Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

I claim that eating meat causes demonstrable harms...
The act of being born causes demonstrable harm. Every living organism will die.

...and that in the lack of a positive case to support it, it should be eschewed. The lack of a positive case is entirely the problem.

Why do I feel like a lone voice crying in the wilderness?

If life is itself a benifit then I give that to the animal (as you note it wouldn't exist otherwise). On top of that I give it day to day protection from predators, the elements, health care and plenty of food.

In return it gives me food.


How clever of wild sheep to have acquired that most versatile adaptation, the shepherd! By forming a symbiotic alliance with Homo sapiens, sheep could outsource their chief survival tasks: food finding and predator avoidance. --Dan Dennet
 
Ken - explain to me how, with current technology, you can eat meat without raising livestock. :rolleyes:

As smug as you are, you seem to have forgotten about the activity of hunting.

If you think less meat is less harmful than some meat, but that zero meat is not the least harmful option, it logically follows that at some point between "some" and "zero" there is a point at which eating less meat becomes more harmful. What's that point?

This makes absolutely no logical sense at all. It does not follow that at some point between some and zero that eating meat becomes harmful.

My premises are that the less meat you eat, the more ecologically-sound your diet. This is backed up by scientific fact, and scientific fact you agreed with. That's the premise.

You mean the less livestock is raised, the more ecologically sound the diet, provided you're eating raised livestock. Right?

You want to argue that at some point, this observation becomes false; that is, at some point before meat consumption falls to zero, there is a point at which to reduce meat consumption becomes more harmful. You're arguing that there is a minimum amount of meat that it is morally obligatory we all eat, to avoid harms.

This straw man that you've constructed is rather silly. Why don't you actually address my points instead of twisting and torturing the words to make an absolutely ridiculous argument I never made?


Prove to me that eating meat is wrong.

Why can't you? Why can't you even ARGUE it? You don't even have a BAD case. You don't have a case at all.

When someone is fighting the status quo, it's up to them to show why that status quo is wrong. That's not an appeal to ignorance, that is just how society works. You're not doing a very good job.

You've only shown that raising too much livestock has a negative impact on the environment.
 
I claim that eating meat causes demonstrable harms, and that in the lack of a positive case to support it, it should be eschewed.

Wow, your simplified explanation is worse than Cain's. I mean, straight out of the Ashoka Edicts (Buddhism [example]).
 
If we stopped raising livestock, I think most of those animal species would become extinct. What environmental impact would that have? Would it be negative or positive?
 
Firstly, that doesn't negate my point - Ken was mocking me (!) for arguing that the end point of harm reduction is zero meat consumption. Even if the harms were negligible, my point would still hold - so it can't have been what Ken meant.

Say you could graph "harm" against amount of meat consumed. You could reach a point where "harm" graph levels off, or even reaches zero before you get to to zero meat consumption. So reducing consumption below this point would not reduce "harm" any further. The problem is that we don't all acknowledge the same things as "harm".

Secondly, your "sufficiently balanced" would require a case to be made for meat eating.

I mean reduced enough that "it tastes good" and "it more conveniently provides the nutrition I need" are a sufficient case. If the harm is seen to be very near zero, then virtually any "plus" will balance it. Again, though, we don't agree on what is or isn't harm, let alone what value to assign to that harm.


Good.

Why? What is the source of your "problem"? What do you find objectionable about a kid kicking a duck to death?

Hard-wired anthropomorphism, I think. In general, the more like a human a creature is, the more "rights" (I'm using the term very loosely, perhaps "protections" would be a better word.) I think they should have. And, killing for "fun" is a foreign concept to me and makes me feel a little uneasy, because I can't really imagine enjoying killing anything.
 
If we stopped raising livestock, I think most of those animal species would become extinct. What environmental impact would that have? Would it be negative or positive?

I would say very likely positive.


From Wikipedia
A 400-page United Nations report from the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) states that cattle farming is "responsible for 18% of greenhouse gases."[33] The production of cattle to feed and clothe humans stresses ecosystems around the world,[32] and is assessed to be one of the top three environmental problems in the world on a local to global scale.[34]

The report, entitled Livestock's Long Shadow, also surveys the environmental damage from sheep, chickens, pigs and goats. But in almost every case, the world's 1.5 billion cattle are cited as the greatest adverse impact with respect to climate change as well as species extinction. The report concludes that, unless changes are made, the massive damage reckoned to be due to livestock may more than double by 2050, as demand for meat increases. One of the cited changes suggests that intensification of the livestock industry may be suggested, since intensification leads to less land for a given level of production.[34]

Some microbes respire in the cattle gut by an anaerobic process known as methanogenesis (producing the gas methane). Cattle emit a large volume of methane, 95% of it through eructation or burping, not flatulence.[35] As the carbon in the methane comes from the digestion of vegetation produced by photosynthesis, its release into the air by this process would normally be considered harmless, because there is no net increase in carbon in the atmosphere — it's removed as carbon dioxide from the air by photosynthesis and returned to it as methane. Methane is a more potent greenhouse gas than carbon dioxide, having a warming effect 23 to 50 times greater,[36][37] and according to Takahashi and Young "even a small increase in methane concentration in the atmosphere exerts a potentially significant contribution to global warming".[37] Further analysis of the methane gas produced by livestock as a contributor to the increase in greenhouse gases is provided by Weart.[38] Research is underway on methods of reducing this source of methane, by the use of dietary supplements, or treatments to reduce the proportion of methanogenetic microbes, perhaps by vaccination.[39][40]

Cattle are fed a concentrated high-corn diet which produces rapid weight gain, but this has side effects which include increased acidity in the digestive system. When improperly handled, manure and other byproducts of concentrated agriculture also have environmental consequences.[41]

Grazing by cattle at low intensities can create a favourable environment for native herbs and forbs; however, in most world regions cattle are reducing biodiversity due to overgrazing driven by food demands by an expanding human population.[42]
 
Two problems with that:

1) it's only telling a partial story (but hey, why stop now?)

2) the choice is not continued current use or complete eradication.

1) I'm sure there are more facets, you could write thousands of pages about the positive and negative effects of the way we raise animals. This UN commission found the net impact to be overwhelmingly negative. If you have evidence against these claims of negative impact, or evidence for claims of positive effects that overwhelm the negative, feel free to post.

2) Not in reality, no, it was the hypothetical I was responding to though. In reality, the choices are to cut back meat production/consumption or allow them to continue to exapnd as the human population does. The available data suggests that the more meat we're producing the greater the negative effects, so minimizing meat consumption would be enviromentally positive.
 
Why do I get called "smug" by the guy smugly posting "I don't NEED a reason! I AM RIGHT?!"?

And why should I bother continuing this discussion?
 
Hard-wired anthropomorphism, I think. In general, the more like a human a creature is, the more "rights" (I'm using the term very loosely, perhaps "protections" would be a better word.) I think they should have. And, killing for "fun" is a foreign concept to me and makes me feel a little uneasy, because I can't really imagine enjoying killing anything.

This is the point I was aiming at; this is the point Cain was aiming at. It's what he meant when he talked of "similar circumstances".

What's the difference between "fun" and "enjoying the taste of meat"?
 
Why do I get called "smug" by the guy smugly posting "I don't NEED a reason! I AM RIGHT?!"?

And why should I bother continuing this discussion?

It's not smug to state a fact. I do not need to provide reasons to eat meat simply because it is legal and no one has yet to show that it is immoral.

The second question is a mystery, though, as you aren't really doing very well in convincing any meat eaters to stop eating meat.

Really, you just now equated "fun killing animals" to "enjoying the flavor of meat."
 
Last edited:
The available data suggests that the more meat we're producing the greater the negative effects, so minimizing meat consumption would be enviromentally positive.
I've no problem with addressing the environmental impact of meat consumption.
 
It's not smug to state a fact. I do not need to provide reasons to eat meat simply because it is legal and no one has yet to show that it is immoral.

Repeating, aggressively, not only that you're RIGHT (!) but that you don't even have to explain why you're right would certainly come across as smug in any other topic of debate.

Imagine a hypothetical Iranian: "It's legal to stone homosexuals to death, and NO-ONE has explained why it's wrong!". That's what you sound like, Ken.

The second question is a mystery, though, as you aren't really doing very well in convincing any meat eaters to stop eating meat.

Really, you just now equated "fun killing animals" to "enjoying the flavor of meat."

No, I equated "fun" with "taste" and asked for the difference between the two.

If it's wrong to kill an animal for fun (to satiate one particular whim), on what basis can killing for the satiation of a similar whim be justified?

The answer to this question requires either that you explain why "taste" is not the same thing as "fun", or that meat eating has a positive case above any beyond killing for kicks. Either would be a starting point for a meaningful discussion.
 
This is the point I was aiming at; this is the point Cain was aiming at. It's what he meant when he talked of "similar circumstances".
I didn't think it fair to pull you into an argument with Cain but if you are going to defend him then I'm going to say that there is scant little argument to his posts. He mostly makes assertions and belittles others.
 
The answer to this question requires either that you explain why "taste" is not the same thing as "fun", or that meat eating has a positive case above any beyond killing for kicks. Either would be a starting point for a meaningful discussion.
I'm not convinced on this idea of "purely for taste". Animal products are a good source of nutrition (I'm attending a nutrition class at UCLA at the moment). They provide dense and complete protein and a wide rante vitamins and nutrients that are easily absorbed by the body when they are eaten. Further, animal products provide not only taste but they are also very satisfying. A vegan diet is drudgery and unsatisfying for many of us. I just don't like it. Animals provide me a nutritious and satisfying meal and provides a sense of well being.

In return, in return, I give them the opportunity to live and to be free from predators and exposure to the elements on a day to day basis. The don't have to be stressed due to hunger or thirst. They can enjoy relatively good lives compared to their wild counterparts. I hate to argue ad nauseam but you won't respond to me.

How clever of wild sheep to have acquired that most versatile adaptation, the shepherd! By forming a symbiotic alliance with Homo sapiens, sheep could outsource their chief survival tasks: food finding and predator avoidance. --Dan Dennet
 
Last edited:
I didn't think it fair to pull you into an argument with Cain but if you are going to defend him then I'm going to say that there is scant little argument to his posts. He mostly makes assertions and belittles others.

Seriously, I agree he's beligerent. But *read* between the belligerence. There's a keen intellect and a razor-sharp argument.

If you don't want to do that, argue with me instead. I make the same points, more politely.

So, the point stands. I contend (and Cain would contend) that killing a duck for fun is a similar act to killing a cow for the taste of its flesh.

Would you disagree? Well, I know you'd disagree - on what grounds? Is "taste" not a type of fun?
 
Seriously, I agree he's beligerent. But *read* between the belligerence. There's a keen intellect and a razor-sharp argument.

If you don't want to do that, argue with me instead. I make the same points, more politely.

So, the point stands. I contend (and Cain would contend) that killing a duck for fun is a similar act to killing a cow for the taste of its flesh.

Would you disagree? Well, I know you'd disagree - on what grounds? Is "taste" not a type of fun?

Look, everyone! An equivocating strawman!
 
Repeating, aggressively, not only that you're RIGHT (!) but that you don't even have to explain why you're right would certainly come across as smug in any other topic of debate.

Imagine a hypothetical Iranian: "It's legal to stone homosexuals to death, and NO-ONE has explained why it's wrong!". That's what you sound like, Ken.



No, I equated "fun" with "taste" and asked for the difference between the two.

If it's wrong to kill an animal for fun (to satiate one particular whim), on what basis can killing for the satiation of a similar whim be justified?

The answer to this question requires either that you explain why "taste" is not the same thing as "fun", or that meat eating has a positive case above any beyond killing for kicks. Either would be a starting point for a meaningful discussion.

Let me take a stab at the difference between shooting an animal because it's fun and eating an animal because it tastes good.

When you eat a non-organic tomato, there are pesticides used that kill bugs, the industrial harvesters invariably kill many more bugs, and other livestock. When the land was cleared for the farm, many more animals were killed. In the processing plant, rats are killed in traps to keep them away from the tomatoes. Emissions from the processing plant and all the vehicles, and runoff of the pesticides into rivers are part of more environmental damage and more deaths. In order for you to have the joy of eating that tomato, animals died.

When you eat a steak, there are all the same things, pesticides, land clearing, and in addition the life of the the cow. Your enjoyment of the steak required a certain share in the killing of the cow and all the other life forms.

When I kill something for pleasure, generally you only kill those animals directly, maybe you contribute a little bit driving out there, by getting some flies on your windshield.

The difference between eating a steak and shooting an animal? One of degree. Eating the steak makes you only responsible for one smaller share of an animals death as opposed to one action/one death. Eating the steak also puts a level of abstraction between your pleasure and the death.

But eating the tomato is just a matter of degree as well, your share in the deaths is a little smaller (although more pesticides are involved) you are a little more distant from the deaths, and at least conceptually, you can more easily choose not to think about them.

Of course, if you grew the tomato yourself or bought it from a small farmer, you may reduce your culpability even more.

Bottom line, any participation in industialized food production has blood of animals on it's hands. The difference between killing an animal for fun and eating a steak is similar to the difference between eating a steak or eating a supermarket tomato.
 
Seriously, I agree he's beligerent. But *read* between the belligerence. There's a keen intellect and a razor-sharp argument.
Little if any argument. Seriously. I've outlined paragraph by paragraph and have time and again only found rhetoric. But that's fine. I just wanted to make the point. We can disagree.

If you don't want to do that, argue with me instead. I make the same points, more politely.
If I could get you to respond to me I would. I sure have been trying.

So, the point stands. I contend (and Cain would contend) that killing a duck for fun is a similar act to killing a cow for the taste of its flesh.

Would you disagree? Well, I know you'd disagree - on what grounds? Is "taste" not a type of fun?
Well, what do you mean by "for fun"? The fun of seeing it die? I percieve that as disturbing and repulsive. But that I'm sure is a result of natural and or social indoctrination. What objective basis do I have to rule that it is imoral to do so? Is there any reason to even consider the point (I'm not saying there isn't, I'm just trying to flesh out the argument)?

What IS our base premise? Here is where Kevin and Cain would stop the discussion, put their fingers in their ears and scream "natural fallacy" even though I'm willing to explore the extent of that argument. They don't want to go there.

So, if we rule out evolved adaptive behaviors and social mores, what is our base premise?
 
I'm not convinced on this idea of "purely for taste". Animal products are a good source of nutrition (I'm attending a nutrition class at UCLA at the moment). They provide dense and complete protein and a wide rante vitamins and nutrients that are easily absorbed by the body when they are eaten. Further, animal products provide not only taste but they are also very satisfying. A vegan diet is drudgery and unsatisfying for many of us. I just don't like it. Animals provide me a nutritious and satisfying meal and provides a sense of well being.

Is "I just don't like the alternative" an argument you'd use in defense of any other action that was demonstrably harmful and which had excellent alternatives should one choose?

I doubt it. That's at the core of this issue, RF. Somehow, you want me to believe (and you need to believe yourself) that the taste of chicken is so sublime, so amazing, so wonderful, that it overwhelms every other sense in your body, and trumps your rationality such that you defend it in ways you would deem ridiculous if similar arguments were offered for any other cause.

Is chicken really that awesome? That harming the environment for no benefit other than the satiation of your taste-buds, and the killing of a sentient animal for no other reason than you get your kicks as a result of the action, is worth every mouthful of factory-processed, water-filled, adulterated sausage-meat you chow down on? Seriously?

The more I think about it, the more meat-eating seems like sadism. Can you explain to me where I'm going wrong?

In return, in return, I give them the opportunity to live and to be free from predators and exposure to the elements on a day to day basis. The don't have to be stressed due to hunger or thirst. They can enjoy relatively good lives compared to their wild counterparts. I hate to argue ad nauseam but you won't respond to me.

We've covered this. Over and over. It's a bad argument. You are not rescuing food animals from anything. You are raising them to harm them, and causing environmental damage to boot. It's not an altruistic action, because you cannot act altruistically towards something that does not exist.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom