So, PETA euthanising animals who cannot be re-homed (and this is not uncommon for rescue shelters) is "genocide". Maybe it is.
That is as false a statement as can be. PETA claims the "cannot be re-homed" after-the-fact of killing them, with the argument that they are putting these animals out of their misery. That's what they do. They don't go to shelters asking for the worst of the worst, and this is demonstrable in the case of the two PETA workers who were caught improperly disposing of carcasses. PETA picks up dogs of all ages, including puppies and young dogs, because they'll take whatever they can talk the shelters into giving them. I could also provide the anecdotal confirmation that they outright lie to shelters, saying that they can find a home for this one or can get the shots for that one, but whether that is taken seriously or truthfully is going to depend on opinions of myself and my views in the first place.
Why isn't killing cows for food "genocide"? What's the difference?
Here you go equivocating again. PETA's leadership and many of their members who are active enough to do more than hold signs or protest naked are of the opinion that no one should keep dogs or cats (or anything) as pets. They go so far as to follow the "one generation and out" methodology for pets. I wouldn't say that their "goal" is the eradication of species, but the goal as stated by Newkirk, who founded PETA, will lead inexorably to the eradication of dogs as a species, among others. While Newkirk wasn't the first person to use the "one generation then out" line-- that would be Wayne Pacelle, the current HSUS president, who first said that-- Newkirk definitely follows the liberation ethos of eliminating any human interaction with domesticated species and blocking any (perceived) interference with undomesticated species. Her own words: "For one thing, we would no longer allow breeding. People could not create different breeds. There would be no pet shops. If people had companion animals in their homes, those animals would have to be refugees from the animal shelters and the streets. You would have a protective relationship with them just as you would with an orphaned child. But as the surplus of cats and dogs (artificially engineered by centuries of forced breeding) declined, eventually companion animals would be phased out, and we would return to a more symbiotic relationship — enjoyment at a distance." -
Ingrid Newkirk, 1989 interview
There would be no "enjoyment at a distance" for the domestic dog, cat, and even ferret breeds that exist today, among others, because they would die out without human interaction due to domestication making them uncompetitive. This goal of "one generation then out" leads inexorably toward extinction of whole species.
The problem I have with PETA in particular is not the opinion that I disagree strongly with, but the fact that PETA and similar groups spend more money on their legal and lobbying departments for pushing through loads and loads of crap legislation that progressively tries to effectively drive out and criminalize pet ownership. It starts with mandatory spay-neuter, then moves on to breed-specific "dangerous dog" laws, adds on bans for "exotic" pets (which they can often define as anything not being a dog or cat), and then the ordinances that are pushed are ones detailing how animals can be kept or more restrictions on implied aggression-- in some areas, with the implication that animal control officers can enter your home based on a phone call or written complaint of barking-- and so on to gradually force the public to have fewer sources where they can get the pets, what pet they are allowed to keep, and the conditions in which they are allowed to keep them. These groups spend so much time, money, and energy pounding their message across in a Scientology-like manner-- in other words, they don't lead with the batcrap insane "final solution"-like goals, but instead the lighter "be nicer to animals" fare-- that they pretty much dominate any conversation on the well-being or protection of animals by simply being the loudest, most distributed, and most attention-whorish in their activities. Attention is all well and good, but the logical, realistic ends of their activities compared to their utopian liberationist goals simply do not line up. I'm strongly of the opinion that the world would be a worse off place to find out the error of their goals
after the elimination or near-eradication of these species, as opposed to taking a good, long, critical look at their entire set of priorities and activities instead of taking their emotional appeals and distortions at face value.