Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

Ah, so you're looking for any excuse now...
Nah, I wasn't looking for it, I knew you already found it.

Um, I wasn't sincere.
Guess what, don't give a hootenanny about that either.

So, where is the link then, or are we first treated to some first-class whining?

Yes, I should do as you: avoid debating the topic, and then accuse my opponent of debating the topic. Is your self-parody almost complete? Just continue doing what you do best: mindless head-nodding and hand-jobs; it seems others need your encouragement.

Whining it is.

No link, no content, nothing. Like the index of the contents of your accumulated knowledge.

These non-replies are empowering and time-saving.
That means you are taking the left-turn to 'evasionville' again?

I am disappointed you're reduced to using the phrase "epic failure" which is almost as bad as "not!" but then again this coming from the comedy stylings of a person who says "seriously?" Your stupidity is unusually bold.
Cool huh? I bet I even get more laid than you as well. Let's bring that in as well, as you seem unable to discuss any point at all.

So, what have we here. A failure to follow up on a promise for a link. A failure to address a point. A failure to insult. A failed attempt at humor.

I think I can nicely abbreviate all that as 'failure'.

But, because you seem unwilling, or unable, to think for yourself, I will start fresh for you.

Isn't that nice of the stupid man? Helping you a bit? Need to be held by the hand a lot, huh?

---------

I state that:

1 - Objective morality does not exist.
2 - It is up to an individuals personal 'motivators' and 'inhibitors' to decide whether or not to undertake an activity like killing an animal, like killing a human being.
3 - There is no difference in killing an animal or killing a human being, objectively.
4 - There are only culturally defined 'penalties' for aforementioned actions.
5 - The individual decides for itself whether it wants to accept these 'penalties' or not.
6 - Morality is not an extension of rationality.
7 - Eating meat is a good thing for a lot of individuals.

Have at it kiddo.
 
I see no reason to dispute your fantasy.

I would only strongly encourage you to send to test your moral theories on independent third parties. If you're interested in this topic, and it seems you are, then regurgitate it over on the Internet Infidels board. I would not be surprised if they already have an animal rights thread running, but you could always start your own. Maybe you'll be less emotionally sensitive to their criticisms, and someone there can disabuse you of your crackpot beliefs. Or, maybe -- it's possible -- you can change minds and blaze trails. Be sure to post the thread link here -- I'd like to skim it.
Wow. Your decorum has unnerved me. Aside from painting my propositions as fantasy and ideas as crackpot you are uncharacteristically polite.

I get invited to a lot of forums. Particularly Skeptical Community. That forum is actually closer to my ideological bent. I like the JREF and I've not the time to invest in other forums.

Feel free to invite any of your friends there to come here.

In the meantime we've got Volitile, joethejuggler and many other posters who don't engage in personal attacks and invective. I think we are well covered here.

Oh, and Cain, if I was all that senstitive I would put you on ignore.
 
See, that's the way it's supposed to work. Philosophy can be an interesting tool for self-examination. It's neat to examine things in abstraction to determine for yourself why you hold the views you hold, and perhaps challenge them. You can then take these insights gleamed, factor back in the realities, and see where that leaves you.

However, most people just use it for an intellectual pissing contest. And that can be fun in the right context, but it's aggrivating when they feel that they have to do it in every single conversation. It's even more infuriating when they feel that somehow making a rational point about an abstract construct really has some actual meaning.

That's why in this thread they won't answer questions like "where does morality come from" or "who enforces it". These have nothing to do with the points they are trying to make, so they aren't interested in them.

Anyway, I wasn't criticising you. You seem to get it. Keep up the Good Fight.
Thanks. I wouldn't have it any other way. :)
 
Cain, can you not take the 30 seconds it takes to google the definition of sapience?!

from dictionary.com "having or showing great wisdom or sound judgment."
 
Cain, can you not take the 30 seconds it takes to google the definition of sapience?!

from dictionary.com "having or showing great wisdom or sound judgment."

Judging by his ripostes and repartees, he consults his sapient hamster, that takes time.
 
This will have to be my last for the day. It's the Fourth of July or something.

Cain, I don't have to justify anything morally simply because you've demanded it. You are the one asserting that this is a moral problem. You have to justify that assertion before expecting anyone else to take it seriously. So far, your only justification for this assertion is that people generally do consider some violence to animals to be morally problematic at the very least, which you then take to extremes and demand everyone accept it.

This is a mischaracterization. If a person already accepts violence against animals is wrong, then I emphasize that this belief should be rationally applied across the board. To those who claim human beings have certain rights, but not animals, I request the moral differences, which, since the idea of animal rights is so obviously crazy, you should be able to produce in an instant. And here again, you self-consciously avoid it.

-----------------
RealPaladin, after much blather, finally attempts to say something about something:

1 - Objective morality does not exist.
2 - It is up to an individuals personal 'motivators' and 'inhibitors' to decide whether or not to undertake an activity like killing an animal, like killing a human being.
3 - There is no difference in killing an animal or killing a human being, objectively.
4 - There are only culturally defined 'penalties' for aforementioned actions.
5 - The individual decides for itself whether it wants to accept these 'penalties' or not.
6 - Morality is not an extension of rationality.
7 - Eating meat is a good thing for a lot of individuals.

Curiously you continue to avoid responding to my argument from earlier that morality is an outgrowth of rationality. While baby-talk suits you, it does not merit much of a response. For your convenience:

The problem with this position, if we try to put its ridiculousness aside, is that the proponent of such a view probably does not apply it consistently, you or anyone. Let's return to Shermer's comment up-thread on animal torture where he asks, "Is it OK if I torture you?" If a person answers that it's not OK, then the argument becomes something like "what makes you so special?" That is to say, if you believe that it's not OK for someone to torture you, then you should believe it's not OK to torture anyone, assuming similar circumstances. There might be circumstances where you think torture is appropriate; you may believe it's permissible for the government to waterboard suspected terrorists, but again, consistency would require that you agree it's OK for the government to waterboard you if you're suspected of terrorism. Morality is an outgrowth of rationality, and you can jump up and down, hold your breath until your face turns blue, attempt at every turn to blather nonsense and avoid arguments, cry there is no objective morality, and that's fine... but you're still agitating for a position that is irrational because it's internally incoherent. And just as reason dispenses of egoism, it takes care of nationalism, racism, sexism, and speciesism.

I almost always refrain using the terms "objective morality" or "moral objectivism" or "moral objectivist." I prefer "moral universalism." As for the above, points 2 and 5 are restatements of another, and 4 is arguably trivial repetition of the same -- a RandFanesque bit of inflation. They're non-essential. Seven should probably say "benefits" rather than "good". Three is a radical statement, and would probably inspire hackles if had not ingratiated yourself on a side.) We'll stick to six for the moment, and see if you can muster anything at all. I should also say that you are an unbelievable moron; outrageously stupid, lacking the slightest bit of self-awareness. You make mimes look cool.

--------------
RandFan:
Wow. Your decorum has unnerved me. Aside from painting my propositions as fantasy and ideas as crackpot you are uncharacteristically polite.

Rest assured, I was mocking you throughout. Those beliefs of yours cannot withstand the slightest bit of scrutiny, which is why I urge you to advertise them. From what I've seen of the Skeptical Community, it's hardly worth anyone's time. Go to IIDB.org/ , which is secular and philosophically inclined (more so than this forum at least). They have a board dedicated to moral foundations, and possibly a thread on animal rights.

---------------------
TBK writes:
Cain, can you not take the 30 seconds it takes to google the definition of sapience?!

from dictionary.com "having or showing great wisdom or sound judgment."

I wanted you to say it, so now you can see how this completely defeats your argument. If "having or showing great wisdom or sound judgment" is the standard, then you cannot possibly include children or the mentally disabled. You have to bite the bullet and say that they do not possess even limited rights, or find some new reason to broaden your rights standard.
---------------

A final comment: All of you, without exception, should be embarrassed by your arguments. I'm glad you have this mutual support group going because it would not hold up in an academic environment for very long. The people who should be most offended are those who hold similar views; they deserve stronger proponents.
 
Rest assured, I was mocking you throughout.
Oh reeeaaaaly. Oh, well, no one would have guessed that. Well shut my mouth. Damn. Cain mocking me. Oh hell. Surprise of all surprises.

Those beliefs of yours cannot withstand the slightest bit of scrutiny, which is why I urge you to advertise them.
It's kinda pathetic that you've got to refer me to some other forum (just wait 'till I tell my big brother on you). I gotta say I'm just a bit embarrased for you.

It turns out that the ethical vegans on our site are only pansies. ****!

Fine, we could use some new blood around here. Let your friends know where I am. I'm not meek and mild by any means. If you've got some big bad ethical vegans who will kick my ass because you can't do it then by all means, bring them by.

Oh, hell, it just occured to me, who is going to tell volitile? I can only imagine his disapointment that not only is big bad Cain not up to the task but Cain doesn't think anyone else here is either. He is likely to be disapointed. Jesus Christ on a cracker, I know I am.

Oh ****, we need some new ethical vegans.
 
Last edited:
This is a mischaracterization. If a person already accepts violence against animals is wrong, then I emphasize that this belief should be rationally applied across the board. To those who claim human beings have certain rights, but not animals, I request the moral differences, which, since the idea of animal rights is so obviously crazy, you should be able to produce in an instant. And here again, you self-consciously avoid it.

You know, just as I told skeptigirl in a different thread, taking what I said, re-wording it, and then shooting it back as if it somehow negates what I said makes no good sense and is not a rational argument. I asked you to admit that's what you were really starting from, that's all. A simple "yes" would have sufficed.

Now, all you have to do is provide a basis for your assertion that this idea is applicable in the "universal" sense you say. You have never done so, and asserting that it has to be the same across the board is not the same as providing a logical reason to justify applying your assertion across the board.
 
Curiously you continue to avoid responding to my argument from earlier that morality is an outgrowth of rationality.

I simply say it is not. Is there in the list. You have not proven it. Again you fail.

My guess is that hardwiring in your brain by seeing a failure everyday in the mirror leads you to conclude that other people might be just the same.

Whatever makes you sleep at night, next to your sapient hamster.

While baby-talk suits you, it does not merit much of a response.
Meh!

For your convenience:
<snip a lot of hot air that is saying nothing and which demonstrates his inability to use information technology>

I almost always

Have to help you here again. 'Almost always' is the same as 'not always'.

refrain using the terms "objective morality" or "moral objectivism" or "moral objectivist." I prefer "moral universalism."

And I will help you again. Moral universalism does not exist. And I do not care a hootenanny for your preferences either.

As for the above, points 2 and 5 are restatements of another, and 4 is arguably trivial repetition of the same

Well, if you see them that way, think of them helping you as you keep demonstrating being thick as a brick.

-- a RandFanesque bit of inflation. They're non-essential. Seven should probably say "benefits" rather than "good". Three is a radical statement, and would probably inspire hackles if had not ingratiated yourself on a side.)
What's with the bracket? Hamster running loose?

We'll stick to six for the moment, and see if you can muster anything at all.
'Anything at all' is more than you demonstrate to be able to do.

I should also say that you are an unbelievable moron; outrageously stupid, lacking the slightest bit of self-awareness.

Good for you kid! Out with those repressed frustrations! Are they, by any chance, sexual by origin?

You make mimes look cool.
Hey, so the mimes have a good day as well!

So, now for your answer...

Wait... that's it? A re-iteration of computer-illiterate babble and some 'insults' a 10-year old would laugh about?

That really is *it*. What happened to the 'Louis XIV' like
We'll stick to six for the moment, and see if you can muster anything at all.
?

There is nothing there is there? And no, that was not the question your 'escort' asked a few nights ago when she uncovered the bed-sheets.


A final comment: All of you, without exception, should be embarrassed by your arguments.

I am pretty embarrassed to having to admit that you are member of the human race.

I'm glad you have this mutual support group going because it would not hold up in an academic environment for very long.
Assumptions, assumptions. You have no single clue as to who I am IRL.

The people who should be most offended are those who hold similar views; they deserve stronger proponents.

You can not make me believe that the people that hold your views are not cringeing with exploding shame every-time you make a post.

They must be thinking "Noooo, not that crackpot again, now everyone will think we suck at debating!"
 
Last edited:
Good for you kid! Out with those repressed frustrations! Are they, by any chance, sexual by origin?

Hey now, this is just going too far.

Saying stupid things on these boards because of sexual frustrations is my shtick. Don't you forget it. :)
 
I wanted you to say it, so now you can see how this completely defeats your argument. If "having or showing great wisdom or sound judgment" is the standard, then you cannot possibly include children or the mentally disabled. You have to bite the bullet and say that they do not possess even limited rights, or find some new reason to broaden your rights standard.

I agree with you. I did agree with you. I do not include children or the mentally disabled.
 
Hey now, this is just going too far.

Saying stupid things on these boards because of sexual frustrations is my shtick. Don't you forget it. :)

Ok, whenever you reach the magnitude of avoidance and volume of hot air as Cain, then I will most certainly respond in kind :)
 
For those keeping score at home:

[*]Kevin won't answer simple questions.

Kevin sees attempts to derail the discussion coming, and declines to take part.

[*]Kevin won't tell us what standard he uses for his objective morality all the while demanding that I answer what standard I would use. I could have played his game and obfuscated and been evasive and simply engaged in gainsaying but I answered.

If you want to learn about objectivist moral theories I've listed more than one in this thread already, and assuming you can google you can find plenty of literature about them.

However there's not much point in discussing them if you can't grasp the arguments against relativism or complete moral skepticism.

[*]Kevin won't give us evidence of objective morality.

As above. If you were genuinely interested then knowledge is a google search away. If you're just trying to pull the focus off the flaws of your own stated theory, then sorry but I'm not playing your game.

[*]Kevin won't give us any reason or logic to assume that there is an objective morality.

This is a lie. I have explained over and over again the fundamental problems that make relativism incoherent, and Cain has repeatedly pointed out that people who claim that there are no meaningful moral claims are virtually always hypocrites who do hold some moral values.

Since I've also stated that I think absolutist moral theories are silly, what's left but objectivist theories?

(For those keeping score, as RandFan would put it, RandFan doesn't seem to have grasped that there is a distinction between objectivist and absolutist moral theories. I don't expect him to figure it out between now and his next post, either. Just don't be confused by his imminent misuse of the terms).

[*]Kevin makes claims about what I've said but won't quote the parts that he claims are contradictory and explain how and why they are contradictory.

This is a lie, it's all I've been doing for pages. But I'll do it again in a sec.

[*]Kevin thinks that the golden rule is hedonistic utilitarianism.

Okay. Right here is yet another giveaway that RandFan isn't successfully tracking the conversation. He's just contradicting me and throwing buzzwords around without actually comprehending them. It's word salad, philosophical mad libs, sound and fury signifying nothing.

What RandFan actually endorsed a minute ago was hedonistic utilitarianism. That's the objectivist moral theory that says that moral action is whatever maximises the sum of gains and losses for all morally relevant parties, measured in terms of pleasure/happiness versus pain/unhappiness.

The problem is that he thinks he just endorsed the deontological, objectivist Golden Rule, which holds that moral action is that action that you would desire of another if your positions were reversed.

Those are two hugely different moral theories. Now some of the time these two theories will yield the same conclusions. However in many difficult cases, and difficult cases are the only interesting ones, they will yield very different conclusions.

What does RandFan really think? We'll probably never know, because he tries to communicate his ideas by throwing around terms like "hedonistic utilitarianism" and "golden rule" which he had demonstrated he doesn't understand.

From his other post:

According to Kevin this won't fly, it can lead to hedonistic relativism.

Hey, I'm on your side.

It it ok to treat me with dignity? Yes.
It it ok to treat me in a just manner? Yes.
Is it ok to treat me in a way to increase my well being? Yes.

Hedonistic to Kevin.

This is pure word salad. No part of it is joined-up thought.

For starters I have no ******* idea what "hedonistic relativism" is.

Okay, we'll be charitable, we'll assume he meant "hedonistic utilitarianism", not the nonexistent "hedonistic relativism". So does his post make any sense now?

Nope. Firstly what Cain is advocating is indeed something that has a lot in common with hedonistic utilitarianism, but that one point is as close to intelligibility as RandFan gets at the moment. If RandFan had even the slightest clue about what I've been saying for several pages, he'd realise that from my perspective it is not a criticism to say that something is hedonistic utilitarianism. I like hedonistic utilitarianism. It's an objectivist moral theory that, among other things, leads fairly directly to the conclusion that it's morally wrong to mistreat animals.

Secondly, RandFan's three dot points are just completely irrelevant to the ongoing discussion. I have trouble envisioning any useful moral theory that says it's "not okay" to be nice to people. You can get that conclusion out of relativism, utilitarianism, multiple deontological theories, you name it. So the implied conclusion that anyone who agrees that it's okay to be nice to people must embrace any one particular moral philosophy is so staggeringly dumb that it passes belief.

So what the hell is RandFan on about? To paraphrase Babbage, I am not able rightly to apprehend the kind of confusion of ideas that could provoke such a post. As best I can make out he doesn't understand what hedonistic utilitarianism is but he thinks I think it's bad, so he thinks he's scored a point by saying that I think Cain's position is hedonistic relativism, but the logical path he took to get to that conclusion only serves to demonstrate how clueless RandFan is about the terms he is pretending to understand.

RandFan: Will you now cease repeating the lie that I have not shown that you are contradicting yourself, and the lie that I have not shown that you do not understand the terms you are abusing?
 
Kevin sees attempts to derail the discussion coming, and declines to take part.
Kevin has the same personality problem as Caine?

Talk about yourself in the first person.

If you want to learn about objectivist moral theories I've listed more than one in this thread already, and assuming you can google you can find plenty of literature about them.

Did. And is just the same nonsense you are spouting here.

There simply *is* no objectivist morality, or, as Caine 'prefers' moral universalism.

All dreamed up nonsense to avoid a real discussion.

However there's not much point in discussing them if you can't grasp the arguments against relativism or complete moral skepticism.

You have gotten the idea of proof wrong:

Proofs against relativism or complete moral skepticism do not make proof for 'objective morality'.

Show me proof *for* that, instead of hoping that someone will say 'aaah, the others have been proven wrong, so it *must* be as the idio^H^H^H^H guys say'.

As above. If you were genuinely interested then knowledge is a google search away.
Did.

Did not find any proof. Just a lot of dreamy blabla.

If you're just trying to pull the focus off the flaws of your own stated theory, then sorry but I'm not playing your game.

Good. Play your game. Give some proof. Or let me make it clearer; show me that you understand what your precioussss Google links say and make the case in your own words.

This is a lie. I have explained over and over again the fundamental problems that make relativism incoherent, and Cain has repeatedly pointed out that people who claim that there are no meaningful moral claims are virtually always hypocrites who do hold some moral values.
Cain has done nothing of the sort. He is a frustrated clown that has made no argument whatsoever.

What Cain has done is made some bruhaha about his alleged academic prowess which degraded rather quickly in childish insults on intelligence.

Cain could not find an argument if it grabbed him by his nuts.

Since I've also stated that I think absolutist moral theories are silly, what's left but objectivist theories?

You are saying that just because you can not think of anything else it simply must be that one?

You start sounding like Yrreg, the God-crackpot from another thread.

And what you state does not amount to a hill of beans anywhere except maybe in PM's with Cain.

Prove it.

(For those keeping score, as RandFan would put it, RandFan doesn't seem to have grasped that there is a distinction between objectivist and absolutist moral theories.
Either that or you and Cain are extremely lousy at explaining.

My current bet is on the latter.

I don't expect him to figure it out between now and his next post, either. Just don't be confused by his imminent misuse of the terms).
I am not by yours, so I will not be by his.

Okay. Right here is yet another giveaway that RandFan isn't successfully tracking the conversation. He's just contradicting me and throwing buzzwords around without actually comprehending them. It's word salad, philosophical mad libs, sound and fury signifying nothing.

Are you sure you are not reading Cain's posts?

What RandFan actually endorsed a minute ago was hedonistic utilitarianism. <snippety>
What does RandFan really think? We'll probably never know, because he tries to communicate his ideas by throwing around terms like "hedonistic utilitarianism" and "golden rule" which he had demonstrated he doesn't understand.

You do understand that you are making the same logical fallacy as Cain here?

Namely that if someone, for the sake of argument RandFan (I am sorry bud, don't think you do, but need you for the example), has a lesser grasp on the definition of terms, that he has a lesser grasp on the concepts.

Definitions of terms are used to avoid ambiguity. If you see in a discussion that the other party does not have the same definition of terms then you start setting up a mutually agreed definition of terms.

It is the sign of academically immature people, like you and Cain, to state that the definition of term you found on a page (book or website) will be the Alpha and Omega in that discussion.

You fail to grasp the basic concept of discussion.

Citing others and posting links as a substitute for your own proof of understanding is weak and academically unsound.

Citing others and posting links is what you do to corroborate and augment your proof of understanding.

Again, you and Cain fail immeasurably here.

Nope. Firstly what Cain is advocating is indeed something that has a lot in common with hedonistic utilitarianism, but that one point is as close to intelligibility as RandFan gets at the moment.
Cain is just plain dumb; he fell in the cauldron with lettersoup when he was a kid, about 5 years ago.

If you call that intelligeble, then abandon all hope.

If RandFan had even the slightest clue about what I've been saying for several pages, he'd realise that from my perspective it is not a criticism to say that something is hedonistic utilitarianism. I like hedonistic utilitarianism. It's an objectivist moral theory that, among other things, leads fairly directly to the conclusion that it's morally wrong to mistreat animals.

I state, plain and simple, that it is not morally wrong to mistreat animals.

Secondly, RandFan's three dot points are just completely irrelevant to the ongoing discussion. I have trouble envisioning any useful moral theory that says it's "not okay" to be nice to people.

You having trouble envisioning something does not make it impossible. Throughout history lots of people had trouble envisioning things that we nowadays take as a matter of fact.

Let me help you, you and Cain really need that a lot;

The caste system in India. The casteless are kicked, spit at an generally abused by just about anyone.
Does it matter to the majority? No, because if they live out this life according to their caste (or castelessness) they get up higher in the next life.

I get berated by the people around me when I want to help a person without a caste.

They think it is a pretty useful moral theory saying 'it is not okay to be nice to people'

You can get that conclusion out of relativism, utilitarianism, multiple deontological theories, you name it. So the implied conclusion that anyone who agrees that it's okay to be nice to people must embrace any one particular moral philosophy is so staggeringly dumb that it passes belief.

Implications, envisioning... a lot of circumstantial humdrum hanging on the value of the value we would put on both you and Cain.

Well, you have reached level 0. That is where you were starting from yes.

But I will pass your regards on to the second-largest population on the planet.

So what the hell is RandFan on about? To paraphrase Babbage, I am not able rightly to apprehend the kind of confusion of ideas that could provoke such a post. As best I can make out he doesn't understand what hedonistic utilitarianism is but he thinks I think it's bad, so he thinks he's scored a point by saying that I think Cain's position is hedonistic relativism, but the logical path he took to get to that conclusion only serves to demonstrate how clueless RandFan is about the terms he is pretending to understand.

Playing hide and seek with terms. Poor Babbage would turn in his grave.

RandFan: Will you now cease repeating the lie that I have not shown that you are contradicting yourself, and the lie that I have not shown that you do not understand the terms you are abusing?

Explain and agree to terms then? You are incredibly unwilling to go into a discussion, but extremely eager to flee in a fake game on the definition of terms.

Just state a couple of terms, for the sake of argument call them 'hoppity', 'floppity' and 'cheesecake' and then start discussing the implications, not the definitions.

Pay attention to class a little more, will you?

EDIT: It just occurred to me, the people that you have such trouble envisioning, are also the largest population of vegetarians on the planet. Irony or what?
 
Last edited:
Keep it civil and on topic please. Discuss the subject of the thread, not other members.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Gaspode
 
Agreed. So, let us start again.

First, why not start with the 'Natural rights'? That concept seems to be necessary to even arrive at the 'moral universalism'.

All the great thinkers notwithstanding, I still postulate:

- There are no natural rights. Defining this even further; there is no such thing as a right at all.

Clarification on my standpoint:

- A right is an activity, process or possession (material or immaterial) that can not be taken away from the entity that has such a right.
- The activity of granting or depriving of a right needs either consensus, pressure or enforcement.
- If a second entity neither succumbs to consensus, pressure or enforcement whilst depriving a right from the first entity, the right is no longer with the first entity.

Therefore I conclude that rights are but social constructs, which, unless you are willing to exert either pressure or enforcement, need consensus from the second entity.

A right therefore does not exist without a social context.

Next postulation:

Moral universalism falls down flat on it's face without the proper social context.

Clarification:

- Whilst having a social context is in conflict with a completely rational procedure I feel that this is not enough to show that moral universalism is but a mere 'feelgood' concept.

- The problem arises when people with different social contexts meet and discuss the 'universal' in the term. It turns out not to be so universal at all.

I already have given the Hindu religion and the caste system versus the liberal European standpoint, but I venture to say that is not enough here.

So we take the Japanese whaler who holds cattle in Hyogo for Wagyu (I know such a person, so it is not hypothetical at all).
He slaughters the whale in the most brutal way, whilst hand-massaging his five cows, making sure they have the best life any cattle can have.
To him, the whale does not represent something worth being gentle with, but his prized Wagyu does. The whale has no right to an ethical treatment, whilst his cow does, albeit with the motivation of having the best beef for dinner.

Or we take the words of a Masai when I asked him about what he thinks of racial issues. He stated to me: "White men are unwise, nature has no rights. No lion asks of the antelope if it is right to kill it. The lion does not feel guilty afterward. The sun does not ask if it is right to burn the crops of the farmers. It does not feel at all. The strongest thing does what it does. And that is all there is to it."

The basic problem stems from the 'rationality'. Most western societies follow the Greek concept of rationality, but the majority of the world does not. It uses that word to justify their line of thinking and make it connect to the English words being used in jabbering meta-ethical concepts.

In my eyes, people like Hepburn and Chomsky are nothing but the new, slightly less wigged, extensions of colonial thinkers that state something and think it is truth.
Chomsky is especially a chump, because he deems it necessary to use derisive terms to explain 'moral universalism', which in itself is a contradiction.

(Remember that it states something along the lines of 'what is good for me should be good for you'? So even the way some, and I will not name them because it is quite clear who, forum members think they can act whilst advocating moral universalism is a contradiction to the very idea).

Now, finally, to my personal standpoints:

- I will eat any animal, as long as my digestive system can hack it. Period.
- I will eat human flesh if it fits the social context I am in. Period.
- I will eat any plant, as long as my digestive system can hack it. Period.
- I will eat any mineral, as long as my digestive system can hack it. Period. (Funnily enough I only know of salt as an explicit mineral that we put into our food).

I accept that you may find me a horrible and terrible person because of that. But that is your valuation of me in your specific social context.

The notion of any universal context is silly and contrived.
 
Kevin won't give a source or outline of objective morality. Instead, he tell us to go google it and find it ourselves. Nice way to convince us and change minds, Kevin. Way to go!:rolleyes:
 
Kevin sees attempts to derail the discussion coming, and declines to take part.

If you want to learn about objectivist moral theories I've listed more than one in this thread already, and assuming you can google you can find plenty of literature about them.

However there's not much point in discussing them if you can't grasp the arguments against relativism or complete moral skepticism.

As above. If you were genuinely interested then knowledge is a google search away. If you're just trying to pull the focus off the flaws of your own stated theory, then sorry but I'm not playing your game.
That's the best you can do to justify your obfiscation?

This is a lie. I have explained over and over again the fundamental problems that make relativism incoherent, and Cain has repeatedly pointed out that people who claim that there are no meaningful moral claims are virtually always hypocrites who do hold some moral values.
Boy you can twist and turn, and squirm. Straw man. I never said that there are no moral values or meaningful moral claims.

In fact, I've said over and over, one can make objective statements about morality.

Since I've also stated that I think absolutist moral theories are silly, what's left but objectivist theories?

(For those keeping score, as RandFan would put it, RandFan doesn't seem to have grasped that there is a distinction between objectivist and absolutist moral theories. I don't expect him to figure it out between now and his next post, either. Just don't be confused by his imminent misuse of the terms).
There is no such thing as objective morality.


The problem is that he thinks he just endorsed the deontological, objectivist Golden Rule, which holds that moral action is that action that you would desire of another if your positions were reversed.
  • I desire to be treated justly.
  • I desire to be treated with dignity.
  • I desre to be free from pain and suffering.
  • I desire to be treated in a way that will likely increase my well being.
I should treat others as I desire to be treated. For that reason these are all golden rule statements and no amount of obfuscation will change that. That there is also utility in the golden rule and recognizing that utility DOESN'T obviate the golden rule.
What does RandFan really think? We'll probably never know, because he tries to communicate his ideas by throwing around terms like "hedonistic utilitarianism" and "golden rule" which he had demonstrated he doesn't understand.
I've never used the term "hedonistic utilitarianism".

Nope. Firstly what Cain is advocating is indeed something that has a lot in common with hedonistic utilitarianism, but that one point is as close to intelligibility as RandFan gets at the moment. If RandFan had even the slightest clue about what I've been saying for several pages, he'd realise that from my perspective it is not a criticism to say that something is hedonistic utilitarianism. I like hedonistic utilitarianism. It's an objectivist moral theory that, among other things, leads fairly directly to the conclusion that it's morally wrong to mistreat animals.
Cool that you like hedonistic utilitarianism. There is no utitlity in treating animals the way we would like to be treated. I honestly did missunderstand your position on hedonistic utilitariansm and I confess that it's been sometime since I've heard the therm "hedonistic" used with utilitarianism.

And I've no doubt that you will hapily take rhetorical advantage of my honesty. I wouldn't do like wise but you won't likely ever give me that opportunity.

Secondly, RandFan's three dot points are just completely irrelevant to the ongoing discussion.
Assertion.

I have trouble envisioning any useful moral theory that says it's "not okay" to be nice to people. You can get that conclusion out of relativism, utilitarianism, multiple deontological theories, you name it. So the implied conclusion that anyone who agrees that it's okay to be nice to people must embrace any one particular moral philosophy is so staggeringly dumb that it passes belief.
Now you are just making things up. "Not okay to be nice"?

RandFan: Will you now cease repeating the lie that I have not shown that you are contradicting yourself, and the lie that I have not shown that you do not understand the terms you are abusing?
Where is this contradiction? What terms am I abusing?

You know, if you would simply demonstrate what it is you are saying we could have a discussion.

There is utility in the golden rule. That I point it out ISN'T a contradiction.
 
Last edited:
For the record:

Scenarios:
  1. Someone is trying to kill you and your best chance to survive is to kill them.
  2. Anne Frank is in your attic and the SS is at the door.
  3. During the tenure of Trevelyan at the time of the Irish famine you have an opportunity to steal corn to keep your children alive.
Questions:
  1. Is it objectively immoral to kill?
  2. Is it objectively immoral to lie?
  3. Is it objectively immoral to steal?
So, where is this "objective" morality? What is it exactly? Does it exist a priori?


For those keeping score at home:

  • Kevin won't answer simple questions.
  • Kevin won't tell us what standard he uses for his objective morality all the while demanding that I answer what standard I would use. I could have played his game and obfuscated and been evasive and simply engaged in gainsaying but I answered.
  • Kevin won't give us evidence of objective morality.
  • Kevin won't give us any reason or logic to assume that there is an objective morality.
  • Kevin makes claims about what I've said but won't quote the parts that he claims are contradictory and explain how and why they are contradictory.
  • Kevin thinks that the golden rule is hedonistic utilitarianism.
  • Kevin's modus operandi consists of attacking others and accusing them of being incoherent when he hasn't even the balls to put his philosophy on the table.
You are becoming rather transparent Kevin.
The questions still stand. And you still refuse to answer them.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom