Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

But it's also arbitrary, at least in the way that you've formulated it. Why, for instance, would my suggesting that morality depends on being a close relative of mine be a worse moral standard?
That would also be objective (or could be if I defined some degree of relatedness, we could do DNA testing to determine if a person was or was not adequately related to me).
The problem, of course, is that it's completely arbitrary.

Now, I'm not saying your definition has to be arbitrary. Only that in the formulation that you've offered, it is.

It's not arbitrary at all. It's simply the existing standard used by almost every carnivorous or omnivorous species (I know of no species that subsists on cannibalism, all known meat eaters eat outside their species).

Your question about DNA testing is absurd. I know of no one who has required such testing to prove their species.
 
"I was only joking about killing them", he said around mouthfuls of bacon, "It's not like anybody here is actually complicit in such killings. The very idea is absurd".

I really wish somebody could answer my questions: what about plants ? Do they have a right to live ? And, if so, what do we get to eat ? Also, do we now prevent animals from killing one another or from killing plants ? And, if not, and I assume this is because it's their "natural tendencies", isn't eating a "natural tendency" to a human ?
 
No. Yes, at least one is necessarily wrong in any useful system of morality.

Amazing.

So if, say, a vegan refuses to eat animal products for some reason or another, and I gleefully eat animal products all the time, and we disagree and agree to disagree, one of us is still wrong ? How does that work ?
 
It's not arbitrary at all. It's simply the existing standard used by almost every carnivorous or omnivorous species (I know of no species that subsists on cannibalism, all known meat eaters eat outside their species).

Your question about DNA testing is absurd. I know of no one who has required such testing to prove their species.

Well, Roboramma has a point. It is kinda arbitrary to limit it to species. But it is objective and certainly very useful and justified: we need to eat.
 
This is actually one of the ways that PETA are flippin' morons. You keeping bees at this point in time(with so many disappearing) is actually a good thing, both for bees and for the ecologies they support.

I've seen PETA's list of arguments for why beekeeping is bad. It is horribly, terribly wrong. Even the rare facts that they got right, they actually got wrong in some way or another. Just one long page of blatant misrepresentation and, occasionally, simple ignorance.

If any of PETA's other policies read the same way (I haven't bothered to look), then the policymakers PETA has working for them are utter fools.
 
If any of PETA's other policies read the same way (I haven't bothered to look), then the policymakers PETA has working for them are utter fools.
My 2 cents: It's supreme arrogance. They don't give a damn about being accurate. They only care about their view. The cause is the view. If they shoot themselves in the foot (which they do with such frequency it's breathtaking) they don't seem to give a damn.
 
Vegans: People who don't just SAY they love animals.

It's not arbitrary at all. It's simply the existing standard used by almost every carnivorous or omnivorous species (I know of no species that subsists on cannibalism, all known meat eaters eat outside their species).

I'm sorry to report the alternatives are not cannibalism and starvation. People can survive without eating animals, and a vegan diet in no way violates your above tenet of food consumption.

----------------------
Belz:
Well, Roboramma has a point. It is kinda arbitrary to limit it to species. But it is objective and certainly very useful and justified: we need to eat.

You're conflating two separate notions -- the need to eat and eating animals.
 
It's not arbitrary at all. It's simply the existing standard used by almost every carnivorous or omnivorous species (I know of no species that subsists on cannibalism, all known meat eaters eat outside their species).
That doesn't change the fact that it's arbitrary. Moreover, the idea that other species use species as a moral category is something you'll have to support by evidence. Not eating members of their own species is much more well explained by the fact that it's just not a good idea than by the idea that they have constructed a moral framework in which they think its wrong to eat other members of their own species. (they still kill each other, after all).

But even if they do, it doesn't make it a non-arbitrary category.

Your question about DNA testing is absurd. I know of no one who has required such testing to prove their species.
I didn't suggest DNA testing to confirm one's species. I suggested it as an objective method of testing relatedness to me, and thus confirming an objective, but completely arbitrary, basis for a moral framework.

Edit: see my response to ken below for clarification on what exactly I'm saying.
 
Last edited:
Well, that may be true, if you include animals (wild and domesticated) as part of society.

Where do you draw your line, Roboramma? Is it ok to kill cows for leather and meat? Is it ok to kill chickens for food? Is it ok to rob chickens of their offspring (eggs)? Ok to fry a beetle and eat it. What if I killed a sponge just to use it as a cleaning tool? How about sea urchin, is it ok to kill and eat those too? If there are ants in my house and they can't be reasoned to leave, do I have to just plan on having long term roommates?
Yeah, I think most of those things are okay, so long as they are done in the most humane possible manner. I don't think that the harm in "killing cows for leather and meat" comes mainly from the killing, but rather from the life that the cow has as a result of it. Everything dies. And I don't think that most other animals have the sort of moral standing that affords consideration for things like "freedom" to make choices about their lives. If we can determine that a cow's "wild life" would be no better or longer than one raised in captivity for meat and leather, then I have no problem whatever with that.
Moreover, even if it is slightly worse, there is also a benefit to people to be weighed against that.
Finally, I extend more moral consideration to a cow than to a chicken, and far more to a chicken than to any sort of insect, because the ability to "experience" is far greater for the cow, and almost non-existent for the insect. I have no problem with killing ants for convience.

You may think that drawing a line on how to treat animals based on species is meaningless, but I disagree.
Well, considering that I specifically said that it isn't meaningless, I think we agree about that.
There is a meaningful difference between a human and a cow, humans are people and sapient beings. Racism is based on a meaningless difference because people of all races think and have desires similarly. And because humans of all races are people.
As I said, the formulation "I am human, therefore better" is arbitrary and meaningless. But that doesn't mean it has to be. The formulation "I am human and have these particular qualities (like the ones you mentioned)" is neither arbitrary or meaningless. I'm only saying that it is those ways in which we are different that gives a different moral perspective.
I actually think we agree about that, as you seem to be making the same point above.
 
Then it sounds like you are functionally basing your morals on what is good for society (the group of people), rather than what you originally described.

Possibly, but it depends on how you define society. Moreover, its specifically the way in which individuals are affected that concerns me. Someone might say "homosexual marriage may not harm any individual, but it harms the moral fabric of society as a whole" or something. Now, we can debate the truth of that notion (I wouldn't accept it), but I also wouldn't accept that even if it were true, it would be an argument against gay marriage, because I don't accept the idea that something that doesn't harm individuals has moral standing.

(Of course, you could make an argument that "the moral fabric of society" is something that affects individuals, but again I see that as a different argument)

The point I'm making I guess is that society isn't valuable in and of itself, but due to the people that make it up, and it's those people as individuals that I'm concerned with, not some vague notion of "what's good for society".

I think we may actually agree with that. What we seem to disagree about is where the value I place on individuals comes from. I tried to give a framework for that earlier. And I think that same framework leads to some value being placed on, for instance, the suffering of some animals (the ones that can suffer).
 
This is actually one of the ways that PETA are flippin' morons. You keeping bees at this point in time(with so many disappearing) is actually a good thing, both for bees and for the ecologies they support.

And this is a good point that I'd like to emphasis. The problem with PETA and some "animal rights" groups is that they are equating things on an incredibly naive grounds. Yes, I think that other species deserve some form of moral consideration, but: "Animals have some moral standing, so if I, as a human, wouldn't like something, it's therefore wrong to do it to an animal" is ridiculous!
If we thought on those grounds, we'd consider parenting to be a form of imprisonment.

Beekeeping is good for the bees. Raising cattle can, when done in a humane way, be good for the cows. Dogs enjoy being pets. So do cats. (when they are being mistreated, that may not be true, but we do have laws to deal with people who mistreat their pets)

Whatever problem that I have with raising livestock, at least in regards to the animals themselves*, is in how it is treated while its alive (not in the fact that it will be killed, nor in it's lack of freedom, nor in the fact that we don't give them the vote).

The problem with people like PETA is that they can't understand the differences between us and animals. I have been trying to make the point that there are meaningful similarities, but it should be obvious to everyone that there are some moral differences (I don't think we need to worry about protecting pigs right to free speech, for instance). Once we recognise that, some of the ideas of PETA become completely ridiculous.

*There may be environmental factors to take into account as well.
 
I'm claiming we can't have a totally vegetarian society, because there are too many uneducated people, and children would die.

Rearing children with a vegetarian diet requires a good understanding of nutrition. A much better understanding that many people are able to gain. Pretty much any combination of meat and vegetables is sufficient to provide nutrition. Vegetarianism is harder to do.

Sorry, but the question wasn't "could we transition to a totally meat-free diet tomorrow with no ill effects on the children of idiots". It was "could we have a vegetarian society". As you say yourself, it's simply a problem of telling people what to feed their children. Even if some people were so totally stupid that they would darwinise themselves in a generation of vegetarianism I can't imagine that leading to the inevitable collapse of civilisation.

To Belz
I really wish somebody could answer my questions: what about plants ? Do they have a right to live ? And, if so, what do we get to eat ? Also, do we now prevent animals from killing one another or from killing plants ? And, if not, and I assume this is because it's their "natural tendencies", isn't eating a "natural tendency" to a human ?

Already answered. Pay attention. If it doesn't have a mental life comparable to that of a really dumb human I don't care. Plants do not have such a mental life.

As for preventing animals killing each other, if I could wave a magic wand and stop predation and parasitism in the animal world yet still have a working ecosystem that does all the things ecosystems are supposed to do then I'd wave it.

Pushing your shopping trolley past the bacon to the tofu is a comparatively trivial operation.

Amazing.

So if, say, a vegan refuses to eat animal products for some reason or another, and I gleefully eat animal products all the time, and we disagree and agree to disagree, one of us is still wrong ? How does that work ?

Let me rephrase that question for you so it is relevant.

If person A thinks "it is morally tolerable to take action Z", and person B thinks "it is not morally tolerable to take action Z", then one of them is wrong. I don't know which one, necessarily, but I know one of them is wrong.

That goes for any Z. Fill in the blank with anything you like.

Any further problems comprehending the answer?
 
Already answered. Pay attention. If it doesn't have a mental life comparable to that of a really dumb human I don't care. Plants do not have such a mental life.

Neither do any animals.

That is to say, I've never heard any dolphins squealing "9/11 was an inside job", "You can't hug a child with nuclear arms" or "Meat is Murder".

As for preventing animals killing each other, if I could wave a magic wand and stop predation and parasitism in the animal world yet still have a working ecosystem that does all the things ecosystems are supposed to do then I'd wave it.

I'm glad you realize that. Now shut up and leave us predators alone.
Pushing your shopping trolley past the bacon to the tofu is a comparatively trivial operation.

Loading up on bacon and passing the tofu is equally trivial.
 
Corn and soybeans are the two most patented seed types in industrial farming. This detail is related to the discussion of what benefits society and the environment.
 
As for preventing animals killing each other, if I could wave a magic wand and stop predation and parasitism in the animal world yet still have a working ecosystem that does all the things ecosystems are supposed to do then I'd wave it.

While you are waving the real bacon goodbye... I was thinking... could you also wish for world peace, social equality and a bunch of ever-grateful photomodels for me?
 
Yes you can. But I will be doubting your mental health on why you would want to hug the child instead of first trying to ask it where the heck it had gotten the nukes from.

The breakfast cereal market is getting really competitive! ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom