Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

...it's simply a problem of telling people what to feed their children.

Not in a free society it's not. I choose not to eat meat but I could never endorse infringing the rights of humans to elevate the rights of animals. Informed choice is where it's at for me but even if we decide to 'educate' rather than 'telling' people, which of the plethora of contrasting dietary advice are we going to teach them?

The status quo seems fine to me on this, budget eggs (etc.) for those who's diets would suffer if they had to pay for free-range (and for those who don't care), free-range for those who wish and can afford to. and shelves and fridges full of alternatives for those who don't want either :)
 
Not in a free society it's not. I choose not to eat meat but I could never endorse infringing the rights of humans to elevate the rights of animals. Informed choice is where it's at for me but even if we decide to 'educate' rather than 'telling' people, which of the plethora of contrasting dietary advice are we going to teach them?

The status quo seems fine to me on this, budget eggs (etc.) for those who's diets would suffer if they had to pay for free-range (and for those who don't care), free-range for those who wish and can afford to. and shelves and fridges full of alternatives for those who don't want either :)
:) Great post. I also like the idea of choice. I also like the idea of free speech and the rights of ethical vegans or anyone who has an idea or cause to propigate their views.
 
....
Pushing your shopping trolley past the bacon to the tofu is a comparatively trivial operation.
....
Yeah, but cleaning up the mess after I have vomited up all that tofu, isn't so trivial ..

While were at it, what's up with all the soy meat substitutes I see at the grocery ?

Why do people who have given up meat, want to pretend they are eating meat ?
 
Neither do any animals.

That is to say, I've never heard any dolphins squealing "9/11 was an inside job", "You can't hug a child with nuclear arms" or "Meat is Murder".

Animals like dolphins, chimps and parrots have reasonably complicated social interactions, are capable of mental tasks children can't reliably complete until the age of six or so, and can have vocabularies of tens or hundreds of words.

So by the rule you just endorsed, it's perfectly okay to pop a four year old on the spit-roast, since it's dumber than some animals.

"But it's got the potential to be smarter!" you cry, thinking that this is an intelligent response. Well, first problem: acorns aren't oak trees, and sperm aren't scientists. If you count future states as morally determinative then in the future we'll all be dead and you can stuff us in a crematorium now. What determines how we can treat an entity is what it is now, not what you reckon it will be at some arbitrary future time.

But even if you buy the ad hoc "potential" argument, it still doesn't get you off the hook, because brain damaged humans can spend their whole lives with a mental age of under six. Is it okay to keep them in steel cages their whole lives then kill them for bacon?

I'm glad you realize that. Now shut up and leave us predators alone.

If you're so dumb that you're incapable of rational thought, which may well be the case based on your posts, it would indeed be unfair to expect moral behaviour from you. Maybe we should put you on the same moral level as a bot fly larva and not judge you for what you do.

Not in a free society it's not. I choose not to eat meat but I could never endorse infringing the rights of humans to elevate the rights of animals. Informed choice is where it's at for me but even if we decide to 'educate' rather than 'telling' people, which of the plethora of contrasting dietary advice are we going to teach them?

The status quo seems fine to me on this, budget eggs (etc.) for those who's diets would suffer if they had to pay for free-range (and for those who don't care), free-range for those who wish and can afford to. and shelves and fridges full of alternatives for those who don't want either :)

I'm not surprised RandFan endorsed this, it's pretty stupid.

As we've clarified before, we're talking about whether it's morally right to kill animals for food just because you like the taste.

Meat eaters like to try to hijack the discussion into being about whether people should be allowed to eat meat, because that's a whole lot easier for them. For now, please assume everyone agrees you should be allowed to eat meat if you choose to do so, so we can get back to the real question which is whether or not eating meat would make you an immoral person.
 
Last edited:
I'm not surprised RandFan endorsed this, it's pretty stupid.
Because? I'm guessing there won't be an answer...

For now, please assume everyone agrees you should be allowed to eat meat if you choose to do so...
I was correct, no answer, just invective and then you concede the point. First you declare it stupid and then brush it aside.

The poster doesn't eat meat but recognizes that PETA (this thread IS about PETA) doesn't agree that anyone should be allowed to eat meat.

...so we can get back to the real question which is whether or not eating meat would make you an immoral person.
Look up, up there, the thread title, THAT'S the real question. I don't know why PETA is so bloody stupid. I only know that they are.

But I'll answer your question about meat consumption. No. It doesn't make me an immoral person.

Any other questions?
 
Last edited:
Kevin,

What I don't get is what's it to you? So we are all immoral? So what? You post as if you have feelings or perhaps a conscience. You post as if it bothers you that animals might suffer.
 
Last edited:
Kevin,

What I don't get is what's it to you? So we are all immoral? So what? You post as if you have feelings or perhaps a conscience. You post as if it bothers you that animals might suffer.

You can keep wondering about that.

All I'm here for currently is to keep people honest, by pointing out bogus arguments. I don't think I'll run out of material any time soon.

I do think if you kill conscious beings in order to eat them you ought to have a better reason than "I like the taste of conscious beings better than that of plants", or "I can digest them so it's okay for me to eat them", or "it's marginally more convenient for me to eat them than to spend half an hour googling for nutritional advice once in my life".
 
I do think if you kill conscious beings in order to eat them you ought to have a better reason than "I like the taste of conscious beings better than that of plants", or "I can digest them so it's okay for me to eat them", or "it's marginally more convenient for me to eat them than to spend half an hour googling for nutritional advice once in my life".
I'm a moral skeptic and find such arguments more likely to simply be an attempt to post hoc rationalize one's preferences. Not that the arguments can't cause change or that one shouldn't sincerely consider the arguments. Moral arguments can have profound effect on one's moral sense but I don't think anyone needs to justify his or her choices to anyone. We have laws, ethics and social convention. If you want to argue in an attempt to change the laws, ethics or convention then that is fine but expecting anyone to justify on a case by case basis for their actions is really asking someone to rationalize their actions post hoc.

If one truly is in need of justification for eating meat then I think Cohen and Ralston provide ample ammunition for that.

I've considered the arguments pro and con and I sleep quite fine at night. I suspect that my conclusions are based in part on what Pinker calls the moral sense and my indoctrination (I grew up on a farm slaughtering chickens and rabbits). I won't tell you that this makes my choice right only that it explains why I perceive it as right (along with serious considerations of the arguments made).

I should note that I was raised a conservative right wing Christian and I believed that homosexuality and pre-marital sex (along with a whole host of behaviors and beliefs) were immoral.

I'm now an atheist and fully support the rights of gays and lesbians.

I didn't come by my current sense of morality blithely or blindly. I seriously and sincerely considered the arguments and I'm fine with eating meat. How much of that is genetic or biological and how much of that is reason I don't know but I know that I've made an informed choice. Something you simply dismiss as "stupid".

FWIW: NPR interviews Steven Pinker on Morality as a 'Sixth Sense' (pinker deals a bit with eating meat).
 
Last edited:
You can keep wondering about that.

All I'm here for currently is to keep people honest, by pointing out bogus arguments. I don't think I'll run out of material any time soon.

I do think if you kill conscious beings in order to eat them you ought to have a better reason than "I like the taste of conscious beings better than that of plants", or "I can digest them so it's okay for me to eat them", or "it's marginally more convenient for me to eat them than to spend half an hour googling for nutritional advice once in my life".
If you think the difference between living a "normal" versus "vegan" or "vegetarian" lifestyle only requires a 30 minute investment sitting on your butt at a computer, then you're worse than the PETA Nazis.

Further, I don't think you're here to keep anyone "honest." I think you're hear to pretend to that, while taking contrary stances in order to afford yourself a sense of moral superiority, and NOTHING ELSE. I'm sure you've proved to yourself that you are better than everyone else currently posting, or possibly better than everyone else currently living... but what else is there to you and your position?
 
You can keep wondering about that.

All I'm here for currently is to keep people honest, by pointing out bogus arguments. I don't think I'll run out of material any time soon.

That's about as useless and arbitrary reason for your continued ignoring of the numerous valid points presented to you as one might get from an eight-year-old about why they left a crap in the middle of the living room.

I do think if you kill conscious beings in order to eat them you ought to have a better reason than "I like the taste of conscious beings better than that of plants", or "I can digest them so it's okay for me to eat them", or "it's marginally more convenient for me to eat them than to spend half an hour googling for nutritional advice once in my life".

I think you should stop attacking the strawmen and actually read what people have already posted.

Really, do you argue this dogmatically against abortion? Against any and all war? Against the death penalty? You talk all this crap about consistency, so can you back up your own assertions or are you just getting off playing devil's deaf advocate?
 
Further, I don't think you're here to keep anyone "honest." I think you're hear to pretend to that, while taking contrary stances in order to afford yourself a sense of moral superiority, and NOTHING ELSE. I'm sure you've proved to yourself that you are better than everyone else currently posting, or possibly better than everyone else currently living... but what else is there to you and your position?

Same thing I've been thinking.
 
Same thing I've been thinking.

To take that thought further(because engaging with that other person seems like a waste of time), shouldn't PETA start targeting lions and tigers for extinction? After all, how DARE one animal eat another!
 
All I'm here for currently is to keep people honest, by pointing out bogus arguments.

Ironic considering there hasn't been an honest statement out of you in this entire thread.

All you have done is beat up on straw men, hurl insults and ad-homs and attempt to dazzle us with your hyper-inflated opinion of your own intellect.
 
Ironic considering there hasn't been an honest statement out of you in this entire thread.

All you have done is beat up on straw men, hurl insults and ad-homs and attempt to dazzle us with your hyper-inflated opinion of your own intellect.

Wow, it isn't just me?

Anyhoo, if you have a minute, should PETA advocate the destruction of carnivores?
 
Wow, it isn't just me?

Anyhoo, if you have a minute, should PETA advocate the destruction of carnivores?
This is along the lines of an argument I've made for years. Life for animals in the wild is brutal and harsh. Predation, the elements, disease etc. Most animals die shortly after they are born. They are usually eaten. Dying of old age isn't a statistical possibility for animals. Neither is a life of bliss. However, some might argue that whatever an animal suffers in the wild doesn't give humans the right to kill and eat them.
 
However, some might argue that whatever an animal suffers in the wild doesn't give humans the right to kill and eat them.

Yes, but those people are stupid. :eek:

What right does a lion have to eat an elk, or whatever it is they are munching on when I flip past Animal Planet?
 
What I find most stupid about this thread is that people use their emotions as a starting point to keep a 'rational' discussion on why the emotions of others should change.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom