating meat is OK when no other sources are available, if the animal has died of old-age or natural causes or if the meat would otherwise go to waste. But these would be positive cases.

A positive case can be made, even if that case has to take into account ambiguities. I don't see that you've done that for your diet - you've just ring-fenced it from rational consideration, and for no good reason other than to do so is uncomfortable.
 
Last edited:
I see nothing wrong with have sex with dead ducks, if someone wanted to raise ducks for the explicit purpose of doing so isn't wrong either. I wouldn't do it, since it just doesn't turn me on.

You seem to think you have a case where you can say killing animals is wrong, yet you haven't made a convincing argument. Why is killing animals, for food, inherently wrong?

Your argument that we can get the same nutrition from a vegan diet doesn't sit well with me. Do you think holding cows hostage for their milk is wrong? What about eggs? Is the crux of your argument that because of modern technology, it's suddenly wrong to kill for meat? Is hunting for food wrong? If the death of the animal is pain-less, is it still wrong to kill the animal for food?
 
This is faulty reasoning. Just because someone cites taste as their primary reasoning does not mean that it is the primary reason overall. It would be like saying that evolution is wrong because someone who believes in evolution cites some faulty evidence.

OK, fine.

So what are your other reasons? I've not yet heard one that stands up to any kind of real scrutiny. What are YOUR reasons for eating meat?

The rest of my objections it appears, though I may have missed it, have been said over and over to be covered, but asserting doesn't make it so.

Sorry, as I said, I was rushing for a bus.

The first thing to note is that even IF wolf on bunny crime is immoral, that would have no bearing on my arguments at all.

The second thing to note, of course, is that the cost of dealing with wolf-on-bunny crime would likely be more harmful than leaving them be.

The third thing is that most moral philosophies (not all) and much of human psychology, as Cain has already explained, privileges the resolution of direct harms above indirect harms. Wolf-on-bunny crime is not our fault. Meat-eating most certainly IS our fault, and situation we already have the ability to do something about.
 
Nope, not good enough. We (humans) do not operate from a tabula rasa, so if you're demanding that a proper counter argument be made against the supposed immorality of eating meat, then make the argument against eating meat in the first place.

When I go into a supermarket, I actively make choices about what to buy for dinner. Explain to me why that ISN'T a tabula rasa?

In any case, I alreadly made the argument, a dozen times - even if you reject the animals-as-moral-agents argument (which you don't), it's certainly harmful to the environment, and in stark conflict with most popularly accepted positions on how animals should be treated (positions which have, at their core, an understand that animals - particularly mammals - are agents with interests). Even if the harms are minimal (and I don't think they are), excluding a good reason to eat meat, we should abstain.

I've said that before. To you. Pretending I've NOT made the argument is extremely disingenuous, as is snipping all the points that could lead to a discussion in favour of... well, what?

You haven't said anything. You haven't argued anything. You've just gainsayed and / or pretended there isn't anything to discuss.

I'd rather not let the sex vs. taste issue go, if you don't mind. You seem to have a moral qualm with raising animals for bestial purposes. Why? Why are harms committed in the course of the fulfillment of the sexual desire to be condemend (or at the least to be viewed as problematic), whereas harms committed in the course of fulfillment of the taste desire to be accepted?

Remember - we could, hypothetically, convert the entire meat industry to an animal-sex-orientated one with a change of packaging. Methods of slaughter the same, husbandry the same - we get all be "conservational" benefits you see as the reason to eat meat. And yet - you still balk. Why?
 
Last edited:
I see nothing wrong with have sex with dead ducks, if someone wanted to raise ducks for the explicit purpose of doing so isn't wrong either. I wouldn't do it, since it just doesn't turn me on.

OK, really?

You seem to think you have a case where you can say killing animals is wrong, yet you haven't made a convincing argument. Why is killing animals, for food, inherently wrong?

It's not inherently wrong. I said that 2 posts ago.

It's wrong when one has nutritionally-complete dietary alternatives easily available. The harms - and you yourself read the UN article on the harms of meat production, even if you don't consider death a 'harm' - are easily mitigated. And yet you choose not to, and you choose not to for spurious reasons.

That's the case. In the absence of compelling reasons to eat meat - a demonstrably harmful activity - one should not.

So, what are the compelling reasons?

Your argument that we can get the same nutrition from a vegan diet doesn't sit well with me.

Then you are in clear disagreement with professional nutritionists, incluing the American Dietary Association. Where's your evidence that a vegan diet is injurious to health?

Do you think holding cows hostage for their milk is wrong?

The production of milk involves killing calves, industrially, so yes. If you small-hold a cow and milk it yourself, fine by me.

Do you small-hold your own cow?

What about eggs? Is the crux of your argument that because of modern technology, it's suddenly wrong to kill for meat? Is hunting for food wrong?

If you're going to argue with me, at least read what I've already written. If you HAVE to hunt for food, then that's fine. If you don't, then it's not.

Do you live in sub-saharan Africa? Are there no food shops in your town?

Eggs are an interesting issue, but I don't think I'd have an issue with eating small-held chicken eggs. The harms are minimal.

If the death of the animal is pain-less, is it still wrong to kill the animal for food?

If you have other forms of food available that are nutritionally equivalent, yes.

It's not a complicated argument, Ken. It's basicaly a logical progression:

1) Meat eating does demonstrable harm
2) These harms are not sufficiently outweighed by the benefits in most circumstances
3) Therefore, we should refrain from eating meat.

I don't think you have an argument with 1 - you've accepted the environmental harms are real, and in the absence of any conflicting evidence, I think it's fair to take this point as agreed.

And neither you nor anyone else has presented a positive case for the benefits of meat-eating (in fact, you have actively refused to do so).

Therefore, the conclusion holds.

You're free to argue 2 if you want, but once again, this requires a positive case for the benefits sufficient to mitigate the harms.
 
When I go into a supermarket, I actively make choices about what to buy for dinner. Explain to me why that ISN'T a tabula rasa?

Your going into the supermarket did not dictate to you the choice to switch diets. Stop being so obtuse.

In any case, I alreadly made the argument, a dozen times - it's harmful to the environment, and in stark conflict with most popularly accepted positions on how animals should be treated (positions which have, at their core, an understand that animals - particularly mammals - are agents with interests). Even if the harms are minimal (and I don't think they are), excluding a good reason to eat meat, we should abstain.

And those arguments have been countered. Numerous times. Your refusal to accept the counters does not negate their existence.

I've said that before. To you. Pretending I've NOT made the argument is extremely disingenuous, as is snipping all the points that could lead to a discussion in favour of... well, what?

I don't know, what? As far as I'm concerned, eat what you feel is right for you to eat. You're the one who is making the judgment here, so you're the one who has to justify why we should take it seriously.

You haven't said anything. You haven't argued anything. You've just gainsayed and / or pretended there isn't anything to discuss.

That's BS and you know it. I'm asking you to make a clear case and stop doing like truthers do, equivocating to ridiculous extremes and demanding all kinds of conditions be met before an answer can be considered acceptable.

I'd rather not let the sex vs. taste issue go, if you don't mind. You seem to have a moral qualm with raising animals for bestial purposes. Why? Why are harms committed in the course of the fulfillment of the sexual desire to be condemend (or at the least to be viewed as problematic), whereas harms committed in the course of fulfillment of the taste desire to be accepted?

What you've found is a topic that is just shock-worthy enough to think it jars the reader into putting some credit to your equivocation, but in the end it's just more equivocation. Bestiality isn't sex with animals, it's masturbation using something other than one's own hand. It's not that I have some sort of moral taboo against masturbating with something other than one's own hand, but constructing a hypothetical shock-scenario to the degree you are, just to try to get around the absurdity of your equivocation fallacy is, at best, indicative of the increasingly emotional attachment you have to the issue.

Remember - we could, hypothetically, convert the entire meat industry to an animal-sex-orientated one with a change of packaging. Methods of slaughter the same, husbandry the same - we get all be "conservational" benefits you see as the reason to eat meat. And yet - you still balk. Why?

Because you've delved into the realm of the absurd in the effort to elicit some kind of shock reaction. That's really just as pathetic and juvenile as the 'protests' PETA engages in.
 
Sure. The key word is "unreasonable" - the search must be justified IN THE POSITIVE.

No, because search and seizure is not in and of itself considered wrong. The measure of "unreasonable" is subjective and arbitrary, depending on the judgment of those who are challenged on it. The boundaries of search and seizure are already defined-- as are the allowable treatment of animals-- yet the application can come up for scrutiny (Bruce Schneier talked about S&S recently, hence it being in my mind), which I agree is a fair way to approach it. So, feel free to produce your scrutiny and conclusion, and we can examine it.

Sure, but that's for a bunch of very sensible reasons - if asked, I'm sure you (or I) could justify this at length, rationally and consistently.

So? Like I already said, I don't consider a vegetarian or vegan diet wrong, so there's nothing for me to justify either way.

And that's because... it is possible to make a positive case that he is not doing so.

That's not my reasoning at all. That's yours. See what I mean about what you bring to the discussion?

Because, even in the examples you give above, each action or belief can be justified in the affirmitve, logically and sensibly, and without contradiction. Even in shades of grey.

No, it's because those things I mention were basic assumptions of general stances that many people have, used specifically because they display what I meant about what you bring to the discussion when dealing with these types of issues. It's not even a black-grey-white issue, because I've already expressed a position that would be considered 'grey' and you are still treating it as if it were totally black or totally white, which still denotes a binary approach.

I've never held a dogmatic position - there are plenty of circumstances in which eating meat is perfectly justifiable. But the key word is "justifiable". I think it's possible to make a case that eating meat is OK when no other sources are available, if the animal has died of old-age or natural causes or if the meat would otherwise go to waste. But these would be positive cases.

A positive case can be made, even if that case has to take into account ambiguities. I don't see that you've done that for your diet - you've just ring-fenced it from rational consideration, and for no good reason other than to do so is uncomfortable.

My comfort has nothing to do with it, and is simply another one of the appeals to emotion I'm asking you to eschew when presenting your case. If you have a complaint about eating meat-- I certainly have a problem with the amount of meat eaten, and have explained it in pretty detailed form already-- then you should be able to express it. Expecting people to defend against an argument that hasn't yet been made is not reasonable. If you are so convinced of the right-ness of your argument, then there is no reason why you would be resisting laying it out in clear form for us.
 
ZirconBlue:


While I agree you favor using animals in a more efficient manner, it's not clear you think "necro-bestiality" should be permitted.

Like I said, I've never really thought about it. I maintain the right to revise my opinion on further thought and debate, but for now, I would say that, as long as there are no public health issues with it, I guess I don't have any problem with people having sex with dead animals, and it probably should not be legislated against.

A direct answer will put you in one of two camps: those who believe in arguing for morality based on reason and those who prefer to legislate their sentiments.

I'm not sure whether my response clarifies which camp I should be in. In general, I'm not in favor of legislating morality.

We may not enjoy the idea of gay sex

I enjoy the idea quite a lot, actually.

or incest because those behaviors are "disgusting" -- the so-called "yuck" factor

No big "yuck" factors for me. My problems with incest have more to do with power dynamics of families and whether both parties are truly consenting, than with any squeamishness over siblings having sex.

-- but these questions normally come down to "who's harmed here?"

Correct. "An ye harm none, do what ye will."

If you do not think an animal merits ANY moral consideration whatsoever, then what's the harm in allowing sadists to do as they please

I believe that animals merit some moral consideration, but that it's not equal to that of humans, and it's not even equal from animal to animal. For that matter, I don't think all humans necessarily merit the same moral consideration. Well, I'm not sure "moral consideration" is the right term, here. I'm trying to say "not all life is equal", even within a species, let alone across species.

(compare with virtual child pornography)

I have no problem with virtual child pornography. If no actual children are used to create the pornography, then it should be allowed, IMO.

If you say such sadists may eventually "escalate," harm humans, then that's an empirical claim we'd have to investigate.

I know that torturing animals is often a precursor to other undesirable behaviors, but I have not studied it enough to know if any causal link has been demonstrated. As you say, we'd have to investigate.


The differences here are fundamental because they go to whether or not you think animals are property.

Some animals are property. Animals in the wild don't belong to anyone.

If you think animals are property, then people should be able to dispose of their property as they please (provided they're not harming anyone else).

The phrase in parentheses is very important. Disposing of animals in some ways can create public health issues, or otherwise harm others.

Instead people like RandFan pussyfoot around the issue saying, "Nobody here ADVOCATES torturing animals." Well, maybe nobody here advocates burning the Bible either, but I'm guessing that most of us believe it's a right.

I certainly don't advocate torturing animals, but I have to admit that I'm not sure whether it should be illegal or not. And I'm not sure that the law should be the same for individuals' pets as it should be for animals raised for consumption. I'll have to think on that a bit.
 
It's wrong when one has nutritionally-complete dietary alternatives easily available.

So it's more about the technology than the killing?

So you are in clear disagreement with professional nutritionists, incluing the American Dietary Association. Where's your evidence that a vegan diet is injurious to health?
Yes. There are other experts that say it is not nutritionally equivalent.

The production of milk involves killing calves, industrially, so yes. If you small-hold a cow and milk it yourself, fine by me.
So it's ok to imprison a cow for it's milk, but not to kill it afterwards? Why?

If you're going to argue with me, at least read what I've already written. If you HAVE to hunt for food, then that's fine. If you don't, then it's not.
So we should only do those activities that are necessary?

Do you live in sub-saharan Africa? Are there no food shops in your town?
It's irrelevant.

1) Meat eating does demonstrable harm
2) These harms are not sufficiently outweighed by the benefits in most circumstances
3) Therefore, we should refrain from eating meat.
1. You have not shown this. At best, you've shown that raising livestock is harmful to the environment.

2. You have not shown this either, as #1 is false.

3. Conclusion based on false premise.


Also, you've made the claim that eating an animal if it dies of old age is ok. So, what if we changed the way we get meat to raising livestock for the purpose of harvesting the meat after the animals die of old age?

If a painless death is irrelevant to you, then how does sentience come into play at all?
 
Last edited:
Your going into the supermarket did not dictate to you the choice to switch diets. Stop being so obtuse.

In a way, it did. I realised that what I bought for dinner was not jusitifable, as the tofu is right there next tot eh chicken. So to speak. I had no excuses not to.

Every time I shop, I have a choice. So do you. On what basis do you pick the meat?

And those arguments have been countered. Numerous times. Your refusal to accept the counters does not negate their existence.

Really not - you said "it's not an issue" and "hmmm... conservation", even whilst holding animals as moral concerns in all other spheres, and forgetting that the conversational aims can be achieved just as well, if not better, without the killing. I also explained that in the absence of compelling reasons for eating meat, we should not do it. You've never countered that other than by gainsaying and avoidance.

And so we're going round in circles. Circles that could be broken as soon as you explained what the good reasons for making the chicken choice. WHen you're at the supermarket door, your choices ARE starting from a flat bottom, a tabula rasa,as far as I can see.

If you content otherwise, explain what exactly compells me towards the meat.

That's BS and you know it. I'm asking you to make a clear case and stop doing like truthers do, equivocating to ridiculous extremes and demanding all kinds of conditions be met before an answer can be considered acceptable.

Again with the gainsaying, rather than just answering the quesiton.

On what grounds is the comparison not apposite. How are raising for sex and raisign for taste different, and why should one be condemned and the other accepted?

All I ask is that you engage in some discussion, rather than just avoiding questions which, were you to answer them, would show your position as rather shallow.

What you've found is a topic that is just shock-worthy enough to think it jars the reader into putting some credit to your equivocation, but in the end it's just more equivocation. Bestiality isn't sex with animals, it's masturbation using something other than one's own hand. It's not that I have some sort of moral taboo against masturbating with something other than one's own hand, but constructing a hypothetical shock-scenario to the degree you are, just to try to get around the absurdity of your equivocation fallacy is, at best, indicative of the increasingly emotional attachment you have to the issue.

Even if it is "masturbation with something other thanone's hand", that doesn't negate my point.

Is raising ducks to use them as sex-toys wrong? It's a straightforward question.


Because you've delved into the realm of the absurd in the effort to elicit some kind of shock reaction. That's really just as pathetic and juvenile as the 'protests' PETA engages in.

Not to shock, Gren. To make you think about the logical consequences of your position. In fact, why is this even shocking to you? You don't even think how we treat animals is a moral issue, apparently. The process in my duck-sex-toy factory is exactly the same as the meat-factories you support (or don't see as a problem). Only the marketing is different.

If you are against dead-duck-*******, tell me why you are. You'd need to tell the duck-****** why he was wrong - he could answer will all the rebutals you've given to me, couldn't he?

So I'm asking: In your opinion, in what grounds can duck-******* be condemned, in your opinion? Why do you even think it's shocking, given your previous assertions?
 
No, because search and seizure is not in and of itself considered wrong. The measure of "unreasonable" is subjective and arbitrary, depending on the judgment of those who are challenged on it. The boundaries of search and seizure are already defined-- as are the allowable treatment of animals-- yet the application can come up for scrutiny (Bruce Schneier talked about S&S recently, hence it being in my mind), which I agree is a fair way to approach it. So, feel free to produce your scrutiny and conclusion, and we can examine it.

Look, Gren. If you're against unreasonable search and seizure, then you must be prepared to justify searches and seizures. That is, give reasons for them.

It may be subjective and arbitrary, but the case will need to be made in the positive even so - and those reasons might be disagreed with by others with firmer, more secure arguments.

If you consider meat-eating reasonable, then give us the reasons.

That's not my reasoning at all. That's yours. See what I mean about what you bring to the discussion?

You don't think Obama is being theocratic. You have positive reasons for believing so.

What are your positive reasons for meat-eating?

We're in that circle again, where I give reasons why meat-eating is problematic, and you then tell me that, whilst there are no reasons it's good, that doesn't matter.

Would you accept such an argument in defence of any other harmful activity?
 
Is raising ducks to use them as sex-toys wrong? It's a straightforward question.

Is raising cows to create leather for bondage gear wrong?
Is raising sheep to use their intestine as condoms for those allergic to latex wrong?

I don't see why.

Is raising ducks to use as sex toys wrong? No, is is kind of gross? Yes, very much so in my opinion. It's a matter of taste.
 
Calling it a terrible argument and not at all actually addressing what was said does not lead me to take your accusation very seriously. That you speak to the "interests" of animals being simpler to the more complex variations for humans as if that's somehow damning of what I said, humans are the only ones who are required to follow the laws, so you're not making much of a point here. Whether you value the different versions of human systems one way or another compared to animals is ultimately subjective to the fact that it is what it is, and there is no universality within it.

Well, let's at least try to be accurate. I called it a terrible argument, and then explained why it's a terrible argument. Observing that it's difficult to legally sort these issues out says nothing at all; first comes the moral argument -- that is, whether or not these issues are worth pursuing. I went on to point out (unnecessarily) that your argument fails on it's own terms as it's probably easier for a legal system to deal with animal rights.

Nope, it's only backwards because you wish to work backwards from the conclusion. You are trying to drive the conversation from the preconceived notion that it's a moral issue to begin with.

This seems like another uniquely bad argument, and I think Volatile's observations indicate you believe otherwise (or ought to for the sake of consistency):

Welfare, conservationism, euthanasia and extinction are all moral issues. You have no grounds to exclude meat-eating, and meat-eating alone, from moral consideration.

Your response went something like, "that's what YOU say" and then demanded he demonstrate meat-eating is a moral issue, even though it obviously involves competing interests, even though philosophers who (attempt to) justify meat-consumption agree it's a moral issue. It's possible for a person to insist he does not view an issue as a moral matter, but sincerity is not enough. An artist may murder people in order to create a crime scene of "transcendent beauty," but there's still an undeniable moral dimension. Reasons for eating meat tend to be more hum drum, given little or no thought, but your behavior still impacts creatures with interests who, it just so happens, are given consideration in other contexts.

You need to define the values you're using first, then present the moral argument, and follow through with why your moral argument is applicable to something most currently consider morally neutral in the general sense....

I should think the examples, "hypothetical games" or whatever you want to call them, unmistakably refer to accepted moral principles that have been repeated countless times. I do not think there has been a failure to understand the arguments; on the contrary, I think people see the implications all too clearly, which is why participation in this thread so often feels like yanking teeth.

This is not intended as a "formal" argument as it summarizes/highlights the basic tactic seen throughout this thread.

-It's wrong to cause harm to a morally significant being for a relatively trivial reason (think about -- oh, say -- stealing money to pay for an IPOD).

-Animals are morally significant beings, meaning their interests are worthy of our consideration. (We've attempted to get explicit consent on this many times, though the example involving a sadist works well. If you think it's OK for a sadist to dispose of an animal however he pleases, then you probably do not believe animals are morally significant beings, which would then move discussion to sub-arguments such as what constitutes a morally significant being, how do animals differ from humans who have moral standing, and so on. Why is torturing animals wrong? I suspect most people think it's wrong because it involves causing great harm for a trivial end; or consideration of interests -- the animal's versus the torturer's -- favors the animal.

-Typical meat consumption involves harming animals for a trivial reason (taste). Here you get into other sub-arguments: "eating is not trivial; we must eat in order to live." That's mistaken for reasons identified earlier, more than once (i.e., you are not required to eat MEAT in order to live). Others want to argue death is not harm (even if this was true, animals raised in factory farms suffer quite a bit). There are exceptional cases where the consumption of meat does not violate the harm principle as we understand it: passive death/killing (e.g., eating an animal that has died from natural causes, or a freak accident (roadkill)). Active killing for food purposes can also be justified: "if I do not eat this animal, then I will die." In such a case any pleasant taste is an unintended byproduct of a far more compelling interest: living. In any case, it might be useful to compare typical factory farm meat to purchasing conflict-diamonds.

Put another way, an animal's interest in its one and only life, in not suffering, outweighs a human interest in the taste of meat, which has plenty of substitutes in the industrialized western world.

-------------------
ZiriconBlue:

I agree that if "necro-bestiality" has "public health issues," then it may warrant outside intervention. For the purposes of these discussions it's usually best to assume the behavior is self-contained. Your point on a cases of incest that are not consensual is another exception for a similar reason: it involves coercion. It should go without saying that some types of harm do not raise moral concern, perhaps when two (or more) people engage in consensual rough sex.

I believe that animals merit some moral consideration, but that it's not equal to that of humans, and it's not even equal from animal to animal.... I'm trying to say "not all life is equal", even within a species, let alone across species.

I think you're expressing a commonly accepted view, but later on you write:

I certainly don't advocate torturing animals, but I have to admit that I'm not sure whether it should be illegal or not.

Well, this goes back to a consideration of interests, the interest in the animal not suffering versus the pleasure a human derives from the act.
 
-Typical meat consumption involves harming animals for a trivial reason (taste).

Much vegetable consumption involves the harming of animals for a trivial reason (taste)

As I discussed with Volatile, anything grown on a large modern farm has blood on it's hands from land clearing, pest control, pesticides released into the environment, transportation and so on. These could be avoided by growing your own food or buying from small farms with more sustainable practices.

Why is eating a pineapple or tomato (that animals died and suffered so you could have) a regrettable small foible while eating meat is a wrong that must be addressed.

Is it the number of animals killed? Because as I stated above, a pound of steak only adds .2% of a life to the tally, probably not as much as the extra pesticides used to keep those tomatoes blemish free.

Is it that switching to a purely vegan diet is "easy" while buying your food locally or growing it is "too hard"?

Why do you draw the line at the way in which it's acceptable for animals to be killed for your convenience/enjoyment at exactly the place you do? Could it be that the visceral artifact of the chunk of meat makes the emotional issue more clear?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom