Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

I'm still amazed that you people have yet to understand the intention behind Kevin_Lowe's post. It was meant to be satirical. I highly doubt that Kevin_Lowe finds the hanging of anyone to be hysterical in any way. What he meant was that committing an action just to spite an organization you disagree with is petty and stupid, as stupid as setting a forest fire because you hate those Smokey the Bear commercials. It's not funny or cute. It's just stupid, and that sort of attitude makes you look like an ignorant **** to anyone trying to look at the situation critically or anyone who disagrees with your viewpoint.
 
I'm still amazed that you people have yet to understand the intention behind Kevin_Lowe's post. It was meant to be satirical. I highly doubt that Kevin_Lowe finds the hanging of anyone to be hysterical in any way. What he meant was that committing an action just to spite an organization you disagree with is petty and stupid, as stupid as setting a forest fire because you hate those Smokey the Bear commercials. It's not funny or cute. It's just stupid, and that sort of attitude makes you look like an ignorant **** to anyone trying to look at the situation critically or anyone who disagrees with your viewpoint.

This is a joke, right?

It's not that most of us don't get Kevin's sardonic shot early on, it's that we have a problem with the equivocation inherent in his sarcasm. The last umpteen pages consist mostly of arguments about the bases for disagreeing with that equivocation, and challenging the bases Kevin (and possibly others) use for presenting that equivocation in the first place. Sure, there were tangents aplenty, but the nit and grit of the idea being mocked in Kevin's post is pretty clear.

Oh, I'm sorry: did I crack your broad generalization?
 
No, harpy, lowe's sarcastic comment conveyed the message that killing an animal is just as bad as killing a human. To be more accurate, to kill an animal to spite PETA is just as bad as killing a black person to spite the civil rights movment.

The qualifier of "to spite" is irrelevant. Killing an animal is not as repugnant as killing a person. Also, I don't think many here actually have killed an animal just to spite PETA, but many of us have described the taste of meat to spite them.
 
No, harpy, lowe's sarcastic comment conveyed the message that killing an animal is just as bad as killing a human. To be more accurate, to kill an animal to spite PETA is just as bad as killing a black person to spite the civil rights movment.

If you read what I actually wrote I said that killing a human for such a reason is slightly worse. I'd describe either action as psychopathic.

I regard the people who genuinely thought the "Ho ho, I'll kill an animal" posts were funny in about the same way you would regard someone who genuinely thought it would be funny to lynch someone to spite the civil liberties movement. They're not quite as bad, but they're close.
 
I guess my remark must have hit home, if you've all still got sand in your reproductive organs over it.

Mind you, I can say in my defence that I don't think it would actually be funny to hang a black person to spite the civil liberties movement. If I did, I think that would make me a morally revolting, intellectually bankrupt idiot. Whereas I think you guys actually do think it would be funny to kill and eat and animal to spite PETA.

Except for that fact animals aren't people, therefore there is no immorality in killing them.

Even less so when one is merely joking about killing them.
 
Last edited:
This would seem to preclude you finding anything immoral if it cannot effect you due to category exclusion. E.g, you are not a child, so child labour is not bad for yourself. You are not homeless, so using homeless people for medical experimentation is not bad for you (and may be very good for you, if it leads to a cure for a disease that you might someday suffer from).
I don't see that at all. I'm not a child, it's not child labour which is bad, it is the suffering of the children you engage in it. And as they are just as able to suffer as I am, I am able to recognise that their suffering is just as bad as my own.
I'm not saying that I think its bad because "It could happen to me too", I'm saying that I can recognise that suffering is bad because I've experienced it. So, if someone else has a similar experience, I can recognise that that is bad as well.

But how do you judge between conflicting suffering? A criminal held in prison suffers, and this suffering does nothing real to ameliorate any suffering they may have caused in the past. People in a coma have no awareness, so would not suffer at all if they were killed by euthanasia, and their families would in some ways have less suffering as a result.
Regarding the criminal, I consider putting them in prison to be a way of discouraging others from commiting those same crimes, and perhaps of keeping that particular person from committing more crimes. Their suffering is justified on that basis.
Regarding someone in a coma, if they don't have a chance of waking up again, I don't have a problem with euthanasia (in theory). In practice determining those cases where it is fitting may be a little more messy.

And what if someone derives pleasure in a way that causes suffering to others?
Then the "badness" of the suffering should be weighed against the "goodness" of the pleasure.
But I'm not saying that these are the only two aspects to morality. I can see a place for the idea of justice as well, for instance. I am not claiming that "pleasure is good, suffering is bad" is a complete formulation of my moral framework. I am only claiming that is it a part of it.

Ultimately, what in your morality restricts your own choices and actions? If something causes you a great amount of pleasure, or relieves you a great amount of personal suffering, is it moral to do it, even though it may cause suffering for others, or restrict their ability to experience pleasure?
How does that follow? I only claim that suffering is bad, whether it is mine or someone else's, and pleasure is good, whether it is mine or someone else's. The only place that I personally come into it is that I know this because of my own experience of pleasure and suffering.

For example, if you find pleasure in listening to really loud music late at night, but it annoys your neighbours, is it morally right for you to crank up the volume as far as you please?
Of course not, because I don't weigh my own pleasure (or suffering) any higher than anyone else's, because there is no meaningful difference between their's and mine.
 
Except for that fact animals aren't people, therefore there is no immorality in killing them.

The conclusion does not follow from the premise. There's no consistent, objective basis for deciding who is morally important that concludes that internet trolls are morally important and pigs are not.

Even less so when one is merely joking about killing them.

"I was only joking about killing them", he said around mouthfuls of bacon, "It's not like anybody here is actually complicit in such killings. The very idea is absurd".

When you say animals, do you include ants or spiders?

Nah. Only things with enough going on between their ears that they are comparable, at the very least, to a really dumb member of our species.
 
I may have to go hunting or fishing this weekend...
 
I regard the people who genuinely thought the "Ho ho, I'll kill an animal" posts were funny in about the same way you would regard someone who genuinely thought it would be funny to lynch someone to spite the civil liberties movement. They're not quite as bad, but they're close.

Yea, I just threw up in my mouth a little bit.

This whole line of conversation is sickening and absurd. The civil rights movement was about equal rights. Voting, segregation, etc. Your comment was M-&-◊◊◊◊◊ racist. Hanging a person because of the color of their skin has nothing at all to do with killing an animal for food. That doesn't even have anything to do with killing an animal for sport. Or for fun.

Hanging a person doesn't have ◊◊◊◊ to do with civil rights, it has to do with HUMAN rights. The fact that you actually think you made a good point with that lynching joke is totally bonkers. The fact that you made a lynching joke is totally bonkers. Satire shmatire. That's going too far. Isn't anyone going to go back to the rape analogy? :rolleyes:
 
The conclusion does not follow from the premise. There's no consistent, objective basis for deciding who is morally important that concludes that internet trolls are morally important and pigs are not.

A.) Yes there is. It's called "Homo Sapiens". It's an objective, universal standard that can be detected by scientific means.

B.) Oh look. You called me a troll. Come back you can come up with an argument that isn't based on childish name-calling, k?

"I was only joking about killing them", he said around mouthfuls of bacon, "It's not like anybody here is actually complicit in such killings. The very idea is absurd".

Only one of the posts I made in this thread was written while under the influence of pork products. However, since killing pigs isn't immoral under any reasonable definition of morality, the distinction is irrelevant.
 
Last edited:
Yea, I just threw up in my mouth a little bit.

This whole line of conversation is sickening and absurd. The civil rights movement was about equal rights. Voting, segregation, etc. Your comment was M-&-◊◊◊◊◊ racist. Hanging a person because of the color of their skin has nothing at all to do with killing an animal for food. That doesn't even have anything to do with killing an animal for sport. Or for fun.

Hanging a person doesn't have ◊◊◊◊ to do with civil rights, it has to do with HUMAN rights. The fact that you actually think you made a good point with that lynching joke is totally bonkers. The fact that you made a lynching joke is totally bonkers. Satire shmatire. That's going too far. Isn't anyone going to go back to the rape analogy? :rolleyes:

Somebody buy this man a bucket of chicken.
 
Yea, I just threw up in my mouth a little bit.

This whole line of conversation is sickening and absurd. The civil rights movement was about equal rights. Voting, segregation, etc. Your comment was M-&-◊◊◊◊◊ racist. Hanging a person because of the color of their skin has nothing at all to do with killing an animal for food. That doesn't even have anything to do with killing an animal for sport. Or for fun.

Hanging a person doesn't have ◊◊◊◊ to do with civil rights, it has to do with HUMAN rights. The fact that you actually think you made a good point with that lynching joke is totally bonkers. The fact that you made a lynching joke is totally bonkers. Satire shmatire. That's going too far. Isn't anyone going to go back to the rape analogy? :rolleyes:

What makes you so special, that it's not okay to kill you for a trivial reason, but it's okay to kill a dolphin or a pig for a trivial reason?

Careful now - you know that if you say something like "I'm special because I can do X!" then I'm going to say "So we can kill anyone who doesn't do X then?". So take some time figuring out your response.

A.) Yes there is. It's called "Homo Sapiens". It's an objective, universal standard that can be detected by scientific means.

Ah, that's very clever, and original too. A homo sapiens saying that an entirely objective test of whether or not a being is morally important is whether or not that being happens to be a homo sapiens. How much more objective can you get?
 
Ah, that's very clever, and original too. A homo sapiens saying that an entirely objective test of whether or not a being is morally important is whether or not that being happens to be a homo sapiens. How much more objective can you get?

You can't. It's clear cut, it is arbitrary, but it is objective. You may not like it, but it is not a subjective standard.
 
What makes you so special, that it's not okay to kill you for a trivial reason, but it's okay to kill a dolphin or a pig for a trivial reason?

No need, I've made my position clear way earlier. Pigs and dolphins are incapable of morals, so dragging their "feelings" and stuff into a moral argument doesn't make sense.

I just see no need to equate things like murder and rape to eating meat. That's insane. If you respond to that with, "Well, what makes rape and murder wrong?" like others have, that just shows delusion on your part. People know why those are wrong, and if you don't, you need therapy and/or jail time.
Applying human things like morality to animals is anthropomorphism. Animals are not humans even if humans are animals.

I've said it before - morality doesn't justify eating meat or killing animals - supply and demand does. We live in societies. In civilization. Two words that animals have NO CONCEPT OF, yet two words that ultimately (an unfortunately) require their sacrifice.
 
I've said it before - morality doesn't justify eating meat or killing animals - supply and demand does. We live in societies. In civilization. Two words that animals have NO CONCEPT OF, yet two words that ultimately (an unfortunately) require their sacrifice.

Don't forget taste! Some animals just taste so damn fine on the BBQ.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom