Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

Cain said

You're just double-dipping in teh crazy sauce. Rather than ignoring them, animal rights philosophers confront (alleged) significant distinctions head-on. And you also still do not seem to understand what moral absolutism means.

Animal Rights is a school of philosophy????

Guess it does not take much to be called a philosopher nowdays.
 
Cain said

You're just double-dipping in teh crazy sauce. Rather than ignoring them, animal rights philosophers confront (alleged) significant distinctions head-on. And you also still do not seem to understand what moral absolutism means.

Animal Rights is a school of philosophy????

Guess it does not take much to be called a philosopher nowdays.

To be fair to Cain, there are people who write philosophical or ethical papers on Animal Rights nowadays-- the two names I mention in my reply to him as an example-- but to call it a school of philosophy is like saying that the large number of JFK conspiracy theory literature out there constitutes a school of historical study all on its own. About the closest you're going to come is a bio-ethicist (most of which are not of the types that would be useful to Cain's liberationist approach), which is a soft-science application to a hard science.
 
He cherry picks what is and isn't relevant. It's a convenient way to avoid uncomfortable questions and facts.

That really tops it as your most intellectually dishonest statement in this thread, Kevin. In fact, this may very well be the most intellectually dishonest statement from anyone in this thread (and I'm even including quotes from elsewhere used here). The irony, considering your numerous comments regarding the 'what if' and rape, is completely staggering.

Since RandFan has bravely put me on ignore, I feel entitled to respond to this dishonest parting shot of his. I guess GreNME piled on out of lingering resentment and the optimistic thought that even if he didn't understand what was going on, he could still try to get a cheap shot in.

What it looked like RandFan was trying to do was throw a lifeboat-type moral dilemma up as a distraction. Conventional ethics tends to assume that there is enough food and water to go around, and then work out the details of how to be nice to each other. "Lifeboat ethics" deals with more problematic situations, such as what you do when a thirteenth person tries to climb into a lifeboat that can only safely seat twelve. Do you push them out to die, or do you risk the boat capsizing and killing all thirteen of you? Most people say "That's a horrible situation, but if it's a choice between thirteen dying and one dying, the moral thing to do is not to let person #13 on to the lifeboat".

In this case the nest is just a one-person lifeboat, which sometimes has two people in it.

So what's the relevance? It's clearly not relevant to the problem of eating meat, unless you are in a one-person lifeboat when a cow tries to climb on board. As we've painfully established eating meat is a matter of pleasure and convenience, not a matter of life and death. Whatever it is relevant to, it's clearly not relevant to the naturalistic fallacy RandFan was wallowing in.

In addition, the question he asked as his big clincher was straightforwardly meaningless. He asked "Is this moral?", without specifying what the hell he meant by "this", but it's hard to find an interpretation that makes any sense. If he asking if the chick's actions are moral? If so it's a stupid question, it's a baby bird, it's not capable of moral thought. It's no more moral or immoral than an asteroid or a virus. Humans are capable of moral thought - or at least we usually think so, although this thread has plenty of counter-evidence.

He could have meant "Would it be moral if the chicks were both fully rational adult humans, somehow, and one decided to kill the other?", but that just reduces straight back to the two-person lifeboat problem, and the point I was pressing RandFan on, to define his egregiously mobile use of the word "morality" so he would have to stop playing his semantic shell games, had absolutely nothing to do with this little instance of lifeboat ethics.

I'm disappointed in RandFan overall, as in the past one of his better traits has been that when he's clearly in the wrong he's been able to admit it. Ah, heck, who am I kidding? He'll read this, and then he'll probably respond to it, since it gives him something to respond to that gets off the point.

I edited my previous post because I'm bored of your game. And it is a game to be sure. I don't know why you are playing it but it's one in which there is no end. You want me to give you a simple answer where there is none to give. I've told you what morality means to me in a descriptive sense. I've to told you that I don't accept normative statements about morality and I've told you how I think we should formulate our ethics.

If you can't deduce from that my position then you are just being obtuse.

Well what do you know? It was like pulling teeth and he put me on ignore before he posted it, but finally something resembling a straight answer comes out.

I nailed it a few posts ago - what RandFan calls "morality" is nothing to do with objective morality. He's using the term solely to mean whatever people think is moral. So to him if people think eating meat is moral, it's moral. If they think raping is moral, it's moral.

In that context, adaptive behaviours are relevant to morality, as long as they shape what people think is moral. So if we're adapted to protect our families, or kill and eat animals, or commit genocide, these are all more likely to be considered moral-in-the-RandFan-sense.

The problem he won't face is that I already explained to him, several posts ago, that his moral relativism is incoherent and hence utterly useless as a moral theory to guide our actions. RandFan can consistently talk about what people think is moral, but his definition gives him no basis for talking about how we should act.

If he was honest and consistent he could boil his whole screed down to "It's natural for humans to eat meat, so it's natural for humans to think it's okay to eat meat". That's it. That's the end of RandFan's moral and intellectual journey.

He can't consistently say anything beyond that. He has nothing to bring to a discussion of whether we should eat meat, except to deny that the concept of should has any meaning, and then hide that denial under page after page of irrelevant name-dropping.
 
You're just backpedaling now, because as you've repeatedly droned on about in the other thread and this one, the utilitarian 'answer' (according to you) has one conclusion.

Emphasis added. Can you please show me where I said such a thing? I am guessing you did not bother to read through the thread again, and made this statement based on recollection... If you're interested, I did bother searching under my name for the terms "utilitarian" and "utilitarianism." I can produce the quotes if you want because they explicitly testify the distinctions I have made here.

So, are you applying this utilitarian concept you're claiming I don't understand in a mistaken fashion? That you don't believe a utilitarian approach misses some of the forest through the trees isn't going to be a very convincing argument that it isn't.

Are you trying to give a clear example of your muddled process?

You mean like Sztybel, who repeatedly produces papers (like The Rights of Animal Persons) that essentially (in long form) dismiss those distinctions? Or like Gary Francione, who consistently argues that there should be little to no legal distinction? Rather than just tossing personal insults when you have no fact-based refutation, you may want to check your 'animal rights philosophers' to see what they're actually arguing. Or not, if you want, since it's really a decision only you can make. However, don't try to play these "you don't know what you're talking about" games with someone who has read plenty of these 'animal rights philosophers' (which I tend to call 'liberationists').

It's not a personal insult to say philosophers arguing for animal rights address these distinctions head-on. Whether or not you (or I) agree with their conclusions is another matter. Unlike yourself, I do have a pretty good memory of the threads you like to reference, and I remember asking you umpteen times to identify significant differences between humans and animals. (See for instance this post: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=3954796&highlight=pulling#post3954796 )

As to moral absolutism's definition: the position that certain actions are absolutely wrong or absolutely right regardless of context. That pretty much describes your position on eating meat to a 'T'. Sure, you use 'utilitarian philosophy' as your excuse to ignore context-- which I'm sure works for you, but obviously it ain't working for most of the rest of us-- but you're pretty much consistent on the absolutely wrong part.

Your definition is correct (surprisingly) but your description of my view is incorrect (not surprisingly). So you're saying I have never claimed that I think it's OK to eat roadkill? You're saying that my posts here do not give any indication that I think it's OK to eat meat if it means avoiding starvation? Therefore, I would never ever write something like:

"Eating roadkill is fine; dumpster diving for double cheeseburgers outside McDonald's is fine. There's nothing intrinsically wrong with eating meat."

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=3921864&highlight=roadkill#post3921864

Someone named "Tranewreck" posited a situation where "the herd will have to be periodically culled in order to protect the integrity of the ecosystem. Should we just destroy the carcasses and not eat the meat?"

And I answered:
"No, we can eat that meat. As I may have said earlier, I'm a fan of roadkill. There's nothing intrinsically wrong with eating meat."

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=4259820&highlight=road#post4259820

Those quotes are about four months apart, but the search generator has me expressing a similar view back in 2004:

"I see nothing morally wrong with eating humans, just as I see nothing morally wrong with eating roadkill."

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=448233&highlight=roadkill#post448233

And then there are all of the other times where I expressed the same sort of view without using the specific term "roadkill" (e.g., animals dying of natural causes, meat grown in a lab) as well as gaps in the JREF's poorly maintained archives. So, in other words, my position on this basic, basic point has been well-established, and given clear expression in at least one thread you have read (well, pretended to read), and I'm pretty sure you acknowledged it at least once (and I can search for that post too, though it would take more effort).

While I always try to avoid aligning myself with others to prevent people such as yourself from smearing them with the same brush, I can say other so-called "black-and-white fundamentalists" on these boards have expressed more or less the same position with regard to meat-eating. That is to say, they allow circumstances where it's perfectly fine.

I should add that I have a natural advantage when it comes to describing Cain's belief system on account of the fact I am Cain. I'm familiar with my own views, so when you start in with "utilitarian" this or that, I can confidently say you're making a complete fool out of yourself.

Now, your turn to reply back about how I obviously have no clue what I'm talking about. :rolleyes:

Yep.
----------------------
Dudalb:
Animal Rights is a school of philosophy????

How do you get school from "philosophers?" As I have long maintained the fight for increasing the status of animals need not come from any particular point of view (utilitarian, Kantian, or other).

Guess it does not take much to be called a philosopher nowdays.

And yet you would never, ever cut it.
 
It would be unfair to confer those statuses to non-humans primarily because they lack the human baseline. This doesn't negate the possibility of some level of appropriate protected status for animals, but it lacks the level of rights associated with humans based on the characteristic of being human in the first place.

What characteristics determine the baseline a species receives in the first place?
 
Since RandFan has bravely put me on ignore, I feel entitled to respond to this dishonest parting shot of his. I guess GreNME piled on out of lingering resentment and the optimistic thought that even if he didn't understand what was going on, he could still try to get a cheap shot in.

There's nothing cheap about the shot: you've come full circle in your argument, and are now showing how you're willing to discard arguments that are inconvenient to your conclusions. It's a common failure of the moral absolutism you've been arguing from.

I nailed it a few posts ago - what RandFan calls "morality" is nothing to do with objective morality. He's using the term solely to mean whatever people think is moral. So to him if people think eating meat is moral, it's moral. If they think raping is moral, it's moral.

In that context, adaptive behaviours are relevant to morality, as long as they shape what people think is moral. So if we're adapted to protect our families, or kill and eat animals, or commit genocide, these are all more likely to be considered moral-in-the-RandFan-sense.

The problem he won't face is that I already explained to him, several posts ago, that his moral relativism is incoherent and hence utterly useless as a moral theory to guide our actions. RandFan can consistently talk about what people think is moral, but his definition gives him no basis for talking about how we should act.

For someone arguing like a philosophy student, you show a huge lack of understanding of the difference between "is" and "ought" here.

If he was honest and consistent he could boil his whole screed down to "It's natural for humans to eat meat, so it's natural for humans to think it's okay to eat meat". That's it. That's the end of RandFan's moral and intellectual journey.

You go to great lengths to misunderstand, even after this mistaken assumption you've proposed has been explicitly denied by RandFan himself. The only intellectual dishonesty going on is with your own obtuse responses to more than one attempt by RandFan to correct you.

He can't consistently say anything beyond that. He has nothing to bring to a discussion of whether we should eat meat, except to deny that the concept of should has any meaning, and then hide that denial under page after page of irrelevant name-dropping.

These are just petty excuses on your part to ignore his point. If he was simply name-dropping he would be relying only on the names as the basis of the argument, while he's specifically pointed out the statements and concepts presented by the names he's mentioned as his bases. Just because you don't like his point doesn't mean there isn't one present.
 
I can't believe this crap about food is still going on. Half the world is starving and you erudite argue about the morality of food. You are All idiots.
 
What characteristics determine the baseline a species receives in the first place?

It usually depends on the species and their relationship to us (humans), their local ecosystem, and the environment. As an example, the mute swan-- this animal was brought into the Chesapeake Bay area by people, sure, but what to do with them now? How do we determine their status compared to the status of the other plant and wildlife in the area? How about rabbits in Australia? Those are extremes, but they give you a clear basis from which to understand what I'm saying. There is no 'A+B results in conclusion C' in what I'm saying, so if it's that you're looking for then you'll be disappointed.
 
Cain: nice backpedaling. You're not really debating at this point, you're just arguing to disagree and insult. Again.
 
RandFan can consistently talk about what people think is moral, but his definition gives him no basis for talking about how we should act.
(emphasis mine) I hadn't intended on responding but I'll take one more bite.

If that is true you could point to where I said that our nature should or could dictate how we should act.
You can't because I didn't.
On the contrary I said it shouldn't.

So you are just being dishonest demonstrating why I tired of your repeated refusal to pay attention to what I was saying.
 
Last edited:
There's nothing cheap about the shot: you've come full circle in your argument, and are now showing how you're willing to discard arguments that are inconvenient to your conclusions. It's a common failure of the moral absolutism you've been arguing from.

Didn't you just try this exact same lie on Cain and get called on it? I'm not a moral absolutist and I think moral absolutism is silly. In fact I recently stated in this very thread that moral absolutism is a view almost exclusively held by religious kooks.

For someone arguing like a philosophy student, you show a huge lack of understanding of the difference between "is" and "ought" here.

"Arguing like a philosophy student" is not an insult when we're talking about philosophy. Unless of course you are claiming to be a philosophy lecturer?

You go to great lengths to misunderstand, even after this mistaken assumption you've proposed has been explicitly denied by RandFan himself. The only intellectual dishonesty going on is with your own obtuse responses to more than one attempt by RandFan to correct you.

I guess it could look like that, to someone who has repeatedly demonstrated that they can't actually follow the arguments being made.

These are just petty excuses on your part to ignore his point. If he was simply name-dropping he would be relying only on the names as the basis of the argument, while he's specifically pointed out the statements and concepts presented by the names he's mentioned as his bases. Just because you don't like his point doesn't mean there isn't one present.

I just summarised his point, hence I can't be "ignoring" it.

Cain: nice backpedaling. You're not really debating at this point, you're just arguing to disagree and insult. Again.

Nice try, but Cain just linked to chapter and verse showing that either you were lying, or you've got the memory of a pop-science goldfish combined with a habit of making up straw men.

I think your credibility here is done.
 
There's nothing cheap about the shot: you've come full circle in your argument, and are now showing how you're willing to discard arguments that are inconvenient to your conclusions. It's a common failure of the moral absolutism you've been arguing from.

For someone arguing like a philosophy student, you show a huge lack of understanding of the difference between "is" and "ought" here.

You go to great lengths to misunderstand, even after this mistaken assumption you've proposed has been explicitly denied by RandFan himself. The only intellectual dishonesty going on is with your own obtuse responses to more than one attempt by RandFan to correct you.

These are just petty excuses on your part to ignore his point. If he was simply name-dropping he would be relying only on the names as the basis of the argument, while he's specifically pointed out the statements and concepts presented by the names he's mentioned as his bases. Just because you don't like his point doesn't mean there isn't one present.
Thanks.

Someone gets it. I couldn't have said it better myself.

For Kevin it never was about what I meant but only about his strawman of what he wanted me to mean. He will never be able to demonstrate where I said that we ought to do something because of our nature.

Oddly enough, his explanation of what Dawkins meant by his statement is pretty much what I believe. Odd that Dawkins can hold such a view without making a naturalistic fallacy but if I even mention Darwinism and adaptive behavior in the same breath as morality I'm commiting a fallacy.

Poor form Kevin.
 
Quote:
If we really believe that animals have the same right to be free from pain and suffering at our hands, then, of course we’re going to be, as a movement, blowing things up and smashing windows … I think it’s a great way to bring about animal liberation … I think it would be great if all of the fast-food outlets, slaughterhouses, these laboratories, and the banks that fund them exploded tomorrow. I think it's perfectly appropriate for people to take bricks and toss them through the windows ... Hallelujah to the people who are willing to do it.
- PETA Spokesman Bruce Friedrich

Question for discussion: If every fast food restaurant, medical laboratory, and financial institution were to explode, what would be the death toll*?

Well it is exactly stuff like this which lead to the release of the Rage Virus which killed almost the entire population of the UK. :D

The spokeman is not refering to exploding the buildings with the people in them. Think of it like the movie Fight Club. They do various acts of destruction as a way to fight consumerism and when they blow the major credit card company headquarters they make sure there are no people inside. Or another way to think of it would be to relate it to people who were against slavery. I'm sure that many would have had no problem advocating burning cotton fields, destroying whips and other impliments used to beat/torture slaves, and freeing slaves. But that doesn't mean they'd also advocate shooting the white slave owners in the process (though I'm sure some may have advocated that as well).

PETA and the spokeman you quoted has a completely different ethical viewpoint than you and many others. They believe that animals have the right to be free from suffering/killed for food. They see it as the same as torturing and killing millions of people. Despite their efforts to bring about change peacably they see us continue to torture and kill millions year after year. Unhappy with the incredibly slow pace of improving rights in this way, they feel that more drastic measures may need to be taken. Each time they smash a labratory or destroy a slaughterhouse they are stopping some animals from having to be tortured/killed and also raise awareness through the media and bring the issue into sight. After all if it's out of sight it's out of mind. I'm sure this was the same mindset as some anti-slavery people. They were likely fed up with the slow pace of change and improved rights and so took matters into their own hands.

Which brings me to my point. While I may not agree with their methods, nor even all of their stances, I can at least say I genuinely understand how they feel, what they believe, and why they do what they do. True understanding of anothers perspective is the first step to resolving conflicts. Calling their beliefs and actions nuts, bloody dam stupid or saying things like "I'm going to eat 2 stakes for every one you don't", only says to them that drastic measures are their only option. After all why would you bother wasting your time talking to people who say things like that to you?
 
(emphasis mine) I hadn't intended on responding but I'll take one more bite.

If that is true you could point to where I said that our nature should or could dictate how we should act.

This claim ("If that is true you could point to where I said that our nature should or could dictate how we should act") does not follow from the claim I made.

In fact, in the post you replied to I characterised your position as "it's natural for humans to think it's okay to eat meat", not as "nature dictates that humans think it's okay to eat meat" or "we should believe it's objectively okay to eat meat because it's natural for humans to eat meat".

You can't because I didn't.
On the contrary I said it shouldn't.

Oh really? It looks like you're trying to sneak a toe back into the objectivist camp, long enough to make a "should" claim.

What is your basis for your "should" claim, seeing as you are on the record as claiming that "morality is simply rules of behavior"? Is this "should" claim true for all people in relevantly similar circumstances, or is it a relativist "should" claim?

So you are just being dishonest demonstrating why I tired of your repeated refusal to pay attention to what I was saying.

Actually you're giving an excellent demonstration of the inconsistency I was trying to iron out of you.

You want to be a moral relativist when it suits you, but then you want to sneak back and help yourself to objectivist thinking whenever you're confronted with a problem with your moral relativism. Yet you don't see this as the blatant inconsistency it is, because you haven't absorbed the fact that your moral relativism is strictly incompatible with rationality.

I called you on this before, you denied it vigorously, and now you're doing it again.
 
I can't believe this crap about food is still going on. Half the world is starving and you erudite argue about the morality of food. You are All idiots.

World hunger has nothing to do with an inadequate supply of food.
 
Last edited:
Didn't you just try this exact same lie on Cain and get called on it? I'm not a moral absolutist and I think moral absolutism is silly. In fact I recently stated in this very thread that moral absolutism is a view almost exclusively held by religious kooks.

Considering you and Cain are making similar absolute arguments (if X then Y, no exception), one could infer based on your arguments alone that you were religious about this matter.

"Arguing like a philosophy student" is not an insult when we're talking about philosophy. Unless of course you are claiming to be a philosophy lecturer?

It's an insult when you fail to understand something as basic as the difference between "is" and "ought" like you insist on doing.

I think your credibility here is done.

Since I don't think you were ever arguing in good faith, it's not my credibility you should be concerned with at this point. You've refused to acknowledge the strawman you demanded I address earlier, and now you're outright ignoring whole arguments RandFan is making. You should be more concerned with anyone taking you seriously at this point.
 
Kevin will tell you that how they feel is irrelevant. Conscience, caring, feeling, these are fallacious.

Putting me on ignore and then trying to snipe like this doesn't make you or your argument look any better.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom