It's interesting how Belz repeats RandFan's six questions (and RandFan even brags they come from a textbook). It does not occur to either the relevance of a generic questionnaire is off in tangent land. But let's compare this to Volatile's question "how do you justify eating meat?" Or the oft-asked question, "is it wrong to torture animals?" Or, perhaps the most crucial question of all (for this topic) "what are the morally significant differences between animals and humans?" If any of these get traction for even a moment opponents of animal rights will say they have been tricked, or "suckered" or boxed into an unfair position.
---------------
TBK:
No, I don't. I've always held the position that the less sapient a life form, the less "rights" it has. Children are not as sapient as adults, that's a huge part of why they have less rights than adults in society. There is no inconsistency here, but you insist on seeing one anyway. Cain, you are not going to trick me into becoming vegan. Why don't you present an argument against eating meat instead of trying to trick me?
Trick you? The comparison is not between children and adults; as I said earlier, your distinction there makes sense. You encounter problems when we introduce animals into the mix because you have to demonstrate significant moral differences.
-----------------------
GreNME:
In Cain's defense, his justification for why eating meat is wrong is that if someone is against the torture or causing any harm to some animals, that this should be applied equally across the board to all animals.
This sounds like a faithful representation of my views, but "some" and "all" have a potential for confusion. If it is wrong to cause harm to animals under certain circumstances, then it is wrong to cause harm under all similar circumstances. What's normally disputed is whether or not the circumstances REALLY ARE similar, but first we must establish values (i.e., it's wrong to cause harm under CERTAIN circumstances).
My criticism is that we don't even apply things this way solely in the domain of human beings, so he needs to provide a justification for furthering such an application equally across the board to all animals.
I'm not clear on what you mean; an example would help. Are you saying something like, "people treat other PEOPLE like ****, so how can we expect to be kind to animals when we're killing our own?"
-------------------
RealPaladin:
Cain, I simply had it with you. Reported you for your inability to stay civil after a warning.
I laughed
out loud. We're having this argument about consistency and universal morality and then you --
you -- report
me for incivility. This is probably greatest thing you've ever done, and the greatest thing you will ever do. Remember it for as long as you can.
With that said, it's a shame you insist on continuing as we could have ended on a high note.
It's difficult to quote your single line comments, so with regard to 'reasons' 1-3: I was commenting on two of your posts, one a reply (or "reply") to me that contained nothing in the way of an argument; it was a series of insults, which is great because I'm saved keystrokes, and I gave it the response it deserved. The other was your "reply" to Kevin, though my name probably appeared a dozen times for infantile asides, which nicely padded another of your empty contributions. And this was probably the post that triggered intervention from a moderator.
Your reasons 4 & 5 are more than a stretch, the former an appropriate characterization of a misguided argument and the latter goes to your credibility (or would you prefer I insinuate you had relations with a hamster? No, this stings because it's not based on speculation; it's all too true.)
You see nothing wrong with the mistreatment of animals, but you do apparently see something wrong with my earlier reply, a transgression that requires you report it to the authorities and post public notice. Your reasoning is comically ad hoc: the difference between your behavior and mine is that I had (crucially) said things AFTER an admin posted a warning. To you this is significant, but I wonder why you even bother to shield yourself from accusations of hypocrisy since Chomsky and all of the moral universalists are mistaken.
Then you go on to list things by the sentence. Now, why not report RandFan, who last I checked called me "sad and pathetic." Well, you might say he made only one uncivil remark -- two at the absolute most -- whereas I said -- Christ -- FIVE things. If any of these sort of arguments run through your head as a defense against hypocrisy, then you're reasoning along the lines of impartiality/consistency. Why? You could just report me because you felt like it. Instead you want to help enforce the totally made-up rules --
fashionable nonsense -- in this particular
social con
text. This is surreal, a mini-replay of the Sokal affair.
Rationality does not, nor has it ever meant, that I need to consider another being's desires, which in themselves are debatable as rational motivations, for giving my own motivations.
That is where the crux of this discussion lies; the fact that some people want to link the desires of other entities to rational behaviour (and in extension, moralism).
"Rational" is not the first word that pops into mind at the mention of "desire" (someone may desire the ability to fly). Regardless, desires/interests -- this is a source of value, and rationally there is no reason why only your desires/interests should count. So in the example you ignored, the one where you eat a human being, you're acting upon a desire for nourishment (and taste), arbitrarily privileging your interests over the victim's.
For some reason we all have been suckered into a reversal of where the burden of proof lies because of your foul mouth covered by a veneer of dictionary.
Obviously I'm a magician.

The problem with this thread, and these discussions in general, is that they quickly devolve into arguments for moral skepticism, which would not be worth mentioning if other threads followed the same pattern of rapid decline. But they don't. Even in arguments over abortion people are capable of producing reasons for and against, attempting to rationally justify their beliefs. In threads such as this one people are all too willing to slice off their own nose, shrieking "NOTHING is wrong!" OK then, why do such people only bother announcing their beliefs in these threads? Any topic remotely related to morality -- levels of taxation, global warming, financial regulation, woman who drowns her kids, faith healing, celebrity murderers, drug addiction, and so on are equally appropriate venues.
Arguments against torturing animals, eating animals, hunting animals, and so on, do not depend upon any one ethical belief system anymore than arguments against rape, murder, and genocide do.* Instead we can appeal to shared values, which leads to the next point on Japanese farmers:
Cherry-picking that example, but hey, let's drop it. What about the other two?
Which other two? The caste system, which you placed aside for this more relevant example? As I said, you never developed your arguments; brought them to a point. It was like saying "white people dance like *this* whereas black people dance like *this*." I can guess what you meant, but why bother guessing incorrectly? That's like playing a game where I choose a number between one and -- oh, say -- ten million.
It
seemed like you were making a fairly common argument, one that observes different cultures have different moral codes, and concludes that there is no universal morality. It may be true or false that there is no "objective moral truth" or whatever we want to call it, but disagreements alone do not prove it as people disagree over many things: the origins of the universe, the existence of spirits, the possibility of the afterlife, the age of the earth. So this argument for relativism is unsound.
Isaac Asimov has a famous remark on this point (which I will edit for length):
When people thought the Earth was flat, they were wrong. When people thought the Earth was spherical, they were wrong. But if you think that thinking the Earth is spherical is just as wrong as thinking the Earth is flat, then your view is wronger than both of them put together.
Some people offer more compelling reasons than others. Had you claimed you reported my post because you were told to do so in a dream, then your argument would not carry as much weight.
As for the Masai you quoted, again, it's not clear what you think it demonstrates. Is this supposed to make relativism more compelling because it comes from someone in a farflung culture? Would you include the argument if it came from your next door neighbor? Yes, the lion does not give consideration to the antelope because, as we have said, animals are not moral agents. Saying "The strongest thing does what it does" is not saying anything at all. Tautologies may sound profound when read as subtitles in foreign films, but they do not normally withstand scrutiny.
*Maybe you think there is nothing wrong with rape, murder and genocide and that only "social context" matters, or whatever, but this is probably not the most appropriate venue for that view. Worse, it seems sometimes you want to dip one foot in the pool of moral relativism, where it IS possible to appeal to shared moral values.
The social dynamics of polarization in these threads is interesting. Sword earlier quoted a PETA person saying he would not cure all disease in the world if it meant killing a rat. This is supposed to suggest animal rights people are all crazy. Well, what if a hard-core Kantian said the same thing about a human being? This comment says more about differences in moral belief systems than it does animal rights.
Similarly, it's interesting how the "It's OK to eat meat" tribe will align itself with moral skeptics when, fundamentally, they share more in common with vegans.