Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

Irony aside, what you're asking is better applied to your arguments, not mine. You see, you're the one arguing that one diet is morally superior than others. I've already pointed out that, yes, there are merits and strengths to a number of reasons to switch to a vegetarian or vegan diet. You're the one getting stuck on the issue that because there are valid criticisms for how meat is currently produced that consumption of meat is immoral.

But go ahead, Kevin: assume it's everyone else who has the problem here.

Here's a case in point. I haven't argued that at all, at any time in this thread. All I've been doing, throughout this thread, is criticising specific pro-meat-eating arguments for being incoherent or stupid.

I've been very careful about that in fact. You may recall RandFan getting quite frustrated that he couldn't get me off the topic of RandFan's logical errors by baiting me into talking about my personal beliefs on the matter.

You assume I must have been arguing that "one diet is morally superior than others" because you're not too good at keeping track of who said what.

So once again, are you absolutely sure you're the one who is in a position to judge competence?
 
OK, fine.

So what are your other reasons? I've not yet heard one that stands up to any kind of real scrutiny. What are YOUR reasons for eating meat?

For the same reason the wolf does. It is nutritious, easy source of energy. It is a source that we have evolved to rely on. I eat it because the cow doesn't care if it is eaten by a wolf or a human, except that the cow doesn't exist in nature as the Urak went away and the human is a lot more likely to kill it faster.


Sorry, as I said, I was rushing for a bus.

The first thing to note is that even IF wolf on bunny crime is immoral, that would have no bearing on my arguments at all.

Why? If they have rights, they have responsibilities.

The second thing to note, of course, is that the cost of dealing with wolf-on-bunny crime would likely be more harmful than leaving them be.

If it is a cost-benefit breakdown, what are the costs of switching to vegetarian or vegan diets for 10% of the population? 20%? 50%? How much more farmland? How many more wild animals die for that farmland? The land for raising animals isn't always the same as the land for planting. One cannot just turn cattle ranches into soybean farms.


The third thing is that most moral philosophies (not all) and much of human psychology, as Cain has already explained, privileges the resolution of direct harms above indirect harms. Wolf-on-bunny crime is not our fault. Meat-eating most certainly IS our fault, and situation we already have the ability to do something about.


The wolf gets off because it is a wolf. The human has the exact same reasons for eating meat. You believe that humans are much more responsible for their actions than animals, and that means we shouldn't eat them. Some of the rest of us feel that humans are much more aware of our actions and being, and therefore it isn't as bad to eat animals, especially ones we raise and provide for.
 
If it is a cost-benefit breakdown, what are the costs of switching to vegetarian or vegan diets for 10% of the population? 20%? 50%? How much more farmland? How many more wild animals die for that farmland? The land for raising animals isn't always the same as the land for planting. One cannot just turn cattle ranches into soybean farms.

I'm sure there would be costs associated with switching to vegan diets, but extra land use wouldn't be one of them. To get a pound of meat, you need to grow many pounds of vegetable matter, corn, grass whatever, so if you include not just holding the cows, but the land required to feed them, you actually do much better just growing vegetables on the land and eating them in terms of calories/acre.

Actually, this study on diets and land use suggests that the best balance is a low meat diet rather than a no meat diet, since cattle and some of their feed can be raised on low quality land unsuitable for other agriculture.
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/10/071008130203.htm

In terms of use of fuels a vegan seems much better
A 2006 study at the University of Chicago concluded that a person switching from a typical American diet to a vegan diet with the same number of calories would prevent the emission of 1485 kg of carbon dioxide. The difference exceeds that of an individual switching from a Toyota Camry to the hybrid Toyota Prius, and collectively amounts to over 6% of the total U.S. greenhouse gas emissions.[17]

I'm sure there are negatives to eliminating meat from the diet, people who like meat are likely to replace it with highly processed soy products which are a bit dubious for health and the environment. You need to be more thoughtful to make sure you are getting all your vitamins, and many people don't think much about their food, so increased malnutrition is a possibility, although I'm sure in a more vegan society, products and knowledge that addressed this would become more ubiquitous.

Overall, the societal, environmental and health effects seem like strong positives. The environmental argument is easier to make than the moral one, but for both environmental, and health reasons, less meat may make more sense than no meat and animal products.
 
Here's a case in point. I haven't argued that at all, at any time in this thread. All I've been doing, throughout this thread, is criticising specific pro-meat-eating arguments for being incoherent or stupid.

No, you're correct here. I used the wrong description of what you've been doing. Good on you for accepting the criticism that RandFan and I have been making about your posts, though: assertions and remarks are certainly better descriptors of what you've been doing, since you have continually failed to put forth an argument.

I've been very careful about that in fact. You may recall RandFan getting quite frustrated that he couldn't get me off the topic of RandFan's logical errors by baiting me into talking about my personal beliefs on the matter.

You assume I must have been arguing that "one diet is morally superior than others" because you're not too good at keeping track of who said what.

So once again, are you absolutely sure you're the one who is in a position to judge competence?

I think your behavior has been pretty self-explanatory, so it doesn't require my judgment. As for my own competence, considering you haven't even presented an argument and have instead been sniping from the start, your display of bad faith isn't a very good starting point to begin assessing the competence of others. However, in my own self-assessment, I haven't been judging myself as any better or worse in terms of competence, and have instead been critical when things I've been saying have either been ignored or taken out of context. For example, a breif run-down from my own perspective on how things have been shaking for the however-many pages:

I point out my reasoning for agreeing partially on how I feel the industry for producing meat operates. However, in this assessment I don't make it about morality or the suffering of animals, and don't present a moral judgment on eating meat. This reasoning goes largely ignored (by you, by volatile, and so on).

Volatile, on the other hand, criticizes myself and others for eating meat on moral grounds. Volatile brings up suffering of animals and environmental aspects in his arguments.

I have, on repeated occasions, expressed an alternative to not eating meat to address the environmental concerns (my partial agreement). I've also pointed out that there are different lines drawn based on different priorities and values that determine whether eating meat is the moral issue or the current state of mass production is the (in my own case, practical) issue.

Volatile criticizes my statements as not being consistent on moral grounds based on his own assertions of it being a moral issue.

I respond that it isn't a moral issue to most people, including myself, and that an argument is necessary to judge the validity.

Volatile again brings up the suffering of animals part, and repeats the earlier assertions. Also begins inserting nonsense about sex with animals-- which isn't actually sex but is masturbation with a foreign object (either living or dead depending on the post).

I state that the animal masturbation scenario is ridiculous and equivocation, and state again that suffering of animals is a relative, subjective line to draw, and that without a proper argument isn't quantified.

Volatile again reiterates that suffering of animals is wrong, thus eating meat is wrong, and refers back again to the animal masturbation scenario-- the only possible outcomes of which being admittance that the behavior is okay, thus being brought up as a "Gotcha!" due to my animal welfare stance; or a statement that it is not okay, thus being brought up as a "Gotcha!" due to the supposed (but not argued) wrongness of raising animals for food. If there is a third option that is not as apparent, please feel free to share as I'm open to alternative scenarios.

In the meantime, Cain makes some fairly cogent statements that he clarifies is not proper argument, but a framework on which to go over the basics.

In my reply to Cain's statements, accepting that they aren't an argument but are the closest that have been in this thread so far, I again go back to my alternative scenario that has a different focus that animal suffering or the assumed wrong-ness of raising foodstock.

Volatile misinterprets my alternative scenario to mean that I am actually applying moral reasons to the issue of eating meat.

I state that volatile's assessment is untrue, and that while better treatment appeals to the animal welfare ideals I hold, I just as easily could apply the fact that meat under less mass-produced conditions tends to taste better, based on personal experience.

Volatile misinterprets my reply to claiming I changed my reasons (ostensibly regarding the mass-production model criticism) to being about getting tastier meat.

I object to the seemingly intentional misinterpretation of what I'm saying

You (Kevin) bounce in with your typical sniping remarks, (again ostensibly) oblivious to the context of the conversation.


The long and short of it, Kevin, is that despite my animal welfare ideals, I have not been convinced that eating meat has any inherent wrong-ness because no sufficient argument has been presented establishing as much. So far, Cain has come the closest to presenting in a reasoned manner the basis for the argument, though not the argument itself. Volatile has presented counter-arguments to relies myself and others have made regarding the boatload of assertions on this thread, but no prime argument to the wrong-ness of eating meat except to state that there are alternatives, which does not a convincing argument make (since I myself offered an alternative).

Despite your increasingly banal snipes, Kevin, you're pretty much the last person on this thread to be offering any judgment about competence on the subject-- you're even more a "Gotcha!" seeker than volatile has been the last few pages, and you're about as effective at it as Sean Hannity is at comedy.
 
I'm sure there would be costs associated with switching to vegan diets, but extra land use wouldn't be one of them. To get a pound of meat, you need to grow many pounds of vegetable matter, corn, grass whatever, so if you include not just holding the cows, but the land required to feed them, you actually do much better just growing vegetables on the land and eating them in terms of calories/acre.

Actually, this study on diets and land use suggests that the best balance is a low meat diet rather than a no meat diet, since cattle and some of their feed can be raised on low quality land unsuitable for other agriculture.
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/10/071008130203.htm

Distributing the production and letting local producers market on equal terms with the mass-marketers would provide even lower long-term costs and more efficient use of the land (not to mention lower fuel use, as you get into below).

In terms of use of fuels a vegan seems much better

There are caveats to that, primarily that the mass-production of crops would have to also undergo a shift in what they're producing, and would have to diversify (which is a huge problem in crop farming currently).

I'm sure there are negatives to eliminating meat from the diet, people who like meat are likely to replace it with highly processed soy products which are a bit dubious for health and the environment. You need to be more thoughtful to make sure you are getting all your vitamins, and many people don't think much about their food, so increased malnutrition is a possibility, although I'm sure in a more vegan society, products and knowledge that addressed this would become more ubiquitous.

Overall, the societal, environmental and health effects seem like strong positives. The environmental argument is easier to make than the moral one, but for both environmental, and health reasons, less meat may make more sense than no meat and animal products.

Precisely, which is a prevailing reason why I advocate it. There are also economic factors pertaining to exportable crops (primarily for large producers) and lowered use of damaging fuels in a distributed model, among other benefits (some of which get into softer sciences like sociology and political science).

There are risks as well: huge droughts would disrupt the flow of available food in a given region, and in areas without sufficient water viability the cost of obtaining food could increase-- provided there's not sufficient importing of food from elsewhere, which is possible (and why larger producing companies shouldn't be completely counted out).

Considering human ability to increase efficiencies, adding a wider array of determining factors to the establishment of industrial farming than simple cost-profit comparisons seems like the most sensible move that addresses current concerns about the mass-production industries as well as a number of other social and political issues that have come into the public discourse over recent years (like the environment, sustainability, etc.).
 
There are risks as well: huge droughts would disrupt the flow of available food in a given region, and in areas without sufficient water viability the cost of obtaining food could increase-- provided there's not sufficient importing of food from elsewhere, which is possible (and why larger producing companies shouldn't be completely counted out).

Drought effects meat production just as severely though, remember that a kg of meat requires 4kg of grain and 100kg of hay to produce, plus all the water used directly in watering and processing the animals.

And since we're not realistically talking about the whole world, or the whole of the US even converting to veganism, the 10, 20, 30 percent conversion rate actually get's us comfortably closer to an environmental ideal in food production.
 
No, you're correct here. I used the wrong description of what you've been doing. Good on you for accepting the criticism that RandFan and I have been making about your posts, though: assertions and remarks are certainly better descriptors of what you've been doing, since you have continually failed to put forth an argument.

I think your behavior has been pretty self-explanatory, so it doesn't require my judgment. As for my own competence, considering you haven't even presented an argument and have instead been sniping from the start, your display of bad faith isn't a very good starting point to begin assessing the competence of others.

This doesn't even make sense as a criticism. It's not "bad faith" to decline to play the game the way you want me to play it. It would only be bad faith if I promised to do so and then did not.

If your arguments hold up, they hold up. If they don't, they don't. Getting sniffy because I point out that your arguments don't hold up is simply childish.

If you want to tell yourself that you are a rational person, you should be able to justify your morally important decisions.

However, in my own self-assessment, I haven't been judging myself as any better or worse in terms of competence

This is a straightforward lie. You can't claim that calling other posters "the poster child for Dunning-Kruger syndrome" does not involve an implicit claim that you hold the necessary level of competence to accurately judge who is philosophically competent and who is not.

blah blah blah

Your "summary" conveniently leaves out the arguments that you have been presented with and which you seem to wish to avoid responding to.

Simply making the facile claim that killing animals so you can eat them "is not a moral issue" does not make it so. In fact this claim is inconsistent with any position that holds that animal cruelty is wrong on moral grounds.

On this point the vivisectionists of the 1800s who claimed that animals were mere automatons that could not feel pain were morally in advance of you. Implicit in their position was the conclusion that if animals did feel pain, it would be morally relevant. Whereas you are happy to argue from the position that hurting animals to bring about human pleasure "is not a moral issue" until someone convinces you otherwise.

Of course nobody can ever do that because you've invented a novel rhetorical escape hatch: claiming that nobody is allowed to point out contradictions in your views because to do so is to cry "gotcha", and crying "gotcha" is somehow against the rules. I don't know where you came up with it, but I am pretty sure it isn't a display of philosophical competence.

This deserves some kind of place in a museum of ridiculous arguments, along with RandFan's claim that contradicting yourself is a necessary part of moral philosophy. As Cain keeps pointing out, that sort of nonsense would be dogpiled immediately in any other thread. If someone tried to present such rubbish to support, say, Japanese whaling, they'd get laughed at. However when it's one of our pleasurable cultural institutions up for scrutiny people trundle out these inane arguments and then get terribly offended when their inanity is pointed out.

But don't worry... you are definitely a philosophical authority capable of judging accurately who is competent and who is not. After all, you can link to a Youtube video you found. If that isn't sufficient expertise, what could be?
 
I'm sure there would be costs associated with switching to vegan diets, but extra land use wouldn't be one of them. To get a pound of meat, you need to grow many pounds of vegetable matter, corn, grass whatever, so if you include not just holding the cows, but the land required to feed them, you actually do much better just growing vegetables on the land and eating them in terms of calories/acre.

Actually, this study on diets and land use suggests that the best balance is a low meat diet rather than a no meat diet, since cattle and some of their feed can be raised on low quality land unsuitable for other agriculture.
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2007/10/071008130203.htm

In terms of use of fuels a vegan seems much better


I'm sure there are negatives to eliminating meat from the diet, people who like meat are likely to replace it with highly processed soy products which are a bit dubious for health and the environment. You need to be more thoughtful to make sure you are getting all your vitamins, and many people don't think much about their food, so increased malnutrition is a possibility, although I'm sure in a more vegan society, products and knowledge that addressed this would become more ubiquitous.

Overall, the societal, environmental and health effects seem like strong positives. The environmental argument is easier to make than the moral one, but for both environmental, and health reasons, less meat may make more sense than no meat and animal products.

Wow, thanks for the link and the discussion. WOW, an actual discussion in this thread!
 
Drought effects meat production just as severely though, remember that a kg of meat requires 4kg of grain and 100kg of hay to produce, plus all the water used directly in watering and processing the animals.

And since we're not realistically talking about the whole world, or the whole of the US even converting to veganism, the 10, 20, 30 percent conversion rate actually get's us comfortably closer to an environmental ideal in food production.

Oh, I meant the risks as pertaining to a less-meat-eating market that was using techniques that use cattle as part of the process in maintaining the soil for the crop production. Sorry if I wasn't clear on that. What I'm pointing to is having a sort-of-like return to a farm with hybridized meat and crop production, where the cattle (or pigs or goats or whatever livestock) are actually grazing on the lower-grade plants for part of a season, and after harvest also take part in taking care of eating down the plant material on the field. The details are obviously more complicated considering the different farming techniques of today, but considering the amount of plant matter that isn't used in food farming (and land going unused in subsidized farming), it's not like we're lacking the available raw materials or acreage to make having livestock and crops on a rotating group of fields a viable and beneficial food-production model. It's just that there are obviously areas in the country (and the world) where variations would be necessary and supplementary methods (for crops and meat) would be required.
 
[masturbatory pontification snipped]

But don't worry... you are definitely a philosophical authority capable of judging accurately who is competent and who is not. After all, you can link to a Youtube video you found. If that isn't sufficient expertise, what could be?

Why, gee, Mr. Lowe! You're absolutely right! I have done gone and seen the errors of my ways. I'm going to have a tough time sleeping tonight, pondering the wonder and intellectual insight you've gone and supplied for me and all the other yahoos here. I don't think I can thank you enough!


Do you really manage to make it through life like this, or is this persona something you put on when you get to the internet? I don't really care what your answer is, I'm just making the observation that it's a wonder anyone suffers you if this is how you regularly come off.
 
CaveMonster:
Much vegetable consumption involves the harming of animals for a trivial reason (taste)

This isn't argument against moral vegetarianism/veganism because vegetables are not primarily consumed for reasons of taste. You might claim some vegetable are more harmful to animals than others and vegetarians who consume those vegetables disregard the interests of animals for taste. Your examples use fruit, however (and I doubt pineapples require an unusual amount of pesticide). I see where you're going with your argument, but since it relies on considerable precision and calculation, this does not bode well...

Why is eating a pineapple or tomato (that animals died and suffered so you could have) a regrettable small foible while eating meat is a wrong that must be addressed.

Is it the number of animals killed? Because as I stated above, a pound of steak only adds .2% of a life to the tally, probably not as much as the extra pesticides used to keep those tomatoes blemish free.

Well, this is an interesting framing device. You talk about how "animals died and suffered" so I could have a pineapple, yet in the case of meat you're all too willing to disaggregate harm.

Is it that switching to a purely vegan diet is "easy" while buying your food locally or growing it is "too hard"?

Why do you draw the line at the way in which it's acceptable for animals to be killed for your convenience/enjoyment at exactly the place you do? Could it be that the visceral artifact of the chunk of meat makes the emotional issue more clear?

And as I'm sure Volatile told you earlier there's more he can do, and I'll tell you now there's more I can do. Perhaps the most moving scene in Schindler's List is where Oskar Schindler engages in harsh self-criticism: he could have saved ten more people by trading in his car, two more for his pin. People with serious moral beliefs should never live up to them, but they should try their best. You seem more interested in rationalizing excuses.
---------------------
Ross Perot/GreNME:
I've already stated that saying the moral argument comes first assumes the conclusion before it's reached.

Yes, you have stated that, but it's an unreasonable statement. Take for instance abortion. We have to determine the moral status of the fetus (at different stages because each is contentious) before according legal rights to the parties involved. This is utterly elementary.

My comments quoted in bold:
-It's wrong to cause harm to a morally significant being for a relatively trivial reason

This is a subjective statement, through and through. Different factors and different opinions on what constitutes harm, what constitutes morally significant, and what constitutes trivial reasons.

Really, you want to challenge this one now? Let's focus on the principle first, which is not really a subjective statement the way you seem to intend. I suggest you try to avoid using the words "subjective," "objective," "absolute" "intrinsic," and "inherent," because you have a habit of flubbing them up. If you want to claim that what people will REGARD as trivial varies from person to person, fine. If you want to say we disagree over what constitutes harm, fine. I allow for that later on. But if you want to say everything is hopelessly subjective -- that killing a person because "I felt like it" versus killing him because he was going to blow up innocents -- then you're outside the realm of morality and rationality.

This is also precisely why it's good to use examples to justify certain types of behavior because it teases out these principles without using confusing language.

-Animals are morally significant beings, meaning their interests are worthy of our consideration.

This is an assertion without substance and is again based on subjective assignment. On top of the subjectivity of morally significant, both the interests of the animals (which I assume at this point you're referring to domestic livestock) and worthiness of consideration are subjective and are not a 'total yes' or 'total no' binary scenario.

Once again you're overplaying your hand. If instead of "animals" we said "humans" these objections would be equally irrelevant: as an idea, the bolded text does not tell us whether or not we should hold doors open for old ladies at the post office; it does not tell us if we should volunteer at the homeless shelter. It's not nearly that ambitious either. It only attempts to establish shared values: animals are worthy of our considerations. To use a most extreme example, we should not torture them for pleasure. Yes, it's entirely possible for a person to privilege the tortuer's pleasure against the relatively "trivial" pain and suffering inflicted upon the animal. And again, that's part of the reason why examples are used: to calibrate levels of concern.

However, the value of human taste for meat compared to the individual lives of each animal, regardless of whether this is to be constituted as suffering-- none of which has been conclusively argued-- has not been established as a completely moral issue. In bringing up the alternatives, it definitely can be made into a strong practicality issue, but the constant assertion of a moral issue is still not established.

This is difficult to take seriously. Whenever interests collide you are probably going to encounter an issue with at least some moral dimension. Do you think the "Humane" in "Humane Slaughter Act" is just careless word choice?

-----------------------------
ZiriconBlue:
I agree with all of this, although we likely disagree on some specific instances of what constitutes "suffering", and I probably put more weight on the human pleasure side of the scale.

As I mentioned earlier in this post, this is where thought experiments become useful because it allows us to gauge interests, and then argue over appropriate levels of concern. A person could believe that humans merit moral consideration, so opposes violence yet steals things from people. He might argue, "I'm not hurting anyone" (which would "cross the line"); he simply values the pleasure he'll get from spending your money more than whatever harm he has done to you. This is where regulating competing interests comes into play, and we must do so in a manner that is as impartial as possible (in spite of how the public may react: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DF9gSyku-fc )
 
You do not need to eat vegetables.



And also because it's the easiest way to get the proteins I need. You seem to conveniently ignore that point every time it's brought up.



Do you kill bugs in your home ? If you do, you're doing so in order to maintain a certain amount of comfort, which is a pleasure don't actually need. In other words, you are engaging in an activity which requires the death of animals solely for the pleasure it brings you. How is that not sadistic ?

Perhaps now you see why your question isn't relevant.



Apples and oranges, Volatile. If you can't see that, I can't really help you.



No, it's not. You are the one who is incapable of distinguishing between two very different things. Those behaviours aren't even remotely similar.



My point is that you're claiming that we shouldn't eat meat. That it's not really a question of choice unless you're evil. So presumably you'd like to force me to NOT eat meat or at least convince me to do so. My argument is that this would result in harm towards me.



I don't see how they are contradictory. In fact, they have nothing to do with one another, whatsoever.

Again, Volatile, I wait for your reply.
 
Again, Volatile, I wait for your reply.

Belz, you're not saying anything substatial that has not been addressed in detail already!

1) I need to eat SOMETHING. This is clear. What's your point?

2) What do you mean by "easiest", exactly? And why should "ease" be taken as a relevant criteria?

3) If the bugs are actively causing me discomfort or danger of food poisoning, I'll kill them. The benefit (my health and safety) outweighs the negatives. Can the same positive case be made for meat eating? Are the reasons for eating meat as strong as the reasons for getting rid of flies from my fridge? Make a positive case as to what these reasons are, and we can evaluate it.

4) "Those behaviours aren't even remotely similar." - Why not? On what grounds do you distinguish them? I've explained why I consider them similar - they are actions in pursuit of a satiation of pleasure. In what relevant ways do they differ?

5) What "harm" would you not eating meat cause?
 
CaveMonster:
And as I'm sure Volatile told you earlier there's more he can do, and I'll tell you now there's more I can do. Perhaps the most moving scene in Schindler's List is where Oskar Schindler engages in harsh self-criticism: he could have saved ten more people by trading in his car, two more for his pin. People with serious moral beliefs should never live up to them, but they should try their best. You seem more interested in rationalizing excuses.

No, I'm asking you a question and you're boiling down to a tu quoque.

You and Volatile are addressing my argument as though I'm saying:
"Yes I agree that participating in a system that kills animals for an end product of my pleasure is wrong, but you do it too, so how can you criticize me"

But I'm actually saying:
"The issue of whether killing animals for reasons of taste is wrong has led to a tangled mess of opinion. Let's say I just give you that one. But you draw another line, the line where a certain amount of avoidable animal death for the tastiness/convenience is acceptable, the 'I'm not perfect" line.

I will jaywalk, I will procrastinate, I will act slightly immorally or even illegally at times, I'm not perfect. I draw the line of acceptable legal/moral behavior at whether a human being is likely to suffer in any way as a result.

You and Volatile say "I'm not perfect" no one is, of course. But you're trying to sell the idea that there is an important difference between your side of the line for animal deaths (wrong but not wrong enough to change in a hurry) and the meat eating side (Must change).

I've asked several times why you draw the line exactly there for those two distinctions, but I haven't gotten an answer yet. I can tell you exactly where I draw the line for my legal/moral imperfections, and exactly why.
 
Last edited:
ZiriconBlue:


As I mentioned earlier in this post, this is where thought experiments become useful because it allows us to gauge interests, and then argue over appropriate levels of concern. A person could believe that humans merit moral consideration, so opposes violence yet steals things from people. He might argue, "I'm not hurting anyone" (which would "cross the line"); he simply values the pleasure he'll get from spending your money more than whatever harm he has done to you. This is where regulating competing interests comes into play, and we must do so in a manner that is as impartial as possible (in spite of how the public may react: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DF9gSyku-fc )

I agree. Well, I can't view the youtube link right now, so I don't know about that, but I agree with everything else in this paragraph.
 
Wouldn't it be appropriate to excise some of the emotion out of this discussion?

First, there are basically three types of fauna on the planet...carnivore, omnivore & herbivore. The first two fall under predator status in that they consume herbivores with humans being omnivores.

It appears emotional based thinking would cast these facts aside and attempt to insert a line of thinking that is outside the natural order of life.

One classic example of where this type of aberrant mindset can become accepted dogma is through media indoctrination such as the Disney movie Bambi. Case in point, the real world applications are a buck deer has absolutely no paternal interests and mate each fall for procreation functions only w/o any bonding whatsoever. They are self-preservation first and foremost only and leave does/fawns to fend for themselves.

The point is a media product such as that movie presents a distorted and fantasy version of actual reality in the outdoor world. Yet, many have bought into such a presentation and extraappropriated it into their version of reality. Get out and spend time in the outdoors to observe the facts of life and then maybe you won't be susceptible to allowing others to do your thinking for you.

The rationale that we should evelate ourselves to a higher plane of being (such as a vegan lifestyle) appears to ignore/discount the cause/effect relationship of commercial farming on the environment.

How much methane was produced when there were ~100 million bison (along with deer, elk, bears & wolves numbering in the thousands) roaming north america?
 
Belz, you're not saying anything substatial that has not been addressed in detail already!

Neither are you, yet I'm still talking to you.

1) I need to eat SOMETHING. This is clear. What's your point?

I thought that would be obvious. You can't make an argument against eating meat that isn't true of eating vegetables as well.

2) What do you mean by "easiest", exactly?

Easier to digest.

3) If the bugs are actively causing me discomfort or danger of food poisoning, I'll kill them. The benefit (my health and safety) outweighs the negatives.

What's so awesome about getting rid of bugs that takes precedence over morality ?

Can the same positive case be made for meat eating?

Yes. In fact it has.

Are the reasons for eating meat as strong as the reasons for getting rid of flies from my fridge? Make a positive case as to what these reasons are, and we can evaluate it.

That's the part that you not only have not understood but completely ignored so far. I'll write it bigger so you'll spot it, this time:

It is not up to us to make a case for eating meat but YOURS to make one for NOT doing so, because it is YOUR claim.

4) "Those behaviours aren't even remotely similar." - Why not? On what grounds do you distinguish them? I've explained why I consider them similar - they are actions in pursuit of a satiation of pleasure. In what relevant ways do they differ?

They're the same only in the same way that sending troops to Afganistan to get rid of the Taliban is the same as going there yourself and raping their little children. You're equivocating two different things, and if you can't distinguish them I can't help you much more.

5) What "harm" would you not eating meat cause?

Now you're being deliberatly obtuse, because I explained it when I said it. I don't like vegetables. Forcing myself to eat only vegetables is an awful prospect to me. Hence the harm.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom