Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

A consensus that it is worse for the environment that a vegan diet.

I didn't see any scientific study that stated this conclusion.

The end point of "less" is "none", clearly.

Really? You seem to have a strange notion about quantities.

The killing of cows for food in the presence of nutritionally-complete alternatives. Killing cows for food is not axiomatically wrong - as I have already explained. Killing anything for food is not axiomatically wrong, if the alternative is starvation. But he process is the problem precisely because we have alternatives which are less damaging, and pretty-much no-one in the West has to make the choice between killing an animal for food, and dying of starvation.

This is just a value judgment, and it's one that I don't agree with.

When you go to buy dinner, you have an irrational choice based on habit and tradition and personal whim, or you have a rational choice based on logical pragmatism and internal consistency. It's up to you which one you pick.

You have yet to show that your position is rational.


Yes, they do. And why do they eat too much meat? Because meat is more damaging than plants. Ergo - no meat is better than some meat. This is all about consistency.

You haven't shown that no meat is better than some meat.

Still. Will you then endeavour to eat less meat? I can send you some recipes. One meat free day a week?

Not really. I'm moving to Russia where the alternatives are very scarce in the small town I'll be living. Also, I don't eat meat three times a day already anyway.
 
So is babies. And cats. And gorillas.

Eat them?
Might be tasty. Haven't had the opportunity to try them. Do they taste like chicken? Or is it more like beef?

So? Why are these necessary components of a positive case? Theism is legal and enriching, and yet you'd readily dismiss anyone making that case in favour of belief in a deity.
How do you know what I'd dismiss? Hmm? I might warmly embrace them, and call them honey, for all you know.

Why don't you care about them? Why shouldn't we care about the moral implications and rational coherency of our actions?
It makes you squeamish to think about how I get my meat. Doesn't me. That's all it boils down to, no matter how you want to frame it.

Simplistic? Yep. You betcha. Ain't that a bitch? But most of these stupid arguments boil down to that. Abortion: You find it repulsive, I don't. (This is just an example, I may or may not have a different position on this, and I don't really care what yours is.) War in Iraq. War in general. Yada yada yada. It still all boils down to "I think it's just awful, how can you think that way?" Well, I'm just an amoral creep. I'm just Jeffery Dahmer with a barbeque grill, except no one can throw me in jail for it. Get over it, or get used to it. We'll all be happier.

Think I'll go kill a cow for Christ now, or the deity/non-deity of your choice.

I'm such a reprehensible bastard. Trouble is, I know it and don't care.
 
Great argument! I'm giving up chess.

Will you do the same with meat?
Are you suggesting that as long as I can offer up reasons why something has negative consequences I can essentially convince you to stop doing it?

Shall I move on to the negative aspects of forum postings? Will you give that up too?

I will still eat meat, and I will still play chess. Despite the fact that both meat and chess, as well as every activity human beings take part in have negative consequences to the planet and cause unnecessary suffering. I'm evil like that.:D
 
I didn't see any scientific study that stated this conclusion.

You read the articles I linked, right? The one that cited the work of the IPCC?

Really? You seem to have a strange notion about quantities.

You don't think "zero" is the teleological end-point of a trajectory towards "none"?

If "less meat" is good, "no meat" is better.

This is just a value judgment, and it's one that I don't agree with.

It's not. It is entirely at the heart of the issue. If one has two alternatives, one of which has demonstrable negatives and few compelling positives, whereas the other has no demonstrable negatives, then one is morally obliged, and rationally and reasonably obliged, to pick the latter. If you only have once choice, then the obligation evaporates.

That you call this a simple value judgement illustrates that you really are missing the point.

The fact remains - two choices, one clearly worse than the other. You pick the worse one every single day. If you could make a case for the worse one, then I'd understand. but you won't. You can't.


You have yet to show that your position is rational.

It follows from the facts on the ground, and is consistent with a position considering unnecessary animal harm wrong.

You have not shown your position to be rational. Quite the opposite, in fact - you have actively claimed you hold it for irrational reasons ("status quo" being the most obvious).

As I said, it falls upon you to make a positive rational case. Please do so.

Not really. I'm moving to Russia where the alternatives are very scarce in the small town I'll be living.

OK. Fine, then meat eating is fine under those circumstances. Morally and rationally. Vegans who claim they'd rather starve than eat chicken are wrong.

Until you move, though, I take it you'll be vegan? As presumably right now you have access to vegan food - beans, grains, pulses and legumes?

Also, I don't eat meat three times a day already anyway.

Who on earth eats meat three times a day? I didn't do that even when I eat meat myself!
 
Are you suggesting that as long as I can offer up reasons why something has negative consequences I can essentially convince you to stop doing it?

Shall I move on to the negative aspects of forum postings? Will you give that up too?

I will still eat meat, and I will still play chess. Despite the fact that both meat and chess, as well as every activity human beings take part in have negative consequences to the planet and cause unnecessary suffering. I'm evil like that.:D

Negative reasons that outweigh the positives. That's important.
 
That is a stupid argument, so it's good no-one made it. I suggest perhaps you read those posts again. Cain and I bring up babies precisely to counter arguments like "It's a good source of protein", to prove that there are necessarily OTHER considerations at play and that the offering of such in defence of one's position belies either mendacity or, more often, an ill-conceived argument.

The argument is not "If you eat cows, why don't you eat babies?", but "If "sufficient protein" is the reason you eat cows, why don't you eat babies/". It's about probing the shallowness of though that seems so often to so into defences of meat-eating.


No. It is a stupid argument. I eat animals specifically raised for human consumption. I have no desire to eat any hominid species.

To whit:



None. Our staple food animals - pigs, cows, chickens, sheep - are all kept as pets and companion animals. I have no issue with eating home-reared eggs, or from shearing free-roaming sheep for wool, so they'd be fine too.




We could start by feeding all the soy we currently feed to beef cattle to humans. That'd be an excellent start.



True - but the yield per acre is much better with plants (remember at the moment, we grow plants, feed them to animals, then eat the animals), so your mental calculations are way off.

And how much of that food is fit for human consumption?


[quote[So the vegans on here surely must know.. What we would need to do to stop eating meat? How much more farmland would we need to provide all the protein that humanity requires?

Less than is currently used to farm beef.
[/quote]

Data. Hard facts, please.

Even though it is scientifically-demonstrable that a meat-eating diet is WORSE for the environment than a vegan one? That's hubris, arrogance and ignorance all in one sentence.

Who cares? Give me the data.

Why not eat grains, leaves, pulses and legumes sufficient to your dietary needs instead?
I do both.

DATA man, DATA. The evidence ball is in your court. I want hard, scientific Data. Very little meat is reared on land suitable for farming. Much of the food fed to these animals seems to be ill-suited for human consumption.

And even if you gave me the data, I would still eat meat. I would just do so with more knowledge. What I do not like is someone telling me that their morals/religion is better than mine, and that I am wrong and thus am a bad bad bad person. If I met someone who told me thus, I would go to KFC, buy a bucket of chicken, and eat it in their face, while talking about how good the tortured cage fed animals are.

I will not be convinced to switch to an all pure vegan diet. Ain't going to happen short of a life threatening illness that would force me to stop consuming animal products. I enjoy the taste, my body seems to adequately process it, and as long as I don't overeat it, I will remain healthy.
 
I understand that morality is subjective

And yet you then say:
morally indefensible.

Just because you don't agree with the defences put forward does not mean they do not exist. For example:
* Humans are evolved to eat meat.
* It tastes nice.
* It's an efficient source of protein.
* It's a source of some nutrients that are not easily available from other sources.
* Tradition.
* Cows are evil and must be punished.
* Eating meat annoys people like PETA.
* Hunting is fun and it's a shame to waste the meat afterwards.

People eat meat for all those reasons and many more. Disagree with them all you like, but you can't just pretend that they don't exist.

In any case, the simple fact is that the vast majority of people in the world disagree with your morality. You are the one trying to get others to change their morality. We don't need to defend our morality because that is already the excepted norm - you are the one who needs to defend yours. So far you're really not doing a good job of it.

The end point of "less" is "none", clearly.

Nonsense. Most people (in the west at least) could do with eating less salt, but it would be rather stupid of them to eat none. Sometimes the end point of "less" is "none", but sometimes it isn't. Your arguments could be a lot more convincing if you dropped all the hyperbole and absolutism.
 
You'd eat ANYTHING? Endangered species? Your mother's kitten? Higher primates? Soya beans from deforested land?

Sure, why not ? If they're available for eating then they're already dead. At that point the fact that they are endangered or not makes no difference.

And if we were farming them the question of numbers is again irrelevant.

You have criteria.

Yes, I don't kill humans for food.

I just proffer they are rationally indefensible and internally inconsistent, just like every other meat-eater I've ever met.

How is it inconsistent ? I said I eat what I want to eat. That's not contradictory at all. You're the one who is trying to create an arbitrary distinction between stuff we should eat and stuff we shouldn't eat. It's up to you to justify such a distinction, and so far you've failed to do so.

It's up to you to convince me otherwise, of course, by actually making a case FOR your diet.

No, I'm not actually making any claim. You are.
 
OK then. Pass the steak... :rolleyes: The fact that there is no clear dividing line between a lower class of animal and some more complex plant species is definitely an argument FOR meat-eating!

Strawman. I never said it was. I was simply pointing out that your claim was WRONG.

My point is - that proves you hold a moral stance when it comes to animals. You consider them within a moral framework. It's therefore necessary to make a positive moral case that eating them is the right thing to do.

That makes no sense, whatsoever. When the animal is DEAD, it cannot suffer and thus there is NO morality involved in eating its remains. I am concerned about suffering while the thing is actually ALIVE, which is before I eat it.
 
You read the articles I linked, right? The one that cited the work of the IPCC?

Did it even mention vegan diets?

You don't think "zero" is the teleological end-point of a trajectory towards "none"?

If "less meat" is good, "no meat" is better.

Really? I want to lose a few pounds, so I decided to eat less food. Eating too much food is bad. By your logic, I should just stop eating, because no food is better than less food.

It's not. It is entirely at the heart of the issue. If one has two alternatives, one of which has demonstrable negatives and few compelling positives, whereas the other has no demonstrable negatives, then one is morally obliged, and rationally and reasonably obliged, to pick the latter. If you only have once choice, then the obligation evaporates.

These negatives vs positives are your value judgments.

The fact remains - two choices, one clearly worse than the other. You pick the worse one every single day. If you could make a case for the worse one, then I'd understand. but you won't. You can't.

You haven't demonstrated that I'm making a worse choice.


You have not shown your position to be rational. Quite the opposite, in fact - you have actively claimed you hold it for irrational reasons ("status quo" being the most obvious).

I don't need to. You're the one trying to change my mind.

As I said, it falls upon you to make a positive rational case. Please do so.

NO

Until you move, though, I take it you'll be vegan? As presumably right now you have access to vegan food - beans, grains, pulses and legumes?

Nope.

Who on earth eats meat three times a day? I didn't do that even when I eat meat myself!

I know plenty of people that do, specifically athletic people.

Did you have an argument as to abstaining from eating meat, or are you just going to stick with the arguments you're using that simply show that society, as a whole, should consume less meat?
 
Because there are no good reasons to eat meat, basically

There are no good reason to eat vegetables, either.

You see ? Any and all reasons you put forward to NOT eat meat also applies to NOT eating vegetables. That one type of food is bad for me is irrelevant, because it is not a moral issue. Eating Willy Wonka products isn't good for me but that is not relevant morally. I can eat them if I want to.

I wouldn't have eaten my cat even when I was eating meat

If your cat died and you decided to cook it I wouldn't have a thing to say against it.

Unhappy with this irrationality, and unwilling to eat Tiddles, veganism strikes me as the only rational dietary choice.

Well I, for one, wish to defend the rights of plants, so now you can only eat dirt or you are an irrational plant murderer! There.

So, even if the harms are contentious, they are there. As such, I think a strong case needs to be made in defence of meat-eating to justify it.

If the farming is done properly the animal isn't harmed. In fact it lives better in captivity than in the wild.

Make a positive case for meat eating, without recouse to fallacies. Please.

No. I'm not making a claim that one is better or more moral than the other. You are. It's your claim and your burden.

The case made in favour of it so far is just puerile and silly - "It tastes good", "I'm lazy", "Everyone else does it". Unsophisitcated, ill-considered blabber.

You've forgotten mine: There is no reason not to.
 
Is there anyone here making the claim that eating meat is right?

I personally don't hold that position. I just feel that eating meat is not wrong.
 
Acting in one's own self interest or in pursuit of happiness is essentially in my opinion a moral act. So the taste of meat for those who like it, and the pleasure derived (and nutritional value) from it does have a moral aspect to it.


So haven't you just conceded, volatile, that the self-interest in choosing to eat something that tastes good is essentially a moral act, yet...

The balance is "Meat tastes good" vs animal harm and environmental impact.

Does the whim of taste supersede the demonstrable negatives?

...you are still belittling the morality of that act as 'whim', in order to make it look like all the valid arguments are on one side. They're not, if the morality of choosing to eat something tasty is valid. It's a matter for each of us to draw the line where we see fit.

To what extent does self-interest over-ride negative considerations?
Again, we each have to judge the relative values to us of the positives versus the negatives. That many chose to draw that line in a different place to you does not make them wrong.

Throwing empty coke cans in the street is quite fun, and it's more convenient than carrying them until I get to the nearest bin -- but my personal whim is outweighed by the social contract and the demonstrable negative consequences of my actions.

I don't throw the can in the street because I don't like what litter does to the neighbourhood. I don't think it would be fun although sometimes it's a slight inconvenience to carry it as far as the bin. Maybe some sociologist or psychologist would put it in terms of 'social contracts' and whatnots but as far as I'm concerned I don't throw the can because I don't want to! That is in my self interest.

Is taste sufficient, in your view, to mitigate the moral inconsistency and the environmental harm?

I don't actually see a moral inconsistency, and and on the environment issue, as I posted earlier in the thread, I love the idea of growing protein (in the form of the fungus Quorn is made of) on our waste veg, which would be a phenomenally efficient use of land for food and would alleviate the methane-from-cows issue (for those to whom it is an issue).

BTW I don't eat meat.

BDd
 
You're telling me, tacitly, that my conclusions are in error, and therefore I should be eating meat.

No, he's not.

I'm not dogmatic. In fact, quite the opposite.

Since you seem completely unable to support your position and yet maintain it, I submit that you should rethink that one.

- Environmental Impact

Yes, pretty much any and all means we use to feed 6.5 billion people will have those.

- Ill-fit with a broader ethical stance on animal welfare

How so ? If the animals are well-treated, then where's the problem ? And if they aren't, the problem doesn't lie in the diet but in the treatment of the animals by the farmers.
 
Actually, there are all sorts of harmful activities that we humans regularly engage in. Harmful to ourselves as individuals and harmful to society. Drinking and smoking are clear examples. Driving cars contributes to global warming.
And when you ask people whether they can justify driving, they will generally give at least semi-plausible justifications in terms of significant interests: without a sophisticated transportation infrastructure, we would worse off in non-trivial ways.

Setting aside the direct harm visited upon animals, animal agriculture is a greater contributor to global warming than automobiles, according to the 2006 FAO report.

And how do people justify continuing to eat meat, in the quantities they do, in light of this? "It tastes good."

In no other realm of human endeavor is harm of this magnitude justified by otherwise reasonable people with a shrug and a "**** happens." Even in relatively enlightened countries, we see periodic atrocities emerging from commercial meat production. Two pigs were boiled alive recently in the UK, two more in Sweden, two more the year before that. That doesn't have to happen very often before I wash my hands of the whole affair.

But the see-no-evil crowd will just say "I see no credible argument blah blah blah." To echo what Kevin, Cain and volatile have been saying, my problem with the meat-eaters in this thread isn't that they have a bad argument. It's that they don't have an argument at all. What they have, instead, is a haphazard strategy. It's like watching a Christian archaeologist look for Noah's ark. "It's gotta be around here somewhere, I guess I'll just start digging."
 
Are you against harming animals unnecessarily?
Would you eat a kitten?

Are those two things supposed to have anything to do with one another ?

ETA: And if you think I'll spend the rest of my life eating stuff I don't like because some people like animals too much, you're horribly wrong.
 
Last edited:
That an animal dies for my benifit is not in and of itself immoral. There is a trade off. An animal that dies for my benifit, as Dennet notes, recieves significant benifits including a statistical gurantee that it will survive it's birth, recieve health care, be largely free from the elements and not worry day to day about predation.

Not to mention that many of them get to do what they are design to do: reproduce.
 
Ken - you're a skeptic, right? You consider your actions rationally and reasonably?

When you sit down to dinner tonight, consider why you're eating that steak. It's a doctrinal product of your upbringing, and you admit as much yourself. I know you don't consider that sufficient reason to engage in any other behaviour, and in all other aspects of your life you make positive judgements for your actions.

You're like a theistic scientist. You've compartmentalised your brain. You've taken a huge pat of your life out of rational consideration.

It's funny that you bring up skepticism. It's because of skepticism that I gave up my crazy vegan militant ways. I tried really hard to justify meat eating as wrong and I couldn't find a good reason. Now I don't see meat eating as something that's morally wrong but just as something I don't like.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom