Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

It usually depends on the species and their relationship to us (humans), their local ecosystem, and the environment. As an example, the mute swan-- this animal was brought into the Chesapeake Bay area by people, sure, but what to do with them now? How do we determine their status compared to the status of the other plant and wildlife in the area? How about rabbits in Australia? Those are extremes, but they give you a clear basis from which to understand what I'm saying. There is no 'A+B results in conclusion C' in what I'm saying, so if it's that you're looking for then you'll be disappointed.

I didn't mean how do we decide the baseline for other species, but in general, for people too. For example what characteristic is used for people in determining/justifying our right to life, as in the right to not be killed?

Do you think that there is some absolute rights that are based on sound reasoning/principles or that the only real rights are those that a society decides on. As an example, was slavery okay back when a vast majority of people and society felt it was okay, or was it always wrong? If it was always wrong, what characteristics/principles determine if something is moral or a right?

Can I quote this as the stupidest thing I've ever read? Please???

http://www.ens-newswire.com/ens/aug2008/2008-08-22-01.asp
"More than enough food is produced to feed a healthy global population. Distribution and access to food is a problem - many are hungry, while at the same time many overeat," the brief states. But, it says, "we are providing food to take care of not only our necessary consumption but also our wasteful habits."

Also please stop insulting other posters as it is against forum rules.
 
I didn't mean how do we decide the baseline for other species, but in general, for people too. For example what characteristic is used for people in determining/justifying our right to life, as in the right to not be killed?

Ahh, okay. Well, the answer to that is we're still working on it. For people, the usual starting point right now tends to be "is a human being," and then from there it gets a little fuzzy depending on a few things, mostly having to do with the current "terrorism" buzz and all that, but on the whole many people have come to an agreement of certain self-deterministic rights (though there seem to be exceptions for certain crimes). How do we do it? Mostly consensus and agreement to a minimum level of acceptability.

Do you think that there is some absolute rights that are based on sound reasoning/principles or that the only real rights are those that a society decides on. As an example, was slavery okay back when a vast majority of people and society felt it was okay, or was it always wrong? If it was always wrong, what characteristics/principles determine if something is moral or a right?

I don't believe there are absolute rights, no, nor do I believe there are absolute principles. I don't think slavery was either right or wrong on a moral level. Slavery was a symptom of a type of rule that was autocratic and exclusive, and the practice went on for longer than suited the type of rule (as that level of autocracy died out long before it). What seems wrong is that the practice outlasted the model that created it. But asking if it was always wrong? That question only parses in absolute terms, so I can't answer it with the kind of 'yes' or 'no' it requires. I mean, sure, in today's terms it was wrong, but some during the time slavery was active would have argued otherwise. So, are you asking me personally or are you asking for a consensus, or something different altogether?
 
*Points to the post right above yours*

To make that statement at all correct, you're going to need to remove the word "supply." The whole reason people are starving is because WE CAN'T SUPPLY IT TO THEM. I get your point, but your original statement is insane. Sure wealthy countries have food to feed the starving, but we can't supply the demand.
 
Sure wealthy countries have food to feed the starving, but we can't supply the demand.

Actually, we can, but in some countries (like the US) we choose to try in some of the most inefficient ways possible. The fact that most of the cash crop produce out there is patented (which stops us from sending just the seeds) happens to be one of the problems.
 
Actually, we can, but in some countries (like the US) we choose to try in some of the most inefficient ways possible. The fact that most of the cash crop produce out there is patented (which stops us from sending just the seeds) happens to be one of the problems.

Okay, sure it's possible to send food to the starving countries, but remember Rwanda and Ethiopia? Even when we get the food there, it gets "rerouted" by greedy bastards. So no, we actually can't supply them. Not even with PlumpyNut. :(
 
So, are you asking me personally or are you asking for a consensus, or something different altogether?

You personally. I was trying to understand what you base your view of morality/rights on. If two people have a different fundamental base for their view of morality/rights then there is likely to be disagrement as to what is moral/right especially concerning the finer details. It also makes it difficult to present arguments, as one persons argument may be based upon a different fundamental base. This is what I would guess is the cause of a lot of the disagreement between people in this thread.

I'm not really talking about specifically us as we've been able to pretty much agree that a certain level of protected status which ensures good treatment of animals raised for consumption would be good. I was just curious about how you view morality.

I'd say I believe in fundamental rights but that such rights cannot be reasonably expected to be instituted at will. People's ability to gather knowledge, learn from past mistakes, and continually improve old systems is a slow process. Improvement comes baby step by baby step and I think that is how fundamental rights come about.
 
To make that statement at all correct, you're going to need to remove the word "supply." The whole reason people are starving is because WE CAN'T SUPPLY IT TO THEM. I get your point, but your original statement is insane. Sure wealthy countries have food to feed the starving, but we can't supply the demand.

Okay, sure it's possible to send food to the starving countries, but remember Rwanda and Ethiopia? Even when we get the food there, it gets "rerouted" by greedy bastards. So no, we actually can't supply them. Not even with PlumpyNut. :(

The Painter was trying to say that we do not have enough food to feed the world population, yet we are complaining about meat consumption. I was pointing out that is misinformed. We have more than enough food by far to feed every single person on the planet. The reason there are still starving people has nothing to do with the food supply (amount of food we produce). Starvation is a result of waste, the inability to get the food to the people who need it (distribution) because of corrupt governments/organizations (as you mentioned), and other factors such as what GreNME mentioned.

It seems there was just confusion about the terms being used. Perhaps I should have used food production rather than food supply.
 
Last edited:
Okay, sure it's possible to send food to the starving countries, but remember Rwanda and Ethiopia? Even when we get the food there, it gets "rerouted" by greedy bastards. So no, we actually can't supply them. Not even with PlumpyNut. :(

That's not the only reason we can't supply them. You see, with the foodstuffs we do send over, there are only so many things they can do with the food. They can't try to re-grow any of the grain or corn or anything we would send over, because it would end what few agricultural trade agreements that they already have with Europe, and they haven't the production and storage facilities to make the food last.

But really, that's a whole nother subject, so I digress.
 
You personally. I was trying to understand what you base your view of morality/rights on.

Personally, it's a mixture of things. Part of it has to do with what's best for me, part my family, part my community, and part larger society.

If two people have a different fundamental base for their view of morality/rights then there is likely to be disagrement as to what is moral/right especially concerning the finer details. It also makes it difficult to present arguments, as one persons argument may be based upon a different fundamental base. This is what I would guess is the cause of a lot of the disagreement between people in this thread.

That's a good observation. I don't have a whole lot of fundamental bases. For example, I don't have a "do no harm" fundamental base, but I do have a "don't do a lot of wanton harm if you can control it," or something to that effect.

I'm not really talking about specifically us as we've been able to pretty much agree that a certain level of protected status which ensures good treatment of animals raised for consumption would be good. I was just curious about how you view morality.

I view it (morality) in a sort of fluid manner, constantly evolving. Usually, it's evolving into something that is better for a wider group of individuals, and sometimes it's self-serving aggrandizement or mysticism (or some other 'woo'). Regarding animals that we eat, I agree that a reasonable level of treatment during their existence. I also feel that there's a certain level of a moral quid-pro-quo that can reasonably be expected as useful for social, environmental, and ecological benefit.

I'd say I believe in fundamental rights but that such rights cannot be reasonably expected to be instituted at will. People's ability to gather knowledge, learn from past mistakes, and continually improve old systems is a slow process. Improvement comes baby step by baby step and I think that is how fundamental rights come about.

I think that's a reasonable enough belief, even if I might not agree on rights being quite so fundamental. I think I agree that it's a slow-progressing type of process, though. As to the finer details you mention earlier, I think we can agree it makes sense that there's not always going to be a synergy in the whole of our beliefs, and the best course is finding a level of agreement and working from there. Your approach seems pretty reasonable, so I don't really begrudge the finer details. Just like I don't see anything wrong with a veg[etari]an diet, I don't begrudge those who want to follow that diet their choice in the matter. It seems only reasonable to me (personally).
 
Cain: nice backpedaling. You're not really debating at this point, you're just arguing to disagree and insult. Again.

Ha, this surely applies more to you than it does me. You're the one who continually uses the "moral absolutism" slur in order to insult those with whom you disagree, and now here you are carefully refusing to acknowledge, much less debate, the cited record. You're so shameless that you continue to falsely attribute "moral absolutism" to Kevin, among other things.
 
The spokeman is not refering to exploding the buildings with the people in them.

Yes he is. It's not the walls and roof of a bank that chooses to finance a fast food restaurant or medical laboratory. It's the manager or the loan officer. PETA is on record as preferring for people to die instead of lab rats.

"If a cure for AIDS came about through animal research, then we'd be against it."
- PETA Founder Ingrid Newkirk

Think of it like the movie Fight Club. They do various acts of destruction as a way to fight consumerism and when they blow the major credit card company headquarters they make sure there are no people inside.

Fight Club was a science fiction movie. I think I'll keep to what happens in the real world when terrorists blow buildings up.

PETA and the spokeman you quoted has a completely different ethical viewpoint than you and many others.

This is true. PETA is a band of depraved sociopaths that has no issues with mass murder.

Which brings me to my point. While I may not agree with their methods, nor even all of their stances, I can at least say I genuinely understand how they feel, what they believe, and why they do what they do. True understanding of anothers perspective is the first step to resolving conflicts. Calling their beliefs and actions nuts, bloody dam stupid or saying things like "I'm going to eat 2 stakes for every one you don't", only says to them that drastic measures are their only option. After all why would you bother wasting your time talking to people who say things like that to you?

I too understand their point of view. I just don't care.

Saying "I'm going to eat 2 steaks" may be a tad snarky, but for them to respond "Well then we are going to kill you" is totally insane.
 
I am watching a documentary about sharks at the moment, on television.

I want to report the sharks for mass murder. They are killing salmon wholesale. AND... some are probably going to get away horribly wounded, so we can probably get the sharks for grievous bodily harm as well.

And they will be eating (and probably running their tongues over) the fishes genital openings. We should be able to make charges of rape, unlawful sexual connection, stalking, sexual battery and (probably) paedophilia stick too.

Are you with me??
 
"If a cure for AIDS came about through animal research, then we'd be against it."
- PETA Founder Ingrid Newkirk

:eek: I hadn't heard that one. I just threw up in my mouth a little bit.

PETA is a band of depraved sociopaths that has no issues with mass murder.

Good call. I'm reminded of a quote from Penn Jillette. Something to the effect of, "Teller and I will strangle every monkey on the planet with our bare hands to save one junkie with AIDS."

Monkeys are cute, but I'm with Penn on this one. A person's life is more valuable than an animals, IMO. Responsibilty, morals, ethics, etc, are traits animals don't have, so arguing about them in relation to animals is moot. That's like arguing about how well different fish would fare at a game of badminton.

...and I'm still curious about PETA's stance on the sanctity of life. PETA people don't swat mosquitos, do they? Do all PETA members have full heads of lice?
 
  • I actually agree with this to some extent (it depends on the premises however)
  • To do so however you must rely on a number of assumption that are not a priori.
  • Otherwise What a priori yardstick would you use?
Let me ask you a hypothetical.
  1. And I basically agree with that. The thing is, however, that I think we all make those assumptions. Whether or not doing so is justified remains to be seen, I admit.

    [*]Many birds species evolved so that one sibling often kills the other.
    [*]Ornithologists have determined that it is because there is not enough time given gestation for a number of species to have a second offspring should the first one die in the crucial time after birth. So, an ESS is to have two eggs and if both survive one kills the other because the parents are not likely to gather enough food to assure the survival of both (that's pretty close as I remember anyway).
    [*]What if humans had evolved like these birds so that one sibling was required to kill the other for the survival of the species?
    [*]Would that be moral?

Good example. I would say that:
A) Until the birds start to examine their own actions, they are neither moral nor immoral.
B) When they do, they may find that they are making the best of a bad situation. That is, while each individual bird that is faced with either death or killing its sibling may say, "this sucks", it has only three alternatives. Two are equally bad (kill/be killed), and the third is worse (come to some agreement not to kill, and both die.
C) On the other hand, if a particular bird found itself in a situation in which it could save both itself and its sibling, I would say that it would be morally justified to do so. And, for those birds who were able to examine their actions from a moral viewpoint, they would be wrong not to.
 
Good example. I would say that:
A) Until the birds start to examine their own actions, they are neither moral nor immoral.
B) When they do, they may find that they are making the best of a bad situation. That is, while each individual bird that is faced with either death or killing its sibling may say, "this sucks", it has only three alternatives. Two are equally bad (kill/be killed), and the third is worse (come to some agreement not to kill, and both die.
C) On the other hand, if a particular bird found itself in a situation in which it could save both itself and its sibling, I would say that it would be morally justified to do so. And, for those birds who were able to examine their actions from a moral viewpoint, they would be wrong not to.
Thank you.

Of course the question of the hypo was people but that's perfectly fine because you get the point.

Great answers. Let me add or amend and tell me what you think.
  • They are making the best of the situation. No "bad". Bad requires an a priori assesment.
  • Morality to the degree that we enjoy is a luxury afforded us by our ability to produce a surplus of resources.
  • If we evolved to require the death of a sibling we might not view death the way we do now. We might not have evolved a moral sentiment that death is a bad thing.
Would you agree that if we were all socio-paths lacking any empthy or compassion our morality would likely be very different?
 
Seems to me that the ethical vegans have yet to provide a reasoned argument based on factual premise. They're still on the attack, making people defend eating meat instead of providing support for their position.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom