GreNME
Philosopher
- Joined
- Sep 16, 2007
- Messages
- 8,276
I haven't really followed his "behaviour", to be honest, and just skim-read the last few pages, so I don't know what you're referring to.
Nevertheless, your reply stood out as, quite clearly, the arguments KL cited are all used, more than once each, during the rest of the thread. Your accusation of "strawman" doesn't stack up - that's all I'm saying. It is quite clear that some posters here - yourself not included - use taste, fallacious appeals to evolution and / or laziness as "reasons" for their dietary choices.
You're being intentionally evasive. First: I used no appeal to evolution as a moral justification, I pointed out that the arguments claiming that eating meat had nothing to do with our development are wrong. Twisting what I said into something I did not is precisely an example of the intellectual dishonesty Kevin has been engaged in throughout the thread.
I don't think a side discussion of Kevin's rhetorical foibles is going to be productive. If you are interested in specific examples of Kevin's using strawmen arguments, more than one person has pointed out specific cases throughout the thread, including myself.