Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

Why not? I dare you to answer that without recourse to a fallacious argument.

Because, you want me to change my behavior. At least, I assume you do. If you consider it immoral for animals to be raised and slaughtered for food, I assume you want that to stop happening. If you want to change my opinion on the matter, you are going to have to convince me. I, on the other hand, have no need to convince you. I couldn't care less whether you eat meat or not, and, at the moment, you are not anywhere close to being in a position to compel me to change my eating habits against my will.

Said another way, I've drawn my arbitrary line about what is acceptable to kill and/or eat in a different place than you have. I don't feel a need to justify my line-drawing to you, in much the same way that I don't need to defend using shampoo or wearing cotton clothes. I don't see anything immoral about those behaviors, either, but I'm not going to expend a whole lot of effort in coming up with a moral argument about why it's OK for me to do them. If someone wants me to stop doing those things, or reconsider the morality of doing them, the onus is on them to make a compelling argument.

The status quo is not always "right". But, in order to overturn it, a lot of people need to be convinced that it's "wrong". Just because the majority considers meat-eating morally right doesn't automatically make it so. Nor does the fact that meat-eating is "natural" and has been an accepted throughout history. But, it does mean that those who want to change our collective morality have the uphill climb.
 
You're not answering my question. What's so hot about a nervous system that means we can't kill those who have it ?

Not can't. Shouldn't.

It's the basic capacity for consciousness, and it divides animals from plants. Where's your line?

Also, what distinguishes vegetables from animals is at the cellular level. Nothing precludes a plant from having the equivalent of a brain.

Plants don't have nervous systems, or brains, Belz. I'm not sure where you're going with that.


What if I mean to eat the spider, instead ?

Go ahead, eat it. If it's threatening your life, then feel free to eat the kill. I take it, however, that these are not the considerations that lead you to your meat-eating diet, so why are you mentioning them?

Allow me to clarify. Why should WE allow animals to eat one another ?

Huh? What re you talking about?

I have. I like to eat meat. Animals are farmed for food. We kill them for food. I eat them. As Randfan points out, animals live much better lives under our protection. Dying later and painlessly is a small price to pay. If the animal is killed properly there is no difference between killing an animal for food and killing a carrot for food.

"I like it" is a terrible, terrible argument.

Do you support animal cruelty legislation, Belz? Agree that harming animals unnecessarily is unjustifiable? If so, your argument, as Cain has discussed up-thread becomes one about just what "necessary" means - and it seems that you consider your personal satisfaction a criteria for establishing the degree of necessity.

"I'm happy" justifies "the price", right?
 
Really, Volatile, the reason why I shouldn't have to justify myself is simply this:

We know we have to eat. So if it's a moral question we're going to have to create two sets, namely the stuff we can eat and the stuff we can't eat. In order to create those two sets we're going to have to define them.

So, what, exactly, are the criteria defining what we can eat and what we can't ?

I don't think there is such a set of criteria.
 
Because it's legal to eat meat and it's the status quo.

Argumentum ad populum - "I eat meat because everyone else does".

Not a good argument, Ken.

I will not consider any moral implications of eating meat until you can show that there is something wrong with eating meat.

You already have moral opinions regarding how animals are treated, I guarantee it. So make a moral case for eating meat. If you can't, admit you can't.

What is the case for meat eating?
 
It's the basic capacity for consciousness, and it divides animals from plants.

It also divides planaries from other animals, so clearly your criterion doesn't work.

Where's your line?

I didn't buy one.

Plants don't have nervous systems, or brains, Belz. I'm not sure where you're going with that.

You said it was what made plants different from animals but it clearly isn't the case. The definition of "plant" does not preclude a nervous system, and several animals don't have one.

Go ahead, eat it. If it's threatening your life, then feel free to eat the kill.

What about if I farm black widow spiders in order to eat them ?

Huh? What re you talking about?

If killing animals for food is so wrong, we shouldn't allow animals to do it.

"I like it" is a terrible, terrible argument.

It's not an argument. It's a fact.

Do you support animal cruelty legislation, Belz? Agree that harming animals unnecessarily is unjustifiable?

Yes. Suffering is bad. Your point ?
 
Really, Volatile, the reason why I shouldn't have to justify myself is simply this:

We know we have to eat. So if it's a moral question we're going to have to create two sets, namely the stuff we can eat and the stuff we can't eat. In order to create those two sets we're going to have to define them.

So, what, exactly, are the criteria defining what we can eat and what we can't ?

I don't think there is such a set of criteria.

You'd eat ANYTHING? Endangered species? Your mother's kitten? Higher primates? Soya beans from deforested land? You have NO moral or ethical criteria in your diet AT ALL.

Sorry. I don't believe you. You have criteria. I just proffer they are rationally indefensible and internally inconsistent, just like every other meat-eater I've ever met. It's up to you to convince me otherwise, of course, by actually making a case FOR your diet.
 
You said it was what made plants different from animals but it clearly isn't the case. The definition of "plant" does not preclude a nervous system, and several animals don't have one.

OK then. Pass the steak... :rolleyes: The fact that there is no clear dividing line between a lower class of animal and some more complex plant species is definitely an argument FOR meat-eating!

Yes. Suffering is bad. Your point ?

My point is - that proves you hold a moral stance when it comes to animals. You consider them within a moral framework. It's therefore necessary to make a positive moral case that eating them is the right thing to do.

Go ahead.
 
Meat is a good source of protein and other nutrients, tastes good and is legal. The rest is histrionics and absurdities I don't care about. Guess I'm just an immoral ol' coot, but I don't care about that, either.
 
Everyone who says "Meat makes me feel good". It's the same class of argument as "Believing in God makes me happy".


"You should feel guilty for something legal and natural" is religion. Projecting your morality onto others is religion.

You want to eat vegan, I have nothing but respect for that. Try and tell me I'm wrong for not following suit, and you're the Jehovah's Witness knocking on my door while I'm trying to watch porn.
 
Tell me why eating vegetables is the right choice.

Because there are no good reasons to eat meat, basically - that and the fact that there several quantifiable negatives from meat eating (animal harm, environmental impact etc.) and it strikes me that omnivorous diets are basically irrational. I wouldn't have eaten my cat even when I was eating meat, so why was I so blase about porkchops for dinner? Unhappy with this irrationality, and unwilling to eat Tiddles, veganism strikes me as the only rational dietary choice.

So, even if the harms are contentious, they are there. As such, I think a strong case needs to be made in defence of meat-eating to justify it. Such a case can be made, for example, by those who have no other dietary options (I do, you do), by those who wish to avoid waste and are eating roadkill or waste (I don't eat roadkill, I assume you don't exclusively subsist on it either), and a few others.

Make a positive case for meat eating, without recouse to fallacies. Please. The case made in favour of it so far is just puerile and silly - "It tastes good", "I'm lazy", "Everyone else does it". Unsophisitcated, ill-considered blabber.

You can do better, Belz. Tell me why I should be eating meat.
 
"You should feel guilty for something legal and natural" is religion. Projecting your morality onto others is religion.

No it isn't. This is a discussion forum, dude. We're having a discussion. This argument is basically "Vegans are right because [insert rational argument based on bio-ethics, environmentalism and logic]" followed by "No, us meat eaters are because... well, just because".

That sure sounds like religion to me. Unsupportable social tradition, carried out by so many unthinking, unconsidered, unreflective drones. "It's legal!" is not a convincing argument - the same could have been made in favour of the Jim Crow laws. "I'm lazy" is not a convincing argument - the same can be made in favour of fly-tipping. "Everyone else does it" is not a convincing argument - the same argument is so often made for belief in a deity. These are all BAD arguments, and every one of you - all posters I respect - would recognise them as such if they were made in support of any other position.

If you can't make a positive case for your beliefs, those beliefs are irrational.
 
Argumentum ad populum - "I eat meat because everyone else does".

Not a good argument, Ken.

It would be fallacious if we were talking about facts. However, you are trying to change opinions. This is a subjective value you are trying to change, so the status quo is very much relevant. Also, it is legal to eat meat, so for you to change my mind about eating meat, you have to present an argument as to why it's wrong. So far, you are failing, miserably.

Trying to shift the burden to me simply won't work.

You already have moral opinions regarding how animals are treated, I guarantee it. So make a moral case for eating meat. If you can't, admit you can't.

What is the case for meat eating?
I live in a free society where people can do what they want until it's been proven to be wrong. This is why I feel that it's ok for people to be homosexual, not because the homosexuals have proven that they are right, but because the anti-gay people haven't shown that it is wrong.

The burden is upon you to change my mind about eating meat. Feel free to start anytime.
 
Last edited:
Meat is a good source of protein and other nutrients,

So is babies. And cats. And gorillas.

Eat them?

tastes good and is legal.
So? Why are these necessary components of a positive case? Theism is legal and enriching, and yet you'd readily dismiss anyone making that case in favour of belief in a deity.

The rest is histrionics and absurdities I don't care about.
Why don't you care about them? Why shouldn't we care about the moral implications and rational coherency of our actions?
 
It would be fallacious if we were talking about facts. However, you are trying to change opinions. This is a subjective value you are trying to change, so the status quo is very much relevant. Also, it is legal to eat meat, so for you to change my mind about eating meat, you have to present an argument as to why it's wrong. So far, you are failing, miserably.

Trying to shift the burden to me simply won't work.

So you're sticking with "Everyone else eats meat", "I like it" and "It's legal". Would these be good arguments in support of any other opinion?

In Iran, everyone hates homosexuals, hating homosexuals makes the society feel better, and hating homosexuals is legal. Does this make their actions OK?

You have a choice, Ken. If "Everyone else does it" is sufficient for you to carry out an action which has negative consequences even within your own moral code, then fine. But I don't believe you'd consider that sufficient as justification for any other action. Why does diet get a free reign?

Does anyone want to make a case FOR eating meat?
 
Last edited:
So you're sticking with "Everyone else eats meat", "I like it" and "It's legal". Would these be good arguments in support of any other opinion?

In Iran, everyone hates homosexuals, hating homosexuals makes the society feel better, and hating homosexuals is legal. Does this make their actions OK?

Yes, I'm sticking with not changing my behavior unless it can be shown to be wrong.

Iran is wrong because they can't show that homosexual behavior is wrong.

If you can't show me that eating meat is wrong, I'm going to continue eating meat.
 
If you can't make a positive case for your beliefs, those beliefs are irrational.


Says the guy who's arguing with:


You can do better, Belz. Tell me why I should be eating meat.


As if ANYONE is telling you that YOU should be eating meat. No one here is judging you for your dietary choices. It's the whole "my morality is the one true morality" stance that turns your argument from one of rationality to one of dogmatism.
 
Yes, I'm sticking with not changing my behavior unless it can be shown to be wrong.

Iran is wrong because they can't show that homosexual behavior is wrong.

They believe it's wrong, it makes them feel good and everyone else they know hates homosexuals too. That's the argument, right?

If you can't show me that eating meat is wrong, I'm going to continue eating meat.

Why is eating meat right? You still haven't told me.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom