One immediate one is dropping litter. "I don't like carrying trash around" is not an argument in favour of littering. Another, more extreme one, is paedophilia - "I don't like having sex with adults" is not an argument
for having sex with children.
Given the choice between a vegan diet and eating animals, I much prefer the animal diet for all of the reasons I've mentioned. A sense of well being after a meal isn't an immoral desire nor is choosing to eat animal products immoral especially given that there is a trade off.
Not immoral in and of itself, no. As I said, it is not inherently wrong to eat meat. But eating it when tasty, nutritionally-equivalent sources are readily available - that's when it becomes immoral, because it is at that point that you let your personal whim over-ride your good conscience.
I don't eat the meat so the animal will suffer and thereby derive pleasure from the fact that the animal suffers. Also eating meat doesn't necassarily equate to suffering.
Who said suffering? I'm talking about death. As far as I can see, the duck-killing kid is immoral even if he breaks the ducks' necks quickly and painlessly. And, perhaps relevantly, perhaps not, his actions would be a crime in the UK either way.
Your whims are only satisfied by animal death, like his. How is that not sadistic?
Now you are pulling a Cain/Kevin. No, no you haven't covered this. You've given a lame argument that was rebuted and you refused to follow up with the rebuttal. You will argue with Ken for all eternity over who is smug but won't follow up on this.
We
have, RF. You cannot act in the interests of something that will not exist.
Straw man. No one said that I am rescuing them. I'm giving them life. I think that life is itself a benifit. Do you think that every existence that leads to death is a priori wrong?
Nope, obviously not. That would be impossible.
If altruism is your goal - of you have these animal's interests at heart - then killing them becomes even less tenable. After all, if the gift of life is so precious - and this is your argument, remember - then taking it for a cheap whim is even more ridiculous. If some life is good, then more life is better - and the sooner you kill an animal, the worse the problem, by your own standards.
This is what I mean about inconsistency, RF. You need to follow through the consequences of your arguments.
I'm raising them knowing that they will die. I simply choose when.
But giving life to something so that it will exist and then die is not in and of itself immoral. Or the act of having children would be immoral.
As to the environment. I'm not against steps to mitigate environmental impact. I don't see that as an argument that eating animals is per se immoral.[/quote]