Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

We've covered this. Over and over. It's a bad argument. You are not rescuing food animals from anything. You are raising them to harm them, and causing environmental damage to boot. It's not an altruistic action, because you cannot act altruistically towards something that does not exist.

False dichotomy.
 
So, if we rule out evolved adaptive behaviors and social mores, what is our base premise?

Be the best person you can be. That's the core of my moral system. That's my base premise. What's yours?

The "fun" issue is important (and it's why Cain and I have been talking about "torture"; to bring this into focus". When it comes down to it, honestly: You enjoy killing animals for fun. It excites you - your taste buds - when animals die. How is that different from a kid slitting duck's throats by the pond because he enjoys how he makes him feel? On what basis do you differentiate between the two?
 
Be the best person you can be. That's the core of my moral system. That's my base premise. What's yours?

The "fun" issue is important (and it's why Cain and I have been talking about "torture"; to bring this into focus". When it comes down to it, honestly: You enjoy killing animals for fun. It excites you - your taste buds - when animals die. How is that different from a kid slitting duck's throats by the pond because he enjoys how he makes him feel? On what basis do you differentiate between the two?

Unless you grow all your own food, I'm guessing that it excites your tastbuds to eat vegetables grown on industrialized farms, or brought in from a large distance. These processes kill animals as well, as outlined in my post above. On what basis do you differentiate?
 
Unless you grow all your own food, I'm guessing that it excites your tastbuds to eat vegetables grown on industrialized farms, or brought in from a large distance.

True.

There are two responses to that. The first is that as I can't grow my own food, and I have to eat, I should take reasonable steps to reduce the impact of my diet. I do this by going vegan, shopping locally and buying with consideration..

The second is that pointing out the foibles of my diet do not invalidate the points I'm making - if anything, they strengthen it. No-one;s perfect, but you're right. I should be growing my own food, and that tinned pineapple I had for desert was, on balance, probably immoral. I accept that. That's not a defence of meat-eating, though. Not at all.

These processes kill animals as well, as outlined in my post above. On what basis do you differentiate?
Direct vs indirect harms, principally, as well as numbers. A meat-eating diet causes all the harms I do indirectly, plus lots more directly.

But as I said, pointing out that I'm not perfect is just an exhortation to me to be more careful in practicing what I preach. It's an argument for my position, if anything. It does not invalidate anything I've said in this thread, and nor can it lend any weight to the opposing argument.
 
Last edited:
No it isn't.

When you only present two alternatives as if they are the only choices, it surely is. Same goes for your strawmen ("you enjoy killing animals for fun") and your equivocations ("what's the difference?"). While I realize these Buddhist qualities seem perfectly reasonable to you, I've already submitted that there are elements to these arguments that you continually fail to acknowledge.

First, you haven't defined why the death of one animal should be considered equal to the death of a different animal. Second, given the first, you have insufficiently supported the (supposed) inherent wrong associated with eating livestock. Third, given the previous two, you have not presented a single argument that explains why the value system you are applying is intrinsically more moral. You keep jumping to the third without sufficiently addressing he prior two, particularly the first, which at this point stands as an assertion of equivocation.

Or, in short: uh huh.
 
Is "I just don't like the alternative" an argument you'd use in defense of any other action that was demonstrably harmful and which had excellent alternatives should one choose?

I doubt it. That's at the core of this issue, RF. Somehow, you want me to believe (and you need to believe yourself) that the taste of chicken is so sublime, so amazing, so wonderful, that it overwhelms every other sense in your body, and trumps your rationality such that you defend it in ways you would deem ridiculous if similar arguments were offered for any other cause.
For example?

Is chicken really that awesome? That harming the environment for no benefit other than the satiation of your taste-buds, and the killing of a sentient animal for no other reason than you get your kicks as a result of the action, is worth every mouthful of factory-processed, water-filled, adulterated sausage-meat you chow down on? Seriously?
Given the choice between a vegan diet and eating animals, I much prefer the animal diet for all of the reasons I've mentioned. A sense of well being after a meal isn't an immoral desire nor is choosing to eat animal products immoral especially given that there is a trade off.

The more I think about it, the more meat-eating seems like sadism. Can you explain to me where I'm going wrong?
I don't eat the meat so the animal will suffer and thereby derive pleasure from the fact that the animal suffers. Also eating meat doesn't necassarily equate to suffering.

We've covered this. Over and over. It's a bad argument.
Now you are pulling a Cain/Kevin. No, no you haven't covered this. You've given a lame argument that was rebuted and you refused to follow up with the rebuttal. You will argue with Ken for all eternity over who is smug but won't follow up on this.

You are not rescuing food animals from anything.
Straw man. No one said that I am rescuing them. I'm giving them life. I think that life is itself a benifit. Do you think that every existence that leads to death is a priori wrong?

You are raising them to harm them...
I'm raising them knowing that they will die. I simply choose when.

It's not an altruistic action, because you cannot act altruistically towards something that does not exist.
But giving life to something so that it will exist and then die is not in and of itself immoral. Or the act of having children would be immoral.

As to the environment. I'm not against steps to mitigate environmental impact. I don't see that as an argument that eating animals is per se immoral.
 
When you only present two alternatives as if they are the only choices, it surely is. Same goes for your strawmen ("you enjoy killing animals for fun") and your equivocations ("what's the difference?").

That's not a strawman. In fact, it was posed, initially, as a question. If taste is the satiation of one whim, on what grounds can it be defended whilst another (similar) whim condemned? I don't see that you, or anyone, has attempted to address that very salient point. What is the difference?

First, you haven't defined why the death of one animal should be considered equal to the death of a different animal.
People don't eat ducks? Or shall we talk about killing cows for kicks? If talking about two species for illustrative purposes is too abstract, then we can be more direct. It's interesting that you'd rather nit-pick than discuss the points on the table, though.

Second, given the first, you have insufficiently supported the (supposed) inherent wrong associated with eating livestock.
You've seen the environmental numbers.


Third, given the previous two, you have not presented a single argument that explains why the value system you are applying is intrinsically more moral.
It results in less harm, is internally consistent and can make a positive case for itself. Now we really are going in circles.

You have - again - pretended that the arguments have not been made, rather than actually address them. That doesn't speak strongly for your position, frankly.
 
Be the best person you can be. That's the core of my moral system. That's my base premise. What's yours?
But what does it mean to be "the best person you can be". I won't forget your question but I want to resolve this first.

The "fun" issue is important (and it's why Cain and I have been talking about "torture"; to bring this into focus". When it comes down to it, honestly: You enjoy killing animals for fun. It excites you - your taste buds - when animals die. How is that different from a kid slitting duck's throats by the pond because he enjoys how he makes him feel? On what basis do you differentiate between the two?
He enjoys the killing for the sake of killing. I don't. But you haven't told me why he is immoral. We can't address your "torture" issue because we don't know what basis to declare killing for enjoyment immoral.

Can you give me one?
 
But as I said, pointing out that I'm not perfect is just an exhortation to me to be more careful in practicing what I preach. It's an argument for my position, if anything. It does not invalidate anything I've said in this thread, and nor can it lend any weight to the opposing argument.

Pointing out that you (and all of us) are not perfect is the point though. Almost every convenience, comfort or pleasure we take has some moral cost, and we all decide where to draw that line. We could live like the Jains and eat only fruit that falls off trees and wear masks to avoid breathing in tiny bugs.

We choose to a certain extent the comfort, pleasure and convenience that we will allow ourselves in the knowledge that it come at the detriment of other life forms, it is our personal moral compass that tells us when reasonable self interest crosses over into selfish cruelty. You draw the ideal line at causing no harm to anything, I don't. Life is compromise and it's really only a matter of degree.

Posting here when I could be out raising money for orphans is imperfect too, I can call it an immoral act, just like your tinned pineapple is immoral. Every day, we draw the line, but it doesn't help anyone to feel guilty about it (unless that causes you to re-draw your line) It doesn't help a single soul to feel bad about eating pineapple or steak.

A single cow provides about 600lbs of meat more or less. If I eat a one pound steak, I'm adding 1/600th, less than .2% of a life to my tally over the background death of running a farm. In contrast, if you eat a vegetable like a tomato that growers want to look good in stores, it uses much more pesticide than the corn that's fed to the cows and ups the death tally of insects, fish, birds and anything else in the area, I don't have hard numbers, but I'll bet it'll cover .2% of a life.
 
Last edited:
Volitile,

Having been in threads where I was answering more posts than anyone else I've been in your shoes before. It's a lot to respond to. Please, take as much time as you need and if you want to put me on the rear burner at any point I've no problem with that.

I really, really appreciate your responses and the even tone. Sorry for the Cain/Kevin remark.

I've no ill will for you.

ETA: I've no ill will for anyone but I've a bit more appreciation for you than some posters. I do think you are a reasonable and thoughtful person.
 
Last edited:
For example?

One immediate one is dropping litter. "I don't like carrying trash around" is not an argument in favour of littering. Another, more extreme one, is paedophilia - "I don't like having sex with adults" is not an argument for having sex with children.

Given the choice between a vegan diet and eating animals, I much prefer the animal diet for all of the reasons I've mentioned. A sense of well being after a meal isn't an immoral desire nor is choosing to eat animal products immoral especially given that there is a trade off.

Not immoral in and of itself, no. As I said, it is not inherently wrong to eat meat. But eating it when tasty, nutritionally-equivalent sources are readily available - that's when it becomes immoral, because it is at that point that you let your personal whim over-ride your good conscience.

I don't eat the meat so the animal will suffer and thereby derive pleasure from the fact that the animal suffers. Also eating meat doesn't necassarily equate to suffering.

Who said suffering? I'm talking about death. As far as I can see, the duck-killing kid is immoral even if he breaks the ducks' necks quickly and painlessly. And, perhaps relevantly, perhaps not, his actions would be a crime in the UK either way.

Your whims are only satisfied by animal death, like his. How is that not sadistic?

Now you are pulling a Cain/Kevin. No, no you haven't covered this. You've given a lame argument that was rebuted and you refused to follow up with the rebuttal. You will argue with Ken for all eternity over who is smug but won't follow up on this.

We have, RF. You cannot act in the interests of something that will not exist.

Straw man. No one said that I am rescuing them. I'm giving them life. I think that life is itself a benifit. Do you think that every existence that leads to death is a priori wrong?

Nope, obviously not. That would be impossible.

If altruism is your goal - of you have these animal's interests at heart - then killing them becomes even less tenable. After all, if the gift of life is so precious - and this is your argument, remember - then taking it for a cheap whim is even more ridiculous. If some life is good, then more life is better - and the sooner you kill an animal, the worse the problem, by your own standards.

This is what I mean about inconsistency, RF. You need to follow through the consequences of your arguments.

I'm raising them knowing that they will die. I simply choose when.

But giving life to something so that it will exist and then die is not in and of itself immoral. Or the act of having children would be immoral.

As to the environment. I'm not against steps to mitigate environmental impact. I don't see that as an argument that eating animals is per se immoral.[/quote]
 
Repeating, aggressively, not only that you're RIGHT (!) but that you don't even have to explain why you're right would certainly come across as smug in any other topic of debate.

You are wrong. I said that eating meat hasn't been shown to be wrong. I am not claiming that eating meat is right.

Imagine a hypothetical Iranian: "It's legal to stone homosexuals to death, and NO-ONE has explained why it's wrong!". That's what you sound like, Ken.

That doesn't quite fit with my philosophy that people should be allowed the freedom to do what they want, as long as it's not impeding on other's freedoms or damaging to society.

No, I equated "fun" with "taste" and asked for the difference between the two.

If it's wrong to kill an animal for fun (to satiate one particular whim), on what basis can killing for the satiation of a similar whim be justified?

People eat meat for taste, they don't kill animals for taste.

The answer to this question requires either that you explain why "taste" is not the same thing as "fun", or that meat eating has a positive case above any beyond killing for kicks. Either would be a starting point for a meaningful discussion.

It would be meaningful if you actually gave a reason as to why eating meat is wrong. So far, you only have shown that too much livestock breeding can impact the environment.
 
But what does it mean to be "the best person you can be". I won't forget your question but I want to resolve this first.

Taking reasonable steps to increase the good I do to the world and decrease the harm. It's not that complicated.

He enjoys the killing for the sake of killing. I don't.

You cannot satiate your whim without death. Neither can he.

But you haven't told me why he is immoral. We can't address your "torture" issue because we don't know what basis to declare killing for enjoyment immoral.

That was discussed in the "Animal Rights" thread and is a long, complex and intricate argument that (in my case) draws mainly on questions of interests and agency. But that's by the by, really: if we can find a point of agreement that the duck-killing kid is at fault, then we can skip the preamble. Again, we're talking about consistency here.

I would argue (in fact, I know) that you hold moral positions towards animals - you are in favour of animal cruelty laws; you've said as much yourself. So let's take that as axiomatic, since we both agree. What I'm interested in is why you find one set of behaviours OK and another problematic, when the only difference I can see is that one satiates the taste buds and the other satiates another set of pleasure-receptors.

On what grounds does taste get elevated above the thrill of the kill? On what grounds do you, personally, find one OK and the other problematic?
 
It's not an altruistic action, because you cannot act altruistically towards something that does not exist.

Did you just make the argument that these animals should be extinct rather than live a full life just to be eaten at the end of it?
 
You are wrong. I said that eating meat hasn't been shown to be wrong. I am not claiming that eating meat is right.

What's the opposite of "wrong", Ken?


That doesn't quite fit with my philosophy that people should be allowed the freedom to do what they want, as long as it's not impeding on other's freedoms or damaging to society
Remember the UN report? Remember how meat-eating "damages society" more than the vegan alternative?

If you're against damaging society, how can you defend your socially-destructive diet?


People eat meat for taste, they don't kill animals for taste.
Ken - that steak is DEAD, dude. If it wasn't dead, you couldn't eat it.



It would be meaningful if you actually gave a reason as to why eating meat is wrong. So far, you only have shown that too much livestock breeding can impact the environment.
Yes. And eating meat involves breeding livestock. :rolleyes: You agree with all the premises:

1) You agree that eating meat is more damaging than the alternative
2) You agree that people should not in good conscience engage in damaging activities
3) You are against killing for fun
4) You understand that animals must die to enjoy the taste of meat.

You agree with all the points that underpin the argument. YOUR OWN REASONING shows that eating meat is wrong.
 
Last edited:
Did you just make the argument that these animals should be extinct rather than live a full life just to be eaten at the end of it?

Why would they be extinct, Ken?

If we want to keep them alive -- if their continuation as a species is our paramount reason for eating them -- we could raise them in exactly the same way we do now, but just not kill them half-way though.

Or were you making it up as you went along when you decided to head down this particular tangent?

Hey! I know! To save the panda, maybe we can all go out and eat panda steak tomorrow...
 
Pointing out that you (and all of us) are not perfect is the point though. Almost every convenience, comfort or pleasure we take has some moral cost, and we all decide where to draw that line. We could live like the Jains and eat only fruit that falls off trees and wear masks to avoid breathing in tiny bugs.

We could. And a convincing case could be made that we should, perhaps. This, of course, does not invalidate other forms of behaviour in the meantime. That I'm not perfect does not excuse your bad behaviour. Quite the reverse.

"You shouldn't litter!" "Well, some companies are pumping sewage into the sea!". It doesn't matter. That we are not perfect is an argument to work towards perfection, not just to give up and say "to hell with it", particularly when the sacrifices are minimal. Being vegan is EASY and the gains are HUGE.
 
Why would they be extinct, Ken?

They would be extinct because they cannot survive without human aid, they have been bred, and the landscape changed and animals transported out of context, so that they can only live with a lot of help from humans, feed, land etc. And that stuff ain't cheap. As soon as there's no economic reason to raise them (meat, eggs, milk) there's no way to keep humans sheeling out all that money to keep breeding them and keep them alive.

When swine flew broke out, the zoo in Iran quarantined the only pig in the country. If we didn't eat meat eggs or dairy, after a few generations, farm animals would only live in zoos.
 
What's the opposite of "wrong", Ken?

Do you think homosexuality is wrong?

Remember the UN report? Remember how meat-eating "damages society" more than the vegan alternative?

That is not evidence that eating meat is damaging to society. It's evidence that too much livestock is damaging to the environment. Nice try though.

Ken - that steak is DEAD, dude. If it wasn't dead, you couldn't eat it.

I've never killed a cow for it's beef. Someone else does and provides it for me to eat.

Yes. And eating meat involves breeding livestock.

Unless it doesn't, like when a person hunts for his meat.

1) You agree that eating meat is more damaging than the alternative
2) You agree that people should not in good conscience engage in damaging activities
3) You are against killing for fun
4) You understand that animals must die to enjoy the taste of meat.

You agree with all the points that underpin the argument. YOUR OWN REASONING shows that eating meat is wrong.

1. No, I did not.
2. Yes.
3. I did not say that.
4. Eventually, yes. I've eaten live animals before though. It's more fresh.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom