GreNME
Philosopher
- Joined
- Sep 16, 2007
- Messages
- 8,276
Cop-out.
But let's go with it. I suspect it will be very americanised.
Not a cop-out, since I've already stated pretty clearly that I don't consider eating meat immoral.
As for the rest, you work very diligently at ignoring the point and continuing to make the issue about meat alone, when it isn't. It's about all foods, and while you assert that people don't care and just want cheap food, that's really beside the point because the food isn't going to be any more expensive if the markeet is tailored to the change.
I keep trying to explain to you, that all the rational arguments in the world do not mean a thing in this story.
I will therefore, give you a small recap:
- Outside the U.S. there are lots of countries that not only show what is in the food by labels, but also by education in schools, actually by almost any means necessary short of stupid violence (tantrum style).
- And the majority of the people do not care. They wholly accept vegetarians and/or vegans, and a lot even cut down on meat intake (mostly cost and cholesterol as a reason), but they do not care.
You keep insisting that the care is not there, and yet you admit that there's a huge difference in behavior in the consumption. Do you not see that the situation you're describing-- lowered consumption in general terms, more required disclosure by producers of food-- is exactly what I'm aiming for? Maybe it's not the case where you live, but considering the very slight difference in cost between the humane meat farmers here in the States and the mass-production meat, that slight change alone would level the playing field and may even possibly give advantage to the smaller farmers, but either way there would be a net result of lowered consumption overall.
Anyhoo, despite your saying that people don't care, I'm saying that doesn't necessarily matter. I'm saying the distribution model for food-- making sure people get their food cheaply and do with it what they want, whether either of us think they care or not-- is going to be the model that makes a difference, and that model would have to include all foodstuffs and not just meat. Making it just about meat is just a tactic that the PETA-folk and other agenda-driven organizations use to ignore trying to find a workable solution. I'm not suggesting turning everyone into a health-conscious, animal-and-environment-friendly, ethic-shopping yuppie. I'm suggesting quite the opposite, actually-- steer the supply side of the market and let efficiencies recreate themselves with the understanding that companies producing crap would have to list "we have crap in our stuff" on the boxes they sell in markets. You may not think that's a huge deal, but I guarantee that when such a doozy hits the biggest consumption market on the planet, the technologies for efficiency will start to change.
In other words, I'm not counting on people caring how the food they eat is made. I'm counting on the producers caring how their products are viewed, and considering how much time and effort companies put into image I'm saying that this is a more effective method than trying to change everyone's mind on the consumer side. I actually agree that people want what they want and have other things they'd rather put thought into.