Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

WTF is a moral difference? I care less about non-human species because they don't even have the potential to become as sapient as humans, in general. The more sapient an animal, the more I care about it's welfare, but I understand that is just irrational anthropomorphism. Your problem is that you seem to want to equate non-humans with humans when it comes to killing and eating them, but why not in all other ways then? Are pets merely slaves to humans that need to be emancipated? Is it wrong to exterminate a nest of ants squatting in your home? You seem to think you have a rational morality, which makes your morality even more irrational.

Try proving your morality is correct before telling me that my morality is wrong. Prove to me that eating meat is wrong.
 
It's interesting how Belz repeats RandFan's six questions

Aside from the fact that I actually didn't repeat any of the questions, what's even more interesting is how you jump to Kevin's defense.

But let's compare this to Volatile's question "how do you justify eating meat?"

That's a crucial question ? How do you justify driving a car ? How do you justify using plastic ? How do you justify killing bugs ?

I think it's been made clear in this thread that one needs to point out why it is wrong to do so. Of course, I haven't seen that one quoted much by either you or Kevin.

Or the oft-asked question, "is it wrong to torture animals?"

Which has nothing to do with eating them.

Or, perhaps the most crucial question of all (for this topic) "what are the morally significant differences between animals and humans?"

... or plants.
 
This sounds like a faithful representation of my views, but "some" and "all" have a potential for confusion. If it is wrong to cause harm to animals under certain circumstances, then it is wrong to cause harm under all similar circumstances. What's normally disputed is whether or not the circumstances REALLY ARE similar, but first we must establish values (i.e., it's wrong to cause harm under CERTAIN circumstances).

That's no different than what I said, you just lawyered it up a bit.

GreNME said:
My criticism is that we don't even apply things this way solely in the domain of human beings, so he needs to provide a justification for furthering such an application equally across the board to all animals.
I'm not clear on what you mean; an example would help. Are you saying something like, "people treat other PEOPLE like ****, so how can we expect to be kind to animals when we're killing our own?"

No, that's not what I'm saying, but it's certainly rhetorically easier for you to point out error if it were. What I'm saying is three-fold: 1) that there are dispensations for humans to justifiably cause harm to other humans, in some cases to the degree of taking their lives, admittedly often in seemingly arbitrary ways, so what you demand be applied across the board to animals doesn't make sense in that context; 2) that the cases where rights are applied across the board with humans requires an agreement (either implicit or explicit) on both sides, with consequences applicable should one side disregard the agreement; 3) that in cases where rights might be conferred to a human party unable to agree, there are 3rd parties that stand in as surrogates or guardians until such time that they are able to agree, and in some cases where this remains an impossibility those rights are either severely curtailed or can be removed completely (Schiavo case as an extreme example), so there is no absolute guarantee for human cases where one party is unable to agree.

Nothing you've argued, Cain, addresses all three of those points with regard to establishing the proposed 'immorality' of eating meat, and most certainly has not mitigated the case that all animals are to be afforded the same level of rights as humans. Indeed, the argument of eating meat as a moral issue diverges from the more general 'animal rights' issue because it pre-supposes rights from the start that are not implicitly or explicitly present in any agreeable format (per the conditions I've pointed out). So, while you've attempted in this thread and the other one to use part (or all) of the 'animal rights' arguments to lead inexorably to the proposed 'immorality' of eating meat, you've never adequately established the (to use your word for it) universality of rights in the first place because a) you can't even do so for the human species alone, and b) you're jumping past that hurdle into a more broad issue in order to work backward from a conclusion. None of your arguments place a non-meat diet into morally positive territory while placing meat-eating diets into morally negative territory-- they still remain morally neutral regardless.

And in case you're interested: yes, I do fully believe that there are cases where human beings have forfeited their rights, even the right to life, depending primarily on the relative conditions of the situation and the context of the values I (and others, if applicable) bring to the situation. This allows for different measures of prioritization for survival in the most general of senses, though it can be measured in specific instances like when a doctor must choose between two patients who are dying or when a rescue worker (fireman, EMS, disaster recovery, etc.) must choose which people in equally treacherous conditions to save first. It's a form of social pragmatism that relies on the conditions at hand-- essentially the moral relativism RandFan and I have spoken of numerous times in this thread-- in order to operate, and the only real constant is that the values are relative to the conditions and not to any absolutes, whether called 'objective' or 'universal' or whatever other descriptor that can be thought up.

Additionally, not a single part of that contradicts or opposes the decision by someone to eat a vegan or vegetarian diet, because both qualify as being just as morally neutral as a diet consisting of meat. Were I attempting to make a case against such a diet, then your accusation of moral inconsistency might be applicable unless I had some kind of compelling argument against, which is in no way at all having anything to do with the arguments I've put forth. The only one condemning, Cain, is yourself, which is why you are the one carrying the burden to justify it and why constantly demanding I justify something I consider morally neutral is evasion of producing a working argument on your part.
 
It's interesting how Belz repeats RandFan's six questions (and RandFan even brags they come from a textbook). It does not occur to either the relevance of a generic questionnaire is off in tangent land.
You are the king of evasion and obfuscation. As if declaring that it is a tangent is an answer. As if bald assertion somehow obviates logical and reasoned argument.


Here's a hint: It's not.

But let's compare this to Volatile's question "how do you justify eating meat?"
I don't need to justify eating meat. That isn't to say that I'm not happy to have a discussion in the abstract.


Or the oft-asked question, "is it wrong to torture animals?"
AKA a straw man.

Or, perhaps the most crucial question of all (for this topic) "what are the morally significant differences between animals and humans?" If any of these get traction for even a moment...
Then you and Kevin will obfuscate, dissemble, engage in personal attack, made bald assertion, claim to have responded and do everything in your power to avoid the arguments made.


OK then, why do such people only bother announcing their beliefs in these threads?
The same reason we announce our beliefs in other threads about ID or the Westborough Baptist types, we don't care much for smug self righteousness that seeks to demonize those with different opinions. Because PETA and their sycophants are so goddamn bloody stupid.


Similarly, it's interesting how the "It's OK to eat meat" tribe will align itself with moral skeptics when, fundamentally, they share more in common with vegans.
Moral skepticism doesn't equate to immorality.
 
Last edited:
I laughed out loud. We're having this argument about consistency and universal morality and then you -- you -- report me for incivility.

Yup. The mod post was my demarcation line. Had it not been there, I would have gladly continued. But you can not deny the fact it is there, can you?


This is probably greatest thing you've ever done, and the greatest thing you will ever do. Remember it for as long as you can.
Why? As I said, you have no clue as to what my life entails. Discussions on this board are but a way to pass time and get some entertainment before I go to bed.

With that said, it's a shame you insist on continuing as we could have ended on a high note.
Now we will never know, will we?

It's difficult to quote your single line comments, so with regard to 'reasons' 1-3:

I was commenting on two of your posts, one a reply (or "reply") to me that contained nothing in the way of an argument;

it was a series of insults, which is great because I'm saved keystrokes, and I gave it the response it deserved.

Huh?

This is what it said:
- There are no natural rights. Defining this even further; there is no such thing as a right at all.

Clarification on my standpoint:

- A right is an activity, process or possession (material or immaterial) that can not be taken away from the entity that has such a right.
- The activity of granting or depriving of a right needs either consensus, pressure or enforcement.
- If a second entity neither succumbs to consensus, pressure or enforcement whilst depriving a right from the first entity, the right is no longer with the first entity.
The other was your "reply" to Kevin, though my name probably appeared a dozen times for infantile asides, which nicely padded another of your empty contributions. And this was probably the post that triggered intervention from a moderator.

Your reasons 4 & 5 are more than a stretch, the former an appropriate characterization of a misguided argument and the latter goes to your credibility (or would you prefer I insinuate you had relations with a hamster? No, this stings because it's not based on speculation; it's all too true.)
Huh?

See above.

You see nothing wrong with the mistreatment of animals, but you do apparently see something wrong with my earlier reply, a transgression that requires you report it to the authorities and post public notice. Your reasoning is comically ad hoc: the difference between your behavior and mine is that I had (crucially) said things AFTER an admin posted a warning. To you this is significant, but I wonder why you even bother to shield yourself from accusations of hypocrisy since Chomsky and all of the moral universalists are mistaken.

Ah, so you DID see the correct post?

And... it quite proves my point more clearly than any discussion ever could, doesn't it?

I am a hypocrite! There! So what? Does it make me lose any sleep? Nope.

But, wait... stop... hypocrisy would be immoral, wouldn't it?

Then you go on to list things by the sentence. Now, why not report RandFan, who last I checked called me "sad and pathetic." Well, you might say he made only one uncivil remark -- two at the absolute most -- whereas I said -- Christ -- FIVE things. If any of these sort of arguments run through your head as a defense against hypocrisy, then you're reasoning along the lines of impartiality/consistency. Why? You could just report me because you felt like it. Instead you want to help enforce the totally made-up rules -- fashionable nonsense -- in this particular social context. This is surreal, a mini-replay of the Sokal affair.

I do not care much for the Sokal affair. I have no clue what it is, and I am not going to look it up.

But I think I demonstrated quite nicely what I mean (unintenionally, agreed) by putting my personal interests directly above yours, without any regards to the fact that I displayed that same behaviour before the demarcation line.

The social consequence could have been that we both would have gotten a 'slap on the wrist'. But as I thought that risk less and in the event it happening acceptable, I acted upon my personal desire.

"Rational" is not the first word that pops into mind at the mention of "desire" (someone may desire the ability to fly). Regardless, desires/interests -- this is a source of value, and rationally there is no reason why only your desires/interests should count. So in the example you ignored, the one where you eat a human being, you're acting upon a desire for nourishment (and taste), arbitrarily privileging your interests over the victim's.

Rationally, there is also no reason why the communities and/or victim's desire should count.

To get there, you have to go the whole nine yards for 'survival of the species'.

What you keep forgetting is that any given behaviour is effective in a quite small set of circumstances, so any rationality, any attempt to create a global set of rules either waters down to being meaningless for an individual (i.e. the genetic argument) or it is full of discrepancies with local realities.


Obviously I'm a magician. :rolleyes: The problem with this thread, and these discussions in general, is that they quickly devolve into arguments for moral skepticism, which would not be worth mentioning if other threads followed the same pattern of rapid decline. But they don't. Even in arguments over abortion people are capable of producing reasons for and against, attempting to rationally justify their beliefs. In threads such as this one people are all too willing to slice off their own nose, shrieking "NOTHING is wrong!" OK then, why do such people only bother announcing their beliefs in these threads?

Because of the generalizing nature of the OP's. I have NOTHING against vegetarianism, and I am one (with the odd big burger every six weeks apart) for half a year now.

Simply out of respect for the people that I live amongst.

The social consequences make me not kill or eat a dead animal.

If you had not gone through the motions of making it a general inevitability, I would have gladly ignored this thread or even chosen your side.

I hold nothing as a general inevitability, with the exception of growing older and dying.

Any topic remotely related to morality -- levels of taxation, global warming, financial regulation, woman who drowns her kids, faith healing, celebrity murderers, drug addiction, and so on are equally appropriate venues.

Arguments against torturing animals, eating animals, hunting animals, and so on, do not depend upon any one ethical belief system anymore than arguments against rape, murder, and genocide do.* Instead we can appeal to shared values, which leads to the next point on Japanese farmers:

Which other two? The caste system, which you placed aside for this more relevant example?

As I said, you never developed your arguments; brought them to a point. It was like saying "white people dance like *this* whereas black people dance like *this*." I can guess what you meant, but why bother guessing incorrectly? That's like playing a game where I choose a number between one and -- oh, say -- ten million.

Is it 1483827?

It seemed like you were making a fairly common argument, one that observes different cultures have different moral codes, and concludes that there is no universal morality.

It may be true or false that there is no "objective moral truth" or whatever we want to call it, but disagreements alone do not prove it as people disagree over many things: the origins of the universe, the existence of spirits, the possibility of the afterlife, the age of the earth. So this argument for relativism is unsound.

And I would agree with that. Could have stated that earlier. Or clearer.

My point about the caste system is that whilst people here do not have the slightes problem avoiding a cow that is lying on the road, and treating (specific) animals with respect, these same people hold nothing wrong with kicking the dogs in the street or just slapping a poor person because they are a caste lower than they are.

I put some of your arguments in front of them and they said: "Is that man mad? Why shouldn't I slap the poor guy or kick the dog? Both are vermin, as it is widely known."

And so, there is nothing universal about the 'desire' argument.

Isaac Asimov has a famous remark on this point (which I will edit for length):

Some people offer more compelling reasons than others. Had you claimed you reported my post because you were told to do so in a dream, then your argument would not carry as much weight.

Nah, I did it because I never play fair. Actually, whenever I play a social game with my friends, that is about the only thing I am honest about: "Guys, if I can, I will cheat!".

As for the Masai you quoted, again, it's not clear what you think it demonstrates.
Is this supposed to make relativism more compelling because it comes from someone in a farflung culture?
Would you include the argument if it came from your next door neighbor? Yes, the lion does not give consideration to the antelope because, as we have said, animals are not moral agents.
Saying "The strongest thing does what it does" is not saying anything at all.
Tautologies may sound profound when read as subtitles in foreign films, but they do not normally withstand scrutiny.

You missed the fact that it was there to show you that other cultures and other people think differently.

If you try to reconcile all these things then you show that even though you understand and respect someone else, you still can have a difference of opinion.

What I want to happen within your brainpan, as you strike me as not quite dumb at all, is that before you let loose on someone, you first try to understand what it is they want to say.

And maybe try to understand why they want to say what they say.

After that, you can start building up your argument and then, when it heats up with enough counter-force, you can let go with everything you have.


*Maybe you think there is nothing wrong with rape, murder and genocide and that only "social context" matters, or whatever, but this is probably not the most appropriate venue for that view. Worse, it seems sometimes you want to dip one foot in the pool of moral relativism, where it IS possible to appeal to shared moral values.

Nah, I do think there is something wrong with rape, murder and genocide. But afaik there are no rules on the forum that I have to be truthful in my arguments.

I just saw someone who should be shown that experience can kick him in the nuts if he thinks he is too almighty because he knows some stuff.

The social dynamics of polarization in these threads is interesting. Sword earlier quoted a PETA person saying he would not cure all disease in the world if it meant killing a rat.

This is supposed to suggest animal rights people are all crazy.
Well, what if a hard-core Kantian said the same thing about a human being? This comment says more about differences in moral belief systems than it does animal rights.

Similarly, it's interesting how the "It's OK to eat meat" tribe will align itself with moral skeptics when, fundamentally, they share more in common with vegans.

As someone on this forum remarked; I already lived a couple of lifetimes around the world and am not done yet.

I usually try to spend some time with people that are different from me, I have spent at least a week with most major religions, spent some time, as mentioned, with some tribes across the world, spending some time in Asia right now.

Same thing with vegetarians and meat-eaters as well.

You will not see me eating meat if you state your desire when we are in the same social vicinity, but as soon as you try to make it bigger than it is, like for instance, an inevitability dictated by <somesuch> or <other>, then I will oppose you, even though I do not completely stand behind the points I defend.

And one good advise Cain, stop quoting other people. You do not need it. You are eloquent enough on your own, and quoting and naming all these so-called authorities one way or another just makes you seem a prick that needs to be taught a lesson.

Nobody will listen to what you really want to say.
 
Last edited:
Does Lowe actually mean Objectivist morals when he says "objective morals"?

Hmmm. Here is what an Objectivist philosopher has to say:

"Objectivism has nothing to say about it beyond the fact that people are not morally obligated, in principle, not to eat meat; rather, it is up to each person to balance the costs and benefits of eating meat according to the standard of his own life."


http://www.objectivistcenter.org/cth--391-FAQ_Animal_Rights.aspx
 
People, the tone of this thread is getting increasingly nasty. Please keep it civil.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LibraryLady
 
Does Lowe actually mean Objectivist morals when he says "objective morals"?

Hmmm. Here is what an Objectivist philosopher has to say:

"Objectivism has nothing to say about it beyond the fact that people are not morally obligated, in principle, not to eat meat; rather, it is up to each person to balance the costs and benefits of eating meat according to the standard of his own life."


http://www.objectivistcenter.org/cth--391-FAQ_Animal_Rights.aspx

Rand's "objectivism" has as much to do with objectivism as Creation Science has to do with science.
 
So the philosophy that Ayn Rand created has nothing to do with her? How does that work.

Perhaps you're talking about "objectivism" without the capital "O." Strangely, you've yet to actually provide any guidelines or definitions to support this "objectivism" you are championing throughout the thread. Why is that?
 
So the philosophy that Ayn Rand created has nothing to do with her? How does that work.

Perhaps you're talking about "objectivism" without the capital "O." Strangely, you've yet to actually provide any guidelines or definitions to support this "objectivism" you are championing throughout the thread. Why is that?

And he still demands that morality is objective but can't tell us if killing another person is immoral.

He knows that if he says "it depends" then he has just admitted that morality is, to some extent, relative.
 
Seeing as how I feel obligated to almost a half-dozen posts, I will have to prioritize arguments in each.

TBK:
WTF is a moral difference? I care less about non-human species because they don't even have the potential to become as sapient as humans, in general. The more sapient an animal, the more I care about it's welfare, but I understand that is just irrational anthropomorphism.

Even if the potential to become "sapient" plays some role in your thinking, you still have to account for non-human beings with cognitive abilities similar to the humans you think merit welfare considerations, otherwise your position is irrational; morally arbitrary.

As for your questions... no, I do not think people treat pets in a manner remotely similar to slavery, and I probably would exterminate a nest of ants.

Try proving your morality is correct before telling me that my morality is wrong. Prove to me that eating meat is wrong.

As I have said earlier, it's not my goal, nor is it necessary, to espouse a comprehensive moral doctrine as most moral outlooks already possess the mechanisms to find meat eating problematic. What you fail to understand is that while veganism may involve a radical lifestyle change, it does not require a radically new way of thinking. This why questions on animal cruelty are important because most people already accept certain forms of mistreatment as profoundly wrong. Similarly a libertarian can make an argument against police tactics that socialists find compelling; socialists (or conservatives or liberals) are not required to accept libertarian axioms.

------------------
Belz:
Aside from the fact that I actually didn't repeat any of the questions, what's even more interesting is how you jump to Kevin's defense.

I'm sorry, you did not actually make the effort to copy/paste them but instead wrote: "So, are you going to answer the questions, or not ?"

:rolleyes: As for Kevin -- he doesn't need any defending from me. I used your bit of nonsense as jumping off point to highlight my own questions.

I will ignore your questions on plastics and driving -- please don't waste my time.

How do you justify killing bugs ?

I try to avoid killing bugs, but I'm much less uneasy about killing them than vertebrates because they're probably not conscious or capable of feeling pain. Later you ask for differences between plants and humans, which has already been explained, but if you're incapable of remembering, or making basic connections, I can say that it has to do with the capacity to consciousness and the capacity to suffer.

On torturing animals:
Which has nothing to do with eating them.

The question goes to establishing animal cruelty -- that animals can be treated in ways that one finds unacceptable. This has moral implications that are all too relevant.
-----------------------
GreNME-

From this:
My criticism is that we don't even apply things this way solely in the domain of human beings, so he needs to provide a justification for furthering such an application equally across the board to all animals.

I was to somehow deduce something like this:

No, that's not what I'm saying, but it's certainly rhetorically easier for you to point out error if it were. What I'm saying is three-fold: 1) that there are dispensations for humans to justifiably cause harm to other humans, in some cases to the degree of taking their lives, admittedly often in seemingly arbitrary ways, so what you demand be applied across the board to animals doesn't make sense in that context; 2) that the cases where rights are applied across the board with humans requires an agreement (either implicit or explicit) on both sides, with consequences applicable should one side disregard the agreement; 3) that in cases where rights might be conferred to a human party unable to agree, there are 3rd parties that stand in as surrogates or guardians until such time that they are able to agree, and in some cases where this remains an impossibility those rights are either severely curtailed or can be removed completely (Schiavo case as an extreme example), so there is no absolute guarantee for human cases where one party is unable to agree.

Examples for 1) and 2) would help tremendously as what you are saying is far from clear to me. I will with-hold comment instead of guessing what you are trying to say.

yes, I do fully believe that there are cases where human beings have forfeited their rights, even the right to life, depending primarily on the relative conditions of the situation and the context of the values I (and others, if applicable) bring to the situation. This allows for different measures of prioritization for survival in the most general of senses, though it can be measured in specific instances like when a doctor must choose between two patients who are dying or when a rescue worker (fireman, EMS, disaster recovery, etc.) must choose which people in equally treacherous conditions to save first. It's a form of social pragmatism that relies on the conditions at hand-- essentially the moral relativism RandFan and I have spoken of numerous times in this thread-- in order to operate, and the only real constant is that the values are relative to the conditions and not to any absolutes, whether called 'objective' or 'universal' or whatever other descriptor that can be thought up.

Do you remember earlier when you accused me of "moral absolutism," and do how I then proved you completely mistaken? Do I have to do that again? Because I already did it the one time...

-----------------
RandFan:
You are the king of evasion and obfuscation. As if declaring that it is a tangent is an answer. As if bald assertion somehow obviates logical and reasoned argument.

Ah yes, it's good to be king. I like how you sort of think you know what you're doing when it comes to debating, claiming assertion and rhetoric. If a question IS ACTUALLY irrelevant, there are few things one can do to demonstrate it's irrelevant. You want to ask if lying is ever justified, fine. I'm not sure why you have to ask if stealing is ever justified as well, at least in the context of this thread and its central arguments. Asking a list of generic questions head-bangingly silly. Do you have no understanding of dialectics?

Hint: it's not.

I don't need to justify eating meat. That isn't to say that I'm not happy to have a discussion in the abstract.

AKA a straw man.

It's difficult to take you seriously when you say these sort of things. My question "is it OK to torture animals?" is a straw man? Really? This is reminiscent of the things you've said about the naturalistic fallacy and tu quoque, which is to say you have no understanding of what these terms mean.

Moral skepticism doesn't equate to immorality.

I suppose it does not "equate" to immorality, but this is like saying 2 plus 2 is potato -- or, I'm sorry -- "equates" to potato. A moral skeptic can behave in a manner that is moral or immoral, but moral skepticism holds that all moral claims are unjustified, whether we're talking about killing humans or animals.
----------------------
RealPaladin:

Yup. The mod post was my demarcation line. Had it not been there, I would have gladly continued. But you can not deny the fact it is there, can you?

This reminds me of dialog from the film Role Models:

Black kid: Hey Ben Affleck.
White Guy #1: I'm not Ben Affleck.
Black kid: You white, you Ben Affleck.
White Guy #2: You are white.
White Guy #1: That's true, I am white...

Yes, that was your demarcation line. It is there...

As for the "huh"s, I will concede your first reply to me was not simply a series of insults but did contain an irrelevant argument against natural rights.

Rationally, there is also no reason why the communities and/or victim's desire should count.

To get there, you have to go the whole nine yards for 'survival of the species'.

This is not the case at all. The question is why should your interests count for more than your victim's? If you answer "because I'm me, and he's him," then you're not responding in a rational, impartial manner. Ethical egoists who aspire to universalism may claim "survival of the species" or resort to some unwitting form of utilitarianism, but that's symptom of a deeper problem.

My point about the caste system is that whilst people here do not have the slightes problem avoiding a cow that is lying on the road, and treating (specific) animals with respect, these same people hold nothing wrong with kicking the dogs in the street or just slapping a poor person because they are a caste lower than they are.

I put some of your arguments in front of them and they said: "Is that man mad? Why shouldn't I slap the poor guy or kick the dog? Both are vermin, as it is widely known."

And so, there is nothing universal about the 'desire' argument.

Do you see the fallacy here? Has it been demonstrated that dogs are "vermin"? These are unexamined cultural beliefs. My mother used to regal me with stories about her epic trip to India, and "widely known" beliefs that were mere superstitions.

I'm not sure how this undermines the "desire" argument. Dogs in India still do not like to be kicked, whales off the coast of Japan do not like to be harpooned. If people from lower castes do like being slapped, then they should not be slapped.

You missed the fact that it was there to show you that other cultures and other people think differently.

If you try to reconcile all these things then you show that even though you understand and respect someone else, you still can have a difference of opinion.

Well, thank you, but I already knew people in different cultures think differently. People in the same culture think differently. People living in the same house, igloo or tepee think differently. One of the only virtues of moral relativism is that it at least imparts an appreciation of tolerance.
 
You want to ask if lying is ever justified, fine. I'm not sure why you have to ask if stealing is ever justified as well, at least in the context of this thread and its central arguments. Asking a list of generic questions head-bangingly silly. Do you have no understanding of dialectics?
So you CAN'T answer the questions? You claim there is such a thing as objective morality and I ask you if killing another person is objectively immoral and you ask me if I understand dialectics? Yes. And?

Dialectics is a form of reasoning the purpose of which, in part, is to draw out contradiction and inconsistency. It doesn't work when one of two people in a discussion/debate refuses to answer questions.

I've asked you if killing another person is objectively immoral.

You could answer, yes, no or it depends. That would be an honest answer. But, in case you haven't figured it out yet, refusing to answer isn't part of the dialectical process.

It's difficult to take you seriously when you say these sort of things. My question "is it OK to torture animals?" is a straw man? Really?
Given that no one is advocating the torture of animals, yeah, really.

A moral skeptic can behave in a manner that is moral or immoral, but moral skepticism holds that all moral claims are unjustified, whether we're talking about killing humans or animals.
Moral skepticism does not hold *necessarily that all moral claims are false (yes, you said "unjustified" i'm just trying to clarify) only that there is no objective means to verify that they are true. Further, moral skepticism does not preclude one from behaving in a manner that is consistent with societal mores or ethics nor does it preclude one from reasoning rules of behavior to further goals such as social cohesion and those that spring from our innate sense of morality (empathy, compassion reciprocal altruism).

*There are three forms of moral skpeticism.
 
Last edited:
This is not the case at all. The question is why should your interests count for more than your victim's? If you answer "because I'm me, and he's him," then you're not responding in a rational, impartial manner. Ethical egoists who aspire to universalism may claim "survival of the species" or resort to some unwitting form of utilitarianism, but that's symptom of a deeper problem.

As long as you can not get your point across except in a 'from A follows B' manner, you are getting nowhere, and judging by the length of this thread, not fast at all.

It does not matter if you call it a 'problem' or Humbug or bibbedybobbedy, people will not be convinced by rational arguments in this matter.

I am trying to convince you that if you think rationally about this issue, you should understand that IN the issue itself, rational arguments amount to very little.

If your cause is to convince people that 'doing harm to animals is not really ok' then you are doing not a very good job.

If your cause is to make all the philosophical lines a lot clearer about a specific philosophical view on the world, then you are just keeping yourself busy.

I have gathered from the onset that both sides have more or less dug in and will now confabulate like world champions to just not lose the argument.

But nothing is gained by 'not losing the argument'.


Do you see the fallacy here? Has it been demonstrated that dogs are "vermin"? These are unexamined cultural beliefs. My mother used to regal me with stories about her epic trip to India, and "widely known" beliefs that were mere superstitions.

Yes, it is not a fallacy, it is the *whole* point here. They *are* superstitions and no more.

But you are just managing to make a sermon to your own choir that they are that, when looked at rationally.

A rational person can see that these people will not listen to rational arguments and will chose something different, something that does work.

I'm not sure how this undermines the "desire" argument. Dogs in India still do not like to be kicked, whales off the coast of Japan do not like to be harpooned.

Exactly! But is it rational to try and have a rational discussion about it with the people who do like to kick and the people who do like to eat the whale? No.

Use your reasoning to create your own firm base, then get into their heads and use their terminology, superstition or beliefs.

If people from lower castes do like being slapped, then they should not be slapped.
That is just plain cruel! :p



Well, thank you, but I already knew people in different cultures think differently. People in the same culture think differently. People living in the same house, igloo or tepee think differently. One of the only virtues of moral relativism is that it at least imparts an appreciation of tolerance.

Do not just 'know' it. Use it.

My physics teacher used to say: "People are like magnets in a coil, move them and you get resistance." (horribly shortened, so don't get pedantic, you do get the gist).

People never really care if someone is right or wrong, they care if someone can move them without a natural resistance.

Find out what moves other people.
 
As for Kevin -- he doesn't need any defending from me. I used your bit of nonsense as jumping off point to highlight my own questions.

If you think asking somebody to answer a question is nonsense it's no wonder you have a hard time understanding the discussion, here.

will ignore your questions on plastics and driving -- please don't waste my time.

They were very serious questions, and if you can't answer them you might see why your own question was ridiculous. That is, of course, if you didn't think asking somebody to answer a question was nonsensical.
 
Cain, we've already been over this. Also, I don't care if you call it absolute or universal or whatever, you're simply lawyering up your language at this point to use a whole lot of words to say nothing or provoke. Be clear about what you don't understand and I'll see if I can clarify. I'm not going to play guessing games trying to figure out what it is you're seeking.
 
They were very serious questions, and if you can't answer them you might see why your own question was ridiculous. That is, of course, if you didn't think asking somebody to answer a question was nonsensical.
For Cain the dialectical process works in one directions. From his mouth to your ear.
 
Sorry, didn't spot these at first.

I try to avoid killing bugs, but I'm much less uneasy about killing them than vertebrates because they're probably not conscious or capable of feeling pain.

I don't know, that ant seems to writhe pretty much like it's feeling pain.

Later you ask for differences between plants and humans, which has already been explained, but if you're incapable of remembering, or making basic connections, I can say that it has to do with the capacity to consciousness and the capacity to suffer.

I do remember. In fact you don't seem to remember me acknowledging that. However several animals share this characteristic with plants. Also, I find it quite suspect to use that criterion because then if you will an animal without causing any suffering then you should be OK with eating meat. Since this doesn't seem to be the case one has to ask: what other criteria are you using ? If it's the "right to live", then plants should have it too.

The question goes to establishing animal cruelty -- that animals can be treated in ways that one finds unacceptable. This has moral implications that are all too relevant.

Indeed, but it still has nothing to do with torture. Killing something is not torture. Killing is not cruelty. Otherwise killing plants is cruelty, as well, because the actual killing doesn't cause pain.

I'm simply asking for a logically consistent set of criteria as to why killing animals for sustenance is wrong.
 
Cruelty to bugs is less immoral than cruelty to cattle?

So, how is it hard to understand that cruelty to cattle is less immoral than cruelty to humans?
 
Cruelty to bugs is less immoral than cruelty to cattle?

So, how is it hard to understand that cruelty to cattle is less immoral than cruelty to humans?

Cain's explained this already, if you'd care to read his posts:

"If it is wrong to cause harm to animals under certain circumstances, then it is wrong to cause harm under all similar circumstances."

It's about context, and, crucially, consistency. Not about stratification. If a herd of cows was invading your home and you had no other way to remove them, then killing the cows becomes morally tenable.

Morality is a cost/benefit trade-off. Always. And as the costs of meat-eating are demonstrable and the benefits spurious, I don't see those who eat meat have a case, really.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom