thaiboxerken
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Sep 17, 2001
- Messages
- 35,139
Around and around we go. When a legitimate argument appears as to why eating meat is immoral, nobody knows.
BTW: You've been asked many times for evidence of this objective morality and for some odd reason you just ignore the request. And by what standard does one use to come to this "objective" morality? Does objective morality resolve all dilemmas? If not then how can it be objective?
I've asked you these questions but you just ignore them.
I'll ask some more for you to ignore (sorry for the rhyme).
Scenarios:Questions:
- Someone is trying to kill you and your best chance to survive is to kill them.
- Anne Frank is in your attic and the SS is at the door.
- During the tenure of Trevelyan at the time of the Irish famine you have an opportunity to steal corn to keep your children alive.
- Is it objectively immoral to kill?
- Is it objectively immoral to lie?
- Is it objectively immoral to steal?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morality Care to point me to the compulsary part? To help you, you can skip the first descriptive definition.Yes, I have read the sentence: "You have a moral obligation to justify your behavior..." The compulsion or "force" is, um,
moral.
What is laughable is that you have to resort to wordplay and self-reference.You have to be more specific because I have used "obligation" more than once in different contexts. Your earlier post refers to the quoted line above which should not be controversial as it essentially says these matters require serious study. If you want to (risibly) insist otherwise, then I can only imagine your knee-jerk response is the product of the same insouciant disregard for cautious thought. If this is the case, then I'd say your opinions are consistent with your principles.
Now, elsewhere, later on, addressing TBK, I did write: "Most importantly, you completely ignore moral obligations to animals." And by this I meant the sort of "obligations" most people observe without tantrum, such as torture and abuse. I wrote: "Are you, for instance, opposed to laws prohibiting the torture of animals?"
Volatile poses the same question to you directly, and you pouted:
I do appreciate your attempt to completely evade all of these serious issues in order to seize upon a word you never dare put into context.
It's much better to avoid arguments of ideas and insist upon squabbling over words, especially if your notions of morality or, perhaps I should say, "morality" resemble the following:
The trouble with this position is that its dependent upon shifting public opinion. It suggests that if you were rewarded with money and praise (no jail time) -- or whatever you desire -- for killing homosexuals (because they're... homosexuals), then you would have no problem doing so.
The same "reasoning" holds for violence motivated by racism and sexism.
Ok, this is why I hate philosophy...
In this discussion, what does "morality" actually mean? How much weight should we put into maintaining it? Who gets to define the criteria?
For example, the argument has been put forth that eating meat is "immoral" because it causes the suffering of other creatures. How do we arrive at "the suffering of other creatures is immoral"?
Is it immoral to punish a misbehaving child? Is it immoral to ask a friend to help me move or pick me up from the airport? If these things are immoral, and I do them anyway, then what is the punishment? What is the reason for me to behave morally?
This is why I say that morality cannot be rational. Even when you bend over backwards trying to make it rational, you still fail. You have started from an arbitrary, irrational point and then tried to make rational arguments for it. Amending this to "unnecessary suffering" just makes it worse, in that now you've added an arbitrary qualifier to an already arbitrary starting point.
But I don't guess that'll stop anyone from trying...
Scenarios:Questions:
- Someone is trying to kill you and your best chance to survive is to kill them.
- Anne Frank is in your attic and the SS is at the door.
- During the tenure of Trevelyan at the time of the Irish famine you have an opportunity to steal corn to keep your children alive.
So, where is this "objective" morality? What is it exactly? Does it exist a priori?
- Is it objectively immoral to kill?
- Is it objectively immoral to lie?
- Is it objectively immoral to steal?
Why?
Argument: 0 Rhetoric: 100%
No argument here.
Argument: 0 Rhetoric: 100%
No argument here either.
Argument: 0 Rhetoric: 100%
No argument. No rebuttal. No substantive response.
Argument: 0 Rhetoric: 100%
You said: So infants get rights because society perceives killing babies as immoral, and you agree...
Nothing in your post makes clear that I don't think that sociobiology alone should define what we see as moral. Which is dishonest because I've made the point time and time again. Humans give rights to infants because they percieve that as moral but it doesn't mean that it should be that way. We could reason that infants shouldn't have those rights.
--------------------IOW: My point about sociobiology doesn't obviate reason.
...
That you think Singer's claim is critical is, JUST AN ASSERTION!
...
Argument 0%. Rhetoric/personal abuse 100%
But, just to make you happier; let me answer that question directly; if we equal FUN to having a good time while munching them and equal TORTURE to them having to be slaughtered, then my answer is a resounding YES.
Now you equal external rewards to my motivators, whilst I just mentioned that the judgement of my peers was an inhibitor.
I keep saying that my motivators are my own...
But to keep you from another day thinking up nonsense; if any of my motivators would move me to kill homosexuals (which they do not) or become a racist (which they do not) or become a sexist (which they do not), then you would be almost right.
You are not very good at this, are you?
Humans are sapient, it's part of what seperates us from other species. Those humans who are "marginal" tend not to have the full rights and responsibilities as those that do. Children are not allowed to vote, for example. A fetus has rights. The mentally disabled are treated on a case by case basis based on severity.
No, this is not a direct answer. His question asked for your position on making it illegal for people to torture animals for fun.
People do not like you, do they? You make it a sport of saying nothing but trying to effect an air of being 'the bar against which it all is judged'.You're desperately attempting to muddy the issue, much like everything else.
I'll accept whatever corrections on your motivators, as you call them, but asked to cite the moral difference between humans and animals all you could summon are legal consequences, which is a non-argument in free-fall.
As for the aside on one's obligation for thoughtfulness and your appeal to the Wikipedia entry on morality as some kind of gotcha moment... I have nothing to say except you embarrass yourself.
Coming from you this means... almost nothing.
Here again, if mental faculties are your standard, then what are the differences between a fetus and an adult chimpanzee?
The only "what's the difference" question you're trying to beat through to everyone else, Cain, is what would the moral difference be between a human and another animal, and for this criteria you continually fail to lay out parameters for why your conclusion is inherently or intrinsically superior.
Proof please?Cain dismantles it.
It all started so well. We actually had some meat to the bone. There are premises and an actual argument. Here's the problem, The conclusions and premises don't stand in contradiction to anything I've said. I don't have a problem with any of this. In fact, it supports everything I've said.Now, we can explain these differences in behavior. The evolution of the human brain is such that we're not designed to think about people starving to death thousands of miles away. Out of sight, out of mind. Moreover, there's a diffusion of responsibility at work: anybody can help starving African children, but only you can help the man on the side of the road. We drive by people stranded on a busy highway, but an empty desert is another story. So sociobiology, or whatever you want to misunderstand from moment to moment, can explain differences in behavior, but the behavior is still inconsistent with expressed moral values.
Ok, you were doing pretty well there. You have some premises, the bulwark of an argument and then, well, your conclusion is a personal attack against me. ??????If I called a tax the "death tax" a majority of people would oppose it. If I call the same exact tax the "estate tax" a majority of people would endorse it. Same tax, different framing. Just because people perceive them as different does not mean they are different, and yes through reason people are capable of seeing how they're the same. We know -- the people arguing against you i.e., your betters -- we all know people perceive things in certain ways, act in other ways, and fail to expand the moral circle. You cannot understand this because your brain power is so slight that if I compared it to a mouse, and if a mouse was capable of understanding the comparison, and if a mouse was capable of expressing outrage, and if he was capable of speaking words, then he would call me names. And he'd be justified.
So, having tried and failed to make a coherent argument that rebutted anything I've said it's back to rhetoric, personal attack and quaint stories of mice.You see what I just did there? The "rhetoric," as you call it, is a result of your repeated failure to make the most elementary connections. Read a ****ing book on the basics of moral philosophy some time. Yeah, yeah, yeah -- no, really read one. And if you have, then, I dunno, try reading another one. Maybe you'd stop saying dumb **** like this:
I like it because it whiles away the hours and I get see silly characters write things using 'foreign' words to make them look smarter. I like Cain, he is quite the clown.![]()
Unless you want to accept that anyone else has something to say about your life, the anser is simpe: You, and you alone.
All else is just hoping that the brutes don't start raising their clubs again and start bashing our heads in.
That question is the basis of my skirmishes here.
Misused by aforementioned clown; the only reason should be your personal inhibitors.
Meaning, you do not like to see someone suffer, you do not want to bother your friend etc.
But they are yours and yours alone.
Very astute.
Not only that, they will, with the zeal of religious fanatics, try to convince you that there is something to their diarrhea of words.
But people like RandFan, and to some degree me, are nothing if not tenacious in trying to point these things out to them.
Holy crap, Cain, we've been through this already. You seem really fond of apples-to-oranges equivocations. Compare a human fetus to a chimp fetus (or an adult chimp to an adult human), and you might have a useful comparison.
But let's stick to non-humans for a second: an adult dog can read my body language and in many ways understand it, which makes it capable of a feat that chimps are not. Chimps can be taught through operant conditioning to respond appropriately to a degree that seems similar, while dogs have this skill inherently (video). This sets up a social framework between dogs and humans that is not evident between chimps and humans, which not only displays a difference in value that humans inevitably place between a dog and a chimp, but also displays a difference in the cognitive awareness (sapience) between a human and a chimp compared to the difference of the same between a human and a dog.
The only "what's the difference" question you're trying to beat through to everyone else, Cain, is what would the moral difference be between a human and another animal, and for this criteria you continually fail to lay out parameters for why your conclusion is inherently or intrinsically superior.
Kill people, torture animals. There is no objective morality.
<self-censored a statement on Cain's presumed sexual problems>
He is Cain, he is not able.
Well, in their own limited perspective, they are probably hitting on all of the correct points and they seem to think they making good arguments. However, even the best philosophical argument is little better than pre-season scouting reports. They may be interesting, but don't mean a damn thing once the ball is in play.But people like RandFan, and to some degree me, are nothing if not tenacious in trying to point these things out to them.
According to Kevin this won't fly, it can lead to hedonistic relativism.Let's return to Shermer's comment up-thread on animal torture where he asks, "Is it OK if I torture you?" If a person answers that it's not OK, then the argument becomes something like "what makes you so special?" That is to say, if you believe that it's not OK for someone to torture you, then you should believe it's not OK to torture anyone, assuming similar circumstances.
Proof please?
See, here is where you get called on your BS. If this were true you could demonstrate it.
It all started so well. We actually had some meat to the bone. There are premises and an actual argument. Here's the problem, The conclusions and premises don't stand in contradiction to anything I've said. I don't have a problem with any of this. In fact, it supports everything I've said.
I guess I have to make myself more clear.
Could you even bullet point the propositions you think I believe and then rebut those? Here I'll give you an example of propositions that I believe in.
- Yes I want argument.
- However I want the argument to address something specific that I believe.
- When I say "address" I don't want it to agree with me if you are going to then tell me I'm wrong. Can you see how that is problematic?
- Sociobiology can and does lead to contradiction and inconsistency.
Asinine. If the standard is sapience, then comparisons are based on awareness, not age (or development).
This is an extremely narrow criterion, and an anthropocentric one owing to the co-evolution of humans and dogs. Other animals in different environments are sensitive to the movements of predators or prey.
It's been mentioned many times: first, the capacity to experience pleasure and pain, which, if you have been following along, sort of explains the attempt by myself and others to establish fundamentals, specifically the right to torture animals. If someone wants to concede torture is wrong, but it's OK to kill animals painlessly, then that's another argument on another level. But let's go to the basement, for RealPaladin, who writes:
[snip]
The problem with this position, if we try to put its ridiculousness aside, is that the proponent of such a view probably does not apply it consistently, you or anyone. Let's return to Shermer's comment up-thread on animal torture where he asks, "Is it OK if I torture you?" If a person answers that it's not OK, then the argument becomes something like "what makes you so special?" That is to say, if you believe that it's not OK for someone to torture you, then you should believe it's not OK to torture anyone, assuming similar circumstances. There might be circumstances where you think torture is appropriate; you may believe it's permissible for the government to waterboard suspected terrorists, but again, consistency would require that you agree it's OK for the government to waterboard you if you're suspected of terrorism. Morality is an outgrowth of rationality, and you can jump up and down, hold your breath until your face turns blue, attempt at every turn to blather nonsense and avoid arguments, cry there is no objective morality, and that's fine... but you're still agitating for a position that is irrational because it's internally incoherent. And just as reason dispenses of egoism, it takes care of nationalism, racism, sexism, and speciesism.
So I try to make them see. And you try that as well.They are vomiting up a preconcieved argument that uses terms and concepts that have absolutely no relation to the way these concepts are used from any other perspective.
Can you spot a poster that churns out verbiage to that effect? (rethorical)Philosophy is an abstraction that has some merit as a thought exercise, but very little real world signifigance. The problem with it is some people, especially college kids being exposed to it for the first time, seem to think that it is end all and be all of all thought.
Because of the inherent superiority they put in this fake abstraction, then won't accept any arguments from any other perspective and thus end up close minded and dense.
It's really a sad progression.
I know where actual morality comes from. It's called "mores" in sociology, so's not to step on the toes of the religious, but it's the same thing. It's an unspoken social contract between people in a society.
It also comes from biology. Humans are so hard-wired towards making these contracts that we'll make them just about anything, one sided though they may be. I personally have social contracts out on everything from my dog, to my car, to my xbox. I realize that these are irrational, but the biological urge is so strong that I can't really help it.
Agreed.I suspect that this is actually what's going on here, and the philosophical backflips are just a way to justify it.
And yet no one has bothered answering it. Suffering in some form or another is a quality of life. If causing it is inherently immoral, then every creature to have ever walked on this Earth is immoral.
True, but with the caveat "within the standards of society". You can't just pick and choose your level of moral behavior randomly.
You are welcome.Thank you.
Well, in their own limited perspective, they are probably hitting on all of the correct points and they seem to think they making good arguments. However, even the best philosophical argument is little better than pre-season scouting reports. They may be interesting, but don't mean a damn thing once the ball is in play.
And this is exactly where your position unravels. The case for animals accords rights in keeping with their awareness; dogs do not get the "right to vote," for example, because they have no concept of or interest in voting. Perhaps it would help if you define sapience because certain beliefs expressed above suggests it does not mean what you think it means. If you're somehow willing to grant rights to a fetus, then you should be at least just as willing to grant similar rights to animals with similar levels of awareness. Here again, if mental faculties are your standard, then what are the differences between a fetus and an adult chimpanzee?
Oh goody... I'm so happy I could just ****.A separate post for you, my dear:
And if I can reference the dozens of pages past, you will examine them closely for the first time, and then realize your mistake. Please.As if I can reference the dozens of pages past, you will examine them closely for the first time, and then realize your mistake. Please.
Rhetorical. Assertion.Again, you just have no idea what you're talking about. You're making a category error -- failing to observe the normative-descriptive distinction. The rest is theater. You can bullet point all you want, pretending that the form lends your arguments substance.
Surprise, surprise surprise. No argument. Plenty of assertion.What's most remarkable here is that you're not responding to the argument as laid out. I get this "meat on the bone," and "you were doing pretty well there" encouragement, but it means nothing. You're running away by restating a case that has been dismantled multiple times by Kevin and myself.