"If you eat cows, why don't you eat babies?" Just.. Stupid.
That is a stupid argument, so it's good no-one made it. I suggest perhaps you read those posts again. Cain and I bring up babies precisely to counter arguments like "It's a good source of protein", to prove that there are necessarily OTHER considerations at play and that the offering of such in defence of one's position belies either mendacity or, more often, an ill-conceived argument.
The argument is not "If you eat cows, why don't you eat babies?", but "If "sufficient protein" is the reason you eat cows, why don't you eat babies/". It's about probing the shallowness of though that seems so often to so into defences of meat-eating.
To whit:
Now. Let us consider. Tomorrow, eating meat becomes illegal, and everyone must instantly become vegans. No meat, no cheese, no eggs, noting that comes from an animal.
What animals would effective become extinct?
None. Our staple food animals - pigs, cows, chickens, sheep - are all kept as pets and companion animals. I have no issue with eating home-reared eggs, or from shearing free-roaming sheep for wool, so they'd be fine too.
How do we provide for the vitamins and protein we need in our diet?
We could start by feeding all the soy we currently feed to beef cattle to humans. That'd be an excellent start.
Pasture land we use to raise animals for food is not always good for the raising of crops. And not all land is useful for all sorts of crops.
True - but the yield per acre is much better with plants (remember at the moment, we grow plants, feed them to animals, then eat the animals), so your mental calculations are way off.
[quote[So the vegans on here surely must know.. What we would need to do to stop eating meat? How much more farmland would we need to provide all the protein that humanity requires?[/quote]
Less than is currently used to farm beef.
Unless it can be shown to be done easily, and without harm to the environment, I will not become a vegan.
Even though it is scientifically-demonstrable that a meat-eating diet is WORSE for the environment than a vegan one? That's hubris, arrogance and ignorance all in one sentence.
I will drink milk, eat eggs, and eat meat as it is efficient for my dietary needs.
Why not eat grains, leaves, pulses and legumes sufficient to your dietary needs instead?