Why is PETA so bloody dam stupid....

It's produced in your liver from two of the essential amino acids which are available from combining two LowBiologicalValue protein sources - and if I recall correctly Vitamin C helps it's synthesis....


Is that what you mean by "not without help"?

Yep, pretty much what I mean. There are a few combination chains in the human body that require raw material from outside sources to create them, and we're not completely in the know for how all of them work or what they all do (at least not completely), but yeah, that's what I mean.

Of course, all that really does is make the case for diversity in diet, not necessarily for or against meat specifically. Also, as to the rest of your post there's not anything I can really disagree on, so I think we're square. :)
 
It just hit me that under vegan standards even the salads I eat wouldn't pass muster since both creamy italian and blue cheese dressing have banned substances (as well as the roast beef shards I like to add but that was more obvious). :(

It's a good thing none of those people decided that plants have a right to live, too.

It's also a good thing that they don't try to save animals from cruelty from other animals.
 
You're gripped by this conviction that instincts are in some way relevant to morality. You don't have any argument for why this should be except that you can't conceive of anything different, nor do you have any response whatsoever to the real elephant in the room: the fact that many of our instincts are counterproductive, selfish, stupid or evil.

I don't know how many times I can say this before it gets through: human beings have no instincts. We have not had that mechanism since before we recorded our own history, and likely much further back to pre-fire times. Stop using instincts as your pseudo-original-sin here.
 
If we really believe that animals have the same right to be free from pain and suffering at our hands, then, of course we’re going to be, as a movement, blowing things up and smashing windows … I think it’s a great way to bring about animal liberation … I think it would be great if all of the fast-food outlets, slaughterhouses, these laboratories, and the banks that fund them exploded tomorrow. I think it's perfectly appropriate for people to take bricks and toss them through the windows ... Hallelujah to the people who are willing to do it.
- PETA Spokesman Bruce Friedrich

Question for discussion: If every fast food restaurant, medical laboratory, and financial institution were to explode, what would be the death toll*?





*People, not animals. Animals aren't people
 
Last edited:
ETA: My cat responds "Mmmmmm, rat's ass." :drool:

Not my cat. In the last week I have has to dispose of the back ends of two rodents. She seems to eat them from the head back to the hips and leaves the rest for me (or maybe the dogs).

And.... in the interests of making this post somewhat on topic - my cat is definitely not a vegetarian, and neither am I.
 
Friedrich is an insane person, and has openly advocated setting fires and blowing things up to advance their nutbag cause. In other words, he's about as credible a source on humane treatment as Ramzi Youseff would be for airline safety.

Agreed, but let's give credit where credit is due: Friedrich is just expressing the feeling of Ingrid Newkirk ,founder and Supreme All Powerful Ruler..excuse me, President of PETA. Newkirk is the #1 Wackjob, Friedrich is just the Second Banana.
I really hope that Law Enforcment finally find solid evidence of PETA giving material aid and support to the Eco terror groups,so that this bunch of nutbags can lose their tax exempt status. But so far Newkirk has been smart enough to cover PETA's tracks.
 
The loved ones part has already been done for me, so why not?

Sorry to hear that.

But as far as I can see it is a non-question trying to appeal to some form of attachment and not a rational way of finding a solution.

So because you have nobody you love alive, you're in the position of deciding rationally who are the ones who "get to go first" :eye-poppi ?

Cutting down the bio-industry would take time, one-child programs as well.

If I would have to pick between 'being nicer to animals' and 'making people just have sex for fun', well, I know what my standpoint is.

Why/when/how on earth would you have to make such a decision? I've had vasectomy for the reason (among others) you mentioned and I advocate better treatment for animals. I fail to understand how the two are related.
 
We could feed those starving millions by other means without having to give up bacon.

I didn't suggest you have to "give up bacon". Just cut down the amount.

In fact, our bacon consumption has notrhing to do with their starvation.

Now, based upon your previous posts I believe you to possess way more intelligence than that phrase holds in it. It's fine by me if you just don't want to discuss that part of the topic. If so, just say it. No need for underachievement ;).
 
- PETA Spokesman Bruce Friedrich

Question for discussion: If every fast food restaurant, medical laboratory, and financial institution were to explode, what would be the death toll*?
Big difference depending on what time of day it happened. I'm not sure why it matters... take the lowest estimate, divide it by 10, and the guy's still advocating mass murder.

Animals aren't people

Some of us are.
 
I've never met a person who wasn't human. I just found out today that the Humane Society has devolved into a PETA-like entity. Check out their website and you'll see that they are becoming a parrot to PETA, they're promoting vegetarianism and speaking out against leather products and such.
 
I've never met a person who wasn't human. I just found out today that the Humane Society has devolved into a PETA-like entity. Check out their website and you'll see that they are becoming a parrot to PETA, they're promoting vegetarianism and speaking out against leather products and such.

That's been happening since about 1980, when the previous board was voted out and a new, more AR activist board was brought in.
 
You're gripped by this conviction that instincts are in some way relevant to morality.
No. I'm simply familiar with the facts. What's bizarre is that you could be presented with so much evidence that adaptive behavior is relevant to morality and you could simply dismiss it as beside the point.

Why not skip the pointless indulgence in the naturalistic fallacy, and just say that reason is the source of moral guidance?
I can't say that "reason" is the only source of moral guidance because it is demonstrably untrue. Should it be? That's the distinction that you DON'T get.

You are going to ignore this like you do everything else but I'm going to repeat it and put the salient point in red to demonstrate your rank willfulness to ignore my point.

I can't say that "reason" is the only source of moral guidance because it is demonstrably untrue. The question is Should it be? That's the distinction that you DON'T get.

No, you just posted a lot of stuff that was utterly beside the point.
Nice tactic. Hear no evil see no evil. What you ignore won't hurt you.

No, Kevin, it's demonstrably NOT beside the point. Asserting that something is so doesn't make it true. And, here's an idea, if it is beside the point perhaps you could explain why it is beside the point?

RandFan: Adaptive behavior has something to do with morality.
Kevin: Your claim is wrong.
Dawkins: Adaptive behavior has something to do with morality.
Wilson: Adaptive behavior has something to do with morality.
Wright: Adaptive behavior has something to do with morality.
Pinker: Adaptive behavior has something to do with morality.
Kevin: These claims are beside the point.
RandFan: :rolleyes:
RandFan: Are you just on autopilot now?

The question you needed to answer is "Why should be pay any attention to these instincts?".
Asked and answered. They are the reason we are here. Since they are and they DO drive our behavior we ought to understand them and why they helped us survive.

...that you can't slow down, think, and realise you've made some fundamental errors in your thinking.
Now you are projecting.

Appeals to nature and emotion are fallacies.
The fatal flaw of your thinking (not that it's wrong per se but that it applies to what I've been saying).

I'm not appealing to nature and emotion to JUSTIFY behavior. I'm making a point that nature and emotions are explanations for our behavior.

Again, I know you will ignore this so I want to repeat it.

I'm not appealing to nature and emotion to JUSTIFY behavior. I'm making a point that nature and emotions are explanations for our behavior.
 
Last edited:
But, again to answer your question, while I think those feelings are wrong, it's not because they are natural. They could have come from Allah, and still they would be wrong. There is simply no connection between whether something is natural, and whether it is good.
Great post. :)

BTW, did you watch the Dawkins video I linked to?

As I told Kevin, I can't categoricly state that there is no connection. There is simply too much evidence that there is a link.

We know that we behave, to some degree, according to adaptive behaviors given us by evolution. That's no longer in question.

The question becomes, how "ought" we behave given what we know about our nature and the consequences of that nature?

I'm willing to bet we can find some agreement.

Sadly I don't think that's possible with Kevin but I don't mean to drag you into that fight.
 
I don't think morality works the way that some seem to think it does.

Without a god, there is no pure morality that exists outside of Humanity. There isn't some logical puzzle that unlock the way to a perfectly moral life. Morality is simply a feature that allows people to function together as a society. It doesn't have to rational, logical, or even sane.

As a social control, morality isn't even particularly strong. As morals are created and enforced by the tacit consent of the population, and interpretation of them can vary wildly from one segment of that population to the other. As such, especially in larger societies, the lines between what is considered "morally bad" and "morally good" tend to be drawn arbitrarily, with lots of grey on either side.

In fact, even attempting to argue morality from logic is problematic. It leads to a host of slippery slope arguments as we've all seen in the abortion and gay marriage debates.

What I don't understand is how anyone can think that PETA is some benign organization that just likes animals. I generally like animals better than people, but even I can see that everything they do is drenched in misanthropic hatred. How does one get to hate their species, as well as its domesticated partners, so much? More importantly, how does one do that and get to be considered a somewhat credible voice?
 
You said that we had an instinct to like clear running water, and that clear running water was good, in support of the (still silly) claim that our natural instincts have something to do with what is moral.

I don't know how many times I can say this before it gets through: human beings have no instincts.

In a nod to GreNME let me clear up some confusion. I'm not sure if I'm the source of it or not. My point is and has been that humans have evolved adaptive behaviors. I don't believe I used the word "instincts" but if I did then I will retract that for this discussion. I believe that "instinct" is anachronistic from an anthropological POV.

In any event, Kevin, you are being disengenious to, on the one hand say that natural "instincts" play no role, and then claim that Dawkins, Wright, Pinker and Wilson's arguments for sociobiology and moral adaptive behavior are beside the point.

That's downright dishonest or willful cognitive compartmentalizing.

Beside the point isn't an argument. It's an assertion.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom