Look in the mirror.
And please, read and consider what I mean and not what you THINK I mean.
I don't think it should be a starting point for discussion. Just because I perceive something as moral or immoral doesn't mean that my perceptions alone should govern my behavior (naturalistic fallacy). Nor should I simply cherry pick a perception to form a basis for all of my other decisions.
Consistency, RandFan, consistency. That's all we ask for.
If you agree with the claim "we should have laws against animal cruelty" and I agree with the claim "we should have laws against animal cruelty" then, if you are being consistent, we can begin a conversation about what follows logically from that claim. It doesn't necessarily matter why each of us believes that claim, as long as we both believe it.
You can call that "forming a basis for all of my other decisions" if you like, but thats not quite right. It's assuming that if you do believe it, then all your other claims must be
consistent with it. We don't care what is based on what, necessarily. We just care that if you claim to believe A, you can't believe anything that necessitates not-A.
And I explained why I had reason to question those. I don't claim that those things "ought to be illegal" because of my perceptions or that I should govern my behavior simply because of my perceptions (naturalistic fallacy). Nor should an arbitrary perception be a base line simply because someone else agrees with me. That's just dumb.
You are being inconsistent.
Actually I think it's you. You claim to believe things (like "we should have laws against animal cruelty"), but when pressed it turns out you only kinda-sorta believe them.
Kinda-sorta believing in several contradictory things is incompatible with having a rationally justifiable position.
I don't agree with the premise. These things might indeed be moral. Let's start from a base line and not some cherry picked mutual agreement that relies on naturalistic fallacy. I could pick the converse and argue that since I perceive eating meat as moral that animal cruelty is moral.
Who said the claim that "we should have laws against animal cruelty" was based on the naturalistic fallacy? It looks to me like you just made that up.
Regardless, you could believe the claim "we should have laws against animal cruelty" because a leprechaun popped out of your bum and told you it was true for all I care - we could still have a logical argument about what logically follows from that claim, if you were only consistent about it.
And what if I am in a discussion with someone where we mutually agree that eating meat is moral. Should I then reason that animal cruelty is moral?
That some arbitrary and cherry picked perception is mutually agreed upon should not be the basis for my morality. If for no other reason than it's a naturalistic fallacy but it is also arbitrary.
Once again I have trouble figuring out the logical incapacity that can give rise to such a post.
If you and someone else have a discussion starting from the mutually agreed upon premise that eating meat is moral, then you could (assuming you argued rationally) mutually come up with conclusions consistent with the idea that eating meat is moral.
If you and someone else have a discussion starting from the mutually agreed upon premise that animal cruelty should be illegal, then you could (assuming you argued rationally) mutually come up with conclusions consistent with the idea that animal cruelty should be illegal.
In neither case would your conclusions be true unless your premise was true, but since you and Volatile both agreed that the premise was true, what's the problem?
Not true, I agreed that I perceive something as moral. That I perceive something as moral doesn't mean that the perception alone should govern my behavior (naturalistic fallacy) and all other decisions should stem from that cherry picked basis. I could pick the converse and find someone to mutually agree that eating meat is moral and then conclude that since I perceive eating meat as moral that animal cruelty is moral.
That's dishonest. I have been consistent. I perceive certain things as moral and certain things as immoral because of adaptive behaviors and social indoctrination. It makes no sense that I cherry pick a single moral perception as a base line for all of my morality. Hell, I could cherry pick my perception that eating meat is moral and reason that animal cruelty is moral.
How can you claim with a straight face to be "consistent"?
If you were consistent, then by definition you would not believe A while also believing anything that necessitated not-A. That's what consistency means.
Yet you argue "You cannot ask me to show how my beliefs are consistent with my claim A. That would be cherry-picking. It is cherry-picking because I also believe things which necessitate not-A. You could equally well cherry-pick one of those beliefs and ask me to be consistent with that belief, in which case I would have to claim not-A. Therefore I do not ever have to show that my beliefs are consistent, because they are inconsistent".
Inconsistency is incompatible with rationality.
I'm a moral skeptic but that doesn't mean that I don't have perceptions of what is and isn't moral and that I can't consider arguments and reason my morality. That I'm a moral skeptics doesn't obviate my ability to feel compassion and empathy or that I can't reason rules of behavior.
Sorry Kevin but you are creating straw men and YOU are being inconsistent. When I debate with you about my perceptions and indoctrinated sense of morality you protest. When Volatile wants to appeal to the self same sense you demand that I must accept this cherry picked perception simply because Volatile agrees with it. Nonsense.
Make up your mind.
If you have two perceptions, A and B, and they cannot both be true, then if you want to call yourself rational or consistent then you must abandon one.
Or at the very least you must admit "I believe mutually contradictory things and I'm confused, but I see no way out of it. I know my position is wrong, I just don't know what is right".
What you
can't say, if you are honest, rational and consistent, is "I believe both of my perceptions to be true".