Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

Cop-out.

But let's go with it. I suspect it will be very americanised.

Not a cop-out, since I've already stated pretty clearly that I don't consider eating meat immoral.

As for the rest, you work very diligently at ignoring the point and continuing to make the issue about meat alone, when it isn't. It's about all foods, and while you assert that people don't care and just want cheap food, that's really beside the point because the food isn't going to be any more expensive if the markeet is tailored to the change.

I keep trying to explain to you, that all the rational arguments in the world do not mean a thing in this story.

I will therefore, give you a small recap:

- Outside the U.S. there are lots of countries that not only show what is in the food by labels, but also by education in schools, actually by almost any means necessary short of stupid violence (tantrum style).
- And the majority of the people do not care. They wholly accept vegetarians and/or vegans, and a lot even cut down on meat intake (mostly cost and cholesterol as a reason), but they do not care.

You keep insisting that the care is not there, and yet you admit that there's a huge difference in behavior in the consumption. Do you not see that the situation you're describing-- lowered consumption in general terms, more required disclosure by producers of food-- is exactly what I'm aiming for? Maybe it's not the case where you live, but considering the very slight difference in cost between the humane meat farmers here in the States and the mass-production meat, that slight change alone would level the playing field and may even possibly give advantage to the smaller farmers, but either way there would be a net result of lowered consumption overall.

Anyhoo, despite your saying that people don't care, I'm saying that doesn't necessarily matter. I'm saying the distribution model for food-- making sure people get their food cheaply and do with it what they want, whether either of us think they care or not-- is going to be the model that makes a difference, and that model would have to include all foodstuffs and not just meat. Making it just about meat is just a tactic that the PETA-folk and other agenda-driven organizations use to ignore trying to find a workable solution. I'm not suggesting turning everyone into a health-conscious, animal-and-environment-friendly, ethic-shopping yuppie. I'm suggesting quite the opposite, actually-- steer the supply side of the market and let efficiencies recreate themselves with the understanding that companies producing crap would have to list "we have crap in our stuff" on the boxes they sell in markets. You may not think that's a huge deal, but I guarantee that when such a doozy hits the biggest consumption market on the planet, the technologies for efficiency will start to change.

In other words, I'm not counting on people caring how the food they eat is made. I'm counting on the producers caring how their products are viewed, and considering how much time and effort companies put into image I'm saying that this is a more effective method than trying to change everyone's mind on the consumer side. I actually agree that people want what they want and have other things they'd rather put thought into.
 
Animals like dolphins, chimps and parrots have reasonably complicated social interactions, are capable of mental tasks children can't reliably complete until the age of six or so, and can have vocabularies of tens or hundreds of words.

So by the rule you just endorsed, it's perfectly okay to pop a four year old on the spit-roast, since it's dumber than some animals.

"But it's got the potential to be smarter!" you cry, thinking that this is an intelligent response. Well, first problem: acorns aren't oak trees, and sperm aren't scientists. If you count future states as morally determinative then in the future we'll all be dead and you can stuff us in a crematorium now. What determines how we can treat an entity is what it is now, not what you reckon it will be at some arbitrary future time.

But even if you buy the ad hoc "potential" argument, it still doesn't get you off the hook, because brain damaged humans can spend their whole lives with a mental age of under six. Is it okay to keep them in steel cages their whole lives then kill them for bacon?



If you're so dumb that you're incapable of rational thought, which may well be the case based on your posts, it would indeed be unfair to expect moral behaviour from you. Maybe we should put you on the same moral level as a bot fly larva and not judge you for what you do.



I'm not surprised RandFan endorsed this, it's pretty stupid.

As we've clarified before, we're talking about whether it's morally right to kill animals for food just because you like the taste.

Meat eaters like to try to hijack the discussion into being about whether people should be allowed to eat meat, because that's a whole lot easier for them. For now, please assume everyone agrees you should be allowed to eat meat if you choose to do so, so we can get back to the real question which is whether or not eating meat would make you an immoral person.

It's not what goes in your mouth that condemns you but what comes out.

Someone famous said that.
 
Already answered. Pay attention.

Well excuse me if I haven't followed every single post in the thread. I simply asked a question and it most certainly wasn't answered the first time around.

If it doesn't have a mental life comparable to that of a really dumb human I don't care.

That's a really useless criterion. Some humans are really dumb, but it's not a good reason to eat them.

Plants do not have such a mental life.

"Mental" life ? What the hell is a mental life, now ? Look, plants have a life, as well. If your only reason is that animals have a "mind", then you step onto other mines: what about vegetables (humans, I mean) ? What about animals that only barely have a mind (spiders, etc.) ?

As for preventing animals killing each other, if I could wave a magic wand and stop predation and parasitism in the animal world yet still have a working ecosystem that does all the things ecosystems are supposed to do then I'd wave it.

Er... why ? What's wrong with animals eating one another ?

Pushing your shopping trolley past the bacon to the tofu is a comparatively trivial operation.

The fact that I don't like tofu isn't trivial.

If person A thinks "it is morally tolerable to take action Z", and person B thinks "it is not morally tolerable to take action Z", then one of them is wrong. I don't know which one, necessarily, but I know one of them is wrong.

Only if you believe there is an objective moral reality. Both of them could be wrong, and both of them could be right depending on the point of view. No ?
 
As we've clarified before, we're talking about whether it's morally right to kill animals for food just because you like the taste.

You'll be hard-pressed to provide an objective argument for why plants shouldn't be allowed to live, too. Basically, you're turning a "humans vs others" view into a "animals vs others" view but both are equally arbitrary.

Meat eaters like to try to hijack the discussion into being about whether people should be allowed to eat meat, because that's a whole lot easier for them.

Maybe it's because we vote for freedom of choice rather than dictating to people what they should or shouldn't eat.
 
You'll be hard-pressed to provide an objective argument for why plants shouldn't be allowed to live, too. Basically, you're turning a "humans vs others" view into a "animals vs others" view but both are equally arbitrary.

If you go back and read the thread you'll find such objective arguments have already been posted.
 
No, I'm not. I'm saying we need to eat. Why not animals, then ?

I recall that you did, and I thought about replying to another post where you talk about the need to eat as a "natural tendency." Regardless, there remain an abundance of food choices and you will not find anybody who disputes the need to eat.

What's disturbing in this thread, at least from the "meat-eaters," is that not only do they have bad arguments, but these bad arguments are poorly argued, hence the tantrums, the personal attacks, and the allegation of fallacy without any of the support. It's the worst kind of ignorance -- a proud ignorance.

You actually have a person complain about a straw man and then say, "shouldn't PETA start targeting lions and tigers for extinction? After all, how DARE one animal eat another!"

Worse, that concern had probably been addressed a half-dozen times already.

Belz wrote:
"Mental" life ? What the hell is a mental life, now ? Look, plants have a life, as well. If your only reason is that animals have a "mind", then you step onto other mines: what about vegetables (humans, I mean) ? What about animals that only barely have a mind (spiders, etc.) ?

And contrary to whatever perception people would like to foster, those few here inclined to recognize animal rights are not the dogmatists because they are at least aware of an uneasy continuum of life in contrast to the Bush-like certainty that picks a morally arbitrary characteristic -- species -- and then bleats it repeatedly and loudly.

We can argue over what counts as a morally significant "mental life," but it's surely further in the right direction than the clumsy "species" category favored above. One bio-ethicist forcefully makes the distinction in an article republished in Bioethics: An Anthology. I'm paraphrasing:

Suppose Jones attempts to murder Terri, but rather than killing her, puts her into a persistent vegetative state. She lays in bed for years until Smith comes along and murders her. Assume both Jones and Smith are equally malicious. The law, as it stands now, punishes Smith more harshly because he technically ended her life (such as it was). However, the paper plausibly argues that Jones committed the greater crime because it resulted in identity death: Terri did not survive his attack (we're left with a shell, or the world's biggest fetus).

What's also remarkable, and related to my earlier comment on tolerance is this hilariously oblivious plea (echoed by others):
if, say, a vegan refuses to eat animal products for some reason or another, and I gleefully eat animal products all the time, and we disagree and agree to disagree, one of us is still wrong ?.

The problem is that we're dealing with harming others. Whether or not you agree with animal rights, any person capable of basic reasoning can, if only for a moment, put herself in another's shoes: "Hmmmmm... this guy has the belief that killing animals is morally wrong. I do not agree with that idea, but I can see the logical consequences that mistaken premise entails." But no, instead you're like a robber saying, "Why can't you just leave me alone? I'm not robbing your house."

The discussion here tracks with low-level arguments between a philosophically inclined atheist and a not-too sophisticated theist who marshals resentment: "Oh, you're so above me with all your philosophy talk. In fact, you're an over-educated, arrogant fool." As I remarked earlier, probably back on page 6 or 7, the views expressed by the meat-eaters are mostly unexamined. It's like they're seeing something categorized as the "cosmological argument" for the first time.
 
The problem is that we're dealing with harming others.
"Others"? When we eat carrots we harm them.

Causing harm in and of itself isn't an argument. It's a lone premise that doesn't resolve anything. The question becomes, are there morally relevant differences between humans and carrots or humans and cows that would make it immoral to kill and eat them?

You say yes to things that are capable of suffering and no to things that are not. I disagree.

While I think it is wrong for an animal to unnecessarily suffer I don't think it is wrong for an animal to die for the purposes of being eaten.

Animals that I choose to eart are not moral agents, they are not capable of entering into a social contract (reciprocal altruism). They don't plan for their futures or comprehend their own mortality. Animal husbandry provides these animals opportunity that they cannot enjoy in the wild. They are free of predators, statistically assured of surviving their birth, protected from the elements and receive medical attention. From an evolutionary standpoint, being a domesticated animal is to be evolutionary fit.

So, to paraphrase you, any person capable of basic reasoning can, if only for a moment, put herself in another's shoes: "Hmmmmm... this guy has the belief that killing animals is not morally wrong. I do not agree with that idea, but I can see the logical consequences that mistaken premise entails."

I'm not holding my breath for that though.
 
Last edited:
I recall that you did, and I thought about replying to another post where you talk about the need to eat as a "natural tendency." Regardless, there remain an abundance of food choices and you will not find anybody who disputes the need to eat.

What's disturbing in this thread, at least from the "meat-eaters," is that not only do they have bad arguments, but these bad arguments are poorly argued, hence the tantrums, the personal attacks, and the allegation of fallacy without any of the support. It's the worst kind of ignorance -- a proud ignorance.

You actually have a person complain about a straw man and then say, "shouldn't PETA start targeting lions and tigers for extinction? After all, how DARE one animal eat another!"

Worse, that concern had probably been addressed a half-dozen times already.

Belz wrote:


And contrary to whatever perception people would like to foster, those few here inclined to recognize animal rights are not the dogmatists because they are at least aware of an uneasy continuum of life in contrast to the Bush-like certainty that picks a morally arbitrary characteristic -- species -- and then bleats it repeatedly and loudly.

We can argue over what counts as a morally significant "mental life," but it's surely further in the right direction than the clumsy "species" category favored above. One bio-ethicist forcefully makes the distinction in an article republished in Bioethics: An Anthology. I'm paraphrasing:

Suppose Jones attempts to murder Terri, but rather than killing her, puts her into a persistent vegetative state. She lays in bed for years until Smith comes along and murders her. Assume both Jones and Smith are equally malicious. The law, as it stands now, punishes Smith more harshly because he technically ended her life (such as it was). However, the paper plausibly argues that Jones committed the greater crime because it resulted in identity death: Terri did not survive his attack (we're left with a shell, or the world's biggest fetus).

What's also remarkable, and related to my earlier comment on tolerance is this hilariously oblivious plea (echoed by others):


The problem is that we're dealing with harming others. Whether or not you agree with animal rights, any person capable of basic reasoning can, if only for a moment, put herself in another's shoes: "Hmmmmm... this guy has the belief that killing animals is morally wrong. I do not agree with that idea, but I can see the logical consequences that mistaken premise entails." But no, instead you're like a robber saying, "Why can't you just leave me alone? I'm not robbing your house."

The discussion here tracks with low-level arguments between a philosophically inclined atheist and a not-too sophisticated theist who marshals resentment: "Oh, you're so above me with all your philosophy talk. In fact, you're an over-educated, arrogant fool." As I remarked earlier, probably back on page 6 or 7, the views expressed by the meat-eaters are mostly unexamined. It's like they're seeing something categorized as the "cosmological argument" for the first time.

Just out of curiosity, what do you think should happen? Do you eventually want there to be laws that make meat eating murder?
 
I'd like to highlight both Cain's post above and Randfan's response as well said. I think I agree with a great deal of what both are saying, and they've said it well.

"Others"? When we eat carrots we harm them.

Causing harm in and of itself isn't an argument. It's a lone premise that doesn't resolve anything. The question becomes, are there morally relevant differences between humans and carrots or humans and cows that would make it immoral to kill and eat them?

You say yes to things that are capable of suffering and no to things that are not. I disagree.

While I think it is wrong for an animal to unnecessarily suffer I don't think it is wrong for an animal to die for the purposes of being eaten.
This is well said, and I agree with it. But only in so much as the killing and eating do not in and of themselves necessitate suffering. The problem that i have with my own meat-eating is the conditions that the animals I'm eating were forced to endure during their lives, not the death itself. I actually get from your posts that you agree with that: that the suffering of animals is a bad thing. The only disagreement you and I may have is on how bad, correct?

Animals that I choose to eart are not moral agents, they are not capable of entering into a social contract (reciprocal altruism).
But what does entering into a social contract have to do with it? When you mention reciprocal altruism it seems that you're basing your concern over others not upon the idea that you should have concern for them, but rather that by having concern for them you make it more likely that they will have concern for you.
Then, from this you conclude that those who are not capable of having concern for you are therefore not beings for whom who should be concerned.
I may be badly misunderstanding here, however, in which case I apologize and only ask you to show me where I misunderstood.

I recognize, by the way, that our moral sense evolved in part due to reciprocal altruism. But just as our desire for sex envolved "for" reproduction, that doesn't suggest that birth control is a bad thing, nor does the above suggest that our moral ideas should be based upon the things that made them selectively advantageous.

They don't plan for their futures or comprehend their own mortality.
I don't know that we know that. It may be true, and is certainly true of many animals, but is it true of all forms of non-human life? I wouldn't be surprised if chimpanzees planned for their future, or had some comprehension of their own morality. Those things are hard to test for, but absence of evidence isn't evidence of absence.
(it's not evidence of presence either, but my point is only that we can't use that as a necessary distinction until we know one way or the other).

Animal husbandry provides these animals opportunity that they cannot enjoy in the wild. They are free of predators, statistically assured of surviving their birth, protected from the elements and receive medical attention. From an evolutionary standpoint, being a domesticated animal is to be evolutionary fit.
A good point that I think people really need to consider. :)
 
I recall that you did, and I thought about replying to another post where you talk about the need to eat as a "natural tendency." Regardless, there remain an abundance of food choices and you will not find anybody who disputes the need to eat.

What's disturbing in this thread, at least from the "meat-eaters," is that not only do they have bad arguments, but these bad arguments are poorly argued, hence the tantrums, the personal attacks, and the allegation of fallacy without any of the support. It's the worst kind of ignorance -- a proud ignorance.

You actually have a person complain about a straw man and then say, "shouldn't PETA start targeting lions and tigers for extinction? After all, how DARE one animal eat another!"

Worse, that concern had probably been addressed a half-dozen times already.
I can recognise the frustration and even a certain amount of truth to the above, but don't you see the hypocracy in it as well? You perhaps correctly suggest that "the other side" is wrong for personal attacks and degrading the argument, then go on to talk about how much smarter "your side" is.

And contrary to whatever perception people would like to foster, those few here inclined to recognize animal rights are not the dogmatists because they are at least aware of an uneasy continuum of life in contrast to the Bush-like certainty that picks a morally arbitrary characteristic -- species -- and then bleats it repeatedly and loudly.

We can argue over what counts as a morally significant "mental life," but it's surely further in the right direction than the clumsy "species" category favored above. One bio-ethicist forcefully makes the distinction in an article republished in Bioethics: An Anthology. I'm paraphrasing:

Suppose Jones attempts to murder Terri, but rather than killing her, puts her into a persistent vegetative state. She lays in bed for years until Smith comes along and murders her. Assume both Jones and Smith are equally malicious. The law, as it stands now, punishes Smith more harshly because he technically ended her life (such as it was). However, the paper plausibly argues that Jones committed the greater crime because it resulted in identity death: Terri did not survive his attack (we're left with a shell, or the world's biggest fetus).
I only quote this to say that I agree with it, and feel it's a good point.

Personally, the thing I have with this issue is that if we are going to make moral distinctions between one thing and another, we need to do so in a non-abitrary manner. I think we all rightly criticize attempts to make moral distinctions within the human species for their arbitrariness.
Once we start to try to find non-arbitrary characteristics with which to make those distinctions, we are forced to recognise the continuum that Cain mentions.
Of course, the implications of that are hardly simple, and in my opinion (echoing randfan here) don't necessitate that meat-eating is wrong. Though it does suggest that we look at it a little more closely I guess.

The problem is that we're dealing with harming others. Whether or not you agree with animal rights, any person capable of basic reasoning can, if only for a moment, put herself in another's shoes: "Hmmmmm... this guy has the belief that killing animals is morally wrong. I do not agree with that idea, but I can see the logical consequences that mistaken premise entails." But no, instead you're like a robber saying, "Why can't you just leave me alone? I'm not robbing your house."
Actually, I disagree, and I think that Randfan makes the point well in his above post. It's more like a robber saying "I'm not doing anything wrong by robbing people", and having a good and consistent argument (albeit one with whose premises you disagree). That doesn't make him an idiot, though I agree that one of you is wrong. (and perhaps both).

The discussion here tracks with low-level arguments between a philosophically inclined atheist and a not-too sophisticated theist who marshals resentment: "Oh, you're so above me with all your philosophy talk. In fact, you're an over-educated, arrogant fool." As I remarked earlier, probably back on page 6 or 7, the views expressed by the meat-eaters are mostly unexamined. It's like they're seeing something categorized as the "cosmological argument" for the first time.

This is just bickering of exactly the sort that you were railing against at the beginning of your post.
 
I'd like to highlight both Cain's post above and Randfan's response as well said. I think I agree with a great deal of what both are saying, and they've said it well.

This is well said, and I agree with it. But only in so much as the killing and eating do not in and of themselves necessitate suffering. The problem that i have with my own meat-eating is the conditions that the animals I'm eating were forced to endure during their lives, not the death itself. I actually get from your posts that you agree with that: that the suffering of animals is a bad thing. The only disagreement you and I may have is on how bad, correct?

1 But what does entering into a social contract have to do with it? When you mention reciprocal altruism it seems that you're basing your concern over others not upon the idea that you should have concern for them, but rather that by having concern for them you make it more likely that they will have concern for you.

Then, from this you conclude that those who are not capable of having concern for you are therefore not beings for whom who should be concerned.

I may be badly misunderstanding here, however, in which case I apologize and only ask you to show me where I misunderstood.

2 I recognize, by the way, that our moral sense evolved in part due to reciprocal altruism. But just as our desire for sex envolved "for" reproduction, that doesn't suggest that birth control is a bad thing, nor does the above suggest that our moral ideas should be based upon the things that made them selectively advantageous.

3 I don't know that we know that. It may be true, and is certainly true of many animals, but is it true of all forms of non-human life? I wouldn't be surprised if chimpanzees planned for their future, or had some comprehension of their own morality. Those things are hard to test for, but absence of evidence isn't evidence of absence.
(it's not evidence of presence either, but my point is only that we can't use that as a necessary distinction until we know one way or the other).

A good point that I think people really need to consider. :)
:) Proof that a conversation can take place without invective and recriminations.

1SCT (social contract theory) is the notion that we give up rights in order to maintain social order. Those individuals that can enter into the contract are entitled to both the rights and privilages of that contract. And no, it's not that we shouldn't have concern, it's that those who are in the contract are entitled to both the rights and responsibilities. We can still have concern for animals.

2 To argue that something is right because it is natural is obviously wrong. However, I might percieve that something is right or wrong because it is an adaptive trait and/or I was indoctrinated to view that thing as right or wrong. One must still be willing to consider arguments and examine his or her views to better reason morality (if that were not the case in my life I would to this day be against full rights for gays and lesbians and my sense of morality would be very different from what it is now).

3 The premise is provisional. I'm happy to enlarge the circle to give greater consideration to animals like primates and perhaps whales, dolphins and others. I don't have a bright and shining line between humans and all other animals. I tried to make that point when I said "animals I choose to eat".

I think the one area in which I'm in danger of inconsitency is pigs. I don't know if they are capable of episodic memory or to what degree they are sentient but they are clearly very inteligent.
 
"Others"? When we eat carrots we harm them.

Causing harm in and of itself isn't an argument. It's a lone premise that doesn't resolve anything. The question becomes, are there morally relevant differences between humans and carrots or humans and cows that would make it immoral to kill and eat them?

I want to say that on the one-hand you of all people should be familiar with my posting history, and since I've rehearsed this argument over a dozen times, and made the same exact clarifications I am forced to make again now, you could have drawn certain inferences, especially since this is within the context of above-mentioned mental-states... but then again, I am familiar with your posting history and it seems your obtusity is boundless. The only time people ever talk about "harming" carrots -- and for some reason they tend to pick carrots -- is in threads such as this one. In the search for common ground, almost everyone agrees it is possible to harm a cow; the different types of harm and the justifications are contested, of course, but there's overlapping agreement.

While I think it is wrong for an animal to unnecessarily suffer I don't think it is wrong for an animal to die for the purposes of being eaten.

Coercion, violence against others -- particularly those beings capable of experiencing pain -- requires a justification, which is implied in the quote directly above. If we all agree it's wrong for an animal to "unnecessarily suffer," then we need to decide what it means to "unnecessarily suffer," which, as I've no doubt emphasized in the past, is an almost meaningless phrase on its own, and your little sentence above is something of a non sequitur since eating meat is not necessary and meat production (esp. as it stands now) necessarily inflicts suffering.

If you want to say it's just an idea divorced from reality and not really a practical guide for behavior, then it's not quite as bad. However, if you want to say something that justifies meat-eating in the current environment, one that is at least reality-consistent, then I should expect you to say something like, "Yes, there is animal suffering in the production of meat, but I think it's justified." We can say whatever we want about Madeleine Albright, or the allegation that sanctions against Iraq had in fact killed a half-million children, but she was articulating a clear moral view when she claimed the the price was "worth it."

Animals that I choose to eart are not moral agents, they are not capable of entering into a social contract (reciprocal altruism).

This is what I mean by bad arguments that are poorly argued. OK, animals are not moral agents, but neither are children (any potentiality digressions should first address Kevin's above post on chickens and eggs). I further agree animals (and children) are not capable of entering into a social contract. Why on earth you follow this with a "reciprocal altruism" note, of which animals are certainly capable, would make no sense to an alien observer. I am, unfortunately, one of the few who has suffered through your posts, so I know you want to stamp your claims with the imprimatur of science, hence the technical term. Perhaps the same could be said for "social contract," which alienates all of the anti-animal rights people who do not respect social contract theory.

They don't plan for their futures or comprehend their own mortality.

Neither do children (the subtext, in case you missed it, is "how is this morally relevant?")

Animal husbandry provides these animals opportunity that they cannot enjoy in the wild. They are free of predators, statistically assured of surviving their birth, protected from the elements and receive medical attention. From an evolutionary standpoint, being a domesticated animal is to be evolutionary fit.

This is a false comparison because it implicitly assumes these animals would otherwise exist in the wild. Not that it matters, but they are not "free of predators" (do you need a hint). "The evolutionary" post-note adds irrelevant information to an irrelevant argument, and here's an irrelevant aside: the same observation could come from The Machines in The Matrix.

So, to paraphrase you, any person capable of basic reasoning can, if only for a moment, put herself in another's shoes: "Hmmmmm... this guy has the belief that killing animals is not morally wrong. I do not agree with that idea, but I can see the logical consequences that mistaken premise entails."

I've been there. The main problem with the vast majority of meat-eaters is that their views toward animals are internally inconsistent. So, let's take you, for example. In an earlier thread you claimed gorillas should have rights. Here you say "Animals that I choose to eart are not moral agents," which suggests there are animals you choose not to eat who are moral agents. I am curious to learn what characteristics gorillas possess that allows them to be admitted into your moral community -- how, specifically, they manage to leap through all of the hoops above: social contracts, moral agency, coming to grips with their own mortality, planning for the future, and so on.

-------------------

Garcia:
Do you eventually want there to be laws that make meat eating murder?

I would like to see killing animals for food outlawed. This would require broad consensus because without a consensus you'll never pass such laws, much less enforce them. Moreover, I suspect that if a society does ever pass such a law most of the population will probably eat meat, but that meat would be grown in lab. It's easy to do the right thing when doing the right thing is easy (which partially explains why some people are open to the idea of granting ape rights because it requires no real sacrifice).

---------
Roborama:
It's more like a robber saying "I'm not doing anything wrong by robbing people", and having a good and consistent argument (albeit one with whose premises you disagree). That doesn't make him an idiot, though I agree that one of you is wrong. (and perhaps both).

You're missing the point. He can certainly say what you wrote above, or adjust circumstances, "It's OK to rob rich people." But that's his premise. If anyone has a chance of arguing this issue at a basic level, then she should be able to put herself in an alternative frame of mind.
 
The only time people ever talk about "harming" carrots...
The point about the carrots is to demonstrate the weakness of the premise. The weakness stands.

If we all agree it's wrong for an animal to "unnecessarily suffer," then we need to decide what it means to "unnecessarily suffer,"...
What I think of as unnecessary suffering is likely to differ from what you think of as unnecessary.

They don't plan for their futures or comprehend their own mortality.
Neither do children (the subtext, in case you missed it, is "how is this morally relevant?"
A domesticated animal doesn't worry about the possibility that it will die (having had children I can tell you from a very young age they do both, in this instance you should use infant). Killing an animal doesn't rob it of something that we perceive as intrinsically important to the human condition.

OK, animals are not moral agents, but neither are children...
Children don't have the same rights and responsibilities as adults.

Given that most people have an evolved adaptive trait to protect children and thus perceive killing and eating children as immoral then I doubt that society is going to adopt that view. I certainly don't see it as moral and I don't think there is any danger of that. I've stated that SCT doesn't preclude giving consideration to those who aren't members of the contract. I'm willing to give primates and other animals the same consideration (perhaps limited rights) as children.

This is a false comparison because it implicitly assumes these animals would otherwise exist in the wild.
But these animals, as Dennet points out, do exist as aphids do for ants. They benefit humans and humans benefit from them. So what if they don't exist in the wild? It doesn't obviate the point.

Not that it matters, but they are not "free of predators" (do you need a hint).
They are free of predators on a day to day basis until we decide to kill and eat them which is a considerably greater age than in the wild. If you compare animals in the wild to domesticated animals you will note a considerable difference. Wild animals are often flighty and afraid. They are often chased by predators and live in fear.

I think you knew what I meant but I'm happy to clarify.

In an earlier thread you claimed gorillas should have rights.
I'm not sure I did but it's possible. Gorillas and other primates are capable of higher levels of thought and self awareness. If greater protection or consideration is better than "rights" then fine but I don't really care about the fine point you want to put on it. I could be persuaded either way. As I said earlier, I could be persuaded to forgo eating pigs.

Here you say "Animals that I choose to eart are not moral agents," which suggests there are animals you choose not to eat who are moral agents.
Poorly worded on my part. There are no animals that I know of that can enter into a social contract with humans. However there are animals with higher functions and I would be willing to give them consideration that I wouldn't other animals.

I've been there.
I wish I had been there to see it.
 
Last edited:
This is a false comparison because it implicitly assumes these animals would otherwise exist in the wild.

And this is why I disregard you animal rights folk: you'll willingly do away with whole species to achieve your intended utopian world where humans are the only creatures on the planet who have to play by the utopian rules.
 
Not a cop-out, since I've already stated pretty clearly that I don't consider eating meat immoral.
Then answer that first. Or should I treat it as U.S. law is; versioned?

As for the rest, you work very diligently at ignoring the point and continuing to make the issue about meat alone, when it isn't. It's about all foods, and while you assert that people don't care and just want cheap food, that's really beside the point because the food isn't going to be any more expensive if the markeet is tailored to the change.
Sources? Proof? Remember, there are more than 5 billion people on the planet. On average needing 2k Calories a day. Mind the transport issues etc. as well.


You keep insisting that the care is not there, and yet you admit that there's a huge difference in behavior in the consumption.
Yep and I even stated that reason; cost and maybe cholesterol (or other 'what's healthy now hype'.
Don't ignore that.

Do you not see that the situation you're describing-- lowered consumption in general terms
Not general terms. Meat.

, more required disclosure by producers of food-- is exactly what I'm aiming for? Maybe it's not the case where you live, but considering the very slight difference in cost between the humane meat farmers here in the States and the mass-production meat, that slight change alone would level the playing field and may even possibly give advantage to the smaller farmers, but either way there would be a net result of lowered consumption overall.
And looking at a world of 5+ Billion people, that's just stroking your own 'male chicken'.

Anyhoo, despite your saying that people don't care, I'm saying that doesn't necessarily matter. I'm saying the distribution model for food-- making sure people get their food cheaply and do with it what they want, whether either of us think they care or not-- is going to be the model that makes a difference, and that model would have to include all foodstuffs and not just meat. Making it just about meat is just a tactic that the PETA-folk and other agenda-driven organizations use to ignore trying to find a workable solution. I'm not suggesting turning everyone into a health-conscious, animal-and-environment-friendly, ethic-shopping yuppie. I'm suggesting quite the opposite, actually-- steer the supply side of the market and let efficiencies recreate themselves with the understanding that companies producing crap would have to list "we have crap in our stuff" on the boxes they sell in markets. You may not think that's a huge deal, but I guarantee that when such a doozy hits the biggest consumption market on the planet, the technologies for efficiency will start to change.

You have probably never tried to calculate the transport issues involved in all of this?
While crops can be grown only on fertile grounds, you can easily build a shack somewhere cram in the animals and feed them ****.

In other words, I'm not counting on people caring how the food they eat is made.

Odd, I seem to remember you having made an argument to the contrary, the labeling thingy?

I'm counting on the producers caring how their products are viewed, and considering how much time and effort companies put into image I'm saying that this is a more effective method than trying to change everyone's mind on the consumer side. I actually agree that people want what they want and have other things they'd rather put thought into.
Well, that is not going to work either. In the U.S. this probably happens as well, but it has either not hit the news yet or they are really good at hiding it.

For some reason, it is allowed in some countries that you increase the weight of meat with water. To make sure the water does not run out, they lace it with protein.

Muslems don't want to eat pork. But the protein is made from ground up little piggies.
So. The label says that the meat is Halal, but kind of forgets to mention that it is made heavier by injecting it with pork-protein laced water.

Next, this news hits the media. What happens? Nothing.

And all and any of your good efforts are totally in vain when (not if) the rest of the emerging economies start shifting their food around.

We will be were we started.

Just don't think that going on a crusade in the U.S. means anything at all.
 
Last edited:
This is what I mean by bad arguments that are poorly argued.
I doubt that there exists such an animal as an argument that I could make that would be considered by you as good or argued well. And not because I'm incapable but because your contempt of me is so great. You rarely pass up any opportunity to deride or belittle. Anything that could even be construed as a compliment is backhanded.

I'm not complainging. Just pointing out that like the boy that cried wolf, there is little integrity to your all too self important opinions. I don't think anyone even cares anymore. At this point it's only for your benifit. You once compared yourself to a Daily Show corespondent. Thing is, the folks at the Daily show are capable of self-effacement.

I'll give you this though, you're not as caustic as you used to be. It's an improvement and yes, I did notice.
 
Just out of curiosity, what do you think should happen? Do you eventually want there to be laws that make meat eating murder?

I can't speak for the animal rights kooks, but if such laws were passed, it would justify taking up arms to overthrow whatever government passed them.

All this talk of philosophy and the nature of morality is just pushing the air around, it accomplishes and ultimately means little. But freedom is something that is always worth fighting for.
 
But freedom is something that is always worth fighting for.

My freedom is not your freedom; my freedom might be that I want to bash in your head...

So we always will be fighting I guess :)

Edit: but I do agree with you :)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom