volatile
Scholar and a Gentleman
- Joined
- Aug 19, 2006
- Messages
- 6,729
Volatile in relation to a couple of points you made surely the decision not to eat a kitten is due to cultural and not moral reasons in a meat eating society? I suppose if it’s your pet there’s also emotional reasons for not eating it, but then again I’m fond of some of the plants in my garden and don’t plan to eat them, which doesn’t make eating plants immoral.
As for the environmental argument I don’t see how the environmental impact of eating animals is a moral argument for the individual not to eat meat, as an individual’s impact on the global environment is insignificant. It’s basically a tragedy of the commons problem as far as I can see, which would make it an argument for global regulation surely?
You're right on both counts.
On the first issue - you're spot on that the "cuddliness" factor is entirely socially constructed. That, in fact, functions as an argument against eating meat - the "torture" line pursued in recent posts shows that, on some level, most of us find some forms of animal harm morally problematic, and yet we absolve certain critters from consideration for rather unsupportable reasons. If you want a consistent, rationally-coherent position, as I did, it strikes me that you must either eat kittens, or not eat meat at all (when alternatives are available)/
On the second, again you're correct. But it is true that going vegan is one of the most pro-active (and easiest, as it happens) ways of reducing one's environmental footprint. That in the scheme of things the harm caused by the single individual is insignificant is not too important - one coke can dropped is not in itself harmful. What is important is the balance of harms vs benefits - and I really can't see "taste" as special or important enough to supersede my moral judgement in other areas. It's whim - and, coming back to the "torture" line - if we agree that, on some level, animal harm is intolerable, and further if we judge "unnecessary harm" to be the problem rather than harm per se (as I said, I have no issue with medical experimentation on animals), it strikes me that a strong case needs to be made as to the necessity of satiating my taste buds with beef. What's the difference, I'd ask, between the kid who gets off on killing cats for fun (a crime) and the kid who really enjoys the taste of cows (a daily, socially acceptable practrce)? Both actions result in the death of an animal solely for the satiation of personal desire. What rational reason can we find to support the latter but condemn the former? I can't think of any, and no-one's given one on this thread yet.
Search the forum for Cain's posts on the Heiress Dilemma, which sets out an interesting abstraction of this problem.
Last edited: