No. I'm simply familiar with the facts. What's bizarre is that you could be presented with so much evidence that adaptive behavior is relevant to morality and you could simply dismiss it as beside the point.
You have shown no such evidence, because no such evidence can exist. You can't get from an is to an ought, without an additional "ought" assumption of some kind. "We ought to do what we are naturally inclined to do" is the "ought" claim you need to make adaptive behaviour relevant, and it's demonstrably false, so you're stuck.
I can't say that "reason" is the only source of moral guidance because it is demonstrably untrue. Should it be? That's the distinction that you DON'T get.
You are going to ignore this like you do everything else but I'm going to repeat it and put the salient point in red to demonstrate your rank willfulness to ignore my point.
I can't say that "reason" is the only source of moral guidance because it is demonstrably untrue. The question is Should it be? That's the distinction that you DON'T get.
What other candidate do you have? You've already admitted that reason trumps inbuilt behavioural tendencies even for you, so what's left? Other than the Bible or tossing a coin?
Reason has the benefit of consistency and coherency at the very least, which puts it above the Bible, the coin-toss and mindless instinctive behaviour.
Nice tactic. Hear no evil see no evil. What you ignore won't hurt you.
No, Kevin, it's demonstrably NOT beside the point. Asserting that something is so doesn't make it true. And, here's an idea, if it is beside the point perhaps you could explain why it is beside the point?
Why is anything beside the point? Because it has no relevance. Because the premise does not lead to the conclusion.
RandFan: Adaptive behavior has something to do with morality.
Kevin: Your claim is wrong.
Dawkins: Adaptive behavior has something to do with morality.
Wilson: Adaptive behavior has something to do with morality.
Wright: Adaptive behavior has something to do with morality.
Pinker: Adaptive behavior has something to do with morality.
Kevin: These claims are beside the point.
RandFan:
RandFan: Are you just on autopilot now?
What's disingenuous is posting the same nonsense over and over and over again, and then expecting novel answers.
Adaptive behaviour is not a source of information about what is morally right. That's the problem.
You can post a ****ing encyclopaedia entry about adaptive human behaviour into this thread every day for the next hundred years and the answer you will get is not going to change on any of those days. Adaptive behaviour will
still not be a source of information about what is morally right, no matter how much guff you bloat this thread with about it.
Asked and answered. They are the reason we are here. Since they are and they DO drive our behavior we ought to understand them and why they helped us survive.
What's that got to do with morality? Assuming they do drive our behaviour, there's no reason to think that they drive our behaviour in moral ways. In fact, we know that sometimes they do and sometimes they don't.
Knowing about them might be empirically useful in figuring out how to get humans to behave in ways that
reason tells us are moral, sure, but that's utterly different.
Now you are projecting.
The fatal flaw of your thinking (not that it's wrong per se but that it applies to what I've been saying).
I'm not appealing to nature and emotion to JUSTIFY behavior. I'm making a point that nature and emotions are explanations for our behavior.
Again, I know you will ignore this so I want to repeat it.
I'm not appealing to nature and emotion to JUSTIFY behavior. I'm making a point that nature and emotions are explanations for our behavior.
What the **** does that have to do with what is
actually morally right or morally wrong?
In a nod to GreNME let me clear up some confusion. I'm not sure if I'm the source of it or not. My point is and has been that humans have evolved adaptive behaviors. I don't believe I used the word "instincts" but if I did then I will retract that for this discussion. I believe that "instinct" is anachronistic from an anthropological POV.
In any event, Kevin, you are being disengenious to, on the one hand say that natural "instincts" play no role, and then claim that Dawkins, Wright, Pinker and Wilson's arguments for sociobiology and moral adaptive behavior are beside the point.
That's downright dishonest or willful cognitive compartmentalizing.
Beside the point isn't an argument. It's an assertion.
I can't extract any intelligent argument from this passage so I'm going to have to ask you to try again to convey whatever it is you mean.
It seems perfectly consistent to me to maintain that all information about adaptive behaviour is irrelevant to the question of what is actually morally right or wrong.
You can flood the thread with more name-dropping and links to videos, but frankly I think your attempt to appropriate good science to prop up an inane philosophical claim is, if anything, offensive to the good scientists whose names you are dropping and whose work you are misusing.