Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

So PETA doesn't give a flying @#$% about victims of AIDS, but they do care about people in or near their terrorist targets?

What is your evidence for this absurd conclusion?
 
I think most people would disagree but that's just argument ad numerum.

As opposed to Cain's comment, which was simply an argument ad rectum.

Sorry, the grade-schooler in my head just wanted to make a butt joke. In Latin.

Now back to your regularly scheduled topic.
 
As opposed to Cain's comment, which was simply an argument ad rectum.

Sorry, the grade-schooler in my head just wanted to make a butt joke. In Latin.

Now back to your regularly scheduled topic.
:D

Welcome to the forum Danton. I suspect you will do just fine here.
 
Hmmm....

Evolution has no goals. There is no evolutionary ideal. From an evolutionary perspective a species lacks something only if it is incapable of survival.
Sure, but I wasn't talking about whether they would be lacking something in an evolutionary sense, when I said sociopaths would be lacking something, I was specifically referring to morality: they would still be morally lacking, even if they couldn't see that.

However, given that humans are a social species and given social norms I would have to agree that a sociopath is demonstrably lacking something very significant for his or her functioning in human society.

Only current human society. It's not impossible that our future evolution could lead to a sociopathic species. But regardless of that, they would still be morally lacking.
 
I would like to add to my list Frans de Waal.

Thanks for that: I'm a big fan of Frans de Waal, though I would like to get my hands on more of his books. :)

Regarding your quote, I think it supports the idea that we should extend some moral consideration to animals. Given that they are capable of some form of morality, that suggests to me that whatever it is that we consider meaningful about ourselves, which makes us extend moral consideration to all humans (rather, for instance) than only humans born in the same country as us, some other animals share some of the those characteristics.

Note, there is no "we are the same" here, just, "we have some things in common".
 
Thanks for that: I'm a big fan of Frans de Waal, though I would like to get my hands on more of his books. :)

Regarding your quote, I think it supports the idea that we should extend some moral consideration to animals. Given that they are capable of some form of morality, that suggests to me that whatever it is that we consider meaningful about ourselves, which makes us extend moral consideration to all humans (rather, for instance) than only humans born in the same country as us, some other animals share some of the those characteristics.

Note, there is no "we are the same" here, just, "we have some things in common".

I'm curious why, in your view, having certain things in common means we should extend them moral consideration.

As far as I can see there is no "should" or "ought" without an "in order to".

In other words, there is no such thing as an action that's just good in some abstract sense on it's own, thats sort of a meaningless concept.
 
Only current human society. It's not impossible that our future evolution could lead to a sociopathic species. But regardless of that, they would still be morally lacking.

As mentioned before, sociopaths are detrimental to society, by definition. The label denotes the peak of anti-social (anti-societal) behavior.
 
For those interested, Ingrid Newkirk is going to have an interview today on our public radio station, on the program "Think" (which is otherwise a very good show). Here is the upcoming schedule. There is a live stream you can listen to, and I also believe there are podcasts as well.

I strongly encourage anyone and everyone (who wishes) to call in or send an e-mail to the program to ask about all of Ms. Newkirk's more controversial stances or the types of statments/actions taken that PETA would rather not address in a critical manner on a public forum. Of those:
  • Ingrid Newkirk in a Vogue interview on September 1, 1989: "Animal liberationists do not separate out the human animal, so there is no rational basis for saying that a human being has special rights. A rat is a pig is a dog is a boy. They are all mammals." She is basically taking a reversed approach to stating that animals deserve the same rights as humans.
    .
  • Ingrid Newkirk in the New Yorker magazine, April 23, 2003 (this one is rich): "I’m not only uninterested in having children. I am opposed to having children. Having a purebred human baby is like having a purebred dog; it is nothing but vanity, human vanity." Oh, please please please someone ask her to elaborate on this on the air.
    .
  • Ingrid Newkirk, November 12, 1999, The Chronicle of Higher Education: "Perhaps the mere idea of receiving a nasty missive will allow animal researchers to empathize with their victims for the first time in their lousy careers. I find it small wonder that the laboratories aren’t all burning to the ground. If I had more guts, I’d light a match." This was in reference to mailing threats to medical researchers with razor blades in the mail.
    .
  • Ingrid Newkirk in the US News & World Report, April 8, 2002: "Our nonviolent tactics are not as effective. We ask nicely for years and get nothing. Someone makes a threat, and it works." Yes, she's straight out advocating and excusing making threats as a way to influence practices she disapproves of or dislikes.
    .
  • PETA spokesman Bruce Friedrich (at an AR conference): "I think it would be great if all of the fast-food outlets, slaughterhouses, these laboratories, and the banks that fund them exploded tomorrow. I think it's perfectly appropriate for people to take bricks and toss them through the windows ... Hallelujah to the people who are willing to do it." Yes, that is a public spokesperson for PETA advocating not only criminal behavior, but criminal behavior on a massive scale.
    .
  • One could challenge Newkirk on the "one generation then out" doctrine that, while publicly stated by the president of the HSUS and not PETA, calls for the complete cessation of any and all breeding of domestic animals. The quote: Wayne Pacelle of HSUS, "One generation and out. We have no problems with the extinction of domestic animals. They are creations of human selective breeding." Ask what Newkirk thinks of such a statement. You may also want to add the following quotes of Newkirk's in case she tries to weasel out of it:
    1. "In the end, I think it would be lovely if we stopped this whole notion of pets altogether." - Ingrid Newkirk, Newsday, February 21, 1988
    2. "Pet ownership is an absolutely abysmal situation brought about by human manipulation." - Ingrid Newkirk, Harper's magazine, August 1, 1988
    3. "For one thing, we would no longer allow breeding. People could not create different breeds. There would be no pet shops. If people had companion animals in their homes, those animals would have to be refugees from the animal shelters and the streets. You would have a protective relationship with them just as you would with an orphaned child. But as the surplus of cats and dogs (artificially engineered by centuries of forced breeding) declined, eventually companion animals would be phased out, and we would return to a more symbiotic relationship — enjoyment at a distance." - Ingrid Newkirk, The Harper's Forum Book, 1989 (p.223)
    4. "The bottom line is that people don't have the right to manipulate or to breed dogs and cats... If people want toys, they should buy inanimate objects. If they want companionship, they should seek it with their own kind." Ingrid Newkirk, Animals magazine, May 1, 1993
    5. "We do not advocate "right to life" for animals." - Ingrid Newkirk in a message to Nathan Winograd, a no-kill shelter advocate.

Well, I think those would be a good place to start. Granted, I'm going to send these quotes in an e-mail to the show's producer and host, but if anyone wants to help get these questions actually asked and put PETA and Newkirk on the spot on-air that would be highly illuminating for those who will be listening here in the Dallas area-- particularly considering these animal rights groups just recently got a mandatory spay/neuter law passed last year.

Just a thought. You know, in case anyone was interested and has some free time today at 12 PM CST. :)
 
Last edited:
I just noticed that Newkirk's appearance is no longer listed for the 12PM slot, and that indeed the entire 12 PM slot isn't listed. Perhaps the folks at the radio station are updating their listing at the moment, but in case it doesn't come back up on the website listing, at 12 PM (noon) Central Standard Time (in Dallas), Ingrid Newkirk will be on the program "Think" on the local NPR affiliate.

ETA: yes, the webmasters were moving the schedule around to match today's schedule: http://kera.org/think
 
Last edited:
Here is the e-mail I sent to the program:
GreNME said:
I know that Ingrid Newkirk's appearance on today's upcoming show is for her new book, but I am hoping that a critical analysis of her very radical and fundamentalist stances will be up for discussion in today's show. I'm not speaking simply of her 'animal rights' stance that is often touched on in their media blitzes-- Ingrid Newkirk in a Vogue interview Vogue on September 1, 1989: "Animal liberationists do not separate out the human animal, so there is no rational basis for saying that a human being has special rights. A rat is a pig is a dog is a boy. They are all mammals."-- I am also talking about Newkirk's advocacy for criminal behaviors by groups in more violent animal rights groups as well as her own stated opinion that she wishes for all domestic animals to be eliminated from human society altogether. Ingrid Newkirk has a history of making statements in public and in interviews to this effect, and it would be edifying for your listeners to hear what Newkirk has to say on her very controversial statements. Some examples of such statements:

* Ingrid Newkirk in a Vogue interview on September 1, 1989: "Animal liberationists do not separate out the human animal, so there is no rational basis for saying that a human being has special rights. A rat is a pig is a dog is a boy. They are all mammals." She is basically taking a reversed approach to stating that animals deserve the same rights as humans.
* Ingrid Newkirk in the New Yorker magazine, April 23, 2003: "I’m not only uninterested in having children. I am opposed to having children. Having a purebred human baby is like having a purebred dog; it is nothing but vanity, human vanity." Since humans cannot breed with other animals, statements of this type make no biological sense. Perhaps she could elaborate on the hyperbole.
* Ingrid Newkirk, November 12, 1999, The Chronicle of Higher Education: "Perhaps the mere idea of receiving a nasty missive will allow animal researchers to empathize with their victims for the first time in their lousy careers. I find it small wonder that the laboratories aren’t all burning to the ground. If I had more guts, I’d light a match." This was in reference to mailing threats to medical researchers with razor blades in the mail.
* Ingrid Newkirk in the US News & World Report, April 8, 2002: "Our nonviolent tactics are not as effective. We ask nicely for years and get nothing. Someone makes a threat, and it works." Yes, she's straight out advocating and excusing making threats as a way to influence practices she disapproves of or dislikes.
* Not Ingrid Newkirk, but PETA spokesman Bruce Friedrich (at an AR conference): "I think it would be great if all of the fast-food outlets, slaughterhouses, these laboratories, and the banks that fund them exploded tomorrow. I think it's perfectly appropriate for people to take bricks and toss them through the windows ... Hallelujah to the people who are willing to do it." Yes, that is a public spokesperson for PETA advocating not only criminal behavior, but criminal behavior on a massive scale. Newkirk, on the other hand, has been on record saying the following:
o "I find it small wonder that the laboratories aren’t all burning to the ground. If I had more guts, I’d light a match." - Ingrid Newkirk, November 12, 1999, The Chronicle of Higher Education
* I have yet to see any media interview of Newkirk challenge her on on the "one generation then out" doctrine that, while being called "one generation then out" due to a comment not made by Newkirk, calls for the complete cessation of any and all breeding of domestic animals. The quote: Wayne Pacelle of HSUS, Animal People News, May 1993, "One generation and out. We have no problems with the extinction of domestic animals. They are creations of human selective breeding." While Ingrid Newkirk has not to my knowledge ever said the phrase "one generation then out," she has made the following quotes.
o "In the end, I think it would be lovely if we stopped this whole notion of pets altogether." - Ingrid Newkirk, Newsday, February 21, 1988
o "Pet ownership is an absolutely abysmal situation brought about by human manipulation." - Ingrid Newkirk, Harper's magazine, August 1, 1988
o "For one thing, we would no longer allow breeding. People could not create different breeds. There would be no pet shops. If people had companion animals in their homes, those animals would have to be refugees from the animal shelters and the streets. You would have a protective relationship with them just as you would with an orphaned child. But as the surplus of cats and dogs (artificially engineered by centuries of forced breeding) declined, eventually companion animals would be phased out, and we would return to a more symbiotic relationship — enjoyment at a distance." - Ingrid Newkirk, The Harper's Forum Book, 1989 (p.223)
o "The bottom line is that people don't have the right to manipulate or to breed dogs and cats... If people want toys, they should buy inanimate objects. If they want companionship, they should seek it with their own kind." Ingrid Newkirk, Animals magazine, May 1, 1993
o "We do not advocate "right to life" for animals." - Ingrid Newkirk in a message to Nathan Winograd, a no-kill shelter advocate.

All of these quotes are cited, and are not simply fabricated attacks meant to insult Newkirk. These are statements made by Ingrid Newkirk herself, statements of her opinions and feelings on the issues listed above. Certainly they are applicable as data for a critical evaluation of what her stance truly is, and what her goals in radical advocacy and activism ultimately are. She has openly admitted to helping to pay for the legal defense of activist criminals who have tried to blow up buildings or kill people. An example of her admitting this: Montreal Mirror, March 2002: "M: You guys have taken a lot of heat lately for allegedly supporting occasionally violent organizations like the Animal Liberation Front. What’s up with that?

IN: Well, it’s not like this is anything we are trying to hide. About three times in our 21-year history we have thought it was a good idea—and still do—to defend some very good activists who have done some decent things for animals and who have happened to get into trouble. One of those people is Rodney Coronado, who is a very committed Native American animal rights activist and a decent person. He did something [firebombed a research facility at Michigan State University] that put him in prison for three-and-a-half years and I think that if we hadn’t provided him with a good legal defence he wouldn’t be back out doing productive things in the community again—like the good person that he is. We are very happy to have done that."

Some of the cases she does not mention (which are more than three) are as follows:

* Money given to ELF, who are considered a domestic terrorist organization: "We did it, we did it. We gave $1,500 to the ELF for a specific program." - Lisa Lange of PETA on the Fox News Channel
* PETA paid $27,000 for the legal defense of Roger Troen, who was charged with burglary and arson for a radical 'animal rights' raid on a University of Oregon building.
* PETA gave $7,500 to Fran Stephanie Trutt, who attempted to murder the head of a medical laboratory.
* PETA gave $5,000 to Josh Harper, who attacked Native Americans on a whale hunt. The attack consisted of throwing bombs, shooting flares, and spraying the Native Americans with a fire extinguisher.
* PETA not only paid more than $45,000 in legal costs for Rodney Coronado, but also 'loaned' $25,000 to Coronado's father during the course of the trial.

These are just some of the cases where Ingrid Newkirk's organization has been found to regularly support the legal defense of radical 'animal rights' criminals who have attempted murder, arson, breaking & entering, and other crimes against people in the furtherance of their cause.

I am not asking that the program become a litany of challenges about Newkirk's long and controversial history of radical statements, but I believe it would be for the benefit of everyone listening that a more critical examination of the positions and statements belonging to Ingrid Newkirk be considered during the show, because more often than not these points never come up in media interviews or are dismissed and let go. Considering the seriousness of these issues, I strongly feel that they deserve much more focus than they receive whenever Newkirk or her contemporaries are given air-time.

I'm asking these things not only as a critical thinker, but as a person who believes strongly in helping the health and welfare of animals. I've adopted animals from shelters (my current dog is a beautiful German shepherd who came from Tri-Cities Shelter), my home has been a dog rescue foster home many times (and will be many times in the future), and I am regularly in contact with people who work diligently and with a great deal of dedication to not only rescue dogs from bad situations, but to find them healthy, happy homes instead of winding up euthanized by a shelter-- a practice which PETA partakes in for more than 95% of the animals that they take in, a number which has gone up consistently (to 98%) over the past 15 years with PETA. My friends and myself, who care so much about animals that we often dedicate our free time to them, are so often at odds with PETA (despite their 'animal friendly' claims) and similar organizations that I'm greatly dismayed at the media attention these groups get, though admittedly that is what happens when an organization has such a large budget for media advertising and advocacy, which is lacking from local rescue groups despite the large organizations (like PETA) having huge budgets.

What I am saying is: from the perspective of an animal welfare advocate who deals with the problems facing so many animals here 'on the ground', Ingrid Newkirk does not represent or speak for us who are doing the work. I would strongly urge Think to consider contacting Nathan Winograd, author of the book "Redemption: The myth of pet overpopulation and the No-Kill Revolution", which more accurately examines the animal welfare issues that more people are going to be able to relate to and understand in a non-hyperbolic, non-sexualized-or-glamourized, and less media-frenzied manner.

Yeah, I used some stuff from an earlier post, and I know there's a bit of (purposeful) hyperbole in use on my end as well. Now I'm working on a set of questions to ask if I can get through on the lines there.
 
I'm curious why, in your view, having certain things in common means we should extend them moral consideration.
Well, because I think that there are certain things about us which mean that we should be afforded moral consideration. The fact that we suffer is one of them.
It's the fact that other people share those things in common with me that suggests to me that I should extend them moral consideration.
Some animals share some of those same properties in common with me (though to a lesser extent), and thus I extend them some degree of consideration as well.


As far as I can see there is no "should" or "ought" without an "in order to".
That's fine. I disagree. I think, for instance, even when something that would hurt others will make my life better, I should not do that thing.

In other words, there is no such thing as an action that's just good in some abstract sense on it's own, thats sort of a meaningless concept.

Well, we disagree about that.
 
As mentioned before, sociopaths are detrimental to society, by definition. The label denotes the peak of anti-social (anti-societal) behavior.

Well, if your suggesting that as a counter to the suggestion that a "sociopathic species" could evolve, I don't see the connection. Evolution is a process that occurs at the level of individuals (and even more so, at the level of genes) not species. It doesn't matter, for instance, if sociopathy is detrimental to a species, if it is selected for at the level of genes. Of course, in this environment it isn't, but that doesn't suggest no such environment could exist.

If you are suggesting that sociopathy is immoral because it is detrimental to society, I don't see the connection. Why is what is good for society necessarily good?
(I can see that in general it is good, but not by definition).

(Please note, I think sociopaths are immoral, but not simply by nature of being bad for society)
 
Well, because I think that there are certain things about us which mean that we should be afforded moral consideration. The fact that we suffer is one of them.
It's the fact that other people share those things in common with me that suggests to me that I should extend them moral consideration.
Some animals share some of those same properties in common with me (though to a lesser extent), and thus I extend them some degree of consideration as well.
I personally can't think of anything wrong with this and I suspect that this will be the dominant view in subsequent generations (in spite of PETA). :)
 
Well, because I think that there are certain things about us which mean that we should be afforded moral consideration. The fact that we suffer is one of them.
It's the fact that other people share those things in common with me that suggests to me that I should extend them moral consideration.
Some animals share some of those same properties in common with me (though to a lesser extent), and thus I extend them some degree of consideration as well.

As RandFan says, I don't have a problem with moral consideration, and certainly the world is moving in that direction. I definitely try to live with such moral consideration, but that doesn't have to preclude the raising of domestic animals or eating meat.
 
As RandFan says, I don't have a problem with moral consideration, and certainly the world is moving in that direction. I definitely try to live with such moral consideration, but that doesn't have to preclude the raising of domestic animals or eating meat.

I agree. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom