Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

A.) Yes there is. It's called "Homo Sapiens". It's an objective, universal standard that can be detected by scientific means.

But it's also arbitrary, at least in the way that you've formulated it. Why, for instance, would my suggesting that morality depends on being a close relative of mine be a worse moral standard?
That would also be objective (or could be if I defined some degree of relatedness, we could do DNA testing to determine if a person was or was not adequately related to me).
The problem, of course, is that it's completely arbitrary.

Now, I'm not saying your definition has to be arbitrary. Only that in the formulation that you've offered, it is.
 
You can't. It's clear cut, it is arbitrary, but it is objective. You may not like it, but it is not a subjective standard.

I think that's also why Kevin was making a comparison to racism. The problem with racism is that it's also completely arbitrary: there's no meaningful distinction between myself and a black person, but there is a distinction. Now, that distinction is somewhat blurred (perhaps to the point of being meaningless at this point), but it even if it was completely clear cut and objective, racism would still be wrong. Why? Because it's a totally meaningless distinction.

The problem with this line of argument is that the distinction between me and a cow is not totally meaningless or arbitrary. I really do think that we have some qualities that give us more moral standing than cows, let alone fish or frogs. But I also think that the argument needs to focus on the ways in which this distinction is not arbitrary, not on the fact that it can objectively be made.

This is why I personally extend some moral considerations to other animals, but certainly not the same moral consideration that I extend to other humans.
 
I think that's also why Kevin was making a comparison to racism. The problem with racism is that it's also completely arbitrary: there's no meaningful distinction between myself and a black person, but there is a distinction. Now, that distinction is somewhat blurred (perhaps to the point of being meaningless at this point), but it even if it was completely clear cut and objective, racism would still be wrong. Why? Because it's a totally meaningless distinction.

Shhhh! You're ruining an entertaining exchange.
 
Sword of Truth's latest brilliant contribution:
A.) Yes there is. It's called "Homo Sapiens". It's an objective, universal standard that can be detected by scientific means.

This is still an arbitrary moral distinction completely lacking in support. The same can be said for a person's sex.

This is why I personally extend some moral considerations to other animals, but certainly not the same moral consideration that I extend to other humans.

And indeed almost everyone thinks animals are worthy of some moral consideration, otherwise the people here would have no problem with torturing them -- unless they want to twist themselves into knots arguing that animal harm could cause a coarsening of the human spirit that leads to harming Homo sapiens.
 
How does that follow? I only claim that suffering is bad, whether it is mine or someone else's, and pleasure is good, whether it is mine or someone else's. The only place that I personally come into it is that I know this because of my own experience of pleasure and suffering.

Of course not, because I don't weigh my own pleasure (or suffering) any higher than anyone else's, because there is no meaningful difference between their's and mine.
Then it sounds like you are functionally basing your morals on what is good for society (the group of people), rather than what you originally described.
 
Then it sounds like you are functionally basing your morals on what is good for society (the group of people), rather than what you originally described.

Well, that may be true, if you include animals (wild and domesticated) as part of society.

Where do you draw your line, Roboramma? Is it ok to kill cows for leather and meat? Is it ok to kill chickens for food? Is it ok to rob chickens of their offspring (eggs)? Ok to fry a beetle and eat it. What if I killed a sponge just to use it as a cleaning tool? How about sea urchin, is it ok to kill and eat those too? If there are ants in my house and they can't be reasoned to leave, do I have to just plan on having long term roommates?

You may think that drawing a line on how to treat animals based on species is meaningless, but I disagree. There is a meaningful difference between a human and a cow, humans are people and sapient beings. Racism is based on a meaningless difference because people of all races think and have desires similarly. And because humans of all races are people.
 
Last edited:
If someone remembers it the next time they think of posting an unoriginal joke about eating meat to annoy PETA, my work is done.
Given that they are pompous, arrogant, irrational and condone violence I think you've got your groups mixed up.

PETA thoroughly deserve mockery and derision. Not because they care about animals but because they are morally inconsistent.

I thought even you could figure that one out.
 
I'm still amazed that you people have yet to understand the intention behind Kevin_Lowe's post. It was meant to be satirical. I highly doubt that Kevin_Lowe finds the hanging of anyone to be hysterical in any way. What he meant was that committing an action just to spite an organization you disagree with is petty and stupid, as stupid as setting a forest fire because you hate those Smokey the Bear commercials. It's not funny or cute. It's just stupid, and that sort of attitude makes you look like an ignorant **** to anyone trying to look at the situation critically or anyone who disagrees with your viewpoint.
Oh BS. Climb down off your soap box. PETA is a political organization with a dogmatic and intolerant bent toward those who disagree with them. They are the epitome of an organization that deserves actions just to spite them, they are up their with the GOP.

The comparison is over the top and so absurd that it invites derision and scorn in and of itself.

I don't think you guys who support PETA get it. Their crimes and hypocrisy are legend and well documented. That they share some of your world view doesn't excuse their excesses.

I'm unapologetically anti-PETA and would gladly tweak their nose anytime just to tweak their nose.

However, you want me to actively campaign to improve the lot of animals jusk ask, I'm there (as long as you don't support ALF or other terrorist organizations that is).
 
It's my understanding that prior to 09/11, animal rights extremist organisations such as PETA were on the government radar in a big way. Didn't PETA give ~$14K to an ecoterrorist who is now sitting in a federal prison in Colorado for torching a ski resort in that state?

IMHO, vegans have an inherent problem in with what to do with the incisor teeth humans possess. Are they for tearing into that tofu burger with a vengance? Anthropomorphism is nothing new nor is there being no fix for stupid.
 
No need, I've made my position clear way earlier. Pigs and dolphins are incapable of morals, so dragging their "feelings" and stuff into a moral argument doesn't make sense.

This is false on a couple of levels. Altruistic behaviour has been seen in animals, so it's false on that level. ("But that's just instinct!" you say. Well, RandFan will argue until he's blue in the face that it's just instinct for us too, to a significant extent). In any case, just because an entity is "incapable of morals" it doesn't follow that you have a license to suspend your own morals and do whatever you like to it. Cats aren't particularly moral, but that doesn't mean that it's okay for you to torture one for fun.

I've said it before - morality doesn't justify eating meat or killing animals - supply and demand does. We live in societies. In civilization. Two words that animals have NO CONCEPT OF, yet two words that ultimately (an unfortunately) require their sacrifice.

Are you claiming that we couldn't have a vegetarian society? Since we've established that humans can live without eating meat I'm not sure why you think civilization requires us to kill and eat animals.

Wait, wait. Are you saying that two people can't possibly have different moral values ? Or are you claiming that one of those two people is necessarily wrong ?

No. Yes, at least one is necessarily wrong in any useful system of morality.
 
Are you claiming that we couldn't have a vegetarian society? Since we've established that humans can live without eating meat I'm not sure why you think civilization requires us to kill and eat animals.
I'm claiming we can't have a totally vegetarian society, because there are too many uneducated people, and children would die.

Rearing children with a vegetarian diet requires a good understanding of nutrition. A much better understanding that many people are able to gain. Pretty much any combination of meat and vegetables is sufficient to provide nutrition. Vegetarianism is harder to do.
 
Oh, and I hooked 5 trout in an afternoon's flyfishing today...

:D

Lucky bastid--I got my trout for the year and have to wait until next year. In this area, trout are farm raised and stocked in ponds, wide spring streams, and rivers for the expressed purpose of being caught. This time of year, whatever trout are left die in the warming ponds and shrinking streams--having fulfilled their purpose for the year.

...what were we talking about again?
 
Good god!

I walked into a river, fished, and can do it again tomorrow (if I want to drive for an hour...), walked out. And I was one of four people fishing that stretch. We all caught fish.

NZ is great.

Completely wild run browns, btw...

:D
 
I will happily continue to keep bees, no matter how awful PETA thinks the practice is. I could say I'd glady keep more bees just to spite PETA's objections, but I actually like beekeeping too much, so it kind of loses the gravity.

PETA can feast on my undergarments.
 
Altruistic behaviour has been seen in animals...
Well this is odd, I wonder if this fact can inform us about our own sense of morality. Hmmmm.....

..."But that's just instinct!" you say.
For many animals, yes, for some like our close cousins the chimps and bonobos it's not all instinct. Perhaps hardwired rules of behavior coupled with socialy learned behaviors constitute a dynamic. Further, that understanding the interplay of the variables in the dynamic scientifically will help inform our morals.

Well, RandFan will argue until he's blue in the face that it's just instinct for us too, to a significant extent).
You could at least have the courtesy, or honesty, to admit that I've addressed that contention and it's adaptive traits, not instinct that we are talking about. And I've made clear scores of times, not that you would care, that one cannot justify what we ought to do simply by what we are.

I don't care if you agree with me. It would be nice if you could at least understand what I'm saying and not put words in my mouth.
 
I will happily continue to keep bees, no matter how awful PETA thinks the practice is. I could say I'd glady keep more bees just to spite PETA's objections, but I actually like beekeeping too much, so it kind of loses the gravity.

PETA can feast on my undergarments.

This is actually one of the ways that PETA are flippin' morons. You keeping bees at this point in time(with so many disappearing) is actually a good thing, both for bees and for the ecologies they support.
 
Bees are people too--they aren't meant to be kept for slave labor. I think we need to free all "buzz kittens" and stop this horrendous behavior of stealing their honey for our own selfish desires.





...mmm, honey...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom