Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

I was arguing within the context of the thread, which is about the ethics or morality of eating meat. I haven't seen anything convincing yet. It appears to me that most of the moral arguments against eating meat are based on anthropomorphizing of other species of animals.
 
Last edited:
AFAIK there is, scientifically nothing really wrong with veganists and vegetarianism; I now live for over half a year in India and a pretty good percentage of people is vegan.

There are probably more vegetarians/vegans in India than the whole of the population of the U.S.

I do not see them really lacking in the health department (the ones that do not drink the Ganges water, or do other weird diseasy stuff).

So it still comes down to:

a) is it immoral? If so, by who's standards?
b) Does the person that has to 'convert' really agree with that standard? If so why? Simply because it being 'immoral' is not enough in this world.

Convince me of a) and then of b) and I will refrain from eating meat when I return.

Just to add; I am a voluntary vegetarian over here (with some KFC and Keema every once in a while) out of respect to my hosts, nought else.
 
I was arguing within the context of the thread, which is about the ethics or morality of eating meat. I haven't seen anything convincing yet. It appears to me that most of the moral arguments against eating meat are based on anthropomorphizing of other species of animals.

Fair enough. I just didn't want the discussion to turn into challenging a vegetarian or vegan on the sensibility of their choice, since there are plenty of worthwhile reasons for doing so.
 
Yep. I probably eat too much meat myself, health wise. But it's so good. When I go to Russia, I'll slow down on the meat. They don't do good beef there. Crap, they don't do good veggies there either. I guess I will be eating lots of pork and salmon.
 
Yep. I probably eat too much meat myself, health wise. But it's so good. When I go to Russia, I'll slow down on the meat. They don't do good beef there. Crap, they don't do good veggies there either. I guess I will be eating lots of pork and salmon.
Yeah, have to wash it down with lots of 'vvvodka' :D
 
I was arguing within the context of the thread, which is about the ethics or morality of eating meat. I haven't seen anything convincing yet. It appears to me that most of the moral arguments against eating meat are based on anthropomorphizing of other species of animals.


That's because there isn't anything wrong with eating meat and this is coming from a vegan :D

Well to be honest I'm not considered a vegan because I eat honey but I guess I'm mostly vegan.

I do however have a problem with animal cruelty but you can get your meat without the cruelty in my opinion.
 
That's because there isn't anything wrong with eating meat and this is coming from a vegan :D

Well to be honest I'm not considered a vegan because I eat honey but I guess I'm mostly vegan.

I do however have a problem with animal cruelty but you can get your meat without the cruelty in my opinion.

Well, that is where the real problem arises and I seriously want to hear an answer...

You can get meat without the cruelty...*if* you are prepared to pay the price.

But since the majority of people do not want to or can not pay more for their meat, it comes down to 'efficiency'.

And efficiency means doing away with any kind of respect towards the animal.

I would dare to wager that most meat is not begotten in an animal friendly way.

But that is just my biggest point, which has been evaded either because I like to clown around, or because there really is no answer to it.

Only a few animals for the few wealthy-enough people on the planet are being slaughtered without cruelty or without copulation-ups(I got reprimanded for not masking completely) that make the animal have a horrible last few minutes of life.

I am one of those idiots that actually went to see a 'factory like' slaughterhouse.

Knowing this, I still want to eat meat. I still like to eat meat.

Now, here comes my question (again):

a) Is this immoral? If so, by whose standards?
b) Why should I hold myself to those standards?
 
Animal cruelty is an entirely different subject. There are methods of slaughtering animals that are humane.
 
Now, here comes my question (again):

a) Is this immoral? If so, by whose standards?
b) Why should I hold myself to those standards?


I can only answer for myself, no I do not think it's immoral to eat the less expensive meat. Yes there is cruelty involved and that is why I don't eat it but that's my choice and I am not going to judge anyone who chooses to eat it or try to stop them from doing so. I don't think anyone should be held to those standards.
 
I can only answer for myself, no I do not think it's immoral to eat the less expensive meat. Yes there is cruelty involved and that is why I don't eat it but that's my choice and I am not going to judge anyone who chooses to eat it or try to stop them from doing so. I don't think anyone should be held to those standards.

So at least we could live in peace... now the little shouters from earlier in the thread...
 
It means arguably yes, arguably no. It depends on what you define as "what we need."

I didn't define anything rather, asked if vegans were self-supporting in diet and the answer appears to be no, per the following;

What are your thoughts on a vegan diet?
Asked by anonymous on Nov 30, 2008 in Nutrition


As a vegan and a nutrition student, I would like to know what you think of a vegan diet. Obviously, I support it but not everyone does from the nutritional standpoint. I've read studies that go both ways but would like a more clear answer on what is good about it and what should be avoided? There are vegans that are too skinny, some that are overweight, and plenty of other people saying you don't get enough protein or quality nutrients that are provided in any other diet.


Answer
I think vegans should plan their diets carefully and take a multivitamin-mineral supplement. Vegan diets eliminate all animal foods including meat, fish, poultry, eggs, dairy products, honey and gelatin. A vegan diet can be nutritionally sound, but when poorly planned, it may be deficient in protein, calcium, and vitamins D, B2 (riboflavin) and B12. Vegans obtain protein from legumes, nuts, seeds, grains, vegetables, and soy foods. Vitamin B12 is best acquired from fermented soy products, fortified yeast extracts and breakfast cereals, and calcium should also come from fortified foods because plant calcium is not well absorbed. Vegans should spend time outdoors to get vitamin D from the sun. All vegetarian diets are associated with a lower risk for chronic disease.


http://caloriecount.about.com/thoughts-vegan-diet-q3429

The point is in a world w/o synthetic vitamins to supplement such a lifestyle the vegan would appear to be at a serious disadvantage. Sounds like an artificial existence to me.

Also, to get back OT/OP the core dietary mantra of PETA contradicts their animal rights posture when you account for all the ecological destruction (aka: row crops) required to grow enough food to sustain a unilateral vegan culture for everyone. At the end of the day, it comes down to their having to rationalize such much akin to their position taken after being busted out for euthanizing animals by the hundreds/thousands.

Ideology can be a rather mercurical concept.
 
Well, that is where the real problem arises and I seriously want to hear an answer...

You can get meat without the cruelty...*if* you are prepared to pay the price.

But since the majority of people do not want to or can not pay more for their meat, it comes down to 'efficiency'.

And efficiency means doing away with any kind of respect towards the animal.

I would dare to wager that most meat is not begotten in an animal friendly way.

But that is just my biggest point, which has been evaded either because I like to clown around, or because there really is no answer to it.

Only a few animals for the few wealthy-enough people on the planet are being slaughtered without cruelty or without copulation-ups(I got reprimanded for not masking completely) that make the animal have a horrible last few minutes of life.

I am one of those idiots that actually went to see a 'factory like' slaughterhouse.

I know what you're talking about. However, the issue isn't quite so simple. Much like how corn farming has exploded since the 1950's, mass meat raising and slaughter has grown nearly exponentially since the 1950's. That's not directly due to population growth, but instead to the facts that 1) more and more products started using corn (and corn by-products) and meat (and meat 'stuff'), and 2) the companies mass-producing things that made use of those things marketed like crazy. Add the growth of the fast-food industry as well. Essentially, when it came to meat and corn (and a few other plants, notably soy and potatoes), what started as an industry looking to make things more expedient became an overproductive beast. Now, there are reasons for this growth and not all of those reasons are bad (or even questionable), but the end result are the slaughterhouses and overly-engineered crops in the US that we have today. I say "over-engineered" lightly, because the reality is that the lack of any regulations requiring these markets to list what they've done and what types of engineered food materials they put into food makes it difficult to quantify completely. While American products using the raw foodstuffs we utilize are used all over the place in the world, you'd find that the US can't even give away things like our genetically-manipulated corn seeds to starving countries, because they won't take it-- not because they're afraid of the woo-ish "genetically modified such-n-such" ideas, but because they don't want to risk the economic disaster that accidental cross-pollenization with crops they export to European markets would cause.

But anyway, what we have in the US are foods with such highly-engineered raw food materials (over-injected meat, genetically-engineered corn in practically everything, genetically-engineered soy in practically everything else) that even the current use of "organic" as a designation of more earth-n-animal-friendly products has become diluted to a large degree. I'd posit that more people would prefer actually earth-n-animal-friendly products if they knew there were products out there and could tell the difference, but the things that are out there are few and far between, usually only found in yuppie-upper-middle-class food markets and not in your local Walmart or Target or convenience store. Heck, butcher shops are practically a thing of the past, and the ability to get reasonably-priced meats that were raised healthier was definitely tied to the existence of butcher shops before the meat market turned into a mega-industry.

Knowing this, I still want to eat meat. I still like to eat meat.

Now, here comes my question (again):

a) Is this immoral? If so, by whose standards?
b) Why should I hold myself to those standards?

Instead of answering those questions for you, I'll suggest an alternative:

Instate regulations that would require companies making this food to display which of their products are made with certain methods-- genetically modified corn used for corn syrup would have to be listed separately from non-modified corn, meat grown in different types of farms would have to be listed separately. Make it more difficult for the misleading commercials showing "happy cows" and nonsense like that, requiring at least a bit more truth in the advertising (this is still advertising, so don't expect complete candor). Have these different products out there actually list what types of meat, what types of corn, what types of soy, what types of other stuff they're putting into what people are getting in the package, and then let the market start doing its thing. Like I said, I posit that more people would start picking the healthier, more humanely-made products if they knew there was a viable alternative, and the only way to ensure a viable alternative is present (without actually forcing people) is to have the requirement of disclosure on the supply-side of things. Right now the level of disclosure is ridiculously low in the US, so that even the 'organic' milk I buy doesn't really necessitate that the cows weren't fed engineered corn-feed or that they aren't in pasture for long enough to 'qualify' as organic and then stuffed into cow-cubicles (cow-bicles?) for milking. Require disclosure by the companies producing the stuff we eat, and chances are likely that people will vote with their pocketbooks on which they would prefer these companies to make more of-- right now that's definitely not the case, which places an unbalanced onus on the healthier food producers to try to justify their costs.

But, see, then we get into a whole `nother line of discussion away from just the eating of meat. In fact, it would be unreasonable to not include some staples from the vegetable side of the food industry, since the problem of industrial food company disclosure isn't just with the meat market. Also, this issue has economic factors that would inevitably result in at least a period of fluctuating prices and arguments that such requirements hamper the capitalism these companies are engaged in and obviously benefitting from (that doesn't mean I'd agree with such a claim, but it would be made). The reality is that a discussion on the horrible conditions of the meat industry and what alternatives are available would eventually include practically all of the farming industries, which means agriculture as well as livestock, and pitting agriculture against raising livestock as the framework of the conversation-- a tactic attempted a few times in this thread-- is a false dichotomy presented to hammer home an opinion rather than logically and practically look at the problems involved.

Dammit, I know there's a book on this subject, as I've read some stuff on it before. There's so much as far as detail and information on it that there's got to be a better way to explain than what I'm fumbling along with. Still, does any of what I'm saying make sense?
 
The point is in a world w/o synthetic vitamins to supplement such a lifestyle the vegan would appear to be at a serious disadvantage. Sounds like an artificial existence to me.

Also, to get back OT/OP the core dietary mantra of PETA contradicts their animal rights posture when you account for all the ecological destruction (aka: row crops) required to grow enough food to sustain a unilateral vegan culture for everyone. At the end of the day, it comes down to their having to rationalize such much akin to their position taken after being busted out for euthanizing animals by the hundreds/thousands.

Ideology can be a rather mercurical concept.

The link you cited was all well and good, but not authoritative. As I said, in some cases supplements are used, and in other cases (see realpaladin's post) they are not and the people using the diet are plenty healthy. You're correct that ideology can be rather mercurial, but what I'm urging is that you not assume that there is going to be a definitive stance on the viability of a vegan diet without supplements. That's an unreasonable expectation due simply on the differences in body types that people have.

I, for example, would atrophy with a very low protein diet, so eating meat has definite advantages to me, but that doesn't preclude a highly-vegetarian diet at times either (though a vegan diet would likely not be recommended for me). On the other hand, a diet high in red meat (in my case) has disadvantages as well that I need to keep highly aware of, so it's not like steak sandwiches would be my optimal diet. It's very often very relative to body type, metabolism, and any medical conditions you may or may not have.
 
That's because there isn't anything wrong with eating meat and this is coming from a vegan :D

Well to be honest I'm not considered a vegan because I eat honey but I guess I'm mostly vegan.

I do however have a problem with animal cruelty but you can get your meat without the cruelty in my opinion.

I can only answer for myself, no I do not think it's immoral to eat the less expensive meat. Yes there is cruelty involved and that is why I don't eat it but that's my choice and I am not going to judge anyone who chooses to eat it or try to stop them from doing so. I don't think anyone should be held to those standards.

Good point. You describe very succinctly how you maintain your own standards while accepting the relativity of those standards. Thanks for being a voice of reason in a thread where there's a lot of yelling. :)
 
Good point. You describe very succinctly how you maintain your own standards while accepting the relativity of those standards. Thanks for being a voice of reason in a thread where there's a lot of yelling. :)

:D
 
I
Instead of answering those questions for you, I'll suggest an alternative:
Cop-out.

But let's go with it. I suspect it will be very americanised.

Instate regulations that would require companies making this food to display which of their products are made with certain methods-- genetically modified corn used for corn syrup would have to be listed separately from non-modified corn, meat grown in different types of farms would have to be listed separately.

Don't visit Dutch supermarkets a lot, huh? We are there for a while already.

Make it more difficult for the misleading commercials showing "happy cows" and nonsense like that, requiring at least a bit more truth in the advertising (this is still advertising, so don't expect complete candor). Have these different products out there actually list what types of meat, what types of corn, what types of soy, what types of other stuff they're putting into what people are getting in the package, and then let the market start doing its thing. Like I said, I posit that more people would start picking the healthier, more humanely-made products if they knew there was a viable alternative, and the only way to ensure a viable alternative is present (without actually forcing people) is to have the requirement of disclosure on the supply-side of things.

You posit, but do not look outside the U.S. huh? The answer is... it did not help at all!


Right now the level of disclosure is ridiculously low in the US, so that even the 'organic' milk I buy doesn't really necessitate that the cows weren't fed engineered corn-feed or that they aren't in pasture for long enough to 'qualify' as organic and then stuffed into cow-cubicles (cow-bicles?) for milking. Require disclosure by the companies producing the stuff we eat, and chances are likely that people will vote with their pocketbooks on which they would prefer these companies to make more of-- right now that's definitely not the case, which places an unbalanced onus on the healthier food producers to try to justify their costs.

Again, extremely U.S. centric. Look a bit around you. The EU is way ahead of you. Doesn't help. People want cheap meat. And they don't give a hootenanny on how it got on the shelves.

They all have seen the documentaries, we have a 'Party for the Animals' in Government, and all the food is labeled. And they still do not give a rats behind.

But, see, then we get into a whole `nother line of discussion away from just the eating of meat.

You started by not answering my questions and going for an alternative.


In fact, it would be unreasonable to not include some staples from the vegetable side of the food industry, since the problem of industrial food company disclosure isn't just with the meat market.

We have a government sponsored website with all the grisly details on how the meat is produced. With all the reports on GM food. With anything you ever do not want to know about your calories.

We have a tv-show 'Keuringsdienst van Waarden', which is a wordplay on 'Keuringsdienst van Waren' (our FDA) and 'Waarden' (values).

That tv-show is quite popular and it shows the things you are on about (next to cheap labour in China etc.)

And when asked what and why people buy something in the supermarket it is simple: It has to be cheap, too bad a cow wasn't happy but I want to be happy at my dinner table tonight and I want to buy a bottle of cheap wine as well.

The 'education' part of this story is an Urban Legend.

Also, this issue has economic factors that would inevitably result in at least a period of fluctuating prices and arguments that such requirements hamper the capitalism these companies are engaged in and obviously benefitting from (that doesn't mean I'd agree with such a claim, but it would be made).

Nobody gives a darn about the companies, as long as the stuff they produce is cheap.


The reality is that a discussion on the horrible conditions of the meat industry and what alternatives are available would eventually include practically all of the farming industries, which means agriculture as well as livestock, and pitting agriculture against raising livestock as the framework of the conversation-- a tactic attempted a few times in this thread-- is a false dichotomy presented to hammer home an opinion rather than logically and practically look at the problems involved.

We. Do. Not. Care. What. You. Pit. Against. What.

People. Want. Cheap. Meat. Because. It. Tastes. Good. And. It. Is. Cheap. Because. The. Animals. Are. Slaughtered. Efficiently.

Get that through to your brain.

Discussing alternatives and yadayada is all nice when you get some educated people and some people that have a little more money to spend or a little more scruples, but it does not mean a thing when you talk to the people that want a pork-chop on the table or a little steak once in a while.

These people do not want to pay more. Period.

And if you really want to talk alternatives and make less animals suffer, go to countries like India and China, or take the continent of Afrika on. That will get you numbers (most probably it will get you killed for trying to put animals anywhere near humans).

Dammit, I know there's a book on this subject, as I've read some stuff on it before. There's so much as far as detail and information on it that there's got to be a better way to explain than what I'm fumbling along with. Still, does any of what I'm saying make sense?

I keep trying to explain to you, that all the rational arguments in the world do not mean a thing in this story.

I will therefore, give you a small recap:

- Outside the U.S. there are lots of countries that not only show what is in the food by labels, but also by education in schools, actually by almost any means necessary short of stupid violence (tantrum style).
- And the majority of the people do not care. They wholly accept vegetarians and/or vegans, and a lot even cut down on meat intake (mostly cost and cholesterol as a reason), but they do not care.

To quote a friend while he was eating a steak and musing on it's life:
"Well, he shouldn't have reïncarnated as a cow then!"
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom