Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

Why would they be extinct, Ken?

If we want to keep them alive -- if their continuation as a species is our paramount reason for eating them -- we could raise them in exactly the same way we do now, but just not kill them half-way though.

And then what? What would be the purpose? If we kept raising the cows, and then not kill them, it would be just as harmful to the environment, would it not?

I didn't make this up, you did.

"It's not an altruistic action, because you cannot act altruistically towards something that does not exist. "

What did you mean by something that does not exist?
 
That's not a strawman. In fact, it was posed, initially, as a question. If taste is the satiation of one whim, on what grounds can it be defended whilst another (similar) whim condemned? I don't see that you, or anyone, has attempted to address that very salient point. What is the difference?
The sociopathic 'whim' to torture an animal for your own gratification and the human 'whim' to seek nourishment are not "similar" no matter how many times you repeat so.

It results in less harm, is internally consistent and can make a positive case for itself. Now we really are going in circles.
Less harm? To whom? Do you really intend to feed the world with veggies and B12 supplements?

Do you live in a home? Why? Is it because of the sick sadistic pleasure you get by living in a house made from brutalized trees?

You have - again - pretended that the arguments have not been made, rather than actually address them. That doesn't speak strongly for your position, frankly.
Pot, I'd like to introduce you to Kettle.
 
One immediate one is dropping litter. "I don't like carrying trash around" is not an argument in favour of littering. Another, more extreme one, is paedophilia - "I don't like having sex with adults" is not an argument for having sex with children.
It could be. I think one needs to take the aggregate in it's entirely. But you've given a laundry list of examples (I asked for them) but not told me why they are immoral or that the arguments are insufficent. You seem to think I'm just going to accept them.

Not immoral in and of itself, no. As I said, it is not inherently wrong to eat meat. But eating it when tasty, nutritionally-equivalent sources are readily available - that's when it becomes immoral, because it is at that point that you let your personal whim over-ride your good conscience.
What is this "good conscience"? Are you saying that I should have it or that every person has it or that I should simply know better?

Who said suffering? I'm talking about death. As far as I can see, the duck-killing kid is immoral even if he breaks the ducks' necks quickly and painlessly.
Ok, but you've not told me why it is immoral. You seem to appeal to my natural inclination to find such an act immoral. How do I know that isn't simply social mores or my involved sense at work?

And, perhaps relevantly, perhaps not, his actions would be a crime in the UK either way.
I accept social strictures. Eating meat in the US isn't illegal.

Your whims are only satisfied by animal death, like his. How is that not sadistic?
I don't take pleasure in the death of the animal. If there was a famine and you killed an animal for food that would make you sadistic?

We have, RF.
No - you - HAVEN'T!

You cannot act in the interests of something that will not exist.
Asserted. This isn't axiomatic.

If altruism is your goal - of you have these animal's interests at heart - then killing them becomes even less tenable.
It's a contract. I have both of our interests at heart. I give it something and it gives me something.

You are now reduced to simply asserting things.


After all, if the gift of life is so precious - and this is your argument, remember - then taking it for a cheap whim is even more ridiculous.
It wouldn't live if I didn't have a reason to grant it life. So your argument doesn't fly.

If some life is good, then more life is better - and the sooner you kill an animal, the worse the problem, by your own standards.
But some life is better than no life and no life is what it would have had. It's a contract. I give it X amount of years in return for food.

Volitile, I know, that in your mind, you think you've been oh so clever at rebutting my argument but you haven't. Having some life is still better than having no life.

Dennets argument still holds true. From an evolutionary stand point domesticated animals have evolved survival traits that include humans.
 
Last edited:
You cannot satiate your whim without death. Neither can he.
I know that you see the two as different but I can't find a reason to equate them. If I hire someone to work for me then I can keep him in a room performing meanial tasks. That's not the same as if I took away someone's freedom for 8 hours a day purely for the pleasure of it.

Your argument doesn't fly.

I would argue (in fact, I know) that you hold moral positions towards animals - you are in favour of animal cruelty laws; you've said as much yourself.
Yes, because I percieve moral positions toward animals.

So let's take that as axiomatic, since we both agree. What I'm interested in is why you find one set of behaviours OK and another problematic, when the only difference I can see is that one satiates the taste buds and the other satiates another set of pleasure-receptors.

On what grounds does taste get elevated above the thrill of the kill? On what grounds do you, personally, find one OK and the other problematic?
Perhaps it is an evolved sense. Perhaps it is indoctrination. Perhaps it is a combination of both.

You can't have it both ways. If you want me to question my sense of morality about one issue by appealing to an innate sense for another then I have a right to be moraly skeptical about my innate sense.

If you want to argue that it is ok to kill a duck for the pleasure of it in the abstract I'm happy to consider your argument and not dismiss the argument because of my innate feelings.

Do you understand that? I cannot say that my innate feelings against animal cruelty are moral truths.
 
Last edited:
GreNME said:
When you only present two alternatives as if they are the only choices, it surely is. Same goes for your strawmen ("you enjoy killing animals for fun") and your equivocations ("what's the difference?").
That's not a strawman. In fact, it was posed, initially, as a question. If taste is the satiation of one whim, on what grounds can it be defended whilst another (similar) whim condemned? I don't see that you, or anyone, has attempted to address that very salient point. What is the difference?

Asserting that it's not a strawman does not automagically fulfill your wish. The reason is that it's not killing animals for fun, it's killing animals for food. Just because you're unwilling to acknowledge the distinction does not remove or reduce that distinction for anyone else. The fact that you continually fail to give a solid argument why I should join you in making no distinction is why this keeps coming back up.

GreNME said:
First, you haven't defined why the death of one animal should be considered equal to the death of a different animal.
People don't eat ducks? Or shall we talk about killing cows for kicks? If talking about two species for illustrative purposes is too abstract, then we can be more direct. It's interesting that you'd rather nit-pick than discuss the points on the table, though.

It's more interesting that you're dodging what I actually said and instead arguing against what you may wish I said. Can you honestly and truthfully say right now that you are not equating the death of one animal to be equal to the death of a different animal? You can choose any two animals you like, because that's beside the point. The point is that you are equating the death of any given animal to the death of any other given animal, regardless of any other circumstances or conditions, when a human being is involved in the killing. Is this not so?

GreNME said:
Second, given the first, you have insufficiently supported the (supposed) inherent wrong associated with eating livestock.
You've seen the environmental numbers.

The two things wrong with this is that first it has nothing to do with killing (or, if you want to split hairs, harming) animals, which has been part and parcel with every one of your other arguments, and as such is a non-sequitur (that I've addressed); second, I've already pointed out the issue with genetically engineered crops as just one example of how the environmental problem has to do with the entire food industry, so bringing up the farting cows is intentionally using only a part of a known issue that you find rhetorically convenient while ignoring that the problem as a whole has to do with production and the whole industry, which is not inherent solely to eating meat.

GreNME said:
Third, given the previous two, you have not presented a single argument that explains why the value system you are applying is intrinsically more moral.
It results in less harm, is internally consistent and can make a positive case for itself. Now we really are going in circles.

Considering you dodged the first and evaded on the second, this is simply an (unsupported) assertion on your part.

You have - again - pretended that the arguments have not been made, rather than actually address them. That doesn't speak strongly for your position, frankly.

I understand completely that you feel completely convinced that these arguments you're making are totally consistent and morally irrefutable. Really, I do. However, I find them unconvincing and inconsistently applied. The primary reason obviously lies in the value you place on the morality of raising and consuming animals versus what value I place on it. However, the reason you keep running into a problem convincing me that your values are inherently superior is because, ultimately, they're subjective and arbitrary, requiring certain preconceived opinions that I simply do not share, the main one being that eating meat is a matter of morality in the first place. I'm not arguing to you that eating meat is either more moral or even moral in its own right compared to vegetarian and vegan diets. I think they're all morally neutral dietary choices that are fine by me.

And to show an example of where you constantly ignore arguments that are plenty valid but inconveniently still not making the dietary choice of eating meat a moral issue, I submit the following post from several pages back where you failed to address my personal position even though I answered you with a brief summary of what's remained my position throughout this thread:
I don't think I've ever seen either of you two articulate why diet is not a moral issue (in fact, I seem to remember both of you making moral arguments against animal cruelty).

For the sake of clarity - and the avoidance of strawmen - would you mind explaining why your dietary choices are not moral issues?

What? You obviously mean dietary choice regarding eating meat, but I'm not saying that what I eat doesn't have a moral value. I'm saying that the values are applied differently and to different things in my case. Like I stated many pages back, I feel that there are very logical and reasonably moral reasons for lowering consumption of meat, not only for the ability to better improve the conditions for livestock but also to minimize the ecological toll (keep in mind, I'm into conservationism) and quite possibly to lower greenhouse emissions (though I'm not 100% on that last one). The value system I apply to it doesn't have a problem with the death, but instead on the waste, and I'd agree that the current system for industrial food (with both meat and plant foodstuffs) is horrendously wasteful.

There's more as far as details and gradation within the value system, but if I had to give a quick nutshell that pretty much works.

Not surprisingly, Cain, Kevin, and yourself have not yet once addressed what is inherently wrong about this position.
 
Hey Volatile, I think you're beginning to see why we gave up on them.

Neither RandFan nor Thaibixerken is capable of consistency on this issue. You can try finding common ground with them to reason from as much as you like, but as soon as you start the reasoning process they'll be running back to undercut that common ground. I cite RandFan's comical demand for you to justify RandFan's stated preference for laws against animal cruelty, and Thaiboxerken's dishonest attempts to equivocate between eating factory-farmed meat in the modern consumer context and eating road kill, a confusion Cain cleared up repeatedly.

GrenMe of course doesn'y even know what a straw man or equivocation is, but he's happy to post whatever he thinks sounds like an intelligent contribution.

You can't have a rational argument with irrational people. These aren't rational people, they're just irrational people who have hung out around the JREF forums long enough to ape the language rational people use.
 
Hey Volatile, I think you're beginning to see why we gave up on them.
You mean you couldn't answer simple questions.

Neither RandFan nor Thaibixerken is capable of consistency on this issue. You can try finding common ground with them to reason from as much as you like, but as soon as you start the reasoning process they'll be running back to undercut that common ground. I cite RandFan's comical demand for you to justify RandFan's stated preference for laws against animal cruelty...
You are so dishonest. You yell over and over that I can't justify morality by adaptive behaviors or indoctrination (which I agree with). Yet when Volatile appeals to that base perception you accuse me of demanding that Volatile justify my preference.

That's intelectually dishonest. I asked him if I couldn't rely on my perceptions of morality then what should I base it on?

You can't have a rational argument with irrational people.
Translation, you can't argue with people who don't agree with you and won't let you slide on your BS.
 
Last edited:
Ahh, Kevin Lowe: poster boy for the Dunning-Kruger effect

I don't know how many times I told Lowe to look in the mirror.


DEMONSTRABLE FACTS:
  1. I answered his questions and responded to his arguments.
  2. He didn't answer my questions and he refused to respond to my arguments.
 
Last edited:
If we stopped raising livestock, I think most of those animal species would become extinct. What environmental impact would that have? Would it be negative or positive?

Here in the US according to the USFW, there are ~9 million feral hogs roaming loose scattered among ~11 states. Most were livestock ~2 generations previous as it appears they can revert back to the wild state in that short of a time.

How many people have heard of "woods cattle"?

They're cattle that have been loosed to free range roam and forage off the land and are rounded up once a year by the owners.

Now...if you've ever been downwind of a cattle feedlot or worse, a hog confinement the stench alone will make a person consider the vegan route. Plus, the antibiotics, growth hormones, etc. they've been shot full with is why I try to keep the freezer stocked with wild game.

Whole food...not crap from a box.
 
Here in the US according to the USFW, there are ~9 million feral hogs roaming loose scattered among ~11 states. Most were livestock ~2 generations previous as it appears they can revert back to the wild state in that short of a time.

How many people have heard of "woods cattle"?

They're cattle that have been loosed to free range roam and forage off the land and are rounded up once a year by the owners.

Now...if you've ever been downwind of a cattle feedlot or worse, a hog confinement the stench alone will make a person consider the vegan route. Plus, the antibiotics, growth hormones, etc. they've been shot full with is why I try to keep the freezer stocked with wild game.

Whole food...not crap from a box.

This has what to do with eating meat? Apart from the other issues. Sounds like a good topic for a different thread though.
 
Whole food...not crap from a box.

This is an argument against certain livestock raising practices. The vegans here are trying to convince us not to eat meat at all because it's evil immoral.

Oh, and I've been to factory livestock farms. It did not deter me from eating meat. I also don't buy into the "dangers" of anti-biotics and growth hormones, etc.
 
I don't know how many times I told Lowe to look in the mirror.


DEMONSTRABLE FACTS:
  1. I answered his questions and responded to his arguments.
  2. He didn't answer my questions and he refused to respond to my arguments.

I guess you did respond in a sense, but your responses and arguments were nonsensical and self-contradictory, and failed to demonstrate any understanding of the points they were presented as a response to. You frequently misused vital terms ("contradiction", "hedonistic relativism", "absolutism", "objective", "objectivism") making any attempt to discuss those terms pointless, you failed to grasp the urgency of the problem with the naturalistic fallacy despite having it explained to you countless times, you freely appealed to mutually contradictory and well-defined moral philosophies whenever it suited you, and now you are demanding that others prove moral claims that you yourself have recently claimed to believe in.

(Yes, I'm aware you denied doing all of these things. That just means you aren't aware of doing them, which just means your problems are with your philosophical skills rather than with your honesty).

I don't feel that such posts earn you some sort of credit, which you can cash in for opportunities to change the subject.

Rational discussion can only take place if you hold yourself to certain standards of discourse. To begin with that means understanding the terms you use, and using them consistently. It means thinking about the contradictions in your position when they are pointed out to you, and then rectifying your position so it is no longer self-contradictory. (If you aren't feigning and you genuinely can't see the problems, then rational discussion is actually impossible).

Can you honestly say that you've been using the terms I mentioned consistently? The point at which I gave up on you was when you went fully irrational and started claiming that it was okay for you to contradict yourself freely because constantly contradicting yourself was inherent to moral philosophy. (I have no words for how colossally inane that statement was).

You are so dishonest. You yell over and over that I can't justify morality by adaptive behaviors or indoctrination (which I agree with). Yet when Volatile appeals to that base perception you accuse me of demanding that Volatile justify my preference.

That's intelectually dishonest. I asked him if I couldn't rely on my perceptions of morality then what should I base it on?

Volatile was using your statement that you support laws against animal cruelty as a mutually agreed-upon starting point for discussion. He assumed, because you said you supported such laws, that it was not necessary to present a justification for such support because both of you already supported those laws.

That's how rational argument works. You establish premises you can agree upon, and argue from there.

You don't do that though. When Volatile started arguing from that mutually agreed-upon premise, you immediately demanded that Volatile justify the premise you already agreed with.

Do you remember an earlier statement of mine, that you responded to with "tl;dr"? Here, I'll grab it for you.

Kevin said:
What you want to do is make a raft of claims like "Y'know, kinda sorta sometimes moral acts are those which you would desire of other people were your positions reversed", and "Y'know, kinda sorta sometimes moral acts are those which maximise happiness and minimise suffering for all affected, morally relevant entities", and "Y'know, kinda sorta sometimes moral acts are those which respect rational entities as worthy of respect as ends in themselves", and "Y'know, kinda sorta sometimes moral acts are those which we think are moral because of our evolved nature", and "Y'know, kinda sorta there are no objective moral claims at all" and "Y'now, kinda sorta moral claims are just the product of social convenience" and "Y'know, kinda sorta moral claims vary in different times and places and that's cool too, I'm not saying Vlad the Impaler was an immoral guy for his time and place".

You grab a sample bag of noises from every philosophy you come across, and then every time you want to justify an opinion you rifle around in it until you find something that suits you. When I point out that you are being inconsistent you get hugely offended because as far as you're concerned, the more random stuff in your grab bag the more philosophically and scientifically erudite you are and the more important your opinion is. In your world you don't need to apply reason to your grab-bag (although "Y'know, kinda sorta we can use reason to sort these claims out" is in your bag as well just for when you want to pretend to be rational).

The other advantage of the grab-bag is that any time anyone tries to pin you down on your claims, you can just point to a contradictory claim you made earlier and accuse them of attacking a straw man.

I think you snipped that and ignored it because it hit home.

Yet here you are doing it again - as soon as Volatile starts trying to engage with you rationally, you back up and start saying "I only kinda, sorta said I was against animal cruelty, I say all sorts of things, you can't hold me to any of them! Now you have to justify that premise, that I freely agreed to a minute ago".

"Kinda, sorta" believing in sixteen different moral philosophies of convenience isn't being nuanced, it's just being confused.

It's starting to look like your real moral philosophy, when we get down to brass tacks, is "This is all inherently so confusing we can't say anything for certain. Who is to say what makes something right or wrong? Nobody can ever make any moral claims, really. Now since you can't make a moral claim that I shouldn't XXXXXXXXXX, I'm going to do it".

In your case XXXXXXXXXX is eating meat, but that argument works when XXXXXXXXXX is a crime against humanity too, because it works where XXXXXXXXXX is anything.
 
Last edited:
Its like a religious argument: "I know my religion is right, and your beliefs mean you're going to rot in Hell!"

That said, I have a pair of bacon wrapped steaks thawing in the fridge. Mmmm.. Dead BBQ'ed cow...
 
This is an argument against certain livestock raising practices. The vegans here are trying to convince us not to eat meat at all because it's evil immoral.

Oh, and I've been to factory livestock farms. It did not deter me from eating meat. I also don't buy into the "dangers" of anti-biotics and growth hormones, etc.

Well, they sure are nasty places from whence a store-bought steak comes from.

When I lived in Nebraska, the guy officing down the hall was a PI that did a lot of work for cattle ranchers. They hired him to pose as a feedlot wrangler to make sure (among other things) their cattle actually were getting the innoculations they were supposed to be receiving as (apparently) there were some feedlot operators with a bent toward shortchanging those items.

I didn't mean to imply antibiotics were somehow "dangerous" as they're certainly required considering the disease and filth endemic in feedlots. But heck, the dead pile is certainly a don't miss scenic sight on everyone's tour agenda.

I just choose to avoid beef/swine/poultry originating from those sources whenever possible. Once you've had personal/custom raised beef, pork or poultry the store bought stuff is certainly inferior especially in taste. I realize not everyone has access to such and more's the pity but it's like our first trip to Hawaii and getting some local pineapple versus the stuff you have on the mainland. Not even close.
 
{assertion snipped}

Rational discussion can only take place if you hold yourself to certain standards of discourse.
Look in the mirror.

And please, read and consider what I mean and not what you THINK I mean.

He assumed, because you said you supported such laws, that it was not necessary to present a justification for such support because both of you already supported those laws.
And I explained why I had reason to question those. I don't claim that those things "ought to be illegal" simply because of my perceptions or that I should govern my behavior simply because of my perceptions (naturalistic fallacy). Nor should an arbitrary perception be a base line simply because someone else agrees with me. That's just dumb.

You are being inconsistent.

Absent an argument for why they should be permissible I've no reason to think that they should. I don't rule out such an argument. At this point in my life I doubt one will be made.

That's how rational argument works. You establish premises you can agree upon, and argue from there.
I only agree that I percieve these things as wrong and I support such laws. But that is simply due to my current perceptions. I've good reason to be skeptical of them. We need to be careful crafting "ought's" from "is's".

Let's start from a base line and not some cherry picked mutual agreement that relies on naturalistic fallacy. I could pick the converse and argue that since I perceive eating meat as moral that animal cruelty is moral. And what if I am in a discussion with someone where we mutually agree that eating meat is moral. Should I then reason that animal cruelty is moral?

That some arbitrary and cherry picked perception is mutually agreed upon should not be the basis for seemingly contrary positions. If for no other reason than it's a naturalistic fallacy but it is also arbitrary.

You don't do that though. When Volatile started arguing from that mutually agreed-upon premise, you immediately demanded that Volatile justify the premise you already agreed with.
Not true, I agreed that I perceive something as moral. That I perceive something as moral doesn't mean that the perception alone should govern my behavior (naturalistic fallacy) nor should seemingly contrary views be deemed immoral because of this cherry picked basis or because it is mutually agreed on. I could pick the converse and find someone to mutually agree that eating meat is moral and then conclude that since I perceive eating meat as moral that animal cruelty is moral.

Yet here you are doing it again - as soon as Volatile starts trying to engage with you rationally, you back up and start saying "I only kinda, sorta said I was against animal cruelty, I say all sorts of things, you can't hold me to any of them! Now you have to justify that premise, that I freely agreed to a minute ago".
That's dishonest. I have been consistent. I perceive certain things as moral and certain things as immoral because of adaptive behaviors and social indoctrination. It makes no sense that I cherry pick a single moral perception as a base line for seemingly contrary positions. Hell, I could cherry pick my perception that eating meat is moral and reason that animal cruelty is moral.

It's starting to look like your real moral philosophy, when we get down to brass tacks, is "This is all inherently so confusing we can't say anything for certain. Who is to say what makes something right or wrong? Nobody can ever make any moral claims, really. Now since you can't make a moral claim that I shouldn't XXXXXXXXXX, I'm going to do it".
I'm a moral skeptic but that doesn't mean that I don't have perceptions of what is and isn't moral and that I can't consider arguments and reason my morality. That I'm a moral skeptic doesn't obviate my ability to feel compassion and empathy or that I can't reason rules of behavior.

Sorry Kevin but you are creating straw men and YOU are being inconsistent. When I debate with you about my perceptions and indoctrinated sense of morality you protest. When Volatile wants to appeal to the self same sense you demand that I must accept this cherry picked perception simply because Volatile agrees with it. Nonsense.

Make up your mind.
 
Last edited:
Look in the mirror.

And please, read and consider what I mean and not what you THINK I mean.

I don't think it should be a starting point for discussion. Just because I perceive something as moral or immoral doesn't mean that my perceptions alone should govern my behavior (naturalistic fallacy). Nor should I simply cherry pick a perception to form a basis for all of my other decisions.

Consistency, RandFan, consistency. That's all we ask for.

If you agree with the claim "we should have laws against animal cruelty" and I agree with the claim "we should have laws against animal cruelty" then, if you are being consistent, we can begin a conversation about what follows logically from that claim. It doesn't necessarily matter why each of us believes that claim, as long as we both believe it.

You can call that "forming a basis for all of my other decisions" if you like, but thats not quite right. It's assuming that if you do believe it, then all your other claims must be consistent with it. We don't care what is based on what, necessarily. We just care that if you claim to believe A, you can't believe anything that necessitates not-A.

And I explained why I had reason to question those. I don't claim that those things "ought to be illegal" because of my perceptions or that I should govern my behavior simply because of my perceptions (naturalistic fallacy). Nor should an arbitrary perception be a base line simply because someone else agrees with me. That's just dumb.

You are being inconsistent.

Actually I think it's you. You claim to believe things (like "we should have laws against animal cruelty"), but when pressed it turns out you only kinda-sorta believe them.

Kinda-sorta believing in several contradictory things is incompatible with having a rationally justifiable position.

I don't agree with the premise. These things might indeed be moral. Let's start from a base line and not some cherry picked mutual agreement that relies on naturalistic fallacy. I could pick the converse and argue that since I perceive eating meat as moral that animal cruelty is moral.

Who said the claim that "we should have laws against animal cruelty" was based on the naturalistic fallacy? It looks to me like you just made that up.

Regardless, you could believe the claim "we should have laws against animal cruelty" because a leprechaun popped out of your bum and told you it was true for all I care - we could still have a logical argument about what logically follows from that claim, if you were only consistent about it.

And what if I am in a discussion with someone where we mutually agree that eating meat is moral. Should I then reason that animal cruelty is moral?

That some arbitrary and cherry picked perception is mutually agreed upon should not be the basis for my morality. If for no other reason than it's a naturalistic fallacy but it is also arbitrary.

Once again I have trouble figuring out the logical incapacity that can give rise to such a post.

If you and someone else have a discussion starting from the mutually agreed upon premise that eating meat is moral, then you could (assuming you argued rationally) mutually come up with conclusions consistent with the idea that eating meat is moral.

If you and someone else have a discussion starting from the mutually agreed upon premise that animal cruelty should be illegal, then you could (assuming you argued rationally) mutually come up with conclusions consistent with the idea that animal cruelty should be illegal.

In neither case would your conclusions be true unless your premise was true, but since you and Volatile both agreed that the premise was true, what's the problem?

Not true, I agreed that I perceive something as moral. That I perceive something as moral doesn't mean that the perception alone should govern my behavior (naturalistic fallacy) and all other decisions should stem from that cherry picked basis. I could pick the converse and find someone to mutually agree that eating meat is moral and then conclude that since I perceive eating meat as moral that animal cruelty is moral.

That's dishonest. I have been consistent. I perceive certain things as moral and certain things as immoral because of adaptive behaviors and social indoctrination. It makes no sense that I cherry pick a single moral perception as a base line for all of my morality. Hell, I could cherry pick my perception that eating meat is moral and reason that animal cruelty is moral.

How can you claim with a straight face to be "consistent"?

If you were consistent, then by definition you would not believe A while also believing anything that necessitated not-A. That's what consistency means.

Yet you argue "You cannot ask me to show how my beliefs are consistent with my claim A. That would be cherry-picking. It is cherry-picking because I also believe things which necessitate not-A. You could equally well cherry-pick one of those beliefs and ask me to be consistent with that belief, in which case I would have to claim not-A. Therefore I do not ever have to show that my beliefs are consistent, because they are inconsistent".

Inconsistency is incompatible with rationality.

I'm a moral skeptic but that doesn't mean that I don't have perceptions of what is and isn't moral and that I can't consider arguments and reason my morality. That I'm a moral skeptics doesn't obviate my ability to feel compassion and empathy or that I can't reason rules of behavior.

Sorry Kevin but you are creating straw men and YOU are being inconsistent. When I debate with you about my perceptions and indoctrinated sense of morality you protest. When Volatile wants to appeal to the self same sense you demand that I must accept this cherry picked perception simply because Volatile agrees with it. Nonsense.

Make up your mind.

If you have two perceptions, A and B, and they cannot both be true, then if you want to call yourself rational or consistent then you must abandon one.

Or at the very least you must admit "I believe mutually contradictory things and I'm confused, but I see no way out of it. I know my position is wrong, I just don't know what is right".

What you can't say, if you are honest, rational and consistent, is "I believe both of my perceptions to be true".
 
If you agree with the claim "we should have laws against animal cruelty" and I agree with the claim "we should have laws against animal cruelty" then, if you are being consistent, we can begin a conversation about what follows logically from that claim. It doesn't necessarily matter why each of us believes that claim, as long as we both believe it.
You are not being consistent. At the beginning of this thread you railed against any natural basis. Hell, I couldn't even mention it. Now, ta da... it doesn't matter.

I'm bothered by animal cruelty. It seems reasonable to try and address the issue. Absent an argument to allow animal cruelty and given current social more's I'm happy to support animal cruelty laws to reduce animal suffering.

I don't percieve eating animals in any sense as troubling. On top of that I've a good reason to think that animal husbandry can be a good thing for animals. I believe that existince is in and of itself a benifit. We see animals in the wild as a good thing and they must suffer day to day predation, exposure, disease, etc.. So we give animals an opportunity to live a life free of want and suffering for the trade off of providing us food.

If you were consistent, then by definition you would not believe A while also believing anything that necessitated not-A. That's what consistency means.
This discussion came up not because I was trying to argue that on one hand animal cruelty is ok and on the other it isn't.


This discussion arose because I objected to Volatiles demand that I form a base line using my natural and or indoctrinated sense of morality and then apply that to all other areas. My objections have been:
  1. My perceptions alone, in any single area, should not be a base line for my moral behavior (as you have argued) as I am skeptical of them.
  2. I don't equate eating meat as animal cruelty (I'm happy to be skeptical of that also).
I've got to log off for awhile folks. I had two very significant projects come in today and they are both on rush.

Best of luck.
 
Last edited:
You are not being consistent. At the beginning of this thread you railed against any natural basis. Hell, I couldn't even mention it. Now, ta da... it doesn't matter.

This is very, very basic reasoning. You should be embarrassed that someone has to explain this to you.

If you think A is true and I think A is false, and we want to reconcile our different beliefs, then we might have a discussion about how we came to our beliefs. You might say "A is true because believing A is true is natural", and I might say "Ah, but that is the naturalistic fallacy, so that argument for A is no good".

On the other hand if we both agree that A is true, but you think that B is true as well whereas I think that B is false, then we might have a discussion about how A relates to B. I might say "A and B cannot be true at the same time, you see" and you might say "Good point, I must abandon one of my two beliefs".

In this case the reason why you and Volatile each believe animal cruelty laws to be a good idea is not currently relevant. You could believe it because of fallacious reasoning or the bum-leprechaun or whatever, it's not relevant to that particular argument.

Accusing me of inconsistency is just a tactic to get the focus of the conversation off the actual problem: That you endorse laws against animal cruelty, yet you vigorously resist engaging with any argument that starts from the premise that laws against cruelty are somehow morally justified.

I'm bothered by animal cruelty. It seems reasonable to try and address the issue. Absent an argument to allow animal cruelty and given current social more's I'm happy to support animal cruelty laws to reduce animal suffering.

I don't percieve eating animals in any sense as troubling. On top of that I've a good reason to think that animal husbandry can be a good thing for animals. I believe that existince is in and of itself a benifit. We see animals in the wild as a good thing and they must suffer day to day predation, exposure, disease, etc.. So we give animals an opportunity to live a life free of want and suffering for the trade off of providing us food.

Okay. So the topic you should be responding to is whether or not these two beliefs are logically incompatible.

Volatile tried to argue that they were incompatible, and instead of arguing otherwise you started demanding that Volatile justify belief in the claim that animal cruelty laws are morally justified.

That's inconsistency.

This discussion came up not because I was trying to argue that on one hand animal cruelty is ok and on the other it isn't.

This discussion arose because I objected to Volatiles demand that I form a base line using my natural and or indoctrinated sense of morality and then apply that to all other areas. My objections have been:
  1. My perceptions alone, in any single area, should not be a base line for my moral behavior (as you have argued) as I am skeptical of them.
  2. I don't equate eating meat as animal cruelty (I'm happy to be skeptical of that also).

I just explained to you in some detail why it was incorrect to refer to consistency as taking your "perceptions alone, in any single area" as a "base line". That is a straw man. What is based on what is not the topic under discussion. We are talking about whether all of your beliefs are logically consistent with all of your other beliefs.

If any of your beliefs are inconsistent with any of your other beliefs, then you are wrong about something. We don't necessarily know what right away, but we know you are being inconsistent.

The fact that you claim to be skeptical of your own beliefs is all well and good, but only if you act on that skepticism by rejecting the beliefs which are incompatible with your other beliefs, or by just admitting that your beliefs are incoherent and you don't know where you have gone wrong.

Otherwise it's not skepticism in any positive sense. It's just incoherent wishy-washiness.

To come back to a very important point: Are you still claiming that constantly contradicting yourself is a necessary feature of moral philosophy? You seem to be at least flirting with the idea that not contradicting yourself is a desirable goal, which might indicate progress, but if you are clinging to that incredibly inane claim then I really doubt we'll ever get anywhere with you using the tools of rationality. Rationality, as I have to keep explaining to you, requires consistency.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom