Belz...
Fiend God
I don't believe you.
That's nice.
I don't believe you.
Well, let's start at square one: Do you think we should we have laws protecting animals from abuse?
No, I said you changed venues. Earlier you claimed those arguing against the status quo were burdened with proof. Volatile presented the example of Iran, and then you conveniently revised your standards using the semantic wordplay that wouldn't fool a five year-old.
Killing someone because you're interested in how he might taste does not sound like a promising justification.
Emphasis mine.
Yes, which doesn't necessarily apply to other species.
...You'd eat ANYTHING - even endangered species? ...
I don't believe you.
You'd eat ANYTHING - even endangered species?
And you're OK with animal torture - literally, people torturing animals to death for fun, a practice which is resolutely illegal in most Western countries?
I simply do not believe you have no line at all when it comes to delineating acceptable vs unacceptable behaviour towards animals.
If you really don't, you're a rare human being indeed.
IIRC there is (or, at least, was) a club at either Oxford or Cambridge University that specialised in so doing. Always struck me as rather silly.
about the slaughtering of termites.
Wordplay? AFAIK 'obligation' means there is something compelling/forcing me and 'consideration' means I will think and decide about it myself.
That is a failed cop-out mister.
No you were not, read your own post where you tell me that you just said that I have an 'obligation'.
It simply *is* not. You make that as a basis of your whole line of reasoning, but the matter of the fact is just that a lot of people do not like it.
Trying to strawman me? Or just lost the major point of your argument and want to go the way of making me look like a 'Sadist'?
Wat does the 'torture' thing, especially 'for fun' have to do with my argument?
There is [no real difference between killing humans and animals]. The critically significant difference here is the consequences; judgement of my peers.
I don't care one way or the other. I personally won't abuse an animal, but that's because of my own irrational distaste of it.
Apparently, you don't understand that when I spoke of status quo, I was speaking of the place where I live. The status quo on Jupiter is irrelevant.
Instead, why not have THEM convince us that eating meat is wrong. After all, the burden is upon them to do so. The social norm is that eating meat is ok. They have to show that it's wrong in order to change society.
Instead of giving an argument as to why raising animals to eat is wrong, you keep trying to shift the burden of conviction onto the status quo. It's generally accepted that raising animals to eat is ok.
Dear All - busy at work and no internet at home. Not disappearing; will be back on Monday.
GrenNME - The discussion on lines is the key one, and the one where Cain's discussions to RF immediately above are very pertinent. I don't think any meat-eater has been able to coherently and consistently explain why they draw the line where they do...
Killing someone because you're interested in how he might taste does not sound like a promising justification. If you think killing a human for food is wrong, and killing an animal for food is A-OK, then you should have no difficulty citing the critically significant difference between the two. Vegetarians freely answer this question with regard to plants all the time.
I know why Singer considers them morally relevant. I'm not sure why YOU consider them morally relevant because you mix and match, making things up as you go along. So infants get rights because society perceives killing babies as immoral, and you agree, probably for some evolutionary reason the great Pinker explains using a study. Cool. Cows don't get rights because intrinsic human values owing to liberty and happiness, for which we should see Jefferson, Mason, and Locke. Chimps do get rights because you remember reading something Singer once wrote about whales. You don't have any organized system of morality. You have a Rube Goldberg machine.
Furthermore, you never reached Singer's moral principle: "Causing suffering to innocent beings without an extremely weighty reason for doing so is wrong." Now you could apply this bit to all of your beliefs, specifically that comment above on how killing animals for food is worth it. Oh wait, what am I thinking, that would require a basic regard for consistency.
Yes, I pepper my observations with ridicule, rhetoric and invective, but only because your criminally stupid opinions deserve nothing less.
Is that Peter Singer you are referring to?
You have not read my arguments at all. I do have a line, but that is in no single way related to any 'moral obligation'.
I do not draw a line at all!
Maybe he's refering to Mark Singer. In the V miniseries, he does note that the aliens use humans as food, after all.
That's nice.
I'm still waiting for someone to point out a reason why we SHOULD eat vegetables. A reason, that is, that doesn't apply to a whole bunch of animals, too.
BS.This is exactly the kind of weaselling that makes it impossible to have an intelligent discussion.
BS. Assertion. Just as one can make objective statements about art one can make objective statements about morality.You're happy to invoke objectivist moral philosophies like utilitarianism, and simultaneously deny that there is any objective morality, and simultaneously act as if evolved behaviours are some kind of guide to how we should act, and simultaneously deny you are doing any such thing.
We don't have to be slaves to our sociobiology. We CAN reason better morals.If you were consistent in holding that things are only perceived as moral, you wouldn't be talking about morality at all, because the term would be utterly meaningless except in a sociological context.
Where? You just make stuff up and expect that everyone is going to accept whatever you say. That is rather arrogant of you.Yet you keep trying to make some kind of argument that eating meat is okay.
We don't have to be slaves to our biology. Humans have brains. We can reason. If you argue that eating meat isn't ok I can argue that it is. The question then becomes if either arguments are valid and are compelling.Not just perceived as okay - the fact that it is perceived as okay by many people is a given. There is nothing to further to say about the fact that eating meat is perceived to be okay. You keep trying to enter the moral arena by arguing that it is okay in more than a purely relativist sense, and your position immediately becomes unglued because you've already denied that any such claim can have meaning.
Get over yourself. That you assert that there is a contradiction doesn't mean that there is one.You're not going to stop talking nonsense until you grasp that you're contradicting yourself...