Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

If it's right - explain why it is.


It is right for exactly the same reasons it is "right" for you to be here on the forum and not currently giving blood. Can you make a positive case for spending time on a forum over helping the sick?
 
A Kitten isn't really my cup of tea as I am sure eating the heart wood of an oak probably isn't yours. Just because we eat meat doesn't mean we want to eat every possible animal on the planet.

Of course not. But what our reactions to that question demonstrate is that diet is an action with moral considerations. The fact that this question is somewhat problematic gives lie to those who want to claim that diet is exempt from moral reasoning.

I appreciate your honesty, by the way.
 
Tastes good and is legal...
So? Why are these necessary components of a positive case?

Acting in one's own self interest or in pursuit of happiness is essentially in my opinion a moral act. So the taste of meat for those who like it, and the pleasure derived (and nutritional value) from it does have a moral aspect to it.
 
It is right for exactly the same reasons it is "right" for you to be here on the forum and not currently giving blood. Can you make a positive case for spending time on a forum over helping the sick?

I'd give blood but they don't want it.

That's also a tu quoque fallacy, as well as fallacious in other ways. When you go to buy your pork chops, you are making a positive decision to engage in an activity which is morally indefensible. That's a different issue from not making a decision to engage in a morally commendable way (and there's a whole host of interesting ethics books on the distinction).

Every time you go food shopping, you have a choice to make, and you deliberately make the bad one.
 
The animal, as Cain points out, would not otherwise exist at all - so this is a bad argument.
Why is that a bad argument? You and cain state that as if it is axiomatic. I don't see it that way at all. If I created something from raw materials and some day destroyed it what would the fact that it wouldn't have existed had I not created it have to do with anything?

What you're doing is inflicting suffering...
It's possible to kill an animal with little or no suffering.

...and causing considerable, unnecessary environmental harm and breaking with your general position on animal welfare (remember the Heiress Dilemma?) for the sake of taste.
I think the environmental harm is a valid point but one that can be mitigated. It's not simply taste, it's a nutritiously dense form of protein. That I can have a contract with an animal to provide it with welfare for x number of years and then kill it and eat it for my benefit doesn't strike me as immoral. If animal husbandry ended tomorrow and all domestic animals vanished then the virtually the only animals alive would be those that fought for survival in the wild. I'm happy with the trade off but I won't dismiss the environmental concerns.
 
I gave them to you about 5 posts ago.

Really? If that's all you have, I'm not convinced. I also don't consider your arguments rational.

It's not just methane. But if we could grow meat in a lab - then sure, eat away.
It's not just the methane. What other environmental impacts are you talking about then?

Do you eat meat grown in a lab? Or do you eat the water-polluting, ozone-destroying stuff?
If we had the tech to make these cows environmentally safer, would you give meat the thumbs up?

Would you eat a kitten? Buy one over the counter and eat tasty kitten meat with chips?
If it tasted good, yes.

It's also necessary to harm a cat to thrill those enjoy torturing them. We need to consider the necessity of the final act.
Why?

Eating meat is not necessary. That's important. And why you need to make a positive case for it.

Which you still haven't done.
Playing chess is not necessary. That's important, and why you need to make a positive case for it.

I will not make a positive case for eating meat. It's legal and you've yet to show me it's wrong. I have no need to make a positive case for eating meat. No one will arrest me for doing so. I have no reason to stop eating meat. You are the one that has to change my mind about eating meat.
 
Last edited:
Acting in one's own self interest or in pursuit of happiness is essentially in my opinion a moral act. So the taste of meat for those who like it, and the pleasure derived (and nutritional value) from it does have a moral aspect to it.

True. To what extent does self-interest over-ride negative considerations? Throwing empty coke cans in the street is quite fun, and it's more convenient than carrying them until I get to the nearest bin -- but my personal whim is outweighed by the social contract and the demonstrable negative consequences of my actions.

Is taste sufficient, in your view, to mitigate the moral inconsistency and the environmental harm?
 
Really? If that's all you have, I'm not convinced. I also don't consider your arguments rational.

Eh?

They're based in logical response to a broad scientific consensus, and logically consistent with the rest of my opinions. What on earth is "irrational" about that?

On the other hand, you're content to ignore all that because the status quo agrees with you.

Seriously? C'mon, Ken. You're better than that.

It's not just the methane. What other environmental impacts are you talkng about then?

Did you read the articles? There's soil erosion, water pollution, impacts from transportation, deforestation etc. etc. etc.


If we had the tech to make these cows environmentally safer, would you give meat the thumbs up?

It's not possible to make them as environmentally light-footed as a plant based diet, because it's NOT JUST ABOUT THE COWS. It's about the entire system of animal husbandry.

But lab meat is OK.

How is this hypothetical future in any way relevant to what you or I are going to have for dinner tonight anyway?

This is prevarication.

On kittens - how do you know they don't taste good? Why haven't you eaten one already?

Playing chess is not necessary. That's important, and why you need to make a positive case for it.

It's not necessary, but it has positive consequences and, importantly, no negatives. Thus, on balance, chess is fine.

The same cannot be said for meat eating. Can it? The balance is "Meat tastes good" vs animal harm and environmental impact.

Does the whim of taste supersede the demonstrable negatives?
 
I understand that morality is subjective, and I'd accept that you see meat-eating as "right" if a meat-eater could make a defensible case as to why this is so.

And I don't feel a need to make a defensible cast that it's "right" until someone gives me compelling arguments that it's "wrong". Taste, convenience, and maintaining a diverse diet are sufficient in the absense of counterbalancing considerations. The only argument against eating meat that's at all compelling to me is the environmental one. And I see that more as an issue of pragmatism than morality. Rather than say "let's not eat meat", I'd rather pursue "let's find a way to reduce/reverse the enviromental impacts".


In other arguments - abortion, say - no matter what side of the argument you're on, "I'm right and I know it" is not sufficient. In any other area of debate, all of you - especially people like you Zircon, and RandFan, who are quick-minded and always able to spot bad arguments made in defence of other positions - would be all over that kind of response. That you're making the same types of arguments you'd criticise elsewhere only proves how weak the case in favour of meat-eating is.

"I'm right and I know it" is sufficient if you're not trying to convince me to agree with you, or attempting to legislate your view into law.

I don't need to convince you to eat meat. I'm perfectly happy for you to be a vegan. In fact, an ideal situation for me would be for most of the world to be vegetarian or vegan, with only enough meat-eaters around to ensure that I had a readily-available source of meat for me and mine.


If it's right - explain why it is.

Because it hasn't been shown to be wrong.
 
Did you read the articles? There's soil erosion, water pollution, impacts from transportation, deforestation etc. etc. etc.

It's not possible to make them as environmentally light-footed as a plant based diet, because it's NOT JUST ABOUT THE COWS. It's about the entire system of animal husbandry.
I think you are being a bit heavy handed on the environmental aspect. BTW: Have you seen George Carlin's take on this?

 
They're based in logical response to a broad scientific consensus, and logically consistent with the rest of my opinions. What on earth is "irrational" about that?

There is a scientific consensus that eating meat is wrong?

Did you read the articles? There's soil erosion, water pollution, impacts from transportation, deforestation etc. etc. etc.

These seem to be reasons to eat less meat, or reduce meat consumption. I thought you were trying to convince me to abstain from eating meat based on some moral implication.

It's not possible to make them as environmentally light-footed as a plant based diet, because it's NOT JUST ABOUT THE COWS. It's about the entire system of animal husbandry.

So you're complaint is about the process, not about the actual killing of cows for food?

How is this hypothetical future in any way relevant to what you or I are going to have for dinner tonight anyway?

How is your argument relevant for what I'm going to eat tonight?

On kittens - how do you know they don't taste good? Why haven't you eaten one already?

I don't know they don't taste good or not. I have yet to find cat meat at the market.

It's not necessary, but it has positive consequences and, importantly, no negatives. Thus, on balance, chess is fine.

Eating meat has some positives. Yes, there are negatives to eating too much of it as well. However, on balance, it's fine with a good wine.

Does the whim of taste supersede the demonstrable negatives?

Your demonstrable negatives are flimsy. At best, you've convinced me that modern societies eat too much meat.
 
I'd give blood but they don't want it.

That's also a tu quoque fallacy, as well as fallacious in other ways. When you go to buy your pork chops, you are making a positive decision to engage in an activity which is morally indefensible. That's a different issue from not making a decision to engage in a morally commendable way (and there's a whole host of interesting ethics books on the distinction).

Every time you go food shopping, you have a choice to make, and you deliberately make the bad one.


Anytime you do anything at all you make a choice not to do something that could be considered morally commendable.

I eat meant and I prefer watching a movie over applying ointment to the sore feet of street urchins. Trying to make a positive case for either is impossible because it's clear (to me anyway) that I am making a conscious decision to adjust my morality to better fit my own comfort. I could adjust my lifestyle to fit a vegan diet, I could also spend all of my time helping people. I choose not to do either for the same reason.
 
And I don't feel a need to make a defensible cast that it's "right" until someone gives me compelling arguments that it's "wrong". Taste, convenience, and maintaining a diverse diet are sufficient in the absense of counterbalancing considerations. The only argument against eating meat that's at all compelling to me is the environmental one. And I see that more as an issue of pragmatism than morality. Rather than say "let's not eat meat", I'd rather pursue "let's find a way to reduce/reverse the enviromental impacts".

And until then, taste trumps all?

I don't understand why you're willing to engage in an action that causes definitive and demonstrable harm and is, I would suggest, incompatible with your general position on animal welfare (is killing an animal for fun OK in your book? - I hastily presume not), for such weak reasons.

Because it hasn't been shown to be wrong.

The way I see it is that in industrialised nations it is easy to be vegan. As such, we can construct our dietary from a neutral middle-ground, considering the pros and cons of each choice. All you're doing is arbitrarily starting from one side because of history and tradition - reasons, I would suggest, that you would reject any arguments in favour of other demonstrably harmful activities.

Which is why I keep coming back to the positive case for meat eating. Taste isn't enough - what makes ME happy is not sufficient in any other part of the way I live my life, and, unless you're of a particularly Libertarian bent, I suspect the same is true of you. We all have pragmatically weigh up our personal whims and desires with their effects on others and on the world. That's the basis of a good life. We do not, I submit, let our personal whims (especially whims on such flimsy grounds as taste - is meat really so tasty that all other considerations some secondary to how good it is to eat?) override our behaviours in other areas of life.

So why in diet are so many people content to have this blind spot? The reason becomes clear when you start scratching the surface - tradition and habit. As a sceptic, these are not sufficient.
 
What a VERY strange argument. We have people who are trying to claim nthat eating meat is immoral, and others who are saying it is not necessarily so.

I indeed eat meat. I enjoy eating meat. It is an excellent, and efficient source of the protein that I need in my diet. I also eat a number of fruits and vegetables. I don't claim to be morally superior to those who don't eat meat, just as I do not expect vegans to act morally superior towards me.

No. On the eating of kittens, gorillas, and babies. Broadly speaking, human beings do not eat creatures we have become emotionally attached to. Kittens (And cats) at least in western culture are considered companions and pets. Gorillas, not only are they endangered, and thus a poor source of food, are very similar to ourselves, making us seem like we're indulging in pseudo-cannibalism. And babies.. Ok. That is just a STUPID argument to make: "If you eat cows, why don't you eat babies?" Just.. Stupid.

Now. Let us consider. Tomorrow, eating meat becomes illegal, and everyone must instantly become vegans. No meat, no cheese, no eggs, noting that comes from an animal.

What animals would effective become extinct?
How do we provide for the vitamins and protein we need in our diet? Pasture land we use to raise animals for food is not always good for the raising of crops. And not all land is useful for all sorts of crops.
So the vegans on here surely must know.. What we would need to do to stop eating meat? How much more farmland would we need to provide all the protein that humanity requires?

Unless it can be shown to be done easily, and without harm to the environment, I will not become a vegan. I will drink milk, eat eggs, and eat meat as it is efficient for my dietary needs.
 
There is a scientific consensus that eating meat is wrong?

A consensus that it is worse for the environment that a vegan diet.

These seem to be reasons to eat less meat, or reduce meat consumption. I thought you were trying to convince me to abstain from eating meat based on some moral implication.

The end point of "less" is "none", clearly.

So you're complaint is about the process, not about the actual killing of cows for food?

The killing of cows for food in the presence of nutritionally-complete alternatives. Killing cows for food is not axiomatically wrong - as I have already explained. Killing anything for food is not axiomatically wrong, if the alternative is starvation. But he process is the problem precisely because we have alternatives which are less damaging, and pretty-much no-one in the West has to make the choice between killing an animal for food, and dying of starvation.

The supermarkets sell all you need to be an nutritionally-complete vegan.

How is your argument relevant for what I'm going to eat tonight?

When you go to buy dinner, you have an irrational choice based on habit and tradition and personal whim, or you have a rational choice based on logical pragmatism and internal consistency. It's up to you which one you pick.

Your demonstrable negatives are flimsy. At best, you've convinced me that modern societies eat too much meat.

Yes, they do. And why do they eat too much meat? Because meat is more damaging than plants. Ergo - no meat is better than some meat. This is all about consistency.

Still. Will you then endeavour to eat less meat? I can send you some recipes. One meat free day a week?
 
"If you eat cows, why don't you eat babies?" Just.. Stupid.

That is a stupid argument, so it's good no-one made it. I suggest perhaps you read those posts again. Cain and I bring up babies precisely to counter arguments like "It's a good source of protein", to prove that there are necessarily OTHER considerations at play and that the offering of such in defence of one's position belies either mendacity or, more often, an ill-conceived argument.

The argument is not "If you eat cows, why don't you eat babies?", but "If "sufficient protein" is the reason you eat cows, why don't you eat babies/". It's about probing the shallowness of though that seems so often to so into defences of meat-eating.

To whit:

Now. Let us consider. Tomorrow, eating meat becomes illegal, and everyone must instantly become vegans. No meat, no cheese, no eggs, noting that comes from an animal.

What animals would effective become extinct?

None. Our staple food animals - pigs, cows, chickens, sheep - are all kept as pets and companion animals. I have no issue with eating home-reared eggs, or from shearing free-roaming sheep for wool, so they'd be fine too.


How do we provide for the vitamins and protein we need in our diet?

We could start by feeding all the soy we currently feed to beef cattle to humans. That'd be an excellent start.

Pasture land we use to raise animals for food is not always good for the raising of crops. And not all land is useful for all sorts of crops.

True - but the yield per acre is much better with plants (remember at the moment, we grow plants, feed them to animals, then eat the animals), so your mental calculations are way off.


[quote[So the vegans on here surely must know.. What we would need to do to stop eating meat? How much more farmland would we need to provide all the protein that humanity requires?[/quote]

Less than is currently used to farm beef.

Unless it can be shown to be done easily, and without harm to the environment, I will not become a vegan.

Even though it is scientifically-demonstrable that a meat-eating diet is WORSE for the environment than a vegan one? That's hubris, arrogance and ignorance all in one sentence.

I will drink milk, eat eggs, and eat meat as it is efficient for my dietary needs.

Why not eat grains, leaves, pulses and legumes sufficient to your dietary needs instead?
 
Negative consequences for playing chess:

Unnecessary forestry for wooden components

Unnecessary petro-chemical usage

Negative environmental consequences with the use of plastics, veneer glue, lacquers ect.

Possible child labour issues

Wasteful time management

Unnecessary stress for weaker opponents

Potential choking hazards

I could do this all day
 
Negative consequences for playing chess:

Unnecessary forestry for wooden components

Unnecessary petro-chemical usage

Negative environmental consequences with the use of plastics, veneer glue, lacquers ect.

Possible child labour issues

Wasteful time management

Unnecessary stress for weaker opponents

Potential choking hazards

I could do this all day

Great argument! I'm giving up chess.

Will you do the same with meat?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom