Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

Moral universalism falls down flat on it's face without the proper social context.
I'm willing to bet that I was one of the first persons to ever use the word "universal" in the context of morality on this forum. Odd that Cain is now using it.

Sociobiology tells us that humans by and large have certain evolved adaptive traits and that these traits are near universal. These traits include empathy, compassion and reciprocal altruism (among others).

I say "near" universal because it is demonstrable that not everyone has all of these traits. Nor do we have them to the same degree. Further we know that environmental factors including parental and social indoctrination can mold or even eliminate these traits.

By understanding these near universal traits we can formulate moral philosophy to compliment and take advantage of them.

However, we can't look into our genetics and say, well, we have gene "x" that tends to cause behavior "y" and therefore "y" is what we ought to do.
 
Last edited:
I'm willing to bet that I was one of the first persons to ever use the word "universal" in the context of morality on this forum. Odd that Cain is now using it.

I'm amusing myself by replacing "universal" with "Catholic" and "objectivist" with "Randian" in Cain's and Kevin's posts.
 
By understanding these near universal traits we can formulate moral philosophy to compliment and take advantage of them.

However, we can't look into our genetics and say, well, we have gene "x" that tends to cause behavior "y" and therefore "y" is what we ought to do.

Agreed insofar we agree that the genes cause the behaviour and not that the behaviour dictates the gene, although reproductional aspects might be influenced by the behaviour.

But it simply can not be the case that any argument *makes* someone have that gene.
 
Kevin won't give a source or outline of objective morality. Instead, he tell us to go google it and find it ourselves. Nice way to convince us and change minds, Kevin. Way to go!:rolleyes:
'Ye olden crappe' of last years academic syllabi and some wikipedia links do not cut it with me.
 
Agreed insofar we agree that the genes cause the behaviour and not that the behaviour dictates the gene, although reproductional aspects might be influenced by the behaviour.

But it simply can not be the case that any argument *makes* someone have that gene.
I would say that adaptive traits influence behavior, not causes behavior. I would also say that sociobiology is better at speaking to groups and not individuals. Any individual who tried to explain his or her behavior by sociobiology would be doing so in contradiction to the experts in that field.
 
I would say that adaptive traits influence behavior, not causes behavior. I would also say that sociobiology is better at speaking to groups and not individuals. Any individual who tried to explain his or her behavior by sociobiology would be doing so in contradiction to the experts in that field.

Nuance noted and agreed.
 
I would say that adaptive traits influence behavior, not causes behavior. I would also say that sociobiology is better at speaking to groups and not individuals. Any individual who tried to explain his or her behavior by sociobiology would be doing so in contradiction to the experts in that field.
Nuance noted and agreed.
I'm giving ammunition to Kevin and I apologize but I want to make clear that I'm talking about specific behaviors. To the degree that I am altruistic and capable of empathy or that I perceive an action as moral could be said likely to be the result of biology (including chemical influences of brain structure while a fetus is in the womb) social environment and a fair chance that it is the result of both. I could not reasonably say that any particular action or belief is directly the result of genetics (I ate bacon and eggs this morning because of my genetics).
 
Last edited:
I'm giving ammunition to Kevin and I apologize but I want to make clear that I'm talking about specific behaviors. To the degree that I am altruistic and capable of empathy or that I perceive an action as moral could be said likely to be the result of biology (including chemical influences of brain structure while a fetus is in the womb) social environment and a fair chance that it is the result of both. I could not reasonably say that any particular action or belief is directly the result of genetics (I ate bacon and eggs this morning because of my genetics).
Hmmm, totally off-topic, but I do not know yet if I agree... I remember reading an article last week that stated that Europeans have a genetically determined 'sweet-tooth' so to say.
I am to lazy to look that up by the way, as it is off-topic anyway.
 
Hmmm, totally off-topic, but I do not know yet if I agree... I remember reading an article last week that stated that Europeans have a genetically determined 'sweet-tooth' so to say.
I am to lazy to look that up by the way, as it is off-topic anyway.
Yes, but again, you are talking about a group. Sociobiology can make group predictions and via study verify those predictions. A study of 1 is statistically meaningless.
 
Kevin won't give a source or outline of objective morality. Instead, he tell us to go google it and find it ourselves. Nice way to convince us and change minds, Kevin. Way to go!:rolleyes:

This is like a Flat Earther complaining that someone is attacking their specific arguments, instead of personally compiling a summary of all paleontology for them.

All I'm doing here is explaining why certain specific arguments and positions are dumb. I'm not going to move on to further content until we've reached agreement on those fundamental points. All I would be doing is giving cover to people who want to avoid the points I am currently making.

That's the best you can do to justify your obfiscation?

I'm not obfuscating, I'm sticking to a very simple set of points.

The obfuscation is in trying to make our conversation be about whatever you want it to be, instead of facing up to the specific arguments presented about your specific claims.

I'm beginning to realise this is a pointless endeavour however since you just aren't capable of metaethical thought. You can make noises as if you are discussing the underlying reasons why some moral claims are better than others, but there's no actual mental traction. All you are capable of is expressing opinions, and then justifying them retroactively with whatever ethical terms are lying around and not nailed down.

Boy you can twist and turn, and squirm. Straw man. I never said that there are no moral values or meaningful moral claims.

In fact, I've said over and over, one can make objective statements about morality.

There is no such thing as objective morality.

:rolleyes:

That isn't even a response to what I posted. You claimed that I had presented no arguments at all for objectivist moral theories, which was and is a lie. So I gave you a recap of the reasons why the alternative categories of moral theory turned out to be useless or incoherent. Nothing you just posted in any way responds to that recap.

Secondly, even if you cling to the fantasy that logical thought is going on in that noodle of yours, even you have to admit that the quotes above contradict each other on their face. It looks like your problem is that you are equivocating between using "objective" in the sense of objectivist moral philosophy, which you reject, and "objective" in the sense of "factual statements about what some people actually believe".

There are deeper problems than that, but if we iron out your errors one at a time we might make progress. Please confirm that this is what you have been doing if I've correctly diagnosed one of your problems.

  • I desire to be treated justly.
  • I desire to be treated with dignity.
  • I desre to be free from pain and suffering.
  • I desire to be treated in a way that will likely increase my well being.
I should treat others as I desire to be treated. For that reason these are all golden rule statements and no amount of obfuscation will change that. That there is also utility in the golden rule and recognizing that utility DOESN'T obviate the golden rule.

:facepalm:

First you articulate a position which is hedonistic utilitarianism. Then you accuse me of attacking a straw man when I point this out and claim you were articulating the golden rule all along. So I explain the differences between the two positions, along with the fact that in difficult cases hedonistic utilitarianism and the golden rule will generate different results even if they agree on the easy cases.

So what do I get in response? You accuse me of unspecified "obfuscation" when I was actually clearing up the confusion you have been causing, pretend I claimed that recognizing utility "obviates the golden rule" whatever that means, repeat several of the easy cases which I just said were going to generate the same results under just about every useful moral theory, and act as if you've contributed something intelligent by pointing out that they generate the same results.

Don't you recognise that this is idiotic and counterproductive? It's about the same as getting phlogiston and oxygen mixed up, accusing the guy who points out your error of "obfuscation", and saying that it doesn't matter because they all agree stuff gets lighter when you burn it anyway.

I've never used the term "hedonistic utilitarianism".

Oh please.

Cool that you like hedonistic utilitarianism. There is no utitlity in treating animals the way we would like to be treated. I honestly did missunderstand your position on hedonistic utilitariansm and I confess that it's been sometime since I've heard the therm "hedonistic" used with utilitarianism.

And I've no doubt that you will hapily take rhetorical advantage of my honesty. I wouldn't do like wise but you won't likely ever give me that opportunity.

I don't think it counts as "rhetorical advantage" to point out that I've been saying you had no grasp on the discussion for some time, and you've just admitted that this was the case to some extent. In any case I'm not shooting for rhetorical advantage. That's just a dishonest claim you've been trying to support by pure repetition, accusing me of "rhetoric" and "assertion" every time you don't understand my arguments.

Assertion.

Now you are just making things up. "Not okay to be nice"?

Where is this contradiction? What terms am I abusing?

You know, if you would simply demonstrate what it is you are saying we could have a discussion.

I just did exactly that. You just "responded" to my doing that, without demonstrating that you even understand there is a problem.

Look, do us all a favour. Snip all of the above if you have to but just respond to this fundamental issue:

Do you agree that a rational position must be internally consistent? That is, that you cannot simultaneously affirm two claims that contradict each others?

Do you agree that it is contradictory to simultaneously assert, purely for example, (1) "moral acts are those which you would desire of other people were your positions reversed" and (2) "moral acts are those which maximise happiness and minimise suffering for all affected, morally relevant entities", since in some situations those two rules would lead to different actions?

What you want to do is make a raft of claims like "Y'know, kinda sorta sometimes moral acts are those which you would desire of other people were your positions reversed", and "Y'know, kinda sorta sometimes moral acts are those which maximise happiness and minimise suffering for all affected, morally relevant entities", and "Y'know, kinda sorta sometimes moral acts are those which respect rational entities as worthy of respect as ends in themselves", and "Y'know, kinda sorta sometimes moral acts are those which we think are moral because of our evolved nature", and "Y'know, kinda sorta there are no objective moral claims at all" and "Y'now, kinda sorta moral claims are just the product of social convenience" and "Y'know, kinda sorta moral claims vary in different times and places and that's cool too, I'm not saying Vlad the Impaler was an immoral guy for his time and place".

You grab a sample bag of noises from every philosophy you come across, and then every time you want to justify an opinion you rifle around in it until you find something that suits you. When I point out that you are being inconsistent you get hugely offended because as far as you're concerned, the more random stuff in your grab bag the more philosophically and scientifically erudite you are and the more important your opinion is. In your world you don't need to apply reason to your grab-bag (although "Y'know, kinda sorta we can use reason to sort these claims out" is in your bag as well just for when you want to pretend to be rational).

The other advantage of the grab-bag is that any time anyone tries to pin you down on your claims, you can just point to a contradictory claim you made earlier and accuse them of attacking a straw man.
 
This is like a Flat Earther complaining that someone is attacking their specific arguments, instead of personally compiling a summary of all paleontology for them.

All I'm doing here is explaining why certain specific arguments and positions are dumb. I'm not going to move on to further content until we've reached agreement on those fundamental points. All I would be doing is giving cover to people who want to avoid the points I am currently making.

No, what you are doing is making many claims and not actually citing the sources for your claims. Where is this source of objective morality? Where does it come from? Where is an outline of these objective morals? Is there a website? Is there a book? Is there any science behind your claims?
 
No, what you are doing is making many claims and not actually citing the sources for your claims. Where is this source of objective morality? Where does it come from? Where is an outline of these objective morals? Is there a website? Is there a book? Is there any science behind your claims?

This might help. ;)
 
"I have never made but one prayer to God, a very short one: "O Lord make my enemies ridiculous." And God granted it." - Voltaire

RandFan:
It turns out that the ethical vegans on our site are only pansies. ****!

No, you misunderstand, but you're even less lucid than usual. I'm saying you should take it to another forum, so others who have no idea of your background, can evaluate it for themselves, and perhaps you'd be more likely to listen to their criticisms. I never suggested bringing others on here.

A second post, RF brags:
I'm willing to bet that I was one of the first persons to ever use the word "universal" in the context of morality on this forum. Odd that Cain is now using it.

And yet, I used the phrase back in 2004: http://www.internationalskeptics.co...hp?p=865412&highlight=universalism#post865412

Less than a year ago I wrote: "I have long maintained a position of moral universalism."
http://www.internationalskeptics.co...?p=3936150&highlight=universalism#post3936150

This is notable because I wrote it in response to YOU, and it went unchallenged at the time (partly, I'm guessing, because it is a stance I have long-maintained). I used the term at least three times in the thread, and considering this comes as news to you now, I'm guessing it would be easy money to take you up on your bet. Wow, not only have you managed to overturn moral philosophy with your normative-descriptive blurring, but you were of the first on these forums to argue for universals. Congrats, Columbus.
-----------------------------
GreNME:
You know, just as I told skeptigirl in a different thread, taking what I said, re-wording it, and then shooting it back as if it somehow negates what I said makes no good sense and is not a rational argument. I asked you to admit that's what you were really starting from, that's all. A simple "yes" would have sufficed.

Now, all you have to do is provide a basis for your assertion that this idea is applicable in the "universal" sense you say. You have never done so, and asserting that it has to be the same across the board is not the same as providing a logical reason to justify applying your assertion across the board.

It seems you lack the slightest understanding of what I'm saying. Not until you produce a reason explaining the different treatment/status of animals and humans can we apply it across the board. You compulsively fail at this task.

---------------------
RealPaladin:
Re: your non-reply to me:
Shockingly imbecilic stuff. At no point do you engage any of the arguments at hand, always favoring the most witless taunts.

As for your non-reply to Kevin, which obsessively mentions me:
I do not think I have ever seen such an awkward and complete meltdown.

For some unfathomable reason you decided to attempt something resembling a response, and it's mind-bogglingly inept. You should stick with the lower expectations of heckling.

You write:
First, why not start with the 'Natural rights'? That concept seems to be necessary to even arrive at the 'moral universalism'.

This is a clue that you have no idea what you're talking about. Moral universalism is a meta-ethic that accommodates a variety of beliefs, and natural rights is but one such belief. Now even if I did adhere natural rights -- which I don't -- and even if you made a half-decent case against natural rights -- which you don't -- you would have bupkis. Never mind your strikes are feeble, they're misdirected. You're going after the tree's limb.

Now, I did wonder how a person who commits such a basic error could casually name drop Hepburn (who the hell is that?), so I googled ["hepburn" "moral universalism"] and for all your bluster about academics I had momentarily forgotten that you attend Wikipedia University. So W includes the views you're presumably responding to (Hepburn and Chomsky).

You're pretty good at stating your position... and you're very bad at arguing for it. It may help for you to think of Chomsky as urging impartiality/consistency/rationality (I use slashes to suggest shared meaning). Morality concerns itself with reasons for action, and so if you choose to eat a human, hummus or hippopotamus, then presumably you have a reason for doing so (usually some combination of nutrition and pleasure). I realize you would prefer to avoid rationality -- and your attempt to pre-empt the term was charming -- but you need to produce reasons why your actions, satisfying your desires or nutrition -- eating humans, for example -- takes precedence over someone else's desires not to be eaten.

As for your underdeveloped example involving a Japanese farmer... well, this is similar to the common argument for moral relativism, which is unsound. It's difficult to tell which direction you're going in with it, and what you intend for it to prove, but then... that's why I'm describing it as underdeveloped.

--------------------------------
TBK:
I agree with you. I did agree with you. I do not include children or the mentally disabled.

You did not agree with me, and you repeatedly fail to clarify your views. Earlier you wrote:

Those humans who are "marginal" tend not to have the full rights and responsibilities as those that do. Children are not allowed to vote, for example.

This more than suggests that children have at least SOME rights, but now you're telling me children do not have any rights, not even "limited" rights. What next, are you going to claim that you have maintained all along that adults do not have rights either? Your ever-shifting view, as it stands now -- tell me if you agree or not -- says it's wrong to torture adults but not wrong to torture children.
 
This more than suggests that children have at least SOME rights, but now you're telling me children do not have any rights, not even "limited" rights. What next, are you going to claim that you have maintained all along that adults do not have rights either? Your ever-shifting view, as it stands now -- tell me if you agree or not -- says it's wrong to torture adults but not wrong to torture children.

Yes, limited rights, as in welfare considerations. I like how you try to twist the contexts and meanings though. You almost tricked me into becoming a vegan.:rolleyes:
 
:facepalm:
Kevin, your last post was a bit more substantive. I'll bet though that if volitile ever comes back he can't find ANY meat in 10 - 20 posts before that. It was all assertion and claims.

This post is more substantive and I appreciate it. The same old assertions and claims become such a bore.

...along with the fact that in difficult cases hedonistic utilitarianism and the golden rule will generate different results even if they agree on the easy cases.
I'm going to make this short and sweet. No moral theory will resolve every moral dillema. It's the difficult cases where moral theory can and does break down.

If you would answer my damn questions you would learn that.

You accuse me of unspecified "obfuscation"...
That's a lie. You refused to address my arguments or answer my questions. To date you have still refused to answer my questions.

...when I was actually clearing up the confusion you have been causing, pretend I claimed that recognizing utility "obviates the golden rule"...
There is NO confusion. That there is utility to the golden rule (and there is) doesn't obviate the golden rule. End of story Kevin.

Oh please, I made a single reference to your position and I've since admitted my mistake and put a strike through the bulleted point to leave my error in plain sight.

I don't think it counts as "rhetorical advantage" to point out that I've been saying you had no grasp on the discussion for some time...
It's rhetorical advantage to make something more of a trivial error.

Odd, you expect me to answer your questions but you won't answer mine. You are one of the most arrogant and narcissistic individuals I've ever met.

I could play your game and obfuscate but I'm not as dishonest as you.

Do you agree that a rational position must be internally consistent?
Yes (with the caveat that no moral position can resolve all dillemas).

That is, that you cannot simultaneously affirm two claims that contradict each others?
Yes (however you can consider two premises that don't contradict when they don't contradict.).

Do you agree that it is contradictory to simultaneously assert, purely for example, (1) "moral acts are those which you would desire of other people were your positions reversed" and (2) "moral acts are those which maximise happiness and minimise suffering for all affected, morally relevant entities", since in some situations those two rules would lead to different actions?
No.


I assert the following:
  1. Morality isn't something that is objective (we can never come to a consensus as to what is moral in the sense that we can come to a consensus as to E=MC2) IOW, morality isn't a priori.
  2. No moral theory will resolve all moral dillemas (that's demonstrable but I can't prove to you that the moon exists if you are too arrogant to look up).
  3. Contradiction is inherent to morality.
  4. At best we can formulate moral theory that strives to be internally consistent.
  5. That utility and the golden rule can come into conflict at some extreme doesn't obviate either theory nor does it mean that should we adopt one that we can never consider the other.
Kevin, if you have an once of sincerity and are willing to engage in dicussion without playing some gotcha game then give me a hypothetical that demonstrates the conflict between the golden rule and utility and I will tell you how I would answer.

And for crying the dark, HAVE SOME BACKBONE AND RESPOND TO MY QUESTIONS.

  • By what standard does one use to come to this "objective" morality?
  • Does objective morality resolve all dilemmas?
  • If not then how can it be objective?
Scenarios:
  1. Someone is trying to kill you and your best chance to survive is to kill them.
  2. Anne Frank is in your attic and the SS is at the door.
  3. During the tenure of Trevelyan at the time of the Irish famine you have an opportunity to steal corn to keep your children alive.
Questions:
  1. Is it objectively immoral to kill?
  2. Is it objectively immoral to lie?
  3. Is it objectively immoral to steal?
So, where is this "objective" morality? What is it exactly? Does it exist a priori?

{nonsense snipped} tldr
 
Last edited:
GreNME:


It seems you lack the slightest understanding of what I'm saying. Not until you produce a reason explaining the different treatment/status of animals and humans can we apply it across the board. You compulsively fail at this task.

How about no? I'm not convinced an across-the-board application is logical, useful, or moral. You're way behind on that whole mess of actually being convincing. You've got the arrogant self-righteousness down, though. Now all you have to do is back it up.
 
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=865412&highlight=universalism#post865412[/URL]

Less than a year ago I wrote: "I have long maintained a position of moral universalism."
http://www.internationalskeptics.co...?p=3936150&highlight=universalism#post3936150

This is notable because I wrote it in response to YOU, and it went unchallenged at the time (partly, I'm guessing, because it is a stance I have long-maintained). I used the term at least three times in the thread, and considering this comes as news to you now, I'm guessing it would be easy money to take you up on your bet. Wow, not only have you managed to overturn moral philosophy with your normative-descriptive blurring, but you were of the first on these forums to argue for universals. Congrats, Columbus.
Damn, sometimes it really sucks being ethical.

You are right. I was wrong.
 
Okay, we're done.


You can't have a rational conversation with someone who is happy to embrace mutually contradictory claims.
You are a coward and intellectually dishonest because:
  1. You won't tell me how I'm embracing mutually contradictory claims (again, you just assert it).
  2. You won't answer my questions or address most of my points even when I answer yours.
I'll ask volitile and perhaps some of the other ethical vegans who are reasonable.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom