Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

And until then, taste trumps all?

No, until then we should make every effort to educate people on the environmental impacts and reduce meat consumption. Hopefully, this would drive demand for more environmentally-friendly practices.

I don't understand why you're willing to engage in an action that causes definitive and demonstrable harm and is, I would suggest, incompatible with your general position on animal welfare (is killing an animal for fun OK in your book? - I hastily presume not), for such weak reasons.

Well, partly because I'm not sure I agree with some of the things you label as "harm". Partly because I'm a selfish S.O.B.: Getting groups of people, as a whole to reduce consumption would have a much greater impact than me personally eliminating meat from my diet. And in the latter case, I'm penalizing myself with no discernible effect on the planet.

My position on animal welfare is one of sliding scales. I do not believe that "all life is equal"; In general, I value human life over animal life, and some animals' over others'.

Is "killing an animal for fun OK"? I don't know. In general, I would say no, but isn't sport hunting essentially "killing for fun"? Most hunters eat their kill, but are they hunting for the meat, or for the fun of hunting? The same goes for non-commercial fishermen. On the other hand, developing and retaining the ability to hunt or fish can be pragmatic. Hunting is sometimes needed to reduce overpopulation of some animals, for example.


The way I see it is that in industrialised nations it is easy to be vegan. As such, we can construct our dietary from a neutral middle-ground, considering the pros and cons of each choice. All you're doing is arbitrarily starting from one side because of history and tradition - reasons, I would suggest, that you would reject any arguments in favour of other demonstrably harmful activities.

Maybe, but, to some degree I feel that a purely vegan diet would reduce my quality of life. Cooking and sharing good meals is a big part of what makes life enjoyable to me. I actually eat quite a few vegetarian and vegan meals, but restricting myself to just those meals would be a drudgery to me.
 
The ball is in your court, what reason do I have to exclude children or chimps? Again, look in the mirror.

Well isn't this another interesting bit of dishonesty. I posed the argument two ways, pal, so it doesn't matter which argument you try to run away from. How neat it is that you need a reason to EXCLUDE. Why so much hemming and hawing when it came to producing a reason to exclude cows?

And I wrote that it is without foundation. Hey, I know, let's go around in circles.

That you assert that I was "pinned down" doesn't make it true. Here you go again, the above is only rhetoric. Hint: It's NOT an argument.

Just because you assert something doesn't make it true. I don't know how long it is going to take before you learn that.

You're padding your post. Now THIS is rich:

[*]Golden rule.
[*]see #1.

So you put your first point before your sentence and an identical(!) point, indeed it reads "see #1" right after. Interesting. It also helps, I suppose, to be as vague as possible. So by "perceiving intrinsically important blah blah blah blah blah human condition" what you REALLY meant, it turns out, was the golden rule. Jesus, why didn't you say that at the start?

Now let's go back to page 20 and see how this comports with your original remark:

A domesticated animal doesn't worry about the possibility that it will die (having had children I can tell you from a very young age they do both, in this instance you should use infant). Killing an animal doesn't rob it of something that we perceive as intrinsically important to the human condition.

So help me out here: are you saying that it's OK to kill animals because of the golden rule? Do you see how this doesn't work at all? I asked why it's OK to kill children -- technically an infant falls under the umbrella of children, but if you insist on a pyrrhic ego-saving victory, fine -- infant. That's why you had to B.S. the term "human condition" along with other fuzzy language because the Golden Rule does not work. (Oh, but just wait until we get to Lockean values in a moment.)

Re: "Why didn't you mention this in the first place?"
[*]Fallacy (the timing of when I mention something does not alter the truth value of the argument) however I wasn't interested in making that argument at the beginning of this thread. I've made that argument with you before.

Yes, as I have said before, the timing makes no difference to the argument. But the "argument" you're putting forward is so bad, not unlike your past behavior on this topic, that it calls into question good faith. In other words, it's magical thinking, post hoc reasoning. If you admitted, "I'm sort of making this up as I go along," then I would be more forgiving. Writing is discovery. But you don't, instead choosing to throw out any B.S. that sticks, relying on vague cliches rather than clear arguments.

[*]I don't use it to include chimps.
[*]Cows have never been demonstrated to be particularly interested in liberty and the pursuit of happiness.

So again how do you include chimps? Oh, wait, that's right, you need me to provide some reason for excluding chimps. I know! How about liberty and the pursuit of happiness. :rolleyes:

Life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. Those are the intrinsic values of humans that other animals don't (by and large) share. Humans want to be free and pursue productive and happy lives as expressed by John Locke, George Mason and Thomas Jefferson. However, to the extent that primates and other animals do have these values then I would happily consider them.

This sounds like a put-on. I know it's not a put-on because you're not sophisticated enough for such Voltaire-esque ridicule. Look at the clumsy, barely there connection to "intrinsic." You do realize that pre-Darwinian natural rights theorists regarded these truths as self-evident, right? Do you not see the dramatic shift in your whole moral framework? What am I saying, of course not.

--------------------------
Thaiboxerken:
Because it tastes good, it's legal, and no one has yet to give me a reasonable argument as to why it is wrong.

I don't think you're interested in a meaningful dialog. It's the brickwall defense: you want to cross your arms and shake your head, and I doubt if any rational argument can convince you otherwise.

Everyone has a moral obligation to justify behavior that negatively impacts beings worthy of our moral consideration, and the fact is there's a broad social consensus that the animals our society consumes fit that bill.

Iran is wrong because they can't show that homosexual behavior is wrong

But according to your demented reasoning Iran does not need to demonstrate homosexual behavior is wrong because people already think it's wrong. According to you, if a society thinks it's OK to murder homosexuals, then it's up gay rights advocates to make the case murder is wrong. And I'll tell you how that story goes:

Advocate: Murdering homosexuals is wrong because they're not any different than you or I.
Mullah: That's crazy! They're gay!
Crowd: Lalalalalalala -- kill him.

In point of fact, social change requires challenging unexamined views, seeking justification. Why is homosexuality wrong? It's about raising questions. If killing animals for food is morally kosher, and you're so confident that it is, then it should be a simple task to explain how it's justified. I doubt you would have any problem explaining why it's OK to imprison a murderer. With these sort of arguments, the burden of proof technically rests with the person (or institution) exercising power over someone else. Volatile did not balk at answering why it's OK to consume vegetables because the justification is there.
 
Well isn't this another interesting bit of dishonesty. I posed the argument two ways, pal, so it doesn't matter which argument you try to run away from. How neat it is that you need a reason to EXCLUDE. Why so much hemming and hawing when it came to producing a reason to exclude cows?

Ok, ok, give me the kid and the chimp, I'll eat them. If I find a culture where it is normal and I am not persecuted legally and they serve it. I'll eat it.

Everyone has a moral obligation to justify behavior that negatively impacts beings worthy of our moral consideration, and the fact is there's a broad social consensus that the animals our society consumes fit that bill.
This is what I actually want to respond to, although the previous statement is true nonetheless.

So, why do I have that obligation? I feel neither obliged nor inclined to justify that behaviour.

And your so-called fact is, of course, very Western oriented.

But according to your demented reasoning Iran does not need to demonstrate homosexual behavior is wrong because people already think it's wrong. According to you, if a society thinks it's OK to murder homosexuals, then it's up gay rights advocates to make the case murder is wrong. And I'll tell you how that story goes:

Advocate: Murdering homosexuals is wrong because they're not any different than you or I.
Mullah: That's crazy! They're gay!
Crowd: Lalalalalalala -- kill him.

Probably it will go like that yes. But I think it morally unjust that you can just think that your way is the only right way and judge them.

I personally would not want to live in a country that thinks like that, but hey, they are a sovereign country. And no matter how much you do not like it, it is their right.

A lot of countries around the world think the U.S. should change in a quite a number of ways. In fact, I dare to say that the majority of the world thinks that the U.S. is dead wrong in how people live their lives.

Are you going to consider their ways of life now?

In point of fact, social change requires challenging unexamined views, seeking justification. Why is homosexuality wrong? It's about raising questions. If killing animals for food is morally kosher, and you're so confident that it is, then it should be a simple task to explain how it's justified. I doubt you would have any problem explaining why it's OK to imprison a murderer. With these sort of arguments, the burden of proof technically rests with the person (or institution) exercising power over someone else. Volatile did not balk at answering why it's OK to consume vegetables because the justification is there.

Before you *make* people justify their behaviour, can you at least give me a justification on why you want them to justify it in a rational way, or in a way that conforms with your methods of justification?

Your behaviour or at least your line of questioning is quite in contradiction with the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

And yeah, there are points in there that do not go well with the behaviour in countries like Iran, but that does not mean you do not have to care about them either.
 

I'm sorry, but the certainty of the wording in the story strikes me as an example of the Science News Cycle, which often matches the research actually produced or any conclusions only by naming the title and sometimes grabbing a few sentences as quotes. I say this because you'll find study after study cited by people who are arguing both sides of the deal (vegetarian diets are bad! / vegetarian diets are better!), as if the study of nutrition and the long-term effects of diets are so conclusive that there is some kind of objective answer within these studies. There isn't, except for the obvious "eat smarter and be healthier" conclusion which applies to all.

I know the quoted post above was likely more in jest. I just wanted to make sure that the link isn't taken without applying general critical thinking skills to it.
 
I know the quoted post above was likely more in jest. I just wanted to make sure that the link isn't taken without applying general critical thinking skills to it.
Why should anyone start now? No one in this thread has, yet...

(I include myself, thank you very much!)
 
Why should anyone start now? No one in this thread has, yet...

(I include myself, thank you very much!)

i liek meet.
banjo.gif
 
Volatile, it seems you've brought a second wind to the discussion.

I just wanted to point out that, in the last thread, I'm fairly certain we were able to reach an agreement that the major difference between where you draw the line on the suffering of animals dictating your dietary choices and where others draw the line on the same is that the lines are in two different places. I also thought we were able to both admit that the lines are each arbitrarily designated due to values we place on several factors. Has this changed?

The reason you're finding fault with those "weaker" arguments (your words) is that you're measuring them from your designated values and not theirs. RandFan and I both have already argued the "why" for the line being drawn in a different location for people who have little or no problem eating meat. The people whose statements your finding fault with aren't making intellectually dishonest claims or arguments, they're stating their basis from a line that places different values on the lives and suffering of animals as you do. When they argue that a case hasn't been made specifically clarifying what is so wrong about eating meat, they're pointing out that there hasn't been a successful argument presented to them that convincingly persuades them to re-evaluate the demarcation point for the values that they've already been working from.

I know-- one of the premises you've put forth is that people generally haven't ever put forth any examination of that line of demarcation. I understand where you're coming from with that. However, what I've already argued is that there are valid arguments for that line of demarcation being set where it is still acceptable to eat meat, just as there are valid arguments for setting that line to be even more restrictive than your own dietary choices. They're just not going to fall in the same place for everyone, and the main problem that's been evident in Cain's and Kevin's arguments is a lack of acceptance that this is a realistic consideration.
 
I don't think you're interested in a meaningful dialog. It's the brickwall defense: you want to cross your arms and shake your head, and I doubt if any rational argument can convince you otherwise.

The same could be said of you. It's pure sophistry in your case, though.

Everyone has a moral obligation to justify behavior that negatively impacts beings worthy of our moral consideration, and the fact is there's a broad social consensus that the animals our society consumes fit that bill.
I agree. However, non-humans are not beings. Otherwise, they would be able to opt into the social contract.

But according to your demented reasoning Iran does not need to demonstrate homosexual behavior is wrong because people already think it's wrong.
Nope. My reasoning is that people should be allowed the freedom to do any activity unless it's been shown to be wrong.

No one has shown homosexuality to be wrong. No one has show playing chess to be wrong. No one has shown meat eating to be wrong.

When people fought for gay rights, they did not do so on the basis of "it's right to be gay." They fought on the basis of freedom and that it's not wrong to be gay. In fact, many of us in the USA are still fighting for gay rights, as in same-sex marriage. Again, not based on the "gay marriage is right" notion, but on the notion that it isn't wrong, it's not harmful and discrimination.
 
Last edited:
Why so much hemming and hawing when it came to producing a reason to exclude cows?
I gave you the reason. You either accept it or you don't. You certainly haven't rebutted it and accusing me of dishonesty isn't an argument as I've told you time and again.

...why didn't you say that at the start?
I don't see why it needs to be said.

So help me out here: are you saying that it's OK to kill animals because of the golden rule?
I'm saying that I might enlarge the circle because of the golden rule.

I asked why it's OK to kill ... infant.
I don't think it is ok to kill infants. I ask you again and again but you won't answer me. What reason does anyone have to kill infants? Yes, I do get your point but it's an invented controversy. Humans have evolved the adaptive trait to protect infants. The hypothesis has lead to several predictions that have been verified by studies (see Pinker).

So, we could argue that it's permissible to kill infants and perhaps it is but YOU need to promote that argument not me.

But you don't, instead choosing to throw out any B.S. that sticks, relying on vague cliches rather than clear arguments.
Rhetorical and false. I've made the same arguments I've made for years. When this thread began I was only interested in advancing a point about human perceptions of morality.

So, one more time, your assertions are NOT arguments.

So again how do you include chimps?
They have higher brain functions than many other animals.

You do realize that pre-Darwinian natural rights theorists regarded these truths as self-evident, right?
You do realize that it doesn't obviate my point, right?
 
Last edited:
The argument is not "If you eat cows, why don't you eat babies?", but "If "sufficient protein" is the reason you eat cows, why don't you eat babies/". It's about probing the shallowness of though that seems so often to so into defences of meat-eating.
Whether vegan or not we don't perceive animals (non-human) and human babies the same. We wouldn't pass laws to protect ruminants in the wild but we would pass laws to protect babies.

If a wild animal were found to be killing infants in some remote village we would go out of our way to stop it. If we find out that some wild animal is eating baby ducks we would simply think that the wild animal is doing its job.

Is it shallow to allow animals in the wild to suffer and die?

I think the issue is far more complex than you would like to believe it to be.
 
I know-- one of the premises you've put forth is that people generally haven't ever put forth any examination of that line of demarcation. I understand where you're coming from with that. However, what I've already argued is that there are valid arguments for that line of demarcation being set where it is still acceptable to eat meat, just as there are valid arguments for setting that line to be even more restrictive than your own dietary choices. They're just not going to fall in the same place for everyone, and the main problem that's been evident in Cain's and Kevin's arguments is a lack of acceptance that this is a realistic consideration.
Agreed.
 
I don't think it is ok to kill infants. I ask you again and again but you won't answer me. What reason does anyone have to kill infants? Yes, I do get your point but it's an invented controversy. Humans have evolved the adaptive trait to protect infants. The hypothesis has lead to several predictions that have been verified by studies (see Pinker).

...yet you're not indulging in the naturalistic fallacy. Nope. Not one bit.

:rolleyes:

The pattern here is that since you've abandoned consistency or coherency, you feel entitled have your argument be everything and nothing at once. If you can cook up an ad hoc justification for your existing beliefs using the naturalistic fallacy you'll do it. When you get called on it, suddenly you don't believe in the naturalistic fallacy at all and you complain stridently about straw men. If you can cook up an ad hoc justification for your existing beliefs using utilitarianism, or the golden rule, or moral relativism, or anything else you're perfectly happy to do that too. When you get called on to employ any of those moral philosophies consistently, you drop them like they are not and squeal like a stuck pig about straw men again.

Yes, you've changed you moral views in the past. That is in no way evidence that you did so on rational bases, or that you are acting rationally now. If anything this thread makes it look like you change your views on irrational bases and then grab any intellectual-sounding justification you can after the fact.

This isn't thinking, RandFan. It's more like you are playing a game of Mad Libs with philosophical terms.
 
Last edited:
...yet you're not indulging in the naturalistic fallacy. Nope. Not one bit.

:rolleyes:

The pattern here is that since you've abandoned consistency or coherency, you feel entitled have your argument be everything and nothing at once. If you can cook up an ad hoc justification for your existing beliefs using the naturalistic fallacy you'll do it. When you get called on it, suddenly you don't believe in the naturalistic fallacy at all and you complain stridently about straw men. If you can cook up an ad hoc justification for your existing beliefs using utilitarianism, or the golden rule, or moral relativism, or anything else you're perfectly happy to do that too. When you get called on to employ any of those moral philosophies consistently, you drop them like they are not and squeal like a stuck pig about straw men again.

Yes, you've changed you moral views in the past. That is in no way evidence that you did so on rational bases, or that you are acting rationally now. If anything this thread makes it look like you change your views on irrational bases and then grab any intellectual-sounding justification you can after the fact.

This isn't thinking, RandFan. It's more like you are playing a game of Mad Libs with philosophical terms.

I'm eating beef right at this moment.

You can really taste the suffering. :D
 
The pattern here is that since you've abandoned consistency or coherency...
A rhetorical device. Like I tell Cain, assertion isn't argument.

, you feel entitled have your argument be everything and nothing at once. If you can cook up an ad hoc justification for your existing beliefs using the naturalistic fallacy you'll do it.
I get how it's easy for you to ignore what others say and simply spout "naturalistic fallacy" but my position is no different than Dawkins, Shermers, de Waal, Pinker et al.

Dawkins points out that humans have an evolved moral sense. No naturalistic fallacy.
RandFan points out that humans have an evolved moral sense. Naturalistic fallacy.

THAT'S INCOHERENT!

In absence of actually dealing with what I'm saying you just viscerally accuse me of committing a fallacy.

I did not say that anything is right or wrong because it's natural. I said that we don't perceive killing and eating babies as the moral thing to do. I'm waiting for an argument to think otherwise. For some odd reason you can't give me one. And get this, surprise surprise neither can Cain. No, you want me to justify killing infants when I don't personally perceive it as moral. I don't believe morals are absolute but I'd need a pretty convincing argument to overcome the disgust and revulsion of killing a baby.

Have you that argument?

Now, I've no inborn or indoctrinated revulsion at killing animals for the purpose of eating them. On top of that I've got a reasonable argument for killing and eating them. One I've made for years and if you and Cain deny that then you are lying. Flat out.

Animal husbandry provides a benefit for an animal in return of the benefit of providing sustenance.

This isn't thinking, RandFan. It's more like you are playing a game of Mad Libs with philosophical terms.
Yeah, more tired rhetoric. You and Cain, that's all your slim opinion relies on. Assertion, personal attack and rhetoric.

No argument just assertion and claims.
 
Last edited:
I agree. However, non-humans are not beings. Otherwise, they would be able to opt into the social contract.

It's not exactly clear what you agree with here. If you're linking being to consenting to a social contract, then you need to show how that's morally significant. Most importantly, you completely ignore moral obligations to animals. Are you, for instance, opposed to laws prohibiting the torture of animals? And so, let's start there: Do you think the case has been made that torturing animals is wrong?

Nope. My reasoning is that people should be allowed the freedom to do any activity unless it's been shown to be wrong.

This is "heads, I win; tails, you lose." Earlier you wrote:

Instead, why not have THEM convince us that eating meat is wrong. After all, the burden is upon them to do so. The social norm is that eating meat is ok. They have to show that it's wrong in order to change society.

and then:

Instead of giving an argument as to why raising animals to eat is wrong, you keep trying to shift the burden of conviction onto the status quo. It's generally accepted that raising animals to eat is ok.

and other expressions of the same sentiment. I'm sure GreNME's going to come in any moment to accuse you of moving goalposts, even though that doesn't go far enough: you're trying to change venues.

I've snipped other parts of your post that are not worth my time.
------------------------------
realpaladin:
So, why do I have that obligation? I feel neither obliged nor inclined to justify that behaviour.

I explained why in the very sentence you quote: you're thwarting another being's interests, placing your own (interest in taste) above hers (interest in living).

Again, there's no way to reason with anyone who prefers to stick their head in the sand. If someone presents arguments for the existence of a god, my short answer is that their ideas are not compelling, but to have any pretense of a discussion I need to explain what's mistaken.

I personally would not want to live in a country that thinks like that, but hey, they are a sovereign country. And no matter how much you do not like it, it is their right.

A lot of countries around the world think the U.S. should change in a quite a number of ways. In fact, I dare to say that the majority of the world thinks that the U.S. is dead wrong in how people live their lives.

Are you going to consider their ways of life now?

You're missing the context of the exchange, which is one reason why I quoted TBK's earlier comments first. I was operating within his framework on burden of proof and status quo (see above).

Before you *make* people justify their behaviour, can you at least give me a justification on why you want them to justify it in a rational way, or in a way that conforms with your methods of justification?

As I already said, it has to do with thwarting the interests of animals, but let's use a comparison from earlier: suppose people think it's OK to dispose of animals in any manner. Jones, for example, can buy a dog, cat, cow, whatever, and torture it as he pleases. Do you think there are compelling moral arguments that can be made to outlaw torture?

------------
RandFan:
I don't think it is ok to kill infants. I ask you again and again but you won't answer me. What reason does anyone have to kill infants? Yes, I do get your point but it's an invented controversy.

What reason does a white person have to kill a black person? The question is one of whether or not infants have rights. If you want a concrete example, then in some African tribes there's a belief that baby rape can cure AIDS. If somebody thinks she can cure AIDS by praying to a statue, we don't much care, but harming others raises concerns.

As for your Steven Pinker comment... just stop embarrassing yourself.

So, we could argue that it's permissible to kill infants and perhaps it is but YOU need to promote that argument not me.

I'm asking why it's wrong.

They have higher brain functions than many other animals.

Are you incapable of integrating these ideas? The question is: how is that morally relevant?

You do realize that it doesn't obviate my point, right?

Should I shriek "assertion," like your vague "assertion/rhetoric" nonsense. No, I'll say more: I forgot that you've suspended the law of non-contradiction; you have a casual disregard for basic consistency. Moreover, you have no idea what you're saying. You think juggling involves keeping four balls in the air at once, but instead of actually juggling the same four balls, you're just rapidly chucking things into the sky. You're an incompetent clown.
 
It's not exactly clear what you agree with here. If you're linking being to consenting to a social contract, then you need to show how that's morally significant. Most importantly, you completely ignore moral obligations to animals. Are you, for instance, opposed to laws prohibiting the torture of animals? And so, let's start there: Do you think the case has been made that torturing animals is wrong?

I didn't realize we have a moral obligation to animals. Can you tell me what those obligations are and what objective source you obtained them from?

and other expressions of the same sentiment. I'm sure GreNME's going to come in any moment to accuse you of moving goalposts, even though that doesn't go far enough: you're trying to change venues.

Except I haven't moved goal posts. You've not crossed any of the goals I've outlined. Did you have an argument as to why eating meat is wrong?
 
I explained why in the very sentence you quote: you're thwarting another being's interests, placing your own (interest in taste) above hers (interest in living).

That is not explaining, that is stating. And it is wrong to boot.

It makes me have a 'consideration', not an 'obligation'.

So. Explain the 'obligation' again?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom