Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

Really? How so?
Unless I were 'unstable' to begin with you can not rationalize me into a guilt-complex when I enjoy my next Whopper or Quarterpounder.

Same goes for the other way around; unless you were unstable to begin with noboday can rationalize you out of 'finding it immoral that people eat meat'.

Nutshelled the whole story for ya.

Continuing, in my book, just means you either have too much spare time on your hands or rather use discussion as a substitute for action to soothe your own guilt-complex.
 
Continuing, in my book, just means you either have too much spare time on your hands or rather use discussion as a substitute for action to soothe your own guilt-complex.

So why do you post? Other than the sorts of ego-sustaining reasons that I've previously attributed to Kevin_Lowe?
 
If you think the difference between living a "normal" versus "vegan" or "vegetarian" lifestyle only requires a 30 minute investment sitting on your butt at a computer, then you're worse than the PETA Nazis.

Further, I don't think you're here to keep anyone "honest." I think you're hear to pretend to that, while taking contrary stances in order to afford yourself a sense of moral superiority, and NOTHING ELSE. I'm sure you've proved to yourself that you are better than everyone else currently posting, or possibly better than everyone else currently living... but what else is there to you and your position?

An unexamined life is not worth living, according to Socrates. So in that sense I'm giving you the opportunity to live a life worth living, by reflecting on your own beliefs and behaviour, especially your belief in your own morality and rationality.

You should be thanking me.

Really, do you argue this dogmatically against abortion? Against any and all war? Against the death penalty? You talk all this crap about consistency, so can you back up your own assertions or are you just getting off playing devil's deaf advocate?

Assume, if it makes you happy, that not only am I totally inconsistent but also that I am Hitler.

It's your own beliefs and behaviour you should be worried about. If you can't maintain a simple, rational discussion about your food choices without descending into infantile antagonism and abuse, what does that say about you?
 
An unexamined life is not worth living, according to Socrates. So in that sense I'm giving you the opportunity to live a life worth living, by reflecting on your own beliefs and behaviour, especially your belief in your own morality and rationality.

You should be thanking me.
Oh yeah, thank you Oh Wisest Person Ever, for pointing out the flaw in all of humanity, and all carnivorous animals, that we may die of starvation and/or malnutrition while maintaining the moral purity demanded of us by some yahoo on the Internet.

EyeRoll.gif
 
Assume, if it makes you happy, that not only am I totally inconsistent but also that I am Hitler.

Hitler had a gift for convincing people to follow him. A gift that he used for the most depraved evil.

I don't believe you have what it takes to be Hitler.


If you can't maintain a simple, rational discussion about your food choices without descending into infantile antagonism and abuse, what does that say about you?

Funny you should ask that.

If you're so dumb that you're incapable of rational thought, which may well be the case based on your posts, it would indeed be unfair to expect moral behaviour from you... I'm not surprised RandFan endorsed this, it's pretty stupid.

Care to answer your own question?

I'm tempted to call KFC and have them send over another bucket of hostages while using your name, however the joke would backfire due to the name "Kevin Lowe" being highly respected where I come from.
 
Last edited:
:) Great post.

Thanks RandFan :)

I also like the idea of choice. I also like the idea of free speech and the rights of ethical vegans or anyone who has an idea or cause to propigate their views.

Abso-piggin-lutely :) Bring it on :)

I'm not surprised RandFan endorsed this, it's pretty stupid.

So I get one thumbs up and one thumbs down which is fine based on the relative value or dis-value I ascribe to the posters complementing me or calling my post stupid!

Meat eaters like to try to hijack the discussion into being about whether people should be allowed to eat meat,

Maybe, but I'm a veggie so if it was a 'hijacking', it was not the case this time :)

As we've clarified before, we're talking about whether it's morally right to kill animals for food just because you like the taste....For now, please assume everyone agrees you should be allowed to eat meat if you choose to do so, so we can get back to the real question which is whether or not eating meat would make you an immoral person.

I would happily 'assume everyone agrees' if everyone's posts implied that they did. The idea of 'telling people what to eat', rings alarm bells for me, hence my post.

I also think it's a fine line between looking at the morality of an act and looking at concepts of rights, particularly with this topic, when the perceived immorality of meat-eating is very closely related to 'animal rights' - 'rights' which could not be protected by law without infringing human rights, the latter of which I consider to be inalienable.

As to the debate on why I and others see an apparently blatantly obvious difference between protecting the rights of (or just discussing the morality of killing) a four-year-old and those of a cow, a cute minc or a slug, I'm not interested.

I've thought about these things, I've made my choice and I live by it. I don't eat meat - but it's also easy for me to see how one could conclude that meat-eating is a perfectly reasonable way to feed oneself. And I would always defend a person's right to do so.

While were at it, what's up with all the soy meat substitutes I see at the grocery ?

Why do people who have given up meat, want to pretend they are eating meat ?

Should cutting off a large chunk of the available protein choices by choosing not to eat meat mean one's diet has to be restricted to a few protein options?

Some soy products such as tofu have been around a long time and are part of traditional Chinese fare, I'd guess because it's a healthy, and done right, a tasty alternative when meat was not available.

Many who make the decision not to eat meat on ethical grounds are very fond of meat - and for some I believe it's quite an undertaking. Why not have pseudo-meat, even if they are not that close in taste and texture to the genuine article, if it assists one live with a difficult choice?

Have the FDA approved Quorn for you guys yet*? It's been around for decades in the UK and I think it's great :) 1/ because it's so versitile and can taste good. 2/ It's a great source of healthy protein 3/ It (being fungus based) can be grown on waste vegetation so in terms of better use of land or methane reduction, it's a good option. Grow veg on land, eat what you need for your carbs, vitamins, fibre etc, chuck what's left in a big vat and grow your protein! How cool is that?

BDd

*From what I remember from years ago, the FDA considered it a 'new food' therefore requiring their approval (and associated tests & costs etc.) before US citizens were allowed to eat it!
 
Last edited:
So I get one thumbs up and one thumbs down which is fine based on the relative value or dis-value I ascribe to the posters complementing me or calling my post stupid!
I gave it two thumbs up. I think Kevin gave you the finger. ;)
 
As we've clarified before, we're talking about whether it's morally right to kill animals for food just because you like the taste.

I take you don't think it is?

If so... When I was at university (a long time ago), I knew a woman who became a vegetarian because she didn't like the taste of meat. Was she morally wrong to do this? If not, could you explain why not?
 
As we've clarified before, we're talking about whether it's morally right to kill animals for food just because you like the taste.

Meat eaters like to try to hijack the discussion into being about whether people should be allowed to eat meat, because that's a whole lot easier for them. For now, please assume everyone agrees you should be allowed to eat meat if you choose to do so, so we can get back to the real question which is whether or not eating meat would make you an immoral person.

My morals are none of your friggin' business!

Morals need a context and your context is not mine. And you can not make your context mine.

And now:

:pigsfly:k:
 
I think you should stop attacking the strawmen and actually read what people have already posted.

How can they be strawman arguments when they've all been posted more than once in this thread?
 
How can they be strawman arguments when they've all been posted more than once in this thread?

Ahh, so demonizing is a valid argument technique?

Come on, Volatile. I have a whole lot more respect for you than that. Do you really think defending Kevin's behavior at this point is in any way useful?
 
Ahh, so demonizing is a valid argument technique?

Come on, Volatile. I have a whole lot more respect for you than that. Do you really think defending Kevin's behavior at this point is in any way useful?

I haven't really followed his "behaviour", to be honest, and just skim-read the last few pages, so I don't know what you're referring to.

Nevertheless, your reply stood out as, quite clearly, the arguments KL cited are all used, more than once each, during the rest of the thread. Your accusation of "strawman" doesn't stack up - that's all I'm saying. It is quite clear that some posters here - yourself not included - use taste, fallacious appeals to evolution and / or laziness as "reasons" for their dietary choices.
 
Assume, if it makes you happy, that not only am I totally inconsistent but also that I am Hitler.

So, in other words, you're not going to answer. You're the one banging the drum of moral consistency, not me, but you're currently not taking questions.

It's your own beliefs and behaviour you should be worried about. If you can't maintain a simple, rational discussion about your food choices without descending into infantile antagonism and abuse, what does that say about you?

The irony of your accusation is not lost on anyone here, Kevin. And no, it's not about my beliefs and behavior at this point. I'm not waving some supposed flag of moral consistency. I asked you those questions because I already know the answer to at least two of them based on your post history, so I know full well you are in all actuality aware of the existence of relative morality and moral choices. You've crossed the line from making a rational, reasonable argument into the realm of playing some kind of self-appointed rhetorical and philosophical hall monitor. At this point, I have no reason at all to believe you have once posted in this thread in good faith, and your continued statements attempting to place yourself above all others here keeps confirming that assessment.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom