Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

The question is one of whether or not infants have rights.
I don't know that they should. Society has bestowed them rights. I percieve that it would be immoral to harm an infant. I've not seen an argument to change my mind.

Do you have an argument to take away the rights of infants?

If you want a concrete example, then in some African tribes there's a belief that baby rape can cure AIDS. If somebody thinks she can cure AIDS by praying to a statue, we don't much care, but harming others raises concerns.
And if it did cure AIDS? It doesn't of course so your example is absurd. But if it did perhaps it would be good for their society. I find such an idea revolting but you and Kevin keep telling me that what I find revolting is neither here nor there. How about you? If raping babies would cure AIDS in parts of Africa where AIDS is skyrocketing, how would you decide and why?

As for your Steven Pinker comment... just stop embarrassing yourself.
More rhetoric. See, this isn't an argument. But then you knew that.

I'm asking why it's wrong.
I've no argument against it. I know that society deems it immoral. I know that I percieve it as immoral. If you have a good argument, like the AIDS argument I'll consider it.

The question is: how is that morally relevant?
I was impressed by an argument made by Peter Singer to consider enlarging our circle. He made it about primates and I can't find it at the moment but his argument for whales is pretty close.

I argued that whales are social mammals with big brains, capable of enjoying life and of feeling pain — and not only physical pain, but very likely also distress at the loss of one of their group.
The brain capacity of an animal and its social interactions were premises offered by Singer that we should consider. I think those are significant and I'm willing to entertain them. Are you saying I should ignore those? That Singer would critisize me for enlarging my personal circle for taking into account his arguments?

No, I'll say more: I forgot that you've suspended the law of non-contradiction; you have a casual disregard for basic consistency. Moreover, you have no idea what you're saying. You think juggling involves keeping four balls in the air at once, but instead of actually juggling the same four balls, you're just rapidly chucking things into the sky. You're an incompetent clown.
See, you substitute ivective, assertion and claims for argument. It's all rhetoric Cain.

It would be nice if you could keep the rhetoric to a minimum and focus more on arguments. I assure you it has no effect. Even some of those who are inclined to agree with you, roborama, volatile, recognize that the abuse just strokes your ego.
 
Last edited:
A rhetorical device. Like I tell Cain, assertion isn't argument.

I'm not getting on the RandFan denial treadmill again. I've demonstrated that your arguments contradict each other many times already, and it doesn't stop you asserting otherwise.

I get how it's easy for you to ignore what others say and simply spout "naturalistic fallacy" but my position is no different than Dawkins, Shermers, de Waal, Pinker et al.

Dawkins points out that humans have an evolved moral sense. No naturalistic fallacy.
RandFan points out that humans have an evolved moral sense. Naturalistic fallacy.

THAT'S INCOHERENT!

In absence of actually dealing with what I'm saying you just viscerally accuse me of committing a fallacy.

Pointing out that you are engaging in a fallacy is dealing with what you are saying. That's the whole point of canonical fallacies as an argumentative tool.

I did not say that anything is right or wrong because it's natural. I said that we don't perceive killing and eating babies as the moral thing to do. I'm waiting for an argument to think otherwise. For some odd reason you can't give me one. And get this, surprise surprise neither can Cain. No, you want me to justify killing infants when I don't personally perceive it as moral. I don't believe morals are absolute but I'd need a pretty convincing argument to overcome the disgust and revulsion of killing a baby.

Have you that argument?

This is just more of your jumping back and forth between positions of convenience.

You're happy to deny that there is any morality, then burble on about morality.

You're happy to claim that you aren't engaging in the naturalistic fallacy, then trumpet evolved behaviours as evidence that those behaviours are moral and demand that people provide you with a counter-argument or else you will take the fallacious argument as conclusive.

Now, I've no inborn or indoctrinated revulsion at killing animals for the purpose of eating them. On top of that I've got a reasonable argument for killing and eating them. One I've made for years and if you and Cain deny that then you are lying. Flat out.

Animal husbandry provides a benefit for an animal in return of the benefit of providing sustenance.

With a bounce you are on to a new utilitarian argument for eating meat. Yet the minute we try to pin you down on cases where an animal can not be said to benefit from the meat-production system, you'll be bouncing away to yet another argument.

There is no intellectual rigor here. Just more RandFan mad libs.

Yeah, more tired rhetoric. You and Cain, that's all your slim opinion relies on. Assertion, personal attack and rhetoric.

No argument just assertion and claims.

We've caught you in self-serving contradictions time after time, and the proof is in this thread. Until you adopt a consistent position and stick with it, there is literally nothing to say except to "attack you" for being wildly and self-righteously inconsistent.
 
mmm...yea. Cain and Lowe aren't doing much to convince people of anything. Volatile, however, has shown me that society should eat less meat due to the environmental impacts. That is, until we can address those impacts.
 
I've demonstrated that your arguments contradict each other...
No.

That's the whole point of canonical fallacies as an argumentative tool.
Only if it is correct.

You're happy to deny that there is any morality...
No, I deny that there is "absolute", "actual", or "objective" morality. BIG, BIG difference.

You're happy to claim that you aren't engaging in the naturalistic fallacy, then trumpet evolved behaviours as evidence that those behaviours are moral...
Keving that is a lie. You know it. I know it. So why do you make a claim that is quite clearly a lie? I've said that they are percieved of as moral.

We've caught you in self-serving contradictions time after time...
One more time, assertion isn't evidence, proof or argument.

But I've got an assertion for you...

No you haven't.
 
mmm...yea. Cain and Lowe aren't doing much to convince people of anything. Volatile, however, has shown me that society should eat less meat due to the environmental impacts. That is, until we can address those impacts.
Volitile is actually willing to engage in discussion as well as debate. He doesn't condesend or patronize. There are others BTW.
 
Keving that is a lie. You know it. I know it. So why do you make a claim that is quite clearly a lie? I've said that they are percieved of as moral.

This is exactly the kind of weaselling that makes it impossible to have an intelligent discussion.

You're happy to invoke objectivist moral philosophies like utilitarianism, and simultaneously deny that there is any objective morality, and simultaneously act as if evolved behaviours are some kind of guide to how we should act, and simultaneously deny you are doing any such thing.

If you were consistent in holding that things are only perceived as moral, you wouldn't be talking about morality at all, because the term would be utterly meaningless except in a sociological context.

Yet you keep trying to make some kind of argument that eating meat is okay. Not just perceived as okay - the fact that it is perceived as okay by many people is a given. There is nothing to further to say about the fact that eating meat is perceived to be okay. You keep trying to enter the moral arena by arguing that it is okay in more than a purely relativist sense, and your position immediately becomes unglued because you've already denied that any such claim can have meaning.

That's why you keep slipping back and forth between presenting explanations of why eating meat is perceived as moral, which are utterly irrelevant to the question of whether it is actually moral, and then acting as if you've contributed something to a conversation about whether it is actually moral in any meaningful sense.

You're not going to stop talking nonsense until you grasp that you're contradicting yourself, and either embrace moral relativism (and absurdity) completely, or abandon your moral relativism and embrace some form of consistent moral objectivism.
 
I'm sorry, but did Kevin give a logical reason as to why eating meat is immoral? If so, can someone summarize it?
 
Yes.


Yes.

I have eaten a grown-up cat already. And a dog. And a lot of other animals you would deem too cute to eat.

Not because I especially did not like them, but because they were on the menu at the time I was at that specific place.

And when in Rome...

Rome, shmome... I've eaten felis domesticus here in Edmonton, Canada.

There was a chinese buffet joint a couple miles from here that I often used to eat at that got busted a few years back for serving cat meat.

When I first heard the on the news what the local health department discovered, I got mad and It's bothered me ever since.

It's been nearly ten years now and I still haven't found another place in town that serves cats. :(
 
Rome, shmome... I've eaten felis domesticus here in Edmonton, Canada.

There was a chinese buffet joint a couple miles from here that I often used to eat at that got busted a few years back for serving cat meat.

When I first heard the on the news what the local health department discovered, I got mad and It's bothered me ever since.

It's been nearly ten years now and I still haven't found another place in town that serves cats. :(

That almost sounds like you miss the taste?
 
That almost sounds like you miss the taste?

It's been so long, I can't remember. I don't even know what specific dishes had the "meow mix". Somehow, I don't think I would have gotten the response I wanted had I called up the health dept. and asked which ones it was. ;)

I just hate cats. :D
 
Last edited:
I didn't realize we have a moral obligation to animals. Can you tell me what those obligations are and what objective source you obtained them from?

Well, let's start at square one: Do you think we should we have laws protecting animals from abuse?

Except I haven't moved goal posts. You've not crossed any of the goals I've outlined. Did you have an argument as to why eating meat is wrong?

No, I said you changed venues. Earlier you claimed those arguing against the status quo were burdened with proof. Volatile presented the example of Iran, and then you conveniently revised your standards using the semantic wordplay that wouldn't fool a five year-old.

-----------------------
RealPaladin:
That is not explaining, that is stating. And it is wrong to boot.
It makes me have a 'consideration', not an 'obligation'.
So. Explain the 'obligation' again?

This is more strained wordplay.

"Why is it wrong to hit my brother?"
"Because you're hurting him."

If you want to completely devolve into RandFan territory you could say something like "Oh, but you're just STATING your EXPLANATION." I'm saying eating animals simply because they taste good is not a good enough reason to subject them to the horrors of industrial animal processing (which tonight Jon Stewart compared, not unfairly, to Abu Ghraib).

Actions follow from a consideration of interests. Let's use a closer analogy: "Why is it wrong to kill a human being for the purposes of eating him?"

Killing someone because you're interested in how he might taste does not sound like a promising justification. If you think killing a human for food is wrong, and killing an animal for food is A-OK, then you should have no difficulty citing the critically significant difference between the two. Vegetarians freely answer this question with regard to plants all the time.
-----------------------
RandFan:

I don't know that they should. Society has bestowed them rights. I percieve that it would be immoral to harm an infant. I've not seen an argument to change my mind.

This is silly. You may "perceive" that a stick under water appears bent. This is precisely where serious investigation and reflection enters.

And if it did cure AIDS? It doesn't of course so your example is absurd. But if it did perhaps it would be good for their society. I find such an idea revolting but you and Kevin keep telling me that what I find revolting is neither here nor there. How about you? If raping babies would cure AIDS in parts of Africa where AIDS is skyrocketing, how would you decide and why?

I only bothered with an example because you (needlessly) asked for one, but if it helps to clarify these issues, fine. The central point is that children have rights and there are certain things you think we cannot do them without violating those rights. Presumably you would be against someone starting a business breeding cure-babies for AIDS. Now that we've breathlessly established that point for those tiny humans, we can branch out to non-humans who have similar levels of consciousness and feeling. Now, I had already basically said this, established it, but you chose the path of digression, and speaking of digression:

More rhetoric. See, this isn't an argument. But then you knew that.

And it was not intended as an argument because your Pinker point is completely irrelevant for reasons explained somewhere between pages 5-15 in excruciating detail.

The brain capacity of an animal and its social interactions were premises offered by Singer that we should consider. I think those are significant and I'm willing to entertain them. Are you saying I should ignore those? That Singer would critisize me for enlarging my personal circle for taking into account his arguments?

I know why Singer considers them morally relevant. I'm not sure why YOU consider them morally relevant because you mix and match, making things up as you go along. So infants get rights because society perceives killing babies as immoral, and you agree, probably for some evolutionary reason the great Pinker explains using a study. Cool. Cows don't get rights because intrinsic human values owing to liberty and happiness, for which we should see Jefferson, Mason, and Locke. Chimps do get rights because you remember reading something Singer once wrote about whales. You don't have any organized system of morality. You have a Rube Goldberg machine.

Furthermore, you never reached Singer's moral principle: "Causing suffering to innocent beings without an extremely weighty reason for doing so is wrong." Now you could apply this bit to all of your beliefs, specifically that comment above on how killing animals for food is worth it. Oh wait, what am I thinking, that would require a basic regard for consistency.

See, you substitute ivective, assertion and claims for argument. It's all rhetoric Cain.

These comments to which you refer, and Kevin's comments on your approach are not mere assertions, much as you would like to reduce everything to that single word. "Well, after all, they're just assertions." No, they're observations. Yes, I pepper my observations with ridicule, rhetoric and invective, but only because your criminally stupid opinions deserve nothing less.
 
RealPaladin:

This is more strained wordplay.

"Why is it wrong to hit my brother?"
"Because you're hurting him."

Wordplay? AFAIK 'obligation' means there is something compelling/forcing me and 'consideration' means I will think and decide about it myself.

That is a failed cop-out mister.

I'm saying eating animals simply because they taste good is not a good enough reason to subject them to the horrors of industrial animal processing (which tonight Jon Stewart compared, not unfairly, to Abu Ghraib).
No you were not, read your own post where you tell me that you just said that I have an 'obligation'.

Actions follow from a consideration of interests. Let's use a closer analogy: "Why is it wrong to kill a human being for the purposes of eating him?"

It simply *is* not. You make that as a basis of your whole line of reasoning, but the matter of the fact is just that a lot of people do not like it.

But in no way does that make that it automatically follows that I have any 'obligation'.

As I said, I do have the 'consideration', but anything that follows is mine.

Killing someone because you're interested in how he might taste does not sound like a promising justification.
It has been done a couple of years ago; with the consent of the victim.
The german cannibal, remember?

You probably missed a lot of the discussion around that one...

If you think killing a human for food is wrong,
Which I don't.

and killing an animal for food is A-OK,
Which I do, but that even without the previous point.

then you should have no difficulty citing the critically significant difference between the two.

There is none. The critically significant difference here is the consequences; judgement of my peers.

Making the consideration would be a lot harder as, for me, it is easier to attach to people than to animals, but the weight and difficulty of the consideration (still not the obligation) do not make the principle less.

I will not kill humans because I like them and I do not like when they get hurt. And I do not want to go to jail. And I want to have a nice social life.

All items that weigh in under the 'consideration'. But there is no single 'obligation'.

Vegetarians freely answer this question with regard to plants all the time.

Good for them?
 
Dear All - busy at work and no internet at home. Not disappearing; will be back on Monday.

GrenNME - The discussion on lines is the key one, and the one where Cain's discussions to RF immediately above are very pertinent. I don't think any meat-eater has been able to coherently and consistently explain why they draw the line where they do...
 
Dear All - busy at work and no internet at home. Not disappearing; will be back on Monday.

GrenNME - The discussion on lines is the key one, and the one where Cain's discussions to RF immediately above are very pertinent. I don't think any meat-eater has been able to coherently and consistently explain why they draw the line where they do...

I do not draw a line at all!

I want to know why I would have to draw one!

I am consistent. And I am pretty coherent at that.
 
I do not draw a line at all!

I want to know why I would have to draw one!

I am consistent. And I am pretty coherent at that.

I don't believe you.

You'd eat ANYTHING - even endangered species? And you're OK with animal torture - literally, people torturing animals to death for fun, a practice which is resolutely illegal in most Western countries?

I simply do not believe you have no line at all when it comes to delineating acceptable vs unacceptable behaviour towards animals. If you really don't, you're a rare human being indeed.
 
You're happy to invoke objectivist moral philosophies like utilitarianism, and simultaneously deny that there is any objective morality, and simultaneously act as if evolved behaviours are some kind of guide to how we should act, and simultaneously deny you are doing any such thing.

If you were consistent in holding that things are only perceived as moral, you wouldn't be talking about morality at all, because the term would be utterly meaningless except in a sociological context.

Excuse me, but is there any point to morals EXCEPT in a sociological context ?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom