Calling it a terrible argument and not at all actually addressing what was said does not lead me to take your accusation very seriously. That you speak to the "interests" of animals being simpler to the more complex variations for humans as if that's somehow damning of what I said, humans are the only ones who are required to follow the laws, so you're not making much of a point here. Whether you value the different versions of human systems one way or another compared to animals is ultimately subjective to the fact that it is what it is, and there is no universality within it.
Well, let's at least try to be accurate. I called it a terrible argument, and then explained why it's a terrible argument. Observing that it's difficult to legally sort these issues out says nothing at all; first comes the moral argument -- that is, whether or not these issues are worth pursuing. I went on to point out (unnecessarily) that your argument fails on it's own terms as it's probably easier for a legal system to deal with animal rights.
Nope, it's only backwards because you wish to work backwards from the conclusion. You are trying to drive the conversation from the preconceived notion that it's a moral issue to begin with.
This seems like another uniquely bad argument, and I think Volatile's observations indicate you believe otherwise (or ought to for the sake of consistency):
Welfare, conservationism, euthanasia and extinction are all moral issues. You have no grounds to exclude meat-eating, and meat-eating alone, from moral consideration.
Your response went something like, "that's what YOU say" and then demanded he demonstrate meat-eating is a moral issue, even though it obviously involves competing interests, even though philosophers who (attempt to) justify meat-consumption agree it's a moral issue. It's possible for a person to insist he does not view an issue as a moral matter, but sincerity is not enough. An artist may murder people in order to create a crime scene of "transcendent beauty," but there's still an undeniable moral dimension. Reasons for eating meat tend to be more hum drum, given little or no thought, but your behavior still impacts creatures with interests who, it just so happens, are given consideration in other contexts.
You need to define the values you're using first, then present the moral argument, and follow through with why your moral argument is applicable to something most currently consider morally neutral in the general sense....
I should think the examples, "hypothetical games" or whatever you want to call them, unmistakably refer to accepted moral principles that have been repeated countless times. I do not think there has been a failure to understand the arguments; on the contrary, I think people see the implications all too clearly, which is why participation in this thread so often feels like yanking teeth.
This is not intended as a "formal" argument as it summarizes/highlights the basic tactic seen throughout this thread.
-
It's wrong to cause harm to a morally significant being for a relatively trivial reason (think about -- oh, say -- stealing money to pay for an IPOD).
-
Animals are morally significant beings, meaning their interests are worthy of our consideration. (We've attempted to get explicit consent on this many times, though the example involving a sadist works well. If you think it's OK for a sadist to dispose of an animal however he pleases, then you probably do not believe animals are morally significant beings, which would then move discussion to sub-arguments such as what constitutes a morally significant being, how do animals differ from humans who have moral standing, and so on. Why is torturing animals wrong? I suspect most people think it's wrong because it involves causing great harm for a trivial end; or consideration of interests -- the animal's versus the torturer's -- favors the animal.
-
Typical meat consumption involves harming animals for a trivial reason (taste). Here you get into other sub-arguments: "eating is not trivial; we must eat in order to live." That's mistaken for reasons identified earlier, more than once (i.e., you are not required to eat MEAT in order to live). Others want to argue death is not harm (even if this was true, animals raised in factory farms suffer quite a bit). There are exceptional cases where the consumption of meat does not violate the harm principle as we understand it: passive death/killing (e.g., eating an animal that has died from natural causes, or a freak accident (roadkill)). Active killing for food purposes can also be justified: "if I do not eat this animal, then I will die." In such a case any pleasant taste is an unintended byproduct of a far more compelling interest: living. In any case, it might be useful to compare typical factory farm meat to purchasing conflict-diamonds.
Put another way, an animal's interest in its one and only life, in not suffering, outweighs a human interest in the taste of meat, which has plenty of substitutes in the industrialized western world.
-------------------
ZiriconBlue:
I agree that if "necro-bestiality" has "public health issues," then it may warrant outside intervention. For the purposes of these discussions it's usually best to assume the behavior is self-contained. Your point on a cases of incest that are not consensual is another exception for a similar reason: it involves coercion. It should go without saying that some types of harm do not raise moral concern, perhaps when two (or more) people engage in
consensual rough sex.
I believe that animals merit some moral consideration, but that it's not equal to that of humans, and it's not even equal from animal to animal.... I'm trying to say "not all life is equal", even within a species, let alone across species.
I think you're expressing a commonly accepted view, but later on you write:
I certainly don't advocate torturing animals, but I have to admit that I'm not sure whether it should be illegal or not.
Well, this goes back to a consideration of interests, the interest in the animal not suffering versus the pleasure a human derives from the act.