He cherry picks what is and isn't relevant. It's a convenient way to avoid uncomfortable questions and facts.
That really tops it as your most intellectually dishonest statement in this thread, Kevin. In fact, this may very well be the most intellectually dishonest statement from anyone in this thread (and I'm even including quotes from elsewhere used here). The irony, considering your numerous comments regarding the 'what if' and rape, is completely staggering.
Since RandFan has bravely put me on ignore, I feel entitled to respond to this dishonest parting shot of his. I guess GreNME piled on out of lingering resentment and the optimistic thought that even if he didn't understand what was going on, he could still try to get a cheap shot in.
What it looked like RandFan was trying to do was throw a lifeboat-type moral dilemma up as a distraction. Conventional ethics tends to assume that there is enough food and water to go around, and then work out the details of how to be nice to each other. "Lifeboat ethics" deals with more problematic situations, such as what you do when a thirteenth person tries to climb into a lifeboat that can only safely seat twelve. Do you push them out to die, or do you risk the boat capsizing and killing all thirteen of you? Most people say "That's a horrible situation, but if it's a choice between thirteen dying and one dying, the moral thing to do is not to let person #13 on to the lifeboat".
In this case the nest is just a one-person lifeboat, which sometimes has two people in it.
So what's the relevance? It's clearly not relevant to the problem of eating meat, unless you are in a one-person lifeboat when a cow tries to climb on board. As we've painfully established eating meat is a matter of pleasure and convenience, not a matter of life and death. Whatever it is relevant to, it's clearly not relevant to the naturalistic fallacy RandFan was wallowing in.
In addition, the question he asked as his big clincher was straightforwardly meaningless. He asked "Is this moral?", without specifying what the hell he meant by "this", but it's hard to find an interpretation that makes any sense. If he asking if the chick's actions are moral? If so it's a stupid question, it's a baby bird, it's not capable of moral thought. It's no more moral or immoral than an asteroid or a virus. Humans are capable of moral thought - or at least we usually think so, although this thread has plenty of counter-evidence.
He could have meant "Would it be moral if the chicks were both fully rational adult humans, somehow, and one decided to kill the other?", but that just reduces straight back to the two-person lifeboat problem, and the point I was pressing RandFan on, to define his egregiously mobile use of the word "morality" so he would have to stop playing his semantic shell games, had absolutely nothing to do with this little instance of lifeboat ethics.
I'm disappointed in RandFan overall, as in the past one of his better traits has been that when he's clearly in the wrong he's been able to admit it. Ah, heck, who am I kidding? He'll read this, and then he'll probably respond to it, since it gives him something to respond to that gets off the point.
I edited my previous post because I'm bored of your game. And it is a game to be sure. I don't know why you are playing it but it's one in which there is no end. You want me to give you a simple answer where there is none to give. I've told you what morality means to me in a descriptive sense. I've to told you that I don't accept normative statements about morality and I've told you how I think we should formulate our ethics.
If you can't deduce from that my position then you are just being obtuse.
Well what do you know? It was like pulling teeth and he put me on ignore before he posted it, but finally something resembling a straight answer comes out.
I nailed it a few posts ago - what RandFan calls "morality" is nothing to do with objective morality. He's using the term solely to mean whatever people think is moral. So to him if people think eating meat is moral, it's moral. If they think raping is moral, it's moral.
In that context, adaptive behaviours are relevant to morality, as long as they shape what people think is moral. So if we're adapted to protect our families, or kill and eat animals, or commit genocide, these are all more likely to be considered moral-in-the-RandFan-sense.
The problem he won't face is that I already explained to him, several posts ago, that his moral relativism is incoherent and hence utterly useless as a moral theory to guide our actions. RandFan can consistently talk about what people
think is moral, but his definition gives him no basis for talking about
how we should act.
If he was honest and consistent he could boil his whole screed down to "It's natural for humans to eat meat, so it's natural for humans to think it's okay to eat meat". That's it. That's the end of RandFan's moral and intellectual journey.
He can't consistently say anything beyond that. He has nothing to bring to a discussion of whether we
should eat meat, except to deny that the concept of
should has any meaning, and then hide that denial under page after page of irrelevant name-dropping.