Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

People, the tone of this thread is getting increasingly nasty. Please keep it civil.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LibraryLady

Could it be because the issue is so emotionally based?

The bottom line line is humans are omnivores as evidenced by certain teeth they are born with and to deny that fact is the result of inserting artificial thinking into the equation.
 
Morality is a cost/benefit trade-off.
I like that. Trade-off. If life is itself a benifit then I give that to the animal (as you note it wouldn't exist otherwise). On top of that I give it day to day protection from predators, the elements, health care and plenty of food.

In return it gives me food.

Seems like a pretty damn good trade-off to me.

How clever of wild sheep to have acquired that most versatile adaptation, the shepherd! By forming a symbiotic alliance with Homo sapiens, sheep could outsource their chief survival tasks: food finding and predator avoidance. --Dan Dennett
 
It's about context, and, crucially, consistency. Not about stratification. If a herd of cows was invading your home and you had no other way to remove them, then killing the cows becomes morally tenable.

Could you take a few minutes to answer my last post to you ?

Thanks :

Huh ? It's the same for abortion: if they couldn't pick an arbitrary line at which abortion was no longer legal then they never would've come up with the damn law. You're trying to make a case for an objective reason why one should or shouldn't eat this and that. It better be well-defined.



Your criterion is incompatible with your claim, Volatile. That's all I'm saying. If you think that taking down an argument for your claim is a claim for mine (assuming I had one) then you don't know much about skepticism.



Sure thing, Vol. And not collecting stamps is a hobby.



How so ? Because you rob the being of its interest in living ? It that's why then again you are being inconsistent because this AGAIN applies to plants and mushrooms. And bacteria.



I don't want to kill my kitten (if I had one) and it's not legal to do so for such a reason. I don't like killing or hurting animals (except bugs), because it's simply not something I do. I also do not like killing or damaging plants, but I eat them, too.



No, I'm happy to pay other people to do it for me.



No, I'm not. You are incapable of differentiating between a counter-argument against YOUR claim and an argument for MY claim. It's exactly the same thing yrreg is doing in the other thread, thinking that just because we don't know how the universe came into being then it MUST be god who did it.

I was saying that the harm of farming animals, to the animals themselves, is less than the harm said animal would endure in the wild. I'm saying that there is no harm in farming animals that are otherwise well-treated.



Such as ?



Broken record:

You're still not getting it. I don't need to justify myself to you. YOU are making a claim that eating meat is WRONG. YOU need to justify yourself.
 
f
As I have said earlier, it's not my goal, nor is it necessary, to espouse a comprehensive moral doctrine as most moral outlooks already possess the mechanisms to find meat eating problematic.

If you don't want to show people that meat eating is wrong, and instead, want people to justify their eating of meat to you, then I'm done talking at you. Your trying to convince me by telling me to prove that I'm right. Sorry, but that type of trickery won't work and it's not even close to being convincing.
 
Could it be because the issue is so emotionally based?

Exactemundo!

The bottom line line is humans are omnivores as evidenced by certain teeth they are born with and to deny that fact is the result of inserting artificial thinking into the equation.

You know that this will end in crying, don't you?

We will go through all the arguments for and against, then we will go against all the for and against about each of the for and against, and in the end?

People calling each other names over it and nobody convinced.
 
Hey Belz... I'll try and get to your post in the morning. To be honest, I feel like we're going round in circles at the moment.
 
Cain's explained this already, if you'd care to read his posts:

I find Cain's posts rather tedious to read so I usually end up skimming them.

"If it is wrong to cause harm to animals under certain circumstances, then it is wrong to cause harm under all similar circumstances."

So, in other words, yes, it is less immoral to kill cattle than humans. If we have less moral obligation to invertebrates because they have less consciousness than mammals, then we have less obligation towards cattle since they have less consciousness than humans.

It's about context, and, crucially, consistency. Not about stratification. If a herd of cows was invading your home and you had no other way to remove them, then killing the cows becomes morally tenable.

I agree about context, but I just don't see where consistency between species is crucial, or even desirable. Different species are, well, different on a fundemental biological level. They have different wants, needs, and levels of understanding. What is cruel to one may be indifferent or even desirable to another.

Morality is a cost/benefit trade-off. Always. And as the costs of meat-eating are demonstrable and the benefits spurious, I don't see those who eat meat have a case, really.

Thing is, cattle don't really understand or value life. In rearing cattle for meat, we are exchanging things that cattle do value, freedom from pain and fear and hunger and the chance to reproduce, for something they don't. Out of this exchange, we get hamburgers.

It is, to the extent that we hold up our end, a mutually beneficial relationship.
 
Last edited:
Volatile, what happened to the "logical progression of less is zero" argument? Are you going to use that one again?
 
So, Ken - if you don't accept that in this context, the logical end point of "less" is "zero", I hope you're willing to follow that line of thinking through:

1) You accept that eating meat is harmful,
2) You accept that in light of this, we should eat less meat.
3) As you do not accept that the logical end point of an obligation to eat less meat is an argument to eat no meat at all, you must then propose that at some point, eating less meat becomes more harmful.
4) Therefore: there's a minimum amount of meat, beyond which the harm caused by a meat-eating diet is mitigated by some greater harm.

So, what's that greater harm? Please do tell.
 
Last edited:
So do I. Perhaps we could focus on a single point of contention and stick to that.

OK.

Let's narrow down this argument about "similar circumstances". To do that, let me start with an unambiguous question.

Are you opposed to someone killing animals for fun? That is, are you opposed to, for example, á kid going down to the local park and kicking ducks to death, because it gives him a thrill?

If you are - and I note that there are laws against this act in my country, so it would not be surprising if you were - might I ask you to explain why?

After that's clarified, we can hopefully demonstrate what Cain and I mean.
 
Last edited:
So, Ken - if you don't accept that in this context, the logical end point of "less" is "zero", I hope you're willing to follow that line of thinking through:

1) You accept that eating meat is harmful,
2) As you do not accept that the logical end point of an obligation to eat less meat is an argument to eat no meat at all, you must then propose that at some point, eating less meat becomes more harmful.
3) Therefore: there's a minimum amount of meat, beyond which the harm caused by a meat-eating diet is mitigated by some greater harm.

So, what's that greater harm? Please do tell.

1. Eating meat is not harmful. There are, however, ecological ramifications to raising the livestock, too much livestock.

2. It makes no sense that the logical progression of eating less meat is to eat none. This also doesn't mean that I propose that eating less meat becomes more harmful at some point.

3. Your premises are false, therefore your conclusion cannot be logically sound.
 
Hmmm...

I'm about to go to a pet store and buy a rat to feed to my boa contrictor, and it occured to me that were I the rat, I would not want to wind up in the coils of a large snake.

However, were I a large snake, I would very much like to eat.

So, which is the moral choice?
 
Your trying to convince me by telling me to prove that I'm right.

Wouldn't you ask anyone else making a claim on this forum to "prove they're right"?

Yes, you would. It's not "trickery" - and it is perhaps rather illuminating as to just how unconsidered and unsceptical your dietary choices are that you would think it was.

Why is your diet the only topic beyond reproach? And what would you say if someone offered this response to you in any other discourse on this forum?
 
Hmmm...

I'm about to go to a pet store and buy a rat to feed to my boa contrictor, and it occured to me that were I the rat, I would not want to wind up in the coils of a large snake.

However, were I a large snake, I would very much like to eat.

So, which is the moral choice?

You tell me. You're the one who has to make it.
 
Wouldn't you ask anyone else making a claim on this forum to "prove they're right"?

Only if they made absurd claims. If someone says "the sun is hot", for example, I would not ask them to prove it.

The claim that eating meat is wrong is absurd and, seems to be, not based on any real logical reason. In essence, prove that eating meat is wrong. I do not need to justify eating meat to you.
 
1. Eating meat is not harmful. There are, however, ecological ramifications to raising the livestock, too much livestock.

Ken - explain to me how, with current technology, you can eat meat without raising livestock. :rolleyes:

2. It makes no sense that the logical progression of eating less meat is to eat none. This also doesn't mean that I propose that eating less meat becomes more harmful at some point.

No, it really does.

If you think less meat is less harmful than some meat, but that zero meat is not the least harmful option, it logically follows that at some point between "some" and "zero" there is a point at which eating less meat becomes more harmful. What's that point?

It's a silly argument, sure, but it's your argument. Follow it through, or discard it.

3. Your premises are false, therefore your conclusion cannot be logically sound.

My premises are that the less meat you eat, the more ecologically-sound your diet. This is backed up by scientific fact, and scientific fact you agreed with. That's the premise.

You want to argue that at some point, this observation becomes false; that is, at some point before meat consumption falls to zero, there is a point at which to reduce meat consumption becomes more harmful. You're arguing that there is a minimum amount of meat that it is morally obligatory we all eat, to avoid harms.

It's a silly argument, but it's your argument.

What's that point, Ken?
 
I know these weren't addressed to me, but I'm going to stick my nose in and answer anyway.:p

3) As you do not accept that the logical end point of an obligation to eat less meat is an argument to eat no meat at all, you must then propose that at some point, eating less meat becomes more harmful.

Alternatively, there could be a point where the "harms" are sufficiently reduced so as to no longer be a concern (or to be sufficiently balanced by taste, convenience, etc.). At which point, there would be no need to continue reducing meat consumption further.


Are you opposed to someone killing animals for fun? That is, are you opposed to, for example, á kid going down to the local park and kicking ducks to death, because it gives him a thrill?

I might have a problem with him/her kicking the ducks to death, but I wouldn't have a problem with him/her killing ants in the same circumstances. A duck's life is worth more to me than an ant's.
 
Only if they made absurd claims. If someone says "the sun is hot", for example, I would not ask them to prove it.

But they could prove it, and easily.

Why can't you? Why can't you even ARGUE it? You don't even have a BAD case. You don't have a case at all.

The claim that eating meat is wrong is absurd and, seems to be, not based on any real logical reason. In essence, prove that eating meat is wrong. I do not need to justify eating meat to you.

I claim that eating meat causes demonstrable harms, and that in the lack of a positive case to support it, it should be eschewed. The lack of a positive case is entirely the problem.

So - what's the positive case? It's as obvious as "the sun is hot", right?
 
Alternatively, there could be a point where the "harms" are sufficiently reduced so as to no longer be a concern (or to be sufficiently balanced by taste, convenience, etc.). At which point, there would be no need to continue reducing meat consumption further.

Firstly, that doesn't negate my point - Ken was mocking me (!) for arguing that the end point of harm reduction is zero meat consumption. Even if the harms were negligible, my point would still hold - so it can't have been what Ken meant.

Secondly, your "sufficiently balanced" would require a case to be made for meat eating.

Thirdly, I would suggest that for this hypothetical point to be reached, most people would need to go more or less vegan ANYWAY, and eat meat only sparsely. This is clearly not acceptable to posters in this thread, as meat eating is so awesome, so the case to eat meat beyond this point still needs to be made.

Fourthly - what's that point?


I might have a problem with him/her kicking the ducks to death, but I wouldn't have a problem with him/her killing ants in the same circumstances. A duck's life is worth more to me than an ant's.

Good.

Why? What is the source of your "problem"? What do you find objectionable about a kid kicking a duck to death?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom