Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

So you CAN'T answer the questions? You claim there is such a thing as objective morality and I ask you if killing another person is objectively immoral and you ask me if I understand dialectics? Yes. And?

Dialectics is a form of reasoning the purpose of which, in part, is to draw out contradiction and inconsistency. It doesn't work when one of two people in a discussion/debate refuses to answer questions.

I've asked you if killing another person is objectively immoral.

As I've said many times, I shun the word "objective" in Internet discussions because people have a misunderstanding of what it means. They seemingly want to suggest that morality is woven into the fabric of the cosmos and we find it with a microscope. Or they think "objective" means "absolute," and ignore circumstances.

Let me try to explain what I mean: killing a person under certain circumstances is wrong regardless of popular belief.

I should also say this sort of thing has been said many times before.

Given that no one is advocating the torture of animals, yeah, really.

Language matters, and I've brought this point up to you earlier. There's a difference between advocating a position and thinking it's permissible. A person may not advocate doing drugs, but he can still think it's an OK thing to do (if you're into that sort of thing).

I want to also comment on your Dennett quote, which you have obnoxiously repeated:

How clever of wild sheep to have acquired that most versatile adaptation, the shepherd! By forming a symbiotic alliance with Homo sapiens, sheep could outsource their chief survival tasks: food finding and predator avoidance.

Why haven't the anti-animal rights people taken this to task for its anthropomorphism? If sheep can enter into an alliance (social contract?), cleverly outsourcing food finding and predator avoidance, then, according to many here, they should have moral standing. Metaphor? Whaaaaaaaaat?

----------------------
Realpaladin:

A rational person can see that these people will not listen to rational arguments and will chose something different, something that does work.

So it goes. Your post here, which seems to be mostly about futility of discussion, does nothing if not support the idea that morality is an outgrowth of rationality... you just think rationality itself is doomed.

On the tolerance lesson from moral relativism...
Do not just 'know' it. Use it.

I'm not sure if you noticed, but you're preaching a higher order moral principle. A morally universal principle used for interacting with other people/cultures may say, "if making a slight change in behavior has a non-trivial outcome, then you should do it." So, perhaps knowing the left-hand is seen as dirty, you consciously avoid using your left-hand. Earlier you said you're willing to forgo eating meat if we had lunch so as not to offend. All I'm saying is that these not-so-difficult concessions apply to animals as well.
----------------------------
GreNME:

Cain, we've already been over this. Also, I don't care if you call it absolute or universal or whatever, you're simply lawyering up your language at this point to use a whole lot of words to say nothing or provoke. Be clear about what you don't understand and I'll see if I can clarify. I'm not going to play guessing games trying to figure out what it is you're seeking.

I said you could clarify them using examples. Illustrating an idea with an example can make it easier to understand. Earlier in this post I talked about a trivial changes in behavior and used the example of left-handedness in order to demonstrate a generalizable principle. Do you see what I just did here? I used an example to show how examples are helpful.

------------------------

Belz has two follow up posts:

I don't know, that ant seems to writhe pretty much like it's feeling pain.

You should be wary of others accusing you of anthropomorphism any second now. I have heard things about insects (not ants) experiencing pain, and I have heard the confident reassurances that they do not. I also have to guard against my own bias: I would prefer it if insects did not feel pain, but they do or do not regardless of my wishing.

I do remember. In fact you don't seem to remember me acknowledging that. However several animals share this characteristic with plants. Also, I find it quite suspect to use that criterion because then if you will an animal without causing any suffering then you should be OK with eating meat. Since this doesn't seem to be the case one has to ask: what other criteria are you using ? If it's the "right to live", then plants should have it too.

Two (important) disagreements. The bold text is wrong, at least as meat is produced now. Even if I did have emphasize pain and only pain, then factory farming is still immoral. Now I do not use that criterion alone. While it's preferable to kill a human being in a manner that causes as little pain is possible, killing can still be wrong because humans have future interests they wish to act upon. The same goes for most animals.

Indeed, but it still has nothing to do with torture. Killing something is not torture. Killing is not cruelty. Otherwise killing plants is cruelty, as well, because the actual killing doesn't cause pain.

I'm simply asking for a logically consistent set of criteria as to why killing animals for sustenance is wrong.

One of the advantages of a transition to this discussion is that these are things we can go out and investigate. Factory farming and animal processing do not simply involve killing animals. They have to be raised, transported, and then killed, and cruelties are visited upon in animals in each of these phases. Do you say otherwise? Earlier this decade the Washington Post printed a story about an undercover investigation into where your dinner really comes from, and Congress passed a new law (with bi-partisan support).
---------------------
Kevin L. on the more thoughtless meat-supporters:

they're just irrational people who have hung out around the JREF forums long enough to ape the language rational people use.

I've tried saying this many times about RandFan specifically, but this is the clearest expression I know.
 
So it goes. Your post here, which seems to be mostly about futility of discussion, does nothing if not support the idea that morality is an outgrowth of rationality... you just think rationality itself is doomed.

No, I do not think the outgrowth is doing the matter at hand any good.

It does not matter one Iota if it is or is not an outgrowth of rationality.

I even would go so far as to say that it severely hampers the case, as it lends itself for meta-discussions and diversionary 'huffing and puffing'.


On the tolerance lesson from moral relativism...

I'm not sure if you noticed, but you're preaching a higher order moral principle. A morally universal principle used for interacting with other people/cultures may say, "if making a slight change in behavior has a non-trivial outcome, then you should do it."

I have even photographic evidence that people do not care for even that. Like picking up litter which would help reducing the number of diseases drastically. Which they know it would.

So, perhaps knowing the left-hand is seen as dirty, you consciously avoid using your left-hand.

Man, you have no idea what their right hand does. The left-hand thing, by the way, is religious dogma, not really cleanliness or rationality.

Earlier you said you're willing to forgo eating meat if we had lunch so as not to offend. All I'm saying is that these not-so-difficult concessions apply to animals as well.

Well, to put it in an easy way, 'it don't hit home'. I do not feel that way towards animals. I grew up amongst them, cared for a good many of them, loved oodles of them. And I still have no qualms eating them.
 
Are you opposed to someone killing animals for fun? That is, are you opposed to, for example, á kid going down to the local park and kicking ducks to death, because it gives him a thrill?

Okay.

First, I'd like to point out that "killing for fun" also includes hunting, so there's a wide range of behaviours, right there. Am I against non-commercial hunting/fishing ? Not really. If properly controlled it doesn't threaten the animal populations, and hopefully it's done in a way that doesn't cause more pain than necessary. In short one would have to show that it is wrong before I become opposed to the practice.

Second, "kicking ducks to death" most certainly results in excruciating pain for the ducks before they go and certainly falls into the animal torture category. So it's a clear "yes, I am opposed to this" thing. Also, if a kid does this I'd recommend a full psychiatric evaluation, lest he eventually move up to humans.

So even there it isn't a simple answer because "killing for fun" is pretty broad.
 
But they could prove it, and easily.

Why can't you? Why can't you even ARGUE it? You don't even have a BAD case. You don't have a case at all.

I don't mean to start a second line of argument while we're still arguing the first one, but could you confirm if you understand our contention that one has to show that eating meat is wrong, and not the other way around ?

I claim that eating meat causes demonstrable harms

If "harm" is to include death, than eating vegetables also causes harm. Again, this is something that I never got an answer to.
 
This is the point I was aiming at; this is the point Cain was aiming at. It's what he meant when he talked of "similar circumstances".

What's the difference between "fun" and "enjoying the taste of meat"?

The difference is very clear to me: in "killing for fun" the fun is in the kill itself. In "enjoying the taste" the fun is derived from something that is already dead.
 
Is "I just don't like the alternative" an argument you'd use in defense of any other action that was demonstrably harmful and which had excellent alternatives should one choose?

While we're on the subject of torture, fun and harm, I'd like to point out (yes I know I'm still all over the place when I said we should focus on one thing) that forcing people to eat things they don't like, and therefore spend the rest of their lives hating eating, can easily be considered harm at best, and torture at worst. Now, apply this to six and a half billion people.

The more I think about it, the more meat-eating seems like sadism. Can you explain to me where I'm going wrong?

Be careful not to get into this territory. If you start personalizing this argument and claiming that your opponents in this debate are monsters, then you garantee that this debate with degenerate.

We've covered this. Over and over. It's a bad argument. You are not rescuing food animals from anything. You are raising them to harm them, and causing environmental damage to boot. It's not an altruistic action, because you cannot act altruistically towards something that does not exist.

I think the point is that livestock isn't suffering much harm when compared to their wild counterparts.
 
Okay.
Am I against non-commercial hunting/fishing ? Not really. If properly controlled it doesn't threaten the animal populations, and hopefully it's done in a way that doesn't cause more pain than necessary. In short one would have to show that it is wrong before I become opposed to the practice.

Heck, if hunting is done right, it can be beneficial to both the animal group and the environment.

In many places, deer often become overpopulated. If their numbers are not thinned through hunting, they will starve and suffer through the winter months and decimate certain plants.
 
This is the point I was aiming at; this is the point Cain was aiming at. It's what he meant when he talked of "similar circumstances".

What's the difference between "fun" and "enjoying the taste of meat"?

A) I don't believe that "fun" and "enjoying the taste of meat" are the same. Eating meat is pleasurable, but is not fun. I'm not sure I can articulate the difference, but "fun" has very different connotations, to me, than, say, "pleasure" or "enjoyment". Even if I conceded that they are the same, though,
2) Killing for "fun" is enjoying the act of killing itself. Enjoying the taste of meat is taking enjoyment in the results of the act, but not enjoying the act itself.
 
2) Killing for "fun" is enjoying the act of killing itself. Enjoying the taste of meat is taking enjoyment in the results of the act, but not enjoying the act itself.

So you're cool with necro-bestiality? Killing animals to have sex with them?
 
So you're cool with necro-bestiality? Killing animals to have sex with them?

I don't know. For some strange reason, I've never had reason to consider the subject before. ;)

I guess I'd prefer that such people wait to use animals that are already dead, or are already being killed for some other reason, rather than killing them just to have sex with them.

I note that killing animals for sex is still just killing to derive pleasure from them, while killing animals for meat has the added benefits of providing nutrition, leather, etc, in addition to the pleasure of eating them.
 
GreNME:

I said you could clarify them using examples. Illustrating an idea with an example can make it easier to understand. Earlier in this post I talked about a trivial changes in behavior and used the example of left-handedness in order to demonstrate a generalizable principle. Do you see what I just did here? I used an example to show how examples are helpful.

What do you want examples of? Different cases where harm is considered justified between humans? Which nation, culture, or group do you want examples from? Which ones would be "acceptable" in your assessment? My guess is that your acceptance of this as a "what is so" is solely dependent on your own ideas about the validity of those cultural mechanisms (I know mine is). You could also look at humor, which is resplendent with examples of joy being taken at the misfortune of others, but again that's going to be subjective by its very nature (some people don't like dead baby jokes). Then you can get into areas where the first and second part begin to overlap, like criminal cases where prosecutions urge trying children as adults-- one of the reasons for this being harsher sentences, and the second being the ability to actually hold the alleged criminal more accountable for their actions since a child is considered to have less responsibility for their actions due to a more limited assignment of rights. That goes even further for those who qualify as mentally disabled-- there's a current case in TX about a group home for the disabled engaged in "fight clubs" with the patients, and it's not the patients who are being held liable for this activity. This brings us to the third part, where these more limited applications of rights to fellow humans require other humans standing in as guardians or surrogates, which is the socially accepted agreement that for these humans who are deemed unable to hold responsibility for their behavior, a third party is to retain responsibility for the choices they make to differing degrees (dependent on the case).

Like I said, you may not share in those different distinctions of values-- I don't share in all of them or have what I do share in possibly different degrees of agreement-- but arguing as if they don't exist even among humans alone, let alone bringing animals into the picture, is irresponsible, or negligent, or just plain inconsistent with reality. I'm not faulting you for not sharing those values, but if you're proposing that we all operate from the value system you choose, then you're way behind in presenting any kind of case for why it should be applied "across the board" (in your own words). With regard to eating meat, as I said to Volatile, you would have to first define why the (human application of) death to one animal should be considered equal to the (human application of) death to a different animal-- you can use ducks or pigeons or leopards or cows or dogs or baboons or lemurs or pigs-- if that is actually what you believe to be so. From that, you should then be able to present an argument detailing the inherent wrong associated with eating livestock. And from that, you should be able to explains why the value system you are applying is intrinsically more moral than what is previously applied by anyone else.

But-- and I'm just making an educated guess based on past attempts to elicit this from you-- you're not going to present any such set of arguments. Instead, (I am guessing that) you're going to come back and nitpick over the examples you asked for, use that to disregard the whole of what I'm saying, and claim you don't have to present any such argument because your nitpicking has shown how obviously I don't know a damned thing about what I'm saying. I'm perfectly fine with you showing me that my guess is wrong, Cain, but we're two threads and several dozen pages of arguments and assertions into examples where this has clearly not been the case.
 
Several pages back I mentioned that Ingrid Newkirk, the head of PETA, was going to be on the radio that day. As it turns out, her appearance was moved because the president had a press conference that was covered instead. Instead, it looks like she's going to be on today, from 1PM to 2PM central standard time (-6:00 GMT), and one can get the live stream by going to this page and clicking the "Listen Live" link in the upper right.
 
Well, I got a call through to the program, but since I had to hang up after my comment I couldn't respond to the lies and misdirections she answered with, particularly by implying myself and those who do what I explained (human networking to move dogs to places where they can find homes) were animal hoarders, I don't feel that there was an opportunity to really challenge her. However, it was interesting that most of the phone calls were either challenging or critical of PETA and Newkirk's statements.
 
I note that killing animals for sex is still just killing to derive pleasure from them, while killing animals for meat has the added benefits of providing nutrition, leather, etc, in addition to the pleasure of eating them.

How about... killing them, have sex with them, THEN eat them and use the rest for additional clothing etc.?

Twice the fun! (I think)
 
Well, I got a call through to the program, but since I had to hang up after my comment I couldn't respond to the lies and misdirections she answered with, particularly by implying myself and those who do what I explained (human networking to move dogs to places where they can find homes) were animal hoarders, I don't feel that there was an opportunity to really challenge her. However, it was interesting that most of the phone calls were either challenging or critical of PETA and Newkirk's statements.

I think "animal hoarder" to Newkirk means "one who doesn't kill pets".
 
I think "animal hoarder" to Newkirk means "one who doesn't kill pets".

Yeah, she's actually now backpedaling out of being caught on that mark. She's now changed what she calls what PETA does with animals. It's no longer a rescue or shelter in their Virginia facility, it's what she calls a "euthanasia service" for people.
 
Yeah, she's actually now backpedaling out of being caught on that mark. She's now changed what she calls what PETA does with animals. It's no longer a rescue or shelter in their Virginia facility, it's what she calls a "euthanasia service" for people.

So they got busted on their own little final solution project and have decided to come somewhat clean.

I still doubt they are listed as "euthanasia service" in the phone book or have it on the side of their van.
 
So they got busted on their own little final solution project and have decided to come somewhat clean.

I still doubt they are listed as "euthanasia service" in the phone book or have it on the side of their van.

Nope. Oh, they may say as much on their website (somewhere, probably in smaller print, away from the front page), but I can attest to knowing that they still go to municipal and other shelters asking to "help" find the animals new homes and take some off the hands of the shelters. They have about five facilities like this that I know of personally.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom