Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

The point about the carrots is to demonstrate the weakness of the premise. The weakness stands.

No, not really. Not at all actually. If you want to pretend some overly-literal, out-of-context reading validates you in some way, fine, but it doesn't cope with the spirit of the argument, or the similar arguments that came before my post, or the many that came before this thread.

What I think of as unnecessary suffering is likely to differ from what you think of as unnecessary.

Indeed. But you put this turn of phrase in the same sentence where you said it's OK to eat them, and many non-vegans/vegetarians agree it is not necessary to eat meat, and almost everyone agrees it is not necessary to eat as much as we do.

A domesticated animal doesn't worry about the possibility that it will die (having had children I can tell you from a very young age they do both, in this instance you should use infant).

Or we could have defined children. Or I could have said toddler. This is yet another evasive action of yours, which brings up a point of style differences: When I make these sort of clarifications to strengthen an argument -- I do it because I want to respond to the strongest possible argument; the important part is the responding part. Do you build on any of the arguments you laid out? No, you do not:

Killing an animal doesn't rob it of something that we perceive as intrinsically important to the human condition.

This is a level nine b.s. argument; you're desperately trying to grab onto anything. The problematic terms here are "perceive," "intrinsically," and "human condition." Instead of articulating a clear moral principle, you lay down this blob. What other things do we perceive as intrinsically important to the human condition? This is off-the-cuff dreck. Please do not waste my time.

Children don't have the same rights and responsibilities as adults.

Neither do animals. You're failing to identify significant differences, which means "what we perceive as intrinsically..." is going to have to do the heavy lifting...

Given that most people have an evolved adaptive trait to protect children and thus perceive killing and eating children as immoral then I doubt that society is going to adopt that view. I certainly don't see it as moral and I don't think there is any danger of that. I've stated that SCT doesn't preclude giving consideration to those who aren't members of the contract. I'm willing to give primates and other animals the same consideration (perhaps limited rights) as children.

So assuming you had in fact worked out this view at least, say, a day ago -- that is, you're not just making it up as you go along, which you have a history of doing -- then my question is: why didn't you bring these considerations to the fore immediately? Why did you compare animals against adults without taking into account the more appropriate comparison to children (or infants :rolleyes: ) raised in my post? If you are not continually revising your view as you go along, then I am led to believe you purposely put forth a straw man. Perhaps making stuff up as you go along is a virtue of the great provisional morality.

On domesticated animals:
But these animals, as Dennet points out, do exist as aphids do for ants. They benefit ["from"? or Freudian slip] humans and humans benefit from them. So what if they don't exist in the wild? It doesn't obviate the point.

The point is... there is no point.

They are free of predators on a day to day basis until we decide to kill and eat them which is a considerably greater age than in the wild. If you compare animals in the wild to domesticated animals you will note a considerable difference. Wild animals are often flighty and afraid. They are often chased by predators and live in fear.

So animals raised for food have a longer lifespan than those in the wild?? It's true that many food processed animals are most definitely not flighty. Yep... there's a reason for that.

I'm not sure I did but it's possible. Gorillas and other primates are capable of higher levels of thought and self awareness. If greater protection or consideration is better than "rights" then fine but I don't really care about the fine point you want to put on it. I could be persuaded either way. As I said earlier, I could be persuaded to forgo eating pigs.

Poorly worded on my part. There are no animals that I know of that can enter into a social contract with humans. However there are animals with higher functions and I would be willing to give them consideration that I wouldn't other animals.

Ah, so I'm putting a fine point on things when you allowed for gorilla rights. You know what's not putting a fine point on things? Making a distinction between children and infants. Anyway, so gorilla thought processes and capabilities are at some level meriting consideration. Cool. Are you sure you want to use that answer and not invoke something about how we perceive some sort of intrinsic importance to the Great Ape condition? Nothing about them being close cousins or evolutionary psychology or empathy or anything like that? You sure now?

OK, so what stands out between a gorilla and a cow? I'm sure it has everything to do with brain function and nothing to do with the fact that people eat cows.
-----------
GreNME:
And this is why I disregard you animal rights folk: you'll willingly do away with whole species to achieve your intended utopian world where humans are the only creatures on the planet who have to play by the utopian rules.

Yes, we want to drive species into extinction through good will. Nothing pleases me more than to see their numbers go from billions to ZERO, which WILL happen if we get our way. No more cows anywhere, ever. And there are those crazy utopian rules that only apply to humans, largely because non-humans are not moral agents, but anyway, it sounds so pernicious and dare I say, eeeeeville. Just wipe away the good old days when we made animals play by our rules.

-------------------
Sword:
All this talk of philosophy and the nature of morality is just pushing the air around, it accomplishes and ultimately means little. But freedom is something that is always worth fighting for.

I hear ya, brother. It's like I always say, what the **** do philosophy and morality have to do with freedom? If them animal rights kooks have their way then I'll retrieve my 5,000 pound arsenal from the bunker and fight for mah freedom (which is worth dyin' for).
 
Sword:


I hear ya, brother. It's like I always say, what the **** do philosophy and morality have to do with freedom? If them animal rights kooks have their way then I'll retrieve my 5,000 pound arsenal from the bunker and fight for mah freedom (which is worth dyin' for).

I didn't say anything about me dying. Animal rights kooks, simply put, can't fight. They tend not to own guns, sign up for the military or join police forces in large numbers.

Unless the kooks somehow achieved a staggeringly enormous numerical or technological superiority, the fight would be a lot like Desert Storm. Short, decisive, all the casualties on one side and not a shred of dispute who the winners are.

The only thing sillier than thinking my Wendy's Baconator™ is a person would be attempting to enforce that view. You would go through a brief flurry of actual people dying only to end up either back where you were before or in an even worse position.
 
GreNME:


Yes, we want to drive species into extinction through good will. Nothing pleases me more than to see their numbers go from billions to ZERO, which WILL happen if we get our way. No more cows anywhere, ever. And there are those crazy utopian rules that only apply to humans, largely because non-humans are not moral agents, but anyway, it sounds so pernicious and dare I say, eeeeeville. Just wipe away the good old days when we made animals play by our rules.

How about you try responding with intellectual honesty for a change, Cain? You know damned well that driving species to extinction would be the result of a world such as you described, which happens to be fairly in line with the general standard for animal rights extremes. It wouldn't be just cows, or chickens, or dogs, and it wouldn't be limited to just domestic animals either. But you can't honestly admit to that, can you? Can you be intellectually honest enough to admit to the logical consequences of what you suggest, both the (proposed) good and the bad?

As for the utopian rules, people are the only ones who could play by those rules, because other animals don't have rules. I don't need to call it evil (though it sure sounds good for your strawmen, I agree), because it is in and of itself shortsighted, shallow, and stupid-- it does not have a workable practical application, and only exists as a utopian idea that ignores logistics of current biodiversity systems that have built themselves up over years, decades, and in some cases centuries of human husbandry of other animals.
 
Just don't think that going on a crusade in the U.S. means anything at all.

No offense, but I really don't think you're approaching this with any consideration, and are mostly being contrary for its sake. If you're not, my apologies, but you really had to bend over backwards into hypothetical narratives to dismiss what I'm saying, when I already said that the fact that the level of consumption is already drastically different on the other side of the pond is good evidence of being the proper direction. There's never going to be a perfect world or a completely humane system of doing pretty much anything, not even concerning other people (the existence of slave labor around the world is astonishingly high). I find the argument "oh sod it, no one cares anyway" to be a bit... lacking.
 
...when I already said that the fact that the level of consumption is already drastically different on the other side of the pond is good evidence of being the proper direction.

To which I pointed out that the Asian world is going totally the opposite way.

There's never going to be a perfect world or a completely humane system of doing pretty much anything, not even concerning other people (the existence of slave labor around the world is astonishingly high). I find the argument "oh sod it, no one cares anyway" to be a bit... lacking.

If you perceive the arguments that way, you might find this indeed.

I find that 'doing the most work where it does the most good' is more effective than trying to talk 'moral' or 'humane' based on U.S. culture.

It is simply not so that the rest of the world has the same views. And therefore most of these arguments do not hold water when viewed from other cultures.

Other cultures *are* allowed to their own opinion, aren't they?

So to refine my 'lacking argument'; "as long as you look from a viewpoint where you can nicely decide what you eat... sod it!".
 
Yes.

...and many non-vegans/vegetarians agree it is not necessary to eat meat...
By "unnessacarily suffer" I mean without any reedeming purpose.

Or we could have defined children. Or I could have said toddler. This is yet another evasive action of yours, which brings up a point of style differences: When I make these sort of clarifications to strengthen an argument -- I do it because I want to respond to the strongest possible argument; the important part is the responding part. Do you build on any of the arguments you laid out? No, you do not:
Rhetorical. No argument to respond to.

This is a level nine b.s. argument; you're desperately trying to grab onto anything. The problematic terms here are "perceive," "intrinsically," and "human condition." Instead of articulating a clear moral principle, you lay down this blob. What other things do we perceive as intrinsically important to the human condition? This is off-the-cuff dreck. Please do not waste my time.
Rhetorical. No argument to respond to.

Neither do animals.
Which is my point.

You're failing to identify significant differences, which means "what we perceive as intrinsically..." is going to have to do the heavy lifting...
You are mixing arguments. We give children consideration and rights and we can give animals with the same cognitive ability as children the same considerations and rights.

So assuming you had in fact worked out this view at least, say, a day ago -- that is, you're not just making it up as you go along, which you have a history of doing -- then my question is: why didn't you bring these considerations to the fore immediately? Why did you compare animals against adults without taking into account the more appropriate comparison to children (or infants :rolleyes: ) raised in my post? If you are not continually revising your view as you go along, then I am led to believe you purposely put forth a straw man. Perhaps making stuff up as you go along is a virtue of the great provisional morality.
First off, the time that an argument is made (today, yesterday, tommorrow) doesn't invalidate the argument. None of this is new for me. I made these argument with you, Kevin and Earthborn years ago.

The point is... there is no point.
Gainsaying. Rhetorical.

Making a distinction between children and infants.
It's an important distinction. Unlike the "rights" vs "considerations" but that's fine.

Anyway, so gorilla thought processes and capabilities are at some level meriting consideration. Cool. Are you sure you want to use that answer and not invoke something about how we perceive some sort of intrinsic importance to the Great Ape condition? Nothing about them being close cousins or evolutionary psychology or empathy or anything like that? You sure now?
Do you have an argument? I'll stand by my answer.

OK, so what stands out between a gorilla and a cow? I'm sure it has everything to do with brain function and nothing to do with the fact that people eat cows.
If I hadn't made the point about pigs you would have a good point. I did and you don't.
 
Last edited:
I find that 'doing the most work where it does the most good' is more effective than trying to talk 'moral' or 'humane' based on U.S. culture.

I agree with this, which is why I'm not suggesting that changes be geared toward emphasizing 'moral' or 'humane'. That would never work because, as I've expressed in other (semi-unrelated) arguments, it's all relative. Transparency in production and working to level the playing field to a degree, however, is at least less relative and has shown efficacy to some degree. Improvements in practices would mostly be a side-effect, and only then after the demand side of the equation has adjusted and moves in that direction.

It is simply not so that the rest of the world has the same views. And therefore most of these arguments do not hold water when viewed from other cultures.

Other cultures *are* allowed to their own opinion, aren't they?

Absolutely. The only area where differences in opinion would become an issue would be in trading between nations or groups in different nations, which incidentally is no different than it is today (though the current condition definitely has the US at a loss in terms of meeting regulatory criteria).

So to refine my 'lacking argument'; "as long as you look from a viewpoint where you can nicely decide what you eat... sod it!".

That's definitely better in terms of refining the argument, but I don't deny that people are going to eat what they want to eat anyway. I'm talking more on the logistical and economic factors of the industries themselves, and to that (regarding your comments to the Asian markets) the regulation is going to be graded depending on the developing status of the economy of a given region-- though it's worth noting that the limitations on what kinds of crops get grown in some nations on the African continent are an example of where First-World regulations are indirectly opposed on developing nations (sometimes, in order to play you have to know the rules).

I'm not always a huge fan of regulating everything, but in some cases-- and for this, I think the food industry is one-- regulation of disclosure and having minimum operational requirements is going to yield better results in the long run than letting the industries have at it and let chips fall where they may (not meant as a dichotomy, but two points on a sliding scale). To this, I'd say that much of Western Europe is already ahead of the curve, even if that doesn't mean all cows and piggies are living in Livestock Marriotts.
 
Missed this one:
Ah, so I'm putting a fine point on things when you allowed for gorilla rights. You know what's not putting a fine point on things? Making a distinction between children and infants. Anyway, so gorilla thought processes and capabilities are at some level meriting consideration. Cool. Are you sure you want to use that answer and not invoke something about how we perceive some sort of intrinsic importance to the Great Ape condition? Nothing about them being close cousins or evolutionary psychology or empathy or anything like that? You sure now?

Impressive: if you watch, you can actually see the goalposts moving as you read.

OK, so what stands out between a gorilla and a cow? I'm sure it has everything to do with brain function and nothing to do with the fact that people eat cows.

You'd be wrong if you were really that sure of yourself.
 
Ah, so I'm putting a fine point on things when you allowed for gorilla rights. You know what's not putting a fine point on things? Making a distinction between children and infants. Anyway, so gorilla thought processes and capabilities are at some level meriting consideration. Cool. Are you sure you want to use that answer and not invoke something about how we perceive some sort of intrinsic importance to the Great Ape condition? Nothing about them being close cousins or evolutionary psychology or empathy or anything like that? You sure now?

OK, so what stands out between a gorilla and a cow? I'm sure it has everything to do with brain function and nothing to do with the fact that people eat cows.

Gorillas aren't cultivated for meat for reasons that have little to do with their brain function. First off is the "Fang Rule". That is, any animal that has them doesn't get put in ranches. Cows, pigs and sheep are far easier to contain and control than something that could eat you. When was the last time you heard about someone getting mauled by a cow?

Second is the fact that some species of gorilla or ape are endangered. One should not attempt to cultivate an animal without sufficient breeding stock to support the industry. We as human beings have an obligation to excersize responsible stewardship over the earths resources. There is nothing wrong with making use of a resource, be it zoological, botanical or geological, so long as we aren't reckless about it. Cows aren't headed for the endangered list anytime soon... ironically this is largely because of our cultivation of them.

But if it helps settle the issue, I am willing to eat a gorilla or ape.

After all, they are still just animals.
 
Yes.

By "unnessacarily suffer" I mean without any reedeming purpose.

Rhetorical. No argument to respond to.

Rhetorical. No argument to respond to.

Which is my point.

I think any sane person will agree you're not saying anything at all here. So I'll just as well ignore it.

You are mixing arguments. We give children consideration and rights and we can give animals with the same cognitive ability as children the same considerations and rights.

And here's the problem -- why do children represent that floor? I'll tell you, that's the exact same rationalization that I used when confronted with arguments for animal rights. Adult chimps, for example, possess awareness and functioning that exceeds humans, so we can grant rights to them. It's such a small concession that preserves consistency and has no serious implications for my taste preferences. But then another argument arises: why should children represent that floor? Is that level of ability non-arbitrary? (This is similar to the Texas sharpshooter fallacy.)

First off, the time that an argument is made (today, yesterday, tommorrow) doesn't invalidate the argument. None of this is new for me. I made these argument with you, Kevin and Earthborn years ago.

Sure. But it points to your preternatural willingness to make up things as you go along; to ********.

If I hadn't made the point about pigs you would have a good point. I did and you don't.

Another stumbling evasion. This is what I pointed to earlier about strengthening the argument. And if I was in your position I would be equally unwilling to defend embarrassing nonsense about perceiving some intrinsically important facet of the human condition.

------------------
GreNME:
Impressive: if you watch, you can actually see the goalposts moving as you read.

If you want to try to generate an argument, then go ahead. But this is meaningless, like much of the above. If one wants to welcome certain species into the community of those deserving protection, then a quite natural question -- one asked of vegans dozens of times in this thread -- is where does it end? Of course, vegans have a much stronger case because we're talking animals and our opponents want to talk about carrots. Some are even so frightened to reply they'll non-answer , "Oh, if you said pigs, then you'd have a point, but instead you said cows, and I'm going to run away now!"

Cain wrote:
OK, so what stands out between a gorilla and a cow? I'm sure it has everything to do with brain function and nothing to do with the fact that people eat cows.
GreNME:
You'd be wrong if you were really that sure of yourself.

I know you like to portray vegans as black-and-white cultists, but the moral reasoning in the face of not-so-clear facts urges erring on the side of caution. If a person has a serious questions about pigs (say), then she probably should not eat them at all. This would be consistent with any reasonable provisional morality, which would impose a moratorium as one can always later return to their meat-eating ways. The problem with this course of action is that it requires self-discipline.
------------------------

Sword:
Gorillas aren't cultivated for meat for reasons that have little to do with their brain function.

[and other stuff]

You're completely missing the point.
 
GreNME:

If you want to try to generate an argument, then go ahead.

What, and get in the way of your ever-shifting goalposts, strawmen, and appeals to non-existent authority? Been there, done that, and I've learned that you're just going to ignore or dismiss anything that disagrees with your foregone conclusion anyway.

Cain wrote:
OK, so what stands out between a gorilla and a cow? I'm sure it has everything to do with brain function and nothing to do with the fact that people eat cows.
GreNME:
You'd be wrong if you were really that sure of yourself.

I know you like to portray vegans as black-and-white cultists, but the moral reasoning in the face of not-so-clear facts urges erring on the side of caution. If a person has a serious questions about pigs (say), then she probably should not eat them at all. This would be consistent with any reasonable provisional morality, which would impose a moratorium as one can always later return to their meat-eating ways. The problem with this course of action is that it requires self-discipline.

No, Cain, I don't portray any general group as "black-and-white cultuists," but I do think that your own lines of argumentation portray you in particular as a black-and-white fundamentalist. Luckily for the world, you and your rhetorical paths are not representative of the vast, vast majority of vegans and vegetarians on the planet, since there are already enough self-aggrangizing and arrogant people in the world.
 
Sword:

You're completely missing the point.

No, I understood your point to Randfan regarding his willingness to make an exception for higher primates based on their intellect.

I was simply pointing out that the reason the human race as a whole does not cultivate them has nothing to do with their intellect and that I myself don't make such exceptions as Randfan does.
 
I think any sane person will agree you're not saying anything at all here. So I'll just as well ignore it.
Look in the mirror.

And here's the problem -- why do children represent that floor? I'll tell you, that's the exact same rationalization that I used when confronted with arguments for animal rights. Adult chimps, for example, possess awareness and functioning that exceeds humans, so we can grant rights to them. It's such a small concession that preserves consistency and has no serious implications for my taste preferences. But then another argument arises: why should children represent that floor? Is that level of ability non-arbitrary? (This is similar to the Texas sharpshooter fallacy.)
Your response bears no resemblance to my argument. If you want to deny children rights or consideration then I'm willing to entertain the argument but I kinda doubt it's going to fly. If someone else wants to deny any consideration for chimps then I would be willing to entertain that argument. As it stands I'm happy to grant both consideration so you are creating a controversy where there is none.

Sure. But it points to your preternatural willingness to make up things as you go along; to ********.
Assertion and without foundation, oh and asterisks, school yard insult? Must be more of that Daily Show fantasy of yours.

Another stumbling evasion. This is what I pointed to earlier about strengthening the argument. And if I was in your position I would be equally unwilling to defend embarrassing nonsense about perceiving some intrinsically important facet of the human condition.
Again, no argument. Just rhetoric. If something is nonsense one would think that you could make an argument as to why it is nonsense. But, that's just above you. Your assertions and opinion don't constitute argument.

So, I argue and you retort with rhetoric and invective.

Nothing new there.
 
Your response bears no resemblance to my argument. If you want to deny children rights or consideration then I'm willing to entertain the argument but I kinda doubt it's going to fly. If someone else wants to deny any consideration for chimps then I would be willing to entertain that argument. As it stands I'm happy to grant both consideration so you are creating a controversy where there is none.

Here again you're running away from the argument. What reason(s) do you have for including some and excluding others?

I wrote: Sure. But it points to your preternatural willingness to make up things as you go along; to ********.

Assertion and without foundation, oh and asterisks, school yard insult? Must be more of that Daily Show fantasy of yours.

This is another of your brilliant non-commitments. I love this ****. Whenever you get pinned down, you resort back to this "rhetoric" "assertion" nonsense thinking (perhaps) it somehow says something. You were caught slinging ********, which could be smelt from a mile away. It's not "assertion... without foundation." It's documented above, and your unwillingness to back it up leaves no room for doubt.

So I'll repeat just to embarrass you further:

How can "perceiving what's intrinsically important to the human condition" serve as a useful guide for morality? What are its specific applications? Why didn't you mention it in the first place? How can you use it to include chimps and children and exclude cows? Yes, cows. These are specific questions that you refuse to answer -- as you must -- so when I call them evasive you're reduced to "answering" with "assertion" coupled with something like "rhetoric," which just makes you look dumber than you probably are -- assuming that's possible. I'm sorry that, like moral beliefs, not all assertions are created equal.

GreNME:
What, and get in the way of your ever-shifting goalposts, strawmen, and appeals to non-existent authority? Been there, done that, and I've learned that you're just going to ignore or dismiss anything that disagrees with your foregone conclusion anyway.

You could have saved yourself a few keystrokes and said: "But I have no argument." This would have had the added virtue of truth.
 
[Peanut gallery]

For all his abrasiveness, Cain's arguments are sophisticated, erudite and very, very sharp. What depresses me most is just how blunt and juvenile all the arguments put forth in response are.

As Kevin (for I think it was he) said earlier on, it really does seem that all most people can muster in defence of meat-eating is insults and fallacies. There's been not one coherently-expressed, reasonable and clear argument expressed by anyone in support of eating animals for food in circumstances where a plant-based diet is available. Not one.

Carry on.

[/Peanut Gallery]
 
I recall that you did, and I thought about replying to another post where you talk about the need to eat as a "natural tendency." Regardless, there remain an abundance of food choices and you will not find anybody who disputes the need to eat.

You're not answering my question: why pick one type of food over another, health value being equal ?

You actually have a person complain about a straw man and then say, "shouldn't PETA start targeting lions and tigers for extinction? After all, how DARE one animal eat another!"

Indeed, how DARE ? Some vegans, as I already said, convert their cat to veganism. If they're willing to prevent their pets from eating what they normally eat, out of principle, then why wouldn't they apply those principles to animals in the wild ? Why are humans so different ? This is a serious question.

We can argue over what counts as a morally significant "mental life,"

Yes, yes we can. Because ants have a "mental life", too. Plants do not, but they do have a life. So, again, I ask: what is your criterion to eat or not eat such or such life form ?

The problem is that we're dealing with harming others. Whether or not you agree with animal rights, any person capable of basic reasoning can, if only for a moment, put herself in another's shoes: "Hmmmmm... this guy has the belief that killing animals is morally wrong. I do not agree with that idea, but I can see the logical consequences that mistaken premise entails." But no, instead you're like a robber saying, "Why can't you just leave me alone? I'm not robbing your house."

Huh ? That's not even analogous in any way, shape or form. I do not agree with that idea, but I can see the logical consequences that mistaken premise entails. PETA, however, does not, and they are willing to harm other people in order to push their agenda. They're the robber in the house, not I.
 
Nervous system.

Why ? What's so hot about a nervous system that means we can't kill those who have it ?

Do spiders have enough of a nervous system to qualify ? If so, does that mean I can't be allowed to kill a black widow spider in my basement ?

And if the only criterion is "nervous system", should animals be allowed to kill one another ? If not, then what's the other criterion ?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom