GreNME
Philosopher
- Joined
- Sep 16, 2007
- Messages
- 8,276
Not really.
What we have, on the one hand, is a line drawn consistently and rationally - that is, a line that is drawn for a specific set of reasons on an internally-consistent set of bases.
That can't be said of the meat-eating position - note Paladin, who denies he draws a line and then baulks at torturing kittens, TBK who just goes with the status quo, and others who refuse even to recognise diet as an issue where "reason" plays a part at all.
It is, and always has been, about consistency, coherency and rationality. You really haven't described any "underlying concepts" at all; you've just declared my [our] position as arbitrary as any other, which simply isn't true.
Come on, you're ignoring loads of posts that describe otherwise. You keep backtracking to individuals when RandFan and I have been talking about the larger social groups. RandFan has done this to a greater degree than I have, but we've both described the social and cultural conditions that people work from, and not always individuals separately. Talk to any individual separately and you're going to get a less-distilled, often simpler initial breakdown of the rationality you're demanding. Meanwhile, Cain, Kevin, and (it seems) yourself are speaking on collectivist terms with regard to a veg[etari]an diet and its (allegedly collective) moral reasoning. I don't think you're intentionally comparing apples to oranges in this sense or I would have called you on it, Volatile, but that has been the result in the disagreements in perspective in the thread.
That's an argument in favour of sustainably-farmed corn and soy, not an argument not to eat corn and soy at all.
But I don't have to argue against eating corn and soy (or any other plants), because I think they're a valid food source. However, my arguments are against the mass-production food industry as a whole, which runs the gamut of destructive practices and doesn't simply become better for the world by switching the balance between meat and produce. The bad behavior here is in the industries themselves thinking they can get more without having adverse impacts, and that applies in a real sense to the mass-production industry as a whole-- who can and sometimes does find better ways, meaning they aren't totally worth removing (this is not an anti-corporation argument)-- and not just about trying to pit one type of food industry against another. When it comes to resource management, the give-and-take can come very close to a zero-sum game, and the food industry's development, processing, and distribution practices exemplify this in meat as well as produce, so it's not like it can be ignored in one while simultaneously being a talking point for the other.