Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

Well, if your suggesting that as a counter to the suggestion that a "sociopathic species" could evolve, I don't see the connection. Evolution is a process that occurs at the level of individuals (and even more so, at the level of genes) not species. It doesn't matter, for instance, if sociopathy is detrimental to a species, if it is selected for at the level of genes. Of course, in this environment it isn't, but that doesn't suggest no such environment could exist.


I'm not going to derail this into a discussion of evolution, but the distinctions you're drawing don't make sense. Species are comprised of individuals. If you posit selection for individuals that are detrimental to the species, you're saying that a group of individuals are detrimental to that group of individuals.

What I was saying that that a society cannot be designed to favor sociopaths because the definition of sociopath is someone with an anti-social personality disorder. Anti-social personality disorders are disorders that inhibit functioning in society. No matter what societal norms you imagine existing, a sociopath is someone who can't handle those norms, because that's what the word means.
 
If you posit selection for individuals that are detrimental to the species, you're saying that a group of individuals are detrimental to that group of individuals.
No, I'm saying that some particular trait that is possessed by those individuals is detrimental, relative to some other possible trait, to the group as a whole. I'm also saying that, in spite of that, it can be selected for (and the trait which is of greater benefit to the group as a whole can be selected against) because it is an advantage to the individuals who possess it.

Note that advantage means specifically that they tend to have more grandchildren than their peers who don't have that trait, in this particular environment.

Group selection (which is what species level selection is), was a popular idea decades ago, but while it may certainly have some importance, most biologists recognise that it is generally swamped by gene-level selection.
See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Group_selection

What I was saying that that a society cannot be designed to favor sociopaths because the definition of sociopath is someone with an anti-social personality disorder. Anti-social personality disorders are disorders that inhibit functioning in society. No matter what societal norms you imagine existing, a sociopath is someone who can't handle those norms, because that's what the word means.

Then society breaks down. That doesn't suggest that our species no longer exists, it just suggests that we become and anti-social species. Most animals aren't particularly social, especially compared to us. There's no reason to believe that its impossible for homo sapiens to evolve in that direction.

Anyway, as you said, this is a derail. My appologies for participating in it, I just like the subject.
 
I've said it before, I'll say it again, nothing makes smart people stupid (and arrogantly so) like philosophy.


Something Awful's Doc Evil once summed up philosophy as perfectly as it will ever be summed up:

Philosophy was always a very interesting subject. The word philosophy comes from philo, meaning "wild, mind blowing :rule10 to think about," and sophy, meaning "until you grow up a little more and realize it's a dumb waste of time."

:D
 
Something Awful's Doc Evil once summed up philosophy as perfectly as it will ever be summed up:

Ignorance isn't funny.

The logic and critical thinking vital to skepticism are taught in the philosophy department of a university, not the science department, as are the host of canonical logical fallacies used every day to keep debates on this board honest. For that matter the ethics lecturers will be in the philosophy department, and what we've just spent many pages discussing is the sort of thing you'd discuss in a first year ethics tutorial.

The discussion in a first year philosophy tutorial would be a lot more intelligent than the discussion in this thread, of course.

Metaphysics and Continental Philosophy could arguably fall in a hole without being missed, of course, but we're getting off-topic.
 
If you are suggesting that sociopathy is immoral because it is detrimental to society, I don't see the connection. Why is what is good for society necessarily good?
Because that is the only non-religious source of morals that allows for rational discussion?

(Please note, I think sociopaths are immoral, but not simply by nature of being bad for society)
Then what is the source for the morality that you follow?
 
Because that is the only non-religious source of morals that allows for rational discussion?
Well, I don't see any reason to consider what is good or bad for society to have any direct connection to morality. (I think that what is good for society is in general moral, but I'm much more concerned with individuals than society in general).

Then what is the source for the morality that you follow?
The idea that those things that I consider good for myself are good, and those things that I consider bad for myself are bad. Because I see no meaningful difference between myself and others, I can see that what is good for them is also good.

Of course this is very vague. A good example is that when I suffer (for instance, if someone inflicts pain on me) that is bad. I go from this to conclude that when others suffer, because their suffering is in no meaningful way different from mine, that is also bad, and for the same reasons (whatever they are).

Similarly, when I experience pleasure (for instance eating a good meal) I think of that as a good thing. So I think when others experience pleasure, that's also good. I think that my experience of happiness (for instance, last year I took four months off work to train yoga and brazilian jiu jitsu, and felt very happy throughout that time) is even better than pleasure (though the two are related to some extent), and so if others are happy, I similarly think that's better than simply having access to pleasure.

That's a pretty simplistic summary of my moral viewpoint, but I think it's valid. I don't see why "what's good for society" should be considered in general good. I think it generally is good because it tends to be true that "what's good for society" is "what's good for the individuals who make up that society", but I don't think that's necessarily always the case.
 
The idea that those things that I consider good for myself are good, and those things that I consider bad for myself are bad. Because I see no meaningful difference between myself and others, I can see that what is good for them is also good.
This would seem to preclude you finding anything immoral if it cannot effect you due to category exclusion. E.g, you are not a child, so child labour is not bad for yourself. You are not homeless, so using homeless people for medical experimentation is not bad for you (and may be very good for you, if it leads to a cure for a disease that you might someday suffer from).

Of course this is very vague. A good example is that when I suffer (for instance, if someone inflicts pain on me) that is bad. I go from this to conclude that when others suffer, because their suffering is in no meaningful way different from mine, that is also bad, and for the same reasons (whatever they are).
But how do you judge between conflicting suffering? A criminal held in prison suffers, and this suffering does nothing real to ameliorate any suffering they may have caused in the past. People in a coma have no awareness, so would not suffer at all if they were killed by euthanasia, and their families would in some ways have less suffering as a result.


Similarly, when I experience pleasure (for instance eating a good meal) I think of that as a good thing. So I think when others experience pleasure, that's also good. I think that my experience of happiness (for instance, last year I took four months off work to train yoga and brazilian jiu jitsu, and felt very happy throughout that time) is even better than pleasure (though the two are related to some extent), and so if others are happy, I similarly think that's better than simply having access to pleasure.
And what if someone derives pleasure in a way that causes suffering to others?

Ultimately, what in your morality restricts your own choices and actions? If something causes you a great amount of pleasure, or relieves you a great amount of personal suffering, is it moral to do it, even though it may cause suffering for others, or restrict their ability to experience pleasure?

For example, if you find pleasure in listening to really loud music late at night, but it annoys your neighbours, is it morally right for you to crank up the volume as far as you please?
 
It's ok to make jokes about hanging people. Describing the luscious taste of meat though, that's just evil.
 
It's ok to make jokes about hanging people. Describing the luscious taste of meat though, that's just evil.


It's all about context, see?

Hilarious:

300px-Lynching-of-lige-daniels.jpg




Tragic:

big-mary-lynching.jpg



Kind of like how PeTA doesn't have any problem with suicide bombing missions as long as they're not carried out by donkeys. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I guess my remark must have hit home, if you've all still got sand in your reproductive organs over it.

Mind you, I can say in my defence that I don't think it would actually be funny to hang a black person to spite the civil liberties movement. If I did, I think that would make me a morally revolting, intellectually bankrupt idiot. Whereas I think you guys actually do think it would be funny to kill and eat and animal to spite PETA.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom