Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

Why ? What's so hot about a nervous system that means we can't kill those who have it ?

It's basically the defining line between animal and vegetable, and (more-or-less) the defining characteristic for rudimentary consciousness.

Do spiders have enough of a nervous system to qualify ? If so, does that mean I can't be allowed to kill a black widow spider in my basement ?

Yes to the first question. No to the second.

And if the only criterion is "nervous system", should animals be allowed to kill one another ? If not, then what's the other criterion ?

"Allowed" makes no sense to those lacking the higher-reasoning ability to make moral judgements (aka all species other than humans). Your question makes no sense.

In any case, as I've discussed before, such arguments only serve to prove the veg[etari]an a hypocrite. They're pointless, and childish, and (ironically, given the accusations so often levelled in the opposite direction) supercilious.

Why don't you make a POSITIVE moral case for your dietary choices? Starting from a blank canvas - where you are able to lay out the pros and cons of various diets - what goes in the "PRO" column for omnivorous? When I did this for myself, I couldn't think of one, other than "taste", that was remotely defensible -- which is why I'm vegan.

In other words, it's not even really about why I (and, I suspect from past conversations, Cain too) am a vegan. It's about why you're NOT.

Show your working.
 


NOFX feels the same way. I love that song. :)

:)

I actively hate it that we have similar music tastes, Drudgie.

NOFX were wrong, though: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bivalvia#Nervous_system

But even if they weren't - though nervous systems are pretty much my (yes, arbitrary) dividing line between "edible" and "non-edible", that would not permit me, morally speaking, to chow down on endangered orchids or to have to starve to death in the desert should the only food available be animals.

Pragmatism is crucial in the construction of a moral position.
 
[Peanut gallery]

For all his abrasiveness, Cain's arguments are sophisticated, erudite and very, very sharp. What depresses me most is just how blunt and juvenile all the arguments put forth in response are.

As Kevin (for I think it was he) said earlier on, it really does seem that all most people can muster in defence of meat-eating is insults and fallacies. There's been not one coherently-expressed, reasonable and clear argument expressed by anyone in support of eating animals for food in circumstances where a plant-based diet is available. Not one.

Carry on.

[/Peanut Gallery]

I think you are suffering from confirmation bias. All of Cain's arguments are fallacious and attempts of making meat-eaters defend the eating of meat instead of actually putting forth arguments as to why eating meat is wrong. In essence, he's saying "prove that eating meat is ok".

Cain's arguments are wordy, and complex. However, they are simplistic in nature as well as irrational. Once either he or Kevin put forth a decent argument as to why eating meat is wrong, I'll let you know.
 
I think you are suffering from confirmation bias. All of Cain's arguments are fallacious and attempts of making meat-eaters defend the eating of meat instead of actually putting forth arguments as to why eating meat is wrong. In essence, he's saying "prove that eating meat is ok".

Cain's arguments are wordy, and complex. However, they are simplistic in nature as well as irrational. Once either he or Kevin put forth a decent argument as to why eating meat is wrong, I'll let you know.

No, seriously. They really aren't fallacious. Those against him are, and almost exclusively so. Demonstrably, they fall into argumentum ad populum, the naturalistic fallacy, ad hominems, and special pleading. Examples of all of those were given on the very first page of this thread. On the contrary, Cain's arguments are strong, coherent, internally-consistent and built upon a range of supportable and sustainable premises that he follows through to theor logical (and pragmatic) conclusion. They are informed by bioethcis, moral philosophy, and a range of scientific discourse. The same, sadly, cannot be said of any of the arguments put forth against him. Yet.

So, to the rub: As an inhabitant of an industrialised Western nation, you have a free choice about what you eat. Further, I believe that you would not disagree that it is behoven upon us all to consider our choices and their impacts, and their relative morality.

Given those two premises, why should I eat meat? I love the taste, but it has a number of clear downsides, and some uncomfortable points of fit with the rest of my moral positions (which I assume you share - you believe, I assume, that animal cruelty laws are justifiable).

So, please. Humour me. Make a positive case for meat-eating. I'd like to hear it.
 
Last edited:
No need. You just made it for me.




:cool:

Seriously? That's enough?

Do you engage in any other activities that have active and demonstrable harms and fit oddly with your broader moral base, simply because you enjoy them? Does the taste of meat, above all things, trump every other concern?
 
Seriously? That's enough?

Do you engage in any other activities that have active and demonstrable harms and fit oddly with your broader moral base, simply because you enjoy them?


Well, sometimes I break the speed limit. But if I get a ticket for it then it's my own fault. Doesn't apply here, since grilling a steak is both legal and mighty tasty.


Does the taste of meat, above all things, trump every other concern?


In short, yes. I simply don't have the same concerns you do. Doesn't mean I think you're wrong for having them, only that they begin and end with what you put on your dinner plate and I'm not going to hoist them onto mine.
 
Examples of all of those were given on the very first page of this thread. On the contrary, Cain's arguments are strong, coherent, internally-consistent and built upon a range of supportable and sustainable premises that he follows through to theor logical (and pragmatic) conclusion. They are informed by bioethcis, moral philosophy, and a range of scientific discourse. The same, sadly, cannot be said of any of the arguments put forth against him. Yet.

This is what you believe, but I have yet to see a logical argument based on supportable premise. Perhaps you can pick just one of them as an example.

So, to the rub: As an inhabitant of an industrialised Western nation, you have a free choice about what you eat. Further, I believe that you would not disagree that it is behoven upon us all to consider our choices and their impacts, and their relative morality.
We have a free choice about what to eat, I agree. However, I don't agree that it is "behoven" to us to consider their relative morality. The reason we have a free choice is because morality doesn't even come into consideration as to what I am going to eat.

Given those two premises, why should I eat meat? I love the taste, but it has a number of clear downsides, and some uncomfortable points of fit with the rest of my moral positions (which I assume you share - you believe, I assume, that animal cruelty laws are justifiable).

So, please. Humour me. Make a positive case for meat-eating. I'd like to hear it.
No. It is the status quo that there is nothing wrong with eating meat. It is the burden of those that think eating meat is wrong to convince ME that it is wrong. Instead, you are doing what I've complained about all through the thread. You are trying to make me prove that eating meat is morally sound. Legally, and ethically, there is no reason for me to do this.

Feel free to show me why eating meat is wrong. I'd like to hear it.
 
it really does seem that all most people can muster in defence of meat-eating

That's because, as thaiboxerken has pointed out repeatedly, there's no need to defend meat-eating. There's been no compelling argument that eating meat is in any way immoral. Until the Moral Vegetarians can demonstrate otherwise, the onus is on them. If you want the majority to buy into your minority position you're going to have to convince us.

And the attitudes and arguments expressed by Cain and Kevin Lowe so far have, if anything, pushed us further away from accepting that position. You guys need to decide if you want to be "right" according to your One True MoralityTM, preaching to your own little choir, or whether you actually want to convince meat-eaters to change their position. Because, right now, you seem to doing the former at the expense of the latter.
 
That's because, as thaiboxerken has pointed out repeatedly, there's no need to defend meat-eating. There's been no compelling argument that eating meat is in any way immoral. Until the Moral Vegetarians can demonstrate otherwise, the onus is on them. If you want the majority to buy into your minority position you're going to have to convince us.

And the attitudes and arguments expressed by Cain and Kevin Lowe so far have, if anything, pushed us further away from accepting that position. You guys need to decide if you want to be "right" according to your One True MoralityTM, preaching to your own little choir, or whether you actually want to convince meat-eaters to change their position. Because, right now, you seem to doing the former at the expense of the latter.
Gee, I wonder if this is the answer to why PETA is so damn stupid?
 
We have a free choice about what to eat, I agree. However, I don't agree that it is "behoven" to us to consider their relative morality.

Why not?

Do you, for example, support animal cruelty legislation? Are you against testing cosmetics on animals? If so, then tacitly you support moral considerations when it comes to how humans treat animals. As such, you MUST make a moral case for eating them. It's as simple as that. These are questions which exist inside a moral framework, even if you'd prefer to pretend they didn't.

Now, you don't have to agree with me, or come to the same moral conclusions. I am a vegan and yet support the testing of medicines on animals, and eating meat where ultimately necessary, and can make moral cases for these positions. Others who disagree with me make moral arguments to the contrary. But the key thing is - these are moral arguments.

Trying to pretend that our dietary choices exist beyond morality is just ridiculous. Even eating cows and not kittens is a moral decision, even if you'd prefer to pretend it wasn't.

You have a free choice about what to eat. So make a positive case for your diet. Else you're just as fit for ridicule as the theist who believes in God just because that's what he's done all his life, never having considered the actual reasons why he acts the way he does.

Tell me why eating meat is the right choice.
 
[Peanut gallery]

For all his abrasiveness, Cain's arguments are sophisticated, erudite and very, very sharp. What depresses me most is just how blunt and juvenile all the arguments put forth in response are.

As Kevin (for I think it was he) said earlier on, it really does seem that all most people can muster in defence of meat-eating is insults and fallacies. There's been not one coherently-expressed, reasonable and clear argument expressed by anyone in support of eating animals for food in circumstances where a plant-based diet is available. Not one.

Carry on.

[/Peanut Gallery]

Nobody has mentioned that it's delicious?

Ah, I see it's brought up later on this very page. (I only peeked in on the last one.)

Seriously? That's enough?

Do you engage in any other activities that have active and demonstrable harms and fit oddly with your broader moral base, simply because you enjoy them? Does the taste of meat, above all things, trump every other concern?

Actually, there are all sorts of harmful activities that we humans regularly engage in. Harmful to ourselves as individuals and harmful to society. Drinking and smoking are clear examples. Driving cars contributes to global warming.

Does taste (or more generally enjoyment) trump every other concern? No. I eat more chicken than beef because it's more affordable. I don't eat a chocolate bar every day because it's not good for me to do that, much as I would like to.

It seems to me that the vegan arguments are nothing more than an attempt to convince other people to live according to vegan moral standards.
 
Trying to pretend that our dietary choices exist beyond morality is just ridiculous.


Convenience (in other words, not having to figure out and prepare all the different alternatives required to substitute the nutrients meat provides) and taste are perfect reasons dietary choices exist beyond morality.

It may drive you nuts, but morality doesn't figure into it for most of us. If you want to attach it to the equation so be it. But you're never going to get more than a "because it's silly" response when you ask how we're able to justify drowning your personal beliefs in A-1 sauce.
 
It seems to me that the vegan arguments are nothing more than an attempt to convince other people to live according to vegan moral standards.

Of course. All moral arguments have that quality, though. Most of this forum - all of this fourm, really - features arguments of this sort. I think I'm right. In the spirit of discussion, however, I'm willing to be convinced I'm wrong - if only someone would step up to the plate with anything other than "just 'cause" as an argument in favour of the alternative.

On the first part of your argument, when you say "Actually, there are all sorts of harmful activities that we humans regularly engage in. Harmful to ourselves as individuals and harmful to society", you are correct. And moral arguments can be presented for and against most of them. Why is diet the only one which has no-one willing to make a decent argument in favour of it?
 
Convenience (in other words, not having to figure out and prepare all the different alternatives required to substitute the nutrients meat provides) and taste are perfect reasons dietary choices exist beyond morality.

Bad argument. The tofu and the chicken are on alternate aisles in the supermarket. And you should be "figuring out" nutrients anyway, vegan or not. Eating a balanced vegan diet really isn't hard, at all. Nor is it bland or unvaried or boring or disgusting.

You're essentially using "I'm lazy" as a rational reason in defence of your diet. If that was proffered in defence of any other position, you'd mock the person claiming it.

It may drive you nuts, but morality doesn't figure into it for most of us.
I know. And that's the problem.

Why doesn't it? Habit, upbringing and social convention. All reasons people cite in favour of all kinds of silly beliefs, and reasons that are rightly and frequently condemned all over this forum.

I take it, then, that you have no actual reasons for eating meat? No rational, defensible reasons? At all? This is what I mean about unsophisticated arguments for the defence - so far we've had "I like it", "I'm lazy" and "I don't care"!
 
Last edited:
Why ? What's so hot about a nervous system that means we can't kill those who have it ?

It's basically the defining line between animal and vegetable, and (more-or-less) the defining characteristic for rudimentary consciousness.

You're not answering my question. What's so hot about a nervous system that means we can't kill those who have it ?

Also, what distinguishes vegetables from animals is at the cellular level. Nothing precludes a plant from having the equivalent of a brain.

Yes to the first question. No to the second.

What if I mean to eat the spider, instead ?

"Allowed" makes no sense to those lacking the higher-reasoning ability to make moral judgements (aka all species other than humans). Your question makes no sense.

Allow me to clarify. Why should WE allow animals to eat one another ?

In any case, as I've discussed before, such arguments only serve to prove the veg[etari]an a hypocrite.

Which is important when pointing out nonsense.

Why don't you make a POSITIVE moral case for your dietary choices?

I have. I like to eat meat. Animals are farmed for food. We kill them for food. I eat them. As Randfan points out, animals live much better lives under our protection. Dying later and painlessly is a small price to pay. If the animal is killed properly there is no difference between killing an animal for food and killing a carrot for food.
 

Because it's legal to eat meat and it's the status quo. I will not consider any moral implications of eating meat until you can show that there is something wrong with eating meat.

Do you, for example, support animal cruelty legislation? Are you against testing cosmetics on animals?

These are irrelevant as to what's for dinner.

Trying to pretend that our dietary choices exist beyond morality is just ridiculous. Even eating cows and not kittens is a moral decision, even if you'd prefer to pretend it wasn't.

I don't agree. Because it is not illegal or even considered wrong to eat meat, you have to convince me that it is wrong. Until so, I will continue to eat meat. It's the moral-vegans that are trying to change the minds of the majority. They need to do so with an argument as to why it's wrong.

You have a free choice about what to eat.

Exactly. Because of this, I have no need to justify what I eat and why. Give me one reason why eating meat is ethically wrong.
 
Bad argument. The tofu and the chicken are on alternate aisles in the supermarket. And you should be "figuring out" nutrients anyway, vegan or not. Eating a balanced vegan diet really isn't hard, at all. Nor is it bland or unvaried or boring or disgusting.


Tofu is freakin' awful.
barf.gif



I take it, then, that you have no actual reasons for eating meat? No rational, defensible reasons? At all?


Tofu is freakin' awful.
barf.gif
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom