Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

I haven't really followed his "behaviour", to be honest, and just skim-read the last few pages, so I don't know what you're referring to.

Nevertheless, your reply stood out as, quite clearly, the arguments KL cited are all used, more than once each, during the rest of the thread. Your accusation of "strawman" doesn't stack up - that's all I'm saying. It is quite clear that some posters here - yourself not included - use taste, fallacious appeals to evolution and / or laziness as "reasons" for their dietary choices.

You're being intentionally evasive. First: I used no appeal to evolution as a moral justification, I pointed out that the arguments claiming that eating meat had nothing to do with our development are wrong. Twisting what I said into something I did not is precisely an example of the intellectual dishonesty Kevin has been engaged in throughout the thread.

I don't think a side discussion of Kevin's rhetorical foibles is going to be productive. If you are interested in specific examples of Kevin's using strawmen arguments, more than one person has pointed out specific cases throughout the thread, including myself.
 
You're being intentionally evasive. First: I used no appeal to evolution as a moral justification, I pointed out that the arguments claiming that eating meat had nothing to do with our development are wrong. Twisting what I said into something I did not is precisely an example of the intellectual dishonesty Kevin has been engaged in throughout the thread.

Did you see where I said "yourself NOT included", Gren? :rolleyes:

Nevertheless, you cannot call arguments "strawmen" that have actually been made with a straight face by numerous posters in this forum. If you think they're bad arguments - and they ARE bad arguments - take it up with those making them. But don't have a go at KL just for pointing out that a great number of people have a massive blindspot in their scepticism when it comes to what's for dinner.
 
Did you see where I said "yourself NOT included", Gren? :rolleyes:

I misread. My apologies.

Nevertheless, you cannot call arguments "strawmen" that have actually been made with a straight face by numerous posters in this forum. If you think they're bad arguments - and they ARE bad arguments - take it up with those making them. But don't have a go at KL just for pointing out that a great number of people have a massive blindspot in their scepticism when it comes to what's for dinner.

As I pointed out, Kevin has used them as blind spots, often in using arguments some people have made against others who haven't, but also in completely twisting what has been said into things that haven't, my comments about evolutionary development included. What makes it a strawman is not that no one has ever used such an argument, but that Kevin picks and chooses (incorrectly) when to argue against them.

I'd also argue that the choice for eating food isn't a matter of a skeptical blind spot, but a refusal to accept that eating meat is immoral. You could argue that the choice to refuse considering it immoral is a skeptical blind spot, but as RandFan, myself, and a few others have argued this is a matter that is relative to the values of the individual and the social unit. It's a matter of differing moral values, not a blind spot. The argument that it ought not be that way has, thus far, not been forwarded in any realistic fashion by Kevin and instead he's taken to appealing to (a self-appointed) moral superiority as the basis for his argument.
 
You could argue that the choice to refuse considering it immoral is a skeptical blind spot, but as RandFan, myself, and a few others have argued this is a matter that is relative to the values of the individual and the social unit. It's a matter of differing moral values, not a blind spot. The argument that it ought not be that way has, thus far, not been forwarded in any realistic fashion by Kevin and instead he's taken to appealing to (a self-appointed) moral superiority as the basis for his argument.
Well said.
 
I don't think I've ever seen either of you two articulate why diet is not a moral issue (in fact, I seem to remember both of you making moral arguments against animal cruelty).

For the sake of clarity - and the avoidance of strawmen - would you mind explaining why your dietary choices are not moral issues?
 
...a great number of people have a massive blindspot in their scepticism when it comes to what's for dinner.

Wow, that's an interesting one. Is the implication here that anyone who is consistently sceptical will by necessity come to the same conclusion on the meat-eating debate? If so it's rather a massive claim methinks! Doesn't it assume we all start off with the same premises when it comes to our source/s of morality?

Just a thought :)

BDd

Edit: I hadn't seen GreNME/RandFan's response before posting - but my point is not exactly the same so I'll leave it.
 
Last edited:
For the sake of clarity - and the avoidance of strawmen - would you mind explaining why your dietary choices are not moral issues?
I can't speak for GreNME but I don't claim that dietary choices can't be moral issues. Swift's modest proposal springs to mind.

I think that what GreNME said was that having considered the arguments we do not find that eating meat is necassarily immoral (it can be). That's my sentiment anyway.
 
I don't think I've ever seen either of you two articulate why diet is not a moral issue (in fact, I seem to remember both of you making moral arguments against animal cruelty).

For the sake of clarity - and the avoidance of strawmen - would you mind explaining why your dietary choices are not moral issues?

Easy. I am a human being. Not a Vulcan or a Borg. Rationality has it's limits regarding it's reach into my life.
 
I don't think I've ever seen either of you two articulate why diet is not a moral issue (in fact, I seem to remember both of you making moral arguments against animal cruelty).

For the sake of clarity - and the avoidance of strawmen - would you mind explaining why your dietary choices are not moral issues?

What? You obviously mean dietary choice regarding eating meat, but I'm not saying that what I eat doesn't have a moral value. I'm saying that the values are applied differently and to different things in my case. Like I stated many pages back, I feel that there are very logical and reasonably moral reasons for lowering consumption of meat, not only for the ability to better improve the conditions for livestock but also to minimize the ecological toll (keep in mind, I'm into conservationism) and quite possibly to lower greenhouse emissions (though I'm not 100% on that last one). The value system I apply to it doesn't have a problem with the death, but instead on the waste, and I'd agree that the current system for industrial food (with both meat and plant foodstuffs) is horrendously wasteful.

There's more as far as details and gradation within the value system, but if I had to give a quick nutshell that pretty much works.
 
I don't think I've ever seen either of you two articulate why diet is not a moral issue (in fact, I seem to remember both of you making moral arguments against animal cruelty).

For the sake of clarity - and the avoidance of strawmen - would you mind explaining why your dietary choices are not moral issues?

Did anyone ever say they weren't?

I'm pretty this discussion at some point encompassed cannibalism as well as eating horses and dogs. These are all dietary choices we make on moral grounds.

What I have issue with is someone saying that because I won't eat a toddler, then I shouldn't eat a pig. Morality doesn't work that way. It's not an either/or choice, it's a more/less choice. Immoral is an arbitrary line drawn when something contains so little morality that it becomes intolerable.

We do this with every single moral issue. Every single one. In this case, we draw the line at animals we consider companions.
 
I can't speak for them specifically, but in most cases it has to do with familiarity, in the empathetic family->social group->larger society sense. People have a strong capacity for empathy, and animals that we view as companions can cross over into the logical realm (even though not the biological one) of 'family' or 'friend', and thus have a different value than an animal that doesn't hold such a designation.

I only say that because I'd admit that I consider my dogs 'family' under such terms.
 
Question

I understand that vegans must take supplements to their daily diet in order to survive. Is that understanding an accurate position?
 
Some vegans do. Others are able to sufficiently vary their dietary intake in order to get pretty much what they need.
 
I understand that vegans must take supplements to their daily diet in order to survive. Is that understanding an accurate position?
Laura Dern is a famous case of a vegan who was told on doctors orders to get some animal protein in her diet.

If you are only interested in an answer then let me google that for you.

Otherwise I would agree with GreNME, *"pretty much".

*Enough to survive and otherwise be healthy.
 

Because.

Seriously, that's the only answer that matters.

ETA: To be more clear and a bit less snarky, the line is drawn that way because most people agree that that is where the line should be drawn for reasons brought up by GreNME. But my point is that it doesn't matter where the line is drawn, because 1) morality isn't really a particularly strong control and 2) it's going to be arbitrary anyway, by it's very nature.
 
Last edited:
For the sake of clarity - and the avoidance of strawmen - would you mind explaining why your dietary choices are not moral issues?

Since the status quo is that eating meat is not considered immoral by the vast majority of the public, it is the the burden of the "anti-meat" people to convince everyone else that it is immoral. I've yet to see a convincing argument, let along a rational from the anti-meat crowd.

So far, they've simply been getting most of the meat eaters to defend eating meat instead. It's sort of like Creationists getting scientists to defend evolution instead of Creationists actually showing why their method is scientific.
 
So far, they've simply been getting most of the meat eaters to defend eating meat instead. It's sort of like Creationists getting scientists to defend evolution instead of Creationists actually showing why their method is scientific.

To be fair, there are reasonable reasons for a vegetarian diet, depending on conditions. There are even weight-loss and medical reasons for some such moderated diets (I believe gout can be relieved some with a vegetarian diet). It's not all just woo and claptrap. As far as arguments on moral superiority, though, I'd say that your mileage is going to vary on the value therein.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom