CaveMonster:
Much vegetable consumption involves the harming of animals for a trivial reason (taste)
This isn't argument against moral vegetarianism/veganism because vegetables are not primarily consumed for reasons of taste. You might claim some vegetable are more harmful to animals than others and vegetarians who consume those vegetables disregard the interests of animals for taste. Your examples use fruit, however (and I doubt pineapples require an unusual amount of pesticide). I see where you're going with your argument, but since it relies on considerable precision and calculation, this does not bode well...
Why is eating a pineapple or tomato (that animals died and suffered so you could have) a regrettable small foible while eating meat is a wrong that must be addressed.
Is it the number of animals killed? Because as I stated above, a pound of steak only adds .2% of a life to the tally, probably not as much as the extra pesticides used to keep those tomatoes blemish free.
Well, this is an interesting framing device. You talk about how "animals died and suffered" so I could have a pineapple, yet in the case of meat you're all too willing to disaggregate harm.
Is it that switching to a purely vegan diet is "easy" while buying your food locally or growing it is "too hard"?
Why do you draw the line at the way in which it's acceptable for animals to be killed for your convenience/enjoyment at exactly the place you do? Could it be that the visceral artifact of the chunk of meat makes the emotional issue more clear?
And as I'm sure Volatile told you earlier there's more he can do, and I'll tell you now there's more I can do. Perhaps the most moving scene in Schindler's List is where Oskar Schindler engages in harsh self-criticism: he could have saved ten more people by trading in his car, two more for his pin. People with serious moral beliefs should never live up to them, but they should try their best. You seem more interested in rationalizing excuses.
---------------------
Ross Perot/GreNME:
I've already stated that saying the moral argument comes first assumes the conclusion before it's reached.
Yes, you
have stated that, but it's an unreasonable statement. Take for instance abortion. We have to determine the moral status of the fetus (at different stages because each is contentious) before according legal rights to the parties involved. This is utterly elementary.
My comments quoted in bold:
-It's wrong to cause harm to a morally significant being for a relatively trivial reason
This is a subjective statement, through and through. Different factors and different opinions on what constitutes harm, what constitutes morally significant, and what constitutes trivial reasons.
Really, you want to challenge this one now? Let's focus on the principle first, which is not really a subjective statement the way you seem to intend. I suggest you try to avoid using the words "subjective," "objective," "absolute" "intrinsic," and "inherent," because you have a habit of flubbing them up. If you want to claim that what people will REGARD as trivial varies from person to person, fine. If you want to say we disagree over what constitutes harm, fine. I allow for that later on. But if you want to say everything is hopelessly subjective -- that killing a person because "I felt like it" versus killing him because he was going to blow up innocents -- then you're outside the realm of morality and rationality.
This is also precisely why it's good to use examples to justify certain types of behavior because it teases out these principles without using confusing language.
-Animals are morally significant beings, meaning their interests are worthy of our consideration.
This is an assertion without substance and is again based on subjective assignment. On top of the subjectivity of morally significant, both the interests of the animals (which I assume at this point you're referring to domestic livestock) and worthiness of consideration are subjective and are not a 'total yes' or 'total no' binary scenario.
Once again you're overplaying your hand. If instead of "animals" we said "humans" these objections would be equally irrelevant: as an idea, the bolded text does not tell us whether or not we should hold doors open for old ladies at the post office; it does not tell us if we should volunteer at the homeless shelter. It's not nearly that ambitious either. It only attempts to establish shared values: animals are worthy of our considerations. To use a most extreme example, we should not torture them for pleasure. Yes, it's entirely possible for a person to privilege the tortuer's pleasure against the relatively "trivial" pain and suffering inflicted upon the animal. And again, that's part of the reason why examples are used: to calibrate levels of concern.
However, the value of human taste for meat compared to the individual lives of each animal, regardless of whether this is to be constituted as suffering-- none of which has been conclusively argued-- has not been established as a completely moral issue. In bringing up the alternatives, it definitely can be made into a strong practicality issue, but the constant assertion of a moral issue is still not established.
This is difficult to take seriously. Whenever interests collide you are probably going to encounter an issue with at least some moral dimension. Do you think the "Humane" in "Humane Slaughter Act" is just careless word choice?
-----------------------------
ZiriconBlue:
I agree with all of this, although we likely disagree on some specific instances of what constitutes "suffering", and I probably put more weight on the human pleasure side of the scale.
As I mentioned earlier in this post, this is where thought experiments become useful because it allows us to gauge interests, and then argue over appropriate levels of concern. A person could believe that humans merit moral consideration, so opposes violence yet steals things from people. He might argue, "I'm not hurting anyone" (which would "cross the line"); he simply values the pleasure he'll get from spending your money more than whatever harm he has done to you. This is where regulating competing interests comes into play, and we must do so in a manner that is as impartial as possible (in spite of how the public may react:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DF9gSyku-fc )