Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

Well, let's start at square one: Do you think we should we have laws protecting animals from abuse?

I don't care one way or the other. I personally won't abuse an animal, but that's because of my own irrational distaste of it.

No, I said you changed venues. Earlier you claimed those arguing against the status quo were burdened with proof. Volatile presented the example of Iran, and then you conveniently revised your standards using the semantic wordplay that wouldn't fool a five year-old.

Apparently, you don't understand that when I spoke of status quo, I was speaking of the place where I live. The status quo on Jupiter is irrelevant.
 
Emphasis mine.

Yes, which doesn't necessarily apply to other species.

This is the problem with many moral vegetarians. They tend to place their own personalities to those of these animals that are being slaughtered for food. They seem to forget that theses animals do not hold such thought processes or cares. It's a form of anthropomorphism, which is illogical and irrational and entirely emotional.
These vegans fail to realize that the main, instinctual reason they assign different values to different animals is because if those animals similarities to us. This is why there will be more outrage by PETA and other irrational nuts about the treatment of cows than there is outrage about the slaughtering of termites.
 
...You'd eat ANYTHING - even endangered species? ...

IIRC there is (or, at least, was) a club at either Oxford or Cambridge University that specialised in so doing. Always struck me as rather silly.
 
I don't believe you.

Then don't. Up to you.

You'd eat ANYTHING - even endangered species?

Pointing to the 'fake' demarcation of 'moral obligation', yup.

As I stated before, I ate things that would make you scream and shout at me.

And you're OK with animal torture - literally, people torturing animals to death for fun, a practice which is resolutely illegal in most Western countries?

Trying to strawman me? Or just lost the major point of your argument and want to go the way of making me look like a 'Sadist'?

Wat does the 'torture' thing, especially 'for fun' have to do with my argument?

I simply do not believe you have no line at all when it comes to delineating acceptable vs unacceptable behaviour towards animals.

You have not read my arguments at all. I do have a line, but that is in no single way related to any 'moral obligation'.


If you really don't, you're a rare human being indeed.

Nah, not really, actually, I think most of the people have my way of drawing the line.

But they usually let themselves get bushwacked into a fake argument about 'obligatory morality'.

Because, the simple fact is; I may just be rare in the fact that I do not need any positive confirmation from anyone to think I am doing pretty ok.

And negative feedback, unless it is something that someone wants to give me so I can improve, does not hit home at all.
 
IIRC there is (or, at least, was) a club at either Oxford or Cambridge University that specialised in so doing. Always struck me as rather silly.

Not to put oil on the fire or something, but most endangered or rare animals do not taste nearly as good as pure free-range beef...
 
Last edited:
Wordplay? AFAIK 'obligation' means there is something compelling/forcing me and 'consideration' means I will think and decide about it myself.

That is a failed cop-out mister.

No you were not, read your own post where you tell me that you just said that I have an 'obligation'.

Yes, I have read the sentence: "You have a moral obligation to justify your behavior..." The compulsion or "force" is, um, moral.

It simply *is* not. You make that as a basis of your whole line of reasoning, but the matter of the fact is just that a lot of people do not like it.

You have to be more specific because I have used "obligation" more than once in different contexts. Your earlier post refers to the quoted line above which should not be controversial as it essentially says these matters require serious study. If you want to (risibly) insist otherwise, then I can only imagine your knee-jerk response is the product of the same insouciant disregard for cautious thought. If this is the case, then I'd say your opinions are consistent with your principles.

Now, elsewhere, later on, addressing TBK, I did write: "Most importantly, you completely ignore moral obligations to animals." And by this I meant the sort of "obligations" most people observe without tantrum, such as torture and abuse. I wrote: "Are you, for instance, opposed to laws prohibiting the torture of animals?"

Volatile poses the same question to you directly, and you pouted:

Trying to strawman me? Or just lost the major point of your argument and want to go the way of making me look like a 'Sadist'?

Wat does the 'torture' thing, especially 'for fun' have to do with my argument?

I do appreciate your attempt to completely evade all of these serious issues in order to seize upon a word you never dare put into context. It's much better to avoid arguments of ideas and insist upon squabbling over words, especially if your notions of morality or, perhaps I should say, "morality" resemble the following:

There is [no real difference between killing humans and animals]. The critically significant difference here is the consequences; judgement of my peers.

The trouble with this position is that its dependent upon shifting public opinion. It suggests that if you were rewarded with money and praise (no jail time) -- or whatever you desire -- for killing homosexuals (because they're... homosexuals), then you would have no problem doing so. The same "reasoning" holds for violence motivated by racism and sexism.

---------------------------------------
TBK:
I don't care one way or the other. I personally won't abuse an animal, but that's because of my own irrational distaste of it.

Well, clearly that's because you're one of heroes. So, according to you people can abuse animals if they say so desire. Cool. Presumably you think it's wrong to torture humans. What, in your view, are the morally significant differences between a human and (say) a chimpanzee?

Apparently, you don't understand that when I spoke of status quo, I was speaking of the place where I live. The status quo on Jupiter is irrelevant.

Well this is an interesting attempt to worm your way out. Let's revisit the snippets:

Instead, why not have THEM convince us that eating meat is wrong. After all, the burden is upon them to do so. The social norm is that eating meat is ok. They have to show that it's wrong in order to change society.

Instead of giving an argument as to why raising animals to eat is wrong, you keep trying to shift the burden of conviction onto the status quo. It's generally accepted that raising animals to eat is ok.

So this principle does not apply to social norms in other countries? Iran was mentioned as a counter-example, not Jupiter, much as you may wish to the contrary.
 
Dear All - busy at work and no internet at home. Not disappearing; will be back on Monday.

GrenNME - The discussion on lines is the key one, and the one where Cain's discussions to RF immediately above are very pertinent. I don't think any meat-eater has been able to coherently and consistently explain why they draw the line where they do...

I draw it at what's available in my local supermarket or on the menu at a restaurant. :p
 
Killing someone because you're interested in how he might taste does not sound like a promising justification. If you think killing a human for food is wrong, and killing an animal for food is A-OK, then you should have no difficulty citing the critically significant difference between the two. Vegetarians freely answer this question with regard to plants all the time.

No... none of us want to kill "someone" to see how "he" tastes. We want to kill an animal for how it tastes.

I know why Singer considers them morally relevant. I'm not sure why YOU consider them morally relevant because you mix and match, making things up as you go along. So infants get rights because society perceives killing babies as immoral, and you agree, probably for some evolutionary reason the great Pinker explains using a study. Cool. Cows don't get rights because intrinsic human values owing to liberty and happiness, for which we should see Jefferson, Mason, and Locke. Chimps do get rights because you remember reading something Singer once wrote about whales. You don't have any organized system of morality. You have a Rube Goldberg machine.

Furthermore, you never reached Singer's moral principle: "Causing suffering to innocent beings without an extremely weighty reason for doing so is wrong." Now you could apply this bit to all of your beliefs, specifically that comment above on how killing animals for food is worth it. Oh wait, what am I thinking, that would require a basic regard for consistency.

Is that Peter Singer you are referring to? Do you think a would-be child killer is an appropriate source to use when discussing morality?

Yes, I pepper my observations with ridicule, rhetoric and invective, but only because your criminally stupid opinions deserve nothing less.

So you're acting like a butthole because we aren't worthy of better behavior from you?
 
I'm still waiting for someone to point out a reason why we SHOULD eat vegetables. A reason, that is, that doesn't apply to a whole bunch of animals, too.
 
You have not read my arguments at all. I do have a line, but that is in no single way related to any 'moral obligation'.

You do have a line? What did you mean, then, when you said

I do not draw a line at all!

You're back-tracking now? Seems I was right not to believe you; such hasty proclamations crumble on first probing.

So: Now we can see you draw a line somewhere north of "torture for fun". You're correct that to do so would make you a sadist.

So what's your issue with that - Why would it make you a sadist? What are your qualms, personally, with torturing animals for fun? Is it the pain, specifically, or the fun, or how the two considerations intersect? This is a moral question, even if pretending it isn't makes you feel better. Once I actually understand how and why you draw the line, we can then probe the consequences of your thought processes, but we'll need to get those clear first.
 
I'm still waiting for someone to point out a reason why we SHOULD eat vegetables. A reason, that is, that doesn't apply to a whole bunch of animals, too.

Fallacy of the heap, Belz. Fallacy of the heap.
 
It's been interesting reading the debate.

As someone who’s pondered becoming vegetarian I’ve found some of the arguments intriguing but I have to say I’ve not been convinced. I suppose my problem is that as we need to eat the arguments for not eating meat appear somewhat arbitrary and seem to boil down to animals are closer to us than plants and therefore we should only eat what’s more alien to us. I can’t see how this is any more or less moral than saying eat whatever you want so long as it’s legal (I’ll accept there’s probably a lot of self justification going on in that argument as I came up with it when I was thinking of going veggie and am willing to think about it again so long as no one tries convincing me of the benefits of tofu which is god awful stuff :D).

Volatile in relation to a couple of points you made surely the decision not to eat a kitten is due to cultural and not moral reasons in a meat eating society? I suppose if it’s your pet there’s also emotional reasons for not eating it, but then again I’m fond of some of the plants in my garden and don’t plan to eat them, which doesn’t make eating plants immoral.

As for the environmental argument I don’t see how the environmental impact of eating animals is a moral argument for the individual not to eat meat, as an individual’s impact on the global environment is insignificant. It’s basically a tragedy of the commons problem as far as I can see, which would make it an argument for global regulation surely?
 
This is exactly the kind of weaselling that makes it impossible to have an intelligent discussion.
BS.

You're happy to invoke objectivist moral philosophies like utilitarianism, and simultaneously deny that there is any objective morality, and simultaneously act as if evolved behaviours are some kind of guide to how we should act, and simultaneously deny you are doing any such thing.
BS. Assertion. Just as one can make objective statements about art one can make objective statements about morality.

That doesn't make either objective. I've explained this to you before.

That I can find utility in something doesn't mean that I must accept absolute morality. Your argument is spurious.

If you were consistent in holding that things are only perceived as moral, you wouldn't be talking about morality at all, because the term would be utterly meaningless except in a sociological context.
We don't have to be slaves to our sociobiology. We CAN reason better morals.

Yet you keep trying to make some kind of argument that eating meat is okay.
Where? You just make stuff up and expect that everyone is going to accept whatever you say. That is rather arrogant of you.

Not just perceived as okay - the fact that it is perceived as okay by many people is a given. There is nothing to further to say about the fact that eating meat is perceived to be okay. You keep trying to enter the moral arena by arguing that it is okay in more than a purely relativist sense, and your position immediately becomes unglued because you've already denied that any such claim can have meaning.
We don't have to be slaves to our biology. Humans have brains. We can reason. If you argue that eating meat isn't ok I can argue that it is. The question then becomes if either arguments are valid and are compelling.

You are not the grand arbiter and you don't really get to tell me that I don't get to argue.

If your ego demands that you refuse to acknowledge my arguments or that you must see a contradiction that's fine but you damn sure haven't demonstrated a contradiction. You just assert, over and over, argument ad nauseam.

It wasn't true before it isn't true now and asserting something over and over isn't logically valid argument.

You're not going to stop talking nonsense until you grasp that you're contradicting yourself...
Get over yourself. That you assert that there is a contradiction doesn't mean that there is one.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom