Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

Yes, I'm a dogmatic believer in the fact that fallacies are fallacies, no matter how often you repeat them. In fact, I'm a complete fundamentalist about the matter, much as I'm a fundamentalist about 2+2 being 4. There's no scope for "nuance", they're just fallacies.
Kevin,

I'm sorry but that ship has sailed. There's no controversy here. I've given you ample evidence. I can't make you accept it.

My stance is the same stance as Dawkins and all of the others. If you don't like it then there's nothing more I can do for you. I'd recomend you read one of the books but you and I both know that that will never happen because they don't conform to your world view.

Then again, perhaps you could send them all letters to inform them why they are wrong. Demanding however that my views differ from theirs though just isn't going to fly and I'm not going to sit here and demand over and over that you accept what is so bloody obvious. I'd as easily convince a flat earther that the world was round.

Sorry.
 
Last edited:
Kevin,

I'm sorry but that ship has sailed. There's no more controversy here than there is between evolution and creation.

I think you're right, but you're not on the side of the divide you think you are. If you rock in to a moral philosophy course at an accredited university some time I think you'll find that amongst the people whose job it is to study the topic, the naturalistic fallacy has no currency.

I've given you ample evidence. I can't make you accept it. So all this "put your left foot in absolutism and your right foot in relavatism is your dance not mine." I only reject your false dichotomy.

The dichotomy between sociological "morality" and objectivist moral philosophy is very real. You're not rejecting a false dichotomy, you're clinging to a self-contradictory mishmash position.

My stance is the same stance as Dawkins and all of the others. If you don't like it then there's nothing more I can do for you. I'd recomend you read one of the books but you and I both know that that will never happen because they don't conform to your world view.

You're assuming, possibly because you think having read those books makes you clever, that I don't already have some of them on my bookshelf. I assure you I'm well up to date on the topic, and there's absolutely nothing in them incompatible with my world view.

Your appropriation of their work to bolster your deeply confused foray into the realm of moral philosophy is the problem, not their work.

Then again, perhaps you could send them all letters to inform them why they are wrong. Demanding that my views differ from theirs though just isn't going to fly.

Sorry.

Okay then. Do one last thing for me.

Tell us what you mean when you use the word "morality".

Do you mean:

1. "Whatever people think is moral".
2."Objective moral rules that apply to all people in relevantly similar circumstances".
3."Both! Neither! Something in between! Whatever! Straw man false dichotomy! You just don't understand me because I'm so nuanced! I tell you I've read DAWKINS!".
 
I think you'll find that amongst the people whose job it is to study the topic, the naturalistic fallacy has no currency.
{sigh}

Kevin, come on. This really doesn't become you. You know better.

Tell us what you mean when you use the word "morality".
I'll answer that question if you will answer one of mine.

#1: In his discussion of morality Dawkins says: "I think there is kindness, charity and generosity in human nature and I think there is a Darwinian explanation for this" what does he mean?


#2:
  1. Many birds species evolved so that one sibling often kills the other.
  2. Ornithologists have determined that it is because there is not enough time given gestation for a number of species to have a second offspring should the first one die in the crucial time after birth. So, an ESS is to have two eggs and if both survive one kills the other because the parents are not likely to gather enough food to assure the survival of both (that's pretty close as I remember anyway).
  3. Assume that humans had evolved like these birds so that one sibling was required to kill the other for the survival of the species.
  4. Would that be moral?
It would be generous of you if you could answer both. If not I'd prefer question #1 but I'd accept #2.
 
Last edited:
{sigh}

Kevin, come on. This really doesn't become you. You know better.

I'll answer that question if you will answer one of mine.

Deal.

#1: In his discussion of morality Dawkins says: "I think there is kindness, charity and generosity in human nature and I think there is a Darwinian explanation for this" what does he mean?

He means that under certain circumstances humans, for biological reasons that evolved over time due to natural selection, tend to exhibit kindness, charity and generosity.

Note that he did not say that this is what morality solely consists of, nor that this is the sole reason anyone acts morally, nor that these adaptive behaviours imply anything about objective moral values. He is making absolutely no philosophical claim, merely stating what he thinks is a factual one about human behaviour and its origins.

#2:
It would be generous of you if you could answer both. If not I'd prefer question #1 but I'd accept #2.

#2 is not relevant to the topic under discussion.

Now can you answer my question?
 
He means that under certain circumstances humans, for biological reasons that evolved over time due to natural selection, tend to exhibit kindness, charity and generosity.

Note that he did not say that this is what morality solely consists of, nor that this is the sole reason anyone acts morally, nor that these adaptive behaviours imply anything about objective moral values. He is making absolutely no philosophical claim, merely stating what he thinks is a factual one about human behaviour and its origins.
Thank you. FTR: I never said that adaptive behavior is what morality solely consists of nor that it is the sole reason anyone acts morally and I never claimed that adaptive behaviours imply anything about objective moral values.

However, it's arguable, that he is making absolutely no philosophical claims.

#2 is not relevant to the topic under discussion.
It's relevant but a deal is a deal, unfortunate but fair enough.

Descriptive: Rules for behavior resulting from a complex dynamic and the interplay of society, individual conscience and philosophy that make up that dynamic (I would grudgingly include religion).

Normative: Moral skeptic. Morality is percieved and not a priori. There does not exist values independent of our subjective perceptions that is objective and axiomatic.

Meta-ethics: I think Shermer says it best. “…we can construct an ethical system that generates a morality that is neither dogmatically absolute nor irrationally relative — a provisional morality for an age of science that provides empirical evidence and a rational basis for belief.” -- The Science of Good and Evil

What Shermer means is that we can examine our human nature and reason morality based on our empathy, compassion, and near-universal moral perceptions (I know this is where your sticking point is and if you are just going to assert naturalistic fallacy without asking how this is possible then there really is nothing left to discuss). However, let me note that I'm not saying that empathy dictates what we should do but we can consider empathy when we decide what we ought to do.

Finally, from Peter Singer.

The Triviality of the Debate Over 'Is-Ought' and the Definition of 'Moral'

"No definition of morality can bridge the gap between facts and action. Nor does any one definition of morality have any important overall advantages as against the other plausible definitions that have been suggested. It follows that the disputes over the definition of morality and over the "is-ought" problem are disputes over words which raise no really significant issues."
 
Last edited:
Descriptive: Rules for behavior resulting from a complex dynamic and the interplay of society, individual conscience and philosophy that make up that dynamic (I would grudgingly include religion).

Normative: Moral skeptic. Morality is percieved and not a priori. There does not exist values independent of our subjective perceptions that is objective and axiomatic.

Meta-ethics: I think Shermer says it best. “…we can construct an ethical system that generates a morality that is neither dogmatically absolute nor irrationally relative — a provisional morality for an age of science that provides empirical evidence and a rational basis for belief.” -- The Science of Good and Evil

Hang on, you've just cut and pasted some stuff using terms you've never used before, in sentences which aren't even grammatical.

Which of those is supposed to be the definition of how you have been using the term "morality" throughout this thread?
 
I don't know how many times I can say this before it gets through: human beings have no instincts.

Depends what you define as instincts. I tend to get out of a speeding truck's way pretty instinctively. And my reaction to seeing this picture of Jessica Alba...



...is pretty instinctual.
 
Hang on, you've just cut and pasted some stuff using terms you've never used before, in sentences which aren't even grammatical.

You know, your act is getting real boring. If I thought for a moment that you were sincere and that you would like to have a conversation and this wasn't all about your ego then I'd happily accommodate you. However it looks like that all you want to do is play some gotcha game. I'm not really interested.

Welcome to ignore.
 
Last edited:
Nonsense. Besides the Shermer and Singer quotes I didn't cut and paste in anything and there isn't a single term I've that I've used that I've never used before. Pick a term and I'll show you that I've used it before. Is this a test of grammer? What is the purpose of your question?

You didn't give coherent answer, you just gave us word salad. I have no idea which, if any, of your bolded headings are supposed to represent your views and it looks to me very much like you googled "morality" and made a half-arsed attempt at summarising something you found without really understanding it.

There has been no single usage. I've told you that morality is contextual.

So you're not incoherent and inconsistent, you're just so contextual and nuanced that you can't explain yourself in plain English? And it's my fault for not correctly defining the "contextual" meaning of morality each time you used it, when you can't even explain that "contextual" meaning now yourself?

  • I've told you that I don't accept absolute morality.
  • I've told you that morality is not a priori.
  • I've told you that morality is simply rules of behavior.
I've used them all and they are not in conflict.
So what on earth is the problem Kevin?

This is very slightly better than word salad, but it's still nothing like an honest definition of what you've actually been meaning by "morality".

Almost nobody except religious kooks accept absolute morality. Almost nobody except Kant thinks morality is a priori. So those two statements eliminate almost nothing - it's like describing your political views by saying "Well I'm not a communist, and I'm not a libertarian. Am I being unclear? What on Earth is the problem?".

Saying that "moraity is simply rules of behavior" is progress towards an intelligible statement, but it's so vague as to be useless. Are these rules objective ones that apply to all people in relevantly similar circumstances, are they mere social conventions, or what?

Since this is the third time I've asked this very specific question I find it hard to believe you don't understand what I'm asking you. Yet you give dot points and evasive, unclear responses instead of a straightforward answer. What's on Earth is the problem?
 
Utilitarianism is an empirical philosophy and possesses mechanisms to generate all sorts of heuristics (e.g., work within the law). Indeed, one argument against utilitarianism is that it can be used to support almost any course of action, which is precisely why it's silly to say the utilitarian answer. There are two-tiered approaches. However, no specific moral doctrine is necessary when it comes to justifying restrictions on human use of animals. You have some Kantian advocating animal rights, and others (indeed, utilitarians are not so big on rights at all except as useful construct).

You're just backpedaling now, because as you've repeatedly droned on about in the other thread and this one, the utilitarian 'answer' (according to you) has one conclusion. So, are you applying this utilitarian concept you're claiming I don't understand in a mistaken fashion? That you don't believe a utilitarian approach misses some of the forest through the trees isn't going to be a very convincing argument that it isn't.

More interestingly your "explanation" for how "It also displays a fundamental rift between the Animal Rights groups and those who advocate Animal Welfare" is strained at best. You're basically speaking nonsense, which is why I advised caution, though perhaps I should have counseled you to withdraw your comment entirely.

Yes, more of your pretending to be some authority figure in this thread. Cain, I don't really care about your cautions or counsel. You seem to grow more and more self-righteous with every post, like some kind of Incredibly Hulk-like creature where it's only your head that grows to immense proportions. In all honesty and with all due respect, I don't give a damn about your assumed self-righteousness except that it gets in the way of you constructively contributing to the conversation.

You're just double-dipping in teh crazy sauce. Rather than ignoring them, animal rights philosophers confront (alleged) significant distinctions head-on. And you also still do not seem to understand what moral absolutism means.

You mean like Sztybel, who repeatedly produces papers (like The Rights of Animal Persons) that essentially (in long form) dismiss those distinctions? Or like Gary Francione, who consistently argues that there should be little to no legal distinction? Rather than just tossing personal insults when you have no fact-based refutation, you may want to check your 'animal rights philosophers' to see what they're actually arguing. Or not, if you want, since it's really a decision only you can make. However, don't try to play these "you don't know what you're talking about" games with someone who has read plenty of these 'animal rights philosophers' (which I tend to call 'liberationists').

As to moral absolutism's definition: the position that certain actions are absolutely wrong or absolutely right regardless of context. That pretty much describes your position on eating meat to a 'T'. Sure, you use 'utilitarian philosophy' as your excuse to ignore context-- which I'm sure works for you, but obviously it ain't working for most of the rest of us-- but you're pretty much consistent on the absolutely wrong part.

Now, your turn to reply back about how I obviously have no clue what I'm talking about. :rolleyes:
 
#2 is not relevant to the topic under discussion.

That really tops it as your most intellectually dishonest statement in this thread, Kevin. In fact, this may very well be the most intellectually dishonest statement from anyone in this thread (and I'm even including quotes from elsewhere used here). The irony, considering your numerous comments regarding the 'what if' and rape, is completely staggering.
 
That really tops it as your most intellectually dishonest statement in this thread, Kevin. In fact, this may very well be the most intellectually dishonest statement from anyone in this thread (and I'm even including quotes from elsewhere used here). The irony, considering your numerous comments regarding the 'what if' and rape, is completely staggering.
I've got him on ignore. He's really left the reservation.
 
Since this is the third time I've asked this very specific question I find it hard to believe you don't understand what I'm asking you. Yet you give dot points and evasive, unclear responses instead of a straightforward answer.
It couldn't be any more clear Kevin.

I edited my previous post because I'm bored of your game. And it is a game to be sure. I don't know why you are playing it but it's one in which there is no end. You want me to give you a simple answer where there is none to give. I've told you what morality means to me in a descriptive sense. I've to told you that I don't accept normative statements about morality and I've told you how I think we should formulate our ethics.

If you can't deduce from that my position then you are just being obtuse.

I can't prove that the moon exists to one who won't even look up.

There's nothing more for me to say.

You are on ignore.
 
BTW: I noticed Kevin that you conveniently ignored my quote from Singer.

The Triviality of the Debate Over 'Is-Ought' and the Definition of 'Moral'

"No definition of morality can bridge the gap between facts and action. Nor does any one definition of morality have any important overall advantages as against the other plausible definitions that have been suggested. It follows that the disputes over the definition of morality and over the "is-ought" problem are disputes over words which raise no really significant issues."
I agree with Singer that the debate over the definition of "moral" and "Is-Ought" is trivial. But that doesn't square with your adenda. Oh well.

Find someone else for your game. Hey, perhaps you could have a debate with Singer. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom