RandFan
Mormon Atheist
- Joined
- Dec 18, 2001
- Messages
- 60,135
I don't know that they should. Society has bestowed them rights. I percieve that it would be immoral to harm an infant. I've not seen an argument to change my mind.The question is one of whether or not infants have rights.
Do you have an argument to take away the rights of infants?
And if it did cure AIDS? It doesn't of course so your example is absurd. But if it did perhaps it would be good for their society. I find such an idea revolting but you and Kevin keep telling me that what I find revolting is neither here nor there. How about you? If raping babies would cure AIDS in parts of Africa where AIDS is skyrocketing, how would you decide and why?If you want a concrete example, then in some African tribes there's a belief that baby rape can cure AIDS. If somebody thinks she can cure AIDS by praying to a statue, we don't much care, but harming others raises concerns.
More rhetoric. See, this isn't an argument. But then you knew that.As for your Steven Pinker comment... just stop embarrassing yourself.
I've no argument against it. I know that society deems it immoral. I know that I percieve it as immoral. If you have a good argument, like the AIDS argument I'll consider it.I'm asking why it's wrong.
I was impressed by an argument made by Peter Singer to consider enlarging our circle. He made it about primates and I can't find it at the moment but his argument for whales is pretty close.The question is: how is that morally relevant?
The brain capacity of an animal and its social interactions were premises offered by Singer that we should consider. I think those are significant and I'm willing to entertain them. Are you saying I should ignore those? That Singer would critisize me for enlarging my personal circle for taking into account his arguments?I argued that whales are social mammals with big brains, capable of enjoying life and of feeling pain — and not only physical pain, but very likely also distress at the loss of one of their group.
See, you substitute ivective, assertion and claims for argument. It's all rhetoric Cain.No, I'll say more: I forgot that you've suspended the law of non-contradiction; you have a casual disregard for basic consistency. Moreover, you have no idea what you're saying. You think juggling involves keeping four balls in the air at once, but instead of actually juggling the same four balls, you're just rapidly chucking things into the sky. You're an incompetent clown.
It would be nice if you could keep the rhetoric to a minimum and focus more on arguments. I assure you it has no effect. Even some of those who are inclined to agree with you, roborama, volatile, recognize that the abuse just strokes your ego.
Last edited: