Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

This is why I don't laugh at their stupid antics. They aren't funny or pathetic or whatever. They are rotten, hate-filled people who secretly advocate genocide while claiming to stand for animal rights.
 
So, PETA euthanising animals who cannot be re-homed (and this is not uncommon for rescue shelters) is "genocide". Maybe it is.

Why isn't killing cows for food "genocide"? What's the difference?
 
PETA advocates not caging animals at all. They want animal liberation. This would render cows extinct if we did this. That's genocide. Raising animals to eat them is not genocide.
 
PETA advocates not caging animals at all. They want animal liberation. This would render cows extinct if we did this. That's genocide. Raising animals to eat them is not genocide.

That's not what he was talking about - it was in reference to the euthanasia of strays.
 
PETA doesn't even really try to find homes for the strays that they collect. They have over a 95% euthanasia rate.
 
I have even photographic evidence that people do not care for even that. Like picking up litter which would help reducing the number of diseases drastically. Which they know it would.

Just because a behavior leads to social efficiency, or even promotes material self-advantage, does not mean people will rationally act upon it. Whether you realize it or not, you're not making an argument moral universalism. People the world over also continue to deny evolution as historical phenomenon.

Man, you have no idea what their right hand does. The left-hand thing, by the way, is religious dogma, not really cleanliness or rationality.

It's my understanding that they do view the left-hand as dirty, but it really does not matter if that is the case, or if they have a rational basis for their belief because the moral principle says extend courtesy if the expense is trivial. Forest, trees.

Well, to put it in an easy way, 'it don't hit home'. I do not feel that way towards animals. I grew up amongst them, cared for a good many of them, loved oodles of them. And I still have no qualms eating them.

This is not a rational argument as your "reasons" are purely based on emotions. It does not matter if we are pre-disposed to feel a certain way towards animals. More on this in a moment.
------------------------------
GreNME:
Like I said, you may not share in those different distinctions of values-- I don't share in all of them or have what I do share in possibly different degrees of agreement-- but arguing as if they don't exist even among humans alone, let alone bringing animals into the picture, is irresponsible, or negligent, or just plain inconsistent with reality. I'm not faulting you for not sharing those values, but if you're proposing that we all operate from the value system you choose, then you're way behind in presenting any kind of case for why it should be applied "across the board" (in your own words).

Thanks. With this clarification I can say a few things, but one very important thing: this is a terrible argument. It also seems to rely heavily upon a dark, stilted understanding of "across the board." Should I have said the law ought to strive for inconsistency? Most importantly, just because it's difficult to legislate and enforce competing claims does not mean animals lack moral standing. Perhaps more devastating to your (no pun intended) densely written objection is that the law is arguably simpler with regard to animals, whose interests are the same regardless of where we find them versus the competing moral claims of people rooted in a tribal or religious culture (read as "thick" identities).

With regard to eating meat, as I said to Volatile, you would have to first define why the (human application of) death to one animal should be considered equal to the (human application of) death to a different animal-- you can use ducks or pigeons or leopards or cows or dogs or baboons or lemurs or pigs-- if that is actually what you believe to be so. From that, you should then be able to present an argument detailing the inherent wrong associated with eating livestock. And from that, you should be able to explains why the value system you are applying is intrinsically more moral than what is previously applied by anyone else.

The problem with this construction is that you have it perfectly backwards. First we dispute relative merits of value systems -- are animals worthy of moral considerations -- then we can argue over circumstances (e.g., animals as livestock, which is an important and practical concern), and later we can argue over the "human application of death" on a species by species or case by case basis, but this is something any criminal justice system will "muddle" through anyway.

---------------------
ZirconBlue:
I guess I'd prefer that such people wait to use animals that are already dead, or are already being killed for some other reason, rather than killing them just to have sex with them.

I note that killing animals for sex is still just killing to derive pleasure from them, while killing animals for meat has the added benefits of providing nutrition, leather, etc, in addition to the pleasure of eating them.

While I agree you favor using animals in a more efficient manner, it's not clear you think "necro-bestiality" should be permitted. A direct answer will put you in one of two camps: those who believe in arguing for morality based on reason and those who prefer to legislate their sentiments. We may not enjoy the idea of gay sex or incest because those behaviors are "disgusting" -- the so-called "yuck" factor -- but these questions normally come down to "who's harmed here?" If you do not think an animal merits ANY moral consideration whatsoever, then what's the harm in allowing sadists to do as they please (compare with virtual child pornography)? If you say such sadists may eventually "escalate," harm humans, then that's an empirical claim we'd have to investigate.

The differences here are fundamental because they go to whether or not you think animals are property. If you think animals are property, then people should be able to dispose of their property as they please (provided they're not harming anyone else). Instead people like RandFan pussyfoot around the issue saying, "Nobody here ADVOCATES torturing animals." Well, maybe nobody here advocates burning the Bible either, but I'm guessing that most of us believe it's a right.
 
Speaking of straying, will you answer my posts on the previous page, especially the one about our current point ?

I haven't got the time at the moment, sorry. I'll try and get to it over the weekend if the thread hasn't moved on too much by then.
 
The difference is very clear to me: in "killing for fun" the fun is in the kill itself. In "enjoying the taste" the fun is derived from something that is already dead.

OK, quickly, if only because the objection to this speculative and somewhat evasive answer is so obvious...

An animal has to BE dead - that is, it has to be killed, if you only ate animals that died of old age, then I'd be fine with that - for you to enjoy the taste. And yet you think the duck-killer is psychotic, and his actions indefensible. What makes you so different from the duck-kicking kid? You're both getting kicks from the death of an animal, and the kicks REQUIRE animal death. Why is "taste" a more justificatory pleasure than the endorphin rush that kid gets from killing? What, in other words, is so awesome about taste that it supersedes your moral sense on what is, on the face of it, a very similar issue?

Further: where do you stand on necro-bestiality? Let's tighten the analogy: If the kid slits the ducks' throats painlessly, then ***** them? No "suffering" in death, and fun derived from something that is already dead. Is that morally-permissible, in your opinion?

This isn't a question of how the death is performed, but a question designed to draw out why you think taste deserves special status. I mean, we could even industrialise the analogy, and have the meat-production industry exactly as it is today, but instead of selling steaks, they're selling stuffed-cow sex toys. The question is about your privileging of the sensation of taste such that it overrides clear moral concerns in similar circumstances.
 
Last edited:
On a less abstract note, and perhaps to make comparisons that many of you will have already thought about:

It is highly probable that most of you are OK with medical testing on animals, but against (or, at the least, find problems with) cosmetic testing. Why?
 
OK, quickly, if only because the objection to this speculative and somewhat evasive answer is so obvious...

An animal has to BE dead - that is, it has to be killed, if you only ate animals that died of old age, then I'd be fine with that - for you to enjoy the taste. And yet you think the duck-killer is psychotic, and his actions indefensible. What makes you so different from the duck-kicking kid? You're both getting kicks from the death of an animal, and the kicks REQUIRE animal death. Why is "taste" a more justificatory pleasure than the endorphin rush that kid gets from killing? What, in other words, is so awesome about taste that it supersedes your moral sense on what is, on the face of it, a very similar issue?

Further: where do you stand on necro-bestiality? Let's tighten the analogy: If the kid slits the ducks' throats painlessly, then ***** them? No "suffering" in death, and fun derived from something that is already dead. Is that morally-permissible, in your opinion?

This isn't a question of how the death is performed, but a question designed to draw out why you think taste deserves special status. I mean, we could even industrialise the analogy, and have the meat-production industry exactly as it is today, but instead of selling steaks, they're selling stuffed-cow sex toys. The question is about your privileging of the sensation of taste such that it overrides clear moral concerns in similar circumstances.

I have to say after some consideration I agree on this point that there's an inconsistancy in saying killing animals for kicks is wrong but killing them for food is ok. True it less wasteful eating them, but I doubt that animal welfare laws are based on a waste not want not rational.
 
I have to say after some consideration I agree on this point that there's an inconsistancy in saying killing animals for kicks is wrong but killing them for food is ok. True it less wasteful eating them, but I doubt that animal welfare laws are based on a waste not want not rational.

Exactly.

This is what I'm trying to probe - people seem to be instinctively FOR killing for the pleasure of food (I am not, as I have said elsewhere, against killing for food when meat is a necessary part of one's diet) but AGAINST killing for [some?] other forms of pleasure, even people on this thread. Why is that the case?
 
OK, quickly, if only because the objection to this speculative and somewhat evasive answer is so obvious...

Why is it that every answer that isn't what you want to hear is labeled "evasive" ? I answered your question honestly and to the best of my abilities. Maybe that makes me an idiot in your eyes but I certainly am no liar.

An animal has to BE dead - that is, it has to be killed

But your claim is like saying that finding pictures of car crashes funny is like having a kick at causing accidents. It simply doesn't follow.

And yet you think the duck-killer is psychotic, and his actions indefensible.

I never said that. I said I'd have him checked by a shrink. Plus the act is illegal. I don't think it's immoral, per se.

What makes you so different from the duck-kicking kid?

I don't kick my food to death for fun.

You're both getting kicks from the death of an animal, and the kicks REQUIRE animal death.

No, we're not. Enjoying the taste simply isn't the same thing as getting a "kick" out of doing something sadistic.

What, in other words, is so awesome about taste that it supersedes your moral sense on what is, on the face of it, a very similar issue?

Here you go again, stating, as though it isn't a point of contention, that killing animals for food is immoral. It quite clearly isn't the case that we all agree on that, in fact several of us have explicitly stated that we don't think it's immoral.

For the record, the taste of meat isn't "so awesome" as to supersede any of my moral values. But as I said before, and this wasn't adressed, I consider that forcing people to eat things they do not like is inflicting harm at best, and torture at worst.

Further: where do you stand on necro-bestiality?

Don't particularily care, actually. The damn thing's dead. Again, however, I'd suggest a psychologist.

Let's tighten the analogy

Ugh. "Bestiality" and "tighten" in close proximity is not pretty ;)

This isn't a question of how the death is performed, but a question designed to draw out why you think taste deserves special status.

I isn't. I don't think killing animals for food is wrong. It isn't just for the taste, although you'd like to make it appear that way.
 
No, we're not. Enjoying the taste simply isn't the same thing as getting a "kick" out of doing something sadistic.

Why not? You do not need to eat meat. But you do, because it tastes good.You're engaging in an activity which requires in the death of animals solely (principally, perhaps) for the pleasure it brings you. How is that not sadistic?

I mean, the duck-shagger would have all the defences you have for your meat-eating - it's convenient, pleasurable and, in RandFan's altruism argument, he's giving them life before he kills them for the thrill. And yet you find his actions "sadisitc" or psychologically-troubled. Why?

Here you go again, stating, as though it isn't a point of contention, that killing animals for food is immoral. It quite clearly isn't the case that we all agree on that, in fact several of us have explicitly stated that we don't think it' immoral.
Which is why we're having this discussion. You claim "it's not immoral", and then express moral concern about similar behaviours.

That's the point.

For the record, the taste of meat isn't "so awesome" as to supersede any of my moral values. But as I said before, and this wasn't adressed, I consider that forcing people to eat things they do not like is inflicting harm at best, and torture at worst.
You eat vegetables, nuts and seeds in addition to your steak already, right? So who's forcing anyone to do anything?

You think dead-duck sex is indicative of psychological problems, but then state that "the taste of meat isn't "so awesome" as to supersede any of my moral values". Those two statements are contradictory. Explain to me how you reconcile them.
 
Last edited:
So, PETA euthanising animals who cannot be re-homed (and this is not uncommon for rescue shelters) is "genocide". Maybe it is.

That is as false a statement as can be. PETA claims the "cannot be re-homed" after-the-fact of killing them, with the argument that they are putting these animals out of their misery. That's what they do. They don't go to shelters asking for the worst of the worst, and this is demonstrable in the case of the two PETA workers who were caught improperly disposing of carcasses. PETA picks up dogs of all ages, including puppies and young dogs, because they'll take whatever they can talk the shelters into giving them. I could also provide the anecdotal confirmation that they outright lie to shelters, saying that they can find a home for this one or can get the shots for that one, but whether that is taken seriously or truthfully is going to depend on opinions of myself and my views in the first place.

Why isn't killing cows for food "genocide"? What's the difference?

Here you go equivocating again. PETA's leadership and many of their members who are active enough to do more than hold signs or protest naked are of the opinion that no one should keep dogs or cats (or anything) as pets. They go so far as to follow the "one generation and out" methodology for pets. I wouldn't say that their "goal" is the eradication of species, but the goal as stated by Newkirk, who founded PETA, will lead inexorably to the eradication of dogs as a species, among others. While Newkirk wasn't the first person to use the "one generation then out" line-- that would be Wayne Pacelle, the current HSUS president, who first said that-- Newkirk definitely follows the liberation ethos of eliminating any human interaction with domesticated species and blocking any (perceived) interference with undomesticated species. Her own words: "For one thing, we would no longer allow breeding. People could not create different breeds. There would be no pet shops. If people had companion animals in their homes, those animals would have to be refugees from the animal shelters and the streets. You would have a protective relationship with them just as you would with an orphaned child. But as the surplus of cats and dogs (artificially engineered by centuries of forced breeding) declined, eventually companion animals would be phased out, and we would return to a more symbiotic relationship — enjoyment at a distance." - Ingrid Newkirk, 1989 interview

There would be no "enjoyment at a distance" for the domestic dog, cat, and even ferret breeds that exist today, among others, because they would die out without human interaction due to domestication making them uncompetitive. This goal of "one generation then out" leads inexorably toward extinction of whole species.

The problem I have with PETA in particular is not the opinion that I disagree strongly with, but the fact that PETA and similar groups spend more money on their legal and lobbying departments for pushing through loads and loads of crap legislation that progressively tries to effectively drive out and criminalize pet ownership. It starts with mandatory spay-neuter, then moves on to breed-specific "dangerous dog" laws, adds on bans for "exotic" pets (which they can often define as anything not being a dog or cat), and then the ordinances that are pushed are ones detailing how animals can be kept or more restrictions on implied aggression-- in some areas, with the implication that animal control officers can enter your home based on a phone call or written complaint of barking-- and so on to gradually force the public to have fewer sources where they can get the pets, what pet they are allowed to keep, and the conditions in which they are allowed to keep them. These groups spend so much time, money, and energy pounding their message across in a Scientology-like manner-- in other words, they don't lead with the batcrap insane "final solution"-like goals, but instead the lighter "be nicer to animals" fare-- that they pretty much dominate any conversation on the well-being or protection of animals by simply being the loudest, most distributed, and most attention-whorish in their activities. Attention is all well and good, but the logical, realistic ends of their activities compared to their utopian liberationist goals simply do not line up. I'm strongly of the opinion that the world would be a worse off place to find out the error of their goals after the elimination or near-eradication of these species, as opposed to taking a good, long, critical look at their entire set of priorities and activities instead of taking their emotional appeals and distortions at face value.
 
I have to say after some consideration I agree on this point that there's an inconsistancy in saying killing animals for kicks is wrong but killing them for food is ok. True it less wasteful eating them, but I doubt that animal welfare laws are based on a waste not want not rational.

Animal welfare laws are based on treating animals, even livestock, more humanely even if their ultimate purpose is to be used for food. Animal welfare often converges with conservationism, which aims to support biodiversity and maintain ecological habitats.

In other words, it's not extremism, which is why you probably see "inconsistancy" there.
 
Animal welfare laws are based on treating animals, even livestock, more humanely even if their ultimate purpose is to be used for food. Animal welfare often converges with conservationism, which aims to support biodiversity and maintain ecological habitats.

In other words, it's not extremism, which is why you probably see "inconsistancy" there.

Gren - they could be kept in the exact same way they are now and be killed for kicks instead of food. We could convert the entire meat-production apparatus into a bestial-sex-toy-production apparatus, and retain all the "benefits" you and RandFan and Belz have cited, except for taste. It'd just need different packaging. But I think you'd find that problematic. Wouldn't you? Many happy meat-eaters would.

If we're interested in biodiversity, then let's do something about that. Let's not engage in practices which go against the very heart of conservationist ethics by using animals as commodities. There are innumerable ways "to support biodiversity and maintain ecological habitats" other than mass-producing food animals - and in fact, an elimination of livestock farming would probably help this goal in a number of ways.

On PETA - I don't agree with them, nor was that the point of my post. What I objected to was (as usual) one poster's inconsistent application of a standard. He was outraged enough at the euthanasia programme to call it "genocide", but still eagerly supported the killing of a different species for a much more amorphous reason.
 
Last edited:
Animal welfare laws are based on treating animals, even livestock, more humanely even if their ultimate purpose is to be used for food. Animal welfare often converges with conservationism, which aims to support biodiversity and maintain ecological habitats.

In other words, it's not extremism, which is why you probably see "inconsistancy" there.

I'd just like to point out that I'm not a vegetarian so the inconsistency that I'm seeing here is in my own attitudes and behaviour. My point is that finding the killing for kicks of animals wrong but seeing killing for food as being ok seems to be rating my pleasure from eating meat as being more morally justifiable than the animal killers pleasure from just killing.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom