Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

As if ANYONE is telling you that YOU should be eating meat.

You're telling me, tacitly, that my conclusions are in error, and therefore I should be eating meat. That's exactly what you're doing.

You're just not doing a very good job of it. In fact, you're reinforcing the decision I came to 4 years ago, when I realised there were no good reasons to eat meat.

No one here is judging you for your dietary choices.
See page 1 of this thread.

It's the whole "my morality is the one true morality" stance that turns your argument from one of rationality to one of dogmatism.
I'm not dogmatic. In fact, quite the opposite. I'd love to hear a reasoned defence of the opposite position. And, as I've said, my case is not dogmatic - eating meat in and of itself is not wrong. It's only eating meat when other non-animal sources are readily available that;s the problem. This is a case built on reason and rationality, not dogmatism and steadfastness.

Unlike the "I'm eating meat because I LIKE IT" crowd. See Ken's last post - "I'm doing until someone convinces me not to" - which is the hallmark of a dogmatic position. No supporting rationale, no rhyme, no reason, no sense and no sensibility. Just "It's what I DO".

Pot, meet kettle.
 
Here again you're running away from the argument. What reason(s) do you have for including some and excluding others?
The ball is in your court, what reason do I have to exclude children or chimps? Again, look in the mirror.

I wrote: Sure. But it points to your preternatural willingness to make up things as you go along; to ********.
And I wrote that it is without foundation. Hey, I know, let's go around in circles.

This is another of your brilliant non-commitments. I love this ****. Whenever you get pinned down, you resort back to this "rhetoric"
That you assert that I was "pinned down" doesn't make it true. Here you go again, the above is only rhetoric. Hint: It's NOT an argument.

"assertion" nonsense thinking (perhaps) it somehow says something. You were caught slinging ********, which could be smelt from a mile away. It's not "assertion... without foundation." It's documented above, and your unwillingness to back it up leaves no room for doubt.
Just because you assert something doesn't make it true. I don't know how long it is going to take before you learn that.

1 How can "perceiving what's intrinsically important to the human condition" serve as a useful guide for morality? 2 What are its specific applications? 3 Why didn't you mention it in the first place? How can you use it to 4[/su]include chimps and children and 5[/su]exclude cows?
  1. Golden rule.
  2. see #1.
  3. Fallacy (the timing of when I mention something does not alter the truth value of the argument) however I wasn't interested in making that argument at the beginning of this thread. I've made that argument with you before.
  4. I don't use it to include chimps.
  5. Cows have never been demonstrated to be particularly interested in liberty and the pursuit of happiness.
Life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. Those are the intrinsic values of humans that other animals don't (by and large) share. Humans want to be free and pursue productive and happy lives as expressed by John Locke, George Mason and Thomas Jefferson. However, to the extent that primates and other animals do have these values then I would happily consider them.
Yes, cows. These are specific questions that you refuse to answer
Oh nonsense. I'm perfectly happy to answer questions. You need to learn the difference between asking questions and making assertions.
 
Last edited:
Of course. All moral arguments have that quality, though. Most of this forum - all of this fourm, really - features arguments of this sort. I think I'm right. In the spirit of discussion, however, I'm willing to be convinced I'm wrong - if only someone would step up to the plate with anything other than "just 'cause" as an argument in favour of the alternative.
Why should anyone else care if you choose not to eat meat? I don't think eating vegan is wrong any more than I think open marriages are wrong. I am not inclined to convince vegans they should eat meat any more than I am inclined to convince swingers they should be monogamous. I just don't find those lifestyle choices desirable for myself.
On the first part of your argument, when you say "Actually, there are all sorts of harmful activities that we humans regularly engage in. Harmful to ourselves as individuals and harmful to society", you are correct. And moral arguments can be presented for and against most of them. Why is diet the only one which has no-one willing to make a decent argument in favour of it?
If you don't find the taste, nutrition and convenience sufficient justification to include meat in your diet, that's fine. Those are personal and subjective valuations.
 
They believe it's wrong, it makes them feel good and everyone else they know hates homosexuals too. That's the argument, right?

Yet they cannot demonstrate it's wrong.

Why is eating meat right? You still haven't told me.

Eating meat isn't right. It's a free choice. Feel free to tell me why it's wrong.
 
Yet they cannot demonstrate it's wrong.

Yes. They have no good arguments in favour of their position.

Like you.

Eating meat isn't right. It's a free choice. Feel free to tell me why it's wrong.


- Environmental Impact
- Ill-fit with a broader ethical stance on animal welfare

And:

- As there are demonstrable harms, no sufficiently good reason to indulge depsite these harms.

In short - it is unnecessary.

It is, of course, a free choice. But it's a free choice with morally-interesting consequences. As such, you need do demonstrate why it is right.

Go ahead.
 
Last edited:
I eat meat knowing it's irrational. I also don't invite the homeless to live with me or give away all of all the income I don't need to survive. There is nothing rational about spending money on televisions or music when that money could easily be spent saving lives around the world. But we do own televisions and we do buy music and a whole host of other goodies while we let people suffer. It's by no means right but it's also not wrong.

Eating meat is a luxury that most people enjoy despite the fact it causes suffering. Much the same way that discussions on forums are a luxury that people enjoy despite the fact that they could be bathing the homeless, giving blood, spending time with lonely elderly people or doing an infinite number of other things that are "morally right."
 
Yes. They have no good arguments in favour of their position.

Like you.

So, you believe that a person should be able to have the freedom to do whatever they want, until it can be shown to be wrong?

- Environmental Impact
- Ill-fit with a broader ethical stance on animal welfare

And:

- As there are demonstrable harms, no sufficiently good reason to indulge depsite these harms.

In short - it is unnecessary.

It's not necessary for people to play chess either.

What is the environment impact of eating meat?
Why is eating meat "ill fit" with a broader ethical stance on animal welfare?
 
You're telling me, tacitly, that my conclusions are in error, and therefore I should be eating meat. That's exactly what you're doing.


Couldn't be further from the truth. I'm saying you're making a personal choice. It's the same with our position on guns. We don't share the opinion on the right own them, but I certainly am not saying "you should have a gun."


You're just not doing a very good job of it. In fact, you're reinforcing the decision I came to 4 years ago, when I realised there were no good reasons to eat meat.


Again, I couldn't have any less of a problem with the decision you came to.


See page 1 of this thread.


You'll have to do better than that. There are 39 posts on page one, and I don't see any that say "if you don't eat meat you're a dummy."


I'm not dogmatic. In fact, quite the opposite. I'd love to hear a reasoned defence of the opposite position. And, as I've said, my case is not dogmatic - eating meat in and of itself is not wrong. It's only eating meat when other non-animal sources are readily available that;s the problem. This is a case built on reason and rationality, not dogmatism and steadfastness.

Unlike the "I'm eating meat because I LIKE IT" crowd. See Ken's last post - "I'm doing until someone convinces me not to" - which is the hallmark of a dogmatic position. No supporting rationale, no rhyme, no reason, no sense and no sensibility. Just "It's what I DO".


The fact you're demanding a "reasoned defense of the opposite position" is what makes your stance dogmatic. Your sensibilities are your own. Suggesting others are immoral or irrational for no other reason than it doesn't vibe with yours is dogmatic.


Pot, meet kettle.


Man I miss the days when smoked, and my cute response to that was "Mmmmmm, pot." :(
 
They are informed by bioethcis, moral philosophy, and a range of scientific discourse. The same, sadly, cannot be said of any of the arguments put forth against him.
And your views can't possibly be colored by confirmation bias.
 
Ken - you're a skeptic, right? You consider your actions rationally and reasonably?

When you sit down to dinner tonight, consider why you're eating that steak. It's a doctrinal product of your upbringing, and you admit as much yourself. I know you don't consider that sufficient reason to engage in any other behaviour, and in all other aspects of your life you make positive judgements for your actions.

You're like a theistic scientist. You've compartmentalised your brain. You've taken a huge pat of your life out of rational consideration.
 
It's not necessary for people to play chess either.

What are the negative consequences of chess?

What is the environment impact of eating meat?
http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2008/sep/07/food.foodanddrink
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/01/27/weekinreview/27bittman.html

That you've never considered this is proof of what I was talking about

Why is eating meat "ill fit" with a broader ethical stance on animal welfare?
Are you against harming animals unnecessarily?
Would you eat a kitten?

That's what I mean.

Given these negatives, how does "I like it" compare as a balancing argument the other way, especially given that the change to veganism is easy and more-or-less consequence-free when it comes to your quality of life?
 
Last edited:
And your views can't possibly be colored by confirmation bias.

Well, show me I'm wrong, RF. You can see for yourself over the last 2 or 3 pages that all we've had in favour of meat-eating are really, really poor and unsophisticated arguments. "I like it", "I'm lazy", "I don't care", "Everyone else does it".

Compare Cain's arguments, which, though abrasive, are considered, coherent and informed.
 
You're telling me, tacitly, that my conclusions are in error, and therefore I should be eating meat.

No, because the meat-eaters in this thread understand that there is no One True MoralityTM. So, even though eating meat is "right" for us, we understand that it may not be "right" for you. I draw my lines in different places than you do. I see no reason to try to get you to draw your lines elsewhere.
 
When you sit down to dinner tonight, consider why you're eating that steak.

Because it tastes good, it's legal, and no one has yet to give me a reasonable argument as to why it is wrong.

You're like a theistic scientist. You've compartmentalised your brain. You've taken a huge pat of your life out of rational consideration.
Insult noted. Now about your rational arguments against eating meat. Have any?

What are the negative consequences of chess?

EXACTLY my point!

That you've never considered this is proof of what I was talking about
If we developed the technology to reduce methane emissions of the meat we're eating, would you give meat eating your thumbs up?

Are you against harming animals unnecessarily?
Yes. It is necessary to "harm" a cow to put it on my plate for dinner, though.

Would you eat a kitten?
If it were legal, yes. In fact, I probably already have being that I've been to poorer nations and eaten mystery meats there.
 
You're like a theistic scientist. You've compartmentalised your brain. You've taken a huge pat of your life out of rational consideration.
I've rationaly consdidered eating meat just as I've rationaly considered dualism, ID, gay rights, leagalizing drugs, leagalizing prostitution etc.. All of these I've changed my mind about, except whether or not eating meat is moral. I've no problem with it per se.

That an animal dies for my benifit is not in and of itself immoral. There is a trade off. An animal that dies for my benifit, as Dennet notes, recieves significant benifits including a statistical gurantee that it will survive it's birth, recieve health care, be largely free from the elements and not worry day to day about predation.
 
No, because the meat-eaters in this thread understand that there is no One True MoralityTM. So, even though eating meat is "right" for us, we understand that it may not be "right" for you. I draw my lines in different places than you do. I see no reason to try to get you to draw your lines elsewhere.

I understand that morality is subjective, and I'd accept that you see meat-eating as "right" if a meat-eater could make a defensible case as to why this is so.

In other arguments - abortion, say - no matter what side of the argument you're on, "I'm right and I know it" is not sufficient. In any other area of debate, all of you - especially people like you Zircon, and RandFan, who are quick-minded and always able to spot bad arguments made in defence of other positions - would be all over that kind of response. That you're making the same types of arguments you'd criticise elsewhere only proves how weak the case in favour of meat-eating is.

If it's right - explain why it is.
 
Well, show me I'm wrong, RF. You can see for yourself over the last 2 or 3 pages that all we've had in favour of meat-eating are really, really poor and unsophisticated arguments. "I like it", "I'm lazy", "I don't care", "Everyone else does it".
I've not made those arguments.

Compare Cain's arguments, which, though abrasive, are considered, coherent and informed.
Abrasive is an understatement. He does not argue in good faith and has not rebutted my arguments. Instead he attacks me personally and makes bald assumptions and relies on brow beating.

Cain has one argument and all counter arguments are wrong by default. If anyone dare make them they will be ridiculed and belittled for daring to make them against the all mighty Cain.

Kevin is, at least he was in the past, willing to engage in an actual debate. Lately he's taken to Cain's tactics though.
 
Last edited:
I've rationaly consdidered eating meat just as I've rationaly considered dualism, ID, gay rights, leagalizing drugs, leagalizing prostitution etc.. All of these I've changed my mind about, except whether or not eating meat is moral. I've no problem with it per se.

That an animal dies for my benifit is not in and of itself immoral. There is a trade off.

I agree. That's why I'm not against vivisection or subsistence farming.

[quote[An animal that dies for my benifit, as Dennet notes, recieves significant benifits including a statistical gurantee that it will survive it's birth, recieve health care, be largely free from the elements and not worry day to day about predation.[/quote]

The animal, as Cain points out, would not otherwise exist at all - so this is a bad argument.

What you're doing is inflicting suffering and causing considerable, unnecessary environmental harm and breaking with your general position on animal welfare (remember the Heiress Dilemma?) for the sake of taste.

Is steak really that tasty?
 
Insult noted. Now about your rational arguments against eating meat. Have any?

I gave them to you about 5 posts ago.


If we developed the technology to reduce methane emissions of the meat we're eating, would you give meat eating your thumbs up?
It's not just methane. But if we could grow meat in a lab - then sure, eat away.

Do you eat meat grown in a lab? Or do you eat the water-polluting, ozone-destroying stuff?

Would you eat a kitten? Buy one over the counter and eat tasty kitten meat with chips?

Yes. It is necessary to "harm" a cow to put it on my plate for dinner, though.
It's also necessary to harm a cat to thrill those enjoy torturing them. We need to consider the necessity of the final act.

Eating meat is not necessary. That's important. And why you need to make a positive case for it.

Which you still haven't done.
 
=Would you eat a kitten?

A Kitten isn't really my cup of tea as I am sure eating the heart wood of an oak probably isn't yours. Just because we eat meat doesn't mean we want to eat every possible animal on the planet. That being said I would eat the same species of cat (fully grown) that I have as a pet. I wouldn't eat my own cat because I have an emotional attachment to him but do suspect he would taste a little like rabbit which I enjoy.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom