Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

Not really.

What we have, on the one hand, is a line drawn consistently and rationally - that is, a line that is drawn for a specific set of reasons on an internally-consistent set of bases.

That can't be said of the meat-eating position - note Paladin, who denies he draws a line and then baulks at torturing kittens, TBK who just goes with the status quo, and others who refuse even to recognise diet as an issue where "reason" plays a part at all.

It is, and always has been, about consistency, coherency and rationality. You really haven't described any "underlying concepts" at all; you've just declared my [our] position as arbitrary as any other, which simply isn't true.

Come on, you're ignoring loads of posts that describe otherwise. You keep backtracking to individuals when RandFan and I have been talking about the larger social groups. RandFan has done this to a greater degree than I have, but we've both described the social and cultural conditions that people work from, and not always individuals separately. Talk to any individual separately and you're going to get a less-distilled, often simpler initial breakdown of the rationality you're demanding. Meanwhile, Cain, Kevin, and (it seems) yourself are speaking on collectivist terms with regard to a veg[etari]an diet and its (allegedly collective) moral reasoning. I don't think you're intentionally comparing apples to oranges in this sense or I would have called you on it, Volatile, but that has been the result in the disagreements in perspective in the thread.

That's an argument in favour of sustainably-farmed corn and soy, not an argument not to eat corn and soy at all.

But I don't have to argue against eating corn and soy (or any other plants), because I think they're a valid food source. However, my arguments are against the mass-production food industry as a whole, which runs the gamut of destructive practices and doesn't simply become better for the world by switching the balance between meat and produce. The bad behavior here is in the industries themselves thinking they can get more without having adverse impacts, and that applies in a real sense to the mass-production industry as a whole-- who can and sometimes does find better ways, meaning they aren't totally worth removing (this is not an anti-corporation argument)-- and not just about trying to pit one type of food industry against another. When it comes to resource management, the give-and-take can come very close to a zero-sum game, and the food industry's development, processing, and distribution practices exemplify this in meat as well as produce, so it's not like it can be ignored in one while simultaneously being a talking point for the other.
 
I guess I'm on your ignore now since you've not responded to my last half dozen responses over the last couple of days to you (I think it's that many).

*Dennett notes, there is a trade off in benifits. The animals get to live. They are statisically assured of surviving their birth. And, they get to live (by and large and day to day) free from the elments, disease, predators, etc.

That these animals would not exist is not a compelling argument. When we kill them they won't exist.

*Dennetts argument is specifically about sheep and he doesn't state that they exist for the purpose of eating meat and I don't want to put words in his mouth. His point could be made for wool production, though that would be somewhat weasely. We don't know as he doesn't make that distincion.

Not on my ignore, no. Just didn't get round to you.

If you want to save them - if that is your reason - then killing them for meat becomes even less justifiable.
 
If altrusim is your reason - if you want to save animals from the wild - then raise them and keep them until old age.
There is simply not the reasources. The ability to do this is based on the trade off. The animal provides benifits to us and we to them and that is why we do it.
 
If you want to save them - if that is your reason - then killing them for meat becomes even less justifiable.
I don't want to simply save them. I want to give them an opportunity to live, to survive their birth, to be free from the elments and disease. It's a trade off.
 
How many grains are there in a heap? If you can't tell me exactly, then there's no difference between a single grain and a heap!

That's the fallacy of the heap. The assertion that if the line between two categories is not firm, then those categories are meaningless.

Huh ? It's the same for abortion: if they couldn't pick an arbitrary line at which abortion was no longer legal then they never would've come up with the damn law. You're trying to make a case for an objective reason why one should or shouldn't eat this and that. It better be well-defined.

Fine. So what? How does that justify eating those that do?

Your criterion is incompatible with your claim, Volatile. That's all I'm saying. If you think that taking down an argument for your claim is a claim for mine (assuming I had one) then you don't know much about skepticism.

I think "death" is suffering.

Sure thing, Vol. And not collecting stamps is a hobby.

Killing something is inflicting suffering, and not just semantically. Cain's touched on this in his posts on "interests".

How so ? Because you rob the being of its interest in living ? It that's why then again you are being inconsistent because this AGAIN applies to plants and mushrooms. And bacteria.

What's your issue with killing your kittens and using them as target practice? After all, the kitten's dead, right?

I don't want to kill my kitten (if I had one) and it's not legal to do so for such a reason. I don't like killing or hurting animals (except bugs), because it's simply not something I do. I also do not like killing or damaging plants, but I eat them, too.

If altrusim is your reason - if you want to save animals from the wild - then raise them and keep them until old age.

No, I'm happy to pay other people to do it for me.

If your "reasons" for eating meat really are to save them from the vicissitudes of life, how can you justify killing them? You're making it up as you go along.

No, I'm not. You are incapable of differentiating between a counter-argument against YOUR claim and an argument for MY claim. It's exactly the same thing yrreg is doing in the other thread, thinking that just because we don't know how the universe came into being then it MUST be god who did it.

I was saying that the harm of farming animals, to the animals themselves, is less than the harm said animal would endure in the wild. I'm saying that there is no harm in farming animals that are otherwise well-treated.

Meat eating causes clear and demonstrable harms.

Such as ?

So show me why it's worth doing. What's so hard? You must have a reason, surely? A reason that is clear and sensible and rational? Don't you?

Broken record:

You're still not getting it. I don't need to justify myself to you. YOU are making a claim that eating meat is WRONG. YOU need to justify yourself.
 
Last edited:
Come on, you're ignoring loads of posts that describe otherwise. You keep backtracking to individuals when RandFan and I have been talking about the larger social groups.
Yes, a point I would very much like to emphasize. Sociobiology doesn't tell us much about any specific individuals behavior. Personally, as I've said in this thread prior, I'm skeptical of the reasons for my moral behavior.

But as Volitile has asked, I do live an examined life. I have had considered the arguments for many ethical moral issues. I've been willing to be objective and set aside my personal bias.
 
Well, clearly that's because you're one of heroes. So, according to you people can abuse animals if they say so desire. Cool. Presumably you think it's wrong to torture humans. What, in your view, are the morally significant differences between a human and (say) a chimpanzee?

Sapience. That's the difference.

So this principle does not apply to social norms in other countries?

No, it does not. I live in the USA where one of the key principles is the freedom to do as one wishes, as long as it hasn't been shown to be harmful to society.
 
Seems to me that the "none is the logical end to less" argument isn't being made by Volatile anymore. I wonder why.........
 
I agree that animal harm is concerning, to me at leats, and is the reason why I've considered going vegeterian,
That used to concern me too. I found the environmental argument fairly persuasive 30 some years ago. I tried being vegetarian. It lasted about a month. My mother was furious at me. My father wasn't very happy either. Worst of all, I really missed eating meat.

It's very cultural, but it's also gender related. My boss, who is Malaysian, complained with a good-bye lunch for an employee who was leaving was at a vegetarian restaurant. Our office manager told him he was truly an American now, which got a big laugh from everyone in the office. American men want to eat meat. We spent the rest of the day asking everyone who came in if he would object to eating at a vegetarian restaurant. Every single male except one Asian guy said they would object. No female would have minded. Non-scientific, but interesting, eh?

At any rate, I have a family. At this point, I'm the only female in the household. Meatless meals get complaints. I think the point of the discussion is simply to bring into people's minds and make them think more about it. It's interesting to hear the arguments again. They haven't really changed much except that the environmental impact argument is cloudier to me now. It's really really hard to accurately gauge the comparative impact. There are so many variables, it's really hard to draw a firm conclusion.
 
I never said that what was "percieved" was correct. I've never said that. And I agree that we must seriously investigate and examine our perceptions.

*sigh* I did not say you said that. Pay attention, you use the non-committal word "perceives" because you're incapable of following through on arguments.

On effing babies to cure AIDS:
A.) I find the idea reprehensive. B.) It doesn't work.

If (B) were not true I'd have to reconsider it. You?

Yes, if B) were true then I'd too have to consider it... for not much longer than an instant. Now if you only gave as much consideration to your naturalistic fallacy nonsense as you do to child molestation your views might actually have some substance.

That you think it was explained doesn't mean that it was. I've explained to you in pages 5-15 why it is relevant.

If 10+ pages did not disabuse you of your elementary mistake, then I don't think it would be possible to do so in this umpteenth post.

Whenever I see a list from you or a red font I know almost for certain that's its special ********:

Yes, but here is where you make your error.
  • I don't claim that our perceptions of what is moral is beyond question.
  • I don't claim that should we have sufficient reason to kill babies that we couldn't kill babies.

This cycles back to the above. It's amusing because you quote me, agree, and then when alleging an error you completely fail to quote me, or engage anything I said.

Sociobiology works. It works very well. It has given us altruism, empathy, compassion and other tools for behaving in a social arena (See Pinker et al). However our morality doesn't stop with sociobiology. We can and ought to use reason to better shape our morals.

You're speaking out of your butthole, and I like how Belz gives you a reach-around to encourage this bit of nonsense. But it has already been addressed.

Actually it was about primates.

This is your "You forgot about Poland!" gaff. You can't come up with an actual argument, but you have to say something. The only difference is that Kerry did fail to mention Poland. I suggest you follow threading:

C:So again how do you include chimps?
RF: They have higher brain functions than many other animals.
C: how is that morally relevant?
RF: I was impressed by an argument made by Peter Singer to consider enlarging our circle. He made it about primates and I can't find it at the moment but his argument for whales is pretty close.


You're such a clown.

If Singer had intended for this to be his only premise then he should have only stated this premise. If this were the only premise then I wouldn't have changed my position.

Let's drop this "only premise" nonsense. I know, I know, you like to have lots of premises because that way it's easier for you to say whatever you please. Let's just refer to Singer's claim here as critical, and it is, and you ignored it.

--------------------
Volatile wrote:
Cain, take over, buddy - I'm going home for the weekend and don't have internet at home.

**** you, no.

------------------------------
TBK on the differences between humans and animals:

Sapience. That's the difference.

This harkens back to Lowe's comments on potentiality because if that's your standard, then you need to somehow reconcile the accepted rights of rational adult humans with marginal cases (e.g., children, mentally disabled, PVS, fetsuses).

No, it does not. I live in the USA where one of the key principles is the freedom to do as one wishes, as long as it hasn't been shown to be harmful to society.

By "society" I take it you mean human society, which suggests you're not even open to the idea of animal rights. In the U.S. the vast majority of people also condemn animal abuse. Do you imagine they oppose animal torture because such abuses are harmful to society? Perhaps some do, but I'd guess most oppose harming animals because it's wrong to needlessly cause animals pain. See (again) the first post in my thread, "Admit it, you believe in animal rights."
 
Yes, if B) were true then I'd too have to consider it... for not much longer than an instant.
Why?

Argument: 0 Rhetoric: 100%

Now if you only gave as much consideration to your naturalistic fallacy nonsense as you do to child molestation your views might actually have some substance.
No argument here.

Argument: 0 Rhetoric: 100%

If 10+ pages did not disabuse you of your elementary mistake, then I don't think it would be possible to do so in this umpteenth post.
No argument here either.

Argument: 0 Rhetoric: 100%

Whenever I see a list from you or a red font I know almost for certain that's its special ********:
No argument. No rebuttal. No substantive response.

Argument: 0 Rhetoric: 100%

This cycles back to the above. It's amusing because you quote me, agree, and then when alleging an error you completely fail to quote me, or engage anything I said.
Irony of Irony. You constantly claim I say things without quoting me. You constantly refuse to address my points but instead choose to belittle me and resort to rhetorical device.

Argument: 0 Rhetoric: 100%

In any event, I did quote you.

You said: So infants get rights because society perceives killing babies as immoral, and you agree...

Nothing in your post makes clear that I don't think that sociobiology alone should define what we see as moral. Which is dishonest because I've made the point time and time again. Humans give rights to infants because they percieve that as moral but it doesn't mean that it should be that way. We could reason that infants shouldn't have those rights.

IOW: My point about sociobiology doesn't obviate reason. You won't acknowledge that fact because it doesn't fit your straw man position that you have invented for me.

You're speaking out of your butthole, and I like how Belz gives you a reach-around to encourage this bit of nonsense. But it has already been addressed.
Argument: 0 Rhetoric: 100%

C:So again how do you include chimps?
RF: They have higher brain functions than many other animals.
C: how is that morally relevant?
RF: I was impressed by an argument made by Peter Singer to consider enlarging our circle. He made it about primates and I can't find it at the moment but his argument for whales is pretty close.

Given that Singer's argument addressed higer brain functions I'm happy to stand by that.

You're such a clown.
Argument: 0% Personal abuse: 100%

Let's drop this "only premise" nonsense. I know, I know, you like to have lots of premises because that way it's easier for you to say whatever you please. Let's just refer to Singer's claim here as critical, and it is, and you ignored it.
It was Singer's argument. Singer chose which premises to include. I didn't force them on him. He must have had a reason to include them. You certainly don't address them or rebutt them. That you think Singer's claim is critical is, JUST AN ASSERTION!

Argument: 0. Rhetoric: 100%

Your post:
Argument 0%.
Rhetoric/personal abuse 100%
 
Last edited:
BTW: Knowing you it's probably a good idea to define argument. I'd like to suggest Monty Python's definition as provided in the argument clinic.



An argument is an intelectual process. A connected series of statements to establish a definite proposition.
 
This harkens back to Lowe's comments on potentiality because if that's your standard, then you need to somehow reconcile the accepted rights of rational adult humans with marginal cases (e.g., children, mentally disabled, PVS, fetsuses).

There is nothing to reconcile. Humans are sapient, it's part of what seperates us from other species. Those humans who are "marginal" tend not to have the full rights and responsibilities as those that do. Children are not allowed to vote, for example. A fetus has rights. The mentally disabled are treated on a case by case basis based on severity.

By "society" I take it you mean human society, which suggests you're not even open to the idea of animal rights.

You are correct, I'm not open to the idea of animal rights.
 
Ok, this is why I hate philosophy...

In this discussion, what does "morality" actually mean? How much weight should we put into maintaining it? Who gets to define the criteria?

For example, the argument has been put forth that eating meat is "immoral" because it causes the suffering of other creatures. How do we arrive at "the suffering of other creatures is immoral"? Is it immoral to punish a misbehaving child? Is it immoral to ask a friend to help me move or pick me up from the airport? If these things are immoral, and I do them anyway, then what is the punishment? What is the reason for me to behave morally?

This is why I say that morality cannot be rational. Even when you bend over backwards trying to make it rational, you still fail. You have started from an arbitrary, irrational point and then tried to make rational arguments for it. Amending this to "unnecessary suffering" just makes it worse, in that now you've added an arbitrary qualifier to an already arbitrary starting point.

But I don't guess that'll stop anyone from trying...
 
This is why I say that morality cannot be rational. Even when you bend over backwards trying to make it rational, you still fail. You have started from an arbitrary, irrational point and then tried to make rational arguments for it. Amending this to "unnecessary suffering" just makes it worse, in that now you've added an arbitrary qualifier to an already arbitrary starting point.

But I don't guess that'll stop anyone from trying...
I tried to get Kevin Lowe to admit that any starting point takes into account feelings (suffering) and feelings are natural and that we don't want to suffer is a natural desire.

That's a bit of non-starter with absolutists though.
 
BS.
BS. Assertion. Just as one can make objective statements about art one can make objective statements about morality.

That doesn't make either objective. I've explained this to you before.

That I can find utility in something doesn't mean that I must accept absolute morality. Your argument is spurious.

You keep referring to objectivist moral theories as absolutist. I have explained to you repeatedly that this is an error. Please knock it off.

Now let's try explaining this one more time. You claim that there is no such thing as objective morality. Yet you also claim that we can improve on our instincts by means of reason. But by what standards are such alterations improvements?

If they are improvements by some higher standard, then you're de facto embracing objectivist morality. If not, then you're just trading one set of utterly baseless prejudices and rituals for another.

I'm charitably assuming you comprehend the idea of consistency and accept that it is necessary for rationality.

We don't have to be slaves to our sociobiology. We CAN reason better morals.

Better by what standard? If it's just because you like it better then you aren't reasoning your way to better morals, you're just making up justifications after the fact by appropriating whatever philosophy or science you think supports your latest whim.

Where? You just make stuff up and expect that everyone is going to accept whatever you say. That is rather arrogant of you.

We don't have to be slaves to our biology. Humans have brains. We can reason. If you argue that eating meat isn't ok I can argue that it is. The question then becomes if either arguments are valid and are compelling.

You are not the grand arbiter and you don't really get to tell me that I don't get to argue.

You get to argue if you do it rationally and consistently. If you can't manage that then you are not entitled to an opinion.

If your ego demands that you refuse to acknowledge my arguments or that you must see a contradiction that's fine but you damn sure haven't demonstrated a contradiction. You just assert, over and over, argument ad nauseam.

It wasn't true before it isn't true now and asserting something over and over isn't logically valid argument.

Get over yourself. That you assert that there is a contradiction doesn't mean that there is one.

I've explained the contradictions repeatedly. If you can't grasp the fact that you are talking nonsense after the same mistake has been explained to you more times than I care to think about it I can't take responsibility for your failings.

You can pile relativism and utilitarianism and the naturalistic fallacy on your plate all at once and call it "nuance", but it's not nuance, it's pseudo-intellectual incoherence. It's meaningless.
 
You keep referring to objectivist moral theories as absolutist. I have explained to you repeatedly that this is an error. Please knock it off.
Says the guy who constructs a thousand straw men from my views.

You claim that there is no such thing as objective morality.
Bingo.... ding, ding, ding...

BTW: You've been asked many times for evidence of this objective morality and for some odd reason you just ignore the request. And by what standard does one use to come to this "objective" morality? Does objective morality resolve all dilemmas? If not then how can it be objective?

I've asked you these questions but you just ignore them.

I'll ask some more for you to ignore (sorry for the rhyme).


Scenarios:
  1. Someone is trying to kill you and your best chance to survive is to kill them.
  2. Anne Frank is in your attic and the SS is at the door.
  3. During the tenure of Trevelyan at the time of the Irish famine you have an opportunity to steal corn to keep your children alive.
Questions:
  1. Is it objectively immoral to kill?
  2. Is it objectively immoral to lie?
  3. Is it objectively immoral to steal?
So, where is this "objective" morality? What is it exactly? Does it exist a priori?

Yeah, you and I both know you won't answer the questions because that's not what you do. You live in some ivory tower where you need not even consider arguments or bother with questions.

In your world you are right and everyone else is wrong and if they don't like it then you will respond by attacking them personally and asserting all kinds of things.

Yet you also claim that we can improve on our instincts by means of reason.
{sigh} Do you go out of your way to be wrong? NOT "instincts". Adaptive behavior (see de Waal, Dawkins, Pinker, Wilson). Sheesh. How many times must you be told?

But by what standards are such alterations improvements?
Are you kidding? This is a ridiculous question at this stage of the discussion. It clearly demonstrates that you haven't a god damn clue what the hell I'm talking about.

It depends on your premises. If you assume that increased well being and decreased suffering is good then one needs to simply do the math.

By the way, I didn't invent that standard.

According to Stephen Pinker, homicide and violence has decreased steadily for thousands of years. According to the UN, modern liberal democracies score higher in HDI than other nations.

Why?


According to Michael Shermer (and Dawkins, and de Waal, and Wilson, et al):
  • Most of care that others don't suffer.
  • Most of want well being.
We, as a near universal, perceive that these things are good.

Better by what standard?
(see above)

I've explained the contradictions repeatedly.
No you haven't and there are no contradictions. I can't prove a negative. However you and I both know that all you are going to do is to keep repeating the same tired line over and over.

You can pile relativism and utilitarianism and the naturalistic fallacy on your plate all at once and call it "nuance", but it's not nuance, it's pseudo-intellectual incoherence. It's meaningless.
And you will go on and on and on and on asserting and claiming and asserting and claiming and won't provide evidence or proof or answer questions, etc..

I'm happy and proud to stand by my record in this thread. I've not resorted to the kind of assertions and rhetoric that you and Cain have to make my case.
 
Last edited:
Says the guy who constructs a thousand straw men from my views.

[That would be a tu quoque argument even if it was true, and it's not. The advantage of an incoherent position like yours is that you can call literally any demand for consistency a straw man.

Now are you going to knock it off, or what?

Yeah, you and I both know you won't answer the questions because that's not what you do. You live in some ivory tower where you need not even consider arguments or bother with questions.

That's because I know what you're up to. You can't actually address the criticism of incoherence, because your position is blatantly incoherent. So you try to drag in every moral dilemma in sight and then demand that someone else solve them for you, the next move presumably being that if you can pick some nit or other with a provided solution that your incoherent position is therefore validated.

Address the issue of incoherence and then we can move forward.

In your world you are right and everyone else is wrong and if they don't like it then you will respond by attacking them personally and asserting all kinds of things.

As I have said many, many times before you don't often get to be certain about philosophical matters but I can be damned sure that an incoherent position is worthless. If someone sticks to an incoherent position after being shown that it is incoherent there's nothing further to say except "You're not capable of telling sense from nonsense, and until you develop that ability attempting to have a sensible conversation is a doomed endeavour".

{sigh} Do you go out of your way to be wrong? NOT "instincts". Adaptive behavior (see de Waal, Dawkins, Pinker, Wilson). Sheesh. How many times must you be told?

Are you kidding? This is a ridiculous question at this stage of the discussion. It clearly demonstrates that you haven't a god damn clue what the hell I'm talking about.

It depends on your premises. If you assume that increased well being and decreased suffering is good then one needs to simply do the math.

By the way, I didn't invent that standard.

According to Stephen Pinker, homicide and violence has decreased steadily for thousands of years. According to the UN, modern liberal democracies score higher in HDI than other nations.

Why?


According to Michael Shermer (and Dawkins, and de Waal, and Wilson, et al):
  • Most of care that others don't suffer.
  • Most of want well being.
We, as a near universal, perceive that these things are good.

Around and around the merry-go-round we go. This is hedonistic utilitarianism, an objectivist moral philosophy. If you stuck with this consistently we could have an intelligent conversation.

You aren't going to, though. The minute you are uncomfortable with any conclusion generated by hedonistic utilitarianism, you'll run and hide behind some totally incompatible theory than justifies your existing prejudices, and then you'll claim with a straight face that you are being completely consistent and you always have been.

No you haven't and there are no contradictions. I can't prove a negative. However you and I both know that all you are going to do is to keep repeating the same tired line over and over.

This is pathetic: It's like complaining that your maths teacher "asserts" that 2 plus 2 is 4 over and over again and you're tired of it.

The answer isn't going to change just because you repeat the same claim over and over again. That isn't how logic works.

Being a relativist-of-convenience and an objectivist-of-convenience and a nihilist-of-convenience and pulling whichever line from whichever source happens to suit your prejudices this instant is inevitably going to lead you to contradict yourself.

Now either pull up a seat at the table of reason, where you are expected to be coherent and consistent, or go play with the woo-woos.
 
Funny side-note: I'm currently watching the film version of Harlan Ellison's A Boy and His Dog, not-ironically, with my own dog. My better half told me that my own dog and I practically communicate as well as Vic and Blood, sans the misogyny and dystopian values. Oh, my dog (Flynn) and I don't have deep or philosophical conversations, but we communicate plenty well enough.

That, essentially, is why I wouldn't eat him. It's also why PETA is so stupid-- they don't seem to understand this type of relationship, and would seemingly prefer I either treat him like a person or have no interaction with him at all (or only "from a distance").
 
That would be a tu quoque argument...
Only if I tried to justify my behavior by what you do.

Now are you going to knock it off, or what?
Get over yourself. This nonsense isn't going to fly. Make an argument or move on.

You live in some ivory tower where you need not even consider arguments or bother with questions.
That's because I know what you're up to.
Thanks for proving me right.

You can't actually address the criticism of incoherence, because your position is blatantly incoherent. So you try to drag in every moral dilemma in sight and then demand that someone else solve them for you, the next move presumably being that if you can pick some nit or other with a provided solution that your incoherent position is therefore validated.
All assertion. No argument.

Address the issue of incoherence and then we can move forward.
Browbeating. Rhetorical. There is no incoherence.

As I have said many, many times before you don't often get to be certain about philosophical matters but I can be damned sure that an incoherent position is worthless. If someone sticks to an incoherent position after being shown that it is incoherent there's nothing further to say except "You're not capable of telling sense from nonsense, and until you develop that ability attempting to have a sensible conversation is a doomed endeavour".
Blah, blah, blah. Words. Rhetoric. You are a bit too taken with yourself.

Around and around the merry-go-round we go. This is hedonistic utilitarianism, an objectivist moral philosophy. If you stuck with this consistently we could have an intelligent conversation.
? How is it hedonistic utilitarianism? You're not even making sense. Assertion and rhetoric.

You aren't going to, though. The minute you are uncomfortable with any conclusion generated by hedonistic utilitarianism, you'll run and hide behind some totally incompatible theory than justifies your existing prejudices, and then you'll claim with a straight face that you are being completely consistent and you always have been.
More rhetoric.


This is pathetic: It's like complaining that your maths teacher "asserts" that 2 plus 2 is 4 over and over again and you're tired of it.
Again, thank you for proving me right.

The answer isn't going to change just because you repeat the same claim over and over again. That isn't how logic works.
Look in the mirror. I make arguments and you don't rebut the arguments.

Being a relativist-of-convenience and an objectivist-of-convenience and a nihilist-of-convenience and pulling whichever line from whichever source happens to suit your prejudices this instant is inevitably going to lead you to contradict yourself.
All asserted.

Now either pull up a seat at the table of reason, where you are expected to be coherent and consistent, or go play with the woo-woos.
You are not being sincere.
  • You don't answer questions.
  • You don't address arguments.
That's intellectually dishonesty Kevin.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom