Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

Has Cain or Lowe given us this source of objective morality yet? Have they outlined what these objective morals are?
 
<drivel & snivelling snipped>
Morality is an outgrowth of rationality
<more nonsense snipped>
First: The 'enter' key is your friend! Do not be afraid!

What? When? Prove it, link it, come on.

I'm more offended by your attempts to insult me.
Great, sometimes you just don't ask how it works, as long as it works!

On Jew Jokes...
Priest: And this offends you as a Jewish person?
J. Seinfeld: No, it offends me as a comedian!
You are quoting Seinfeld?

And you think people take you serious? Seriously?
 
Has Cain or Lowe given us this source of objective morality yet? Have they outlined what these objective morals are?
Nah, Cain resorts to more clowny antics and Kevin, well, more of his same.

Do you want me to PM you when either of them finally do? Saves you time from re-reading the same 'not saying anything' nonsense.
 
Has Cain or Lowe given us this source of objective morality yet? Have they outlined what these objective morals are?
27 pages of pleading and begging and demanding and asking and a big fat zero. Cain has tried to pass the golden rule off as objective morality but he doesn't explain how or why it constitutes a valid argument for objective morality.

So no, no evidence. Hell, Cain and Kevin, as far as I can tell, have no formal philosophy whatsoever. They are only here to tell us all that we are wrong and stir the ****.

I know that they think killing and eating animals is wrong. I know that Cain has posited, via Shermer, a derivation of the golden rule argument but beyond that it's "Bupkis mit Kuduchas".
 
Last edited:
The golden rule is objective? At any rate, how in the crap does the golden rule apply to non-humans? Never mind, I know the answer. These people are trying to get others to see non-human animals as people too. Thus, this is where the disagreement is.
 
...specifically the right to torture animals. If someone wants to concede torture is wrong, but it's OK to kill animals painlessly, then that's another argument on another level.
Wait, wait, WAIT! Stop, just stop. Who is advocating the torture of animals?

I like how you just slipped that straw man in.

Cain, the topic of discussion is and has been the killing of animals for the purpose of consumption.

I don't know of anyone advocating the toture of animals.

Many, perhaps most, of us would happily support reduction in animal suffering. PETA has fought for means to kill animals that reduce or eliminate suffering. I've no problem with that
 
Wait, wait, WAIT! Stop, just stop. Who is advocating the torture of animals?

I like how you just slipped that straw man in.

Cain, the topic of discussion is and has been the killing of animals for the purpose of consumption.

I don't know of anyone advocating the toture of animals.

Many, perhaps most, of us would happily support reduction in animal suffering. PETA has fought for means to kill animals that reduce or eliminate suffering. I've no problem with that

That would be my fault. I agreed to the following:

If you call the killing of animals because you want to eat them TORTURE and you want to call the eating of them FUN. Then yes, I am torturing animals for fun.

I still stand by that because it just could have said:

If you call the killing of animals because you want to eat them SBOOGLE and you want to call the eating of them SMOOGLE. Then yes, I am sboogling the animals for smoogle.

Because it means not a thing. It is wordplay and nothing real comes out of his mouth.

Consider me feeling chastised for giving the clown a straw-puppet to play with.
 
You either have a problem understanding or you're just being intentionally obtuse at this point. I'm inclined to conclude the latter.

That's great, but this is not a rebuttal.

You accuse arrogance while displaying it with impunity yourself. I made it clear that there are several ways to cumulatively assess different criteria, and gave one example (and some ways it can be taken). Just because you ignore the fact that I said this doesn't mean I didn't say it. As for the issue of co-evolution: so what? It is what it is. You demanded a distinction and I gave one. Now you're backpedaling out of admitting that there are indeed distinctions to be made.

Not surprisingly, you're confused. If you're saying the co-evolution of dogs and humans is morally meaningless, then I agree, just as the rest of your post was almost completely devoid of relevant content. What's interesting is that you asked for clearly defined parameters, I offered them, and you -- again, not surprisingly -- completely ignore it.

Oh bull. You're just trying to get back to the old "speciesism" canard, which is just a fancy wrapping for your equivocation fallacy.

We went over this in the other thread: you have to demonstrate morally significant differences between humans and animals. For centuries it was more or less alleged the notion of sexism was a form of the equivocation fallacy, and indeed evolutionary psychologists sometimes remark that it's helpful to think of the sexes as different species.

You wanted someone to provide a comparative distinction for different values with animals, and that's what was provided. Just because you don't like the results does not give sufficient justification to ignore the comparison-- or, more correctly, you may very well feel justified in ignoring the comparison, but that damages your own credibility for approaching the subject with intellectual honesty.

Do you want me to apologize because your arguments are lacking?
Whose next? I'll take on all you mental midgets.
--------------------------
TBK:
Actually, I meant that a fetus has NO rights.

I guess you're competing for most shallow member of the opposition. OK, so you said a fetus has rights, but you made a mistake and meant the exact opposite. Neat. You're still refusing to answer the arguments in my post, and notably fail to define a certain key term.

--------------------
RandFan: It seems as though you have nothing to say, which is good actually because you normally write -- though most of it is re-writing -- nonsense that's already been refuted. We can agree to disagree. Now whose next?
-------------
RealPaladin:
What? When? Prove it, link it, come on.

This is nice. You cut out the argument, and then demand an argument. You tell me not be afraid, yet you are too scared to put forth a reply. Shall I copy/paste so that you can avoid it -- no doubt "directly" -- once more? I'm sorry that some of us prefer to think for ourselves instead of hyperlinking.
---------------
A sorry bunch, so let's return to RandFan:

Cain, the topic of discussion is and has been the killing of animals for the purpose of consumption.

I don't know of anyone advocating the toture of animals.

Well, I'm not sure if these words were carefully chosen ("toture" suggests they were not), but let's address it anyway. We need to establish boundaries, and torture is probably a good one since, even though most people, even if they think eating meat is OK, oppose animal torture. Perhaps it's true no one here has advocated torture, but some have said there's nothing wrong with it either.
 
Last edited:
This is nice. You cut out the argument, and then demand an argument. You tell me not be afraid, yet you are too scared to put forth a reply. Shall I copy/paste so that you can avoid it -- no doubt "directly" -- once more? I'm sorry that some of us prefer to think for ourselves instead of hyperlinking.

If you did not prefer whining so much you would have already done that.

And I do not give a hootenanny about you being sorry.

Stop snivelling and whining so much and get with the program.

Hop! What a pathetic excuse for a debater you turn out to be.
 
Last edited:
That would be my fault. I agreed to the following:

If you call the killing of animals because you want to eat them TORTURE and you want to call the eating of them FUN. Then yes, I am torturing animals for fun.
Thank you for that. However we should note that this is all semantics (as that is the point of your argument) and Cain goes out of his way to distinguish actual torture from a word that has been redefined to mean killing and eating an animal.

On the otherand, according to Cain, we all drool and can barely operate a computer much less understand the intricacies of moral philosophy. He has a pet mouse that is ever so much smarter than the rest of us (the rest of us meaning those that disagree with him). I'm still waiting for further episodes in the tail of the mouse. It's quite promising.
 
Last edited:
I guess you're competing for most shallow member of the opposition. OK, so you said a fetus has rights, but you made a mistake and meant the exact opposite. Neat. You're still refusing to answer the arguments in my post, and notably fail to define a certain key term.

--------------------

Yes, somehow the NO didn't make it into my original post about the fetus. However, if you look in any abortion thread, you will see that I have always maintained the position that a fetus has no rights.

I do not think non-human animals have rights either.
 
RandFan: It seems as though you have nothing to say, which is good actually because you normally write -- though most of it is re-writing -- nonsense that's already been refuted. We can agree to disagree. Now whose next?


We can agree on the following (simply because it is demonstrable):
  • I've asked questions you've refused to answer.
  • I've made arguments you refuse to rebut.
  • I've presented propositions you refuse to address.
  • You've refused to advance an argument in favor of your position (beyond some variant of the golden rule which ISN'T objective morality).
Given all that it is fair at this point to conclude that objective morality is likely woo.

If and when you can muster an argument in defense of objective morality I (and likely others) will consider it.

Oh, and please to continue with your heartwarming tale of the mouse. That looked more promising than anything else you've written.
 
Last edited:
That's great, but this is not a rebuttal.

Because you didn't address what I actually said, and instead created some other mistaken meaning from it. When you address what I say you'll get a rebuttal.

Not surprisingly, you're confused. If you're saying the co-evolution of dogs and humans is morally meaningless, then I agree, just as the rest of your post was almost completely devoid of relevant content. What's interesting is that you asked for clearly defined parameters, I offered them, and you -- again, not surprisingly -- completely ignore it.

You offered no parameters except for an apples-to-oranges comparison. Additionally, you're (perhaps intentionally, again) taking what I actually said and ignoring it in favor of what you'd like to assume I said. Some of the criteria for distinction has been laid out for you, and you reject it. As for the co-evolution of dogs and humans (or any domesticated animal and humans), there is indeed significance and arguably a moral meaning to it (depending on the society and culture we're talking about). However, I take it you're going to continue to ignore that as well.

We went over this in the other thread: you have to demonstrate morally significant differences between humans and animals. For centuries it was more or less alleged the notion of sexism was a form of the equivocation fallacy, and indeed evolutionary psychologists sometimes remark that it's helpful to think of the sexes as different species.

As we also went over in the other thread: you claiming there are no morally significant differences does not an argument make. The differences are that they are not humans, and thus not engaged in human moral contracts. Next, you move to your next faulty idea about infants and the mentally infirm, thus continuing the cycle of you trying to find exceptions to the rule instead of acknowledging the rule itself. You're demanding a whole different definition for how morals are created, observed, and applied, yet you provide no more rational reason to do so than an eight-year-old asking an adult "yeah, but what about..."

Do you want me to apologize because your arguments are lacking?
Whose next? I'll take on all you mental midgets.

I don't want you to do anything except provide an actual argument instead of assertions and strawmen. Whether you choose to be a prick while doing so is entirely up to you.
 
<comatose droning deleted>
This is nice. You cut out the argument, and then demand an argument. You tell me not be afraid, yet you are too scared to put forth a reply. Shall I copy/paste so that you can avoid it -- no doubt "directly" -- once more? I'm sorry that some of us prefer to think for ourselves instead of hyperlinking. <snippety for sanity>
Perhaps it's true no one here has advocated torture, but some have said there's nothing wrong with it either.

Whahaha.. man you *are* an epic failure!
 
You know who else said there's nothing wrong with torture? HITLER

See? I win the argument.
 
You know who else said there's nothing wrong with torture? HITLER

See? I win the argument.

Nah, that is too direct and clear cut. You first have to obfuscate it, then go left and right a couple of times, then you have to try and insult everyone, but raise a ruckus if someone insults you and then you just claim victory.

But the nicest thing is Cain is the answer to the title of this thread, and he keepeth giving!
 
:)

I wholeheartedly agree (with one caveat) I'm a moral skeptic. I've no illusions that any argument I make to explain my behavior is subject to confirmation bias and post hoc rationalization. Considering arguments that others have made has lead me to change my positions on many things and I'd like to think that my morals are superior today than they were 20 years ago but I've no arrogance as to that belief.

If by "they" you meant Cain and Kevin then I can't begin to speak for them. I take your point to heart nonetheless.

I'm sorry I missed your earlier post and I thank you for your contributions.

See, that's the way it's supposed to work. Philosophy can be an interesting tool for self-examination. It's neat to examine things in abstraction to determine for yourself why you hold the views you hold, and perhaps challenge them. You can then take these insights gleamed, factor back in the realities, and see where that leaves you.

However, most people just use it for an intellectual pissing contest. And that can be fun in the right context, but it's aggrivating when they feel that they have to do it in every single conversation. It's even more infuriating when they feel that somehow making a rational point about an abstract construct really has some actual meaning.

That's why in this thread they won't answer questions like "where does morality come from" or "who enforces it". These have nothing to do with the points they are trying to make, so they aren't interested in them.

Anyway, I wasn't criticising you. You seem to get it. Keep up the Good Fight.
 
If you did not prefer whining so much you would have already done that.

Ah, so you're looking for any excuse now...

And I do not give a hootenanny about you being sorry.

Um, I wasn't sincere.

Stop snivelling and whining so much and get with the program.

Hop! What a pathetic excuse for a debater you turn out to be.

Yes, I should do as you: avoid debating the topic, and then accuse my opponent of debating the topic. Is your self-parody almost complete? Just continue doing what you do best: mindless head-nodding and hand-jobs; it seems others need your encouragement.

Later, you wrote:
Whahaha.. man you *are* an epic failure!

These non-replies are empowering and time-saving. I am disappointed you're reduced to using the phrase "epic failure" which is almost as bad as "not!" but then again this coming from the comedy stylings of a person who says "seriously?" Your stupidity is unusually bold.
-----------------
TBK:
Yes, somehow the NO didn't make it into my original post about the fetus. However, if you look in any abortion thread, you will see that I have always maintained the position that a fetus has no rights.

I do not think non-human animals have rights either.

I believe it was sincere mistake. What is less forgivable is your habit of cherrypicking one thing -- for example, clarifying in the above post that you do not believe a fetus has rights -- and then ignoring everything else. For the second (or third?) time you have failed to define sapience, much less answer the arguments at hand.
----------------------------
RandFan:
We can agree on the following (simply because it is demonstrable):

I see no reason to dispute your fantasy. I would only strongly encourage you to send to test your moral theories on independent third parties. If you're interested in this topic, and it seems you are, then regurgitate it over on the Internet Infidels board. I would not be surprised if they already have an animal rights thread running, but you could always start your own. Maybe you'll be less emotionally sensitive to their criticisms, and someone there can disabuse you of your crackpot beliefs. Or, maybe -- it's possible -- you can change minds and blaze trails. Be sure to post the thread link here -- I'd like to skim it.
------------------------------
GreNME:
Because you didn't address what I actually said, and instead created some other mistaken meaning from it. When you address what I say you'll get a rebuttal.

I most certainly did: if the standard is sapience, then comparisons must be based on sapience. According to Thaiboxerken, children do not have the same rights and responsibilities as adults because they do not possess the same level of awareness. Your objection -- chimp fetuses to human fetuses -- is laughably off-point. It's like saying to Ken "No, no, no. You should take the adults of today and go back to when they were children in order to make a comparison against children." It's also at odds with the (reasonable) case-by-case standard for the mentally disabled.

You offered no parameters except for an apples-to-oranges comparison.

There are multiple comparisons in the exchange so far, and this reference is unclear. Your apples-and-oranges cliche suggests you're referring to the chimp fetus/human fetus dispute whereas the threading on "parameters" deals with pleasure/pain versus your stuttering nonsense on dogs and goats.

Additionally, you're (perhaps intentionally, again) taking what I actually said and ignoring it in favor of what you'd like to assume I said. Some of the criteria for distinction has been laid out for you, and you reject it. As for the co-evolution of dogs and humans (or any domesticated animal and humans), there is indeed significance and arguably a moral meaning to it (depending on the society and culture we're talking about). However, I take it you're going to continue to ignore that as well.

What's the moral meaning? You have to justify it, and yes, I suspect this is another sloppy version of the naturalistic fallacy.

As we also went over in the other thread: you claiming there are no morally significant differences does not an argument make. The differences are that they are not humans, and thus not engaged in human moral contracts.

Social contracts are unusually popular in this thread. First, it's true that my simply claiming there are no moral differences does not mean there are no moral differences, and of course I've never said that it did. You have to identify those crucial differences. Your last sentence is a joke: Yes, those non-humans are not engaged in HUMAN moral contracts -- that's senseless. More importantly, certain humans are somehow worthy of rights (e.g., children, the mentally disabled, the fetus By what mechanism do you include them? You think that by anticipating this criticism you can avoid it:

Next, you move to your next faulty idea about infants and the mentally infirm, thus continuing the cycle of you trying to find exceptions to the rule instead of acknowledging the rule itself. You're demanding a whole different definition for how morals are created, observed, and applied, yet you provide no more rational reason to do so than an eight-year-old asking an adult "yeah, but what about..."

Demonstrate how it's faulty. It's nice that you have a rule, but you must consistently apply that rule, which should NOT involve "creating a whole different definition..." and so on. There's a simple explanation for why you get and hot bothered on this point, and it's because you're challenged and you cannot generate rational non-arbitrary arguments, as evidenced here and especially in the previous 800 post thread.
 
Cain, I don't have to justify anything morally simply because you've demanded it. You are the one asserting that this is a moral problem. You have to justify that assertion before expecting anyone else to take it seriously. So far, your only justification for this assertion is that people generally do consider some violence to animals to be morally problematic at the very least, which you then take to extremes and demand everyone accept it.

Seriously, that is the heart or your argument. Can you please at least admit that much?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom