Utilitarianism is an empirical philosophy and possesses mechanisms to generate all sorts of heuristics (e.g., work within the law). Indeed, one argument against utilitarianism is that it can be used to support almost any course of action, which is precisely why it's silly to say the utilitarian answer. There are two-tiered approaches. However, no specific moral doctrine is necessary when it comes to justifying restrictions on human use of animals. You have some Kantian advocating animal rights, and others (indeed, utilitarians are not so big on rights at all except as useful construct).
You're just backpedaling now, because as you've repeatedly droned on about in the other thread and this one, the utilitarian 'answer' (according to you) has one conclusion. So, are you applying this utilitarian concept you're claiming I don't understand in a mistaken fashion? That you don't
believe a utilitarian approach misses some of the forest through the trees isn't going to be a very convincing argument that it isn't.
More interestingly your "explanation" for how "It also displays a fundamental rift between the Animal Rights groups and those who advocate Animal Welfare" is strained at best. You're basically speaking nonsense, which is why I advised caution, though perhaps I should have counseled you to withdraw your comment entirely.
Yes, more of your pretending to be some authority figure in this thread. Cain, I don't really care about your cautions or counsel. You seem to grow more and more self-righteous with every post, like some kind of Incredibly Hulk-like creature where it's only your head that grows to immense proportions. In all honesty and with all due respect, I don't give a damn about your assumed self-righteousness except that it gets in the way of you constructively contributing to the conversation.
You're just double-dipping in teh crazy sauce. Rather than ignoring them, animal rights philosophers confront (alleged) significant distinctions head-on. And you also still do not seem to understand what moral absolutism means.
You mean like Sztybel, who repeatedly produces papers (like
The Rights of Animal Persons) that essentially (in long form) dismiss those distinctions? Or like Gary Francione, who consistently argues that there should be little to no legal distinction? Rather than just tossing personal insults when you have no fact-based refutation, you may want to check your 'animal rights philosophers' to see what they're actually arguing. Or not, if you want, since it's really a decision only you can make. However, don't try to play these "you don't know what you're talking about" games with someone who has read plenty of these 'animal rights philosophers' (which I tend to call 'liberationists').
As to moral absolutism's definition: the position that certain actions are absolutely wrong or absolutely right regardless of context. That pretty much describes your position on eating meat to a 'T'. Sure, you use 'utilitarian philosophy' as your excuse to ignore context-- which I'm sure works for you, but obviously it ain't working for most of the rest of us-- but you're pretty much consistent on the absolutely wrong part.
Now, your turn to reply back about how I obviously have no clue what I'm talking about.
