Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

Volatile in relation to a couple of points you made surely the decision not to eat a kitten is due to cultural and not moral reasons in a meat eating society? I suppose if it’s your pet there’s also emotional reasons for not eating it, but then again I’m fond of some of the plants in my garden and don’t plan to eat them, which doesn’t make eating plants immoral.

As for the environmental argument I don’t see how the environmental impact of eating animals is a moral argument for the individual not to eat meat, as an individual’s impact on the global environment is insignificant. It’s basically a tragedy of the commons problem as far as I can see, which would make it an argument for global regulation surely?

You're right on both counts.

On the first issue - you're spot on that the "cuddliness" factor is entirely socially constructed. That, in fact, functions as an argument against eating meat - the "torture" line pursued in recent posts shows that, on some level, most of us find some forms of animal harm morally problematic, and yet we absolve certain critters from consideration for rather unsupportable reasons. If you want a consistent, rationally-coherent position, as I did, it strikes me that you must either eat kittens, or not eat meat at all (when alternatives are available)/

On the second, again you're correct. But it is true that going vegan is one of the most pro-active (and easiest, as it happens) ways of reducing one's environmental footprint. That in the scheme of things the harm caused by the single individual is insignificant is not too important - one coke can dropped is not in itself harmful. What is important is the balance of harms vs benefits - and I really can't see "taste" as special or important enough to supersede my moral judgement in other areas. It's whim - and, coming back to the "torture" line - if we agree that, on some level, animal harm is intolerable, and further if we judge "unnecessary harm" to be the problem rather than harm per se (as I said, I have no issue with medical experimentation on animals), it strikes me that a strong case needs to be made as to the necessity of satiating my taste buds with beef. What's the difference, I'd ask, between the kid who gets off on killing cats for fun (a crime) and the kid who really enjoys the taste of cows (a daily, socially acceptable practrce)? Both actions result in the death of an animal solely for the satiation of personal desire. What rational reason can we find to support the latter but condemn the former? I can't think of any, and no-one's given one on this thread yet.

Search the forum for Cain's posts on the Heiress Dilemma, which sets out an interesting abstraction of this problem.
 
Last edited:
It's been interesting reading the debate.

As someone who’s pondered becoming vegetarian I’ve found some of the arguments intriguing but I have to say I’ve not been convinced. I suppose my problem is that as we need to eat the arguments for not eating meat appear somewhat arbitrary and seem to boil down to animals are closer to us than plants and therefore we should only eat what’s more alien to us. I can’t see how this is any more or less moral than saying eat whatever you want so long as it’s legal (I’ll accept there’s probably a lot of self justification going on in that argument as I came up with it when I was thinking of going veggie and am willing to think about it again so long as no one tries convincing me of the benefits of tofu which is god awful stuff :D).

Well, not for nothing, but if you were considering switching to a vegetarian diet, I suggesting going at it slowly, on a graded diet pattern, where you progressively eat less meat as you get used to eating more balanced non-meat meals. It's a good way to avoid throwing your digestive system into a spin while it tries to adjust to a different intake-- anyone who's ever attempted any fancy weight-loss diets would likely understand.

-----

GrenNME - The discussion on lines is the key one, and the one where Cain's discussions to RF immediately above are very pertinent. I don't think any meat-eater has been able to coherently and consistently explain why they draw the line where they do...

This is what I mean, though-- all of the lines are going to seem arbitrary and relative compared to your own. That's an intrinsically superficial assessment on your part, while RandFan and I have described the underlying concepts for what you're describing.
 
On the second, again you're correct. But it is true that going vegan is one of the most pro-active (and easiest, as it happens) ways of reducing one's environmental footprint.

This simply isn't an accurate statement. As I've pointed out, corn and soy are two of the most patented engineered seed products available. They have a different impact on the environment than the meat industry-- more impact on the ecological diversity and material waste than the carbon emissions side-- but to call catering to the mass-agricultural industry more pro-active is simply excusing one wrong in the food industry for the sake of eschewing another.
 
Fallacy of the heap, Belz. Fallacy of the heap.

The who to the what, now ?

What you said isn't an argument. I'm asking you WHY we should eat vegetables, the same question you ask about meat. But you must be able to provide a reason that doesn't apply to animals, as well.
 
This is silly. You may "perceive" that a stick under water appears bent. This is precisely where serious investigation and reflection enters.
I never said that what was "percieved" was correct. I've never said that. And I agree that we must seriously investigate and examine our perceptions.

However, absent a compelling argument why I should eat babies I'd rather not.

Presumably you would be against someone starting a business breeding cure-babies for AIDS.
A.) I find the idea reprehensive. B.) It doesn't work.

If (B) were not true I'd have to reconsider it. You?

See, you won't answer that question. I've asked it at least twice now but you evade it, why?

And it was not intended as an argument because your Pinker point is completely irrelevant for reasons explained somewhere between pages 5-15 in excruciating detail.
That you think it was explained doesn't mean that it was. I've explained to you in pages 5-15 why it is relevant.




So infants get rights because society perceives killing babies as immoral, and you agree...
Yes, but here is where you make your error.
  • I don't claim that our perceptions of what is moral is beyond question.
  • I don't claim that should we have sufficient reason to kill babies that we couldn't kill babies.
Sociobiology works. It works very well. It has given us altruism, empathy, compassion and other tools for behaving in a social arena (See Pinker et al). However our morality doesn't stop with sociobiology. We can and ought to use reason to better shape our morals.

Cows don't get rights because intrinsic human values owing to liberty and happiness, for which we should see Jefferson, Mason, and Locke. Chimps do get rights because you remember reading something Singer once wrote about whales.
Actually it was about primates.

Furthermore, you never reached Singer's moral principle: "Causing suffering to innocent beings without an extremely weighty reason for doing so is wrong."
If Singer had intended for this to be his only premise then he should have only stated this premise. If this were the only premise then I wouldn't have changed my position.

These comments to which you refer, and Kevin's comments on your approach are not mere assertions...
Actually many of them are. Though I should note, this post of yours was an over all improvement. More meat to the bone and less rhetoric and assertion. I hesitate to say that because I suspect that you will find such a compliment beneath you. But it's sincere nonetheless.

...much as you would like to reduce everything to that single word. "Well, after all, they're just assertions." No, they're observations. Yes, I pepper my observations with ridicule, rhetoric and invective, but only because your criminally stupid opinions deserve nothing less.
:) You wouldn't be Cain without some invective.
 
Last edited:
This is what I mean, though-- all of the lines are going to seem arbitrary and relative compared to your own. That's an intrinsically superficial assessment on your part, while RandFan and I have described the underlying concepts for what you're describing.

Not really.

What we have, on the one hand, is a line drawn consistently and rationally - that is, a line that is drawn for a specific set of reasons on an internally-consistent set of bases.

That can't be said of the meat-eating position - note Paladin, who denies he draws a line and then baulks at torturing kittens, TBK who just goes with the status quo, and others who refuse even to recognise diet as an issue where "reason" plays a part at all.

It is, and always has been, about consistency, coherency and rationality. You really haven't described any "underlying concepts" at all; you've just declared my [our] position as arbitrary as any other, which simply isn't true.
 
This simply isn't an accurate statement. As I've pointed out, corn and soy are two of the most patented engineered seed products available. They have a different impact on the environment than the meat industry-- more impact on the ecological diversity and material waste than the carbon emissions side-- but to call catering to the mass-agricultural industry more pro-active is simply excusing one wrong in the food industry for the sake of eschewing another.

That's an argument in favour of sustainably-farmed corn and soy, not an argument not to eat corn and soy at all.
 
The who to the what, now ?

What you said isn't an argument. I'm asking you WHY we should eat vegetables, the same question you ask about meat. But you must be able to provide a reason that doesn't apply to animals, as well.

Nervous system. It's the basic component for suffering.

Sure, some lower-order animals only have rudimentary nervous systems, and some complex plants might be said to be nociceptive. But that the line is occasionally blurred is not a reason to pretend the line does not exist. To do so would be committing the fallacy of the heap.

At least I have criteria. How do you choose what YOU eat? What are your criteria? That's what I'm trying to get at here. Rationalise your diet for me, and more than that, rationalise in consistently with your broader moral position on how humans and animals should interact.
 
Sociobiology works. It works very well. It has given us altruism, empathy, compassion and other tools for behaving in a social arena (See Pinker et al). However our morality doesn't start and stop with sociobiology. We can and ought to use reason to better shape our morals.

Haven't you argued this since your first post, here ?

It's amazing that somebody needs you to repeat it so often.
 
Haven't you argued this since your first post, here ?
YES!

And thank you for noticing.

It's amazing that somebody needs you to repeat it so often.
It's amazing that somebody will deny that it was ever made and/or that asserting that the fact of sociobiology and our ability to reason are contradictory.
 
Nervous system. It's the basic component for suffering.

Sure, some lower-order animals only have rudimentary nervous systems, and some complex plants might be said to be nociceptive. But that the line is occasionally blurred is not a reason to pretend the line does not exist. To do so would be committing the fallacy of the heap.

What the **** is a fallacy of the heap anyway ?

First, you are way off mark. Some animals don't HAVE a nervous system AT ALL. So your criterion does not exclude all animals. Now, the question becomes, at what point do you determine that the animal has enough of a nervous system to experience suffering ?

Second, if your criterion is suffering, then it is moot, because by the time I eat the animal's meat it is dead and therefore incapable of suffering. And as RandFan has pointed out, while they live in captivity they have it way better and easier than in the wild.

At least I have criteria. How do you choose what YOU eat? What are your criteria? That's what I'm trying to get at here. Rationalise your diet for me, and more than that, rationalise in consistently with your broader moral position on how humans and animals should interact.

You're still not getting it. I don't need to justify myself to you. YOU are making a claim that eating meat is WRONG. YOU need to justify yourself.
 
Well, it has to happen to everybody, every one in a while.

You think it was a lucky guess, rather than one based on observation and evidence? I suggest you go back and read the thread again. :rolleyes:

All too often, people claim, baldly, that they "don't care" about animals, or that diet isn't a moral issue. But ask them if they support animal cruelty -- which, if they had no moral conception of animal life at all they would logically have no issue with -- they turn a shade of pale.

Most people don't think about what they eat, or why they eat it. They don't care about where it comes from, or how their dinner intersects with their broader morality. Even the high-minded, thoughtful, self-reflective rationalists on this forum. This thread is proof enough of that.

So, all we ask, Cain and I, is that you ask yourself what positive justifications you can find for eating meat when other sources are available. If "taste" is the only, or even just the primary, reason - we ask you to consider if you think this is sufficient to override the demonstrable harms and the problems such a position poses when considering how diet fits with ethics more generally.

You're a rational guy. You act, primarily, for good reasons; considered reasons. Why, then, do you eat meat? What's the positive case for meat-eating?
 
You're right on both counts.

On the first issue - you're spot on that the "cuddliness" factor is entirely socially constructed. That, in fact, functions as an argument against eating meat - the "torture" line pursued in recent posts shows that, on some level, most of us find some forms of animal harm morally problematic, and yet we absolve certain critters from consideration for rather unsupportable reasons. If you want a consistent, rationally-coherent position, as I did, it strikes me that you must either eat kittens, or not eat meat at all (when alternatives are available)/

I agree that animal harm is concerning, to me at leats, and is the reason why I've considered going vegeterian, I suppose my argument against it is I'm not sure whether my preferences against animal harm whilst accepting harm to plants is entirely sound. As I said it appears somewhat arbitary to me.

On the second, again you're correct. But it is true that going vegan is one of the most pro-active (and easiest, as it happens) ways of reducing one's environmental footprint. That in the scheme of things the harm caused by the single individual is insignificant is not too important - one coke can dropped is not in itself harmful.

In relation to the enviromental impact surely the taste argument is a stronger argument here? As you accept what you do individually in envirmomental terms is neglegiable (I would say less so than droping a coke can), surely a rational response is to go for what pleases you most? Which could still be not eating meat. I suppose I'm just not convinced by the usefulness of individuals enviromental actions (collective actions are another matter of course.)

What is important is the balance of harms vs benefits - and I really can't see "taste" as special or important enough to supersede my moral judgement in other areas. It's whim - and, coming back to the "torture" line - if we agree that, on some level, animal harm is intolerable, and further if we judge "unnecessary harm" to be the problem rather than harm per se (as I said, I have no issue with medical experimentation on animals), it strikes me that a strong case needs to be made as to the necessity of satiating my taste buds with beef. What's the difference, I'd ask, between the kid who gets off on killing cats for fun (a crime) and the kid who really enjoys the taste of cows (a daily, socially acceptable practrce)? Both actions result in the death of an animal solely for the satiation of personal desire. What rational reason can we find to support the latter but condemn the former? I can't think of any, and no-one's given one on this thread yet.

Search the forum for Cain's posts on the Heiress Dilemma, which sets out an interesting abstraction of this problem.

Will have to have a look for that post when I have some time.

In a quick reponse to what's the difference between killing a cat for pleasure and killing it to eat. I could respond by asking what's the differnce between the kid who anti socially destroys plants and the kid that eats plants for enjoyment? Obviously there's a stronger emmotional response to the torture of animals, I'm just not really convinced than it's more than subjective preferences though.

Well, not for nothing, but if you were considering switching to a vegetarian diet, I suggesting going at it slowly, on a graded diet pattern, where you progressively eat less meat as you get used to eating more balanced non-meat meals. It's a good way to avoid throwing your digestive system into a spin while it tries to adjust to a different intake-- anyone who's ever attempted any fancy weight-loss diets would likely understand.

Well I already eat quite a bit of veggie food, but I think my work colleagues would appreicate it if I did switch if I did it slowly :D so thanks for the heads up.
 
Last edited:
What we have, on the one hand, is a line drawn consistently and rationally - that is, a line that is drawn for a specific set of reasons on an internally-consistent set of bases.

Just about as consistent as biblical litteralism, Volatile. You said we shouldn't eat animal meat but your criterion doesn't exclude all animals, anyway. Especially not dead ones.

That can't be said of the meat-eating position - note Paladin, who denies he draws a line and then baulks at torturing kittens, TBK who just goes with the status quo, and others who refuse even to recognise diet as an issue where "reason" plays a part at all.

What the hell does torture have to do with eating ? We're not like cats, who play with their live food. We usually kill and THEN play with it.

If your pet cat or dog is dead then there is no reason, aside from sentimentality, to NOT eat it.

It is, and always has been, about consistency, coherency and rationality. You really haven't described any "underlying concepts" at all

I think you're seeing this issue as way more than it really is.
 
What the **** is a fallacy of the heap anyway ?

How many grains are there in a heap? If you can't tell me exactly, then there's no difference between a single grain and a heap!

That's the fallacy of the heap. The assertion that if the line between two categories is not firm, then those categories are meaningless. It simply isn't true. See also: Loki's Wager.

First, you are way off mark. Some animals don't HAVE a nervous system AT ALL. So your criterion does not exclude all animals.

Fine. So what? How does that justify eating those that do?

Second, if your criterion is suffering, then it is moot, because by the time I eat the animal's meat it is dead and therefore incapable of suffering.

I think "death" is suffering. Killing something is inflicting suffering, and not just semantically. Cain's touched on this in his posts on "interests".

What's your issue with killing your kittens and using them as target practice? After all, the kitten's dead, right?

If you did that, you'd be arrested in the UK, and, I assume, Canada too.

And as RandFan has pointed out, while they live in captivity they have it way better and easier than in the wild.

If altrusim is your reason - if you want to save animals from the wild - then raise them and keep them until old age. If your "reasons" for eating meat really are to save them from the vicissitudes of life, how can you justify killing them? You're making it up as you go along.

You're still not getting it. I don't need to justify myself to you. YOU are making a claim that eating meat is WRONG. YOU need to justify yourself.

Meat eating causes clear and demonstrable harms. So show me why it's worth doing. What's so hard? You must have a reason, surely? A reason that is clear and sensible and rational? Don't you?
 
You're a rational guy. You act, primarily, for good reasons; considered reasons. Why, then, do you eat meat? What's the positive case for meat-eating?
I guess I'm on your ignore now since you've not responded to my last half dozen responses over the last couple of days to you (I think it's that many).

*Dennett notes, there is a trade off in benifits. The animals get to live. They are statisically assured of surviving their birth. And, they get to live (by and large and day to day) free from the elments, disease, predators, etc.

That these animals would not exist is not a compelling argument. When we kill them they won't exist.

*Dennetts argument is specifically about sheep and he doesn't state that they exist for the purpose of eating meat and I don't want to put words in his mouth. His point could be made for wool production, though that would be somewhat weasely. We don't know as he doesn't make that distincion.
 
Last edited:
Cain, take over, buddy - I'm going home for the weekend and don't have internet at home.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom