Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

You don't get to do that without being called on it if you're been claiming for ten pages that you're a moral relativist.
I've never claimed to being a strict moral relatavist.

...we can construct an ethical system that generates a morality that is neither dogmatically absolute nor irrationally relative — a provisional morality for an age of science that provides empirical evidence and a rational basis for belief.

...a new theory of provisional ethics that challenges the reader to confront these timeless issues from a new perspective — one that suggests that both morality and immorality evolved in human biological and cultural evolution, that we can make free moral choices in a determined universe, that moral principles can have a sound rational basis supported by empirical evidence (without being dogmatically absolutist or dependent on an external source of validation), and that we can be good without God.
That's it Kevin. I don't give a damn if you don't like it.
 
Note that this is and has been my position and no one, not Kevin or Cain has invalidated a single premise.

So, they invent arguments for me AKA strawmen.

...I'm getting very sick of this.

1. Moral sentiment is an adaptive behavior (see Dawkins, Shermer, Pinker, Wright, de Waal, etc.)

Not quite right. Some moral sentiments are the result of evolutionary pressure towards behaviour that was adaptive in the past. Close though. Depending on what you include in the set of moral sentiments, some moral sentiments might be the result of reason too.

What we percieve as "moral" is formed by many things including evolved adaptive traits.

True.

We can reason beyond our adaptive traits (we need not be slaves to our nature, and besides, our nature is contradictory as it is).

This is the claim that has been responded to specifically, repeatedly and very recently, so claiming it has never been addressed is indicative of dishonesty or stupidity.

HOW do you think we can we "reason beyond" these adaptive, instinctive feelings, and where are we reasoning to? On what basis are we adopting some instinctive feelings as moral, and others as immoral?

The only offerings you've given us are social convenience or utility, which would make you a fascist objectivist consequentialist, or pain and suffering which would make you an objectivist hedonistic utilitarian.

In other words you've built a castle in the clouds of moral relativism, appeals to the naturalistic fallacy and pure denial. But when your castle encounters the real world, you have to immediately abandon it and become an objectivist or you end up with conclusions you can't stomach.

Yet you can't admit this after spending pages denying that objectivist moral philosophies make any sense, and more recently getting absolutism muddled with objectivism.

That something is natural doesn't make it right (we should not confuse "is" with "ought").

Yet throughout this thread you have constantly tried to introduce adaptive behaviours or sentiments as relevant to "ought" claims, and then constantly denied that you were doing this.

If there is a disconnect between "is" and "ought", you need to bridge that gap between the existence of instincts and the moral imperative to obey those instincts in some cases.

All you have to offer to bridge that gap, when we press you on it, are varying flavours of objectivist utilitarianism.

Now, identify which premise you deem wrong and we will address that.

Based on your previous behaviour I doubt it.
 
...I'm getting very sick of this.
I can assure you that you are not as sick of me as I am sick of you which is why I put you on ignore in the first place. I've been on this forum for a long time and it is rare that I run into anyone as incapable of understanding such a simple point and who has gone to such lengths to protect his precious ego.

Depending on what you include in the set of moral sentiments, some moral sentiments might be the result of reason too.
Pedantic but fine, I agree, not the point. My point was that our capacity for moral sentiment is an adaptive trait.

Hallelujah! Better late than never.

... is indicative of dishonesty or stupidity.
Yeah, personal abuse is always a good way to avoid being put on ignore.

HOW do you think we can we "reason beyond" these adaptive, instinctive feelings, and where are we reasoning to?
Are you saying that you lack the means to reason morality? Really?

Here's the thing Kevin, you can choose whatever moral reasoning you want and you can either take into account sociobiology or not.

That's it. All of the hand waving and brow beating is ENTIRELY beside the point. You may insert any moral philosophy you want into the blank line. RandFan is a __________. I don't care. I have a moral philosophy but I don't need to justify that philosophy to you.

I DON'T argue that adaptive behaviors must be taken into account to reason morality. I think it wise that we do so. So, I don't give a **** what you use to reason your morality. I'm with Pinker, Dawkins et al.

  • I think that the negative aspects of torture outweigh any benifits of torture.
  • I wouldn't want to be tortured.
  • Formulating a morality where I'm not tortured increases the likelyhood that I won't be tortured.
  • It distrubs me when I find out that others have been tortured.

If there is a disconnect between "is" and "ought", you need to bridge that gap between the existence of instincts and the moral imperative to obey those instincts in some cases.
No. I only need recognize moral instincts and how they inform our morality.
 
Last edited:
?

You are a bit late. I allready covered that (see post 563).

Um... that's the post I was referencing.

To sum up. Kevin is engaging in a strawman.

**** you, no. You always pull this ****. You reference these one word fallacies (even though "straw man" is two words) without any explanation whatsoever. But then I complained about this over five years ago. Anyway, it has a lot to do with you not knowing what you're talking about.

No. I answered the question so accusing me of avoiding it is a lie.

Where did you answer it? Quote your answer. Instead you asked ESS questions.

Actually, Kevin introduced me to Singer's expanding circle long before that.

Here's a gold star.

That's right. I did reach a value judgement based on reason and considering feelings. My morals produce greater well being for a greater number of people for a small sacrifice of giving up the Vampires desire to consume human blood. And my morals can resolve the first person question posed in your Shermer post.

Then this certainly does smack of a utilitarianism. You cannot parachute in self-contradictory beliefs when it is convenient to do so. It's like saying you're vegan between meals.

Oh, and the signature thing. Earlier I clicked on this thread, saw that post, and wondered if I had the right page (page 15). I'm not sure why you would again demand I change it if you're having so much fun reveling in a delicious irony, or whatever nonsense you wrote. Well, you can keep that up. Hell, if you post the hyperlink code, I'll put it into my sig. That argument is not anything you should be proud of. Anyone can reasonably dismiss a typo -- "what make rape wrong?" but that mess?
 
Is there a society filled with these individuals? Has this behavior resulted in an ESS?

What difference does it make? You're avoiding the question with a vague appeal to society. Are you looking for an efficient ratio of rapists to non-rapists?
I'm pointing out to you that a society filled with such people would likely be selected against (it's not likely to result in an ESS). There's a reason I point that out. You see, there's a reason evolution works. It's not perfect but for social animals it is not likely to produce animals who are largely anti-social.
 
Last edited:
I can assure you that you are not as sick of me as I am sick of you which is why I put you on ignore in the first place. I've been on this forum for a long time and it is rare that I run into anyone as incapable of understanding such a simple point and who has gone to such lengths to protect his precious ego.

You're so far off base it's not funny. The problem is not failure to "understand a simple point", it's that I understand the point very well and no matter how many times you restate it it is still a load of bollocks.

As far as my own ego goes, I've never put forward my own moral philosophy in detail in this thread. I've never even stated my own opinion or practises about the consumption of meat in this thread. This isn't about my ego, it's about your pet moral philosophy and it's glaring inconsistencies, which I'm not going to pretend do not exist no matter how much you shout.

Hallelujah! Better late than never.

To quote Cain, *** you. No. You don't get to pull that one.

I've taken for granted from the start people's that people's moral beliefs (note that I'm just talking about what individual people walking around believe) are influenced by their inherited behavioural tendencies.

What I've been arguing, with complete consistency, also from the start, is that this tells us nothing about whether those beliefs they are walking around with are actually moral.

Are you saying that you lack the means to reason morality? Really?

This has got to be up there with the stupidest straw men in this very stupid thread full of straw men.

Here's the thing Kevin, you can choose whatever moral reasoning you want and you can either take into account sociobiology or not.

That's it. All of the hand waving and brow beating is ENTIRELY beside the point. You may insert any moral philosophy you want into the blank line. RandFan is a __________. I don't care. I have a moral philosophy but I don't need to justify that philosophy to you.

I DON'T argue that adaptive behaviors must be taken into account to reason morality. I think it wise that we do so. So, I don't give a **** what you use to reason your morality.

So it's not a problem for you if your precious philosophy is internally inconsistent? If your beliefs don't actually make any sense? If it's nothing more than an overcomplicated, pseudointellectual way of reverse engineering your existing moral beliefs with the aid of pop science?
 
Last edited:
The problem is not failure to "understand a simple point"...
It's exactly the point.

As far as my own ego goes, I've never put forward my own moral philosophy in detail in this thread.
BFD. Your ego doesn't necassette you puting forward your philosophy. It's certainly with in the realm of possibility that your ego dictates your disagreement with what you think I've said.

To quote Cain, *** you.
And YOU are lecturing me about morality. Nice.



What I've been arguing, with complete consistency, also from the start, is that this tells us nothing about whether those beliefs they are walking around with are actually moral.
  • BS (you've resisted from the start that adaptive traits have anything to do with morality and only relented after pages of my posting support from experts like de Waal, Dawkins and others.
  • There's no such thing as "actual" morality.
I don't know how I can make that any more clear. Of everything we've discussed nothing could be more stark than that silly assertion that there is "actual" morality is pure nonsense. It doesn't exist and never has. Morality only became a concept (as far as we know) when humans evolved and reasoned moral sentiment (other animals do in fact have moral sentiment, see de Waal).

So it's not a problem for you if your precious philosophy is internally inconsistent? If your beliefs don't actually make any sense? If it's nothing more than an overcomplicated, pseudointellectual way of reverse engineering your existing moral beliefs with the aid of pop science?
I'm not infaliable nor am I dogmatic. I'm not incapable of changing any belief. I've chaned many beliefs over the years.

I provisionally accept the arguments made by Shermer, Wright et al. I didn't invent anything nor did I consciously add anything. I'm happy to go back to the sources and correct any error.

But that's not the point.

What I stated about sociobiology and evolutionary psychology I stand by and no one has rebutted it.
 
Last edited:
BS (you've resisted from the start that adaptive traits have anything to do with morality and only relented after pages of my posting support from experts like de Waal, Dawkins and others.

Nope. Wrong. That is purely your straw man, and one I've pointed out many times before. It's never been anything other than your straw man.

Adaptive traits have nothing to do with morality, if we are speaking about morality as what is actually moral. They have something to do with what people walking around on the street believe to be moral, but then again so do religion and cultural values, and they aren't determinative of right and wrong either.

There's no such thing as "actual" morality.

You keep saying that. Yet when the rubber meets the road you just can't get out of invoking objectivist utilitarianism to justify your specific moral beliefs.

That's the contradiction you can't get out of, constantly snip from my posts, and utterly refuse to address.

If there's no such thing as actual morality, then slavery, genocide, torture, public executions for petty crimes, shooting street children, gassing the disabled, cannibalism and so on aren't actually morally wrong. They're just arguably inefficient ways to do things, and the minute someone shows the maths to demonstrate that society would be better off gassing everyone in our mental asylums then you'd have to endorse it.

I know you don't actually believe that. You are just unwilling or unable to pursue your stated beliefs to their logically necessary conclusions.

I don't know how I can make that any more clear. Of everything we've discussed nothing could be more stark than that silly assertion that there is "actual" morality. It doesn't exist and never has. Morality only became a concept (as far as we know) when humans evolved moral sentiment.

Yet you just can't get out of invoking objectivist utilitarianism to justify your specific moral beliefs.

What I stated about sociobiology and bio-ethics I stand by and no one has rebutted it.

Oh please. What you've stated about the facts of sociobiology nobody even disagrees with, so of course nobody has rebutted it. It doesn't make your overall position consistent though, and the inconsistency in your stated position is the problem you keep running away from or denying even exists.
 
Last edited:
It's never been anything other than your straw man.
It's demonstrably correct. I've quoted you criticizing me for thinking that morality had anything to do with adaptive traits (paraphrased).

Adaptive traits have nothing to do with morality, if we are speaking about morality as what is actually moral.
There is no such thing.

You keep saying that. Yet when the rubber meets the road you just can't get out of invoking objectivist utilitarianism to justify your specific moral beliefs.
You are conflating the ability to make objective statements about morality with objective morality. They aren't the same.

If there's no such thing as actual morality, then slavery, genocide, torture, public executions for petty crimes, shooting street children, gassing the disabled, cannibalism and so on aren't actually morally wrong.
Thaaaaaats riiiiiight!!!!
They're just arguably inefficient ways to do things, and the minute someone shows the maths to demonstrate that society would be better off gassing everyone in our mental asylums then you'd have to endorse it.
There's a few problems with that.
  • My society evolved to see gassing mental patients as immoral and I, as a member of that society, have been indoctrinated with that morality (I, to a large extent share the moral zietgeist).
  • I have empathy and it would cause me to suffer to simply gas people who are weak.
  • I might someday become infirm and I don't want anyone to be easily able to exterminate me (supporting the prohibition increases the likelyhood that I won't be exterminated).
  • I've not seen any argument that would compel me to call for their extermination in the face of the above facts. You've certainly not presented one so far.
You'll have to do better if you want me to agree to eugenics or anything approaching it. BTW: Killing the infirm in social societies doesn't appear to be selected for. But I'll grant that predation would likely make that a moot point.
 
Last edited:
I'm pointing out to you that a society filled with such people would likely be selected against (it's not likely to result in an ESS). There's a reason I point that out. You see, there's a reason evolution works. It's not perfect but for social animals it is not likely to produce animals who are largely anti-social.

Earlier you accused me of lying: "No. I answered the question so accusing me of avoiding it is a lie." When called upon this accusation to quote your answer you cite two questions you asked me and now you're saying those two questions made up a coherent answer? You also misunderstood the example, which involved genetic engineering, not natural selection. Oh, and you still failed to answer the question.

Everybody's sick of this thread, including myself, and I'm a raging moron for wasting so much of my Sunday talking to the Supreme Emperor of the Dunces, so I'll stop. I have work tomorrow, stuff I should have done today.
 
Earlier you accused me of lying: "No. I answered the question so accusing me of avoiding it is a lie." When called upon this accusation to quote your answer you cite two questions you asked me and now you're saying those two questions made up a coherent answer? You also misunderstood the example, which involved genetic engineering, not natural selection. Oh, and you still failed to answer the question.
I sincerely thought I had been clear. Your question is nonsensical. It's like asking "what if we engineered square circles?"

Anti-social people are by definition not good for society. Your hypo is fatally flawed. That's why I pointed out that no society existed with a large population of anti-social people as an ESS.

There's a point to decent with modification and natural selection. Anti-social people tend to be selected against so claiming that you could engineer a society populated with antisocial types that would also be good for society is rather silly.

That's part of the problem you and Kevin are having IMO. You don't get that social evolution results in certain traits by default (social behavior). It's not perfect. It's going to include a percentage of anti-social folks but that won't be the norm. Recpricol altruism (see game theory) will be the norm.
 
Last edited:
It's demonstrably correct. I've quoted you criticizing me for thinking that morality had anything to do with adaptive traits (paraphrased).

Yes you did. I've explained to you repeatedly that in those instances I was using "morality" to mean objective morality, not sociological whatever-people-think-is-moral.

I tend to do that, because the alternatives (moral relativism and moral absolutism) are so inane that they are scarecely worth discussing.

You're about unique in clinging to moral relativism even after the problems with it have been explained.

There is no such thing.

You are conflating the ability to make objective statements about morality with objective morality. They aren't the same.

You haven't got a clue what I'm saying, but we knew that.

Look, you either get to claim "there is no objective morality" or you get to appeal to objectivist utilitarianism. You don't get both.

Thaaaaaats riiiiiight!!!! There's a few problems with that.

My society evolved to see gassing mental patients as immoral and I, as a member of that society, have been indoctrinated with that morality (I, to a large extent share the moral zietgeist).

This is moral relativism. Moral relativism is incoherent.

I have empathy and it would cause me to suffer to simply gas people who are weak.

Not everyone throughout history has shared your views. Anyway, since people's empathetic responses differ this is moral relativism, and moral relativism is incoherent.

I might someday become infirm and I don't want anyone to be easily able to exterminate me (supporting the prohibition increases the likelyhood that I won't be exterminated).

This is self-interest. A moral philosophy which is indistinguishable from self-interest is uninteresting to say the least.

I've not seen any argument that would compel me to call for their extermination in the face of the above facts. You've certainly not presented one so far.

That's not the point, as I suspect you are well aware. I have always phrased these arguments in the form "if it turned out that atrocities X, Y and Z were efficient you would have to endorse them".

I'm not saying that you're the kind of immoral person who supports genocide. If what you've just stated is an accurate depiction of your moral thinking though you are the kind of person who would endorse genocide if their society told them to endorse it, and it turned out to be efficient, and it was in your interests.

You'll have to do better if you want me to agree to eugenics or anything approaching it. BTW: Killing the infirm in social societies doesn't appear to be selected for. But I'll grant that predation would likely make that a moot point.

Not universally true.
 
You're about unique in clinging to moral relativism even after the problems with it have been explained.
Straw man.

Look, you either get to claim "there is no objective morality" or you get to appeal to objectivity utilitarianism. You don't get both.
Nonsense. And for crying in the dark, if I make a point address the point and don't just gainsay. You are conflating objective morality with making objective statements about morality. Look, I can make objective statements about art. That doesn't mean that art is objective.

Now, if I'm wrong you are going to have to do better than simply contradicting me.

...this is moral relativism, and moral relativism is incoherent.

This is self-interest. A moral philosophy which is indistinguishable from self-interest is uninteresting to say the least.
Blithely stating something doesn't make it so. Self interest alone might be uninteresting but it can very well be part of one's moral philosophy. IOW, there's nothing to preclude self interest as a consideration in formulating a moral theory. All else being equal a society with a lower likelyhood of harm to oneself is a better choice. Besides, wanting to live in a society for reciprocal altruistic purposes is not simply self-interest. And that you find such a theory uninteresting is hardly a persuasive argument.

That's not the point, as I suspect you are well aware. I have always phrased these arguments in the form "if it turned out that atrocities X, Y and Z were efficient you would have to endorse them".
They would have to not only be efficient but they would have to meet the criteria of my conscience.

I'm not saying that you're the kind of immoral person who supports genocide. If what you've just stated is an accurate depiction of your moral thinking though you are the kind of person who would endorse genocide if their society told them to endorse it, and it turned out to be efficient, and it was in your interests.
And IF my conscience and sense of empathy didn't dictate otherwise. I strongly suspect that my conscience would be pricked. The suffering of others bothers me significantly. I'd like to think that I would be one who would risk his life to hide Anne Frank. I don't know that for a fact.

Nothing about what I've said can predict how I would act had I been raised and indoctrinated in another society with different social mores.

Few things if any about social norms are universally true.
 
Last edited:
I've got to go to bed and I don't know when I'll be able to log back on.

'night.

One more thing if I may.

And I don't blame you for critizing me on this as it is late in the game and I should have brought up earlier. Still it is a position that I hold.

I'm very skeptical of personal moral philosophy. I think it likely that individuals are more apt to rationalize their beliefs rather than adopt a coherent and logically valid philosophy on the grounds that it is reasonable and logical.

How does one control for confirmation bias? How do you know that you are not simply picking a theory that fits with your own moral sentiment or that your stated moral philosophy represents what you truly believe? How many Germans believed that they would have acted differently in the course of the Holocaust before it happened?

I honestly don't know. I do know that my philosophy has caused me to jettison a number of ideas that I think I'm better for including the acceptance of gay rights which even Obama and the a majority of the state of California is against. I did so largely because I reasoned that my personal opinions about gays and lesbians did not trump their rights as individuals. I put myself in their position and I thought I would not want to be treated the same. I also believe that if I live in a society that values the rights of individuals then my rights are more likely to be valued.

I honestly considered these things.

I don't know how many people do this and alter their decisions contrary to their personal feelings.

No, the conclusions I came to do not prove that my reasoning was sound but I think it was.
 
Last edited:

Ah, touche.

Well, that settles it. Never mind you're claiming I am excusing behavior that I am not.

Your response to PETAs call to violence was "You have to understand, animals are getting hurt!" when it should have been "I am disgusted by the call to violence and want only peaceful debate".

You were at the very least excusing it, if not outright endorsing it.

Never mind you claim animal rights terrorists do not mind blowing up buildings full of people, even though they do.

No... no, they don't. That's a silly assumption to make given what they've actually said.

In fact, I think they prefer the buildings to be loaded with people. It isn't terrorism if it doesn't terrorize.

Consider again, PETAs position on the fruits of medical research: "Even if animal tests produced a cure for AIDS, we’d be against it."

Now Ingrid Newkirk is a bloodthirsty sociopath, but I don't believe she is an idiot. She knows what AIDS is, she knows what it does and she knows what will continue to happen without a cure or a reliable treatment.

But she doesn't care.

Compare PETA founder Newkirks comment with PETA spokesman Freidrichs quote: "I think it would be great if all of the fast-food outlets, slaughterhouses, these laboratories, and the banks that fund them exploded tomorrow."

Note that his position is identical to Newkirks. Better that people should die than lab rats.

PETA has never said that it wants it's targets to be empty when they or their operatives carry out their attacks. And given their complete and utter disregard for sufferers of AIDS or other diseases, there is no reason to assume such.

The fact that Animus couldn't come up with anything other than a science fiction movie for his model of a bloodless terror campaign should tell you how realistic such an expectation is.
 
Last edited:
Let's wrap up this exchange as well.

Your response to PETAs call to violence was "You have to understand, animals are getting hurt!" when it should have been "I am disgusted by the call to violence and want only peaceful debate".

Which demonstrates you are ignoring the context of my remarks. We're talking about terrorist groups who blow up buildings and take care not to harm anyone, which runs contrary to Osama Bin Laden, who, as far as I know, wants to kill as many infidels as people. You see how those two philosophies are opposed? One which does not like the killing and the other that does?

Techno claimed eco-terrorists could still harm people because the flames might get out of control, or the bomb might not go off when it should. Indeed, and the terrorists would be responsible for those deaths. Now that we have incorporated this moral understanding into our outlook, and if we all accept it, then let's apply it to factory farms and slaughterhouses, where "unintended" abuses invariably take place.

And what sort of response do we see against a call for coherency? Nothing except faux outrage and mistaken allegations of a fallacy people do not understand, improperly capitalize, and, I'm guessing, probably cannot pronounce. In other words, angry cluelessness across the board.

You were at the very least excusing it, if not outright endorsing it.

And here are my controversial remarks:
These are important considerations. Now import the same type of reasoning to the slaughterhouse and the factory farm, where you have documented mistreatment (not at all surprising given the billions of animals processed each year). An unnecessary exercise but, if you want, compare this to the number of people eco-terrorists have actually hurt or killed.

The first sentence, as I clarified in numerous follow up posts in case the meaning somehow escaped anyone, agrees the considerations are valid. In other words, eco-terrorists would be responsible for the deaths of firefighters, people unaccounted for in the building, and so on even if far greater crimes are committed inside the building they're blowing up, or 10,000 miles away, or 20,000 years ago. I assume we all agree with that, yes? Cool. Now if you think this is an appropriate moral standard, then apply it consistently. Importantly, in the case of factory farms and slaughterhouses we do not use the words "if" and "could" because we're not speculating about some future death that may or may not happen; we'd instead be talking about deaths that have happened, are happening, and will continue to happen. But you people are incapable of confronting that argument, hence the tantrums, mistaken "fallacies," and misguided self-righteousness.

As for the rest of your post, you are talking out of your butthole. Perhaps RandFan can translate. I'm not fluent in butthole, but I've picked up a few things from this thread, and most of what you're saying is just irrelevant to the idea of foreseeable consequences and I'm not going to get baited into a discussion outside the purview of my original comments.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom